Beautiful performance on the beautiful work. Fourth is the most lyrical and bittersweet symphony by Schumann, I especially like the second theme of the fast section of finale, starting at 22:46. The composer’s life was shadowed by mental health problems and those are clearly present, again especially in the finale (agitated ”screams” by the full orchestra). Schumann’s colleague and friend, Johannes Brahms, preferred the original version and was leading its publication against Clara’s wishes. Interesting historical facts lies behind the music.
Wer senkt bei so einer Aufführung den Daumen? Man sollte wirklich dankbar sein, daß solche Konzerte im Netz zu sehen sind. So hat man wenigstens was von den Zwangsgebühren, die einem vom ÖRR abgepresst werden.
Spannende Interpretation dieses romantischen Meisterwerks voller deutschen Klarheit mit perfekt synchronisierten Töne aller Instrumente. Der unvergleichliche Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im inspirierenden Tempo mit völlig effektiver Dynamik. Klasse!
Unabhängig von der großartigen künstlerischen Leistung muss man auch mal festhalten, dass die Abmischung der Aufnahme(n) wieder einmal hervorragend ist. Wirklich tolle Arbeit!
This is an exciting, dramatic account of Schumann's Fourth, so much so that it not only left me invigorated, but also a little tense. It is a tightly and economically constructed work that perhaps needs less rigid tempi and a little more room to breathe. It gave me the impression that Janowski didn't go much below the music's surface. It's definitely more a "classic" than a "romantic" view, although Herreweghe's rendition which I recently enjoyed has much the same character, but with more of a relaxed aura. It makes for a fascinating comparison, and causes me to wonder which performance I would value more over an extended period of time. I might be surprised.
This symphony is from an era when melody and harmonious sound had a very high value in constructing any work. Not any more - all we get is weird, unintelligible rhythmic patterns and percussive noise. Classical music is dead - for now. Composers are no longer inspired - they have become engineers, not musicians like Bach, Mozart, and Brahms.
Die Interpretation hat mich nicht berührt, leider. Falscher Augenblick, falsche eigene Stimmungslage ?, was auch immer... Allen Schumann Bewunderern / Verehrern möchte ich deshalb einmal meinen Favoriten zur Kenntnis geben: @ Ich wusste nicht dass Detroit so ein hervorragendes Orchester hat. UA-cam hat es mir zur Kenntnis gebracht....:-) 25.8.19 .... dass hier mein Link s.o. zensiert wurde ist armselig....
Beautiful performance on the beautiful work. Fourth is the most lyrical and bittersweet symphony by Schumann, I especially like the second theme of the fast section of finale, starting at 22:46. The composer’s life was shadowed by mental health problems and those are clearly present, again especially in the finale (agitated ”screams” by the full orchestra). Schumann’s colleague and friend, Johannes Brahms, preferred the original version and was leading its publication against Clara’s wishes. Interesting historical facts lies behind the music.
Wonderful Schumann symphony no.4. Enjoyed it and as usual Frankfurt Radio Symphony orchestra were brilliant including Marek!
Wer senkt bei so einer Aufführung den Daumen? Man sollte wirklich dankbar sein, daß solche Konzerte im Netz zu sehen sind. So hat man wenigstens was von den Zwangsgebühren, die einem vom ÖRR abgepresst werden.
👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍
Thu for explanation
I have great respect and admiration for this orchestra. love the sound that comes from it.
Spannende Interpretation dieses romantischen Meisterwerks voller deutschen Klarheit mit perfekt synchronisierten Töne aller Instrumente. Der unvergleichliche Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im inspirierenden Tempo mit völlig effektiver Dynamik. Klasse!
Sehr schön und zart
@@astridrunzheimer9921 Stiimt. Die beste Kombination der deutschen Klarheit und der romantischen Zärtlichkeit.
Very good explanation thu
An dem Abend habe ich meinen alten Traum verwirklicht, dieses Orchester live zu hören. Ein unvergessliches Erlebnis!
Diesen Traum werde ich mir auch noch erfüllen.
With this excellent orchestra and Janowski's direction I felt Schumann's true musical spirit for the first time. Stunning interpretation!
Sehr schön und zart
I. Ziemlich langsam - Lebhaft ∙
00:26 - 11:06
II. Romanze. Ziemlich langsam ∙
11:07 - 15:03
III. Scherzo. Lebhaft ∙
15:04 - 20:33
IV. Langsam - Lebhaft - Presto ∙20:33 - 29:57
A superb account of Schumann 4 - Janowski is deeply knowledgeable but also so convincing in his measured intensity.
Unabhängig von der großartigen künstlerischen Leistung muss man auch mal festhalten, dass die Abmischung der Aufnahme(n) wieder einmal hervorragend ist. Wirklich tolle Arbeit!
Ja und ja, ich pflichte bei!
Obrigado amigos e amigas musicistas!
C'est une magnifique symphonie très bien interprété. Bravo !!!
Brilliant!!!!
Bellísimo concierto para la Sinfonía 4 de Schumann!! :) Bravo!!
chocolates geminis
Schumann è così riconoscibile in quel che compone....
This is an exciting, dramatic account of Schumann's Fourth, so much so that it not only left me invigorated, but also a little tense. It is a tightly and economically constructed work that perhaps needs less rigid tempi and a little more room to breathe. It gave me the impression that Janowski didn't go much below the music's surface. It's definitely more a "classic" than a "romantic" view, although Herreweghe's rendition which I recently enjoyed has much the same character, but with more of a relaxed aura. It makes for a fascinating comparison, and causes me to wonder which performance I would value more over an extended period of time. I might be surprised.
Wanderful is the second of Schumann.. I like very much... Also 4th.thu for explanation
MÜZİK RUHUN GIDASIDIR.
La musique est la nourriture de l'âme.
Splendid! Great pacing and cohesiveness! Don't miss it!
La cadence qui cloture la symphonie est miraculeuse, aussi inventive qu'inattendue.
Fantastisch :)
Me agrego a los aplausos !! Y muchas gracias por compartir este concierto.
Большое спасибо Франкфуртскому оркестру за чудесный концерт!🇺🇦
Excelente sinfonía. Muy buena interpretación. Bravo 👌 💪
Wanderful orchestra... Veri nice Schumann
0:26 begins | 6:11 royal | 7:59 variation | 12:07 checkpoint | 13:52 *cough | 18:43 |
Fast tempi, very cleanly played and superbly controlled by Maestro Janowski. Dieser Dirigent ist absolute Spitze.
One of the biggest assholes in the musical world.
What a underrated composer.
Very nice performance 👏 ❤
Um belíssimo concerto. Espetacular.
Probably the shortest slow movement in any symphony - only four minutes long.
Fabuloso...
Orchestra fantastc
Très bel orchestre.
Genial
C est beau Schumann
👍🎶🎵🎼💓
Clara wanderful
And where is Ravel's Concerto in G played during the same concert?
Does anyone know who the lead flutist is? I have seen her several times and she is a class performer!
Clara Andrada.yes,she is great
16:30
Mvt IV - 20:33
Cornelius Castoriadis says “thank you” 😁
this is where the uefa 2024 song was stolen from :D but Schumann is the better composer! #uefa2024
Why the 2nd part without a pause?
This symphony is from an era when melody and harmonious sound had a very high value in constructing any work. Not any more - all we get is weird, unintelligible rhythmic patterns and percussive noise. Classical music is dead - for now. Composers are no longer inspired - they have become engineers, not musicians like Bach, Mozart, and Brahms.
Such a fine concertmaster - bravo!
5:50 10:25 15:00
Some strange accelerations (especially in the first movement) that I felt broke the flow unnecessarily.
For me they added a sense of urgency and drive.
18:00 22:00 28:30
cest 따봉
WUNDEBAR!
Musica che non va commentata ma "sebtita" in religioso silenzio "!
Sentita!
Not karajan kie
mir kommt das ein wenig zu schnell und zu getaktet vor.
Die Interpretation hat mich nicht berührt, leider. Falscher Augenblick, falsche eigene Stimmungslage ?, was auch immer...
Allen Schumann Bewunderern / Verehrern möchte ich deshalb einmal meinen Favoriten zur Kenntnis geben:
@
Ich wusste nicht dass Detroit so ein hervorragendes Orchester hat. UA-cam hat es mir zur Kenntnis gebracht....:-)
25.8.19 .... dass hier mein Link s.o. zensiert wurde ist armselig....
Thank you for playing warm.
Jiki K Yep, free willy as well...
뭔 일 났수