I actually forgot two products I wanted to talk about!🤦♀ The MAKE Beauty Multi-Chromatic eyeshadows...I tried them in a video and they were some of the most beautiful eyeshadows ever, but they faded SUPER fast, within a couple of hours. I was so disappointed in those. Also the new Huda Beauty Faux Filler lip glosses were too thick and goopy, they got all over my teeth and they made those "strings" between your lips when I would talk. They also didn't seem to "fill" or plump my lips either.
I completely understand where your thoughts are coming from and I agree with what you said, I’m Canadian and Brow products we run through pretty quickly I’ve never had a NYX Lift and Snatch pen last me as long as yours do . I get about 5 weeks but I also build my Brow from very little to start with, here I pay 15,99 for just 1 NYX pen and the LA Girl is only 7 ,69 and last the same amount of time I think you might have had a bad one TBH . So for me the choice is obvious what I’m going to choose as anything even remotely Beauty related here is double if not triple the cost in the States, also we only get if we’re lucky about half of what the Brand offers in the States IF the Brand is even available here we get the very short end of the stick when it comes to what’s available here in any category. Most ppl right away go to “ well you have free healthcare “ actually no we don’t our taxes pay for it that’s why Canada is one of the top most heavily taxed Countries and only a few things are “ free” we have to pay for any type of therapy whether it be Phyiso , Chiropractic, Dermatologist, Dentist, Pediatrist, among many others. We say goodbye to a minimum of 33% of our paycheck to just Federal Income Tax that’s not any other deductions or taxes on absolutely everything we buy , im not saying Americans do not pay high taxes I know you do but everyone thinks Canada has it better and I’m here to tell you NO we don’t lol . I’d love to have the things available to us that’s available for Americans especially the advantages in Healthcare I have Chronic Health issues and the medications that would really benefit me are not available to Canadians nor is the quality of medical care, we get the Drs and Surgeons that have been sued to many times or lost their ability to Practice in the States they come and Practice here because they can and here NOBODY can sue for ANYTHING absolutely NOTHING! A Muppets is running the Country making us a huge laughing stock our Countries are Neighbors but also extremely different and as an outsider looking in I can see so much more available in every category, but I’m sure it’s the same for those looking at us as a Canadian we’ve had to learn so much about America but American never had to learn about us , I’ve often wondered why that is , anyway I’m positive you don’t really care LOL this was about the cost of a Brow Pen which I have to order online because not sold in any Stores in my City LA Girl is not available anywhere in my Province I’m not sure if it’s available in other Provinces TBH I have to order it off of IHerb it’s not even on our Amazon which is also extremely different than the American Amazon same goes for Walmart two completely different Stores in each Country. Anyway I’m sorry for my thought vomit .
I often wonder how an eyeshadow eyeshadow would fade without rubbing your eyes or sweat/rain. Your hair is looking top notch. What are you doing with it.
Hi Jen, thanks for the video. I like these periodic "disappointing product" videos as opposed to doing a big round up at the end of the year. That's a long time to wait, and possible purchases made without knowing any better. I do have a thought as to what the purpose of the new Milk primer is...boosting the brand's bottom line! Also, I see you're wearing Laura Geller products in this video. Can we look forward to a review video? I'm especially interested in your thoughts on the Baked Powder Foundation. I see this advertised a lot as being good for "mature" skin, but I'm skeptical as to how well a powder foundation works on dry skin. Assuming that's what they mean by mature; some people do have oily skin through old age.
Haven’t tried these but love getting these round up videos so I know what not to waste my money on. Having the information come from someone that isn’t sponsored is huge, and we have the same age skin and skin type (dry). Unrelated, I think this is the prettiest color, cut, and style hair I’ve seen on Jen 🤩
Exactly not being Sponsored EVER in this Industry is something to be commended and we know for certain that the opinions are absolutely genuine, it takes a certain special people to say No Thank You to the massive amounts of money that is being made in Sponsored and Partnerships like literally Hundreds of Thousands to Millions with the huge Creators . We also know those huge Creators especially over on TikTok lie about Sponsored Content and their opinions change depending on if they’re getting paid, we see it over and over again from the same handfuls of ppl , what are they going to do IF that App is banned or IF the FTC starts to crack down in North America.
Aw thank you! It's definitely not easy to say no to big paychecks, but I'm extremely blessed to be in a great financial situation and I would much rather give my real opinions than be beholden to brands. :)
As a 53 yr old with, well 53 yr old looking skin, I have found that base serums & thin skin tints are no friend of mine. They sink in & magnify every pore, line, and teensiest dry patches. Tinted moisturizers, I believe, deliver a similar product - the ultra light skin tint- within a nice moisturizing & smoothing core formula, esp one with silicones. The difference has been amazing. I gave up on all base products until I found bare minerals complexion gel & Neutrogena healthy skin anti-a perfector. I tried quite a few less expensive ones but nothing less costly than the Neutrogena has looked natural, fixed my skin texture appearance, and evened out the tone. My big sunspot isn't concealed at all, but it's barely noticeable with the light zhuzz of color that balances my splotchiness. Granted, sun damage is almost "cute" in Montana esp among queer gals, so I look outdoorsy which is good lol. But honestly, these skin tints seem best for skin with amazing smoothness - but I think a nice somewhat fluffy tinted moisturizer would give most people a nice alternative if they share my un-smooth texture lol
I have to say, I really love watching you. I mean. I watch every video beginning to end. Your honest , calm, no drama, all around a joy. Love these agree on the brow color. I need to try this one
Same! Most BGs I end up fast forwarding through parts or have to stop the video to do something and never come back. Jen I always watch the entire thing. Even if the title is something that doesn’t seem like something I’m interested in (like products I wasn’t thinking about), I still always watch and usually end up hearing about something I want to try or, even if I don’t, I just enjoy watching it!
This video just confirms one of the many reasons I love your channel with the wear tests and updates - Most of these products you said how much you INITIALLY liked/loved it when first applied but then for whatever reason, either at end of day after a wear test after trying it for a bit (like with the LA Girl Brow Pen dried out). So many BGs just do FIRST impressions with no wear test, say how much they LOVE it, and you never hear about it again - either not using it again since they always try new stuff so don’t know if it’s because of that or if they just didn’t like it after using it for a bit and/or never giving updates.
I really hate when drugstore brands go for those thin, powdery formulas like those LA girl palettes. They're soft but have no pigment or staying power. Boo. I knew that I had to wait for your review of the new Flower beauty blushes before buying. I'm so glad I did.
I swear, LA Colors, darling of the Dollar stores & Big Lots, is outperforming LA Girls! My favorite drugstore palette so far this year has been the LA Colors Bubble Tea quad ($1.25, same any of product as drugstore quads,) & I've loved their new liquid shadows
I mix the Catrice serum drops w/ EL Double Wear & it is AWESOME! Lasts all day, coverage but not too much, so pretty/natural. I have super dry skin & don’t notice it making me look dry thru the day.
Brows are an area I really should pay attention to, especially since some are not growing back after too much tweezing etc. I really like this eye look, soft and simple. I have to tone my eyeshadow down even more these days because lately I feel like it ages me, so I appreciate these more basic looks. Most people find them boring but not me! Good video.
I was just going to leave a comment about the eye shadow palette from Laura Gellar that was used. I went to check it out. Wouldn't you know. I just saw this one and another at Marshall's over the weekend. They're selling for $14.99. If you have a Marshall's nearby go check there first. I've purchased 2 of her palettes at TJ Maxx in the past. They're not those types of shadows that give you a lot of bang right off the bat but they do create some very nice, mellow looks. Hope you're able to find one if you are interested... 👍
It's just so disappointing when products don't work out. I was excited abt the lagirl brow pen after it worked out so well for you because I use & love the nyx pen. Oh and their eyeshadows, what a disappointment. Thank you for being with us !
I apply the Revlon blushes with a dense brush and stipple them on and they work great. I've never tried them with my fingers. The mauve is my fav and it shows up really well with a brush.
I was going to suggest she try a brush as well. The one time I did apply a blush with my fingers was the last time. The product was the Maybelline heat blushes. Not the full name but they're the ones that come in a squeezey tube. It disappeared just like she experienced but when I use the #7 brush from IT Cosmetics I had no problem with the application. Can't hurt to try it that way before she gets rid of them, right? 🤷♀️
The Milani weekend brow is teeny tiny brush too but it’s very pigmented. I wish somebody made one like stila’s old brow pen that was so sheer and subtle.
Essence makes a dupe for Benefits brow mascara (is it called "Gimme Brow"? I can't remember the name. Anyway....) and it's really fabulous. I have so many brow products--i used to have great brows, but as I've aged, they've got lighter and lighter, and I still have good amount of brow hair. It's just almost transparent . (Gotta love being blonde...) The Essence brow mascaras are really good, they are cooler in tone than nearly any other brow products, and they don't give you crunchy brows.
I tried both ELF CC versions and compared both in a video. I didn’t see much of a difference between the 2. I did notice that it broke up around my nose area which can be an issue except it was really noticeable with both. It’s fine for a weekend foundation but not a 10 hour workday in my experience. I also don’t think it’s a dupe for IT cosmetics CC. I love that product and the CC Nude Glow.
Thanks Jen so much for your reviews and insight. I've found true gems because of you! You're my Sunday morning video date every week, hot tea, toast with jam and Jen Phelps! Much love from Vancouver, Washington 🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲
Love your roundup videos, helps to save me money to purchase other things you try that are good, you’ve never failed me. I got that Jane Iredale lip stain you had shown and got it at Ulta half off during one of their sale days, got that peach color and it doesn’t turn that popsicle pink, yeah. I’m sad cause I got that new NYX bronzer in Deserve Betta and I loved the formula but the color just had a tint of red that didn’t look good on my light/med skin tone. I sent it to my daughter. I hope they get them in stores to look at the shades cause the formula was so nice. Oh and I also picked up 3 shades of the Too Faced blushes too and I’m loving them, half price too. Thank you Jen❤
Chanel has a new Spring Collection; does anyone else? And would you be interested in finding drugstore dupes and/or alternatives for a spring/easter look? Thanx.
I was so disappointed pin the Elf CC cream also! Looked so heavy on my mature skin! LA Girl is on sale at Ulta so I bought a nude palette that was $5.99 half price. Feverish, something was the name. I certainly didn’t need it. Why do I buy things without checking with you first!😊I feel the same about the ELF lip pens, I bought two of them. Very patchy even with lip primer. Thanks Jen for a great video,! Can’t wait for favorites! Hope all is well with you! We’re getting up to 8 inches of snow with 40 mph winds! Spring equinox, wuh, where!😂sending much love a big hug❣️🌹❤️😊
In your opinion, for more mature skin that's a little on the drier side ( I'm 55), what is the best cream and or liquid bronzer and blush? Are any high end products better than drug store? What is the best of both; is there a product that's just the best in your opinion? I do have texture, and my skin tone is pretty good, but a little uneven as most people have. I really enjoy your channel and am slowly converting to using drug store brands you recommend that are truly "the best!" Thank you for all of your hard work and expense in doing all of your research for us!!!
I personally loved it, but I hate the click up pens and that needs to go, makes no sense. Even though I like the formula I won't buy another because of that.
ooh interesting, I also have dry skin and I had a very similar experience with the Catrice foundation except it didn't even look good at the beginning lol, but I did actually really like the Elf hydrating foundation and it looked very dewy on me!
I tried the elf camo hydrating cc cream. It dried me out too! I love the it cosmetics hydrating in the green tube. So pretty and glpwy and last all day!
The original elf cc cream felt like paste on my skin, I was too afraid to even try the new one, thinking it would just be a waste of my money, glad I skipped it, my dry skin doesn’t need that.
That's crazy, bc my flower blush is super pigmented! I apply with brush off of my hand, I have to be super careful bc I always over due it! When I was watching you apply and I still wasn't seeing color I'm baffled!
I love your look in this one! Especially the eyeshadow! I haven’t tried any of these products but a big flop for me this year was the It cosmetics new matte cc cream.. no matter how I applied it or how much or little I put on, my face was a cakey mess. Which sucked because the color match was spot on.
I can not tell how happy I am to watch this video Jen. I remember when you tried all of these products as I watch all of your videos and I have not really gotten any of them yet. I remember you saying some of the same things in the videos when you tried them, especially the Milk primer or skin tint. You said then that you did not see anything that it had done. So glad I won't be wasting my money now. Thank you so very much Jen. You never fail us.❤
I agree about the elf pout clout pens. I do not like it! I got one (apparently forgot about your review) and it sticks in my dry spots and is all thick and gloopy. Not great at all, and I like a lot of elf products.
It's so interesting that you love the heavy glitters so much more because I feel like soft colors and glitters look so much more flattering on your light skin tone. You have such beautiful skin and soft make up brings that out even more. ❤🎉
Aw thank you! I actually don't like heavy glitters, I prefer minimal (or no) glitter, but a soft metallic sheen is my preference. The hard toppers they're coming out with now don't offer any color and the little micro-glitters get everywhere.
They're at Walmart, I got one online. I am surprised she didn't like it, I'm 41 and it makes my lips so plump and smoothed the lines out well. The formula felt silky and glides beautifully. I was actually surprised I didn't regret the purchase 😅 Not getting another because I'm not a fan of the click pen, they're so dumb. But otherwise I had a very different experience and I wonder why. 🤔
Thank you for this video! Some of the products I was debating on trying but I won’t waste my money on them. I trust your opinion and recommendations 😊 thank you for spending your $$ so we don’t have to! I did get the LA Girl brow pen after seeing you try it and love it the first time. I got the soft brown but it’s too light for me. I was going to get the dark brown but haven’t yet. I’m not going to now knowing it only lasts for a couple of weeks. That is crazy! I will stick with my maybelline ultra precise brow pencil. That is my favorite so far 😊 I bought the ELF Camo hydrating CC cream bc I have dry skin and I thought it would work for me. The regular one is too drying. Well so is the hydrating one 😒 it feels just like the original on my skin. Disappointing. I am loving the About Face the Performer Skin Focus foundation though! That sits beautifully on my skin and isn’t dry at all!😊 hope you have a great day! Hugs! 💖🌸
Bummed about LA girl brow pen running out fast. I had it on my list but just erased. Thanks for letting us know. What about the build-a-brow pen? Is it smaller than the NYX and good cool brown color? I’ve always thought the Nyx pen marks were too thick. Just trying to find something thinner in the marker pen style.
I’ve had terrible foundation days…even with Lancôme, NARS and Estée Lauder. Yesterday I had a great foundation day with kopari sunscreen and purlisse cc cream. 🤞🏻this is the winning combo. I did order Clinique foundation because I’ve never tried it. I’m so pale that shade matching is an issue. Your content is sooooo good.
I also tried the LA girl nude eyeshadow palettes, and I did not care for them. The mattes were not too bad, but the shimmers were not pigmented and dry and chalky. I don't care for the glitter topper eyeshadows, they are not pigmented. Elf and wet n wild eyeshadows are so much better.
I saw a video recently talking about makeup trends for gen z, and it talked about how their eye shadows are less harsh, and a bit more subtle. More seamlessly blended and upturned. So, maybe that is coming through in those palettes (it is being marketed to give a more subtle look because that is on trend). Not sure but was just a thought. I appreciate your comment too about maybe they just didn't play nice with you. Some of the color might show up more on other skin tones. 🤷♀️
From experience I haven’t found any “glowing” anything in makeup in the “drugstore” category! Everything that glows in the beginning doesn’t last for more than 5 minutes! Unless your skin is so hydrated that it shines! Then any makeup will look dewy or glowing on your skin! I guess if a high end one makes your skin look like that then it’s worth the splurge! 😮
Andrea Matilliano said the exact same thing about the L.A. Girl brow pen! If 2 of my 3 favorite O.G. creators of all time say the same thing about the same product....my attention in UNDIVIDED!
Thanks Jen! These are my favorite videos you make! I loved these… I hated these… I like your dupes vids too. Would love a brush tutorial… when to used what ❤
Jen, you look great in this video. Like, you've gotta Jennifer Aniston/Avril Lavigne look going on. I love it! Now, on another note, I love your honesty when it comes to your reviews. So many influencers make so many ridiculous claims that do nothing more than disappoint their viewers`and I dont appreciate that. I hardly ever buy products that influencers recommend or review because of what I observe with the products in their videos. There might be a few things I'll get, but its all based on what I observe, the price, and its uniqueness. What may look great on someone else may not look great on me. I know what I like, what I prefer, and what I will use. With that said, I enjoy trying new things as well. I agree these products are overrated and disappointing.
Hi Jen, I like that you are doing quarterly round up (best & worst) products) it’s better for you and for us, i enjoyed this video. Love Katherine xoxo
Did u get the Dior Smokey Essentials pallet? The taupe and grey shades together are soooooooo perfect for me it would look great on you too were very similar lol it’s my new favorite go to look with Natasha D lipstick in Noa and 3.5 storme liner perfect neutrals lol every shade in that pallet is perfect 🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍
Hey Jen! You look fabulous! I haven't tried any of these products, but thanks for reminding me that I don't want to! Happy Sunday! And I hope you're feeling the holidays and secure in your knowledge of the true meaning: Holy Days. God is good!
I love the Flower beauty blush wand in cheeky. I wear it almost everyday since it came out. I apply it straight to my face & blend it out with the elf complexion duo brush. Mine are pretty pigmented but buildable on my fair to light skin without lifting any foundation. Sorry it didn’t work for you. I love the formula ❤
Jen youve got to try cover girl clean fresh brow pencils. They are a close dupe to the tiny benefit brow pencils. They are so small and work so good. I havent heard anyone talking about them and im shocked. They are sooo good!!
Oh no! I just bought two bottles of that Catrice skin tint... I have dry, mature skin so I don't have hope 😑. And thank you for the heads up about the Make Beauty eyeshadows.. I was just about to pull the trigger on those instead I will go with Moira! ❤
Hey Jen! If you want a skin tint that does not fade, crease or look dry, you got to try the new one from Lisa Eldrige. It's expensive, but worth it. I've tried everything on this 68 year old dry skin and this is surely the best! You only need two to three drops and is buildable.
I can’t tolerate blushes that go on sheer. On my skin tone, they truly do not show up. I also have become wary of certain inexpensive brow and eyeliner products that have so little product in them they are gone right away. No matter how inexpensive they are, they are their own kind of rip off.
I read that Catrice foundation is for dry skin. It brings out the dryness in me, just like you. I prefer the Catrice HD foundation, of which I have the old version though
I really dislike the hard pan/topper shades. Lime Crime did some of these years ago and I never bought another one of their palettes. They’re finicky and I don’t need makeup frustration.
Are their other Neutrogena cosmetics that you've tried that you could share with us? I've tried a few of their products and I am pleased with the few I've tried so far 😊 Thanks Jen 💕
I’m a huge Catrice cosmetics fan.. however when I got the catrice glow my bottle was empty!! I always order from the catrice website and they immediately reimbursed me.. they are very good to refund.. and that’s the only product I have ever been disappointed in by catrice!
I actually forgot two products I wanted to talk about!🤦♀ The MAKE Beauty Multi-Chromatic eyeshadows...I tried them in a video and they were some of the most beautiful eyeshadows ever, but they faded SUPER fast, within a couple of hours. I was so disappointed in those.
Also the new Huda Beauty Faux Filler lip glosses were too thick and goopy, they got all over my teeth and they made those "strings" between your lips when I would talk. They also didn't seem to "fill" or plump my lips either.
I love how honest you are. Love that
I completely understand where your thoughts are coming from and I agree with what you said, I’m Canadian and Brow products we run through pretty quickly I’ve never had a NYX Lift and Snatch pen last me as long as yours do . I get about 5 weeks but I also build my Brow from very little to start with, here I pay 15,99 for just 1 NYX pen and the LA Girl is only 7 ,69 and last the same amount of time I think you might have had a bad one TBH . So for me the choice is obvious what I’m going to choose as anything even remotely Beauty related here is double if not triple the cost in the States, also we only get if we’re lucky about half of what the Brand offers in the States IF the Brand is even available here we get the very short end of the stick when it comes to what’s available here in any category. Most ppl right away go to “ well you have free healthcare “ actually no we don’t our taxes pay for it that’s why Canada is one of the top most heavily taxed Countries and only a few things are “ free” we have to pay for any type of therapy whether it be Phyiso , Chiropractic, Dermatologist, Dentist, Pediatrist, among many others. We say goodbye to a minimum of 33% of our paycheck to just Federal Income Tax that’s not any other deductions or taxes on absolutely everything we buy , im not saying Americans do not pay high taxes I know you do but everyone thinks Canada has it better and I’m here to tell you NO we don’t lol . I’d love to have the things available to us that’s available for Americans especially the advantages in Healthcare I have Chronic Health issues and the medications that would really benefit me are not available to Canadians nor is the quality of medical care, we get the Drs and Surgeons that have been sued to many times or lost their ability to Practice in the States they come and Practice here because they can and here NOBODY can sue for ANYTHING absolutely NOTHING! A Muppets is running the Country making us a huge laughing stock our Countries are Neighbors but also extremely different and as an outsider looking in I can see so much more available in every category, but I’m sure it’s the same for those looking at us as a Canadian we’ve had to learn so much about America but American never had to learn about us , I’ve often wondered why that is , anyway I’m positive you don’t really care LOL this was about the cost of a Brow Pen which I have to order online because not sold in any Stores in my City LA Girl is not available anywhere in my Province I’m not sure if it’s available in other Provinces TBH I have to order it off of IHerb it’s not even on our Amazon which is also extremely different than the American Amazon same goes for Walmart two completely different Stores in each Country. Anyway I’m sorry for my thought vomit .
I often wonder how an eyeshadow eyeshadow would fade without rubbing your eyes or sweat/rain. Your hair is looking top notch. What are you doing with it.
😫
Hi Jen, thanks for the video. I like these periodic "disappointing product" videos as opposed to doing a big round up at the end of the year. That's a long time to wait, and possible purchases made without knowing any better. I do have a thought as to what the purpose of the new Milk primer is...boosting the brand's bottom line!
Also, I see you're wearing Laura Geller products in this video. Can we look forward to a review video? I'm especially interested in your thoughts on the Baked Powder Foundation. I see this advertised a lot as being good for "mature" skin, but I'm skeptical as to how well a powder foundation works on dry skin. Assuming that's what they mean by mature; some people do have oily skin through old age.
Haven’t tried these but love getting these round up videos so I know what not to waste my money on. Having the information come from someone that isn’t sponsored is huge, and we have the same age skin and skin type (dry). Unrelated, I think this is the prettiest color, cut, and style hair I’ve seen on Jen 🤩
Aw thank you so much!!
Exactly not being Sponsored EVER in this Industry is something to be commended and we know for certain that the opinions are absolutely genuine, it takes a certain special people to say No Thank You to the massive amounts of money that is being made in Sponsored and Partnerships like literally Hundreds of Thousands to Millions with the huge Creators . We also know those huge Creators especially over on TikTok lie about Sponsored Content and their opinions change depending on if they’re getting paid, we see it over and over again from the same handfuls of ppl , what are they going to do IF that App is banned or IF the FTC starts to crack down in North America.
Aw thank you! It's definitely not easy to say no to big paychecks, but I'm extremely blessed to be in a great financial situation and I would much rather give my real opinions than be beholden to brands. :)
Thanks so much for your honesty and authenticity,Jen❣️💯💐
As a 53 yr old with, well 53 yr old looking skin, I have found that base serums & thin skin tints are no friend of mine. They sink in & magnify every pore, line, and teensiest dry patches. Tinted moisturizers, I believe, deliver a similar product - the ultra light skin tint- within a nice moisturizing & smoothing core formula, esp one with silicones. The difference has been amazing. I gave up on all base products until I found bare minerals complexion gel & Neutrogena healthy skin anti-a perfector. I tried quite a few less expensive ones but nothing less costly than the Neutrogena has looked natural, fixed my skin texture appearance, and evened out the tone. My big sunspot isn't concealed at all, but it's barely noticeable with the light zhuzz of color that balances my splotchiness. Granted, sun damage is almost "cute" in Montana esp among queer gals, so I look outdoorsy which is good lol. But honestly, these skin tints seem best for skin with amazing smoothness - but I think a nice somewhat fluffy tinted moisturizer would give most people a nice alternative if they share my un-smooth texture lol
I have to say, I really love watching you. I mean. I watch every video beginning to end. Your honest , calm, no drama, all around a joy. Love these agree on the brow color. I need to try this one
Same! Most BGs I end up fast forwarding through parts or have to stop the video to do something and never come back. Jen I always watch the entire thing. Even if the title is something that doesn’t seem like something I’m interested in (like products I wasn’t thinking about), I still always watch and usually end up hearing about something I want to try or, even if I don’t, I just enjoy watching it!
And she does such a good job finding good products.She never looks overdone, just polished and beautiful.
This video just confirms one of the many reasons I love your channel with the wear tests and updates - Most of these products you said how much you INITIALLY liked/loved it when first applied but then for whatever reason, either at end of day after a wear test after trying it for a bit (like with the LA Girl Brow Pen dried out). So many BGs just do FIRST impressions with no wear test, say how much they LOVE it, and you never hear about it again - either not using it again since they always try new stuff so don’t know if it’s because of that or if they just didn’t like it after using it for a bit and/or never giving updates.
I really hate when drugstore brands go for those thin, powdery formulas like those LA girl palettes. They're soft but have no pigment or staying power. Boo. I knew that I had to wait for your review of the new Flower beauty blushes before buying. I'm so glad I did.
The tarte juicy lip plump... the minis aren't in the click up packaging & I love those. I'm not a fan of the clicky pens.
This really helps with ones I was thinking of getting. Saving money.
I just don't like a lot of elf products. Their blush duos were great. Plus they can be an easy eyeshadow look too.
I swear, LA Colors, darling of the Dollar stores & Big Lots, is outperforming LA Girls! My favorite drugstore palette so far this year has been the LA Colors Bubble Tea quad ($1.25, same any of product as drugstore quads,) & I've loved their new liquid shadows
I agree! And they're the same company too, which makes it even stranger!
These are my favorite kind of videos, I will def watch these bc I try to avoid fomo
Hi Jehn ❤ Happy Sunday!
Can you please compare the elf nude mood perfect 10 eyeshadows to the Mario palette thank you 🙏🏻
I mix the Catrice serum drops w/ EL Double Wear & it is AWESOME! Lasts all day, coverage but not too much, so pretty/natural. I have super dry skin & don’t notice it making me look dry thru the day.
Great tip! Thanks will try.
Brows are an area I really should pay attention to, especially since some are not growing back after too much tweezing etc. I really like this eye look, soft and simple. I have to tone my eyeshadow down even more these days because lately I feel like it ages me, so I appreciate these more basic looks. Most people find them boring but not me! Good video.
I was just going to leave a comment about the eye shadow palette from Laura Gellar that was used. I went to check it out. Wouldn't you know. I just saw this one and another at Marshall's over the weekend. They're selling for $14.99. If you have a Marshall's nearby go check there first. I've purchased 2 of her palettes at TJ Maxx in the past. They're not those types of shadows that give you a lot of bang right off the bat but they do create some very nice, mellow looks. Hope you're able to find one if you are interested... 👍
@@tammiemartinez6485 Good to know...thank you
I have tried L’Oréal panoramic mascara and it’s my best find in a long time. ❤
It's just so disappointing when products don't work out. I was excited abt the lagirl brow pen after it worked out so well for you because I use & love the nyx pen. Oh and their eyeshadows, what a disappointment.
Thank you for being with us !
I apply the Revlon blushes with a dense brush and stipple them on and they work great. I've never tried them with my fingers. The mauve is my fav and it shows up really well with a brush.
I was going to suggest she try a brush as well. The one time I did apply a blush with my fingers was the last time. The product was the Maybelline heat blushes. Not the full name but they're the ones that come in a squeezey tube. It disappeared just like she experienced but when I use the #7 brush from IT Cosmetics I had no problem with the application. Can't hurt to try it that way before she gets rid of them, right? 🤷♀️
I love that you do the roundups throughout the year! It helps me optimize my budget every quarter!
The Milani weekend brow is teeny tiny brush too but it’s very pigmented. I wish somebody made one like stila’s old brow pen that was so sheer and subtle.
I love the formula of the Milani but all of the colors look too warm on me. I wish I could find an exact (or close) match...then I would love it!
Ohhh I’d forgotten about the Stila brow pen, it was my first brow pen and your right it was great. It was good but user friendly!
@@stellafoufas6102 the lines it made were so transparent, it was more forgiving, harder to make noticeable mistakes. Loved it so much.
Essence makes a dupe for Benefits brow mascara (is it called "Gimme Brow"? I can't remember the name. Anyway....) and it's really fabulous. I have so many brow products--i used to have great brows, but as I've aged, they've got lighter and lighter, and I still have good amount of brow hair. It's just almost transparent . (Gotta love being blonde...) The Essence brow mascaras are really good, they are cooler in tone than nearly any other brow products, and they don't give you crunchy brows.
Not every Elf product is a hit with everyone
Sure, and replace "elf" with the name of literally any brand!
I tried both ELF CC versions and compared both in a video. I didn’t see much of a difference between the 2. I did notice that it broke up around my nose area which can be an issue except it was really noticeable with both. It’s fine for a weekend foundation but not a 10 hour workday in my experience. I also don’t think it’s a dupe for IT cosmetics CC. I love that product and the CC Nude Glow.
Really love these disappointing makeup vids, I know everyone has some for sure...
Thanks Jen so much for your reviews and insight. I've found true gems because of you! You're my Sunday morning video date every week, hot tea, toast with jam and Jen Phelps! Much love from Vancouver, Washington 🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲🌲
❤ you hair Jen!
Love your roundup videos, helps to save me money to purchase other things you try that are good, you’ve never failed me. I got that Jane Iredale lip stain you had shown and got it at Ulta half off during one of their sale days, got that peach color and it doesn’t turn that popsicle pink, yeah. I’m sad cause I got that new NYX bronzer in Deserve Betta and I loved the formula but the color just had a tint of red that didn’t look good on my light/med skin tone. I sent it to my daughter. I hope they get them in stores to look at the shades cause the formula was so nice. Oh and I also picked up 3 shades of the Too Faced blushes too and I’m loving them, half price too. Thank you Jen❤
Morning Jen...your hair looks great today straight like that! Looking forward to seeing the video now...enjoy your weekend...Lindy
Thank you Lindy! 🥰 Happy Sunday!
I think Jen rocks it both ways!
I love the straight hair on u! You look so youthful❤️❤️
Your hair looks so pretty in this video! The color and everything. Love it! Thanks for the video.😊❤
Thanks for your honest thoughts on these products! And I look forward to the "bests!"
You just saved me some money - i thought about getting huda palettes because both colour stories were perfect for me.. such a letdown
Chanel has a new Spring Collection; does anyone else? And would you be interested in finding drugstore dupes and/or alternatives for a spring/easter look? Thanx.
I LOVE that cream pallet. That's all I wear. It looks beautiful.
I was so disappointed pin the Elf CC cream also! Looked so heavy on my mature skin! LA Girl is on sale at Ulta so I bought a nude palette that was $5.99 half price. Feverish, something was the name. I certainly didn’t need it. Why do I buy things without checking with you first!😊I feel the same about the ELF lip pens, I bought two of them. Very patchy even with lip primer. Thanks Jen for a great video,! Can’t wait for favorites! Hope all is well with you! We’re getting up to 8 inches of snow with 40 mph winds! Spring equinox, wuh, where!😂sending much love a big hug❣️🌹❤️😊
I've had my nyx pen a year and a half while I do not use it daily it has never dried out. it's still at the ready.
In your opinion, for more mature skin that's a little on the drier side ( I'm 55), what is the best cream and or liquid bronzer and blush? Are any high end products better than drug store? What is the best of both; is there a product that's just the best in your opinion? I do have texture, and my skin tone is pretty good, but a little uneven as most people have. I really enjoy your channel and am slowly converting to using drug store brands you recommend that are truly "the best!" Thank you for all of your hard work and expense in doing all of your research for us!!!
One more thing, if you don't mind. What is the best liquid eyeshadow as well, that's long wearing, non- creasing, and not drying?
Love from Greece 🇬🇷 ❤my beautiful Jen❤🎉
I completely agree with you about the Elf Pout Clout. A total disappointment for me.
I personally loved it, but I hate the click up pens and that needs to go, makes no sense. Even though I like the formula I won't buy another because of that.
Like your quarterly take on things.
ooh interesting, I also have dry skin and I had a very similar experience with the Catrice foundation except it didn't even look good at the beginning lol, but I did actually really like the Elf hydrating foundation and it looked very dewy on me!
Great video! Your hair looks so pretty in this video!
I tried the elf camo hydrating cc cream. It dried me out too! I love the it cosmetics hydrating in the green tube. So pretty and glpwy and last all day!
The original elf cc cream felt like paste on my skin, I was too afraid to even try the new one, thinking it would just be a waste of my money, glad I skipped it, my dry skin doesn’t need that.
That's crazy, bc my flower blush is super pigmented! I apply with brush off of my hand, I have to be super careful bc I always over due it! When I was watching you apply and I still wasn't seeing color I'm baffled!
I love your look in this one! Especially the eyeshadow!
I haven’t tried any of these products but a big flop for me this year was the It cosmetics new matte cc cream.. no matter how I applied it or how much or little I put on, my face was a cakey mess. Which sucked because the color match was spot on.
Jen, I love your makeup look. It's so youthful. I haven't tried anything recently. But appreciate your honest review on these popular drugstore items.
I can not tell how happy I am to watch this video Jen. I remember when you tried all of these products as I watch all of your videos and I have not really gotten any of them yet. I remember you saying some of the same things in the videos when you tried them, especially the Milk primer or skin tint. You said then that you did not see anything that it had done. So glad I won't be wasting my money now. Thank you so very much Jen. You never fail us.❤
Jen I am loving your look today! The straight hair and your shirt color are so flattering! Thank you for your honest reviews
I agree about the elf pout clout pens. I do not like it! I got one (apparently forgot about your review) and it sticks in my dry spots and is all thick and gloopy. Not great at all, and I like a lot of elf products.
I don’t understand how I’m finding such great eyeshadows on Amazon, but the drugstore brands just get it together! 🤷🏻♀️
These blushes were so pretty! One of my fave beach blushes is One Size Cheek Clapper in Phat Ass.
It's so interesting that you love the heavy glitters so much more because I feel like soft colors and glitters look so much more flattering on your light skin tone. You have such beautiful skin and soft make up brings that out even more. ❤🎉
Aw thank you! I actually don't like heavy glitters, I prefer minimal (or no) glitter, but a soft metallic sheen is my preference. The hard toppers they're coming out with now don't offer any color and the little micro-glitters get everywhere.
Thanks for the video it really helps me cause I trust your judgement...You look beautiful...
I wanted to try the elf clout pout but they don’t seem to be sold in stores anywhere. So when you didn’t like them it was an easy pass for me
They're at Walmart, I got one online. I am surprised she didn't like it, I'm 41 and it makes my lips so plump and smoothed the lines out well. The formula felt silky and glides beautifully. I was actually surprised I didn't regret the purchase 😅 Not getting another because I'm not a fan of the click pen, they're so dumb. But otherwise I had a very different experience and I wonder why. 🤔
Would love a review on Ulta Beauty eyeshadow Pallets I love them and no one talks about them >>> Thank you for all your hard work Love your videos
Thank you for this video! Some of the products I was debating on trying but I won’t waste my money on them. I trust your opinion and recommendations 😊 thank you for spending your $$ so we don’t have to! I did get the LA Girl brow pen after seeing you try it and love it the first time. I got the soft brown but it’s too light for me. I was going to get the dark brown but haven’t yet. I’m not going to now knowing it only lasts for a couple of weeks. That is crazy! I will stick with my maybelline ultra precise brow pencil. That is my favorite so far 😊 I bought the ELF Camo hydrating CC cream bc I have dry skin and I thought it would work for me. The regular one is too drying. Well so is the hydrating one 😒 it feels just like the original on my skin. Disappointing. I am loving the About Face the Performer Skin Focus foundation though! That sits beautifully on my skin and isn’t dry at all!😊 hope you have a great day! Hugs! 💖🌸
Bummed about LA girl brow pen running out fast. I had it on my list but just erased. Thanks for letting us know.
What about the build-a-brow pen? Is it smaller than the NYX and good cool brown color? I’ve always thought the Nyx pen marks were too thick. Just trying to find something thinner in the marker pen style.
I like the Kosas BB cream. With a light hand, and a good primer.
Bummer on the brow pencil 😔 it did look great. It looked so good I sent two to my dsughter 😮
I’ve had terrible foundation days…even with Lancôme, NARS and Estée Lauder. Yesterday I had a great foundation day with kopari sunscreen and purlisse cc cream. 🤞🏻this is the winning combo. I did order Clinique foundation because I’ve never tried it. I’m so pale that shade matching is an issue. Your content is sooooo good.
I also tried the LA girl nude eyeshadow palettes, and I did not care for them. The mattes were not too bad, but the shimmers were not pigmented and dry and chalky. I don't care for the glitter topper eyeshadows, they are not pigmented. Elf and wet n wild eyeshadows are so much better.
These videos are helpful! My skin eats blush-even blush marketed as long lasting. So, I will pass on those Revlon blushes, though they are tempting.
Have not tried these, thank goodnesss💲💲. Going to try your recommendations on the tried and true products.🎉🎉
Hi Jen! Thank you for reviewing these. I haven’t tried any of these that you have mentioned.
I saw a video recently talking about makeup trends for gen z, and it talked about how their eye shadows are less harsh, and a bit more subtle. More seamlessly blended and upturned. So, maybe that is coming through in those palettes (it is being marketed to give a more subtle look because that is on trend).
Not sure but was just a thought.
I appreciate your comment too about maybe they just didn't play nice with you. Some of the color might show up more on other skin tones. 🤷♀️
You may be right; there may be a trend coming through for more subtle eye shadow. We'll see.
From experience I haven’t found any “glowing” anything in makeup in the “drugstore” category! Everything that glows in the beginning doesn’t last for more than 5 minutes! Unless your skin is so hydrated that it shines! Then any makeup will look dewy or glowing on your skin! I guess if a high end one makes your skin look like that then it’s worth the splurge! 😮
I am new to your channel and I’m just loving it!! So glad I found you - thank you!❤️
Thank you so much! Welcome! 🥰
Hi from Portugal! I hated the Catrice foundation too! Used it once and threw it away! 🤦
LA Girl has really good eyeliners!!! Ther good for tightlining ur upper eyelid and they don't transfer at all
Yes they do! Love those!
I like your hair like this, Jen.
Andrea Matilliano said the exact same thing about the L.A. Girl brow pen! If 2 of my 3 favorite O.G. creators of all time say the same thing about the same product....my attention in UNDIVIDED!
Thanks Jen! These are my favorite videos you make! I loved these… I hated these… I like your dupes vids too. Would love a brush tutorial… when to used what ❤
Loving the cool toned ashy hair color....that suits you very well, congrats 🎉😅
Thank you! It's been this color for a long time but my lighting was making it look so yellow. I adjusted my lights. 🥰
Jen, you look great in this video. Like, you've gotta Jennifer Aniston/Avril Lavigne look going on. I love it!
Now, on another note, I love your honesty when it comes to your reviews. So many influencers make so many ridiculous claims that do nothing more than disappoint their viewers`and I dont appreciate that. I hardly ever buy products that influencers recommend or review because of what I observe with the products in their videos. There might be a few things I'll get, but its all based on what I observe, the price, and its uniqueness. What may look great on someone else may not look great on me. I know what I like, what I prefer, and what I will use. With that said, I enjoy trying new things as well. I agree these products are overrated and disappointing.
Hi Jen, I like that you are doing quarterly round up (best & worst) products) it’s better for you and for us, i enjoyed this video. Love Katherine xoxo
Did u get the Dior Smokey Essentials pallet? The taupe and grey shades together are soooooooo perfect for me it would look great on you too were very similar lol it’s my new favorite go to look with Natasha D lipstick in Noa and 3.5 storme liner perfect neutrals lol every shade in that pallet is perfect 🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍
Hey Jen! You look fabulous! I haven't tried any of these products, but thanks for reminding me that I don't want to! Happy Sunday! And I hope you're feeling the holidays and secure in your knowledge of the true meaning: Holy Days. God is good!
Yes! God is good! 🙏🙏❤️❤️
I love the Flower beauty blush wand in cheeky. I wear it almost everyday since it came out. I apply it straight to my face & blend it out with the elf complexion duo brush. Mine are pretty pigmented but buildable on my fair to light skin without lifting any foundation. Sorry it didn’t work for you. I love the formula ❤
I got the Catrice foundation and have been a little disappointed too. Still trying it. I love the elf hydrating cc cream though!
Omg, strong fragrance is a total minefield for me, since I have sinus and when I smell something very strong, I'm just gonna sneeze a lot.
I love your hair today! ❤
Jen youve got to try cover girl clean fresh brow pencils. They are a close dupe to the tiny benefit brow pencils. They are so small and work so good. I havent heard anyone talking about them and im shocked. They are sooo good!!
Have u tried the Maybelline build a brow everyone is raving bout the pen part of it.
Yes, it's not bad...I don't like the gel on the other side though!
@@JenPhelps thats what everyone is also saying.
I had the same reaction to the Elf Camo Hydrating CC cream. It might be better for oily skin. It's nothing like the It Cosmetics CC cream.
Oh no! I just bought two bottles of that Catrice skin tint... I have dry, mature skin so I don't have hope 😑. And thank you for the heads up about the Make Beauty eyeshadows.. I was just about to pull the trigger on those instead I will go with Moira! ❤
I have it for a year now, since I live in an European country and my tip is use a brush or a make up spatula unstead of your fingers or just a sponge.
Hi Jen. I love your hair 💕
Hey Jen! If you want a skin tint that does not fade, crease or look dry, you got to try the new one from Lisa Eldrige. It's expensive, but worth it. I've tried everything on this 68 year old dry skin and this is surely the best! You only need two to three drops and is buildable.
I definitely want to try it...I love her regular foundation so I have a feeling the skin tint is great!
I can’t tolerate blushes that go on sheer. On my skin tone, they truly do not show up. I also have become wary of certain inexpensive brow and eyeliner products that have so little product in them they are gone right away. No matter how inexpensive they are, they are their own kind of rip off.
Can you do a CC cream review?
maybe you could dip LA GIRL pen into another product in order to make use of the fine tip? IDK.
That's actually a great idea!
I read that Catrice foundation is for dry skin. It brings out the dryness in me, just like you.
I prefer the Catrice HD foundation, of which I have the old version though
I thought it was for dry skin too, so I was even more surprised!
Wow,..lots of surprises. Your hair looks so nice. You look 20 years younger ❤
I really dislike the hard pan/topper shades. Lime Crime did some of these years ago and I never bought another one of their palettes. They’re finicky and I don’t need makeup frustration.
❤Thanks for the honest reviews!
Thank you Jen! Have you tried kokie micro brow pencil? One on my favorites
No I haven't! I've been using brow pens mostly these days but I'll put it on my list to try!
@@JenPhelps 🧡😘
Love your hair! Looks very nice 😃
Are their other Neutrogena cosmetics that you've tried that you could share with us? I've tried a few of their products and I am pleased with the few I've tried so far 😊 Thanks Jen 💕
Yes! I talked about quite a few favorites in this video recently: ua-cam.com/video/RGDaqRNp6b0/v-deo.htmlsi=-DRJVtBYymFPUpop
I love the maybelline bulid a brow. Not as messy as the NYX.
I like that one but I'm not a fan of the gel on the other side.
@@JenPhelps I don't use the gel because I don't even have enough brow hair to use the gel 😂
Thank you so much for all the previews ❤
I’m a huge Catrice cosmetics fan.. however when I got the catrice glow my bottle was empty!! I always order from the catrice website and they immediately reimbursed me.. they are very good to refund.. and that’s the only product I have ever been disappointed in by catrice!