Is P-Gear better than Dragy?!?!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 97

  • @VancityAudi
    @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +20

    I was wrong when I said you are not able to turn the 1ft rollout on/off with Dragy. If you turn off the option in Dragy called (NHRA Rules) that will eliminate the 1ft rollout. Thanks to Northside Custom RC for the info!

  • @MrScoopage
    @MrScoopage Рік тому +2

    Theres a draggy 2.0 now. Cool to see this redone with the new draggy

  • @GyroPyro121212
    @GyroPyro121212 2 роки тому +6

    It seems like the Pgear P610 is probably superior to the dragy. However, I like the compactness of the dragy and I already have one. I will likely never buy a pGear as the dragy is plenty accurate and has shown no signs of stopping. If one day my dragy fails, I’m sure they will have come out with a 20 hz or better dragy by then and I’ll buy that one.

    • @jdmcarrepairs142
      @jdmcarrepairs142 Рік тому +2

      You still feel this way today? Lots of people have been having more issues with their Dragy DR69s(the old one) now that Dragy released the new version. Pretty suspect honestly, they worked fine before but suddenly the old one has trouble grabbing satellites frequently. I like the Dragy but stunts like that make me want to switch.

  • @jonnymac8925
    @jonnymac8925 2 роки тому +3

    It would be cool to test both of them at the drag strip so you can compare the Dragy and Pgear to the track timer!

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому +3

      I was planning on doing that but never got around to it. Perhaps I can before the end of the year.

  • @DevineDigital
    @DevineDigital 3 роки тому +2

    I like the PGEAR because the app actually works on my iPhone or my android vs the DRAGY which only freezes on my iPhone.

  • @losio155
    @losio155 3 роки тому +5

    I think 1/4 mile times are all right in both. It's all about accuracy. When you have 10hz (dragy) times of every run may differ by 1/10 of second (0,1s). If you have p-gear in 20hz version then times may differ only by 1/20 of second (0,05s). Which version of p-gear do you have? There are 10 and 20hz versions.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +3

      I believe I have the 10hz.

    • @ShawnGilbert1967
      @ShawnGilbert1967 3 роки тому +2

      P600 is 10hz the p610 is 20hz it would be twice as accurate

  • @pklifter
    @pklifter 3 роки тому

    Thanks for sharing. TIL that the draggy I just bought can record video. I will have to use that feature next time.

  • @Merlinen82
    @Merlinen82 3 роки тому +4

    They were 0,02-0,09 sec appart and on first 1/4 mile 0.09 and you can not belive it?? :)
    Fells like the normal variation in GPS measurements :)
    And never have 2 GPS devices that close to each other, they can interfere with each other.
    Both are good, buy the one that you get cheaper or go with RaceLogic but they cost $$

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +1

      No, it didn't look right considering my Dragy unit is super consistent and has proven to be .02 - .03 slower than it should read over the past 2 years. Having the 2 devices beside eachother should make absolutely no difference. I have done this testing already with multiple Dragy devices and they all read within .02 of eachother: ua-cam.com/video/LGWvSaXtSSE/v-deo.html

    • @Merlinen82
      @Merlinen82 3 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi Ye but there is a good reson why Racelogic for ex space the GPS antennas way apart when they do testing (For Buggatti/Koenigsegg and so on), and GPS company if any should know....

  • @erniethompson1776
    @erniethompson1776 2 роки тому

    For anyone looking at this now. Dragy reads slower at the track because it reads when the car starts to move and on the track you have to move through a light beam before the time starts

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому

      That would be incorrect. There is an option on Dragy called (NHRA Rules) under the 1/8, 1/4, 1/2 and 1 mile readings where it is supposed to account for the 1ft rollout that you're referring to. It still doesn't calculate that properly and has never been perfectly accurate for me. If you turn that option off it gets even worse.

  • @coryswinerton3296
    @coryswinerton3296 3 роки тому +3

    You can’t compare accuracy without a control test. If your 1/4 mile time slips are usually a bit lower than dragy results, then this may mean that the P-Gear unit actually is more accurate since it gave you a slightly lower ET.....
    A fair comparison would be to test both units at the drag strip.... Then compare both to the actual timers at the track.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +2

      Not sure that you watched the full video, or even listened to what I said in the video, lol.
      I have 2 full years of using that exact Dragy device at the drag strip. I have been comparing the times it has produced for 2 years now vs the track slips I have been receiving. They have ALWAYS been slower than what the track slip says. Meaning that the consistency of this device seems to always been bang on. Always slower, never a perfect match and never quicker than the time slips. That provides me more than enough of a control to test the P-Gear against it.
      I also say that the Dragy device has NEVER been as off as the P-Gear shows so I think the P-Gear was registering incorrectly and wasn't correct with that 1-ft rollout.
      Not only that, I specifically say in the video that I'll be bringing them both to the track to test once again. I'm confident the Dragy will be more consistent and possibly more accurate once again. Only time will tell though and I'll be sure to share that info with everyone once I've done the testing.

    • @coryswinerton3296
      @coryswinerton3296 3 роки тому +2

      @@VancityAudi Waiting on the 1320 testing day. I think you may be surprised.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      @@coryswinerton3296 We shall see!!!

    • @jdmcarrepairs142
      @jdmcarrepairs142 Рік тому

      Cory you had very good points they dismissed here for no reason.

  • @standardIssues67
    @standardIssues67 3 роки тому +1

    Are either of these accurate when using on a grade in the 2-4% area. EG:freeway on-ramp

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      You have to have less than a 1% slope in order for these devices to generate valid results

    • @standardIssues67
      @standardIssues67 3 роки тому +1

      ​@@VancityAudi Thanks. I live in Western Pennsylvania-the only things flat here are the rivers.

  • @EnviedKing
    @EnviedKing 3 роки тому +2

    I just received the Pgear and I have to say Im not satisfied with the app at all. Unless I am doing something wrong(since theres no instructions for the app) the Pgear does not automatically restart the testing once you drop back below the starting point of measurement. So when I go out on my motorcycle to measure 60-130, I can only do it once before having to pull over and start it again but with the Dragy I dont have to restart it as it automatically restarts. So I can do all my pulls and then check the results at the end. Anyway to make the Pgear do this as well that you know of?

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +1

      I'm honestly not sure. I've never done more than one 60-130 pull without coming to a stop. Are you using it in EASY mode or another one of the modes?

    • @EnviedKing
      @EnviedKing 3 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi I think it was just in drag mode. I'll try putting it in easy mode. Hopefully it works so I can finish this review and hopefully on a positive note and not feeling like I wasted $130 LoL

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      @@EnviedKing Hope it works out for ya!

    • @Omgjosh925
      @Omgjosh925 3 роки тому +2

      @@EnviedKing yeah you need to use easy mode bro, it allows multiple tests -josh with pgear

    • @Omgjosh925
      @Omgjosh925 3 роки тому +1

      We’re working with developers to make all drag modes do this, but generally you use drag mode to record one pass and view your results immediately after like at the drag strip. Hence “drag mode”

  • @artosiltala9965
    @artosiltala9965 Рік тому

    Wish you would test the devices again since 20hz (p610) version is out there. It will not make your car faster tho.
    I've used dragy since it came in, was it 2017. Recently moved to pgear.
    Key differences, and take it with a grain of salt, becase I'm no engineer and cand say I get this things:
    P-Gear better that dragy because:
    - The refresh rate is twise as fast - Can't say how much this affects my times tho.
    - The 3d mpu sensor, dunno is it gyroskope or something (gforces, acceleration/brearking, lines - Much more data in the run especially on the track or road course.
    - Slope reading usually on point, compared to dragy that shows random readings.
    - Detailed view of you run, track or drag
    - Cloud saving
    - All in one app (vs dragy, dragy route, dragy track)
    - Leaderboards are pain in the ass, because they require video of the run. But that's kinda cool since they are checked by pgear, so you cant cheat much
    - Easier to add and follow friedns, and you can actually invite them to race your custom track.
    - I can search my car model and see its times. In dragy they have free typing method so there is: rs3, rs3 saloon, rs3 white, rs3 500hp and so on, hard to see all times)
    - To me windshiel mount is easier to use
    Dragy better than pgear because:
    - Feels smaller and more robust
    - UI is much cleaner becasue of the light theme
    - Social media integration
    - Much more users, there fore much more times
    - I can throw it out of the window in 100mph and it will survive
    - easier to go to leaderboard since you can run a time without video and post it. So I can upload anything. Good and bad, i see some 1l golf doing 1sec 0-60 its hard for me to believe.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  Рік тому

      This video was shot almost 2 years ago. Sadly I don't plan on testing wthe new units. Both Dragy and P-Gear have a new model available since then and I'm sure they both work better than before.

  • @onelowvdub
    @onelowvdub Рік тому

    pgear does lap times .good for us road course drivers

  • @bagelbandit6076
    @bagelbandit6076 3 роки тому

    Can’t wait to see the comparison with a time slip

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +1

      Same. I'm really interested now to see if it is more accurate or not.

    • @bagelbandit6076
      @bagelbandit6076 3 роки тому +1

      @@VancityAudi it’s 100% accurate 40% of the time...

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      Lol

  • @chadpennington4594
    @chadpennington4594 2 роки тому

    As far as slope goes, maybe when you point the thing up to the windshield.... it needs to be level? I'm considering one of these two units, not sure yet. Is battery life good on both units? Dragy sounds like the winner

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому +1

      Slope has nothing to do with the angle of the device. I've tested it further in a bunch of different ways and the slope reading is by far the least accurate part of how the Dragy works. Sadly I didn't test the battery life, but I will say I always bring a charging cable with me when I go to the track with it because sometimes it runs low on juice

    • @chadpennington4594
      @chadpennington4594 2 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi Gotcha! Thanks!

  • @superduper476
    @superduper476 2 роки тому

    How did the 0-60mph compare? Was 1 foot rollout in both? Tks!

  • @superduper476
    @superduper476 2 роки тому

    I heard dragy now accounts for the 1 foot rollout is that correct??? Tks.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому

      Check out the pinned comment. Thanks for watching.

  • @911Hammer
    @911Hammer 2 роки тому +1

    Sorry but there are many issue with the way of testing this. GPS variations on devices like this can be significant. Specially when measuring in the 1/100’s of seconds and feet…

  • @Fluke2SS
    @Fluke2SS Рік тому

    Considering my Dragy hasn't worked since the day I bought it, I think anything works better than dragy at this point.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  Рік тому

      Damn! I'm really sorry to hear that! Have you tried leaving it connected to a power supply while using it or first connecting it? If you have, you're not the only person I've heard of where their unit didn't work and had to get another.

  • @moochiezpitt
    @moochiezpitt 3 роки тому +1

    Hey Adam. Thanks for the vid. I just got my Dragy, so I don't see myself buying another drag device. 🙂 Cheers.

  • @mikelin7
    @mikelin7 2 роки тому

    How you sign up from P gear APP. Mine says my email is invalid

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому

      Luckily I've never had that issue before. I'd suggest reaching out to PGear via email.

  • @John-qc1zv
    @John-qc1zv 3 роки тому

    So after using them for 9 months, which one would you order if you have to buy only 1 today ?

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +2

      Dragy

    • @artosiltala9965
      @artosiltala9965 Рік тому

      The 10hz version is not available much anymore, so it's hard to compare anymore.

  • @RK-sn2hp
    @RK-sn2hp 3 роки тому

    so to be honest, what is better ? i have dragy, been thinking of pgear too

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      I personally prefer Dragy, but PGear has some cool features too.

    • @PatC1
      @PatC1 3 роки тому

      PGear 20hz FTW

  • @shaunald
    @shaunald 3 роки тому

    My P3 guage showed 4.17 0-100 but the Dragy showed 4.47 on the same run. Not sure what to believe. The new car will have a built-in performance monitor so I'll compare that to Dragy of it ever arrives.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      I'd trust a Dragy based off of GPS over a P3 gauge.

    • @shaunald
      @shaunald 3 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi I figured the fact that P3 connects to the OBD port would make it more accurate no?

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +1

      @@shaunald It's based off of the right rear wheel speed sensor. When the car is at 0 the gauge says "rdy" and as soon as it leaves 0 it starts the timer. The timer ends as soon as the gauge sees 60mph.
      If your tire height is any different than stock your speedo won't read correctly meaning the results will be inaccurate.

    • @shaunald
      @shaunald 3 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi once again, you have more information than the manufacturers own website 😅. Thanks man.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      @@shaunald hahaha, I just know people that know people.

  • @dimmacommunication
    @dimmacommunication 3 роки тому

    I've seen people using both P-gear and dragy on the same software , wich software could you use ?

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      Not sure what you're asking...

    • @dimmacommunication
      @dimmacommunication 3 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi I've seen people reading GPS times and get reported at the same time on the phone.
      But no problem, I will probably buy just dragy

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      @@dimmacommunication I'm really sorry that I don't understand the question.

    • @dimmacommunication
      @dimmacommunication 3 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi It's ok man :)

    • @shaunald
      @shaunald 3 роки тому +1

      My P gear showed about .3 seconds fast to 100 than the dragy

  • @MOTORHEADS2K
    @MOTORHEADS2K 2 роки тому

    Its too late. dragy took over the industry and has become a standart among everybody. the social media around it is neat and the device is very accurate.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому

      Unless you live in China where P-Gear is the go to device 😉

    • @MOTORHEADS2K
      @MOTORHEADS2K 2 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi Thing is that dragy became a standart/ china or not. unless your 60-130 result is dragy aproved and posted on their leaderboard...you dont exist lol

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому

      That's where you'd be wrong. The standard in China for 0-100km/h and 100-200km/h is P-Gear. In North America Dragy is king though.

    • @MOTORHEADS2K
      @MOTORHEADS2K 2 роки тому

      @@VancityAudi could be.

  • @mattcross428
    @mattcross428 2 роки тому

    Try a clear day my dragy is off in the rain. So is my google maps mph and my hp tuner is almost dead on but dragy is off about the same as yours but never tried a p gear.

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  2 роки тому

      As I mentioned in this video I've drag raced with it plenty of times and it's never bang on. The majority of times I race at the drag strip, it's clear skies.

  • @axelriet
    @axelriet 3 роки тому +1

    “Nine one hundreds” wtf? Besides that this video could be 75% shorter without any loss of information.

  • @Christdeliverme
    @Christdeliverme 3 роки тому

    Interesting your voice pitch dropped using Dragy!

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому

      Ya, I thought that was SUPER weird as well. Like the mic was distorted while recording with Dragy or something

  • @sjs-yc5my
    @sjs-yc5my 3 роки тому +4

    P gear 20 HZ,draggy 10 Hz........

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  3 роки тому +2

      My P Gear is the older version that is 10hz as well.

    • @StuntmanMike366
      @StuntmanMike366 3 роки тому +2

      P610G (your) 10hz, the P610 or P610S are 20hz versions 👍🏼

  • @AJMods123
    @AJMods123 2 роки тому

    Few days ago....
    Tw D2 company say that fake shit products........ 🤣🤣🤣🤣
    Totally shit bcoz he can't get the results he want on the device
    He told if the device can't test 0-400 bcoz p gear not send signal from 0kmh
    Totally rubbish shit

  • @christianmartinez4150
    @christianmartinez4150 3 роки тому +3

    I’m liking the p gear cuz it’s cheaper 🤣

    • @michaelangelo5783
      @michaelangelo5783 3 роки тому

      When was that? It's $169 now vs dragy at 149. These boxes should be 100 bucks, tops.

    • @dylan-nguyen
      @dylan-nguyen 3 роки тому

      @@michaelangelo5783 and Dragy is on Amazon so free shipping + 5% cash back if u got an amazon card

    • @michaelangelo5783
      @michaelangelo5783 3 роки тому

      @@dylan-nguyen
      I just returned my Dragy. First off, it was used and sold as new. Had car crumbs on it and even a beard hair or pube hair sticking out of the bottom edge/line (took photos in case Amazon gives me shit). But it worked okay timing runs a few days, but videos wouldn't export, it would hang. Then it stopped working completely, wouldn't connect to my phone, very annoying because I got up extra early before work when it's nice and cool, lowered my rear tire PSI, drove 5 miles to the sticks to a straight flat empty backroad. Tried re-installing and whatnot, just a pile. Not sure if I'll buy it again, since most Discover/Amex/xyz credit card promos won't work because while it's shipped by Amazon, the seller is a 3rd party. I also did multiple runs comparing dragy to a free app called Drag Racer (I think). With a good phone mount close to the window I recorded nearly identical times.

    • @dylan-nguyen
      @dylan-nguyen 3 роки тому

      @@michaelangelo5783 the reason phone apps will never work though is your phone GPS only refreshes once a second
      the dragy refreshes at 10hz thus giving it it's accuracy
      unfortunate that you got a used item but for anything purchased on Amazon my 5% cash back works 🤷‍♂️

    • @michaelangelo5783
      @michaelangelo5783 3 роки тому

      @@dylan-nguyen
      If the phone app only refreshes at 1hz, how was it giving me readings that were virtually on par with Dragy? Is it just extrapolating data and using cell tower and wifi signals also?? A good launch is 5.0s to 60mph/8.7-8.8s 1/8th. Mediocre launch is several tenths slower.

  • @joryhaggerty5380
    @joryhaggerty5380 3 роки тому +1

    P gear app looks way better

  • @MuscleAKAOzzy
    @MuscleAKAOzzy 2 роки тому

    Ehy would you want an extra mount lol dragy is perfect;

  • @isaalghazi9131
    @isaalghazi9131 19 днів тому

    So Gay, wayyyy too much talk... but at least I know the CHEAPER unit is not quite as accurate. Glad I have the Dragy. I ride a motorcycle. Who cares about a windshield mount? FWIW this guys gives my 'creepy guy' meter a bit of a reaction.... (shudder)

    • @VancityAudi
      @VancityAudi  19 днів тому

      🤣🤣🤣 What's worse? The guy on UA-cam trying to make a video to help people get the best bang for their buck or the c$ck gobbler that leaves rude comments about the effort he puts in???🤔🤔🤔 ... 🤣🤣🤣 Thanks for watching!!!