Bing Crosby & Temptations sing "My Girl"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 287

  • @wesgriffin6081
    @wesgriffin6081 9 років тому +97

    Paul handled that lead damn good !!!

    • @rioboy13
      @rioboy13 6 років тому +5

      He sure did!

    • @MGillDesign
      @MGillDesign 5 років тому +14

      I'd like to hear a version with just Paul and no Bing Crosby.

    • @beatricebarfield6005
      @beatricebarfield6005 2 роки тому +1

      Yes Paul did it was smooth soft and GENTLE or shall i say GENUINE!!!

    • @Frnk_3
      @Frnk_3 2 роки тому

      @@MGillDesign Honestly you could find someone to remove Bing’s parts audibly and edit out the conversation between him and Paul in the beginning.

  • @Margarhett
    @Margarhett 3 роки тому +7

    My Dad was a big Bing fan and I loved the Temptations. I wish he was still here to see this, he would have loved it as much as me.

  • @WithLoveforPaul
    @WithLoveforPaul 16 років тому +44

    There are many, many videos on here with David leading, those in which we all love, however this single video with Paul leading has to be challenged... Mr. Williams has always been underrated and underappreciated, and that is what cannot be disputed...
    Thank you Paul Williams for this wonderful lead.

    • @jeed2924
      @jeed2924 6 років тому +5

      And Paul showed his class by keeping it on the down low so, singing it gentle so as not to overshadow his host

    • @densincomprehend8879
      @densincomprehend8879 2 роки тому

      It's not that he's unappreciated we gotta stop saying that ppl love Paul
      Its just David had better leads and dennis Edwards
      But ppl acknowledged Paul as a great singer

  • @kxngshyicide6886
    @kxngshyicide6886 5 років тому +35

    I would've loved a studio version of Paul doing this on lead. I loved his voice so much. he could just stand there and hum and I would've been in awe.

    • @donnellfilms7893
      @donnellfilms7893 2 роки тому +1

      There technically is. They did a medley of My Girl and My Guy with the supremes Paul dose lead on the my girl parts

    • @MGillDesign
      @MGillDesign 2 роки тому +2

      @@donnellfilms7893 Man you got my hopes up. That medley is Dennis Edwards not Paul. Dennis is singing very lightly. Softest i've heard him sing, actually. His voice just isn't made for My Girl, but he tried. Now songs like "Papa Was A Rolling Stone, Cloud 9," absolutely. But "My Girl" is better suited to David and/or Paul.

    • @donnellfilms7893
      @donnellfilms7893 2 роки тому

      When I look it up it says Paul. But now Ik not sure

    • @densincomprehend8879
      @densincomprehend8879 2 роки тому

      @@MGillDesign actually dennis can sing it perfect but to be fair it was the beat..... Kinda made it weird

    • @MGillDesign
      @MGillDesign 2 роки тому

      @@densincomprehend8879 Dennis's voice is too over powering. Paul and David have well controlled singing voices. Dennis is better suited for the Norman Whitfield psychedelic stuff (Cloud Nine, Can't Get Next To You, Ball of Confusion). He's just too loud for some of these ballads. Paul sounds about as close to David, as they could get. Different, but similar.

  • @EazyE275
    @EazyE275 12 років тому +45

    wow paul was really good with 'My girl' Loved it.

    • @jeed2924
      @jeed2924 6 років тому +3

      Paul sang to accommodated Bing's singing with them, Paul had CLASS. Bing was the Television Host, and he was giving them exposure to his T V LAND audience, persons who might not have otherwise listened to them

    • @jeed2924
      @jeed2924 6 років тому +1

      +Lou zerr, same here and standing beside Bring really shows up his height and elegance, WOW!

  • @BigBingFan
    @BigBingFan 15 років тому +27

    For those too young to know or remember, Bing mentioned the intro sounded like "Dardanella", a Dixieland song he song on an album, featuring duets with Louis Armstrong. Bing's first love was Dixieland, the New Orleans Jazz sound, etc. I know a bit about Bing, and this was from the Kraft Music Hall that he hosted when he was about 60+. Bing was dueting with the Temptations, and the "talking over the melody" originated with Louis Armstrong, chiefly. Bing complimented a great song by the group.

  • @arlenaf.3503
    @arlenaf.3503 7 років тому +59

    Paul was the Man!!!

  • @Celtics26davis
    @Celtics26davis 11 років тому +38

    Paul is my favorite Temp. I like My Girl with him singing it any day. You've got to love that gritty voice.

    • @patriciamissie8763
      @patriciamissie8763 4 роки тому +2

      My favorite too. I love IT when he sung don't look back live at the Roostertale

    • @barbarahamlin6482
      @barbarahamlin6482 4 роки тому +3

      @@patriciamissie8763
      Yes! Paul really gave that song new meaning with that arrangement. And the background was on point, too.

  • @budrocket1
    @budrocket1 11 років тому +52

    Paul took over "My Girl" after they ousted Ruffin, and this may be the only existing document of that.

    • @edwardmalone5257
      @edwardmalone5257 Місяць тому

      You're right. Dennis for some reason was never comfortable leading that song.
      He did it once on a TV special with the Supremes, but thereafter he relinquished the duty to Paul.
      And when Paul left the group, it was Richard who led the song.
      I wish Bing Crosby had shut up and let the Tempts sing.
      Paul sounded great.

  • @mmarie294
    @mmarie294 6 років тому +69

    Paul could just flat out sang!

  • @ljo88
    @ljo88 15 років тому +11

    Paul was so smooth! I love his swagger! I bet the ladies love him back in the day. His voice take him on a whole different level. I can listen to him talk or sing all day.

    • @olgajones6530
      @olgajones6530 2 роки тому +1

      Paul Williams was Great. He could lead what are these people thinking 🤔

  • @2jorjay
    @2jorjay 6 років тому +7

    I love collaborations of great legends like this. You'll never see this with today's artists.

  • @kechellbynum2656
    @kechellbynum2656 3 роки тому +9

    Paul’s voice is hands down all good. Make a girls mind drift off.

  • @scorpio_9810
    @scorpio_9810 11 років тому +30

    take a bow, Paul. undoubtedly the greatest temp.

  • @rexpunzle
    @rexpunzle 12 років тому +22

    i would love to see more of Paul singing the lead like this

  • @SpoozyVideos
    @SpoozyVideos 13 років тому +15

    Crosby was cold with that last bassline tho!

  • @tommiexander
    @tommiexander 15 років тому +8

    Paul did a very good job in singing David's part. He sang it like he has always sang the lead part. Man, they are missed soo much, but at least their legacy will never die.

  • @EssexBeer
    @EssexBeer 15 років тому +9

    What a treat! Bing Crosby, like Dean Martin, could sing with anyone on his radio and television programs. And The Temptations! Right up there with The Mills Brothers as one of the greatest male vocal groups of all time!

    • @garymayfield5995
      @garymayfield5995 2 роки тому +2

      What planet is you from,the Mills wasn't even in the same class with the Temptations

  • @bassistdc
    @bassistdc 14 років тому +13

    Paul was an awesome singer. I never heard him do My Girl before. Also, there is no reason to compete with David. They were both extraordinary singers.

  • @jamesbyersmusic
    @jamesbyersmusic 4 роки тому +5

    Perhaps the most unlikely pairing I could ever think of, but I love it!! Paul handled 'My Girl' brilliantly!!

  • @sexibeast965
    @sexibeast965 14 років тому +3

    love both paul's and bing's voices they sound great together

  • @malotonga4957
    @malotonga4957 4 роки тому +7

    if yall didnt know thats the reason why you can hear paul after david in my girl because paul is too good hes the reason the temps made it, just listen to who do i turn to, and for once in my life live performance the man has the most emotional voice ever

  • @simon4186
    @simon4186 13 років тому +5

    Bing Crosby+ the Temptaions= Perfection In Performance. I LOVE MOTOWN!

  • @2jorjay
    @2jorjay 6 років тому +6

    The Temptations and Bing Crosby.... awesome!

  • @bettythompson80
    @bettythompson80 9 років тому +9

    Thanks for I wish I could see full video of whole show love this Paul Williams leading amazing singer love him so much talent, eloquent, sensational, inspirational singer gotta love him...love me Paul Williams......Xoxo xoxo..

  • @jamilmali49
    @jamilmali49 11 років тому +19

    Paul was my favorite Temptation.

  • @DatesTwinn
    @DatesTwinn 15 років тому +6

    Temps footwork is classic.

  • @91trueblue
    @91trueblue 15 років тому +12

    The Tempts were all about putting out good music. Paul and David were great friends. Smokey understood what sound he wanted for this song. He never stopped believing in Paul. Once this song took off, a lot of the leads shifted to David, then Eddie, down to Paul. They were ALL great singers! Timing in life is everything. When this song charted, they stuck with this formula. Its no doubt in my mind that the leads could have been handled different. But who could argue with results?!

  • @Amaro2021
    @Amaro2021 14 років тому +2

    Awww paul singing this I love this!..great!

  • @markrauson2050
    @markrauson2050 3 роки тому +5

    Paul Williams did a real good job singing my girl on the bing Crosby show

  • @holygroove2
    @holygroove2 13 років тому +34

    Aww you dudes need to realize that this was cool for its time. Bing Crosby gets my respect b/c he was a white cat singing w/ major black talent - Louis Armstrong hello?
    Remember that this country wasn't always cool with black and white on the same stage. Bing had his own vibe, but he was def a musician. Notice that he doesn't try to take over the song like most of the modern vocalists would try to do - he gives MAD respect to the Temptations musically, even though he himself was cool.

    • @patriciamissie8763
      @patriciamissie8763 4 роки тому +2

      I love all music and Bing Crosby was one of many singers that I watch act and sing.

    • @Judeaben
      @Judeaben 4 роки тому

      bullspit!!! The Temptations were sellouts!

    • @holygroove2
      @holygroove2 4 роки тому +4

      @@Judeaben lol!! If the Temptations were selling out, then so was everyone else who got popular!

    • @anthonynero1078
      @anthonynero1078 4 роки тому +3

      I agree with you, Holygroove and I guess Snoopdog is a sellout also for hanging out and making a show with Martha Stewart.

    • @olgajones6530
      @olgajones6530 2 роки тому

      Thank you, you said exactly what I was thinking. Different time, I love the Respect from both Gentlemen!

  • @earvinlewis1
    @earvinlewis1 4 роки тому +5

    Damn Paul did a really good "My Girl" lol

  • @beebandloz
    @beebandloz 16 років тому +4

    This is so good, love the temptations and this shows that Paul could have sang David's songs and been given more leads. R.I.P Paul, Eddie, Melvin and David

  • @holygroove2
    @holygroove2 12 років тому +13

    I don't think anyone in this context is forgetting color, which is why I have so much respect for Bing here. The message is not "I don't see color", but rather, "I love these people, and they happen to be black, so deal with it...oh and by the way I'm going to have fun up here too..." =)

  • @djreelballer
    @djreelballer 16 років тому +2

    dang! Paul singin My Girl, just amazing cuz he put some SOUUULL into it.

  • @LauraBotsfordmusic
    @LauraBotsfordmusic 11 років тому +2

    Wow what a classic performance. First time seeing this missed it back when I was a teen. Cool beans

  • @genobourn7423
    @genobourn7423 6 років тому +3

    Legends in their own right! Loved it!

  • @dynamite8503
    @dynamite8503 15 років тому +4

    PAUL=PERFECTION

  • @simonlevante2257
    @simonlevante2257 8 років тому +22

    Bing can sing anything and make it classy!

  • @dayfan1962
    @dayfan1962 10 років тому +23

    Thank you for posting this rare and historical clip. Bing Crosby held his own with these legendary soul singers. This is a perfect visual example of how music can bridge any gap; racial, generational. and cultural.

  • @kechellbynum2656
    @kechellbynum2656 3 роки тому +5

    All of them were 6’0-6’4. Am I the only one that look at their long feet and huge hands? They were real eye candy and they can sing as well they were the total package.

  • @williemuhammad80
    @williemuhammad80 2 роки тому

    Bing Crosby and the Temptations, classic 👌 thanks for sharing Paul Williams leading vocals on My Girl I think David Ruffin liked it 😀 so did i

  • @UFCtrumpsboxing
    @UFCtrumpsboxing 6 років тому +8

    I love Paul Williams' voice as well

    • @arlena532
      @arlena532 6 років тому

      Like wise. His smooth and passionate voice.

  • @chrisbell2101
    @chrisbell2101 3 роки тому +4

    Eddie kept them Temps looking good

  • @joshuawilliford3743
    @joshuawilliford3743 6 років тому +2

    that was an amazing part when Bill said is that the intro? And Paul say yes LOL and he does that laugh and cool head nod. That part is amazing. Along with Paul singing with that heartwrenching sound along with Bill.

  • @gua117
    @gua117 15 років тому +1

    Wow, this is a classic. Ole Bing was hangin in there!!.

  • @504boi8wd
    @504boi8wd 15 років тому +1

    a true treat indeed...def miss david but nice hearig paul do this....wish he had more leads than he did with them! temps 4ever!!!

  • @mildredfitts2785
    @mildredfitts2785 5 років тому +2

    I Love This Paul Did To Good, Thank You Very Much For Sharing.

  • @dorisehughes2115
    @dorisehughes2115 6 років тому +5

    Eddie is smooth with the dance moves

  • @WithLoveforPaul
    @WithLoveforPaul 16 років тому

    Smiles all around, right?! Agreed, definitely could not stop smiling watching this one... Just to see Paul sing & might I add do a little acting... Though cleary some of it was meant to be comedic he couldn't help but to sing it with heart, because that's all he knew, absolutely Love that from him. Absolutely love this, thank you so so much for posting.

  • @Caldom
    @Caldom 16 років тому +1

    OMG!!!!! I have never seen this before Paul did an excellent job on this song !!! love it thanks for the post

  • @BigBingFan
    @BigBingFan 12 років тому +5

    Yes, holygroove2, you are correct about Bing-at various times in his long career, Bing highlighted Louis Armstrong, Ella Fitzgerald, Nat King Cole, etc. on his Radio shows, variety shows, Movies (like "HIgh Society" featuring Louis Armstrong's whole band)-at a time when blacks didn't get exposure in media. I am obvously a BigBingFan, but recognize his contributions to forgetting COLOR and highlighting TALENT. I think he said his favorite female singer was Ella & Satchmo a favorite duet partner

  • @Caldom
    @Caldom 15 років тому

    You are soooo right , he looks so good in this clip all I can say is WOW !!

  • @Caldom
    @Caldom 15 років тому +2

    Your right about that only Paul. He sang with so much feeling, David & Eddie were GREAT, but Paul was by far my favorite

  • @Lampshade51
    @Lampshade51 13 років тому +7

    Crosby was cool. Always open to the new music. Said of Elvis: "that boy's really got something". Said of The Beatles: "Some marvelous songs, lots of talent". Heard David Bowie, ("compelling performer") booked him on his last TV special (1977) and sang with him. Sinatra, Como, others put down the new sounds.....Bing embraced them. Gotta give him his due. He was a pretty hip dude.

    • @bryanismyname7583
      @bryanismyname7583 7 років тому +1

      Sinatra didn't like rock & roll much, but he did do a special with Elvis in 1960 and tried his hand at some more modern songs and styles (even made 2 disco records) during the '70s with mixed results. Tony Bennett, however, claims to have literally gotten sick when trying to sing modern songs.

    • @michaelcondry1493
      @michaelcondry1493 7 років тому

      Lampshade51 yes but I can promise you ANY singer from the golden age is rolling in their grave hearing the music of today.

    • @tszshamng3149
      @tszshamng3149 6 років тому

      Lampshade51 Lori

  • @Soundwves
    @Soundwves 15 років тому +2

    Paul, when dancing with the temps looks short, although I know all the temps were 6ft. +. but next to Bing he looks really tall and extremely handsome. They all do.

  • @PetePeterkin
    @PetePeterkin 8 років тому +14

    Who knew.... MY GIRL would have been a hit with Paul on lead?? He just NAILED IT!!! And let me tell you I have not heard ANYBODY come even close to Ruffin on that song! Not Michael Jackson...not Marvin Gaye....not Otis Redding....not even Smokey himself! (Check youtube versions before hating)

    • @flakyb321
      @flakyb321 5 років тому

      Pete Peterkin to be fair My Girl would have been a hit with my garbage disposal on lead but Paul’s recalibration had me yelling in my garage just now. How I wish somebody could extract his voice from this so we don’t have to suffer through Bing’s half. Paul is the absolute best no question, I’d love to hear the master recordings with his voice only

  • @margierobertson9552
    @margierobertson9552 10 років тому +1

    Congrats to Temptations y'all are the greatest group of Motown forever lol.

  • @noraparker4137
    @noraparker4137 5 років тому

    Profiles in Pittsburgh
    This is So Fabulous Six Brother Vocalists!!!
    Otis Williams founder New and Original Temptations at Heinz Hall in 2018.
    Brother Bing Crosby Love Pittsburgh Too, and Brother Bing was The Owner in the 1960s of The Pittsburgh's Pirates Baseball Team. YES .❣️🙏 Pittsburgh's Pirates , which is across from, Downtown Pittsburgh's Heinz Hall.
    WOW WOW WOW Amen

  • @WithLoveforPaul
    @WithLoveforPaul 16 років тому +1

    Absolutely, true singer...

  • @d-low650
    @d-low650 4 роки тому +4

    I think they should have also recorded a version of Paul Williams singing my girl

  • @bustabass9025
    @bustabass9025 4 роки тому +1

    The post Classic Five era begins another long run for the Temptations. They would continue to set the bar for other groups to strive towards, with shared leads from Paul, E.K., and of course the newly added Dennis Edwards. The times changed, the music changed, and they changed. But the Classic Five with David Ruffin squalling out the lead lyrics in that gritty baritone of his will always personify THE Temptations!
    🎤👓🎩👞

  • @Maestro2500
    @Maestro2500 14 років тому

    All I can do is sit here with my jaw on the floor in awe. For two minutes and fourteen seconds, the only thing I could do was look at this image of a golden past and ask myself: What happened to music in this country?

  • @lindabrooks9296
    @lindabrooks9296 4 роки тому +1

    I miss my Temptations!!

  • @Willrell
    @Willrell 7 років тому +1

    I'm glad I got to hear paul version I love his version has more range than I thought out side of David he is the only one that can sing it superb

  • @lorimerrill9725
    @lorimerrill9725 3 роки тому

    I love the way they all work together

  • @swilliams9213
    @swilliams9213 15 років тому +1

    A Disaster? NO...More like 50 years and 2 golden generations of superstars performing (real) classic music together... See if you'll ever see that happen again in our lifetime!!!

  • @ericdobson1051
    @ericdobson1051 11 років тому +19

    David ruffin Eddie Kendricks but thats Paul Willams With the leads here

    • @mgj1s479
      @mgj1s479 5 років тому +1

      David Ruffin isn't on there. Dennis Edwards is

    • @rudymoore8579
      @rudymoore8579 5 років тому +1

      Paul Williams on Lead (Back) L to R: Eddie Kendricks, Melvin Franklin, Dennis Edwards & Otis Williams that’s when he was kicked out of the group but in the 80s he rejoined...

    • @Frnk_3
      @Frnk_3 3 роки тому +1

      @@rudymoore8579 Well him and Eddie joined for the reunion only. They were after Christmas 1982. Eddie wanted to rejoin badly. Otis didn’t allow it tho and kept Glenn Leonard.

  • @staxsteve
    @staxsteve Рік тому

    Never thought I’d see my dads favourite singer with my favourite group

  • @binghlcrosby
    @binghlcrosby 15 років тому +5

    I would hardly call Bing's style 50s, and most certainly not playful back and forth. He, for the large part, invented moderning singing with a microphone and emoting lyrics in a personal style. The strength, stability and warmth conveyed in his voice meant a great deal to a great many people during both the Great Depression and World War II. I agree that his voices colour and tone doesn't lend itself naturally to a soul song though.

  • @Jerky101
    @Jerky101 16 років тому

    I never heard any Tempt. cover David's songs as well as Paul!!
    Both are exceptional performer/singers.

  • @lorenzoadamson6893
    @lorenzoadamson6893 7 років тому +1

    Love love love it !!

  • @chariotwofilthy8374
    @chariotwofilthy8374 3 роки тому +1

    Gm edagdwg thanks for sharing this history of respect for yourself and others God is always around this is real life having fun with anyone cares about people love is real Linda j peace ☮️☮️☮️☮️☮️🦋🦋🦋🦋

  • @petulia67
    @petulia67 14 років тому +1

    Paul had that great aching voice.

  • @olgajones6530
    @olgajones6530 2 роки тому

    Loved this Special performance ❤ 💖 💜

  • @lindahines8287
    @lindahines8287 5 років тому +3

    Go Paul!

  • @JRobbySh
    @JRobbySh 12 років тому +4

    Bing is having a good time.

  • @TheSharongreen
    @TheSharongreen 14 років тому +1

    Paul could sing anything..he was just fantastic...can't say enough about him..there will never be another..just my opinion lol

  • @54spiritedwill54
    @54spiritedwill54 15 років тому +1

    Fantastic video!

  • @Paul70
    @Paul70 14 років тому +1

    Bing was reminding me of the scene in The Five Heartbeats where the White group came out to sing one of the Five Heartbeats songs..LOL!!
    I wonder what's the next rare video i'm going to see on You Tube??
    Perry Como & Sly & The Family Stone doing Sing A Simple Song..LOL!!

  • @jonkeiser1537
    @jonkeiser1537 6 років тому +1

    That was a good base voice Mr Crosby did at the end.

  • @snoops71
    @snoops71 16 років тому

    That was very, very, VERY cool!
    Love it!!!

  • @sierria64
    @sierria64 15 років тому

    bing has a soulful voice

  • @94997075
    @94997075 16 років тому +2

    This is my favorite song and I love Paul's versions of it but my man David is still the only one who can sing it for me. His songs are his alone as well as Paul' s and any other lead singer.

  • @dynamite8503
    @dynamite8503 16 років тому +1

    OMG! OMG! OMG! WHAT A TREAT!

  • @jaylene.turner6524
    @jaylene.turner6524 Рік тому

    The Temptations:
    Paul Williams(Singing lead with Bing).
    Background Vocals
    Left to Right:
    Eddie Kendricks(First Tenor/Falsetto),
    Melvin Franklin(Bass),
    Dennis Edwards(Baritone),
    and
    Otis Williams(Second Tenor).

  • @holygroove2
    @holygroove2 12 років тому

    Oh and as I look at this again, I can tell that Pops was Bing's favorite duet partner from how Bing is interacting here. This video is cool on a whole bunch of levels.

  • @AtomicLobotomy
    @AtomicLobotomy 10 років тому +20

    Bing Crosby definitely left his mark on American music--he's a "great"--and give him credit for having Temptations on show he was hosting, but the actual performance here makes it clear Bing Crosby and Temptations were singing two different types of music, and inhabited two different musical universes. To my mind, Bing's voice (and, in this case, his "cuteness") just don't mesh with the Temptations, their power, their harmonies, and their getting and keeping it all together.

    • @jeed2924
      @jeed2924 6 років тому

      If you listened carefully to Bing Atomic Lobotomy, you will hear Bing telling Paul......."I'm not good on the harmony Paul"........

  • @mmarie294
    @mmarie294 5 років тому

    ahhh the brothers were so smooth!

  • @djdeitch
    @djdeitch 16 років тому +1

    Fantastic video,.ktf.

  • @macho123kid
    @macho123kid 12 років тому +1

    Beautiful

  • @Eirana9
    @Eirana9 15 років тому

    While Ruffin sang lead on, and did a studio recording of You'll Lose a Precious Love, it wasn't released until after My Girl. So I guess it comes down to semantics. :)

  • @cathkarr
    @cathkarr 16 років тому +1

    "His Bingy Ass". LOL

  • @alnewberry
    @alnewberry 16 років тому +2

    David could naturally sing higher than Paul since he was more of a second tenor and Paul was a baritone. You don't hear Paul using falsetto much, if at all. It's hard to know just how high he could sing since we don't hear him using falsetto much.

  • @jayburke813
    @jayburke813 6 років тому

    Bing Crosby killed it at the end tho. 🎵talking bout his girl🎵

    • @3912James
      @3912James 6 років тому

      Until I saw the video....I just assumed it was Melvin singing.

  • @Oldchestnut34
    @Oldchestnut34 16 років тому

    omg thankss so much for the post

  • @priscillaaddison-crosby3641
    @priscillaaddison-crosby3641 3 роки тому

    Paul beautiful voice

  • @angel2u945
    @angel2u945 3 роки тому

    Wow..Love it..

  • @rogerrrubin
    @rogerrrubin 12 років тому +1

    cool clip!

  • @mrsmarkwahlberg
    @mrsmarkwahlberg 14 років тому

    love it...bing doing his thing ;p