It’s not hurting Mumbai…. Mumbai is overloaded. Need other cities to step up to help mumbai to reduce load… Glad that gift city and Pune are one of those helping hands
Pune help karte karte khud jam ho gaya gain ab...I cannot see the difference between Mumbai and Pune now..😅 Pune traffic is worst after Bengaluru in India...many IT companies from Pune finding alternatives such as Hyderabad, Nagpur... Pune authorities should take actions asap to resolve traffic issue
@@shramdeepasawale9900 as guy who lives in Gujarat, I didn’t know traffic of pune.. mismatched public transit is issue everywhere … here in Ahmedabad - metro/brts/amts works separately instead of working as one unit to provide last mile connectivity…
@@shramdeepasawale9900 metro station should he brts/amts bus terminal and single tickets for all. So people can use all 3 type of services in mix so they get encouraged to use public transit
I'm gujrati but I don't think that mumbai will replace by other city Gift city's aim is different it's not hurting mumbai's financial status & even navi mumbai is challenging mumbai
Mumbai is just shitttt and foreigners don't give damn on Mumbai Because it's just fucking crowd with lot's of slums unhygienic nature and crowded locals ewwww.
As a Mumbaikar I am saying this. Lol. Whole india india will develop bt not mumbai. Without min wage nothing going to change in mumbai. In mumbai people live becuz of slums as they are cheapest in whole india. If u remove slums whole cheap laboroures will leave mumbai. And all retail shops and restaurants will start booking losses😂😂in india Businessman don't share their profit to their employees. Just take example of mumbai. In mumbai there are many retail shops and restaurant and movie production houses. And u will see most laboroures or gig job workers who work their are either relatives of them or up, bihari and Bangladeshis. They hire rhem cuz they work in cheap salaries. hence in mumbai slum population is increasing and now uts upto 55%. Where 40% Bangladeshis, 28% up and bihair and 15% south indians living. Becuz of cheap laboroures all local people whether they are marathi or gujju, marwari or sindhi or parsi who were living since mumbai formed are either have to choose white collar jobs, do business or go abroad. Businessman are main problem of this country. Cuz they dont share high salary to employees. Second problem is overpopulation done by up, bihari and peaceful community. In mumbai slums and especially in bihari and Bangladeshis area u will see parents having 3-4 kids. Mumbai has most poor people in whole country. And they live in slums cuz living in slum is cheapest. In slums they have 5-6 k rent and they share with 5-7 members. And no tax and other maintenance. In building of 1rk min rent is 15 k with maintenance and election and other taxes
@@sankkhamwow bro. I love people who admit their place's situation. Also great observation. Mumbai will eventually lose to other cities because of high prices. Even navi mumbai will give tough competition to mumbai. According to me that's good because we need more cities like mumbai so that it will be less crowded. Atleast 50 cities should have that calliber. Imagine 50 cities like mumbai. India will become great again
@@mayankbhardwaj550 u still didn't get. Mumbai is cheapest city if anyone lives in slums. No city in india can replace Mumbai cuz no city has cheap labour like mumbai. I work as ad and director in bollywood. And here for labour jobs and Jr artist not a single Mumbaikar is there. Cuz all migrants work with cheap salaries, 12-15 hrs and without any facilities or insurance. They work cuz most live in slums where u don't need good salary to survive. Mumbai's population is lesser than all metro cities in india if u calculate people who live in legal houses. In mumbai illegal slum population is high. Businesses earn more profit in mumbai due to slum population. as people who live their can afford to work with 10-15 k salary. Ambani, adani, godrej, tata etc have many private properties and there slum exist. They never even tried to remove slums on their private land. Cuz all Buisnesmen want cheap labour. In 90s Mumbai's slum population was 33%. In 2010 it was 43%. Now it's 55%. Govn also helping Businesses to grow slums due to cheap laboroures. More than that. After kolkata mumbai has most Bangladeshis in india. And the more Bangladeshis means more slums and illegal crimes.
Yes we should have many Mumbai like cities in every state so that middle class don't have to migrate and face problems and exploitation by people of that state.
@@Indian_RajputIt is happening because of not giving people liberty. Like If I say I am proud to Hindu doesn't makes me anti Indian or saying proud to be Gujarati either
You are saying this most probably because you are not from Mumbai. Mumbai future is looking dark under Gujarat Janta Party who are running their govt in the name of Indian govt. Everything is going to Gujarat and even the future semi conductor will be build there. You know what? Even they building largest Film City to attract Bollywood to Noida NCR. Mumbai will left with nothing. Financial and Entertainment capital of India tags will go to some other cities. Gujarat Janta Party is only developing Gujarat
@@Hello-kh6bk first of all Noida is not in Gujarat and Hindi film industry should be in a Hindi speaking state. On one hand you guys want everyone to speak Marathi in Mumbai and on the other hand you also want the Hindi entertainment industry in Mumbai. Bunch of hypocrites.
I think Gujarat and Ahmedabad earned GIFT city under CM Modi even before BJP came to power. Its good to have more than 1 financial city. Mumbai still gets more branches by fintech companies instead of GIFT. Mumbai’s Metro will further make it even more attractive. Kudos for Gujaratis for their Business model. India to achieve a 10 trillion dollar economy and beyond, such IFSCs even outside of Mumbai are important. Gift will still get political backing for at least another 5 years under BJP
Its okay for Mumbai-GIFT to be dual hubs after a decade or so. OR It will also be fine if Mumbai serves its purpose well and then pass on the financial mantel to another city. Overuse of every region is fatal. Like what we did in Punjab during the green and white revolution. Now all Punjabis giving up farming and moving to Can Aus US
Also, if one notices a very bizzare phenomenon- many of the financial and infrastructure projects are halted in India no matter which city they're in. Halted then started then halted again. Many of it is State-Centre and/or State1-State2 power struggle. BUT many NGOs also play a BIGGG role in knocking the train off its tracks. Only a few handful of them are genuine, while the other (NGOs) are actually foreign-funded. Especially by a certain colonizer.
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
*Im from Finance Field Senior Team Bengaluru,,, Gujarat Gift City Job & Work is Based on Singapore,,,(Currencey work etc) Where is Mumbai Work is Based on South Indian Companies,,, I Don't Think there is even 10% Similarity,,, its like Buying Laptop or TV,, Both Look same work is differ (Even, Thanks to that All Giant Gujarati BUsiness men,,, Relience, Amul, Wipro Long List,, No one is From Maharastra*
@@erwinsmith5796Gujrat does not have centred economy like mh Gujrat economy is spreaded all over the state, whereas if you remove Mumbai from mh,nothing much wil remain
Mumbai honestly is big brother in finance as such. Mumbai is unique as it is like NewYork of India. Ahmedabad is like younger brother to Mumbai. It will take at least 25 years for Ahmedabad to reach to level of Mumbai seen today. By that time Mumbai will be already a established world city. We have to be realistic about fantasy vs reality.
Mumbai will remain a focal point but GIFT is about leveraging location. The ports all around Saurashtra connecting directly to Gulf countries are the major factor here. An insane amount of ports are accelerating their development. It is going unnoticed because people are more interested in trains and expressways. New York developed due to it also being on the Atlantic trade route from Europe. If they can set up a high speed water taxi or underwater rail from Okha to Oman, that can change the destiny of both India and West Asia.
Why do you think only these two cities wil devlop Maharashtra also have Mumbai and Pune and nagpur too they will also devlop in 15 year@divyeshpatel2463
Thanks for realising this. Maharashtra government should focus on building a business district like that in navi mumbai with wide roads and all modern amenities and not allow people to build slums close to it. Mumbai is losing its sheen because of unchecked slums popping up everywhere. I don't know why the Maharashtra government isn't thinking about it but there should be something like the times square nyc in navi mumbai.
@@Vishesh.077well said bro. Maharashtra doesn't mean only mumbai and pune. Vidarbha region is most bakcward region in country still govt is always biased towards west Maharashtra. Govt should make big projects on cities like Nagpur, Sambhaji Nagar, Wardha, Solapur
In Mumbai you have to pay Rs 25000/- rent for 310 sq ft flat and travel to work in overcrowded train. GIFT city will reduce the population leading to lower rents and reduce overcrowding in train. Mumbaikar will benefit the most from GIFT city. Only builder lobby will loose as they will not be able to sell their flats at exorbitant price to helpless home buyers as people can instead choose to settle in GIFT city instead.
Finance is a high leverage industry you don't need that many people per unit of economic activity. If you want to reduce train rush, finance is the last sector you should Target.
I would also like to add one more thing. Instead of making our cities like Paris, Singapore, Shenzen, Beijing, Tokyo, Shangai, Guangzhou, and California, we should make plans that suit over needs. Every city in Bharat is different and every city requires a different set of solutions. What made Singapore that things may not work in cities like Bengaluru, Mumbai, Chennai. My extended family lives in Bengaluru and I visit Bengaluru 2-3 times a year. I will say that govt had plans to make Bengaluru equivalent to Dubai but those plans never worked both in the tenure of the BJP and Congress.
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
Gift cities will benefit Mumbai in long term. Landprices are skyrocketing in Mumbai, A commonman can't buy a flat near office place, people have to travel 100 km daily for workplaces. There is hardly any place in Mumbai to develop new business districts except Godrej land and Eastern suburbs
ICICI Bank Ltd has shifted its registered headquarters from Vadodara to Mumbai.experts in corporate governance told that one major consequence of shifting the bank’s registered office from Vadodara to Mumbai is that ICICI Bank will now pay its corporate income tax in Mumbai, increasing Maharashtra’s share in central taxes collected from states. Stamp duty on large corporate loans will also be paid in Maharashtra as these loans will be registered here. In addition, the bank’s annual general meetings (AGMs) will now be held in Mumbai.😅
Because finance professionals do not want to work in a dry state like Gujarat. The Central Government is just pushing the gift City. Without them this city will fail.
@@DannycageGhostrider Yes my friend but they have not shifted the office physically, only registration addres will be mumbai and corporate tax will be paid to Maharashtra.
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
*Im from Finance Field Senior Team Bengaluru,,, Gujarat Gift City Job & Work is Based on Singapore,,,(Currencey work etc) Where is Mumbai Work is Based on South Indian Companies,,, I Don't Think there is even 10% Similarity,,, its like Buying Laptop or TV,, Both Look same work is differ (Even, Thanks to that All Giant Gujarati BUsiness men,,, Relience, Amul, Wipro Long List,, No one is From Maharastra*
Thank you so much for this video on gift city power train. GIFT City will take india on a global international financial standing. Its important for India's development.🇮🇳🇮🇳
I am from Mumbai but i believe the motive is totally different and the gift is for international companies and Mumbai was never a financial centre but you can see wholesale companies in Mumbai
@@31davidwarnergift City worst hai. Companies gift city me isiliye ja rahe kyunki koi dusra IFSC nahi Hai jis din ek dusra IFSC ban gaya sari companies use dry state ko chhodkar bhagenge😂
@@31davidwarner should merge Delhi and up Delhi ke pass jameen nahin hai aur up ke pass Paisa nahi Hai agar donon state sath mei a gaye to baval Ho jaega
Mumbai is nothing but a piece of shitttt It's shameful for us that it is a part of india. Poor people live there streets are fucked up and main point is the backward people live in shitttt like slums. It's the financial capital of India and we still see slums more than skyscrapers.
It's very important,that maharashtra government wakes up from it's sleep , and designate , Navi Mumbai as a special economic zone , cut down taxes and if possible copy GIFT city model
I don't like comparison videos of Indian cities but I kind of agree with this. If Mumbai doesn't improve itself then I won't be surprised when GIFT City will be called the financial capital of India Just look at Kolkata. In spite of being 3rd largest city in India how the government policies have destroyed that city. It is hard to believe Kolkata was once the capital city of India even though it was during British India but it was still a big city. Now -a- days it hardly comes in news.
Kolkata is still a big city....see kolkata is not like other city...means it's not like kolkata is not developed it doesn't mean kolkata don't have any company....it means kolkata don't have that much fdi investment and other global product base companies.....there is also a fintech hub establishing in kolkata...but its unable to attract global attention....
Jyada kolkata kolkata mat koro. Pura Wb, bihar, up main area ke hisab se population bohut jyada hai. Ihape bara industry nahi ho sakta koi jamin nahi dega
This is great! The amount investments Gift city will bring into India will be highly valuable. Besides, we should have competition among our cities too! But that is only beneficial if state governments also decide to compete with each other and try to develop the best cities instead of just accepting defeat and letting other cities grow way past them. It will be a problem for developed place as well as just like places like Mumbai and Bengaluru, gift cities will become over populated as well.
Hope gift city will get the crown of financial centre.I think so every year by year every state should get the chance of financial centre so it will be help to develop India easily
Dont say gift city is threat to Mumbai. Gift city is competetion to Mumbai. Both will vie for investment, in the process will better facilities to investors. Competetion is good Not a threat.
Maharashtra is richer than gujrat in terms of GDP. But condition of farmers in Maharashtra is more critical than gujrat. Just because Gujraties are business minded and less engaged in agriculture. And more workforce engaged in manufacturing, industrial and services sector. Were, Amul, and green revolution helps to uplifting the good condition of Gujarat farmer's Maharashtra have govt. Owned JNPT. But Gujarat have privately owned Mega Mundra Port, But Mundra Port have seamless cargo handling capacity then JNPT.
@@hello_1456ecause mumbai is the oldest metropolitan in india. So mumbai attracted a lot below poverty line people in india. Which came here and built slums. Gujrat has had a gradual well thought out development which mumbai never had. So more people from poor backgrounds came to Mumbai. So gujarat having a better gdp per capita is a no brainer.
Economic, industrial, banking and financial institutions should not be concerned in a single city. For the development of nation it should scattered in different cities and parts. Mumbai is highly concentrated city .
Gift city will help India to establish an international financial hub between Dubai and Singapore. Second it will help rich Indians to establish their office in gift city instead of migrating to the west, Singapore or Dubai. The desired goals are not yet achieved but tale tale signs are visible now after almost a decade. Hope it’ll thrive and support mumbai and establish India in international financial markets.
I too believe cities like mumbai, Bangalore are becoming extremely crowded and chaotic, hence to shift its burden to other cities would bring a positive change and also such cities will also develop
Very well explained. People of Maharashtra are very much interested in development now. People have watch on each and every new project, where new firms go, in which state they invest. Mumbai is our crown and politicians are really under pressure to maintain that crown. So many infrastructure projects are currently going on in Mumbai. Due to trans harbour link hinterland is connected to Mumbai and lands have low rates as compare to mumbai. Many new projects will be in New Mumbai. Maharashtra has just announced new IT Policy to make navi mumbai IT HUB. Also maharashta gov has established M Hub like T HUB of Telangana. New MITRA foundation is also very much Intresting to
I'm from MH but I admit that Mumbai was never been a Financial Center Except the Forced shift in British rule and last 75yrs. The Financial Centers of Ancient Bharat Were Always been from Gujarat i.e Surat or from UP and Bihar i.e Ancient Kingdoms of Magadh and Kosala and the Old things always tends to shift to their Original Place like Our Bharat is Regaining It's Lost Glory Therefore it's bound to happen with Mumbai
Good to reduce burden on overcrowded, land scarce, over expensive Mumbai...Clean up the slums and make the city liveable to human life...Thanks to GJ and GIFT city on taking lead with reducing load on Mumbai
India Semicon Mission 2023 is being held in Gandhinagar, Gujarat from July 28 to July 30 and more than 10 major Semicon companies of the world are coming.
Having multiple economic centers is better. Mumbai will be dominant with bse,nse and rbi. Gift city can have ifsc Delhi Bengaluru and other cities can dominate in banking , IT , automotive and other electronic+ semiconductor manufacturing.
Bombay(Mumbai) will remain a big economy in the coming decades too. But it has reached its peak from the point of view from population to spaces, Mumbai doesn't have enough space and people to sustain every thing. Growth should be done from delhi-Jaipur-Ahemdabad-Mumbai-Bengluru, this way india will be having multiple growth and industrial centers.
Namaste Bhai, Gujrat, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu are most richest states in india and they have 3 to 4 large cities and they developing the cities in equally (like 1)GJ has Amdavad, Surat ,Vadodara &rajkot 2)MH has Mumbai , Pune, Nagpur & Ch.Sambhaji Nagar 3( TN Has Chennai Covai Madurai &Trichy , Karnataka also in the list but has only large city Bengaluru. Karnataka & Other states also follow this and every state should make this happen 3 to 4 cities grow equally in state and Boost their economy . What's Your view on this?❤ #askPT
This won't replace Mumbai, Bangalore, Hyderabad or gurgaon To attract services industry you need humans resources and it's hard to attract talent to gujrat that's just the fact you can check with any recruiter Genz will be backbone of workforce and they won't live in a city with zero social life and restrictions put in place by boomers
Hmmm don't compare this upcoming city with ur Hyderabad Mumbai. I visited these cities and let me tell u one thing, let's forgot that Mumbai, Hyderabad is not even capable of giving competition to city like Patna from Bihar. I'm never going to visit these Hyderabad city. Shittt streets, horrendous smell near Hussain sagar and even rest of area's. Shittttt people who don't even know how to eat. Have you even visited that fucking area near char minar?? And Mumbai is the capital of slums and can't even give competition to city like jakarta. Feel shame for ur cities.
Gujarat Manufacturing mein hi aagey badhegi, skill & High skill Service industry grow karna mushkil hain kyunki Dry State, Non veg, Clubs, Nightlife inn sab cheez ki bje se IT professional & IT Company GUj choose nahi karenge. Gift city abhi 25 saal aur lagengey grow karne mein.
Good to reduce burden on overcrowded, land scarce, over expensive Mumbai...Clean up the slums and make the city liveable to human life...Thanks to GJ and GIFT city on taking lead with reducing load on Mumbai
For the first time in life I have seen sensible and positive maharastrian crowd in comment section. Otherwise they are always be like gujarat this, gujarat that. In a real life too they are rude and always criticize other. Glad to see these people here who are sensible.
One point should be noted is GIFT was thought and developed for exact same reason what it is being now. Main reason it was nit picking up quickly before 2014 was because central gov of Congress was not supporting it as it needed changes in some laws. Idea, innovation & vision was created by GIFT like 15 years ago, if it is given to Mumbai than it would be injustice to GIFT, you can’t just steal idea of other city or government and give it to different city (Mumbai). While if Mumbai really wanted this to be created as international financial hub, it would have done 15 years back, as GIFT is new city from Scratch while Mumbai already had infrastructure.
My Town Nautanwa ( 273164 ) dont even have direct connectivity to my state capital Lucknow.. We have to travel 45 km to nearest station to catch train and at night we have to travel 3 hrs early because we dont get buses at night.
hmm,you mean Anand Nagar,hona to chiye Sonauli tk but major railway stations nhi he to nhi chlti wha tk.Waise bhi humlog ka district hi itna developed he ki ajj tk Maharajganj me hi railway line nhi bnawa paya BJP ke sansad hone ke baad bhi bus btte .Ab sb Yogi baba ke hth me he jo Gkp se kbhi chutti paye to syd Maharajganj pr bhi dhyan de.
@@abhishekmaurya6352 gkp se itna train chalta hai koi train to nautanwa se chalaa de agar gkp 10 baje chalti thi to nautanwa se 8 30 pe chala de timing bhi nahi change hoha
Mumbai ko develope krke bhi kuch nhi ho sakta kyu ki Mumbai Mai bohot slums, hygiene problem gande street's aur logo ka lifestyle bohot ghatiya hai. Rather than Mumbai we can invest in upcoming cities. Like a gift city it's a good one. I agree with the government. And btw I'm from Maharashtra born in the Marathi family.
The problem with Mumbai is that Mumbai only develops the Mumbai area instead of its Metropolitan area . Delhi developed it's Satellite towns too, unlike Mumbai Metropolitan Region is mostly underdeveloped compared to Mumbai. Mumbai only focused on Mumbai instead of its Metropolitan region such as Thane , Navi Mumbai, other satellite towns .
@@aniketmahajan8422dude i have visited Delhi too and let me tell you one thing Delhi has some problems of slums and water itself in its main area. Like Mumbai, Delhi should avoid that problem. I don't understand why the government gives fucking permission to people to build there slums in main cities. This creates a bad impression on India. And Foreigners like to visit such areas and they should make some decisions like china. In china u can't enter in bad areas. They Strictly ban foreigners from entering and shooting in such areas.
Dry state and harsh climate of gujrat are the major reason that nobody wants to work there, my L&T office shifted there 4 years back. Almost 80℅ engineers left and came back to mumbai.
Gift city is necessary in India. It is not competing with Mumbai but creating its own market where it is needed. The reason is very simple. In India if any foreign entity like NRI or FII want to invest in India, there are a lot of regulatory burden plus most foreign entity have to pay a lot of charges if they invest directly in Mumbai. Sometimes upward of 30%. Because of which making investment in India is not viable for them. This is the reason most NRI and FII uses Mauritius to setup there office to invest in India. But then Indian government does not get tax on investment made from Mauritius and there is no accounting of whose money it is. To solve this issue a new city is created which act as Special Economic Zone (SEZ) for financial services to foreign entity. Which does not have old regulation that apply to Mumbai. And since every foreign entity have to register in India itself. It will bring more transparency, accountability and will reduce stock manipulation and fraud.
Haan har state m ek aisi city honi chahiye fii NRI invest online ni kr sakte hum forex m invest ni karsakte ye nautanki pura scam hai ye apki koi vote ni milega bjp ko
Forget about International danka if we can't even tolerate our nation's development then why you're proud to be Indian? Just be proud to be a Mumbaikar, Delhiite or Bangalorian?
Good news....let mumbai breathe. I am a local guy and my heart aches to see Mumbai die under the burden of influx of ppl, uncleanliness, overcrowding, traffic woes, let Mumbai rest a bit.
अच्छा ही है मुंबई अपनी क्षमता से ज्यादा भार झेल रही है शहर में बहुत सी समस्याएं जन्म ले रहीं हैं उसका भार कम करने और संतुलन स्थापित करने के लिए भारत में कयी नगरों को स्थापित करना ही चाहिए महाराष्ट्र का पूणे और नवी मुंबई से थोड़ी राहत तो है और भविष्य में नैना सिटी भी बन जाएगी और भारत को विकसित राष्ट्र घोषित कराने के लिए मुंबई जैसे कयी आर्थिक समृद्ध नगरों को अस्तित्व में आना जरूरी है। चारों महानगरों (मुंबई, दिल्ली, कोलकाता, चेन्नई)के आस पास के शहरों का तेज़ी से विकास करना चाहिए।
Why do some individuals in Maharashtra, particularly in Mumbai, harbour resentment when other regions of India experience growth? There seems to be frustration with the government in Maharashtra, with accusations of incompetence and blame-shifting. What drives this attitude, and how can we foster a more constructive dialogue for the betterment of the entire nation
It would be gift no one wants 😂😂😂😂. Mumbai took 200+ years my friend to get at this stage. It’s hard for companies to shift their purchased offices. Also connectivity is just incredible.
Mumbai needs the Shanghai treatment. Demolition of the 1970-2000 built, dilapidated structures. For that, property values must fall temporarily, allowing investors to sweep in, purchase the lots and redevelop the city.
Gujarat is being continuously upgraded to attract business since 25 years, at this juncture gujarat ecosystem provides everthing that a business need to smoothly function. Thus inturn businesses prefer such ecosystem.
@@hello_1456 😂bro metro to vaise hi aani thi bcz of need to metro cities .... Highways ki baat kare to dusre Big states ke mukalble bahut kam Highways he MH me ...Jaise UP , gujrat me large number of Highways he & even railway routes
Even CHINA (144 crore population) have two major financial capital/ centre/ stock exchanges namely SHANGHAI and SHENZHEN and recently they start BEIJING STOCK EXCHANGE and have to mention they indirectly control of HONGKONG which already well known IFSC 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Though i am Marathi manoos i dont have problem with multiple financial centre across country. Only Competition can give satisfactory results not monopoly of one city/ entity.
Mumbai shouldn’t complain they should make themselves more competent because even if we see the history as well, economic capital of country keeps changing weather it’s from Bengal to Mumbai and now from Mumbai to somewhere else but Mumbai still have few years to buckle up and get ready to give a healthy competition 😎🙌🔥
Mumbai population is more than 2.5 cr which is more than Australia County population 5 rs bus service 10 rs local train service except property rate every thing is affordable in Mumbai
@@hussainsadriwala8845 Using a 10rs train to go to my closet sized apartment isn't really life. Builders and property owners are exploiting the people and native MH people can't even afford it.
Freeing congestion from Mumbai, is beneficial for Mumbai. Historically Mumbai is not the economic hub in ancient Bharat ,it was Britishers who artificially created it as an economic centre.
@@millennialmind9507 Yes, the Suez made Mumbai and it is the Gulf that is making GIFT. Easy access to ports of a state that is very close to wealthy Gulf countries: Oman, Chahbahar, Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Qatar, Kuwait City.... A speed boat water taxi from Dwarka to Oman is quite easy to see. And then rail from there would take goods into UAE, Qatar, Bahrain and Saudi. Then there is the north-south corridor from Dwarka to Chahbahar, going all the way to Europe by land route.
Sir, Apne video ke Last me Jo baat kahi ki Mumbai over burden ho chuki hai ye sch hai. I m from Mumbai.And more and more people are increasing in the population of Mumbai. And i think to reduce this burden this is good step. But one thing all should accept no one city can replace Mumbai.
I don't agree with this video. It means that all other states should stop making any efforts to attract investors, and everyone should invest in Mumbai only. Investing in one state does not mean it is a loss of other states. We need 10 Mumbai like cities and our country would become prosperous. Saying that all investments should be made in one state is foolish.
Those states which provides better infrastructure and policies to attract investment and job's will prosper. Unfortunately,only southern and western states are doing well to attract investment. North India states, such as Himachal Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh is trying to attract investment rest is not doing good. Eastern states such as West Bengal and Assam and jharkhand and Orissa is also need to do lot's.
It's about coasts and states with ports are always preferred. But if those states can be linked via WDFC and EDFC like you see happening with UP now, things will fly. UP is geared to become the manufacturing capital of India.
Business tycoons don't setup offices on emotional decisions. They are going to Gujarat because their government is providing better offers. Atleast they have stable government since 23 years. Result of which they have made ordinary businessmen to billionaires. Maharashtra has highest GDP but major industrialists are gujaratis only.
Mumbai ko financial capital bhi Gujarati banaya he... yee bat koi naa nahi kahe sakta.. or marathi log or maharashtra ko uska fyada hua.... marathi people should thankful to Gujaratis for this
It’s not hurting Mumbai…. Mumbai is overloaded. Need other cities to step up to help mumbai to reduce load… Glad that gift city and Pune are one of those helping hands
💯
Pune help karte karte khud jam ho gaya gain ab...I cannot see the difference between Mumbai and Pune now..😅 Pune traffic is worst after Bengaluru in India...many IT companies from Pune finding alternatives such as Hyderabad, Nagpur... Pune authorities should take actions asap to resolve traffic issue
@@shramdeepasawale9900 as guy who lives in Gujarat, I didn’t know traffic of pune.. mismatched public transit is issue everywhere … here in Ahmedabad - metro/brts/amts works separately instead of working as one unit to provide last mile connectivity…
@@shramdeepasawale9900 metro station should he brts/amts bus terminal and single tickets for all. So people can use all 3 type of services in mix so they get encouraged to use public transit
@@shramdeepasawale9900 because pune have worst roads. No one single roads good in pune
I'm gujrati but I don't think that mumbai will replace by other city
Gift city's aim is different it's not hurting mumbai's financial status
& even navi mumbai is challenging mumbai
Mumbai is a piece of shitttt
Lots of slums, dirty crowd
Unhygienic nature
Shitttt street's
It's not hurting but it's removing burden on Mumbai 😊
@@bot_nemetronicus exactly bro as a mumbaikar i can understand
Mumbai will always be worthy no 1 city of India richest financial commercial City of India
@@dmcindianfan5374yhhhh with lots of slums and shittt streets. Mumbai great
honestly, we need more cities like gift so that people dont overcrowd mumbai.
Mumbai is just shitttt and foreigners don't give damn on Mumbai Because it's just fucking crowd with lot's of slums unhygienic nature and crowded locals ewwww.
As a Mumbaikar I am saying this. Lol. Whole india india will develop bt not mumbai. Without min wage nothing going to change in mumbai. In mumbai people live becuz of slums as they are cheapest in whole india. If u remove slums whole cheap laboroures will leave mumbai. And all retail shops and restaurants will start booking losses😂😂in india Businessman don't share their profit to their employees. Just take example of mumbai. In mumbai there are many retail shops and restaurant and movie production houses. And u will see most laboroures or gig job workers who work their are either relatives of them or up, bihari and Bangladeshis. They hire rhem cuz they work in cheap salaries. hence in mumbai slum population is increasing and now uts upto 55%. Where 40% Bangladeshis, 28% up and bihair and 15% south indians living. Becuz of cheap laboroures all local people whether they are marathi or gujju, marwari or sindhi or parsi who were living since mumbai formed are either have to choose white collar jobs, do business or go abroad. Businessman are main problem of this country. Cuz they dont share high salary to employees. Second problem is overpopulation done by up, bihari and peaceful community. In mumbai slums and especially in bihari and Bangladeshis area u will see parents having 3-4 kids. Mumbai has most poor people in whole country. And they live in slums cuz living in slum is cheapest. In slums they have 5-6 k rent and they share with 5-7 members. And no tax and other maintenance. In building of 1rk min rent is 15 k with maintenance and election and other taxes
@@sankkhamwow bro. I love people who admit their place's situation. Also great observation. Mumbai will eventually lose to other cities because of high prices. Even navi mumbai will give tough competition to mumbai. According to me that's good because we need more cities like mumbai so that it will be less crowded. Atleast 50 cities should have that calliber. Imagine 50 cities like mumbai. India will become great again
@madhuarahinde : U r absolutely ryt saying 👍
@@mayankbhardwaj550 u still didn't get. Mumbai is cheapest city if anyone lives in slums. No city in india can replace Mumbai cuz no city has cheap labour like mumbai. I work as ad and director in bollywood. And here for labour jobs and Jr artist not a single Mumbaikar is there. Cuz all migrants work with cheap salaries, 12-15 hrs and without any facilities or insurance. They work cuz most live in slums where u don't need good salary to survive. Mumbai's population is lesser than all metro cities in india if u calculate people who live in legal houses. In mumbai illegal slum population is high. Businesses earn more profit in mumbai due to slum population. as people who live their can afford to work with 10-15 k salary. Ambani, adani, godrej, tata etc have many private properties and there slum exist. They never even tried to remove slums on their private land. Cuz all Buisnesmen want cheap labour. In 90s Mumbai's slum population was 33%. In 2010 it was 43%. Now it's 55%. Govn also helping Businesses to grow slums due to cheap laboroures. More than that. After kolkata mumbai has most Bangladeshis in india. And the more Bangladeshis means more slums and illegal crimes.
I think it's nice to have multiple economical cities instead of just one
Mumbai should build one too.
Trueeee!!
@@-rate6326 Mumbai space km h
Yes we should have many Mumbai like cities in every state so that middle class don't have to migrate and face problems and exploitation by people of that state.
@@ayushind27then it should built in Navi Mumbai or other parts of Maharashtra
no matter who gets investment till its in INDIA. Proud to see India is growing.
Yeah increasing regionalism instead of Nationalism among some people is very dangerous
@@Indian_RajputIt is happening because of not giving people liberty.
Like If I say I am proud to Hindu doesn't makes me anti Indian or saying proud to be Gujarati either
You are saying this most probably because you are not from Mumbai. Mumbai future is looking dark under Gujarat Janta Party who are running their govt in the name of Indian govt. Everything is going to Gujarat and even the future semi conductor will be build there. You know what? Even they building largest Film City to attract Bollywood to Noida NCR. Mumbai will left with nothing. Financial and Entertainment capital of India tags will go to some other cities. Gujarat Janta Party is only developing Gujarat
@@Hello-kh6bkyes these don't understand anything they are living in dreams they don't understand the situation
@@Hello-kh6bk first of all Noida is not in Gujarat and Hindi film industry should be in a Hindi speaking state. On one hand you guys want everyone to speak Marathi in Mumbai and on the other hand you also want the Hindi entertainment industry in Mumbai. Bunch of hypocrites.
Both Maharashtra and Gujarat doing very well for our country. Love from West Bengal ❤🇮🇳
I wish kolkata te o eram kichu hoto...sigh
The talent & resource pool in India needs 10 Mumbai-like Cities😮
I think Gujarat and Ahmedabad earned GIFT city under CM Modi even before BJP came to power. Its good to have more than 1 financial city. Mumbai still gets more branches by fintech companies instead of GIFT. Mumbai’s Metro will further make it even more attractive. Kudos for Gujaratis for their Business model. India to achieve a 10 trillion dollar economy and beyond, such IFSCs even outside of Mumbai are important. Gift will still get political backing for at least another 5 years under BJP
There won’t be more than 1 financial Center. There will always be 1 financial centre. I hope Mumbai don’t become Kolkata
Its okay for Mumbai-GIFT to be dual hubs after a decade or so.
OR
It will also be fine if Mumbai serves its purpose well and then pass on the financial mantel to another city.
Overuse of every region is fatal. Like what we did in Punjab during the green and white revolution.
Now all Punjabis giving up farming and moving to Can Aus US
Also, if one notices a very bizzare phenomenon- many of the financial and infrastructure projects are halted in India no matter which city they're in.
Halted then started then halted again.
Many of it is State-Centre and/or State1-State2 power struggle.
BUT many NGOs also play a BIGGG role in knocking the train off its tracks.
Only a few handful of them are genuine, while the other (NGOs) are actually foreign-funded. Especially by a certain colonizer.
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
Gift has many tax exemptions
We need atleast 50 new high tech cities in long term because we are seeing mass migration in cities
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
GIFT City is going to change worlds perspective towards India
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
*Im from Finance Field Senior Team Bengaluru,,, Gujarat Gift City Job & Work is Based on Singapore,,,(Currencey work etc) Where is Mumbai Work is Based on South Indian Companies,,, I Don't Think there is even 10% Similarity,,, its like Buying Laptop or TV,, Both Look same work is differ (Even, Thanks to that All Giant Gujarati BUsiness men,,, Relience, Amul, Wipro Long List,, No one is From Maharastra*
Its better that economics is not centre to just one city and is really good that Maharashtra wants to compete with gujrat
Nice joke mh wants to compete with GJ 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
GJ wants to compete MH not vice Versa
@@erwinsmith5796 Gujarat per capita income>>>
@@erwinsmith5796Gujrat does not have centred economy like mh Gujrat economy is spreaded all over the state, whereas if you remove Mumbai from mh,nothing much wil remain
@@bot_nemetronicus read again my previous comment
@@erwinsmith5796 yes mh wants to compete with gj
china has like 10 financial centre with gdp same or more than mumbai...india needs that too
India needs a LOT more things than just GDP.
The question is, does India have what it takes to make it.
Mumbai honestly is big brother in finance as such. Mumbai is unique as it is like NewYork of India. Ahmedabad is like younger brother to Mumbai. It will take at least 25 years for Ahmedabad to reach to level of Mumbai seen today. By that time Mumbai will be already a established world city. We have to be realistic about fantasy vs reality.
Mumbai will remain a focal point but GIFT is about leveraging location. The ports all around Saurashtra connecting directly to Gulf countries are the major factor here. An insane amount of ports are accelerating their development. It is going unnoticed because people are more interested in trains and expressways. New York developed due to it also being on the Atlantic trade route from Europe. If they can set up a high speed water taxi or underwater rail from Okha to Oman, that can change the destiny of both India and West Asia.
Why do you think only these two cities wil devlop Maharashtra also have Mumbai and Pune and nagpur too they will also devlop in 15 year@divyeshpatel2463
Partiality and pampering going on towards gujuland...@divyeshpatel2463
Thanks for realising this. Maharashtra government should focus on building a business district like that in navi mumbai with wide roads and all modern amenities and not allow people to build slums close to it. Mumbai is losing its sheen because of unchecked slums popping up everywhere. I don't know why the Maharashtra government isn't thinking about it but there should be something like the times square nyc in navi mumbai.
💯 maharastra should also focous on other cities more rather than mumbai and should make them economical strong.
@@Vishesh.077well said bro. Maharashtra doesn't mean only mumbai and pune. Vidarbha region is most bakcward region in country still govt is always biased towards west Maharashtra. Govt should make big projects on cities like Nagpur, Sambhaji Nagar, Wardha, Solapur
Vote ka Chakar hai babu भैया slum ka Kuchh na hoga
Kharghar business district
@@maxnorris9441More such districts. Also a times square.
In Mumbai you have to pay Rs 25000/- rent for 310 sq ft flat and travel to work in overcrowded train. GIFT city will reduce the population leading to lower rents and reduce overcrowding in train. Mumbaikar will benefit the most from GIFT city. Only builder lobby will loose as they will not be able to sell their flats at exorbitant price to helpless home buyers as people can instead choose to settle in GIFT city instead.
Finance is a high leverage industry you don't need that many people per unit of economic activity. If you want to reduce train rush, finance is the last sector you should Target.
@@lhxperimental It's the peripheral population that follows (labor and slums) that makes it unbearable now.
Time for Maharashtra govt to develop Navi Mumbai and Pune to its best capacity
I would also like to add one more thing. Instead of making our cities like Paris, Singapore, Shenzen, Beijing, Tokyo, Shangai, Guangzhou, and California, we should make plans that suit over needs. Every city in Bharat is different and every city requires a different set of solutions. What made Singapore that things may not work in cities like Bengaluru, Mumbai, Chennai. My extended family lives in Bengaluru and I visit Bengaluru 2-3 times a year. I will say that govt had plans to make Bengaluru equivalent to Dubai but those plans never worked both in the tenure of the BJP and Congress.
Yes but aesthetic projects ke time pe hum sab jaante hai ki political pressures boht hote hai
Bhai nhi banne aLa bharat will always look village 😢😅
@@desiqueen695ek baar village dikhe toh bhi chlega lekin koi bhi city ya village jakr chaos nhi lagna chahiye jeise mumbai me lagta hay
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
@@nilaypatel1971 not really, western aesthetic is better
Gift cities will benefit Mumbai in long term. Landprices are skyrocketing in Mumbai, A commonman can't buy a flat near office place, people have to travel 100 km daily for workplaces. There is hardly any place in Mumbai to develop new business districts except Godrej land and Eastern suburbs
ICICI Bank Ltd has shifted its registered headquarters from Vadodara to Mumbai.experts in corporate governance told that one major consequence of shifting the bank’s registered office from Vadodara to Mumbai is that ICICI Bank will now pay its corporate income tax in Mumbai, increasing Maharashtra’s share in central taxes collected from states. Stamp duty on large corporate loans will also be paid in Maharashtra as these loans will be registered here. In addition, the bank’s annual general meetings (AGMs) will now be held in Mumbai.😅
Because finance professionals do not want to work in a dry state like Gujarat. The Central Government is just pushing the gift City. Without them this city will fail.
@@DannycageGhostrider Yes my friend but they have not shifted the office physically, only registration addres will be mumbai and corporate tax will be paid to Maharashtra.
*We Should Think as a indian,,, Im from Delhi,, We Know that 70% Business Turn over done by Gujarati Giant Business men in india,, Its Choice of Gujarati Business men to Where to invest,, Tell me 1 name of Famous Giant Marathi Business men,, No one,,Majority Business gift by Gujarati & Marvadi, Jay hind, Be Indian,,*
@@nilaypatel1971 ऐ दिल है मुश्किल जीना यहाँ ज़रा हट के, ज़रा बच के ,ये है Bombay मेरी जाँ
*Im from Finance Field Senior Team Bengaluru,,, Gujarat Gift City Job & Work is Based on Singapore,,,(Currencey work etc) Where is Mumbai Work is Based on South Indian Companies,,, I Don't Think there is even 10% Similarity,,, its like Buying Laptop or TV,, Both Look same work is differ (Even, Thanks to that All Giant Gujarati BUsiness men,,, Relience, Amul, Wipro Long List,, No one is From Maharastra*
Thank you so much for this video on gift city power train. GIFT City will take india on a global international financial standing. Its important for India's development.🇮🇳🇮🇳
Time keeps on changing. First there was Kolkata, then there was Mumbai, and now it will be Gujarat.
We need to develop 50 major cities to share the overburden on few cities.
Kolkata ! Kuulkata😂
Kolkata was destroyed by communist and for some reason Bengalis keep voting for them
It's Kolkata 😅😂
We need to develop north india
I am from Mumbai but i believe the motive is totally different and the gift is for international companies and Mumbai was never a financial centre but you can see wholesale companies in Mumbai
GIFT CITY BEST HAI 😊
@@31davidwarnergift City worst hai. Companies gift city me isiliye ja rahe kyunki koi dusra IFSC nahi Hai jis din ek dusra IFSC ban gaya sari companies use dry state ko chhodkar bhagenge😂
@@31davidwarner should merge Delhi and up Delhi ke pass jameen nahin hai aur up ke pass Paisa nahi Hai agar donon state sath mei a gaye to baval Ho jaega
@@DannycageGhostrider gift city Navi mumbai is honkong Singapore etc all tax maaf heaven
@@DannycageGhostrider NCR ke bahut se cities up mai he hai. Merge ki jagah NCR region ko expand karna chahiye
I don't think the GIFT city is replacing Mumbai it's an alternative of Mumbai
We should try to spread development all over India not in only one city👍
Mumbai is nothing but a piece of shitttt
It's shameful for us that it is a part of india. Poor people live there streets are fucked up and main point is the backward people live in shitttt like slums. It's the financial capital of India and we still see slums more than skyscrapers.
It's very important,that maharashtra government wakes up from it's sleep , and designate , Navi Mumbai as a special economic zone , cut down taxes and if possible copy GIFT city model
It is actually important. Also political stability , which right. Ow Maharashtra do not have .
@@train_xc exactly, political stability is also an issue
ha bro, ye sab bhutnike politicians madrachod sale
There should be multiple International Finance Centres accross India....
I don't like comparison videos of Indian cities but I kind of agree with this. If Mumbai doesn't improve itself then I won't be surprised when GIFT City will be called the financial capital of India Just look at Kolkata. In spite of being 3rd largest city in India how the government policies have destroyed that city. It is hard to believe Kolkata was once the capital city of India even though it was during British India but it was still a big city. Now -a- days it hardly comes in news.
Kolkata is still a big city....see kolkata is not like other city...means it's not like kolkata is not developed it doesn't mean kolkata don't have any company....it means kolkata don't have that much fdi investment and other global product base companies.....there is also a fintech hub establishing in kolkata...but its unable to attract global attention....
@@adityabanerjee0244seeing the condition of democracy in Bengal it would be shocking if even someone thinks about investing there😅
@peternolan6409 yes in bengal there should be rastrapati rules...
Jyada kolkata kolkata mat koro. Pura Wb, bihar, up main area ke hisab se population bohut jyada hai. Ihape bara industry nahi ho sakta koi jamin nahi dega
@@CHINMOYGAMING bihar ka Pata nahi...up ka to hoga ....west bengal ka vi hoga lekin paise Jeb me ghuser ne k baad...
This is great! The amount investments Gift city will bring into India will be highly valuable. Besides, we should have competition among our cities too! But that is only beneficial if state governments also decide to compete with each other and try to develop the best cities instead of just accepting defeat and letting other cities grow way past them. It will be a problem for developed place as well as just like places like Mumbai and Bengaluru, gift cities will become over populated as well.
Hope gift city will get the crown of financial centre.I think so every year by year every state should get the chance of financial centre so it will be help to develop India easily
organic growth 💯🔥
Maharashtra shasan 🇮🇳
Dont say gift city is threat to Mumbai. Gift city is competetion to Mumbai. Both will vie for investment, in the process will better facilities to investors. Competetion is good
Not a threat.
Maharashtra is richer than gujrat in terms of GDP.
But condition of farmers in Maharashtra is more critical than gujrat.
Just because
Gujraties are business minded and less engaged in agriculture.
And more workforce engaged in manufacturing, industrial and services sector.
Were,
Amul, and green revolution helps to uplifting the good condition of Gujarat farmer's
Maharashtra have govt. Owned JNPT.
But Gujarat have privately owned Mega Mundra Port,
But Mundra Port have seamless cargo handling capacity then JNPT.
Gdp per capita of Gujarat>>Maharashtra
@@hello_1456ecause mumbai is the oldest metropolitan in india. So mumbai attracted a lot below poverty line people in india. Which came here and built slums. Gujrat has had a gradual well thought out development which mumbai never had. So more people from poor backgrounds came to Mumbai. So gujarat having a better gdp per capita is a no brainer.
@@doge3436what bullshit.
The people living in slums in Mumbai are better off than the below poverty line people in the rest of the states
@@hello_1456but poverty index of gujrat is 19% while Maharashtra is 13% so wealth distribution in Maharashtra is more optimal
@@hello_1456Gujarat is a dry state and without Government support give City will never became a financial hub
Economic, industrial, banking and financial institutions should not be concerned in a single city. For the development of nation it should scattered in different cities and parts. Mumbai is highly concentrated city .
Gift city will help India to establish an international financial hub between Dubai and Singapore. Second it will help rich Indians to establish their office in gift city instead of migrating to the west, Singapore or Dubai. The desired goals are not yet achieved but tale tale signs are visible now after almost a decade. Hope it’ll thrive and support mumbai and establish India in international financial markets.
I too believe cities like mumbai, Bangalore are becoming extremely crowded and chaotic, hence to shift its burden to other cities would bring a positive change and also such cities will also develop
Very well explained. People of Maharashtra are very much interested in development now.
People have watch on each and every new project, where new firms go, in which state they invest. Mumbai is our crown and politicians are really under pressure to maintain that crown. So many infrastructure projects are currently going on in Mumbai.
Due to trans harbour link hinterland is connected to Mumbai and lands have low rates as compare to mumbai. Many new projects will be in New Mumbai. Maharashtra has just announced new IT Policy to make navi mumbai IT HUB. Also maharashta gov has established M Hub like T HUB of Telangana.
New MITRA foundation is also very much Intresting to
Good to see investment coming to india, whether it goes to gift city or mumbai...
I'm from MH but I admit that Mumbai was never been a Financial Center Except the Forced shift in British rule and last 75yrs. The Financial Centers of Ancient Bharat Were Always been from Gujarat i.e Surat or from UP and Bihar i.e Ancient Kingdoms of Magadh and Kosala and the Old things always tends to shift to their Original Place like Our Bharat is Regaining It's Lost Glory Therefore it's bound to happen with Mumbai
U forgot South India
@@31davidwarnerthey don't have that much knowledge on ancient southern India
Good to reduce burden on overcrowded, land scarce, over expensive Mumbai...Clean up the slums and make the city liveable to human life...Thanks to GJ and GIFT city on taking lead with reducing load on Mumbai
Surat was the Major Trade Hub Before Mumbai even existed!!
You got your facts correct!
You are from gujrat and you are using a fake name come from real Id then talk ?
Gift and dholera is going to be big deal i hope ❤
India Semicon Mission 2023 is being held in Gandhinagar, Gujarat from July 28 to July 30 and more than 10 major Semicon companies of the world are coming.
Having multiple economic centers is better.
Mumbai will be dominant with bse,nse and rbi.
Gift city can have ifsc
Delhi Bengaluru and other cities can dominate in banking , IT , automotive and other electronic+ semiconductor manufacturing.
Bombay(Mumbai) will remain a big economy in the coming decades too. But it has reached its peak from the point of view from population to spaces, Mumbai doesn't have enough space and people to sustain every thing. Growth should be done from delhi-Jaipur-Ahemdabad-Mumbai-Bengluru, this way india will be having multiple growth and industrial centers.
Namaste Bhai, Gujrat, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu are most richest states in india and they have 3 to 4 large cities and they developing the cities in equally (like 1)GJ has Amdavad, Surat ,Vadodara &rajkot 2)MH has Mumbai , Pune, Nagpur & Ch.Sambhaji Nagar 3( TN Has Chennai Covai Madurai &Trichy , Karnataka also in the list but has only large city Bengaluru. Karnataka & Other states also follow this and every state should make this happen 3 to 4 cities grow equally in state and Boost their economy . What's Your view on this?❤ #askPT
Places like TN don't boost economy. Period.
They boost their women's gold reserves.
Belgaum Mangalore Mysore are big city of Karnataka Karnataka is also developed like Gujarat
@@abhishek4702 No bro, Karnataka Government Only Focus Bengaluru Development
For a country like India with 1.4 billion people , we need more that atleast 100 cities like Mumbai and Delhi .
This won't replace Mumbai, Bangalore, Hyderabad or gurgaon
To attract services industry you need humans resources and it's hard to attract talent to gujrat that's just the fact you can check with any recruiter
Genz will be backbone of workforce and they won't live in a city with zero social life and restrictions put in place by boomers
Hmmm don't compare this upcoming city with ur Hyderabad Mumbai. I visited these cities and let me tell u one thing, let's forgot that Mumbai, Hyderabad is not even capable of giving competition to city like Patna from Bihar. I'm never going to visit these Hyderabad city. Shittt streets, horrendous smell near Hussain sagar and even rest of area's. Shittttt people who don't even know how to eat. Have you even visited that fucking area near char minar?? And Mumbai is the capital of slums and can't even give competition to city like jakarta. Feel shame for ur cities.
True dat
Gujarat Manufacturing mein hi aagey badhegi, skill & High skill Service industry grow karna mushkil hain kyunki Dry State, Non veg, Clubs, Nightlife inn sab cheez ki bje se IT professional & IT Company GUj choose nahi karenge. Gift city abhi 25 saal aur lagengey grow karne mein.
Such competitions are good for the development of the country
Nice presentation, Mumbai is definitely overgrown city, however Finance & Film Industries should remain Mumbai’s prerogative
bharat jaisa badha market mei koi ek centre nehi ho sakta..
Good to reduce burden on overcrowded, land scarce, over expensive Mumbai...Clean up the slums and make the city liveable to human life...Thanks to GJ and GIFT city on taking lead with reducing load on Mumbai
Back to back informative unique and banger vids 💪🏻salute to you
For the first time in life I have seen sensible and positive maharastrian crowd in comment section. Otherwise they are always be like gujarat this, gujarat that. In a real life too they are rude and always criticize other. Glad to see these people here who are sensible.
India is a very big country we can't depend on only one financial and economical center, like in China they have shanghai, shenzen, hong- kong
One point should be noted is GIFT was thought and developed for exact same reason what it is being now. Main reason it was nit picking up quickly before 2014 was because central gov of Congress was not supporting it as it needed changes in some laws. Idea, innovation & vision was created by GIFT like 15 years ago, if it is given to Mumbai than it would be injustice to GIFT, you can’t just steal idea of other city or government and give it to different city (Mumbai). While if Mumbai really wanted this to be created as international financial hub, it would have done 15 years back, as GIFT is new city from Scratch while Mumbai already had infrastructure.
My Town Nautanwa ( 273164 ) dont even have direct connectivity to my state capital Lucknow..
We have to travel 45 km to nearest station to catch train and at night we have to travel 3 hrs early because we dont get buses at night.
Jb district headquarters Maharajganj me railway station hi nhi bna Aaj tk to or khi ki to baat hi choro😅😅
@@abhishekmaurya6352 ha nautanwa me hai , par nautanwa se train chalwane ka koi kharcha nahi aayega bas gkp se train to backward extend krna hai.
hmm,you mean Anand Nagar,hona to chiye Sonauli tk but major railway stations nhi he to nhi chlti wha tk.Waise bhi humlog ka district hi itna developed he ki ajj tk Maharajganj me hi railway line nhi bnawa paya BJP ke sansad hone ke baad bhi bus btte .Ab sb Yogi baba ke hth me he jo Gkp se kbhi chutti paye to syd Maharajganj pr bhi dhyan de.
@@abhishekmaurya6352 gkp se itna train chalta hai koi train to nautanwa se chalaa de agar gkp 10 baje chalti thi to nautanwa se 8 30 pe chala de timing bhi nahi change hoha
@@praveentripathi9114 baat to shi he but koi kaam nhi Krna apne DM ko baith ke paise pelne se fursat mile tb na kuch kre.
Exactly GiFt city is going to be leader in global finance.
Maharashtra government is sleeping, copy GIFT city model to the T in Navi Mumbai , provide similar benefit and show up some competition
Navi mumbai alrady have it
Navi mumbai alrady have it
Mumbai ko develope krke bhi kuch nhi ho sakta kyu ki Mumbai Mai bohot slums, hygiene problem gande street's aur logo ka lifestyle bohot ghatiya hai. Rather than Mumbai we can invest in upcoming cities. Like a gift city it's a good one. I agree with the government. And btw I'm from Maharashtra born in the Marathi family.
Bhai navi mumbai bhi development ho rahi hai.
@@doge3436Navi Mumbai will never going to give a tough competition to cities like New York, Tokyo , hong kong, and Shanghai.
The problem with Mumbai is that Mumbai only develops the Mumbai area instead of its Metropolitan area . Delhi developed it's Satellite towns too, unlike Mumbai Metropolitan Region is mostly underdeveloped compared to Mumbai. Mumbai only focused on Mumbai instead of its Metropolitan region such as Thane , Navi Mumbai, other satellite towns .
@@aniketmahajan8422dude i have visited Delhi too and let me tell you one thing Delhi has some problems of slums and water itself in its main area. Like Mumbai, Delhi should avoid that problem. I don't understand why the government gives fucking permission to people to build there slums in main cities. This creates a bad impression on India. And Foreigners like to visit such areas and they should make some decisions like china. In china u can't enter in bad areas. They Strictly ban foreigners from entering and shooting in such areas.
*Mumbai took business from Kolkata in 1950s*
*Happy to see Gujarat taking business from Mumbai* 💪💪💪💪💪
Mumbai ka wo business bhi Gujarati ka hi he... ghum fir ke Dono side business Gujarati hi karege....
Happy for India, Mumbai will remain relevant
@@sudhir2854 kyu teri nahi he?? ese hi usko bhi gali deta he kya shameless person
People talking about Mumbai while Gujarati have all ready captured new Jersey and new York🗽 🇺🇸🇮🇳
@@sudhir2854 galat to nhi bola bhai most of Indian invester Gujarat se hai
Dry state and harsh climate of gujrat are the major reason that nobody wants to work there, my L&T office shifted there 4 years back. Almost 80℅ engineers left and came back to mumbai.
Lol ,seriously?
@@ashishnair136 nahi kya?
Nobodys talking about the shuddh hindi in his videos? Love it bhai , keep it up 😎😄
👍👍
advance congratulation for 500K subscriber
Gift city is necessary in India. It is not competing with Mumbai but creating its own market where it is needed. The reason is very simple. In India if any foreign entity like NRI or FII want to invest in India, there are a lot of regulatory burden plus most foreign entity have to pay a lot of charges if they invest directly in Mumbai. Sometimes upward of 30%. Because of which making investment in India is not viable for them. This is the reason most NRI and FII uses Mauritius to setup there office to invest in India. But then Indian government does not get tax on investment made from Mauritius and there is no accounting of whose money it is. To solve this issue a new city is created which act as Special Economic Zone (SEZ) for financial services to foreign entity. Which does not have old regulation that apply to Mumbai. And since every foreign entity have to register in India itself. It will bring more transparency, accountability and will reduce stock manipulation and fraud.
Haan har state m ek aisi city honi chahiye fii NRI invest online ni kr sakte hum forex m invest ni karsakte ye nautanki pura scam hai ye apki koi vote ni milega bjp ko
Very nice and Informative video! ❤
Gift city is not prepared
Gujarat ❤
Gujrat 🥣
Forget about International danka if we can't even tolerate our nation's development then why you're proud to be Indian? Just be proud to be a Mumbaikar, Delhiite or Bangalorian?
Good news....let mumbai breathe. I am a local guy and my heart aches to see Mumbai die under the burden of influx of ppl, uncleanliness, overcrowding, traffic woes, let Mumbai rest a bit.
अच्छा ही है मुंबई अपनी क्षमता से ज्यादा भार झेल रही है शहर में बहुत सी समस्याएं जन्म ले रहीं हैं उसका भार कम करने और संतुलन स्थापित करने के लिए भारत में कयी नगरों को स्थापित करना ही चाहिए महाराष्ट्र का पूणे और नवी मुंबई से थोड़ी राहत तो है और भविष्य में नैना सिटी भी बन जाएगी और भारत को विकसित राष्ट्र घोषित कराने के लिए मुंबई जैसे कयी आर्थिक समृद्ध नगरों को अस्तित्व में आना जरूरी है। चारों महानगरों (मुंबई, दिल्ली, कोलकाता, चेन्नई)के आस पास के शहरों का तेज़ी से विकास करना चाहिए।
Mumbai or Gujarat it's all India.
So don't separate this by comparing
Tere jaise unpadh yaha comment kyu karte hai yaar?
@@MARKCRASTO Abe gawar sale tujhe koi bola he kya comment karne ko
right
Why do some individuals in Maharashtra, particularly in Mumbai, harbour resentment when other regions of India experience growth? There seems to be frustration with the government in Maharashtra, with accusations of incompetence and blame-shifting. What drives this attitude, and how can we foster a more constructive dialogue for the betterment of the entire nation
Then give permission for IFSC in BKC, mumbai..
It would be gift no one wants 😂😂😂😂. Mumbai took 200+ years my friend to get at this stage. It’s hard for companies to shift their purchased offices. Also connectivity is just incredible.
Mumbai needs the Shanghai treatment. Demolition of the 1970-2000 built, dilapidated structures. For that, property values must fall temporarily, allowing investors to sweep in, purchase the lots and redevelop the city.
Exactly , natural >>> artificial
Very Good Information 👍......
Reality is central govt largely focus on gujrat 👍,bcz of Modiji & amit Shah are from Gujarat
This project is run by Gujarat govermant when Narendra Modi was the CM of Gujarat this project was announced.
Desh me is waqt har jagah infrastructure ka kaam ho raha hai
Aur wo modi hi kar raha hai
Gujarat is being continuously upgraded to attract business since 25 years, at this juncture gujarat ecosystem provides everthing that a business need to smoothly function. Thus inturn businesses prefer such ecosystem.
Metros highway expressway are mostly given to Maharashtra because Nitin Gadkari is Marathi 👍
@@hello_1456 😂bro metro to vaise hi aani thi bcz of need to metro cities ....
Highways ki baat kare to dusre Big states ke mukalble bahut kam Highways he MH me ...Jaise UP , gujrat me large number of Highways he & even railway routes
Gift city me abb google bhi aa chuka h.🤩
Gift city mein residential tower or project kab banenge wahi swift ho jata hu
Naina का नाम सुना.मेंने वहाँ इन्वेस्टमेंट किया है.
2013 से चल रहा है,वहाँ कुछ भी ग्राउंड पे नहीं हुआ है.
Even CHINA (144 crore population) have two major financial capital/ centre/ stock exchanges namely SHANGHAI and SHENZHEN and recently they start BEIJING STOCK EXCHANGE and have to mention they indirectly control of HONGKONG which already well known IFSC 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Though i am Marathi manoos i dont have problem with multiple financial centre across country.
Only Competition can give satisfactory results not monopoly of one city/ entity.
We need GIFT cities in all state jiske bajah se waha ke local people ko dur jane ka jarurat nahi hoga
Hi, is it a good time to invest in residential in gift city?? Can we expect 3× 5× returns in next 10 years??
10:10 gujrat is dry state but gift city is not dry area you can consume alcohol in gift city.
Mumbai shouldn’t complain they should make themselves more competent because even if we see the history as well, economic capital of country keeps changing weather it’s from Bengal to Mumbai and now from Mumbai to somewhere else but Mumbai still have few years to buckle up and get ready to give a healthy competition 😎🙌🔥
Mumbai population is more than 2.5 cr which is more than Australia County population 5 rs bus service 10 rs local train service except property rate every thing is affordable in Mumbai
@@hussainsadriwala8845 Using a 10rs train to go to my closet sized apartment isn't really life. Builders and property owners are exploiting the people and native MH people can't even afford it.
Very good governance by modi govt❤❤❤, thanks for SK much progress
Freeing congestion from Mumbai, is beneficial for Mumbai.
Historically Mumbai is not the economic hub in ancient Bharat ,it was Britishers who artificially created it as an economic centre.
Ancient bharat also used bailgadis to travel
Wrong, suez canal made it what it is today
@@millennialmind9507 Yes, the Suez made Mumbai and it is the Gulf that is making GIFT. Easy access to ports of a state that is very close to wealthy Gulf countries: Oman, Chahbahar, Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Qatar, Kuwait City.... A speed boat water taxi from Dwarka to Oman is quite easy to see. And then rail from there would take goods into UAE, Qatar, Bahrain and Saudi. Then there is the north-south corridor from Dwarka to Chahbahar, going all the way to Europe by land route.
Sir,
Apne video ke Last me Jo baat kahi ki Mumbai over burden ho chuki hai ye sch hai.
I m from Mumbai.And more and more people are increasing in the population of Mumbai.
And i think to reduce this burden this is good step.
But one thing all should accept no one city can replace Mumbai.
I don't agree with this video. It means that all other states should stop making any efforts to attract investors, and everyone should invest in Mumbai only. Investing in one state does not mean it is a loss of other states. We need 10 Mumbai like cities and our country would become prosperous. Saying that all investments should be made in one state is foolish.
As mumbaikar now also noida,dholera, banglore & Hyderabad has growing cities in future they give us growth in gdp for india
Mumbai and maharashtra me jab koi political party safe nhi hai to investment safe hogi uski kon guarantee lega...😅
Those states which provides better infrastructure and policies to attract investment and job's will prosper. Unfortunately,only southern and western states are doing well to attract investment. North India states, such as Himachal Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh is trying to attract investment rest is not doing good. Eastern states such as West Bengal and Assam and jharkhand and Orissa is also need to do lot's.
It's about coasts and states with ports are always preferred. But if those states can be linked via WDFC and EDFC like you see happening with UP now, things will fly. UP is geared to become the manufacturing capital of India.
What about Haryana
6th in fdi attraction in india
Haryana attract more fdi then UP
Gift is like a dystopian city, where everything will be monitored.
China and Dubai already do that.
@@AO-xd2ml They're both jails. Ones an islamic country with laws favouring Islam & locals and the other is a communist police state.
Healthy competition must be appreciated because it's important for our country's development 🇮🇳🚩
Business tycoons don't setup offices on emotional decisions. They are going to Gujarat because their government is providing better offers. Atleast they have stable government since 23 years. Result of which they have made ordinary businessmen to billionaires. Maharashtra has highest GDP but major industrialists are gujaratis only.
Mumbai ko financial capital bhi Gujarati banaya he... yee bat koi naa nahi kahe sakta.. or marathi log or maharashtra ko uska fyada hua.... marathi people should thankful to Gujaratis for this
🤣🤣🤣🤣 average gujju thinking
It will be good as long as it creates healthy competition.
Gujrati people are hard working, we will definitely complete this Gift and Dholera project soon
Gift city won't hurt Mumbai...
- every Gujarati
Make a video of on Bengal fintech hub..... There's some remarkable new advancement happened there recently.
#AskPT Please make video on Dream City Surat ❤
Once Maharashtra Government gets stabled everything will be good
महाराष्ट्र कि राजनीतिक अस्थिरता कि वजह से भी कम्पनियां दुसरे राज्यों के तरफ रुख कर रहे हैं
Power shifting is the law of nature soon it'll be seen in other states of India eg UP.
Way towards development...😌
GIFT city's Brand Ambassador is Devendra Fadanvis.
How
Nope moke like Udhav.
Bhai advance congrats on 500k subs 🎉