Thank you, Mr. Janowski! This is the true soul of Schumann. This is the best Rheinische experience in more than 50 years as listener and in about 40 years as a professional classic orchestra musician.
You bring me moments of joy, HR sinfonie. I'm a big fan from Brazil and don't miss any of your concerts on YT. Your musicians are gorgeous. Love your woodwind. Thank you so much!!!
Magnificent! Well played and relationship with orchestra and conductor superb. Janowski does not need the score, he knows and feel Schumann's passion. Brahms must have listened to this and studied it! Schumann passes his musical legacy!
You bet! I listen to ALL computer music on a wondrous headset. Speakers are quite inferior reproducers. The cabinet is full of peaks and valleys that distort the music.
@@gorge5412 Sooo true!! You haven’t lived until you’ve heard-and FELT!--the NY PHIL playing a simple forte passage (Mehta was conducting, and I think it was Liszt’s “Mazeppa”). They weren’t straining at all, yet the floor was simply rumbling! I couldn’t believe it-as though the earth itself was getting “goosebumps”-an elemental, geological frisson. I’m sure it’s the same with any great symphony orchestra. Live, acoustic music is simply the best, however, these videos are a great stand-in until one can afford the real thing!
IMHO, Schumann's four symphonies are highly underrated. This piece is amazing and extremely well played although it's a bit faster than I've heard before.
I agree that it's a bit faster here. I actually like it that way which is unusual for me. I normally prefer a somewhat slower tempo but the up tempo in the last movement gives it a graceful energy that it needs.
I've never heard of this! Schumann's music is also not just his symphonies. He is, just like Brahms one of the great Composers of the german romantic era of music
@@mrdietergericke Exactly. Schumann's depth is not shown in his symphonies, but in his piano and chamber music. A good example is his Dichterliebe. Schumann and Brahms were friends, but that doesn't mean they were equally great or had a similar musical style.
One can't fault this recording, such a blazing glow shimmers and entrances. Maestro Janowski ... lives this music. Worst aspect is the DREADFUL camera work, stunning horns in 2nd movement and shows trumpets.
I appreciate valuable performance. It is majestic and dazzling play. Orchestral organization also is impeccable. This masterpiece is one of my favorites. Also Schmann loved this sympony as well as Clara. I depict twice this work unwittingly.
Castelli, fortezze, cavalli, cavalieri,valli, vallate, montagne, si sente tutto ciò in questo gran straordinario e geniale capolavoro! Schumann is a great composer!!
My favorite part. The end where that dominant just stews and then finally resolves--bliss! And then the final chords of the dominant over the pedal E flat--all I can say is Wow!!
The first movement describes Schumann's impression of Koelner Dom. The second movement depicts the Fluss of Rhien. I used to live in Duesseldorf for seven years and used to walk along the Fluss of Rhein. Eiji Furuyama
2nd movement looks like Beethven sympony no.6. 3rd movement has lyrical impression. The orchstra flow like moderate sea.fluently. Next part dashes into magnificent mood. It's even splendid. Finally the last movement run toward home.. harbor The performance is brillant.. It is so marvelous..
Robert Schumann - Symphony No. 3 in E-flat major, Op. 97 (1850) I. Vivace II. Scherzo: Molto moderato (C major) III. Non veloce (A-flat major) IV. Solennemente "The Cathedral movement" (E-flat minor) V. Vivace
From 9:10 (Scherzo) on, I hear "my" Lower Rhine Area. Wide, open areas (you can see who is going to visit you tomorrow), a (mostly) peaceful, calm and tender Rhine. Before, there's the dangerous upper Rhine with its cliffs, bends and dangers. I LOVE Beethoven -but the "Rheinische" is really home to me ...
1:14 excellent! The conductor remarks the counterpoint oboe?? or maybe english horn?? but you can hear perfectly something i couldn't have heard before! Thanks!!
I think Schumann had a different way approaching a symphony. I hardly find something that resembles his melodies-harmonies that i can recognise in his pianistic works although they have a symphonic writing. If someone told me that this symphony is from an another romantic composer i would easily get convinced.
I have probably heard the Rhenish Symphony more than any other one. I especially love the blazing horn parts. This performance is just a little too fast for my taste.
Marek Janowski is a prestigious missionary of Schumann's aesthetics . Schumann will be happy . From Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵 Which national are you watching this video ？
I've always liked the dramatic flow of this symphony - it just seems to lift me up and carry me along in its pleasant journey, and Janowski keeps it moving. It's beautifully performed, although a little more urgency and weight in the 'feierlich' would have been welcomed. In fact the whole symphony could have benefited from that treatment.
That very strange syncopation at 1:14 gets me every time I hear it. I guess syncopation is the wrong word. It's at bar 63, where flutes, horns & 1st violins carry the melody and oboes, clarinets & bassons lag half a bar behind.
the opening theme of this symphony is one of the most uplifting melodies in the entire repertoire...after that the music can't maintain the same level of inspiration...
Musikfreundinnen und Musikfreunde, was bedeutet der Vierte Satz wirklich? Mit dem, was ich bisher über ihn gelesen habe, bin ich nicht wirklich zufrieden. Dear friends of music, what does the forth movement really mean? I am not satisfied with what I read so far about this "Feierlich".
Does anyone know if (and how) the fanfare at 30:20 is related to the last movement of Mahler's first symphony? In my ears it sounds too similar to be a coincidence?
Must be something about this piece. I saw Muti conduct it in Philadelphia about 40 years ago - he gave the downbeat while the audience was still applauding!
Thank you, Mr. Janowski! This is the true soul of Schumann. This is the best Rheinische experience in more than 50 years as listener and in about 40 years as a professional classic orchestra musician.
Yes it is wonderful, Have you heard Leonard Bernstein's version with the Vienna Philharmonic? It's better I think, specially the 3° and 4° movement
And is there deeper feeling in any art
than what is expressed in his Traumerei?
That 3rd mvt. is so revealing to Schumann's mental state, I believe....what a great piece of music! One of my favorite moments in music!
das perfekt abgestimmte orchester begeistert mich immer wieder! die visuelle darstellung ist natürlich wie gewohnt eine untermahlung der musik!
Love this orchestra. Anything they play is a joy to listen to. Thanks.
Me too. Wonderful always!
@@fabiusgraco5296 absolutely!!! and so wonderful they provide it without advertisements. Thank you Frankfurt! I play you all the time during work.
You bring me moments of joy, HR sinfonie. I'm a big fan from Brazil and don't miss any of your concerts on YT. Your musicians are gorgeous. Love your woodwind. Thank you so much!!!
Magnificent! Well played and relationship with orchestra and conductor superb. Janowski does not need the score, he knows and feel Schumann's passion. Brahms must have listened to this and studied it! Schumann passes his musical legacy!
Hören wir immer im Musikunterricht. Mittlerweile ein echter Ohrwurm
Feine Aufführung dieser wunderbaren Sinfonie!
Ah Schumann ! mon préféré, cette symphonie est magnifiquement interprétée, merci Marek Janowski.
1. 0:22 Lebhaft
2. 9:10 Scherzo
3. 15:57 Nicht schnell
4. 21:14 Feierlich
5. 26:16 Lebhaft Schneller
F
F
F
F
F
Thank you Frankfurt Radio Symphony for freely sharing on YT. Much appreciated, and a wonderful performance of the Rheinische.
Such a glorious work by Schumann. Give this a listen with decent headphones or earbuds for a "you-are-there" experience of this performance.
Yes; in addition, feeling the vibrations on your body in the orchestra hall is uniquely enjoyable.
You bet! I listen to ALL computer music on a wondrous headset. Speakers are quite inferior reproducers. The cabinet is full of peaks and valleys that distort the music.
@@gorge5412 Sooo true!! You haven’t lived until you’ve heard-and FELT!--the NY PHIL playing a simple forte passage (Mehta was conducting, and I think it was Liszt’s “Mazeppa”). They weren’t straining at all, yet the floor was simply rumbling! I couldn’t believe it-as though the earth itself was getting “goosebumps”-an elemental, geological frisson. I’m sure it’s the same with any great symphony orchestra. Live, acoustic music is simply the best, however, these videos are a great stand-in until one can afford the real thing!
These performances are a gift musically and for the video, which doesn't overdo itself just because it can.
Wanderful Schumann.. Good rendition orchestra
IMHO, Schumann's four symphonies are highly underrated. This piece is amazing and extremely well played although it's a bit faster than I've heard before.
I agree that it's a bit faster here. I actually like it that way which is unusual for me. I normally prefer a somewhat slower tempo but the up tempo in the last movement gives it a graceful energy that it needs.
@@Bob31415 Have you heard Carlo Maria Giulini's recording with the LAPhil?
I adore Gardiner's and Tilson Thomas' cycles of his symphonies. Have you listened to them?
@@reflectivesilverdoe No I haven't. Maybe I'll give that a listen. Thank you.
faster is better!
Love this music so much. Thank you.
What a sublime symphony!
I've heard people call Schumann "second-rate Brahms", which is completely absurd. Wonderful performance of a wonderful symphony.
It's rather the opposite. Schumann is a deeper composer than Brahms. Brahms seems deep but it's just dense.
I've never heard of this! Schumann's music is also not just his symphonies. He is, just like Brahms one of the great Composers of the german romantic era of music
@@mrdietergericke I agree completely. They're both excellent composers.
Not to mention, they were close friends until R. Schumann died. After his death, Clara Schumann (his wife) and J. Brahms continued as friends.
@@mrdietergericke Exactly. Schumann's depth is not shown in his symphonies, but in his piano and chamber music. A good example is his Dichterliebe. Schumann and Brahms were friends, but that doesn't mean they were equally great or had a similar musical style.
Romantico per eccellenza! Grandissimo Schumann e che brava questa orchestra!
At 11:30 the first oboe wails. I have never heard such beautifully expressive oboe playing in my life. Gracias José Luis.
José Luis García Vergara.
Very beautiful indeed.
Love the grandeur of the opening bars - encapsulate the beauty and majesty of the Rhine.
YES! One of the best intros to the music.
the music is so beautiful and AWESOME
I can really feel the warmth of the sun, the breeze air of the river, overall, it's such a lovely & pleasant promenade .. great interpretation!
슈만의 교향곡을 하나씩 듣고 있어요.마렉 야노프스키의 hr. 심포니 오케스트라의 연주를 통해 많은 것을 느낍니다. 감사합니다.
Bravi!!!!!!!!! Fantastic music and great video!
One can't fault this recording, such a blazing glow shimmers and entrances. Maestro Janowski ... lives this music.
Worst aspect is the DREADFUL camera work, stunning horns in 2nd movement and shows trumpets.
I appreciate valuable performance.
It is majestic and dazzling
play. Orchestral organization also is impeccable. This masterpiece is one of my favorites. Also Schmann
loved this sympony as well
as Clara. I depict twice this work unwittingly.
Castelli, fortezze, cavalli, cavalieri,valli, vallate, montagne, si sente tutto ciò in questo gran straordinario e geniale capolavoro! Schumann is a great composer!!
:)!
Слышал впервые. Остался удовлетворен.
21:14 I love that chorale, great harmonies and great choosing of instruments.
My favorite part. The end where that dominant just stews and then finally resolves--bliss! And then the final chords of the dominant over the pedal E flat--all I can say is Wow!!
Very enjoyable. Thank you.
Ganz ausgezeichnet. Vielen Dank von den Vereinigten Staaten.
The first time I have heard and it`s really wonderful
The symphony is wonderful. I like it very much.
Obrigado amigos e amigas musicistas!
The first movement describes Schumann's impression of Koelner Dom. The second movement depicts the Fluss of Rhien. I used to live in Duesseldorf for seven years and used to walk along the Fluss of Rhein. Eiji Furuyama
2nd movement looks like
Beethven sympony no.6.
3rd movement has lyrical
impression. The orchstra flow like moderate sea.fluently. Next part dashes into magnificent mood. It's even splendid.
Finally the last movement
run toward home.. harbor
The performance is brillant.. It is so marvelous..
For years the first two minutes was the melody used in a TV program at the Dutch TV..... only complete forgotten which show it was, it has been ages.
It was the opening music (Part two) in a local programme (18.00) of WDR, which means Westdeutscher Rundfunk (Cologne), West German Broadcasting.
Amo questa Orchestra,amo Schumann e questa Sinfonia !
brilliant - describing dramatic event in life. finally understand the music meaning.
How... I LOVE this work...!!!!
NOTHING like Happy... joyful, Schumann... I wish he knew how happy he made US!
Robert Schumann - Symphony No. 3 in E-flat major, Op. 97 (1850)
I. Vivace
II. Scherzo: Molto moderato (C major)
III. Non veloce (A-flat major)
IV. Solennemente "The Cathedral movement" (E-flat minor)
V. Vivace
Janowski conducted a very good Rhenish !
From 9:10 (Scherzo) on, I hear "my" Lower Rhine Area. Wide, open areas (you can see who is going to visit you tomorrow), a (mostly) peaceful, calm and tender Rhine. Before, there's the dangerous upper Rhine with its cliffs, bends and dangers. I LOVE Beethoven -but the "Rheinische" is really home to me ...
Wow
Beethoven sucks
AC/DC!
@@jennykim5087 Try Beethoven 6th
I love how some conductors, like this one immediately start after coming on stage, causing some musicians to have trouble.
They should know by now its one of the oldest conductor tricks in the book (:
Znakomite wykonanie! Gratulacje!
É uma bela Sinfonia, os temas são bem característicos, o do Scherzo (II) é daqueles que ficam, até parece um tema bem utilizado em filmes clássicos.
The best movement: 21:12 IV. Feierlich
Obrigado, esse terceiro movimento é de uma tristeza sublime, que, com a sua doçura, como expurga de nós todos os tormentos do mundo.
BELLISIMA!! GRACIAS SCHUMANN!!!MAGNIFICO!!AL ESCUCHARLA ME SUMERGO EN VARIADAS EMOCIONES!!!
Semplicemente grandioso!
Great tempo. It helps a lot
This tune really speaks of the rhineland. Its wondeful!
1st pg : 0:20
2nd pg: 1:47
3rd pg: 4:27 (cut)
4th pg: 7:06 cut up to 7:15
2nd mvmet
start 9:10
5th mvmt
start 26:16
2nd pg 27:53
Bravo!!!!!!
Bravíssimo! Muito lindo ! 👏👏👏👏
This is almost as good as the Willow soundtrack! Good effort, guys!
Very pleasant listening. And playing too! We played it with Manchester Beethoven Orchestra and both sides of conductor enjoyed it :)
참 좋습니다(very good)!
Excellent
At 6:54 is the little tune with which Brahms opens and closes his third symphony.
Bravo.
Me enamoro cuando escucho esta sinfonía. 😍
Schumann me encanta.
After moving to Düsseldorf I wanna jump in Rhine too. I don't blame Schumann.
Did you?
2악장은 정말 감미롭습니다~^^
Orthodoxe und zugleich lebhafte Aufführung dieser feierlichen Sinfonie im angemessen Tempo und ohne überflüssige Agogik.
Just the right amount of blabla. Well done.
Do the same thing by yourself.
@@notaire2 War'n Kompliment
Das verstehe ich. Danke!
Romantic interpretation
1:14 excellent! The conductor remarks the counterpoint oboe?? or maybe english horn?? but you can hear perfectly something i couldn't have heard before! Thanks!!
This symphony announces those of Brahms
Excelente
06:20 it's the theme from WILLOW!! 🎶😀 (or rather, a possible inspiration for Horner's theme for that film)
Does anyone else notice?
For sure! Apparently James Horner intended it. Checkout the Willow entry on Wikipedia
I think Schumann had a different way approaching a symphony. I hardly find something that resembles his melodies-harmonies that i can recognise in his pianistic works although they have a symphonic writing. If someone told me that this symphony is from an another romantic composer i would easily get convinced.
Likely the Beethoven symphonic influence, he wanted to continue that line
Stimmt, gute Anmerkung!
bravo
Lebhaft sure sounds like it was a HUGE inspiration for the main theme to Horner’s score for WILLOW.
Perfect!
No, this man was a genius!
I have probably heard the Rhenish Symphony more than any other one. I especially love the blazing horn parts. This performance is just a little too fast for my taste.
Excellent!
훌륭하고 멋진 영상 고맙습니다.
Thank you~^^
Marek Janowski is a prestigious missionary of Schumann's aesthetics .
Schumann will be happy .
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
Which national are you watching this video ？
6:53 brahms 3rd symphony 1st mov. main theme
Cagin thu. Are greatest composer in all time
I've always liked the dramatic flow of this symphony - it just seems to lift me up and carry me along in its pleasant journey, and Janowski keeps it moving. It's beautifully performed, although a little more urgency and weight in the 'feierlich' would have been welcomed. In fact the whole symphony could have benefited from that treatment.
30:23 Wieder-Reingeh-Motiv in der Kölner Philharmonie
That very strange syncopation at 1:14 gets me every time I hear it. I guess syncopation is the wrong word. It's at bar 63, where flutes, horns & 1st violins carry the melody and oboes, clarinets & bassons lag half a bar behind.
i guess it’s a kind of imitation, canon at the unison ?
@@geoffstemen3652 it’s not really a strict canon, so normally it just be called ‘canonic imitation’.
the opening theme of this symphony is one of the most uplifting melodies in the entire repertoire...after that the music can't maintain the same level of inspiration...
C'est plaisant en effet
Musikfreundinnen und Musikfreunde,
was bedeutet der Vierte Satz wirklich?
Mit dem, was ich bisher über ihn gelesen habe, bin ich nicht wirklich zufrieden.
Dear friends of music,
what does the forth movement really mean? I am not satisfied with what I read so far about this "Feierlich".
Does anyone know if (and how) the fanfare at 30:20 is related to the last movement of Mahler's first symphony? In my ears it sounds too similar to be a coincidence?
I came here for the Willow plagiarism, stayed for the whole symphony 😁
Beau comme tout, Pierrot le fou !
It would really suck to be a trombone for this symphony
11. (1851) Schumann, Symphonie rhénane, déb 1er mvt (jusqu’à 3’07)
That downbeat came really fast!
Must be something about this piece. I saw Muti conduct it in Philadelphia about 40 years ago - he gave the downbeat while the audience was still applauding!
Robust...like a good red wine!
MEHR JANOWSKI !!!!:)
Nicely forceful opening! This is a wondrous piece of music.
This is my Jam. Come at me.
Sounds like a mixture of Wagner and Beethoven
🎉good
L O V E you guys!!!!!!!!