So glad to be able to hear this classic once again after all those years. My fav DT piece and also my peer. Oh, and the fact that the audience is singing along not only to the vocals but also guitar & keyboard melodies goes to show that the light has not yet died out 🥲
Nah, conclussion: the guitarist in the middle plays far more better and clean than petrucci himselff.. Petrucci is "Petrucci" because of his composing skills.. There are thousands of god-like tier guitarists in youtube
@@pablogonzalez4044 Lesson 1:, find someone who knows how to play guitar, please ask him to listen the arpegios starting from 1:44 in this video... Then let him listen the one played by Petrucci at watch?v=8h81PggfE8I starting from 2:00... then ask him which one was more accurate and clean..... Lesson 2: before calling someone delusional, be sure that he may have dozens of years of experince in the subject at which you are only acting like a teen fanboy...
Eu tava bem próximo de vc, pq tenho certeza que consigo ouvir minha voz gritando ali hahahaha, show foda, um dos melhores que já fui na vida, portnoy é surreal de tão bom.
Don't Haken members seem better at playing old Dream Theater songs than Dream Theater themselves nowadays? Probably because they're huge fans and awesome musicians themselves.......
@@danielpzmusic Well, I won't go as far as to say there's no feel. I think Portnoy's exuberance on stage often masked over the other guys' general shyness/lack of audience engagement, and now since that element is missing, it seems like DT have lost feel. It's like getting rid of a sofa you grew up with, the home never really feels the same.
They're also younger and not as burnt out of the older material as dt might be, also the 1# step suite is one the most demanding pieces of guitar playing ever., So having 3 guitars probably helps.
Actually no, Petrucci does layers of guitar tracks in studio and then approximate the parts with Rudess live. This way, you have stereo rhythm parts with solo in the middle and its much closer to the sound of the record than DT ever could get with only JP.
I didn't find the moment you said, could you tell me the exact moment and I'll be able to explain. Sorry for the delay in responding, I didn't even know that the video is being watched by many people, nor that it would have comments. Thanks!
Cliff it's not like that actually, the band Haken has 2 guitarists, but for this tour they called another guy to participate because he's a big fan, the solo guitar could play good songs.
What does people mean when they say "you need 3 guitarists to play John Petrucci's songs"? Seriously, you think any of those musicians have troubles playing anything. People admire Petrucci's compositions, but is not like he plays impossible things. And honestly, I think this sounds way more powerful and organic than the soulless band that is dream theater now after Mike Portnoy left the band.
But it was the MP who chose them to do this tour, so he liked what the guys presented! I really liked the presentation and from the video it looks like the audience was enjoying it too, even though it wasn't the DT with MP. Nice day!!!!
Sorry dude, my cell phone had 5% battery, and in order not to lose all the recording before it turned off, I closed the video... until today I'm sad about it...
Most of recordings uses multiple guitar layers to give more depth to the sound in a song. So, to replicate the studio sound in a live show there’s the option to use samples of different layers or simply adding more guitars so they can play different parts. This was a great choice. The Shattered Fortress was the best DT show I’ve attended.
Entendo seu posicionamento, mas a banda tem a formação mostrada... isso não cabe ao MP decidir, ele apenas escolheu a banda. O show foi top mesmo com a formação mostrada!
No, Portnoy invito a toda una banda mas amigos a tocar, estoy seguro que un guitarrista de Haken podria tocar todo Dream Theater, otra cosa es la composicion que es unico de Petrucci
A Dream Theater cover band, because Portnoy isn't ever coming back. He's been stalking the band at recent shows hoping for an invite, but it didn't happen and Mike Mangini rules that spot anyhow. Look at this debacle, three Petrucci wannabes and the a cringey Labrie clone that can't carry a tune in a bucket. Ugh.
It's going to be SO SICK to see Mike play these with DT again, after all these years!! 🔥🔥
So glad to be able to hear this classic once again after all those years. My fav DT piece and also my peer. Oh, and the fact that the audience is singing along not only to the vocals but also guitar & keyboard melodies goes to show that the light has not yet died out 🥲
I agree with you on all aspects, here in Brazil the public even sings the melody
i miss those songs so bad...
Brazilian crowds always turn the energy at metal gigs up to 11! This should've been a live album!
I believe that there is footage from this tour for a live album, but they couldn't put it out becausd legal reasons
I wish concerts here in Canada had this kind of energy, wow
Here in Brazil we have the idea of ??singing the melody, funny in some cases, but the energy is surreal!
Haken and Mike Portnoy? Oh, hell yes! Even if is just for a couple of songs!
Amazing day, i still happy to stay present!
@@Arcmed_TM I bet! It must have been glorious! I hope, one day, they will do it again! Cheers!
how do you say in Brasil: Mike Portnoy é fod# porr#!!!
They do a great job on BOTH songs IMO... Diego played that intro solo in This Dying Soul beautifully.
Brasileiro mostra que é fã contando a parte da harmonia 😀
Vários gringos piraram na animação da galera!!!!!
I was there!! Amazing gig!
Um dia único meu Brother!!!!!
Brasil é Brasil. Melhor público, com certeza 😊❤
the best crowd ever
Brazilians can sing the melody!
Bem vindo de volta ao DT, Mike!
Welcome back on DT, Mike!
The conclusion, you need 3 guitarists to play John Petrucci's song
Yup one is equivalent to three
Nah, conclussion: the guitarist in the middle plays far more better and clean than petrucci himselff.. Petrucci is "Petrucci" because of his composing skills.. There are thousands of god-like tier guitarists in youtube
@@burakverid646 yeah, right... The solos in the glass prison were so much cleaner than Petrucci's right? Wrong!!
@@burakverid646 oh thats some fucking delusion if ive ever seen it
@@pablogonzalez4044
Lesson 1:, find someone who knows how to play guitar, please ask him to listen the arpegios starting from 1:44 in this video... Then let him listen the one played by Petrucci at watch?v=8h81PggfE8I starting from 2:00... then ask him which one was more accurate and clean.....
Lesson 2: before calling someone delusional, be sure that he may have dozens of years of experince in the subject at which you are only acting like a teen fanboy...
Nunca vou superar o fato de ter perdido esse show.
E eu nunca vou esquecer de ter ido...muito bom
Perdeu um showzaço
@@Arcmed_TM Carioca Club?
@@dilsonnovais5006 sim, lá mesmo man! Dia épico!
A melhor filmagem de todas!!! Foda demais esse dia,irmão!!
Em breve veremos o DT novamente irmão.... Seloko.... vai ser dukaaaaaa!!!
This crowd fucking rocks, no pun intended.
This crowd singing the melody it's surreal, Brazilian Crowd insane!
Eu estava nesse show que noite 🌙
Foi demais em, eu me arrependeria amargamente se tivesse ficado em casa no dia, ou até mesmo feito outra coisa. Foi um show monstro!!!
awesome crowd
Sao Paulo, Brazil...bro
16:38 i love how Eric is just casually scratching the back of his head like this is too easy for him 😂
adjusting his in-ear monitor
Eu tava bem próximo de vc, pq tenho certeza que consigo ouvir minha voz gritando ali hahahaha, show foda, um dos melhores que já fui na vida, portnoy é surreal de tão bom.
Se eu não estivesse presente esse dia, iria me arrepender demais em.... seloko!!!!
E AGORA QUE ELE VOLTOU????????
@@Arcmed_TM finalmente, achei que esse dia nunca chegaria mas felizmente chegou, agora é só esperar o novo cd, e a vindoura turnê pra irmos
Sounds great! But there is only one Petrucci
On the other hand: there are three Griffith/Hensall/Gilette
mike make mistake to leave DT
and no labrie
Well Petrucci hasn't played this song live in 20 years, and Haken covered it flawlessly
They three 3 guitarists to match even a fraction of Petrucci's power.
In fact the band has more than one guitarist, as they were playing with the MP they shared the work.
Don't Haken members seem better at playing old Dream Theater songs than Dream Theater themselves nowadays? Probably because they're huge fans and awesome musicians themselves.......
Yes they are on point and you can feel the adrenaline and exite ment, modern dt is like 'yea we are the best' no feel
@@danielpzmusic Well, I won't go as far as to say there's no feel. I think Portnoy's exuberance on stage often masked over the other guys' general shyness/lack of audience engagement, and now since that element is missing, it seems like DT have lost feel. It's like getting rid of a sofa you grew up with, the home never really feels the same.
They're also younger and not as burnt out of the older material as dt might be, also the 1# step suite is one the most demanding pieces of guitar playing ever., So having 3 guitars probably helps.
It's probably cus they got portnoy lol
Que tremendo guitarrista es Eric gilette, Dios mío.....
Realmente... procura por outras bandas dele... toca demais!!!
That’s sick!
Caralho o primeiro solo da This Dying Soul no teclado ficou A NI MAL
Animal bicho, tão bom quanto o original!
Eu pirei demais tbm...
Perfect cover
It's not a cover
Qual o nome do tecladista? O cara é fera demais!
Diego Tejeida
Sensacional!
Haken Theater with Portnoy >>> Dream Theater with Mangini
It takes three guitar players to cover petrucci.
Actually no, Petrucci does layers of guitar tracks in studio and then approximate the parts with Rudess live. This way, you have stereo rhythm parts with solo in the middle and its much closer to the sound of the record than DT ever could get with only JP.
Why the heck video stops right before the SOLO?
I didn't find the moment you said, could you tell me the exact moment and I'll be able to explain. Sorry for the delay in responding, I didn't even know that the video is being watched by many people, nor that it would have comments. Thanks!
This was a great performance, but for so many people speaking bad about Labrie, i dont see Haken vocalist is better
I agree with you, but I believe that fans often like to complain too much.
They need 3 guitarist to Sound like Petrucci 😄
Is that Portnoy on Drums?Sounds great tho!🤘✌
Cliff it's not like that actually, the band Haken has 2 guitarists, but for this tour they called another guy to participate because he's a big fan, the solo guitar could play good songs.
@@Arcmed_TM I was only playing around,😃
That actually was a great idea to have all 3 guitarist...You all sounded nice a full✌😊
where was this? really amazing crowd!
São Paulo, Brazil, I believe
SP Brazil
Eric Gillete é um absurdo.
Toca muito mesmo!!!! seloko!!!
Que vídeo foda do caralho!!
Puta que pariu!!! 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻
2 guitars is already for this band not 3
That vocalist is gooood
vocalist from Haken
Is Haken bro, obviously good! 🤘🏻
What does people mean when they say "you need 3 guitarists to play John Petrucci's songs"? Seriously, you think any of those musicians have troubles playing anything. People admire Petrucci's compositions, but is not like he plays impossible things. And honestly, I think this sounds way more powerful and organic than the soulless band that is dream theater now after Mike Portnoy left the band.
tha Haken, Gilette, MP are awesome, but the vocal just dont match for the song.
typical fanboys lol. They are fucking moron.
But it was the MP who chose them to do this tour, so he liked what the guys presented! I really liked the presentation and from the video it looks like the audience was enjoying it too, even though it wasn't the DT with MP. Nice day!!!!
You sure cant be serious. Petrucci tone is drom another planet.
Vrg... se pone más bueno que los conciertos de dream
Who's the third guitarist who played the solos?
Haken band + MP
@@Arcmed_TM yes I know them but there's this guitarist in the middle who plays the solo at 1:42.. he's not in Haken and he's def not MP :D
@@mostafaalkady6556sorry, understand.... His name is Eric Gillette from Neal Morse Band
Isn’t that Haken? With Mike on drums
Yes man, amazing day. this show happen in Sao Paulo, Brazil.
\m/
Better than dream theater plays it lol
maybe the drummer is better than DT's
WHY YOU STOPPED RECORDING WHYYY
Sorry dude, my cell phone had 5% battery, and in order not to lose all the recording before it turned off, I closed the video... until today I'm sad about it...
@@Arcmed_TM I'm still super grateful to you, cuz Glass Prison is one of the best songs ever.
ITAIPAVA porra
show mto foda, pena que ele n solta o dvd que gravou na europa
i realize it's kind of randomly asking but do anyone know of a good place to watch newly released tv shows online ?
@Gunnar David Flixportal =)
@Raiden Bode thank you, signed up and it seems like they got a lot of movies there :) I appreciate it!!
@Gunnar David no problem :D
Imagino o peso disso ao vivo 13:09
Eu de verdade trocaria o vocal, mas para as músicas da banda ele arrebenta!!!! Foi Nice demais esse dia!!!!!
Foda damais! E o Petrucci derruba todas essas sozinho...
kkkkkkk pesado teu comentario mais concordo.rsrs
Também achei desnecessário demais tanta Guitarra..
@@marcusviniof a questão é que a banda tem mais de um guita... E ele chamou a banda toda, foi animal o show
Sem dúvidas neah mano! Esses caras aí fizeram um excelente trabalho! Mas o Petrucci e único mano, o som dele não tem nem comparação!
3 to make Petrucci's work
Luisito comunica on the vocals!
why are there 3 guitars?
Most of recordings uses multiple guitar layers to give more depth to the sound in a song. So, to replicate the studio sound in a live show there’s the option to use samples of different layers or simply adding more guitars so they can play different parts.
This was a great choice. The Shattered Fortress was the best DT show I’ve attended.
it just featuring, why not?
they can spare guitar part each other
MP hire the Haken, and Gillette all along..
3 guitars players for Petrucci cover man... That explains a lot
1 John Petrucci= 3 badass guitar players
ok cover band.. bar level.
Bar level?!!! Hahahaha, is Haken! HAKEN!!!... definitly you dont know them.
@@elementsofpersuassion i know them.. whats wrong? i said its ok cover, bar level.. have you seen cover band these days?.. just like this.
Singer lacks labrie’s balls. Still a good show.
Yes....that's part of it, but the show was animal. Nobody sings like Labrie sang on the 6DOIT album, not even him...LOL
no me gusto que tuvieran 3 guitarristas haciendo el trabajo de uno. pero aparte de eso sono muy bien
A banda Haken só estava junto ao Portnoy
Fun Fact:You need 3 guitarist to play John Jesus Petrucci Song
2 rythms 1 lead 🙄
@@SunkaiFoxStudios did dream theater need 2 guitarist?,hell nah
Duas guitarras é muito mais do que necessario já. Três é pura palhaçada
Entendo seu posicionamento, mas a banda tem a formação mostrada... isso não cabe ao MP decidir, ele apenas escolheu a banda. O show foi top mesmo com a formação mostrada!
So, you need 3 guys to play Petrucci parts...
No, Portnoy invito a toda una banda mas amigos a tocar, estoy seguro que un guitarrista de Haken podria tocar todo Dream Theater, otra cosa es la composicion que es unico de Petrucci
Uh how you gonna play rhythm and lead at the same time
Petrucci sucks
Se nota que no conoces Haken.
Haken band man, they shared the guitar parts, but the solos are always the same guy playing, after all he is the band's lead guitar!
A Dream Theater cover band, because Portnoy isn't ever coming back. He's been stalking the band at recent shows hoping for an invite, but it didn't happen and Mike Mangini rules that spot anyhow. Look at this debacle, three Petrucci wannabes and the a cringey Labrie clone that can't carry a tune in a bucket. Ugh.
Tks for watching... 🤟😎
Damn bro who pissed in your cheerios
Oh you could not be more wrong my friend :D :D :D
Could a comment have aged any worse?
Lmao. Chump.
mangini best
I'm not worried about that kind of thing, I like the good music they both make!