Can You Recite Quran on Graves?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 чер 2024
- In this insightful video, Dr. Shadee explores the permissibility of reciting the Quran on graves. He delves into the nuances of Islamic teachings, shedding light on the practices of reciting the Quran and making dua in graveyards. Join us as Dr. Shadee provides a comprehensive understanding of this topic, offering valuable guidance for those seeking clarity on honoring the deceased through Quranic recitation and supplication.
Full Episode: ua-cam.com/users/livejUtP5QCGB_o
Subscribe and hit the 🔔 icon to receive the latest news & updates from Safina!
Hoist the sails & join the tales on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, & Twitter @safinasociety! - Розваги
This was very comforting to hear. I’ve been to graves of loved ones and instinctively sit down and recite Quran. Thank you for sharing your knowledge.
i read surah yaseen at my mums grave
and 4 quls
ayatul kursi
at everyone else grave that i know
Allah bless you
May allah bless you on this noble duty of spreading the message of ahlu sunnah.
These knowledge has been passed onto us but when we reach western lands the wahabi waswas kicksin, its reassuring to hear this from other madhabs and lands
I used to think reciting the quran and giving its reward to the dead its a bidah when i was a salafi then i came to know that many scholars allowed this not only al nawawi even ahmed bin hanbal, abu hanifa, ibn taimiyyah, ibn al qayyim, ibn qudamah and other giants, but this modern salafi movement of course forbids it and even goes to the extent of calling it a bidah subhanallah, and they dont tell you those great names that i just mentioned because they want to hide it from the people who dont do research themselves. Ibn Qudamah actually goes so far as to say that there is a consensus on the point: 'There is [now] a consensus of the Muslims [about it]. For in every time and place they agreed upon reciting the Qur'an and gifting its reward to their deceased, without any objection.
Thank you, may Allah bless you. I want to recite for my teacher who has passed ❤️🩹
Same with tradition in Indonesia with majority syafi'i mazhab.
@safina - you quoted hanbali but I did not hear any reference for this. Can you please share?
❤❤❤
Alhamdulilah to have Ijma on issues like this
asalamualaykum. i would like to know more about isal-e-sawab, is it a thing, permissible or not and if it is what are the best forms of it
Whats the citation for tht hadith?..
Did the prophet pbuh this?
Is there any hadith or quranic verse that confirms this?
Did you not watch the video?
Hadith and Quran Verse are two from many Sources, you have to ask other way. Are there daleel for this? Answer: yes
The issue is that there is a Sahih hadith in Bukhari and Muslim which states the Prophet Muhammed PBUH said that the deeds of a dead person comes to an end except 3 things, a pious child that make Dua, knowledge that the deceased had spread and sadaqatul Jariyah (charity that is ongoing example contirbuted to a msujid, built a well etc). Based on this Hadith, the recitation of Quran does not help the dead. Only Dua, which is asking Allah to forgive that person etc etc.
There is no sahih hadith that says that reading Quran for a dead benefits them.
He quoted Shaykhs who know hadiths and Quran better than us and understand the meaning of all the daleels better than us and they are saying it’s valid. So that should be enough for us common Muslims.
@@Bash2ok No, absolutely wrong. We dont blindly follow "Shayks". If a "Shayk" says something then he has to provide evidence from Quran and Sahih Hadith. Where is the Quran verse? Where is the hadith?
Blindly following Shayks is what will lead the pious astray in the time of Dajjal. The "common" muslims will accept everything Dajjal says as they will think he is a pious shayk, awliyah etc which will lead them to Jahannum.
Hence it is very important to ensure that what people say, regardless of who they are, their status, education etc come from Quran and hadith. Remember, Iblis even led the Prophets of Allah astray (Adam AS) or would have led them astray (Yusuf AS). So who on earth are these shayks compared to the best of creation, aka the Prophets of Allah (Peace Be Upon Them All).
@@786Inferno even if he quoted Hadith or a verse. We don’t know how to “understand” these proofs since we never studied the religion. But the Shaykhs did. So it’s not blindly following, it’s just the natural order of how we seek knowledge. If you only want Quran and Hadith as your source of daleel, then seek knowledge until you reach that level of understanding.
Because even if you received a Hadith, what choice will you have but to nod your head and say ok, that’s sufficient evidence for me? What if that Hadith that was quoted was infact, NOT the proper daleel, how would you even know? You wouldn’t because we’re not at that level of understanding. Therefore out of necessity, we are forced to take from what the scholars have said and that’s it.
@@Bash2okyou are missing the point COMPLETELY. How do you know if what these shayks are saying is true? You have no basis at all but to blindly accept it, and if they are wrong you will also follow them. Refer to what I said about Dajjal. Will you accept everything he says as truth? You won't know who he is.
Regarding quoting a Hadith that's not Sahih. It's funny you use this argument when you don't even bother with proof. But to answer you, we are born with information at our fingertips. It's very easy to fact check whether a Hadith is Sahih or not. You can also go buy a volume of Hadith. Most of the Quran and Hadith are translated to simple English. If you want detail You can read the tafsir which further explains everything.
If you think this is too much for a common person, then unfortunately you will also be misguided. We live at a time where the wrong is being portrayed as right and Muslims are too lazy to seek knowledge hence why there are 2 billion Muslims but Islam is weak.
Muslims would rather sit at a 3 hour gathering then take 30 min to fact check a "shaykh".
@@Bash2okit is blindly following because you didn't bother to check the evidence
Providing you pinch your left ear lobe with your right fore finger and thumb while you recite , then it is permissible.
why?
The salafis say its bid'a im confused
It is a bid'ah the Prophet never did it. All he did was make dua for them not read quran
@asjadiqbal9790 so your saying its bid'a to recite surah yasin at the grave
@@tamjidislam5558 there are two types of innovations those that are good and those that are evil.
Qiyaas something that practicable in the time of the Prophet and sahaba, but they did not do. I don't gamble, so I won't do it.
Qiyaas is a problem sometimes 😂
Wahabism is a bigger problem always 😅
@@waqasriaz3497 Wahabism is a fitnah. Falsehood appears temporarily but then is destroyed when Truth stands up. Right now the Ummah is under siege everywhere so the Wahabis have an easier time causing troubles for Muslims.
@@waqasriaz3497😭 not everything is wahabism bro chill, dont follow anything from ibn wahaab and the scholars after him then check out Bukhari's ra chapter called Baab Karaahat al-Salaah fi’l-Maqaabir (Chapter on it being disliked to pray in graveyards)also check Abu Dawood ra masaa'il p158 “I heard Ahmad being asked about reading Quran at the graveside. He said, ‘No [that should not be done].’” There are other hadith as well for eg “Do not make your houses into graveyards, for the Shaytaan flees from a house in which surah al-Baqarah is recited.” also “Pray in your houses and do not make them like graves.” Bukhari said it could be understood to mean its makrooh to pray in the graveyard. if you weigh up both sides of the issue if you are honest with yourself you will see the balance in favor of not doing it is better. And Allah knows best.
Arrogance is a bigger problem 😂
Indeed very arrogant to put qiyaas over the texts
Isnt this topic of disagreement among the scholars ? Why does some scholars say its an innovation?
Because a lot of "scholars" don't know what bidah is. I think Ibn Hajr as Qalani and Ibn Taymmia said that bidah is something that has no asl (foundation) in Islam. Modern scholars say every new thing is bidah, which is false because the second azaan for jummah was a new thing added by Usman radiatallah anh during his caliphate, but no sunni would say Sayyidina Usman is an innovator. The Quran was compiled into a mushaf after the time of the Prophet Sallallahu Alayhi Wasalam, but we dont call it bidah. Which is why we call new matters that have goodness is them good bidahs, because they are only linguistic bidahs, not bidahs in the sense that the Prophet alayhi salam forbade them. The clasical scholars that didn't like the term good bidah used the term "linguistic bidah," but both terms mean the same thing.
@@vol94you don’t know what bid’ah is. In Nasai 1578, [The Prophet ﷺ said “The evilest matters in religion are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.”] With regards to the additional adhaan in the jummuah prayers, who would call this a bid’ah, when the Prophet ﷺ said in Tirmidhi 2676 [“Beware of the newly invented matters, for indeed they are astray. Whoever among you sees that, then he must stick to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the rightly guided Khulafa',”] Every sunni knows Uthman was from the Khulafa ar Rashideen, so if the Prophet ﷺ told us to follow him and his actions, why would anybody believe his actions were bid’aat? Furthermore, the compilation of qur’an into a mushaf was sunnah of Abu Bakr, and in Tirmidhi 3663, [the Prophet ﷺ said “Verily, I do not know how much longer I will remain with you. After me, follow these two,” and the Prophet pointed to Abu Bakr and Umar.] Again, nobody among the Ahlus sunnah wal jama’ah would call it a bid’ah to follow Abu Bakr. Regarding the ‘linguistic bid’ahs’ this is only applicable to a select few scenarios, such as the introduction of congregational qiyam at the time of Umar ibn al Khattab radiAllahu anh- modern bid’aat are not under this term. ‘Good bid’ahs’ is an excuse used by the deceivers to try and sugarcoat the misguidance which they promote. The deen was perfected at the time of Prophet ﷺ , and was implemented by the salaf us saaliheen, so those are the people we should follow when it comes to these matters, and Allah swt has made this deen easy for us, there is no need to introduce new things when we can simply follow what is authenticity narrated. ‘Good bid’ahs’ would NOT have been missed by the Prophet ﷺ, or the golden generations after him, and so claiming that there are any new and ‘good’ bid’aat is the same as saying the Prophet ﷺ did not tell us everything we need to know about the deen. May Allah guide you to the aqeedah of ahlus sunnah and protect us all from misguiders.
Quran was in the form of a book in the lifetime of muhammed pbuh it's a misconception that quran was compiled after his death
Avoid the "salafis". They are something new. The term "Salafi" can also be called a bidah itself.
Because like any religion or system, shaytaan loves to cause chaos and fitna. Modern scholars including salafism and wahabbism have contradicted many things that scholars used to regularly do. One way wahabbis tried to prove their points was through al-bani whereby he restructured the hadith gradings and removed 3000 hadiths from his own version of sahih bukhari. That is the most dominant version of sahih bukhari that exists in the world today. Similarly we had other extreme scholars cause fitna by polemically and physically attack scholars of old, primarily to gain political control. Every political system has an ideology and with that, the religious countries then dictate their form of Islam to the masses. This has happened in every century. Today, because the likes of saudi arabia like to think they are the only people who understand tawheed in its truest form, that every other person not following their way is a mubtadi (innovator). When you have shock labels to easily dismantle others opinions, it becomes hard to argue until all new generations breed the same views. We live in a time where judgement day is near and money rules the world, regardless of the levels of religiosity by the leaders of such countries. Our Prophet sallallhu alahi wassallam intentionally lived a poor life whereas all the leaders today live lavishly and quite funnily enough, most citizens of those countries have a huge income gap between socioeconomic classes.
The summary is this: follow the early views of madhabs unless no opinion of a certain legal issue exists and thereby you need to rely on modern scholarship (i.e. transgenderism which didn’t exist before but now it is rampant). May Allah swt allow us to have the most tender of hearts, increase us in knowledge and give us the opportunity to love him and his Prophet sallallhu alahi wassallam the way they deserve to be loved.
What does that face mask/picture symbolize? Looks demonic 😬
Looks like our Muslim brother and rapper MF Doom's Mask. May Allah have mercy on him as he passed away in 2020.
Looks like Dr. Shadee is MF Doom's or Doctor Doom's fan 😅😅
It’s a hockey jersey lol he showed it in one of the streams
Where is the proof from the sunnah? To recite Qur'an
@@mdabdulkhalique9186he mentioned it in the video my dear brother. In the description of this video, there is also a link to the full episode which will provide more context