Babylon 5 Newbies React to 4x14 | Moments of Transition | First Time Watching

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 121

  • @chrisfraser5088
    @chrisfraser5088 13 днів тому +30

    RIP Neroon 😢 Went out like an absolute legend.

    • @toddkes5890
      @toddkes5890 12 днів тому +2

      Remember a previous comment by Marcus to Neroon, in the s3e19 episode 'Grey 17 is Missing' - "The next time you want a revelation, could you possibly find a way that isn't quite so uncomfortable"

    • @cutthr0atjake
      @cutthr0atjake 5 днів тому +1

      Neroon is my favourite character in the whole series. His character arc is fantastic.

  • @darrenbabidge4694
    @darrenbabidge4694 13 днів тому +63

    The reveal that the starfire wheel was Neroon and Delenne's plan all along to prove Shakiri was a coward is perfect. The sacrifice Neroon makes is just peak B5. For such little screen time it's just soooo good.

    • @RKnights
      @RKnights  13 днів тому +14

      That was so well done

  • @RangerChris61
    @RangerChris61 13 днів тому +23

    While he will always be known for playing Chekov, Bester is his magnum opus.

  • @dunringill1747
    @dunringill1747 13 днів тому +33

    This is such a great episode. Delenn making the power move. Neroon going out like a boss. Sheridan fed up and willing to go head to head with Earth.
    As for Michael Garibaldi, it's ok to hate him or be annoyed at the story progress. Just make sure you aren't missing out on what is really happening. Story seeds are being planted here. That's all I want to say.

    • @this.is.a.username
      @this.is.a.username 12 днів тому +5

      the only bad writing from JMS that really made me dislike an episode was his abysmal treatment of Lyta. There's no way Sheridan wouldn't have had her join the staff after all she'd done for him and the station.

    • @tjtenser7828
      @tjtenser7828 12 днів тому +1

      @@this.is.a.username The treatment and disrespect of Lyta is one of my few gripes about the series. I'm really not a fan of the Garibaldi storyline this season too.

  • @chriscoombes6751
    @chriscoombes6751 13 днів тому +13

    RIP Neroon, you think he's played Delenn, then not only does he show his true allegiance - he pulls a God-tier move to unite his people with the ultimate sacrifice!
    Also one of the most chilling lines in Sci-fi: Bester ''Yes: I've had a nice day''.

  • @rufustrotman4322
    @rufustrotman4322 12 днів тому +4

    The Garibaldi plotline is something of a slow burner, but then again who would have thought that a well presented man asking the ambassadors "what do you want?" would've been the harbinger of the whole shadow war (including Garabaldi's disappearance at the end of S3, and his changed personality on his return)?
    Stick with it, the players are moving into place, the payoff really is worth it.

  • @martintoggweiler2343
    @martintoggweiler2343 10 днів тому +2

    Not sure when you plan to rewatch, but back in S1 when we first meet Neroon, he was Branmer’s lieutenant, the sha-aylit whose dead body was to be put on display. Branmer had originally been religious caste but became warrior after the killing Dukhat. Neroon completes the circle, born a warrior but becomes religious caste right before the Starfire Wheel disintegrates him.

  • @thomasriddle7005
    @thomasriddle7005 12 днів тому +3

    Don't forget about the time Garibaldi was missing. I'll just leave it at that. Also, this may be Bester at his shadiest, and I love it.

  • @william_santiago
    @william_santiago 13 днів тому +12

    12:37 Mr. Adams is actually SCOTT Adams of Dilbert cartoon strip fame. This is his only live acting role from what I know.

    • @hyloguy6847
      @hyloguy6847 12 днів тому

      Yeah, back when he seemed to be sane and not political, and could be a fun cameo all nerds could appreciate. Who could have known then how he would descend into MAGA madness to the point of getting axed from newspaper syndication last year due to making racist remarks.

  • @catprog
    @catprog 13 днів тому +4

    27:00
    5 worker class
    4 non warrior (2 religious + 2 warrior)

  • @michaelconnor1542
    @michaelconnor1542 13 днів тому +11

    Remember the pay-off here?
    Trust in JMS for Garibaldi.

  • @pedanticperson1149
    @pedanticperson1149 13 днів тому +15

    Such a powerful episode, with Delenn & the Starfire wheel, Sheridan at the end deciding that they're going to war, you're going to love the rest of the season.
    I've always felt the problems Lyta faces were a little contrived, it would be so out of character for Sheridan & the others to leave her struggling like this; especially given how valuable she is as a resource, but also just because they would want to help her. It's not like providing her with room & board (in exchange for her working for them) would be too difficult.

    • @AndrewLuke
      @AndrewLuke 13 днів тому

      I dunno. What she faces is down to negligence. That's how people get kicked out of their homes. It's an interesting thread for discussion though.

    • @pedanticperson1149
      @pedanticperson1149 13 днів тому +2

      @@AndrewLuke Yes, but giving her room & board in exchange for her help, when it's needed, wouldn't be difficult for them. That makes this a narrative choice*, but it's one I think is out of character for Sheridan & the others.
      *which we can't really get into without spoilers.

    • @toddkes5890
      @toddkes5890 13 днів тому +2

      Especially since Sheridan diverted some of the budget to pay for his larger quarters. This was a bad move by Sheridan; imagine if someone had come along to hire Lyta for a job off-station right before Sheridan had realized that they would need her help.

  • @bankbarcomo806
    @bankbarcomo806 12 днів тому +2

    28:50 This War of Mine. I could only play it for several hours or so, so depressing.

  • @joeychicago6436
    @joeychicago6436 13 днів тому +8

    HELL YEAH! these are the episodes we were waiting for you to get to!
    You heard season 5 is weak, but, it also has a cluster of vicious episodes.

  • @JRcomments
    @JRcomments 13 днів тому +9

    "You should have thought about that before you tore our people apart." That line aged like fine wine.....sadly.

    • @Grimloxz
      @Grimloxz 13 днів тому

      How?

    • @levenkay4468
      @levenkay4468 13 днів тому +1

      @@Grimloxz JRcomments may be remembering the oft-repeated "enemy from within", characterizations of those evil people who opposed Dear Orange Leader.

    • @Grimloxz
      @Grimloxz 13 днів тому

      @@levenkay4468 Ahhhhh

    • @Grimloxz
      @Grimloxz 13 днів тому

      @@levenkay4468 A lot of time left yet too, unfortunately…

  • @MarvinNoFun
    @MarvinNoFun 12 днів тому +2

    Minbari don't kill Minbari. As much as they don't lie. Never. And they don't poop neither.

  • @davidb1565
    @davidb1565 13 днів тому +9

    You guys missed a couple of crucial lines in your understandable excitement. One from Neroon right after Delenn shows she is staying in the fire and another from Bester as he is monologuing about what a good day he has had, listen to what he says about Michael.

  • @connorwatson6766
    @connorwatson6766 13 днів тому +9

    Bester is an amazing villain, and a lot of it is that he's the hero in his own mind, he's doing everything to help his people, Telepaths. He is a hero to them, and to the average Earther. He's only a villain to us and the B5 crew.

  • @this.is.a.username
    @this.is.a.username 12 днів тому +1

    Just finished watching a react to the series finale. oh i cannot wait for you boyos to get to that point.

  • @Jagaroth_
    @Jagaroth_ 13 днів тому +1

    A few more twists and turns with Jerrybaldi, but it WILL be worth it in the end, Ray.

  • @Jacana2k6
    @Jacana2k6 12 днів тому +1

    One of my favorite episodes. Just all around so good. I can listen to Mira/Delenn do the long speeches all day. Amazing job by John Vickery/ Neroon and Walter Koenig/ Bester.

  • @sword4005
    @sword4005 13 днів тому +15

    really hated how little the main cast treated lyta this episode, after all she sacrificed, and they kicked her out of apartment without even telling her in person, treated her like nothing and that forced her to accept besters help, shame on them

    • @RKnights
      @RKnights  13 днів тому +4

      That is so true. She has done so much for Babylon 5 and the crew. She did not deserve that. At least not the way they handled it

    • @shootingreal5945
      @shootingreal5945 13 днів тому +1

      Well no spoilers but it sets her character up as far as her decisions moving forward but it was bad how they treated her.

    • @matthewteague623
      @matthewteague623 12 днів тому +2

      I agree completely. But , From a certain point of view, it makes it more believeable. Sheridan and the rest of the command crew aren't saints. All-too-human faults like taking people for granted, and not even thinking about someone else's troubles because you're preoccupied with what's in front of you, is entirely plausible. It's a failing, absolutely. Sheridan should have been taking steps to take care of Lyta. But it's a failure that's easy to see happen when they're used to military command structures, or dealing with foreign governments.

  • @kelaarin
    @kelaarin 13 днів тому +2

    Yes, while Delenn was willing to die to prove her point, Neroon’s sacrifice meant that the Warrior caste technically won the civil war. But then he handed over the victory to Delenn, by switching castes, and telling them to listen to her.

  • @jakephocas1396
    @jakephocas1396 13 днів тому +8

    WE TOLD YOU that there were S-tier episodes coming! This is just one!
    This is not Game of Thrones. Your patience will be rewarded.
    Think of it this way; it's so good now, you think it's sex, but it's just foreplay. Sex is not here yet!
    You'll understand by the end of the season.

    • @stuartanderws5705
      @stuartanderws5705 13 днів тому

      All good things come to those how weight. There will be some many good things to come.

  • @maximillianmetscher7020
    @maximillianmetscher7020 12 днів тому +1

    As the man said. This is where the fun begins

  • @SirMarshalHaig
    @SirMarshalHaig 13 днів тому +8

    Shakiri: This is madness! *jumps out of the ring*
    Neroon: This
    Is
    Minbar! *kicks him back*

  • @derekramsaroup3883
    @derekramsaroup3883 13 днів тому +12

    OK,I'll admit it ...Sheridan scared the crap out of me at the end .. and I'm on His side !...

    • @Ower8x
      @Ower8x 12 днів тому +1

      Thats what Delen meant when she said he was hiding his Dangerous side from them ....

  • @chrisdavies9821
    @chrisdavies9821 13 днів тому +5

    The massacre of civilians at Proxima directly echoes the demand by the Warrior Caste in regards to the Minbari capital. Delenn and Neroon choose to interpret the orders in a way that was in stark contrast to the way that the Earth Force crew did. As for the storyline regarding Garabaldi - you are forgetting it's B5! Slow and steady and build the ground work for what is too come. If you hadn't watched the Shadow build up - would the massacre of the Narn or the Shadow/Vorlon War been as memorable? In watching B5 - watch for the breadcrumbs that lead to the conclusion

  • @Netherburn
    @Netherburn 13 днів тому +1

    Neroon also changing caste to religious before his death placed the religious caste in power.

  • @keithborders2375
    @keithborders2375 13 днів тому +11

    Hold on to your butts… the rest of the season is insanely good!!

  • @PurpleDrazi
    @PurpleDrazi 13 днів тому +7

    Mr Garibaldi's story isn't quite done yet . . . 🙃

  • @dbell1016
    @dbell1016 13 днів тому +2

    Micheal Garibaldi's story line , when resolved , will hit as hard as " He is behind me, you are in front of me... " . Be patient !!!

  • @dbell1016
    @dbell1016 13 днів тому +2

    Thanks!

  • @StaK_1980
    @StaK_1980 13 днів тому +3

    There were a couple of thing that I didn't like about this episode then, and I don't like it now.
    Neroons turn at the very last second was kind of strained in my opinion. This "I'm mixed!" revelation at the end felt forced.
    Also Delenn is an absolute power player: she didn't get her way with the original council, so she disbanded it. Now she got to chose and form the new one to her liking. Her putting the leader on the spot was also an definitve power move.
    I'd hate to play poker against her. :-P

    • @toddkes5890
      @toddkes5890 12 днів тому

      Delenn at least made certain that it was not her caste in control. She couldn't leave the Warrior caste in its original strength after the fighting. She couldn't leave her Religious Caste greater than the Warrior caste. That means she had to give the positions to the Worker Caste. Representatives of the ordinary people, that have not been seen as main characters, are now in control.

  • @TheSPoS
    @TheSPoS 13 днів тому +1

    Top episode.

  • @Haldurson
    @Haldurson 13 днів тому +4

    You don't need to be an AI to be on call 24 hours a day -- Several years ago, before I retired, I had a job where I had to be on call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. In my job description, I was the 'technical guru' in our IT department. Whenever there was a software issue, I'd be the guy that would be called, if the 'official' on call person was stumped or unavailable (eg. not answering his or her phone). I once worked all night over a New Years Eve. I've had to dial in while I was visiting a friends house. I've had to leave movie theaters, and restaurants. (I even had to drive into work immediately after ordering my meal at a fancy restaurant with co-workers and my boss. I've worked 72 hours straight on some weekends. Welcome to the wonderful world of IT.

  • @farvencore
    @farvencore 13 днів тому +3

    I am ready.

  • @SSPerfectChaosRCT
    @SSPerfectChaosRCT 13 днів тому +1

    You've probably already seen the episodes. And believe me, I understand your frustration with Garibaldi's story. But this is going to be one of those stories with the unsatisfying pay off, but the most realistic possible ending. That's what I'll say about that.

  • @superzentredi
    @superzentredi 11 днів тому +1

    The threat of cancellation (yes, they actually wanted to CANCEL this great show) really can amp up the story from this point, sadly we never got to see the full scope of the slower burn vision the creators had in mind because it was supposed to run for 5 seasons with the current story arcs. They do a great job with the time they have left.

  • @ale8oneale8one22
    @ale8oneale8one22 13 днів тому +4

    It's worth it 100%

  • @bcsr4ever
    @bcsr4ever 13 днів тому +2

    I know they needed it for plot reasons, but seriously if I was Sheridan I would have put Lyta on a paid retainer with B5 as the station telepath and provide quarters. I fully blame Sheridan for this oversight.

  • @philmarston9078
    @philmarston9078 13 днів тому +5

    She many things to say. Be patient with the Garibaldi story. The payoff is amazing.

  • @ingotdearth
    @ingotdearth 13 днів тому +2

    a comment and thumbs up - great episode

  • @xaemosxone
    @xaemosxone 13 днів тому +2

    Remember the WHITE STAR ships are part Vorlon, Part Membari and very little earth tech. So actually the White Star ships are more advanced than all other ships.

  • @ScottRutter
    @ScottRutter 13 днів тому +2

    "Moments of Transition"
    🎶 This is the eye of the hurricane. This is the only way I can protect my legacy! 🎶 #Ham4B5

  • @Rangera-ct1xu
    @Rangera-ct1xu 13 днів тому +1

    that was the man who created dilbert. the cat is catbert, the dog is dogbert. and yes they are trying to take over the galaxy.

  • @Grimloxz
    @Grimloxz 13 днів тому +1

    Clarke goes full Bibi.

  • @neilbiggs1353
    @neilbiggs1353 13 днів тому +1

    I know you don't want to hear this, but keep waiting on Garribaldi...

  • @ryanlynn
    @ryanlynn 11 днів тому +1

    Don't worry Garibaldi's Fall and Redemption will be worth it.

  • @stuartanderws5705
    @stuartanderws5705 13 днів тому +1

    You get one big thing an episode, so Neroon this week, Graybody has to hold off for a bit. When it happens you will not miss it. and the next episode I could watch over and over it's that good. You don't have long now.

  • @atwalhome
    @atwalhome 13 днів тому +5

    *SLAP*
    Keep Mr Garibaldi's name outta your mouth 😂 👍

  • @StevenJShow
    @StevenJShow 13 днів тому +13

    This is one of those pivot point episodes.
    JMS wrote most of season 3 himself, which shows clearly in its consistent voice throughout, and the subtle elements that arc from episode to episode.
    Season 4 is also majority written by JMS, and I think from here to the end is just a damn roller coaster ride, and one of my favorite episodes is still to come. I can't wait.

    • @cruelangel8689
      @cruelangel8689 13 днів тому +7

      JMS wrote all of seasons 3 and 4. His unbroken streak started towards the end of season 2 up through the first part of season 5.

    • @RKnights
      @RKnights  13 днів тому +9

      This episode was so powerful

  • @sergioaccioly5219
    @sergioaccioly5219 7 днів тому

    About following orders, after WW 2 the germans started teaching their soldiers that "no superior officer ranks higher than your conscience".
    More militaries should teach their personnel this lesson.

  • @alfhughes6571
    @alfhughes6571 10 днів тому +1

    who doesn`t want Lyta?

  • @Carl_Gustav_Häyhä
    @Carl_Gustav_Häyhä 13 днів тому +3

    Delenn doesn't quite understand what surrendering means. If I were that warcast leader, I would have said "Nope... I don't like this. Let's continue Bombings. Neroon! Come here! Guards!"

    • @matthewteague623
      @matthewteague623 13 днів тому +6

      The point is, had Shakiri done that, neither. Neroon nor any other Warrior would have obeyed him. Your soldiers aren’t mindless robots or video game NPC’s. They only obey you so long as they decide you are worthy of their loyalty.

    • @Carl_Gustav_Häyhä
      @Carl_Gustav_Häyhä 13 днів тому +1

      @@matthewteague623 OMG! My child, if You don't obey an order on any level on any army, You will immediately be in big trouble

    • @dnocturn84
      @dnocturn84 13 днів тому +3

      @@Carl_Gustav_Häyhä The point is, that all of this was broadcasted to every Minbari out there. They all would witness them breaking and violating the ancient traditions they all claimed to follow, because of simple fear, which is also against the very nature of their warrior caste. He should have studied the significance of this meeting ground and any potential drawbacks involved first. Or he should have just straight up went for the sacrifice, which is a hard thing to do, if it's your own selfish ambition that is driving you.

    • @DeonTain
      @DeonTain 13 днів тому +2

      If Shakiri had walked away the warrior cast would have won. However he would not have stayed in power long. Having fought a war to establish that might makes right and then shown himself to be a coward, there would be warrior caste lining up to fight him for leadership. His only chance to both win and hold on to control of the warrior cast was to accept the challenge and win. He lost because he valued his own position over the victory of the warrior caste.

    • @walkir2662
      @walkir2662 10 днів тому

      @@Carl_Gustav_Häyhä If one guy refuses to execute an order, it's that guy's problem. If enough of the army refuses, the guy giving the order is in trouble. (you owe the bank 1,000, you're in trouble. You owe the bank 10,000,000,000, the bank is in trouble)

  • @JeshuaSquirrel
    @JeshuaSquirrel 13 днів тому +5

    This episode is one of the major changes from the original plan written before the show started. The Minbari civil war was always going to happen. But the Warrior Caste was going to win, take over the government, and start a Minbari v Earther rematch. If you recall the flashforward Sinclair saw in season 1, that flashforward was supposed to be near the end of season 5 and it was the Minbari Warrior caste boarding the station.

  • @sergioaccioly5219
    @sergioaccioly5219 7 днів тому

    The way Lyta was treated in this episode (and others) wasn't only unjust, it was moronic. She is too valuable an asset to be treated that shabbily.

  • @lizd2943
    @lizd2943 13 днів тому +3

    What if they both die in the Starfire Wheel? Then two more step up? Then two more? What if they all killed themselves.

    • @ianstopher9111
      @ianstopher9111 13 днів тому

      ...one by one, and those who follow us
      and those who follow them...
      ...on and on, every race, every planet,
      until there's no one left to kill.

  • @duaneswab3420
    @duaneswab3420 3 дні тому

    Did y'alll recognize Scott Adams, the creator of Dilbert? He was looking for his dog and his cat, i.e. Dogbert and Catbert from his cartoon strip.

  • @aexious
    @aexious 13 днів тому +1

    Delenn is part human. It wouldn't kill her.

  • @BubbaFett00
    @BubbaFett00 13 днів тому +4

    I love Koenig infinently better as Bester than Chekov

  • @MrTickleTrunk
    @MrTickleTrunk 13 днів тому +2

    🔥

  • @shomeghuy7226
    @shomeghuy7226 13 днів тому +3

    What would you say to the freaks who say season 5 sucks?

  • @corneliusoverton2617
    @corneliusoverton2617 13 днів тому +5

    Mr. Adams, is Scott Adams, the cartoonist who wrote the Dilbert comics. Hence the dog and cat references.

  • @KymPridham
    @KymPridham 13 днів тому +1

    Do you really think Lise is married to an AI?

  • @TechnoMageB5
    @TechnoMageB5 3 дні тому

    6:52 "Death is simply the release from our obligation."
    I see even Minbari like to plagiarize G'Kar...

  • @aaronleffew9593
    @aaronleffew9593 13 днів тому +4

    You're gonna hate michael for a while. It'll be worth it though

    • @RKnights
      @RKnights  13 днів тому +2

      I hate that I hate him

    • @matthewteague623
      @matthewteague623 13 днів тому +1

      That too, is as it should be. We know Michael is and should be better than this. We just know, right now, he’s not better than this, and urge to throttle him and ask whatsamattau is very large.

  • @biocapsule7311
    @biocapsule7311 13 днів тому +4

    Delenn didn't take the post of the Grey Council because she is already 'the One who is', the head of the Rangers. Ranger One is a separate apolitical position from the council, who duty is to inform and advise the council with the intel the Rangers have. Not to be involve in ruling the Minbari. Valen/Sinclair founded both the Council, followed by the Rangers. He was never part of the council, he was 'the One', and when the Rangers came later, he become Ranger One. So Traditionally Ranger One stands outside the Council.
    And the US military for example, sworn to obey the order of the 'office of the presidency', to protect the constitution and the country. So there some interpretation to that. Currently from what I heard, Trump apparently wants the military to sworn a new oath to him personally, not the office of the presidency. I doubt he could ever make that happen, but that's what he wants.

    • @shootingreal5945
      @shootingreal5945 13 днів тому

      Please tell me what speech he ( Trump) made stating that..if you can't it's nothing more than one's personal opinion.

  • @tomriddle8273
    @tomriddle8273 13 днів тому +3

    I hope you guys like crow because you're gonna have to eat it for Garabaldi soon lol at least turkey day is coming up to help wash it down

  • @gallendugall8913
    @gallendugall8913 13 днів тому +4

    You are supposed to be angry at Garibaldi.
    That makes what happens next have more impact.

    • @pedanticperson1149
      @pedanticperson1149 13 днів тому +1

      Shhhh...

    • @mightheal
      @mightheal 13 днів тому +1

      He gets that but he's also right about Garibaldi's storyline progresses to slowly this season.

    • @RKnights
      @RKnights  13 днів тому

      Taking so long

  • @gallendugall8913
    @gallendugall8913 13 днів тому +7

    Peter Woodward, one of my favorite underrated actors, does play a Technomage primary cast member in one of the spin off series... which were all bad.

    • @connorwatson6766
      @connorwatson6766 13 днів тому +5

      I'm not going to argue that Crusade was great, because it wasn't, but it had it's moments.

    • @gallendugall8913
      @gallendugall8913 13 днів тому +3

      @@connorwatson6766 Agreed

    • @StevenJShow
      @StevenJShow 13 днів тому +5

      It had potential.
      The single worst part of Crusade was that they jettisoned Christopher Franke for that guy who's musical composition amounted to random synth beats and fart noises.
      Had Crusade been given a fair shake, I think it would have turned out excellent.

    • @connorwatson6766
      @connorwatson6766 13 днів тому +3

      @StevenJShow If it wasn't cancelled before the first episode was shown, it might have done well

    • @JeshuaSquirrel
      @JeshuaSquirrel 13 днів тому +5

      Crusade was ruined by TNT. The network forced the show to rework the series after five episodes had already been shot. Then those five were shown last. Additionally, the very next episode that would have been produced would have been the first heavy arc episode.

  • @connorwatson6766
    @connorwatson6766 13 днів тому +4

    Don't be patient with Garibaldi, you're supposed to feel the way you do. Everything will be explained when it makes sense for it to be explained. It's just as good as the other stories, it's just taking longer.

    • @shootingreal5945
      @shootingreal5945 13 днів тому +1

      Exactly..as a matter of fact, it's really compelling when we find out the why of it all.