Jewish Israelis: If you are all related, why are you different colours?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 лис 2024
- The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
www.paypal.me/...
/ askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
My conclusions as an Israeli:
1) Israelis need better education in genetics.
2) Israelis need to understand that mixing with others was inevitable and it happened a lot more than they'd like to believe.
3) Israelis need to learn that being born in Ethiophia does not mean your skin becomes black. Evolution does not happen over the course of 5000 years (to the extent of changing skin colors).
Ariel Weinberger not 'israelis'. Uneducated people on the streets
@@Levi-hu8jb Who should have known all this as ones who studied in the ISRAELI education system. So yes, Israelis.
@@arielweinberger Don't Israeli schools teach kids from an early age about the history of the Jews?
I don't understand how mixing with other people could have happened, would you describe your theory? According to my knowledge the Jews segregated themselves back in the time and did not intermarry. And affairs were not common as well.
Ramy Gaw In the United States there people with last names cohen who are not even jewish but probably have jewish dna because of intermarriage.
Also include converts it happens a lot that's why the general rule is if your mother is a jew you are a jew.
"You became white from the cold" lol
Its simple science. Skin tone is a manifestation of DNA coding based on how much sunlight (and intensity of sunlight) the DNA has been coded to protect for and against. The rays of the Sun do not hit equally on all parts of the world. The poles receive lower amounts with the highest and most direct concentration hitting at the equator. You cannot have too much melanin at the poles because this would thwart production of Vitamin D, which is a key nutrient derived from the Sun. Therefore, DNA coding registered to areas that receive low amounts of sunlight manifest in as "pale skin" because you don't need additional shade preventing you from soaking up the little available sunlight. As you move down to mid latitudes, you will notice that people TAN. This is because sunlight varies and their body lightens to absorb sun in low light months and darkens to protect during high exposure months. At the equator, you have an overload of sunlight, so the body manifests with dark skin (like sun glasses for your body) to prevent over exposure and burn.
Pale skin people burn in the sun because the skin is not made for high intensity zones. Dark skin people develop sickle cell from low sunlight environments because they can't absorb enough Sun and then the little Sun that is available, their skin blocks it, because its needs longer and more intense sunlight exposure.
This is all just how the body safely permits the human to generate Vitamin D and survive in the various types of Sunlight exposure at optimal measure.
So yeah, Cold regions (usually associated with regions of low light and months of darkness) produces skin tone without the Sun buffer called melanin.
It wasn't a dumb comment.
@@kaitemarie5404 ohhhhh come on
@@kaitemarie5404 so black jew become black because the heat
I live in Kuwait it is the hottest country on earth I'm still white
Son you telling me if I moved to Germany and my family lived there for 1500 year they will become blonde blue eyes even if they didn't mary from any German person
@@anawa7edminalnass206 just in case thé vast majority pr ashkenazim arent blond blue eyes it's bullshit. M'y family are as dark as egyptians and lived in poland. Annnnnd there are différent skin tone in every country, morocco, Lebanon spain.......
@@anawa7edminalnass206
Genery is not invented. It was established early on. Your DNA responds to its environment. Its optimal environment is the one it is programmed for.
If you are fair skinned in the middle East, then you have genetic coding programmed for low light areas.
Nobody is "white" in the middle East. Sorry. If they are blond or blue-eyed, thats a direct result to mixing of bloodlines.
African jews get African genery through mixing.
Askenazic jews are mixed.
Mizrahim mixed.
Pure race people are rare.
So DNA coding, established long ago sets traits. The further up your heritage hails from, the lighter you can be.
The closer to the equator, the darker.
A direct result of genetics and environment. Specifically how to optimize Vitamin D production and/or protect from high intensity/long exposure to Sun.
Is it just me who was expecting more intelligent answers....
It is a recurring thing with the people from these videos and their answers, most of them just walk in circles to avoid giving the right answers.
Yes. Don’t expect logic here
many of them are nice people having a good time when some stranger shows up asking loaded questions...
It's not just you lol
So what would you have said? A geneticist would know, everybody else is just guessing.
That question seems to upset Israelis more than your usual questions. Obviously during 2000 years of exile there was some mixing with local populations, but modern Israelis seem to be very resistant to that notion.
Rev 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
2:05 "Do you think your people mixed with local people in Europe?"
"No"
HHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
truly an idiot.
Felix Lagemann jewish literally mixed with all races of the planet, eyptians, arabs, sirians, europeans, babilonians, persians etc
@@oskaralegre5094 no Oskar Alegre we didn't mix thats why we still keep our original language and alphabet unlike you and nations you listed.
@@oskaralegre5094 Jews lived in European ghettos separately. IT's a fact. You never been to Europe. Where are you from? Some communist country in South America?
OF course not.
Samaritans are pure Levantine Israelites who never left the region and they range from white skin, red hair, blue eyes to brown skin, black hair, black eyes. As others have said, the Levant has always been physically diverse.
Yes, there's been intermarriage with non-Jewish, but modern Jews are no more physically diverse than modern Italians or African Americans, who are 15-20% Northern European.
@Eternal Fisherman Not really true. Genetics show Samaritans as being almost identical to Bronze Age Levantines. No other group in the region is so unmixed. Lebanese/Palestinian Christians are probably a close second, but they best resemble Roman era Levantines. That's ~1500 years difference!
Deep inside their heart they know they are not related😂.
Can you explain this? Do they believe they never intermarried or something?
@@lyssalouise2705 have you ever heard about khazaria?
@Sarah Mann - WHO "destroyed" the Khazars over 1000 tears ago ? In fact, the Khazar EMPIRE was destroyed, but NOT the Khazars who migrated to West, in Europe, starting with the Hungarian migration to Pannonia. 3 out of the 10 so called "Hungarian" tribes were Khazars (Kabbars).
The Khazars took over Israel itself, and I am pretty sure YOU are a Khazarian woman too. They did NOT disappeared, but MULTIPLIED.
PLEASE STOP misleading the people.
@Sarah Mann - lady, it looks like you are indeed...manipulative. Here is what I was writing about, and you know it well : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kabar
see "Archaeological theories on Religion" - "At least some Kabars were of the Khalyzians' Jewish faith; others MAY (but NOT sure !!) have been Christians, Muslims or shamanists."
Then Hungarians and Khazars - "Around 830, a rebellion broke out in the Khazar khaganate. As a result, 3 Kabar tribes of the Khazars (probably the majority of ethnic Khazars) joined the Hungarians and moved through Levedia to what the Hungarians call the Etelköz, the territory between the Carpathians and the Dnieper River. The Hungarians faced their first attack by the Pechenegs around 854, though other sources state that an attack by Pechenegs was the reason for their departure to Etelköz. The new neighbours of the Hungarians were the Varangians and the eastern Slavs. From 862 onwards, the Hungarians (already referred to as the Ungri) along with their allies, the Kabars, started a series of raids from the Etelköz into the Carpathian Basin, mostly against the Eastern Frankish Empire (Germany) and Great Moravia, but also against the Lower Pannonian principality and Bulgaria. Then they together ended up at the outer slopes of Carpathians, and settled there, where the majority of Khazars converted from Judaism to Christianity in the 10th to 13th centuries. There could be shamanists and Christians among these Khazars apart from Jews." - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khazars#Khazars_and_Hungarians
@Sarah Mann
1 - www.jstor.org/stable/41035790?seq=1
2 - did you EVER compare Wikipedia to Britannica or Oxford or any ORHER Encyclopedia ? No, you didn't. Well, it became BETTER than ANY other encyclopedia being MORE detailed and having lots of Notes = Biography. Yes, Wikipedia is a GOOD source of knowledge, despite the fact that is still seen as inaccurate. Simply, make a study on your on.
3 - the Khazars converted to Judaism around 740 AD; other sources say 9 or 10 century. Actually, it does NOT matter the reason, but the conversion ITSELF which led to the ASHKENAZI in our times. - brill.com/view/title/14220
www.researchgate.net/publication/303087691_The_conversion_of_the_khazars_to_judaism/link/5f67eab9a6fdcc008631cd7b/download
(I just downloaded this text by the Khazar Jew Peter. B. Golden)
Don't write me, please, about the NON-Turkic DNA in the Ashkenazi's blood. Fake tests and writings are everywhere. In fact, you want to CONVINCE the OTHER readers of these comments that you Khazars don't exist, therefore you have the right to the Palestinian land as descendants of the Israelites. Please, STOP, it’s USELESS. We KNOW you are Khazars.
4 - the Khazar Jew Shaul Stampfer wrote : "The view that some or all the Khazars, a central Asian people, converted to Judaism at some point during the ninth or tenth century is WIDELY ACCEPTED." - www.jstor.org/stable/10.2979/jewisocistud.19.3.1?seq=1
I don't know why you CONTINUE to DENYE the REALITY among your people.
5 - "On the Date of the Khazars' Conversion to Judaism and the Chronology of the Kings of the Rus Oleg and Igor. A Study of the Anonymous Khazar Letter from the Genizah of Cairo" by the Khazar Jew Constantine Zuckerman - www.persee.fr/doc/rebyz_0766-5598_1995_num_53_1_1906
I don't know why you CONTINUE to DENYE the REALITY among your people.
6 - "Date of the Khazar Conversion to Judaism
This has already been referred to above (see *Būlān and below Khazar Correspondence). The date c. 740 C.E. is suggested by converging considerations, namely, the circumstances of the reported conversion to Islam in 737 and the dating given by *Judah Halevi in the Kūzari (Cosri). The absence of distinct references to the Judaism of the Khazars in the biographies of St. Abo of Tiflis, who was in Khazaria c. 780 C.E. and of Constantine (Cyril), who was there c. 860, should not be pressed as proof that the conversion to Judaism took place only later (cf. also M.I. Artamonov, Istoriya Khazar, 332-3). Mas ʿ ūdī states positively that the king of the Khazars became a Jew in the caliphate of Hārūn al-Rashīd (786-809 C.E.). This may well refer to the reformation c. 800 under *Obadiah of which the Reply of Joseph speaks. S.P. Tolstov has sought to explain the Khazar conversion to Judaism as a result of the conquest of Khwārizm (*Khorezm) by the Arab general Muslim ibn Qutayba in 712." - the Jewish site "Jewish Virtual Library" - www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/khazars
I don't know why you CONTINUE to DENYE the REALITY among your people.
7 - there is a batch of correspondence in Hebrew between the Khazar king Joseph and a Spanish Jew, Ḥisdai ibn Shaprut. In the texts it is written that a generation ago the king of the Khazars was choosing a religion and decided that his religion would be Judaism.
I don't know why you CONTINUE to DENYE the REALITY among your people.
8 - historian and traveler Al-Masudi is often cited by the Russian historian Kokovets. Al-Masudi lived in the late ninth-early tenth century and claimed that during the rule of ar-Rashida, the fifth caliph of the Abbasid Caliphate, Khazaria made the decision to convert to Judaism.
I don't know why you CONTINUE to DENYE the REALITY among your people.
9 - I gave you here OTHER links than Wikipedia. Are they reliable ?
Wow, the hardest question for them to answer ever!!
Either they don't know much about genetics or they don't want to accept that thay have been mixing up with other peoples (gentiles) through history.
Possible solution follows from the fact that by Judaism, you are a jew if your mom is, then a jewish women can start a jewish roots with a non jewish black/white/yellow/purple man.
Another one raises by the conversion option, i.e. you can convert to judaism. So a 1000 years ago converted e.g. black women could have a really great number of black jewish descendants by now.
Some avoided to answer the question and started saying strange stuff like jews turning white because of the cold and the snow ....or coming from 12 different tribes ... even then tribes that are of different race mean that their descendants are also different.
Only Tal the guys with the 2 girls 6:48 was candid in his answer and said jews weren't related by blood but by religion...culture etc
Its blindly obvious that jews have intermarried with locals, but few of the people asked are willing to contemplate. It's been genetically proven that the maternal DNA of ashkenazi jews is overwhelming southern Italian in origin. The paternal DNA is from the Levant. If a largish group of black people go to Germany and only ever marry other black people, 500 years in the future their offspring will all still look black. However, if they intermarry with the local white germans, after 500 years their offspring will no longer resemble the original group. Their ressemblance will match the local germans. This is clearly what happened with the jews. Just living in different climates, does not change skin colour after a few thousand years. It takes much longer than that. The jews intermarried where they went. Just like all cultures do.
True, but they only intermarried when they had no choice, for example when the community was too small and young. Once it became large and established enough they practiced endogamy. That's why the maternal ancestry you mentioned was Italian and not German, reflecting the earliest stage of Ashkenazi formation.
There are even religious laws that say a child is only Jewish if his/her mother was Jewish. Mother is chosen instead of father in order to be more exclusive in who counts as a Jew and avoid introducing many non-Jews into the community
Of course there was intermarriage going on in the diaspora, this is beyond dispute. Why then were there laws all over mediaeval Europe prohibiting Jews from intermingling with non Jews if it wasn't already a common enough occurance? I think the answer to the question is yes but only to an extent. Most Jews will have very similar genetic markers and that's because most of them originate from common ancestors in the Levant. Clearly between then and now there's been a lot of migration to different climates/geographies and so you have Jews that look very different in appearance.
In a lapsus of 2000 years you cant talk about appearence. If a family of africans go to Sweden and they are there for 2000 years they will not become whites... Thats just dumb...
@Starhopper You know, you confuse me sometimes. Sometimes you post comments like this that are logical and coherent. Other times you just troll and spread hate. Is there a reason for that?
Peace
@@hailandplaice Sounds like you're regurgitating the same unconfirmed and fanciful Khazar myth of Ashkenazi ancestry. Elhaik's methods are disgraceful and shoddy. History doesn't support the hypothesis. Ashkenazim didn't originally migrate to the Khazar empire, but originally migrated to Ashkenaz (Germany/Rhineland) where Yiddish originated as a mix of Hebrew and High German (West Germanic), and only migrated east after persecutions by Christians hundreds of years after the fall of the Khazarian Khaganate by Sviatoslav I in the late 980's. So the Khazarians are recorded as dispersing into the Yerevan/Armenia/Dagestan.. and the Ashkenazim were already recognized as a distinct group at that time and recorded by Charlemagne in the 800's. Maybe you shouldn't make such wide sweeping generalizations about a population group without actually backing it up.
@@mcrotty I have deleted my comment after discovering new DNA studies on the subject. These do show it is likely some Ashkenazim may be the descendants in the male line of converts within the Khazar Empire but only about 10-15%. It seems the history of Ashkenazim is much more complex than some people have thought (including myself), I am happy to be enlightened on the subject!
www.nature.com/articles/5201319
www.nature.com/articles/ncomms3543
Most of the people asked seem unwilling to admit the blindly obvious. Of course jews intermarried. It's been proven genetically as well. Maternal DNA of ashkenazi jew is 80% European. Paternal DNA was overwhelming middle eastern. So the jewish men mated with gentiles who probably converted. Welcome to the human race!
Basic courses of evolution, genetics, anthropology should become mandatory.
Some of these people probably didn't go to enough Biology classes at highschool
@@talknight2 they get more Zionist religious propaganda to justify claiming the land from the natives
@@chakir348 Keep your racist bullcrap to yourself please
@@chakir348 the Natives? You mean the Roman Christians? Because that's who the Arab Muslims stole the land from.
@@MrJoebrooklyn1969 shut the f up with your lies and propaganda the arabs didn't expile the native population they ruled over them like in every other country in the eria thats why the Levant countries today genetically so different from the gold country and the same with north Africa the Palestinians Christians and muslims and samaritans .. share the same dna with different religions and they are a result of thousands years of human existence in the region like every other levant country gentic facts dont lie the jews in Israel share religion only nothing more a bunch of different people from different countries and different cultures a Yemeni jew looks like a Yemeni arab and share the same DNA with him a morocco jew look like a Moroccan a Russian jew look lika Russian an Ethiopian jew look like an Ethiopian they look different and genetically they are so different , and even that stupid irrationally excuse of claiming a land after 3000 years is so dumb no one uses that crazy fanatic mumbo jambo in the 21 century to justify stealing land ethnic cleansing creating an apertheid state and committing war crimes . So shut the f up you probably crie like bi...t when they told you wear masks , and you came here telling a indigenous population to gave their land and homes to a bunch of eastern European settler colonialists because in their fairytales book god gave it to them .
First of all, the indigenous people of the Levant (Jews, Samaritans, Lebanese and Arameans) have different skin shades since ancient times which is a result of much more ancient admixture between North African, Anatolian, Caucasian and Mesopotamian people in the Levant.
Secondly, the vast majority of genetic studies have already shown that most Jews (Ashkenazim, Italqim, Sefaradim and Mizrahim) largely share the same male ancestry which is traced back to the Levant. It's only in terms of female ancestry that one finds a higher level of diversity due to admixture with non-Jewish women outside Israel, particularly in the case of Ashkenazim, who are mainly descendants of Italqim (whose community was mainly formed by Jewish men and Italian female converts) and to a lower extent, Sefaradim.
This is the main reason why it's much more frequent to find Ashkenazim with lighter skin and blue eyes and red or blond hair. Notwithstanding, there are also plently of Ashkenazim who have a clear Levantine physical look. You just don't see them as often on TV. They don't meet the European-look requirement.
They're no different from other non-Jewish people of mixed Levantine and European origins such as fashion models Gigi Hadid and Bella Hadid or CNN report Hala Gorani.
But one just needs to look at anti-Israel activists such as Ahed Tamimi or the famous Northern Israelite singer Sofi Tsedaka to see how some of the ancient Levantine people already had light skin and red hair and blue eyes.
It was the massive admixture between Levantine people with North Africans and Arabians that changed the way most people in the Levant look like.
In other words, Levantine people always had since ancient times mixed looks.
For your information I actually believe that the the majority of people who self identify as Palestinians today are in fact largely indigenous to the land of Israel but that's only because most of them descend from Jews and other Israelites (Samaritans) who were gradually converted to Christianism and Islam and became Arabized.
I know this well because that was the case with two sides of my family that still live in Jersualem and near Hebron.
What makes both factions in this conflict distinct from each other is the fact one side became mixed with other people outside Israel (in some areas more than others) but still preserved its tribal identity as Jewish/Israelite, whereas the other faction became mixed with Arabians and other who settled in Israel during the last 2000 years but stopped identifying itself as Jewish/Israelite as they were converted to Islam and Arabized.
Now its time to reconcile both factions and make them realize their common Jewish/Israelite origin despite their admixture with other people in order to live side by side in peace and unity under a secular and democratic one state solution.
We've already shed too much innocent blood in this conflict. We owe it to ourselves and to our children a better future.
Shalom / Shlam / Salam
Actually if you look at the research paper "Genome-Wide Diversity in the Levant Reveals Recent Structuring by Culture" by Haber et al., you see graphs (Figure 2) showing where human groups from a large number of SNP studies lie in relation to other groups and the geography of the middle east. What was found is that there aren't clear divisions between the groups in the Levant, with the exception of a small part of the Ashkenazim where some were closer genetically to groups from the caucus (due to the reasons you mentioned above about some maternal lines) but, there is a clear distinction between groups from the Arabian peninsula and other's from the Levant (includes Palestinians, Sephardim, Ashkenazim, Cypriots Lebanese, Jordanians, Syrians, etc).
Other than this genetic research we also have to understand that terms like "Arab" and "Jew" are not monolithic. I've noticed a lot in these discussion boards (which are very cancerous for some reasons, I don't think people here understand Cory's message of creating these videos ) that some Arabs believe all Israeli Jews are magically all from Europe without any ancestral connection to the land. which is nonsense; and I have also noticed lots of Jews who think that Arabs (they don't distinguish between Palestinians from the generic term "Arab" for some reason ?) are all magically from the desert or from Yemen , which we also know that is ridiculous, since the term "Arab" is not inherently an ethnic term, it's cultural and linguistic (after all Arabs in the north call themselves "Arabized" unlike the Arabs from Yemen and the peninsula).
The bottom line is this game of making a genetic argument is ridiculous on both sides since everyone is "mixed" (depends how you define one ethnicity vs another, after all ethnicity is a social construct and not inherently based in genetics), We should understand how ridiculous these claims are and forget about racist ideology like racial purity (whatever that's supposed to mean ?) and just live democratically as one.
And just to save people the trouble who will say that Arabs would never live with Jews and vice versa. This view aims to be a self fulfilling prophecy, rather than actually being an observation of some kind of intrinsic fact of reality; if humans live side by side and are a part of an interactive community we know that they will view each other as brothers and sisters. We often look at the bad in the world and cite atrocities between certain communities and call that "the reality", but we also ignore cases when people treat one another as if they are a part of larger community even if he have different backgrounds and ideology (political or religious ), why don't people cover this "reality" as well??
Focusing on the negative, and citing it to show that nothing positive can happen will just make the world as negative as pessimists make it out to be, we should take hold of our future and spread positivity to combat the negativity.
Peace
@@Omar-hm2gp That's a good point. Well said
@@g.3304 Its ironic how all the information and details you provided are about the Jews and not the Palestinians and then you claim that very few Palestinians have a connection to Palestine. You are very biased.
@@g.3304 no one cares about the history of the name(which we know what it means) except for the Jews who came from Europe.
Nationality doesnt matter if there was a population living there regardless of their identity, the land is theirs and, we were reffered to as Palestinians pre-1900 and by the way, if we Arabs didnt "betray" the Ottomans, you wouldn't have gotten your "Israel" on a plate of gold by the British Empire.
You are claiming that not all Arab who came to Palestine are indigenous and I would say yes however the majority are indiginous.
We Palestinians are more open minded than our occupier, we cared about other Arabs regardless of their religion which contradicts your claim and we accepted immigrants.
Just look at the US, anyone who immigrated there became a citizen and so did other Arabs who immigrated and became Palestinian.
Atleast, Arabs were local to the region while the Ashkenazis came from Europe which is very far away from the middle east itself. When the Ashkenazis came to Palestine, there were no DNA tests and there was no way to prove that the Ashkenazis had a connection to the land 3000 years ago so they had to occupy the land by force instead of integrating with the locals.
The Jews also ignore the fact that there were also different Kingdoms and people living in Palestine/Israel before and after the Kingdom of Israel but the Jews are the only ones who are claiming and stealing land today because of a historical and archaeological claim.
The kind of rule you are talking about which you are calling "dimmi" rule is a thing of the past and not a single muslim country uses it. Christians and Jews had the same rights as Palestinians in Palestine and sharia law is much complicated than the simple concept which you have in your mind.
Sharia law is different between each and every Muslim country.
Sharia law is a set of rules based on Islamic teachings from the Quran and Prophet Muhammad's words but each country can adopt a different set of rules and modify them to fit the modern society but, in the west and Israel, you people are only taught that Sharia law is taboo when you don't even understand what it is.
You are lucky that Palestinians today are agreeing to a two-state solution which was seen as impossible in the past but now Israel is the greedy one breaking international law and building illegal settlements on Palestinian land.
Their brain are confused! They think they belong to the Land Israel, but they don't think they come from Sons of Israel! 😂😂😂😂😂
they're confusing religion with enthnicity lol. Prob cuz of the fucktards that keep saying "jeW IS An EThNO-rELIgoUS grOUP!"
juadisim is 3k years old. the ppl that praciticed it came from all over the world
ethnic jews became an ethnicity around 700 years ago due to the discrimination they faced in europe due to their religion.
ethnicity is not a religoin and you cant have both.
All this israli historical claims are from theology, you cant use religion to try to predate another ethnic group.
This guy just asks stupid questions to stupid people in intention to make all Israelis and jews look bad and the same, as someone who lives in Israel I can confirm 99% of the people are not like that.
@@itaysd3721 I have to agree that the questions are very problematic .
@@sashagamino2268 thats the point. To provoke thought & dialogue.
Anyways, those are not his Questions.
These Questions come from Americans and other non-jews. He's just asking the questions.
@@limbbar1381 it is an ethnoreligion and despite that all Jewish groups share at least some genetic component which points to a shared root. What you people are basically saying is that indigenous status has a time limit
"Do you think you are connected to the Children of Israel by blood?"
"Yes" Because if I say no, it would delegitimize our whole occupation of Palestine.
lol
Yup
God look at the answers 😂😂 it's hilarious 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 and after this they come to our land and say we used to live here 2000 years ago
Because they did.. And that's like1% of the whole story, I'm not gonna waste my time writing to you the entire deal but I'm just gonna tell you to do some research 👍🏻
@@itaysd3721 Why does it matter what happened 2000 years ago? Until 100 years ago, for hundreds if not over a thousand years, maybe 10% of the population living in the area was jewish. The rest were muslim or something else. These kinds of arguments are pointless. At the end of the day, there is no real moral justification for anything and the sooner everyone realizes that the sooner a compromise will be reached
@@itaysd3721
Historical facts:
1- the palestinians are descendants of Canaanites (who came to palestine from the arabian peninsula) over 3200 years before JC.(so they have been there for 5200 years )
2- the jews claim they are the descendant of Abraham pbuh . And its a well known fact that Abraham peace be upon him came from iraq(BABYLON) to palestine 1950 year before JC.
So who was there first?
3-the jews were present in that land for 418 yrs only. From the moment the entered it with prophet Joshua pbuh after claiming it from the Canaanites who were there centuries before them. To the moment the babylonians dessimated them.
418 yrs only from 7000 years of history.
4- what will happen if every nation decided to claim back the land that belonged to her in the past. What if the Turks(ottoman empire) decided to claim back the parts of eastern europe that belonged to them in the past centuries? Eh?
5- Lastly, most of the jews colonizing palestine have nothing to do with abraham pbuh or with his descendance. Or with Moises pbuh. Especially the Achkenazim. Their ancestors (kazarian kingdom) converted to Judaism in 9th century. So really they have NOTHING to do with that holy land.
I think YOU should do some research
@@ghofranesalhi7386 where’s your proof that Ashkenazi Jews come from Khazars when they’ve been living in Europe before the Khazars?
That is because in school the teach Bible and not jewish hestory and Antil the crusaders 2-3 largest community of jews was in Isreal and then most were exiled or kild after the crusders there were 200 jews in Isreal
Such a ridiculous question, I'm a mix of Mizrahi, Ashkenazi, and Sefaradi. Within my own family there is a mix of skin tones, but the mix isn't what you would think -- white/fair on the Ashkenazi side, brown,/dark on the Sephardic/Mizrahi side. Both sides come in a range of complexions. My father was red-haired/ginger and he was Syrian-Sephardic (partly descended from Spanish Jews who had been in the Land of Israel for centuries, partly Syrian Oriental Jews with some Spanish Jews, with touch of Moroccan (and Sephardic-Spanish on the Moroccan side too). But he had darker-skinned brothers, sisters, cousins and aunts and uncles. My mother is Hungarian (Ashkenazic) and she is dark (as a young woman and an old woman) but she also had a range of skin tones in her own family. And this is very common, the idea that European/Ashkenazic Jews = white and pale and fair and Middle East/North Afriican (Mizrahim, Sefaradim) always equals dark and brown and olive-colored Jews is not correct.
And of course among Arabs one also finds a wide range of skin tones and complexions, including among Palestinian Arabs.
That proves that you Jews are not the sons of Israel. Many claim the land because is yours by blood... Your ancestors... The jews are the most racist demographic. Not every Jew of course, but many are sectarian, many think that their blood is the "original" blood, 100% jew, and thats why they claim the land of Palestine. It's beautiful to see different races united by a religion, but many Jews dont accept it because they understand Judaism as a closed sect... And thats sad. And that explains what they had to create a country called "the Jew country". They could live in Palestine freely as jews...
Exactly, people moved everywhere since the beginning, Roman Empire, crusades, Spanish inquisition....etc
@@MrZxcvbnm22 You sir, don't understand anything about Jewish culture...It doesn't matter that Jews are not 100% genetically the same as their ancestors. Nobody is, and the only people that claim it are fascists or ignorant or both. If you want to now why the Jewish state was created I advise you to read "The Jewish State" by Theodor Herzl. Spoiler : it was not racially nor religiously based.
@@MrZxcvbnm22 where did you find the Jewish claim by blood?
The Jewish claim is historic with archeology proving Jewish heritage in this land.
The only claim Arabs aka Palestinians have a claim to Jerusalem is through the myth of Mohammed's night ride on a winged horse with a human face to Jerusalem to a mosque which was not even built until 80 years after Mohammed died
The closest Palestinians ever came to Jerusalem was through the illegal Jordanian occupation in 1948 to 1967.
The closest Palestinians ever came to JUDEA and SAMARIA was through the illegal Jordanian occupation of the West bank in 1948 to 1967.
Arabs aka Palestinians have no ancient historical claim to Israel.
There never existed a Palestine ever in recorded history when it was ruled, governed or even occupied by Palestinians for Palestinians.
Arafat the Egyptian boasted that he had invented the Palestinians in 1964 as a political pawn against Israel.
The Palestinian flag was created on 28th May 1964, reinforcing the fact that Palestinians were invented by Arafat in 1964.
@efopo yes, and everything else is fake....
Myths, Hypotheses and Facts - imninalu.net
www.imninalu.net/myths-pals.htm
That the massive increase in Arab population was very recent is attested by the ruling of the United Nations: That any Arab who had lived in the Holy Land for two years and then left in 1948 qualifies as a "Palestinian refugee". II - Myths and facts about Jerusalem and Temple Mount
Most genetic research nowadays is consistent with the idea that male Jewish lines were preserved but that most of the Jewish diaspora had periods where there was a lot of mixing on the maternal side (ie, local women converting to Judaism and marrying Jewish males). This is why the Jews from different parts of the world each have their own "flavor" but still share significant ancestry and cluster near each other in most PCA comparisons.
Some bred with every race on the planet while others kept to their own
All my respect for the first one who answer "All humans are related we came from one mother Eve "
thats just stupid cause eve had more to offer the mother of all genes bu thing stoped after so black stayed black white stayd white
They left as brown people and came back as white people.
@xi jinping how come israel has the highest skin cancer rate in the world?
Even the sun is telling them that they dont belong there.
Jews are an ethnic group originating in the Levant,but the Jews were scattered to diffirent parts of the world that's why they have different skin tones,all Jews look mostly the same,why have i seen Ashkenazi Jews that look like Arabs? Especially like Palestinians Syrians Lebanese? You can find dark and light in all Jewish groups.
They're convert Jews. Not true Israelites. If you claim to have the same mother, then u should stay authentic like Africans, or like Arabs, or like Asians..but you're not .
@@الراسخونفيالعلم-ل4ط its you jiihadis who converted jews and christians
@Alden Buyer Lies. Look up Palestine Australia football game on youtube all jews
'you think you'd turn black in canada?' Love these people :') 3:08
Apparently black canadians don't exist.
Most Ashkenazi have high amount of Slavic-Caucasian, Ugric, Turkic and Germanic ancestry. Phenotypically, they don't look like indigenous, Semitic people.
@@g.3304 That's anecdotal evidence. I looked her up (did not know her - I'm not a celebrity fanboy) and her Wikipedia states that only one of her grandparents was of German-Jewish ancestry. Her other grandparents came from Austria, -Hungary- Poland and Czech Republic. She does not look predominantly Middle Eastern, but more like a very good looking East European with some Central / Northern European admixture. She reminds me of a very lovely girl who once was my classmate. She is very "easy on the eyes" I will have to admit.
Ashkenazi jews are a mix mixture of Levantine men from the time of the Roman empire and Southern Italian women who converted to Judaism.
Researchers estimate it takes 10,000 years with no intermarriage for skin color to completely change, add just a little bit of intermarriage, and converts throughout the thousands of years and it's no surprise at all that after thousands of years they have different skin colors.
estimates means nothing. just a wish...
@@non9886 Its more accurate than claiming bs based on no evidence.
Bro, stop watching this stupid channel, it makes average people answer stupid questions about things they aren't interested in, stop believing that xrap
10,000 years for skin color to change to what? From lily white to jet black? From lily white to brown? What about hair and eyes? Jews have only been in diaspora for 2000 years. So even by your "estimates " you're not even close.
What research
If you live in Antartica would you turn into a penguin?
Hahahhaa. Good one!
If you stay more then two winters
The people who came out of Egypt in the Exodus were a "mixed multitude", not all who entered into the covenant at Mt Sinai came from Jacob's children. Likewise, the Tanach speaks of slaves and converts from other nations, Babylonian exile, etc.
It should be remembered that the Jews were scattered across Arabia, Northern and Southern Africa, Europe and Asia for centuries after the BabylonIan captivity and the Destruction of Masada. Some migrated to areas in search of better economic opportunities. They often intermarried with the people from the areas they lived in, while keeping their religion. Zionism and the right to return to their original homeland united them as a people together with their faith, although they looked different from one another?
Cory, most people don't understand your questions correctly. You should sit with a Hebrew/Arabic speaker and consult about the wording before going out.
And thank you for these interesting videos.
EXCELLENT Point!!
Corey's Hebrew has gotten much better! But you are correct--he should prepare the questions and check the exact meaning of what he is going to say prior to going out to interview.
Because of various mixtures, crossings, meltings, meetings, coercings, courtings, courtships, mashings, and scramblings
So according to some of them, if I give birth to a child in Sweden, my child will have blond hair and blue eyes, while I have olive skin, brown eyes and hair? What about African Americans for example, why did not they turn into whites over the years, they and their ancestors have been reproducing in north America? And why whites in north America does not look Amerindians yet.
A lot of sex can happen in 2000 years.
I saw more than once in the comment sections of Corey's videos Arabs saying "... and Palestinians on the other hand all look similar because they are an ethnically indigenous people".
What?! Every goddamn video where Corey interviews Israeli or Palestinian Arabs, some of them look like very tan South Arabians, some of them look like black people from Africa, some of them are pretty white and then some of them are very white like Europeans and even with light hair and eyes. How is that any different than modern Jews who are obviously (I'm not denying the obvious in contrast to some other people) racially mixed at least to an extent BUT in enough studies were indeed shown to still have (excluding a few modern Jewish communities such as Ethiopians) genes coming from the Levant area? That includes white Ashkenazi Jews from Europe.
You should actually ask they same question to the Arab Palestinians: if you are all related and claim to be an actual real ethnicity indigenous to the land, why are you all different colours?
Because we don’t claim we are genetically related we are Arabs by language not blood line ...Jews claim that they are the choosing people they have to be Genetically related
@@salahali9793 That's not what was claimed by some people. If I remember correctly it was about looks supposedly being similar amongst Palestinians (in contrast to Israeli Jews) because the Palestinians are an actual ethnicity with shared genealogical roots.
So that's obviously bullshit, and if the claim is "we are related by language" you can also say that about all Israelis who speak Hebrew nowadays. Obviously some of the past immigrants to Palestine came from places where they hadn't necessarily spoken Arabic.
And if we're being accurate Hebrew was actually studied and used liturgically and sometimes secularly amongst many different Jewish communities in the diaspora way before modern Israel was even an idea, because it had always been the notion that the Jews are the descendents of the Israelites and thus that Hebrew is their original language.
Iran is the same thing I mean people in Northern Iran look Russian and then people in central Iran look Brown like the typical Arab and then Southern Iran people are very dark like pakistanis
All Jews ,no matter what their color or place of birth, have a right to return to their ancestral homeland in Israel.
I cannot say it ever struck me that people in Northern Iran look the slightest bit like Russians.
Linda Steckel my question is this. if less than 10% of your ancestry is Semitic...than why is your right to return to THAT land, and not the land that corresponds with the MAJORITY of your ancestry. in other words, why does a minor part of your genetic ancestry overdetermine the rest?
@@Linda43 yet the Palestinians who were born there and have been expelled and still being displaced are denied the right of return. Seems fair.
For instance, Ahed Tamimi comes from Tamimi clan, a traditional palestinian group of people, a family. Her hair is between blond and red, her skin is so pale and her eyes are not brown but green or blue or something in between, she looks like an irish girl or even she can be confused and seen as an ashkenazi girl. It's ironic how the existance of this advocate of palestinian cause is a living proof that when people say that ashkenazim are not real jews it is pure racism and it should be hated as such, the same people questioning the Israelite background of ahkenazim is the people that says Ahed Tamimi is a real ethnic palestinian. Jewish people have had a very strong endogamy for centuries and they are all related with genes and culture even when if they mixed a bit with non jews who became jews by marriage. They just went back to their historical home after centuries of european pogroms.
They are bosnian immigrants from the othman imperial occupation times. Boshnaks.
the whole terrorist state of israel fears a young lady like Ahed Tamimi. she is an avenging angel who stands up to the murderers who invaded the Palestinian Homeland.
Uatahá Ch'ixi Mitã ahed if from Arabian tribe (tamimi) this tribe origin from Arabian peninsula the people of this tribe are all over Arab countries saudiarabia Kuwait Iraq Palestine Jordan ..
Ahed Tamimi is an illegitimate child, her father is an Israeli Ashkenazi soldier
Look at her brothers and her father they are brown!!!!
Israeli Arab she is not askinazi
Her tribe is arabian tribe from arabia not from europ
Although I'm an Atheist Swede, I'm a huge fan of the Jewish people. They are so tolerant and embracing of cultural/ethnic/sexual differences and seem to understand we are all equal and are all brothers unlike Christians who are always causing trouble and preaching hate. Travelling to Israel in particular Tel Aviv is definitely on my bucket list as I know it is an LGBT-friendly destination. Being married to a transgender woman makes me weary of going to certain countries but I know we will be safe there.
Gustav Einarsson You are welcome to post on my channel anytime. What do you think of the Islamization of your country?
Or Israel's ethnostate policy.
I wouldn’t be so naive. Look at how Israel ethinically cleansed Palestinians.
Zionism is an extremist ideology that isn’t good for anyone other than Zionists.
Mostly everything oppressive from Christianity and Islam has origins in Judaism.
A lot of Jews automatically don’t like Northern Europeans because of nazis.
Don’t be so naive
11:10 I'm living now more than 20 years in Dänemark and still waiting to become White and blond! Maybe it's could happen once.
You hang on to that dream friend. 😂
They say that just to keep the land.
The best answer is we are all that is left of Jewish ppl. Don’t forget we had twelve tribes and now we are small. All off Jewish ppl from all over are one ppl. That is why in the prophets books we are being called to come back. Did some mix? Maybe, were some raped?? Maybe, were some converts?? Maybe. Most importantly is that we are back. Baruch HaShem.
Jews may come from a common genetic stock but have intermingled (intermarried) with other ethnic groups over the centuries, this is definite, not subject to opinion. This explains the different appearances of Jews from different places. Jewish men frequently took wives from the non-Jewish population around them and their children were raised as Jews. Also over the centuries there has been conversion of non-Jews into the Jewish people. This infusion of non-Jewish genes into the Jewish people is a very well known and well documented fact.
Few people converted to Judaism. Usually only after marrying into a Jewish family. It was more common for Jews to convert to other faiths.
2:30 She could very likely be an iranian Jew.
@@mesopotamiankurdishgirl6539 her eyes!! You have to check the eyes. Some iranians have bigger eyes
@@mesopotamiankurdishgirl6539 how do you describe iranian ? Some look pretty white sometimes don't they ?
She kind of looks like a gypsy from east Europe
@@mesopotamiankurdishgirl6539 She's too dark to be likely to be Spanish or Italian.
As a Muslim I think that every human that has ever lived is related to each other as we are all the sons/daughters of Adam
No. Israelites are the only only ones decendent from adam and Eve. The rest of the ethnicities were created on the 6th day, 2000 years before adam
@@J3MOdh3NOWX3S oh no okey
@@J3MOdh3NOWX3Sare you crazy or drunk
Arabs in Israel are also white, olive, brown and black. Originally Sudanese, Syrian, Egyptian, Bedouin, Lebanese and Iraqi arabs came in different waves and settled in different towns all over the country.
Ya there is this myth that a lot of Arabs believe, that all Israeli Jews came from Europe, which is not true. And there is this myth that people , like yourself believe, that all the Palestinians are just immigrants who went over to good old Israel from every single country in the middle east (with the exception of Palestine/Israel of course because THERE WAS NEVER ANY ARABS THERE) due to the FANTASTIC job opportunities that the European Jews brought in , in the 1880's. The sad truth is that Modern day Israeli historians like Benny Morris and Ilan Pappe call this narrative pure bs;
it assumes that Palestine/Israel was just a sparsely populated land with basically no one living in it till the good old Jewish immigrants came back........ seriously ........ we're talking about the "middle east" here, where arid conditions are very very common, and you expect me to believe that one of the few places with arable land was simply ignored by the people there for thousands/hundreds of years till Jews started immigrating to Palestine/Israel lol,.........gimme a break here. I don't know what world you're living in but people always go to fertile land, and my grandfather's entire family for generations were simply shepherds living in Tel Lachish and grew wheat to harvest, like everyone in their former village (now destroyed and is a grazing ground for cattle in Israel) none of them came because of any immigrants bringing jobs lol, last I checked that happend to a very little extent in port cities like Haifa and Tel Aviv, where people from Egypt moved to work in the ports, again in very very very small quantities, (if you have ever been to Jordan you realize the majority of the labor in restaurants, parks, etc. there is Egyptian, but no one claims that Jordanians are actually Egyptian , its nonsense).
The biggest point here is that I hear your claim everywhere ... but where is the census records, the registries, where is any historical evidence that the majority of Palestinians are foreigners and that Palestine/Israel was empty for hundreds of years. The majority of world historians and Israeli historians claim other wise my friend.
@@Omar-hm2gp
I don't believe a myth. I ask Arabs in Israel where is their family from and they tell me. Last names hint as well. So many masri, halabi, mugrabi,faiumi, iraqi.. very common names, can tell me more than records. A lot of Egyptians came as a result of the conditions of the horrible forced labour of digging the Suez canal. And many others when the British government and Jewish population developed the land.
@@jonathanrotem251 Hi Johnathan,
I’ll try to avoid meaningless polemics here, but you never answered any of the points I postulated.... like at all.
The MAJORITY of historians have claimed that what you said has no shred of historical evidence. Mentioning bad labor conditions while building the Suez in Egypt (hell it reiterated what I mentioned before in my comment about a small amount of workers coming in to work in the port cities!) , does your argument absolutely no favors, how does that prove the majority of Palestinians are foreigners , lol?
And regarding the naming, some of these names you mentioned span geographies and aren’t tied to any one place, let's say I entertain your story (that Palestinians with "common last names" (any statistics on how common??)told you that they aren't from Palestine/Israel) how does that contradict any of the claims that I postulated? and how does it prove your point in any way? You expect people to believe that the majority of Israeli historians just lied to us? and for what reason? It seems to me you just hear what you want to hear lol.
And again this brings me to reiterate my point, provide primary sources to verify your claims, hell even reliable secondary sources? After all you say it's these Arabs who told you about their origins (again not sure how you can generalize random conversations to encompass all Palestinians and claiming the majority are foreign?), so if I am not you and can't know that for my self why should I believe anything you say if there isn't shred of physical evidence you're providing?, after all that's how one supports a claim, bringing up anecdotes does you no favors especially if your audience isn't you, lol.
This isn’t a game of who’s right it’s all about information and educating ourselves, how does believing an inherently bigoted myth do anyone any favors? Reading your comment directly mirrors other posts I read here where you see ignorant comments claiming that Ashkenazim are actually descended from central Asian Khazars, yet they clearly provide no proof whatsoever and WE KNOW for a fact that that’s not true, as I mentioned before in other posts look up Haber et al paper on PLoS One about genetic markers of people in the Levantine (look at Figure 2). Both of your comments make outrageous claims and of course neither provide any shred of evidence! Tell me why would the majority of historians disagree with you? Do you expect people to believe that everyone got it wrong and Jonathan Rotem is the one who got it right?
Focus on learning my friend, spreading misinformation does everyone a disservice , especially to your self. After-all if Palestinians aren’t all foreigners like you want to believe, how does that effect you in anyway? It doesn’t mean that Jews have no right to live in Israel/Palestine whatsoever, so there is really no point for you to believe this nonsense to even serve meaningless ideological debates.
Peace
@@Omar-hm2gp
I don't understand what you found problematic in my answer. All I said was that I BELIEVE arabs when I ask them where are they from. Many of them KNOW 200-300 years of history of their hamulah, I have no problem with them.
No Arabs don't have different colours Arab!
-
The black people are African .
and the white people that have pink pig skin are European origin or Armenian or mixed.
-
The Indian look people are Indian and Pakistani origin people there are maaaaaany in the gulf countries!
Those are not Arabs by blood they don't belong to the middle East in general! They just live in Arab countries since hundred years ago they born speak Arabic go to school with Arabs have Arab country citizenship they born and they know nothing about their ancestors land and they call themselves Arabs! They dressed like Arabs even have arab traditions! But again their blood, DNA, look, is not Arabic!
so Arabs don't have different colours!
The Arabic speakers have different origins and of course different colours!
Color doesn't matter at all.
There are light and brown ethiopians (warm country), and light and brown ashkenazy (cold countries) jews.
The common denominator is that we are ALL Jews, all colors, temperaments. We mix our Jewish history and different cultures into our one Jewish pot.
you're all devious, greedy and cold blooded killers.
@@pusanghalaw You are just a troll.
The hottest weather in world is in iraq and kwait and then uae and ksa , bahren .
Yes many of us have dark skin but the ethiopian jews are darker than darker one of us .
The weather in ethiopia is cooler than our weather .
Nah they are just mixed with other races and DNA tests proof that 😉don't change the fact they still jews and believe in the Torah but they absolutely mixed!
can we discuss a minute about the woman on 2:31 who takes a drag from an unlit cigarette?
Very real question I have been asking myself a long time.
Does it simply mean Judaism is a religion like the others ?
Using a religion to get rights on that country is strange!
Judaism is supposed not to be prosylitic and it is transmitted through the mother. So how was it propagated?
We indeed are genetically similar. But only to an extent. Let's say, I'm Argentinian, I'm probably more genetically related to an average Israeli than to my neighbor. However, most of us have ""goi"" genetic markers (again, it's not exactly like this), because naturally jews mixed sometimes with locals through history. So, in the end, we are a very broad ethnoreligious group. That being said, we should treat EVERYONE as equal. :)
A Jew is a person whose religion is JUDAISM.
The Jews returned to the land not because of religion but because of their history.
The first refugees were not religious - they came from Europe from the death camps to build a country which historically belongs to the Jews.
Middle East history for dummies
by Shmuel Katz
(Jerusalem Post article)
The alternative may simply be a continuation of terror against Israel from behind the protective wall of the sovereignty of a Palestinian state.THE ARABS have made it clear that the state they are now demanding represents the penultimate phase so often referred to by Arafat in the struggle for Israel's destruction.
It's a state they could have had in 1947, under the UN Partition plan. They could surely have had a state when Israel offered to give back Judea, Samaria and the Gaza Strip in return for peace after the Six Day War. Their contemptuous rejection of the offer was an open declaration that peace with Israel was not their objective.
The propaganda against Israel in the Arab world, indeed within the Muslim world, has since that time become more strident and more specific. In the mosques, on the streets and in the schoolrooms they do not call for a state on the "West Bank," they call for a Palestinian State "from the [Jordan] river to the [Mediterranean] sea." Why do they prefer to fight and kill (and die) in order to gain sovereign possession of this sliver of Jewish territory?The answer seems to be that they cannot tolerate the idea that the Jews who lived in Muslim lands as third-class citizens are now treated as equals in human society. That is why the Arabs, when they have been defeated in war by Israel, insist that it is England or America that fought the war for them.
If the present policy of pressure on Israel while the Arabs are cheering is pressed to the end, the Bush vision will prove empty and the road map a lie. And there will still be no peace.
@Alden Buyer The typical convert is someone who marries a Jew and converts for that purpose. Conversion to Judaism is quite a laborious and committed undertaking, it's not something you can get through in a couple hours like in Christianity or Islam.
@Alden Buyer
Does it mean all the Jewishs in World must leave their current country and gather to Israël?
Are you aware of the patriotism suspicion when we leave a country and consider another foreign as our real one?
@Alden Buyer
Big difference: Irish is born in Ireland and has Irish parents. Irish can also be Jewish and his country is Ireland!
When an Irish decides to stay in a new country, he asks for permission from the local citizens.
If you were born in hot places your melanin is effected in different ways. After the 2nd Temple we scattered.. Over 1000's of yrs our skin change whats important is Jewish first skin color does not matter
Yeah I agree. obviously u talking bs
That's incorrect. Skin color takes longer to evolve than modern humans have been alive. 'Whites' have light skin tone because they mixed with neanderthals who had pale skin. Pale skin reflects UV light and creates vitamin D faster than any other skin giving them a genetic cheat sheet for surviving in extreme environments both extremely hot and extremely cold.
Ashkenazi Jews are pale skinned because they emerged from an intentional breeding program that is of under 300 people sent to both 'Romes' of the time, western Europe (what is now central Germany) and Spain with the purpose of blending in with the locals - and now thanks to modern genetic studies this interesting part of history is now very well documented and studied. It's super interesting stuff and I encourage anyone to research it regardless of their ancestry.
23 & Me had some fantastic findings on the Khazar link but they were removed due to a backlash as it tied into a 'khazar origin conspiracy theory' but are available on archive sites. The DNA results were super interesting. But the general purpose of the breeding program was to mask that they were Jewish and set them up as foreign agents acting for Jewish interests in countries that would otherwise be hostile to them after the money shaving incidents that got them expelled from Britain only decades earlier.
Melanin genes don't change that fast. Melanin is very important for all kinds of things other than skin color. Having kids with someone else is the fastest way to get lighter genes into a group.
@@bashkillszombies I have no idea about the 23&Me thing, but you're right about the adaptation part. You don't just go white or brown in such a short period of time. It takes way longer than that. If these guys are different looking it's because they don't share a lot of genetics in common. However, there has been research that there is a genetic tie between the Ashkenazim and the Sepharadim. It's far back, but it's nevertheless there.
Nonsense.
The mythos of the nation-state is deeply rooted in the minds of people, having taken over our collective mentality with its fairy-tale appeal. It takes a lot, A LOT of effort to rid humanity of it, so we can finally move forward with logic and our best self-interest in mind.
Amit....the first guy...excellent answer...i agree totally...im muslim from Malaysia
Is it so difficult to admit that the ancestors mixed with Europeans, Africans, Arabs?
2:35 is she smoking an unlighted cigarette? Lol
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lmaoo
I feel bad for Corey having to ask these dumb questions.
U can send him a Q if u want.
I also think that the questions are irrelevant.
Why are there blond and blue eyed Arabs and Jews? Intermarriage and integration.
My family are a mix of Kurdish, Moroccan, Ashkenazi...dark hair, blond hair, dark eyes and skin, blue eyes and fair skin.
We are one family.
I feel bad that almost 90 percent of those people dont know the right answer
@ericj305 are you talking about the so called Right of Return of the 1964 Palestinians?
Avi: lol
Can you ask Palestinian christians how they think the palestinian authority of the west bank is treating them, like in bethlehem if it's possible to get there.
Of course they support me
@Starhopper
If Palestinian Christians in the West Bank and Gaza are being persecuted then why doesn't Israel provide them protection? Well, at the least the ones who live in the West Bank since the West Bank is still under the control of the IDF?
If Palestinian Christians from the West Bank and Gaza apply for asylum, will Israel accept their asylum requests? After all, Palestinian Christians do not have to prove they are persecuted since this fact is clear as the Sun.
Don't have jew more pure in this world than a Christian From Galilee.. Abu bakar
in the past judaism was more popular.it took more time for christianity to be powerful for example.so it makes sense that people from other countries converted to judaism to marry someone jewish.in families who pretty much didn't mix at all they have the same color.you can see people in ashkenazi families who are suddenly born dark even though a few generations are all white,which means the color is a recesive gene.but you can see there are features which are very similar to all jewish people.
Hey Cory, IDK what your deal is, but when you ask Israelis, you rarely include Ethiopian Jews, even though I see them walking around in the background. Not sure why, but I want you to know that treating them differently is part of the problem. You only include them when you have special videos regarding their community. IDK not accusing you of anything, I'm not sure if you even realize you're doing it, but it comes off as kind of shady.
He has done whole videos about Ethiopian Israelis.
@@Theouterrim77 I know, but I said include them in videos where people ask Israelis in general, I see them walking around in the background and he never says anything to them, unless he's doing a video on them specifically. It's weird , and makes it look like he doesn't value their opinions. Hopefully that's not the case
@@tvtalkwithavi There are not that many Ethiopian Israelis, with 130,000. There are less opportunities to catch them. I am willing to bet Corey doesnt do it on purpose.
@@Theouterrim77 they walk in the background dude...
@@itaysd3721 Corey has done whole videos on Ethiopians. This is BS
Stupid question.
Arabs are colored as well.
No real Arabs are from Saudi Arabia emirate and Qatar and they all have the same color
@@SimonKanner-si3it Yes Arabs do have white skin rich Arabs who don't have to work or walk under the sun don't have a tan
@@svlo3245 lol where did you get that info from? There is no such thing as a "real Arab" it's a term that covers a linguistic and cultural group, not some weird ethnic racial term. Basically what I'm saying is that Arabs are not a race or ethnicity.
Peace
No Arabs don't have different colours Arab!
-
The black people are African .
and the white people that have pink pig skin are European origin or Armenian or mixed.
-
The Indian look people are Indian and Pakistani origin people there are maaaaaany in the gulf countries!
Those are not Arabs by blood they don't belong to the middle East in general! They just live in Arab countries since hundred years ago they born speak Arabic go to school with Arabs have Arab country citizenship they born and they know nothing about their ancestors land and they call themselves Arabs! They dressed like Arabs even have arab traditions! But again their blood, DNA, look, is not Arabic!
so Arabs don't have different colours!
The Arabic speakers have different origins and of course different colours!
The question is about Jews in Israel. The question is not about Arabs (or Persians or Americans or any other country!)
This question is idiotic. I'm a fully Ashkenazi Jew with darker features and my first cousins are also fully Ashkenazi Jewish with lighter features. So family members with the exact same genes can be different colors. Genetic studies have shown that Diaspora Jews are all related with a shared ancestry from Israel plus different Diaspora admixture. The interviewer also assumes that Ashkenazi Jews are all light-skinned when there are German and Polish Jews who are darker than Iraqi and Moroccan Jews.
Intermarriage and conversion has always been a big part of Jewish experience. That's why Ashkenazim are white and Ethiopians are black. To think otherwise is sheer folly.
Can someone explain to me what reference was used to establish the Jewish DNA profile?
Was the profile established based on DNA analysis from ancient bones dug up from authenticated ancient Jewish burial sites? If yes then can someone point me to such studies?
Was the profile established based on DNA analysis from modern inhabitants of the Levant? If yes then how can Palestinians be labeled as non-indigenous when their DNA was used (or partially used) to establish the Holy Land indigenous reference?
I guess you can google most of it. But what you define as palastinians are actually recent immigrants from places as far as albania, chechnia , iraq and north africa... from the blond blue eyed boshnaks and circassians (bosnians and chechens) to the sudanese origin folks of dark complexion.... fascinating thing when you look into it.
@@dogbert52
Why do I always get the same answer "google it"? I did and I could not find an answer to my question!!!!
Seriously, why no one is able to answer my straightforward and important question?
Is there anyone out there who can answer my original question?
@@johns22 because it’s all lies and claims just to deny Palestinians their right to their land
Corey you could change your channel's name to Antisemites Ask. Lucky that Israelis are such good sports.
I once asked a very religious rabbi this question. His answer was, Jews are pure but God wants you to fit in wherever you live so he makes you look like the local population.
Lol it's funny how jews say that there parents were persecuted. As A moroccan , We never persecuted jews. Jews were forced by their own governement to leave to isreal. Btw: love your videos keep up the good work.
Look up the history of Jews in Morocco during the middle ages. History begs to differ.
Hi El Mehdi, that's not accurate, I am myself a Yemenite jew, there were a lot of pogroms against the Jewish community in Yemen in the first half of the 20 century, which escalated with the decision of the U.N on the creation the state of Israel, the Jewish community houses and business were destroyed, people were brutally killed in multiple occasions, most noticeably the Aden riots, the reality is the Jewish community was worried for their safety there, as the country didn't protect them from the riots and violence of the local population, and often the police even did take part in those, the reality is they were refuges escaping Yemen as they were worried for their families lives, and when they did arrive Israel they were living in a refuge camp for a long period, they weren't worried for their life here, but encountered 2nd class citizen treat for the first years when comparing the treat they got compared to European immigrants.
If Israeli are descended from Abraham, Ishak and Jacob, then what distinguishes them from Arabs is only their religion, not their genetics. They are not belong to that land
Ask: Ethiopian Jews, do you consider Jews such as Ashkenazim Sephardim Mirachim etc your brothers? Or Ethiopian Jews, How do you see Jews not from your group?
there is no way israelis can be dfferent colours without mixing with others
And some with blond hair and blue eyes while others in Africa don't have that .
An Ethiopian Jew does not look like a Russian Jew.
Just like an Indonesian Muslim does not look like a Nigerian Muslim.
The same apply to Christanity.
Only Jews who are trying to make a race our of religion.
To justify colonialism
I like how diverse the jewish nation is.
What does your dna have anything to do with belonging to a people or your cultural identity?
You know this destroys diversity?Such shortsightedness...
@WhiteNationalist Portugal Bison I am mixed, we all come from Africa. I borrowed that quote from an Arab.
@Ian Miles Would I be less French because my parents come from Africa?
@Anthony R ... French nationality, African racially, ethnicity. Make sense?
Your cultural experience as an African in France must be quite different from a Frenchy whose family has been French for generations even though you identify culturally as French
Because they claim that land is theirs based on DNA
Hahaha the stoned guy at 5:30
The real answer is in the *bible.*
Abraham was called "שחום עור" "tanned" since he came from Ur Cashdim (a real aciant city, today in the Iraqi-Turkish borders) his grandson, Jacob, let his sons marry Cannies in the bible, that had darker skin, Moses was dark skinned as well, but he married with "beautifull dark skinned woman" ("כושית" in Hebrew)
King David was called "אדמוני" red headed, red skinned white guy since as you probably know he came from Ruth, a convert, yet he became one of the best king to the Israelites and a true israelit and jew (from the tribe of Judeh)
my point is, if the bible itself told you how diverse were the Hebrews, even back than, then how can you look at Jews now and say "you're not related, too diverse." really?
I'm half marrocian half Iraqi jew, I'm telling you this because my mom is really white looking, she even have champion hair and green eyes, but my dad is brown naturally, with dark eyes and hair, and to tell you the truth? I don't look like my sisters! 😂 we don't look related at all(!!) my little sis is brown (more than even dad) my youngest is as white as they come and I'm the in middle. and it's not just my small family, even just my Iraqi side had people like my grandmother, that her family was always in Iraq yet she has blue amazing eyes and pale skin.
my point is, you can't assume someone isn't related because they don't look alike, Gene's are more than just your appearance, and at least in Gene's we know there have been studies showing that most Jews do share some 3 big fathers (like in the bible) and some connection, as well as originated from the Levant.
@@SimonKanner-si3it
old*
and be real. in Judaism even the Hatam sofer ordered families to teach girls just as boys since 1,600 (or 1,400? I forgot) so, there were no "old days" unless you lived 400 years ago
@Eternal Fisherman
yea, but you can really say it about every culture that ever existed.
mostly the woman weren't the ones being smart analytically but more of "emotionally smart"
Judaism also recognized this that's why bat mizvah (for girls)is earlier than bar mizvah (for guys) since, "girls are more grown up" in at least a year at that point, than guys.
though there are still amazing smart women, even in the bible, like Devura, for example, she was smarter then any man in her story 😂 and Sarah, and of course there were evil smart women as well like Izevel.
Please show us the verses where Abraham and Moses are described as "dark skinned," in the Bible. Do tell, point us to the verses. This seems like "Black Hebrew Israelite" cult reasoning, not Biblical. It is true, however, that Moses married an Ethiopian woman, yes (Numbers 12:1, KJV). But Moses was not black (or African like his wife) there's no evidence of that. Don't make things up. And where is David called "red?" However, I do agree, that there appears to be at least some diversity of marriage over time in different cases amongst the Israelites in the Bible (Ruth, Moses' wife, etc.), as you mentioned.
And the answer to your question is because Jews came from the 12 tribes of Israel originally.
Which tribe was the whiteys? which was the niggaz?, which was the samdniggaz?
'Jews' today, belong to 3 Israelite Tribes: Levy, Yehuda and Benjamin
Empress 24 how do you know
Qwer Tzu Because the northern kingdom was destroyed
@@empress2423 They're called Jews because they came from the Kingdom of Yehuda (Judah), which included only those 3 tribes. The other 9 tribes were either already gone by the time the Israelite kingdoms were founded, or were wiped out after the fall of the Kingdom of Israel, the kingdom that split from Judah. The modern-day Samaritans are believed to be the remnants of the Kingdom of Israel, but according to mainstream Judaism they are not 'true Jews' (I don't know about their genetic lineage).
The real question is: Who is a Jew? Rav Yochanan sheds (different) light on it. See Megilla 13a, second paragraph.
descendants of Levy, Benjamin and Yehuda, who were expelled from their land ¬2,000 yrs ago (others lived in Egypt, Babylonia, Yemen, etc)
Jew is a an ethnic group.
Even the Rabanut is using DNA test in order to define who is Jew (by the Rabanut a person is Jew, only if the mother is Jew)
“We all came from one mother, Eva. You just need to understand science “😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Pretty much all living humans today came from mitochondrial Eve
Ha ha ha ha ha
We come from a black women who mated with a neadrethal
Judaism as Islam and Christianity is a religion, not an ethnic group. The misunderstanding that Judaism is an ethnicity instead of a religion has favored Israel's colonial project in Palestine!
Not true, you can convert to Islam or Christianity in the same afternoon, if you have 10 minutes. To become a Jew, it takes 1 to 3 years of study. You are turned down many times, if you keep trying, you must learn the history, culture, festivals, law, traditions, Hebrew language, then you must go before a Rabbinic court and be questioned. If you pass the questioning, then, if male, you must undergo circumcision, after that Mikvah, then you are allowed to join the Jewish people.
It is not a religion, it is a nation of people.
Jews have been living in the diapora for 2000 years, Thomas Jefferson’s descendants have remained in the same country for 200 years yet they are multiracial also. Clearly race has absolutely nothing to do with descendancy. Uneducated question.
Jeffesrsons descendants r black/ multiracial because of mixing of races
@@fatman9196 oh course, and yet despite this mixing it doesn’t diminish the fact that every single one of them is a descendant of Thomas Jefferson regardless of their color today. That is precisely my point.
@@aarona7024 I understand but Thomas Jefferson lived recently like 200 + years ago.. the Jews that the ashkenazi r supposed to have descended from left the Middle East 2000 years ago.. most people would say that even if they have Semitic maternal lineage they r basically jus Eastern Europeans who claim to b native .. n that’s not including people who have converted to Judaism over that period of time
@@fatman9196 Except Ashkenazim are proven genetically to be their own unique genetic group regardless of what people think. This is science vs opinion.
@@aarona7024 I’m talking about their overall dna admixture not just their maternal lineage
This question was on my mind for long time!
"Ani lo hakatovet." I love that line. I'm going to start using that.
Mosaic law provided for foreigners who were not ethnically connected to the sons of Jacob to convert after which it was lawful for them to be married to ethnic Jews. It is possible for the Jews to have acquired much ethnic diversity without compromising their law.
Best question yet!!! 😁
Jacob married Lea and Rachel and had children with Bilha and Zilpa too. Nowhere in the Bible it says that Laban (the father of Lea and Rachel had children with one wife (it was common to have more bed partners, tho it was/is sinful behavior), he could have had children of two wives with different ethnicity. Bilha and Zilpa could also have been of completely different ethnicity. Nowhere in the Bible it says Israel stems from a single ethnic group.
The supposedly lived in the same land for millennia. Some were expelled by the Romans others converted converted to Christianity and later Islam and were absorbed in to Arab culture just like the rest of the Arab world.
remember too that in those times people used to believe that women have nothing to do on pregnant, they believed that men were the only ones who can procreate
@@DD-rv8hi That doesn't even make any sense. Of course people knew that women had a role in pregnancy. People knew back then that the red months play a role.
So ridiculous. Imagine getting your DNA test done and it coming back with "40% Buddhist, 30% Catholic, 20% Rastafarian, 10% atheist"
My 23andMe came back with 99.8% Ashkenazi Jewish 😂 Judiasm is more than just religion.
@@Mishyou33 lol why did they delete my comment. All I said was that a lot of people take multiple DNA tests and they come to different results. It's amazing how the truth is censored and buried here. We couldn't have a conversation if we wanted to. Watch "Europa: the last battle" on bitchute... it's over 12 hours of historical truth about the events leading up to and through world war 2.
@@ryublueblanka How drastic are the differences in results though? If its small, it's likely just due to different databases having different information. I wouldnt call that censorship. I'll check out the docuseries though
@@Mishyou33 of course my comment got deleted. I wonder why? Jk I know exactly why. Btw to your point about your DNA results...all that is telling you is that you're of central or eastern European decent. Your religious beliefs don't have anything to do with it and you preserve Palestinian rather than Babylonian traditions.
@@ryublueblanka again, Judaism is not just a religion. If "all that is telling" me that I am of Eastern/central European descent, I wouldn't get Ashkenazi. I would get Russian, Polish, or even "broadly European" but I didn't so...
The answer is intermarriage (miscegenation). This happened across centuries, but genetically Ashkenazi, Shepardic, and Mizrahi ethnic groups are closest to each other than to any other ethnic group in the world. We can see on scatter graphs
This is the equivalent of asking a partially- First Nations person why they're so heavily mixed with white. I think we all know the answer.
@@SimonKanner-si3it Native Canadians.
Don't we all come from Adam and Eve , even gentiles come from them... ( I think)
jay Weiss Adam and Steve
Yes they do.
If you believe the Bible/Torah, then yes, we all genetically come from Adam and Eve. Jews, having been called via Abraham.... even atheists have what's called, "genetic Adam and genetic Eve" via DNA testing.
Darwin answered your question.
@@salim_shabaz no. Darwin has a theory. It's not proven. It's still a theory and it still takes faith. They just talk like they know for sure and claim it's fact. But even they admit it's still a theory.... actually, different atheists have different theories as to how the earth and mankind came to be.
The topic is most interesting and merits deep research/digging into it..... Could you make further vlogs on the same topic... This was something that keep occurring to me while watching your videos in Israel as to why Israeli people were looked so different in the complexion if they were genetically of the same origin!
Rev 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
The real story is it was intentional and is far far more interesting than you'd think. A few centuries ago a bet din sent Jewish men and women to western Europe and Spain to mix with the local population in an effort to enable greater trade without rousing suspicion that they were Jewish.
This allowed them to operate with impunity in those two lands which were cynical of Jews after the money shaving incidents that led to their expulsion from many nations and with both western Europe and the caliphate that Spain was ruled under being the power houses at the time it enabled greater trade opportunities and the forwarding of Jewish interests in both regions.
The Ashkenazim come from literally less than 300 Jews who were part of this eugenics like breeding program. 23&Me did some interesting write ups about it all. Although they had to remove a bunch of their findings because there was an outcry as the majority of Ashkenazi DNA was from Khazari stock.
Given that there is a stigma around Khazar roots in European admixture Semitic peoples it led to legal threats and extreme backlash so most of the articles on their genetic findings are only available on the wayback machine or archive sites.
Can you post us where you got those "findings"? Like, can you provide us sites and documentation?
And as well as Arabs have different skin.. mine is darker that my siblings...as swell as my cousins....but jewish comes from France .Germany and many different countries and these is a variety of cultures that is why their skin color is never similar. Because their great great grandfather comes from different countries and they born from different parents because they have interracial marriage unlike us.
All Jews regardless of what they look like or where they were born during the Roman exile belong to the land of Israel.
Arabs in Israel come in a variety of colors too. And there is intermarriage with other groups as there are Muslim converts. Or
Blondes like the Tamimi family originally from Bosnia. Or
Beduin who resemble Africans.
The Arabs in Israel are a mixed bag.
soia Please be a little easier on her. She is someone you can at least have a rational conversation with.
Thanks!
She almost never replies unless its to her taste. No dialog here. Sorry
@@Linda43 at least she's polite and she's not rude or insulting...unlike some. Her English skills are decent. I personally choose not to answer to people who are aggressive or rude or plain immature . You are blunt but you're polite as well.
@soia it's called foundation. Thanks for your lovely comment.
Hold on...I’m a black guy born in Canada. And I’m still black...am I miss something?
So _you’re_ the one?
I don't think people understand the question. First of there on such thing as different races all humans are realted geneticly to eachother.
Most Jews have shared ancestry but also have mix ancestry. From Moses wife Tziporah to Ruth non-Jews have converted to Judasim and married into the Jewish people.
it is very simple, those who lived for hundreds of years in a hot environment became more dark in their skin because of a certain material in their skin which make the skin darker to protect it from the sun.
The education there must suck. Honestly, it's quite easy to find out what happened throughout the Jewish diaspora by reading a little history. There was plenty of intermixing, in Europe more than in the Middle East. The amount of ignorance in this video is a bit surprising to be honest.
The education does suck but the indoctrination is world class. Was married to an Yemeni Israeli who's family name was Bashari but didn't think she was arab, but Jewish Israeli only
I'm white. If I have a kid with a white woman, the kid will be white. If I have another kid with a black woman, the kid will be black. If I have another kid with an Asian woman, the kid will be Asian. The three look different, but are all half-brothers. This is why Jews can all be related but look different from one another, because we're descended from the same bunch of Middle Eastern men who boned their way across the the Mediterranean.
The European Jews are mixed. Male Jews arrived in France, Germany and Spain. They intermarried with local women. In Iraq Jews did not mix. They arrived from Judea with King Nebukenezar. Other Jews were converts. It's a mish mash.
If Jackie Chan converts today to Judaism 100 years from now his kids would say my people suffered for 5000 years crazy.
It's because There is no Jewish DNA
there is a Semitic dna / race
Even the lore saying that they came from Canaan to Egypt
Means they are from Old Canaantites pagans and shamans .
Judaism erased everything that has something to do with idols becusee they are a shame of that .
My Jewish friend visited Jerusalem as a tourist. He came back home saying the Jewish merchants tried to rip him off. He said they were all the same when it came to money!
That was a brilliant question 😂 They don’t have any actual answer. They know very well their background where they came from. They could not explain the truth. There is no name Israel as a country before 1947. They occupied Palestinian. Their answers were ridiculous
Answer: Because Jews intermarried with, to various extents with Gentile converts from their host populations during The Diaspora. Meaning each community (Ashkenazim, Sephardim, Mizrahim, etc...) is, genetically speaking, a mix of Middle Eastern/Levantine and non-Jewish 'Diaspora host population' elements. So yes, there is a common Middle Eastern/Levantine genetic element in all Diaspora communities. Genetic studies corroborate that.
0:25 apsolutely right we came from one mother Eve or Hawa👏🏼👏🏼
pretty sure God created some other people after, otherwise we'd all be inbreds according to Abrahamic religions.
@@slimking what?!