@@DhirajKumar-pt9xn नामित वही किया जाता है जिसपर विश्वास होता है, अगर मृत्यु के पूर्व नामांकन रद्द किया जाता हैं और किसी को नामित नहीं किया जाता हैं तो जबतक सभी हिस्सेदार मय सबूत नहीं आते तबतक सरकार रोक सकती है, नहीं आनेपर सब सरकार का है ही 😜😜😜वैसे भी अरबों, खरबों रूपये सरकार दबाएं बैठीं है जो या तो मरगए या एकाउंट में मिनिमम बैलेंस छोड़ कर बैंक नहीं गए सरकार का कर्तव्य है कि रुके अकाउंट के पता पर पत्र से सूचित करे कि या तो अकाउंट बंद कर पैसे ले ले, या अकाउंट चालू करवा ले, यहाँ ये कुछ नहीं होता है हर विभाग लूटने में लगा है
Sir. How nominee will get his share...pl share/ explain..If nominee is third party/ not blood related what's his role? If any legal heir comes to know the fact, after 3/4 years or some period, and meantime as. Per nomination banks closed account by handing over the funds, how legal heir can claim the amount of decreased
Name of nominee itself indicates that the deceased person wanted the nominee to get the money after his or her demise.... Koi kisi ko kyo karega nominee? .mai kisi aur parichit vyakti ko kyo banau nominee ..??? ..isiliye ajkal share aur nominees ka nam likha rehta hai with relationship and ID proof .
कहानी में लौजिक नहीं है बड़े भैया। जगमोहन का माइनर बेटा तो उसकी बीबी का ही न था, फिर बेटे को क्या जरूरत थी केस करने की, जो उसकी माँ को मिलता वहीं बेटा का भी होता और जबकि उसकी पत्नि का डायवोरस भी नहीं हुआ फिर वह माइनर बेटा दादा दादी का सपोर्ट क्यों करेगा। हिस्सेदार उसकी बीबी और उसकी माँ, दो लोग होने चाहिए थे।
अगर सभी का अधिकार बराबर बराबर है तो नॉमिनी बनाने की जरूरत ही क्या है। सभी बीमा कंपनी के पास जा कर दावा पेश कर दें। ऐसे ही बैंक अकाउंट के मामले में भी हो सकता है । इस केस में तो बीमा कंपनी के मैनेजर को नॉमिनी बना देना चाहिए था। जिससे कोई पड़ोसी या दूर का रिश्तेदार भी दावा पेश कर सके कि मृत व्यक्ति की सेवा मैने भी की थी। मुझे भी हक मिलना चाहिए।
Then why supreme court is not making mandatory to make the will and registered it..son earnings are used and parents save their earnings and giving it to daughters
Now SC is saying even registered Will is not valid! So how to find solution. SC is the highest court of justice. If judges give such judgements which are against natural jurisprudence, anyone with money power can get judgment in his/her favour. Then the person who the money was intended to will be deprived. This kind of judgement should be overruled.
इंसान कुछ सोच समझ कर ही नॉमिनी रखता है उसके जिंदा रहते जो दिल से खयाल रखता है उसी को वो नॉमिनी रखता है पता नहीं ये फैसला कैसे huwa tab shayad situation kufh alag Rahi hogi
मान लिजिए एक पिता के तीन बच्चे है। और एक लडका बहुत अच्छा है। और बाकी के दो लडके या लडकी बहुत ही खराब है। उनके पास संपत्ती देना मतलब व फिजुल मे खर्चा कर देंगे इसलिए पिताजी ने अच्छे लडके को सारी संपत्ती दे दी और सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुताबिक तो सारे हकदार है। तो बिचारा जो नॉमिनी चूज करता है। उसका तो अधिकार का खंडन कर दिया.कैसे सुप्रीम कोर्ट का न्याय बहुत अच्छा लग रहा है, आपको...?
System for documentation & related act needs a change Nomination के साथ साथ legal successor and will का भी प्रावधान किया जाना चाहिए। 4th front's policies are for benifits of humanity Laws and civilization development of nation and peoples
This is right decision as my fatherin law give all his money that he got from selling his shop to his mother , Who lived in haridwar she kept it in her account for 15 long years and on her death his sister claimed all money because she was nominee. And my fatherin law died with depression. When my husband and 3 sisterinlwas raised there voice, she smartly use divide and rule policy. She told my sister inlaws that she is with them in claiming there right in their fathers property. And they did claimed it . Ultimately my husband was left with 1/4 share in his fathers property resulting him landless.
Nomini ka adhikar khatam kyun bhai .? Jisne bhi ye kanoon saalon phle banaya tha uska kuch meaning tha jo sahi tha kyunki nomini koi ese hi nhi kisi ko banata ..?? Jo Hak takhta h wahi banaya jata h 💯 ye ultra seedhe kanoon jaane kon kyun bana tha h …???🥺😣😣🤨💔
@@LegalAttack1,Sir, kya agar ham 3 sisters hai aur ek bhai hai joh apna business meh acha kha sa kamata hai aur dusre state meh apni family k saat hai. Ham sisters meh se sirf 1 job karti hai unmarried age 52 aur ham doh age 60+aur ek divorcee hai. Mother hai age 87 jinka woh khud apna chala rahi hai lekin shrey bhai ko diya jata hai jab ham inke saat alag se kamre meh rehte hai aur dekbal karte hai. Hamara property share b nahi dena chahete hai aur ghar se nikalne k khosish kiye jha rahe hai. Ise situation meh agar apne naam k saat sister ko nominee rakha gaya hai toh bhai aur maa ka kya hakh hota hai jab woh khud he hame beghar karne meh laghe hai aur apna share dene k liye sign b nahi dena chahete hai. Hamre pass joh b hai woh khane aur dawa k liye kafi nahi hoga budape meh toh yeh kanon ka kya faidha hoga agar hamse ek ko kuch hoga toh joh b bacha ho uska equal share meh banta jai unke saath joh apne hote hue b apne nahi hai aur har second meh marre jha rahe hai jab unka ek paisa b nahi meela hame? SC ko aise be cases ko dekna chahiye joh samne nahi ate na bahut sare logh apni jindagi har ek din mare jha rahe hai apno se he. Isliye jab koyi nominee leekhta hai woh ape bhorasemand ko he haqk deta hai apna dekhbal karne k liye aur nominee ka nam leekta hai.
@@LegalAttack1 care taker takes care of asset in way he likes.... If he is obligated to take care of the asset by distributing to legal heirs then why will he even take care of the asset....He will not even claim the asset till the legal heirs forget about it.
Vakil sahab ye btayein ki kisi ki do patuiyan hai jb rtd. hua to us mein pension ke dauran ek hi patni nomini rakhi kya mrne ke bad dinon ko pension milegi ya nomini ko kripya btayein
ये नियम बिलकुल ही गलत है। मान लो कोई व्यक्ति है और उसके परिवार में उसके 2 बेटे एक बेटी है और पत्नी है। करोड़ रुपए की पॉलिसी है । जिंदगी में उसको बेटो ने छोड़ दिया और सहारा नही दिया और पत्नी कही जाकर अलग रहने लगी । बेटी ने सहारा दिया और उस व्यक्ति ने बेटी को नॉमिनी बना रखा हो। डेथ हुई तो पॉलिसी की 1 करोड़ राशि हड़पने के लिए पत्नी भी आ गई और दोनो गुंडे बेटे भी और 75 लाख हड़प गए। जिस बेटी ने टटी उठाई नहलाया खाना खिलाया इलाज कराया उसको मिले सिर्फ 25 लाख । ऐसे में ये कहां का नियम है की देखभाल करने वाले और सच्चे साथी को ऐसा सबक मिले। नॉमिनी अपनी होशो हवास में बनाए जाते है। वकील साहब खुद पर लागू करके बताए ऐसे में क्या करे कोई ??
Will execute karna jaruri kar diya hai ek tarah se iska matlab. This is very unfair..kuch aisi he situation main apne ghar par anticipate kar raha hu and sometimes i think ki wrong person ko kuch hissa nahi milna chaiye after my death. I am just 39 or mujhe nahi lagta ki mujhe abhi se will banani chaiye. Ab har choti choti policy k liye will nahi bana sakte
Yes sir, as per section 45 of, N.I. act. Nominee will will be like a trustee n has to distribute funds to all the legal heirs & he cannot become owner of the funds or estate...
अगर नॉमिनी उत्तराधिकारी भी हो और मृत्यु के बाद diseased claim लेकर बाक़ी उत्तराधिकारियों को बताये ही नहीं की क्या अकाउंट था और कितने पैसे थे तो बाक़ी उत्तराधिकारियों को क्या करना चाहिये?
लयभारी ,सर नाँमीनेशन धारकने सब पैसा अपना समजकर खर्च किया ,भागधार को देने से मना करे तो क्या करे ?भागधारक्षको पैसा वापस मिलेगा क्या ? मार्गदर्शन किजीये सर धन्यवाद!
मुझे एक बात समझ में नहीं आती कि क्या किसी एक मेटर में सुप्रीम कोर्ट का दिया फैसला पूरे देश के लिए यूनिवर्सल कानून कैसे मान लिया जाता है ?? क्या फिर बने बनाये संविधान का कोई मतलब नहीं है ?? मतलब सुप्रीम कोर्ट के जजों के फैसलों से ही देश में कानून बनते हैँ क्या ?? चाहे गलत हो या सही!!! और क्या ये सिर्फ अपने ही देश में होता है या विदेशों में भी ??
It was one of fine decision by SC. But it applies where there are minor children and old aged parents without any fixed income as well as there are family differences and disputes. In ordinary common cases of joint family, who cares about the claimant, after all money is coming to the family 😅
is this judgement applicable in any case...for example...my son died on 01.01.2024 and he has given his wife as nominee in the company he was working...me and my wife (his parents) are we eligible for the dues from his company, as we both being senior citizen and retired...
Right judgement. I salute to the honourable Judge of our Supreme Court for this susceptible and beneficial verdict in favour of the survivors. Though the caption of the video is misguiding and alarming. Right of nominee was not denied by the verdict of the honourable Judge of the Supreme Court.
Nomini ka naam hai usko hi sab mila chahiye baad mein inke gharwale nipat le ismein court aur bank ko koi lena nahi. Baad mein gharwale nomini ke khilaf case kar le.
Of course nominee should Take care of own family if wife nominee leave the husban,s family and goes to other family by 2nd husband,on brother father house then nominee should changed immediately through bank authority or police administration,it will be better
I think it needs to be clarified. If the person wants to bequeath any asset of theirs to a particular person they should mention them in their WILL. If that person is also the the nominee of the bank asset ( and it is his or her self earned asset, not ancestral property) then the nominee becomes the owner of that asset.
The will of person, whether alive or dead, must prevail on his personal earnings & assets, irrespective of any court judgement in this regard, which is not concerned with it at all
We have made a will,not necessary to register it,make 3 copies hand it over to any body you trust and one copy you can keep it in your locker. It can be hand written by you,just have to follow the format..no money is spent.
जब सुप्रीम कोर्ट यह कहता है की वक्फ बोर्ड पर वह सुनवाई करने में असमर्थ हैं,तब ऐसे नये कानून लाने का अधिकार उसके पास कैसे आया. धिक्कार हैं ऐसे सुप्रीम कोर्ट के जजों पर. मुझे तो लगता है दाल में कुछ काला है,क्योंकी पहले ही private service वालों को पेंशन भी नही मिलता. फिर nominee का क्या हाल होगा.
Agar nominee Nehi claim huwe to fir log apna Ghar me money jama karenge apna paribar ke liye to bank account Khali parega 1 sal ke ondor ,kanun ho to bhalaike liye hona sahiye ,
It's a clumsy decision of the honourable Supreme Court, if you said so. If a person dies without making Will then who may claim for his/her banking amount. What is the use of asking nominees even till the date.
क्या ये नया रुल है ?? आठ महिने पहले मेरे पत्नी का डेथ हुवा ,दो बॅक मे उसके एफडी.थे नाॅमीनी मेरा बेटा था.बिना कुछ झंझट १५ दिनमे उसको दोनो बॅंक से पैसे मीले.
In that case Nominee will not even work to claim the amount ....The legal heirs cannot claim the amount if Nominee doesnt take steps to claim the amount.
@@LegalAttack1 Geting Succession certificate is a nightmare ...especially when the legal heirs stay out of country or city . Its a very very cumbersome procedure... In so called Digital India , these basic stuffs are not digitalized .
Will the property than go to whom Who has drafted this new law Please reply If a person dies without making a will then if the nominees right becomes invalid then to whom will the property go
Agr koi vyakti apne account me kisi bhi nominee ka naam mention hi ma kiya ho or uski death ho jaye tab kya hoga?? Wife claim kr skti h ya nahi?? Please reply as soon as possible it'll be helpful for us
Sir... Plz clear one doubt. If I die and leave a policy or an FD behind, will the bank ask the nominee to bring the details of family who may be the level heirs of that money and then will distribute the money equally amongst heirs following the paper work? Or Heirs will have to knock the doors of court to claim that share?
So good change sir Mere pass koi FD ya savings nai...bus 1 75000 ki policy hai Aur bete ki 2lakhs lic n husband ki bi meri tarah 75000 ki policy...aur beti ki policy lapse hogai..... nai...
Very insightful...thanks for sharing
Welcome and Thanks for kind Support 🙏 ☺ 😊
@LegalAttack1
Hii 77@@LegalAttack1
@@LegalAttack1l
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
कोर्ट का गलत फैसला है जनता का सब लूट लो अंग्रेजो के बाद भारतीय लुटेरे लूटने लगे😢😢😢😢😢
Bilkul correct
नहीं भई,,पूरा सुन लो,,,यह सही फैसला है,,,क्योंकि नोमिनी परिवार के बाकी को पूछते तक नहीं है,,,
@@DhirajKumar-pt9xn नामित वही किया जाता है जिसपर विश्वास होता है, अगर मृत्यु के पूर्व नामांकन रद्द किया जाता हैं और किसी को नामित नहीं किया जाता हैं तो जबतक सभी हिस्सेदार मय सबूत नहीं आते तबतक सरकार रोक सकती है, नहीं आनेपर सब सरकार का है ही 😜😜😜वैसे भी अरबों, खरबों रूपये सरकार दबाएं बैठीं है जो या तो मरगए या एकाउंट में मिनिमम बैलेंस छोड़ कर बैंक नहीं गए सरकार का कर्तव्य है कि रुके अकाउंट के पता पर पत्र से सूचित करे कि या तो अकाउंट बंद कर पैसे ले ले, या अकाउंट चालू करवा ले, यहाँ ये कुछ नहीं होता है हर विभाग लूटने में लगा है
सही कथन।
नामांकित को स्वामित्व का अधिकार कभी नहीं था और ३८ वर्ष की बैंक नौकरी में सैकड़ों मृत्यु दावे निर्धारित किए और परामर्श दिया।
Then change the term nominee.
Remove nominee and simply write care taker.
Or same time you can say the dipositer to make the proper will.
अगर नॉमिनी का कुछ वैल्यू नहीं तो नॉमिनी डिटेल्स क्यों माँगते हैं बैंक और बाकी संस्थाए ?
Nominee ko uska share to milta hai...
Sir. How nominee will get his share...pl share/ explain..If nominee is third party/ not blood related what's his role? If any legal heir comes to know the fact, after 3/4 years or some period, and meantime as. Per nomination banks closed account by handing over the funds, how legal heir can claim the amount of decreased
Nominee ka share 100% hota hai kisi bhi account me, ab batao nominee ko kitna milega
Name of nominee itself indicates that the deceased person wanted the nominee to get the money after his or her demise.... Koi kisi ko kyo karega nominee? .mai kisi aur parichit vyakti ko kyo banau nominee ..???
..isiliye ajkal share aur nominees ka nam likha rehta hai with relationship and ID proof .
Is son noomee is not entitled to receive full amount nt
This judgement is against the will of the person, whose last wish is being ignored.
It's complicated
@@ASH9366As a student of law I may state that will is on different footing as compared to nomination.
Agar registered will hai tho us ke according hoga. Yes, nominee is only a caretaker/custodian
@@dineshjoshi4745 Registeration of will is optional as per Registeration Act.
कहानी में लौजिक नहीं है बड़े भैया। जगमोहन का माइनर बेटा तो उसकी बीबी का ही न था, फिर बेटे को क्या जरूरत थी केस करने की, जो उसकी माँ को मिलता वहीं बेटा का भी होता और जबकि उसकी पत्नि का डायवोरस भी नहीं हुआ फिर वह माइनर बेटा दादा दादी का सपोर्ट क्यों करेगा। हिस्सेदार उसकी बीबी और उसकी माँ, दो लोग होने चाहिए थे।
ऐसा तो मैंने भी कहीं नहीं देखा, पूरा हक तो नॉमिनी को ही मिलता है.
Government Work As a Thief
Minor uska bhai tha,beta nahi
अगर सभी का अधिकार बराबर बराबर है तो नॉमिनी बनाने की जरूरत ही क्या है। सभी बीमा कंपनी के पास जा कर दावा पेश कर दें। ऐसे ही बैंक अकाउंट के मामले में भी हो सकता है । इस केस में तो बीमा कंपनी के मैनेजर को नॉमिनी बना देना चाहिए था। जिससे कोई पड़ोसी या दूर का रिश्तेदार भी दावा पेश कर सके कि मृत व्यक्ति की सेवा मैने भी की थी। मुझे भी हक मिलना चाहिए।
Bekar bate Kyo karteho
यह वीडियो देखने के बाद कई घरों से बर्तन फेकने की आवाजें आना शुरू हो गई हैं।
Sahi hai naye bartan aa jayengy 😀😀
😂
Supreme court has passed Tuqlaq judgement
What is the use of nomination then
Then why supreme court is not making mandatory to make the will and registered it..son earnings are used and parents save their earnings and giving it to daughters
But Sons can get Parents to register their Wills@@hrk3059....why you seem Bugged ????? Maybe answer lies in my Question..... 😂
@@hrk3059You are 100% right. I also say the same thing. A 'Will' will find a way 😅😅😅
Now SC is saying even registered Will is not valid! So how to find solution. SC is the highest court of justice. If judges give such judgements which are against natural jurisprudence, anyone with money power can get judgment in his/her favour. Then the person who the money was intended to will be deprived. This kind of judgement should be overruled.
इंसान कुछ सोच समझ कर ही नॉमिनी रखता है उसके जिंदा रहते जो दिल से खयाल रखता है उसी को वो नॉमिनी रखता है पता नहीं ये फैसला कैसे huwa tab shayad situation kufh alag Rahi hogi
सुप्रीम कोर्ट का यह फ़ैसला बिल्कुल ही ग़लत है इस पर सुप्रीम कोर्ट को दुबारा विचार करना चाहिए ता कि जनता के साथ कोई भी धोखा न हो ।
अगर उस व्यक्ति ने वसीयत बनाकर किसी NGO को लाइफ इंश्योरेंस पॉलिसी की पूरी रकम देने को लिख दिया हो तो नॉमिनी को क्या करना होगा?
मान लिजिए एक पिता के तीन बच्चे है। और एक लडका बहुत अच्छा है। और बाकी के दो लडके या लडकी बहुत ही खराब है। उनके पास संपत्ती देना मतलब व फिजुल मे खर्चा कर देंगे इसलिए पिताजी ने अच्छे लडके को सारी संपत्ती दे दी और सुप्रीम कोर्ट के मुताबिक तो सारे हकदार है। तो बिचारा जो नॉमिनी चूज करता है। उसका तो अधिकार का खंडन कर दिया.कैसे सुप्रीम कोर्ट का न्याय बहुत अच्छा लग रहा है, आपको...?
Not happy with court's decision.
boss asa nahi ...againe rit case bhi cort me dal sakte he.meen manmani nahi karsakte
Bilkul galat hai maa bap ki jo sewa kre vo unko apne hisab se dega sabko nhi milna chahiye
बिना पूरी फॉर्मेलिटी के जब बैंक खाता नहींखुलता है तो बिना नॉमिनेशंस के कैसे खाता खुलता है इसके लिए जिम्मेदार बैंक है ना की खातेदार
Wrong decision. What if legal heirs are bad people? That's why nominee is made so that money doesn't go to wrong hands.
Will can over rule nominee and supreme court .that person could have written in will as per nomination amount should be given 😊
SC has also termed 'registered will' as invalid in one case.
They want common people to spend money on making a will ,
If nominee is not entitled to receive the money then who will receive the money. This is not justified.
System for documentation & related act needs a change
Nomination के साथ साथ legal successor and will का भी प्रावधान किया जाना चाहिए।
4th front's policies are for benifits of humanity Laws and civilization development of nation and peoples
This is not SC's decision,this is Modi's decision
Ye modi aisa khatarnak kanoon kyu laata unko family nahi to family ki takaliffe kya pata
..@@chayaoza2588..
What Mr Modi has got to do with this legal battle? Be sensible and act wisely.
HC ARORA
Vaishali Ghaziabad UP
1983 me modi tha
This is right decision as my fatherin law give all his money that he got from selling his shop to his mother , Who lived in haridwar she kept it in her account for 15 long years and on her death his sister claimed all money because she was nominee. And my fatherin law died with depression. When my husband and 3 sisterinlwas raised there voice, she smartly use divide and rule policy. She told my sister inlaws that she is with them in claiming there right in their fathers property. And they did claimed it . Ultimately my husband was left with 1/4 share in his fathers property resulting him landless.
Replace Nominee word with caretaker or manager matter will get clear to all..no further confusion or waste of time in legal court fights
Okk
If nominee denies to pay the share of fd amount to lagal heir then what steps to be taken against
Nomini ka adhikar khatam kyun bhai .? Jisne bhi ye kanoon saalon phle banaya tha uska kuch meaning tha jo sahi tha kyunki nomini koi ese hi nhi kisi ko banata ..?? Jo Hak takhta h wahi banaya jata h 💯 ye ultra seedhe kanoon jaane kon kyun bana tha h …???🥺😣😣🤨💔
Laws are equal for everyone
Right
@@LegalAttack1,Sir, kya agar ham 3 sisters hai aur ek bhai hai joh apna business meh acha kha sa kamata hai aur dusre state meh apni family k saat hai. Ham sisters meh se sirf 1 job karti hai unmarried age 52 aur ham doh age 60+aur ek divorcee hai. Mother hai age 87 jinka woh khud apna chala rahi hai lekin shrey bhai ko diya jata hai jab ham inke saat alag se kamre meh rehte hai aur dekbal karte hai. Hamara property share b nahi dena chahete hai aur ghar se nikalne k khosish kiye jha rahe hai. Ise situation meh agar apne naam k saat sister ko nominee rakha gaya hai toh bhai aur maa ka kya hakh hota hai jab woh khud he hame beghar karne meh laghe hai aur apna share dene k liye sign b nahi dena chahete hai. Hamre pass joh b hai woh khane aur dawa k liye kafi nahi hoga budape meh toh yeh kanon ka kya faidha hoga agar hamse ek ko kuch hoga toh joh b bacha ho uska equal share meh banta jai unke saath joh apne hote hue b apne nahi hai aur har second meh marre jha rahe hai jab unka ek paisa b nahi meela hame? SC ko aise be cases ko dekna chahiye joh samne nahi ate na bahut sare logh apni jindagi har ek din mare jha rahe hai apno se he. Isliye jab koyi nominee leekhta hai woh ape bhorasemand ko he haqk deta hai apna dekhbal karne k liye aur nominee ka nam leekta hai.
Sir I m merried to kiya me apne new bnk ac ya insurance me apne Bhai ko nominee banskti hu ya husband ko hi bnana hoga nominee
If Hon.ble Supreme Court has decided 40 years before then why Banks ask for nominee ?
Because nominee is termed as care taker of account....
WHY USE WORD NOMINEE. ?
USE WORD CARE TAKER.
@@LegalAttack1. What is the meaning of caretaker of the account ?
@@LegalAttack1 care taker takes care of asset in way he likes....
If he is obligated to take care of the asset by distributing to legal heirs then why will he even take care of the asset....He will not even claim the asset till the legal heirs forget about it.
Perfect decision ,
नॉमिनी(मैनेजर)और वारसदार(खून का रिश्ता)
But then husband wife Kaun honge then?
Tell us then how to make nominee as the whole and sole legal heir of the bank account? Do we need will? If yes how to draft wording of the will.
Vakil sahab ye btayein ki kisi ki do patuiyan hai jb rtd. hua to us mein pension ke dauran ek hi patni nomini rakhi kya mrne ke bad dinon ko pension milegi ya nomini ko kripya btayein
ये नियम बिलकुल ही गलत है। मान लो कोई व्यक्ति है और उसके परिवार में उसके 2 बेटे एक बेटी है और पत्नी है। करोड़ रुपए की पॉलिसी है । जिंदगी में उसको बेटो ने छोड़ दिया और सहारा नही दिया और पत्नी कही जाकर अलग रहने लगी । बेटी ने सहारा दिया और उस व्यक्ति ने बेटी को नॉमिनी बना रखा हो। डेथ हुई तो पॉलिसी की 1 करोड़ राशि हड़पने के लिए पत्नी भी आ गई और दोनो गुंडे बेटे भी और 75 लाख हड़प गए। जिस बेटी ने टटी उठाई नहलाया खाना खिलाया इलाज कराया उसको मिले सिर्फ 25 लाख । ऐसे में ये कहां का नियम है की देखभाल करने वाले और सच्चे साथी को ऐसा सबक मिले। नॉमिनी अपनी होशो हवास में बनाए जाते है। वकील साहब खुद पर लागू करके बताए ऐसे में क्या करे कोई ??
Esi situation mai vo person Will execute kar sakta hai ladki k favor mai...
Will execute karna jaruri kar diya hai ek tarah se iska matlab. This is very unfair..kuch aisi he situation main apne ghar par anticipate kar raha hu and sometimes i think ki wrong person ko kuch hissa nahi milna chaiye after my death. I am just 39 or mujhe nahi lagta ki mujhe abhi se will banani chaiye. Ab har choti choti policy k liye will nahi bana sakte
Yes sir, as per section 45 of, N.I. act. Nominee will will be like a trustee n has to distribute funds to all the legal heirs & he cannot become owner of the funds or estate...
Its a joke this law the nominee files a case that takes 15 years to settle... The nominee wasn't even the legal heir....
अगर नॉमिनी उत्तराधिकारी भी हो और मृत्यु के बाद diseased claim लेकर बाक़ी उत्तराधिकारियों को बताये ही नहीं की क्या अकाउंट था और कितने पैसे थे तो बाक़ी उत्तराधिकारियों को क्या करना चाहिये?
Baba ji ka thullu hilaye
लयभारी ,सर नाँमीनेशन धारकने सब पैसा अपना समजकर खर्च किया ,भागधार को देने से मना करे तो क्या करे ?भागधारक्षको पैसा वापस मिलेगा क्या ? मार्गदर्शन किजीये सर धन्यवाद!
I express my deep gratitude to Learnered Advocate for elucidating and interpreting the legal matter about Nomination in a crystal clear manner.😊
Sir agar class 2 legal heir nominee ho policy me aur class 1 legal heir ko kya karna chahiye, uska kitna share hoga ya poora milega . Pls batayiye
मुझे एक बात समझ में नहीं आती कि क्या किसी एक मेटर में सुप्रीम कोर्ट का दिया फैसला पूरे देश के लिए यूनिवर्सल कानून कैसे मान लिया जाता है ?? क्या फिर बने बनाये संविधान का कोई मतलब नहीं है ?? मतलब सुप्रीम कोर्ट के जजों के फैसलों से ही देश में कानून बनते हैँ क्या ?? चाहे गलत हो या सही!!! और क्या ये सिर्फ अपने ही देश में होता है या विदेशों में भी ??
इसका मतलब बैंक या इंशुरन्स कम्पनी नॉमिनी को भुगतान नहीं करेगा और लीगल heirs के क्लेमस का इंतज़ार करेगा ? कृपया आप बताये ?
Is there any government order to all banks to ignore the nomination and to secure legal heirs oder from court in such cases?
Apart from regular judgements the judge can grant discretionary powers .The case cited doesn't ratify the status of nominee
It was one of fine decision by SC. But it applies where there are minor children and old aged parents without any fixed income as well as there are family differences and disputes. In ordinary common cases of joint family, who cares about the claimant, after all money is coming to the family 😅
I think a legal WILL should be done regarding all assets, policies and demat account.
is this judgement applicable in any case...for example...my son died on 01.01.2024 and he has given his wife as nominee in the company he was working...me and my wife (his parents) are we eligible for the dues from his company, as we both being senior citizen and retired...
It's up to her, but legally you have no rights to claim any money
Agr Uska bank account ka paisa upi se nikalta ha toh uske uper kuch case banta ha kya
Right judgement. I salute to the honourable Judge of our Supreme Court for this susceptible and beneficial verdict in favour of the survivors. Though the caption of the video is misguiding and alarming. Right of nominee was not denied by the verdict of the honourable Judge of the Supreme Court.
Then omit the nominee option
If the nominee option is omitted, then the amount or resources left by the deceased will be taken by the government.
Nomini ka naam hai usko hi sab mila chahiye baad mein inke gharwale nipat le ismein court aur bank ko koi lena nahi. Baad mein gharwale nomini ke khilaf case kar le.
Please clarify in joint policy/ account who shall be first entitled to lay claim - remainder account holder or nominee? 8:15
Nominee banane ki jarurat hi kya hai.phir to account/amount ko. Kisiko bhi sarkar bant de. Not agreed.
India ke law mein hi dam nahi hai... isliye sab cheating karte hai
Very true
Being a banker then v r only wasting time by adding nominee
Of course nominee should Take care of own family if wife nominee leave the husban,s family and goes to other family by 2nd husband,on brother father house then nominee should changed immediately through bank authority or police administration,it will be better
The most genuine youtuber you clearly all the doubts very easily❤
Thank you so much for your appreciation....and support ❤ 🙏
I think it needs to be clarified. If the person wants to bequeath any asset of theirs to a particular person they should mention them in their WILL. If that person is also the the nominee of the bank asset ( and it is his or her self earned asset, not ancestral property) then the nominee becomes the owner of that asset.
Bank me surviving member cartfiket dena hota hai,
What about will ? If a nominee is registered however a will is made post that? Which of these documents will be considered for property distribution?
Agar nominee pura haldar nahi hai tho case supereme court Tak kyo haya, kya bakike court ko knowledge nahi hai
Kyo gaya
Opinion and experience depends on person to person
Haldar nahi। Haqdaar
ऐसे ज्ञानी सिर्फ सुप्रीम कोर्ट मे ही मिलते हैं।
The will of person, whether alive or dead, must prevail on his personal earnings & assets, irrespective of any court judgement in this regard, which is not concerned with it at all
Wrong decision of SC.
Nope
After the death, only legal heir should be allowed to use the money
Perfect Decision by SC . Highly Appreciable 👍🏼
Wrong decision
Nominee hata do phr
Pl also guid us on 'WILL', absence of 'WILL' and about unregistered 'WILL'
Wrong decision. How many of us senior citizens are in a position to make a Will. Lot of expenditure and time involved
We have made a will,not necessary to register it,make 3 copies hand it over to any body you trust and one copy you can keep it in your locker. It can be hand written by you,just have to follow the format..no money is spent.
Even if you have only one child,still will is a must.
qq@@ramarammohan2526
What about nomination in Mutual funds& Shares ? Is same rule is applicable here also?😊
Supreme Court कई बार अपने ही फैसले बदल देता है। वैसे भी ये उस व्यक्ति के साथ धोखा है कि उसके द्वारा nominated व्यक्ति को पैसा नहीं मिले।
जब सुप्रीम कोर्ट यह कहता है की वक्फ बोर्ड पर वह सुनवाई करने में असमर्थ हैं,तब ऐसे नये कानून लाने का अधिकार उसके पास कैसे आया. धिक्कार हैं ऐसे सुप्रीम कोर्ट के जजों पर. मुझे तो लगता है दाल में कुछ काला है,क्योंकी पहले ही private service वालों को पेंशन भी नही मिलता. फिर nominee का क्या हाल होगा.
What if there is a will giving names of beneficiaries
Then in that case Will has a final dictate ! Asset will go as per the Will.
Nominee=care taker. Share rishte mein patni, mata pita, bacho kadhikar hoga.
Nominee is not the full owner of the cash, jwellery or a property. A nominee is only the trustee.
Ok 👍
अगर अन्य दावेदार नहीं हैं तो पूरी रकम क्या नॉमिनी को नहीं मिलेगी।
UnMarried ke FD kaha jayeegeee agar Nominee Brother Ho toa ???
Brother ko?
Bilkul sahi hua yeh kanoon. Jinda rahthe hue gumrah karthe h risthedar.
Good Information sir. Thank you.
Thanks for kind Support 🙏 ☺
Agar nominee Nehi claim huwe to fir log apna Ghar me money jama karenge apna paribar ke liye to bank account Khali parega 1 sal ke ondor ,kanun ho to bhalaike liye hona sahiye ,
कानून कौन कौन व्यक्ती मृत व्यक्ती के पश्चात बॅंक बॅलन्स रक्कम के हकदार हो सकते है! कृपया इस बारे मे अधिकाधिक इन्फर्मेशन देने का प्रयास करे! धन्यवाद
Equal distribution to his heirs is correct. Good decision.
जो नामिनी बनकर बैठे वह सब अब कैंसिल😮
Unky hisay ka to right hai but absolute nahi hai....except insurance law new amendment....
Sir nomine ko fixed deposit mil sakta hai? Ager account wale ki death ho jaye?
Joint Holder account me baki family members ki kya position hai,first Holder now expired,
Sir Kiya legal hair has right to collect bank statement from bank. As I am refused by bank bcz my brother is nomani in account.
Very fine explained sir
Thanks for kind Support 🙏 ☺
NOMINEE NAHI ISKA MATLAB SARKAR KO PAISE KHANA HE
Will equally divide in legal heirs
Parfect dicision by SC.🙏
तो ये सरकार लोगो को क्यों हैरान कर रही है नॉमिनी का नाम दर्ज कराने के लिए 😂😂😂
Right
Me to nominee modi ko banwaunga ..mera 15 lakh ka loan chal rha h ..mere bad wo hi chukayega loan 😂😂😂
तो फिर बाकी सब प्रॉपर्टी भी मोदी को मिलेगी😂😂😂
It's a clumsy decision of the honourable Supreme Court, if you said so. If a person dies without making Will then who may claim for his/her banking amount. What is the use of asking nominees even till the date.
Wrong decision of Supreme Court
The property holder or the insured person needs to make a will and also a TRUST and accordingly the share will be distributed.
क्या ये नया रुल है ?? आठ महिने पहले मेरे पत्नी का डेथ हुवा ,दो बॅक मे उसके एफडी.थे नाॅमीनी मेरा बेटा था.बिना कुछ झंझट १५ दिनमे उसको दोनो बॅंक से पैसे मीले.
Pl tell ABT ..FULL DETAILS ...THEN NOMINEE KA SHARE AMT ...( IN CASE OF FD OF BANK ) KIS KO DEGY? ..?
In that case Nominee will not even work to claim the amount ....The legal heirs cannot claim the amount if Nominee doesnt take steps to claim the amount.
Vo Succession certificate se ho jata hai
@@LegalAttack1 Geting Succession certificate is a nightmare ...especially when the legal heirs stay out of country or city .
Its a very very cumbersome procedure...
In so called Digital India , these basic stuffs are not digitalized .
@@LegalAttack1agar nominee hi eklota ho toh? Mtlb or koi davedar na ho to? please bataye.
A
@@LegalAttack1
I do not think SC ordered like this. Something is missing in your video. Against the name of nominee % of share to be mentioned. Say 100%. share.
ग़लत फैसला देने पर क्या जिला और हाईकोर्ट के जजों को सजा दी गई?
बिल्कुल भी नहीं दी गई होगी।
भाड़ में जाए ऐसी कानून व्यवस्था।
Will the property than go to whom
Who has drafted this new law
Please reply
If a person dies without making a will then if the nominees right becomes invalid then to whom will the property go
Meaning..ur money is not yours to decide..its now in the hands of supreme court !
Agr koi vyakti apne account me kisi bhi nominee ka naam mention hi ma kiya ho or uski death ho jaye tab kya hoga?? Wife claim kr skti h ya nahi??
Please reply as soon as possible it'll be helpful for us
Sir... Plz clear one doubt. If I die and leave a policy or an FD behind, will the bank ask the nominee to bring the details of family who may be the level heirs of that money and then will distribute the money equally amongst heirs following the paper work?
Or
Heirs will have to knock the doors of court to claim that share?
All decisions by supreme Court should be made public.
यदि मृत्यु के नॉमिनेशन से हमारे चयनित व्यक्ति को संपत्ति का उत्तराधिकार नहीं मिल सकता है तो फिर क्या 'विल' बनाना ठीक रहेगा ?
Wrong decision of court for the reason best known to him. Nominee should be treated as will Declarations.
😂😂😂😂 १ मिनिटकी बात के लिये ८ मिनिट लगाये।ऐसे ही एक कागज के ५ कागज बनाकर केस लंबा खिचकर नजतासे पैसा निकालते रहते है
Bank sab kush nominee ko deta hi par all legal heir can claim their share from nominee if they want.
सर एक बात बताइए
अगर एक अविवाहित महिला किसी प्रकार का एफडीए या अपना सेविंग अकाउंट में किसी को नॉमिनी बनाती है ।
तो असली असली हकदार कौन होगा?
Because the guy did not had Will. Will is very important ragister is great or notarized. But pls have Will.
Another Worst Judgement by Suprem Kotha
Circumstance par nirbhar hai. Har koi case ki judgement kisi dusre case. Ki barabar ho nahi sakta.isliye apko Jada study ki jarurat hai.
So good change sir
Mere pass koi FD ya savings nai...bus 1 75000 ki policy hai
Aur bete ki 2lakhs lic n husband ki bi meri tarah 75000 ki policy...aur beti ki policy lapse hogai..... nai...
बहुत अच्छी जानकारी दी आपने