"Well, that's no fair. I can't eat them now." Then he waits until sunrise, checking his watch from time to time, hoping they regain consciousness... but eventually just slithers off disappointed.
this has to be one of my favorite Are You Scared. The twists and turns, initially thinking Hans was betraying them only to realize he'd sacrificed himself for his friends. Uggh. What a story.
I think it depends which owner you toured with (I know it changed not many years back) or if it was one of the tour guides hired for the season. Personally I thought it was from a diff asylum not in WI 😅
It’s from the no sleep subreddit. I don’t think it’s a real urban legend which is a shame because Wisconsin does have a lot of urban legends. Source- I’m from Milwaukee
There's no way that the person who wrote the story is even from Sheboygan, probably not even from Wisconsin.. based on the fact that they think people in Milwaukee and Madison don't know that Sheboygan exists. Dude, everyone in the entire state knows about Sheboygan! If only because of how fun it is to say 😉 but also because it's really not that small; it almost makes the top ten biggest cities. So I wouldn't worry that, being from Sheboygan, you haven't heard this story.
@@wayward.philosophercan confirm as a Minnesotan whose uncle lives near Sheboygan and would always mention the town when he visited it always stuck out as a kid because it's one of those words that is spelt exactly how you think it would be and it's very fun to say
@@AccessizzyI feel hesitation at rendering a verdict with the language of cancelling in a sincere way; to answer what I think you’re asking people have historically called folks with perceived or diagnosed develop/mental disorders “slow” as in a thing you are, not a descriptor of an action you take, like your brain itself is “slow” in a pejorative way. Like calling someone “special” not phrased as a good thing. In addition to that I’d also say folks can have trouble processing as quickly as others regardless of whatever measure of intelligence so at most charitable interpretation it’s not very aware of human variety
People also use “slow” as a code word for disabled (similar to the way some people will describe something as “urban” when they mean Black)-it treats disability/disabled as taboo when in reality it’s a part of the breadth of human experience
19:37 JUSTICE FOR MARK!!!! Shane ran away first at Waverly! On Buzzfeed Unsolved's Almost 70th Episode special, during Mark's interview segment (7:40), he says that the most scared he had ever been was in Waverly because it was creepy and that was the first time Shane got scared (Shane mentions that everybody was a little terrified there; Ryan adds that Waverly is "comically horrific"). Mark goes on to remember that they were in the body chute hearing weird croak noises, and he was okay thinking it was just a frog. But then, Shane goes "what's that noise?". Mark's camera moves around a bit and the footage gets dark, then the light is back on and you can see Shane running way ahead of Mark (9:02). Mark says, "And if Shane runs and I'm left behind, I'd be terrified because if Shane is afraid, I gotta be", to which Ryan agrees saying that "It must be something real then." Shane, you absolutely left Mark behind 😭
"They got in and out in the asylum???😮 I didn't know doordash delivered to those places" 😮💨 Lemme tell you... We do.. I once delivered to a place that was essentially a prison for children and I've never felt more downtrodden in my life after leaving somewhere 😢
@@greasymoth4172 basically I roll up to this place that's kinda far away from everything else in town and has a long "driveway" to get to and tall fences and light posts outside but the light posts have cute paintings on them like butterflies and stuff like that and behind the fences I can see playgrounds. I immediately get this weird feeling in my stomach and when I drop off the food there's a guy outside that's like a janitor and I straight up ask him "what is this place?" And he kinda hangs his head a little and avoids eye contact and gets a little choked up and says: 😭🥺" a children's correctional facility." Listen I know kids do bad stuff and get in trouble sometimes but something about seeing the actual playground and paintings and knowing they're in jail... Idk man it broke something in me and obviously in that guy too. It's a different kinda sad... 💔
@@sunflowerglo1771 lots of kids get tried as adults too - people too young to drive or vote getting treated as grown ass adults by the law. it's really fucked up, and people don't want to change anything because they think punishment is the same as justice.
@@sunflowerglo1771 there's lots of non-profits that try and advocate for incarcerated children! You should do some research, there might be something for children in your area.
As someone from Wisconsin, we have a weird mix of the most normal people combined with unhinged weirdos. My theory is the miserable winter months driving us insane.
New England here and I can say the same. But then again there is "FL man", but people who go through 4 seasons seam to have an edge to them the south doesn't.
I mean isn’t that most states? Although I will say I did see a guy riding a tractor while walking his dog (like the dog was walking on the side of the road and he was in his tractor)… so maybe you’re right
@@Aw-ns1qxid imagine never ending summers and hurricanes probably have similar affects on the mind as long winters, and as a resident of Ohio I can confirm we get the worst of both sides and thus our people are the worst
As someone who has had several concussions, I hate when characters have "mild concussions" after being unconscious for at least several minutes if not hours. Of course Jimmy doesn't remember anything that happened, he has permanent brain damage.
I know about Sheboygan because there was an episode of the Beetlejuice cartoon where he tells himself a joke. He mumbles quietly and then yells “SHEBOYGAN!” and laughs hysterically
As someone from Milwaukee…saying “Sheboygan is just a little town no one knows about us owo 🥺” is crazy. There’s a lot of National boat racing competitions and surfing competitions there because of Lake Michigan having big waves. That’s the craziest part of this story
Yeah, I thought the same thing that that was the weirdest part of the story! No way the author is even from the state IMHO. Also, I think those surfing competitions are international level. I thought I'd read it was the freshwater surfing capital of the world.
The intro had several weird bits like that; not sure why they try to break the reader's engagement right from the start. Thankfully the rest, once it gets into the story proper, was solid.
@@CourtZilligenreally? Bear's fans coined the term cheese heads, not us. We just rolled with it. Also, a ton of you use WI as tax haven and come to our lakes on the weekend. But, sure, you don't think of us 😉
@@saraharmstrong6442no it’s from the no sleep subreddit. Someone made it up. There’s other urban legends from Wisconsin tho like boy-scout lane, bloody bride bridge, the phantom man, siren bridge, hogsback road, u of madison mass murder, rhinelander hodag, beast of bray road, etc. Surprised they haven’t been to the famous asylum where Rosemary Kennedy was forced to live in after her lobotomy called St. Coletta’s. We really are famous for our serial killers, dairy, alcohol, and asylums.
I think that was legitimately top 3 stories on this show. I have to go rewatched the other two and see what place it was. I had no idea what the twist could have meant until the last sentence. And it was actually funny and scary. 10/10
I grew up in Sheboygan Falls, right outside of Sheboygan. My dad’s grandpa was a barber at the asylum, my dad talks about it sometimes. I drive there sometimes and sit along the road and sing (outside the fence, the owners are known for not being forgiving to trespassers). It was my favorite place to drive when I was in high school, the south side Walmart parking lot is close by and we didn’t exactly have much to do. The asylum is actually a peaceful place in the middle of the country. As a mentally ill person, it reminds me of how far we’ve come. That being said, the owners made it into a haunted attraction. It makes me sad tbh. I’ve always wanted to explore there. Sheboygan is a small and fairly tight knit community. Everyone knows everyone somehow. I feel a special kind of community with those who were treated there. Also, never heard of milk white lol
Glad you have good memories of growing up there, but Sheboygan itself is not that small, at least not now. It's almost 50,000 people and the 13th biggest city in the state. Also, Milk white was clearly made up by someone not from there... i.e. they claimed people in Milwaukee and Madison don't know Sheboygan exists.. ridiculous!
@@wayward.philosopheryeah lol I figured out they didn’t actually live there as soon as they said the hospital was right off the highway. It’s really really not lmao. It is fun to hear a different perception of my hometown from someone else :3
The twist of Hans sacrificing himself is actually heartbreaking and scary because it leaves you to imagine what exactly happened to him. The horror of being dragged away while your friends are unconscious.
Amidst all the fowl scandals hitting UA-cam recently, Can we please all take a moment to thank the social media gods that Watcher's biggest scandal has been the time they tried to switch to a monthly subscription model? We stan
When you guys bring back Mystery Files can you please do episodes on the following: -Where is Canadian Clubs hidden whiskey? -Where are the hidden Gems of the Book "The Secret"? -The Kentucky Alien invasion in the 1950's -The mysterious birds of Audubon's "Birds of America" book -The Montana Hyena -The mysterious abandonment of Portlock Alaska -The theories of what is behind the Missing 411 cases in the US. -Kasperov vs Deep Blue computer -What hit Officer Val Johnsons Car? -Why are there Piranhas in Americas Waterways? -Dalnegorsk Spaceship remnants. -What did Captain Mantell encounter over FT. Knox? -Who were the Sea People that collapsed the Bronze Age Civilizations? -The strange encounter between Woodrow Derenburger & Indrid Cold. -Did Patience Worth write poetry from beyond the grave? -The Green Children of Woolpit -What flew over Washington DC in July of 1952? -Shag Harbor incident -Flight 2501 & the Michigan Triangle -Meat Rain of Coach farm -The Clairvoyance of Lady Wonder -Americas First bank heist with Pat Lyons -The blue people of Kentucky -What guards the treasure of the Superstition Mountains? -What scared the Herrman family in 1958? -Ted Serios' "Thoughtographs". -What causes the "Third Man Effect"? -Where is the City of El Dorado? -Where is the Gold of the Cara Nevada? -Could Charles Hatfield make it rain? -How did Alfred Hobbs pick the Bramah lock? -What caused the sinking of the M/S Estonia? -What was the substance that inspired "The Blob". -What caused the "La Pain Maudit" incident? -Who was the Real Shakespeare? -Gef the Mongoose -The disapperance of Lisa Marie Young in Nanaimo, Canada -The disapperance of the Hell's Angels chaper President Zeke Mickel -The Beast of Bladenboro (I especially want Shane to do this one).
coming here to say, as a long time watcher (lol) I appreciate y’all putting in the effort to finding an area where folks can still support the Watcher train even if they’re not able to subscribe individually. For what it’s worth, ads drive me crazy but when I see UA-camrs (especially y’all) make some light joke about ads in the guise of selling an idea or service, it literally puts everything back into touch The fact that we’re all just people doing what we can to get by I wholeheartedly support you & thank you for doing what you do One day when I make it (probably around the same time y’all offer business & economic videos on your channel) I will be subscribing & supporting the artists that have made my life better, in whatever way I’m able Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhb am I scared of milk white? Only if it becomes the only color I get to experience ✨ cheers to y’all Also please go and investigate the State Schools in Belchertown MA; they’re slowly demolishing the buildings & turning the land into an “acccesible” park & walkways geared towards elderly folks; I’ll never forget the day I was first invited to explore there, I couldn’t even enter the building I was so on edge from something
I've been to that asylum!!! They have actual ghost tours sometimes with a local ghost hunting team. It was so much fun and taken very seriously. We didn't hear the story of Milk White but there were a lot of very creepy stories about the asylum. Highly recommend, from a fellow Wisconsinite. Also Spotted Cow & Mars Cheese Castle are GOATED 🙌
I just randomly got Buzzfeed on my wall, saw they posted your comp. videos, then was reminded of your new channel, in which I loved this series as well and have many to catch up on. YIPPEE. thank you guys y'all are hilarious. ❤️❤️
I have been watching this series since the first one came out and one of the first few was Wall Man is still my favorite, every time I see watcher posted a new watcher episode I always get excited and almost never fails to disappoint. Hope this series last another 4 years!
The moment Hans struck the narrator I was like "He makes them go to sleep. Smart." and suddenly Shane and Ryan start to screech. That was a whiplash. Good story!
As someone from Milwaukee Wisconsin can confirm the crazy. A house I walked by (more times I could count and even to school all alone) few blocks from my childhood house. A dude lived alone in this house, turns out he was kidnapping women and children and chopping them up....putting them in suitcases and putting the suitcases all around the state. So yeah, people sometimes would just show up dead. I have tons of Wisconsin horror stories lol.
@cherubmius Another one me and my family nick named it "the streak". So we have a pretty popular state fair....a mom and son (son was 23) were walking back from the state fair (everyone would because it's Milwaukee and walking home drunk is the norm). The accident happened at midnight. The mom had way to many drinks and was in a blackout state. She passed out right outside a cremation center (no it's not going that way it's worse). The son went home....got into his car and drove back. He then parked in the road....got his mother who was passed out and put her in the middle of the road. Got back in his car, backed up and just proceeded to run her over till there wasn't much left. Then fled the scene. The blood streak from the cars tires ran from the crime scene and down the streets where everyone usually walked to get to the State Fair...for 4 blocks. Each block slightly less red. Next day me and my friend walk over to the state fair and start seeing the "pink" marks. We thought it was spray paint so we sadly walked on it....until we got to the crime scene, stopping as we saw all the police caution tape and what was remaining of the woman. (They "cleaned" it up) but there was no way they could remove "everything". That was the summer of me and my friend stopped going to the State Fair.
I have such a hard time with normal scary content because it genuinely gets to me -- I can only watch it with The Boys softening the scares with their sh*ts and giggles 🥹
Sheboygan is mentioned in Home Alone, and it's the home of the greatest surfer ever known, Chicken Joe. Why does the author think nobody has ever heard of Sheboygan?
So many of these stories give me the impression of being written by an alien trying desperately (and mostly failing) to convince us it's a Normal Human Person with Human Experiences.
people saying that those in larger cities like MKE and madison dont even know that sheboygan exists is like people who are more than comfortable financially claiming to be poor. sheboygan is the 13th largest city in wisconsin according to the 2020 census and there are A LOT of cities. sincerely, someone who lives in a bigger WI city than sheboygan.
You're right, literally everyone in the entire state knows about Sheboygan. The author clearly is not from here, meaning anywhere in the state, much less Sheboygan! 😂
are you scared is one of the best shows watcher has going on !! i absolutely love it and the podcast version on Spotify is literally the only thing i can listen to while studying, hoping they post new episodes (on Spotify)
Are You Scared videos are slowly becoming the only _true Watcher_ contents after the paywall slip-up. This type of content is why we're here, not the podcast!
As someone who isn't American and is so terrible at American geography that I thought Chicago was a state until 2 years ago: I have definitely heard of Sheboygan before.
I have semi-frequent insomnia, and the best way to fall asleep I've found is to pretend there's a woman on my ceiling, who watches me. She'll Get Me if she knows that I know she's there, so I can't lay awake and stare at the ceiling.
@@DannyBlissOfficial Wdym? sounds like a riveting experience. How many people can say they play a game of "Hide and Don't Seek (to not be murdered)" to fall asleep every night 😭😭
I’ve been on a binge of all the old episodes of are you scared and honestly I forgot that they are still making them lmao this notification was a pleasant little surprise for me
you know, I have tried to watch these videos at night so that I could have a good scare before going to bed... but it never happens. Yeah, I watch them at night. That happens for sure. but I never get scared because the second I get into the mood, you guys crack me up with your comments here and there!
😂😂sorry on behalf of the state! The Packers fans especially take "Cheesehead" very seriously because Bears fans tried to insult us with that name and instead we took it, ran with it, and turned it into very profitable merchandise that is worn with great pride. In other words, we take our cheese very seriously, but that's no excuse to be rude! Haha!
Having severe anxiety, and an absolute hatred of the horror genre, I have avoided this series for so long. I only recently got up the courage to watch them, and I’m so glad I did. If I’d known they were so hilarious I would have started watching sooner!! 😂😂😂
Download the FREE Upside App at upside.app.link/watcher to get an extra 25 cents back for every gallon on your first tank of gas.
was the submission link only available for when it aired on WatcherTV?
Nice
At some point you guys should have an episode just reading Bad Two Sentence Horror.
Is there anyway to submit stories or no? My friend has a good one
If you want to save on gas vote Republican. Drill baby drill.
why is no one talking about how sad this is, bro sacrificed himself for his friends but the whole town thinks he did something awful to those two
Omg yes I was looking for this comment!! What a twist, I'm left with so many feelings 😭
and they said he isn't the sharpest tool in the shed but... he knew how to save his friends. he's just a sweet boy, it breaks my heart
its giving stranger things season 4
@@elaavellana4177instantly thought about Eddie lol
at least the protag knew😔
WARNING: To anyone who is lactose intolerant, viewer discretion is advised.
Not only am I lactose intolerant I hate the thought of it I don't even want to look at it. It's disgusting
read this too late, shit myself
Instructions unclear: blew 6 gallons of ice cream. Now ripping new toilet.
@@andy56duky ate 3 pieces of pizza now acid reflux with cheese bloat
@@andy56dukyi guess viewer excretion is advised
it’s funny to imagine Hans somehow knocking himself out and Milk White just left standing there like🧍🏼
Milk be like 👁️👄👁️
"Well, that's no fair. I can't eat them now."
Then he waits until sunrise, checking his watch from time to time, hoping they regain consciousness... but eventually just slithers off disappointed.
Like in hindsight why didn’t he though
These creepypastas could use approximately 175% more anachronistic New York street-tough characters like Jimmy
Yeah, but imo i wanna see someone stret tough but still nuce and actually backs his talk up, jimmy was all bark but no bite😭
this has to be one of my favorite Are You Scared. The twists and turns, initially thinking Hans was betraying them only to realize he'd sacrificed himself for his friends. Uggh. What a story.
It was my first thought that Hans knocked his friend out to save him... didn't think he'd do the same for his own bully tho, what a hero hans is
hans lived because he wasn't a kid and he knew the others were :]
Like an actual good one, and it’s really well written with no plot holes or anything!
Definitely not your fault but jeez I wish I hadn't checked the comments 😭
It was a surprise when Hans knocked him out but as soon as he did it I figured it was to save him. Poor hans
“his brains no good, he’s sundowning!” caught me so off guard 😭
Wish I knew what that meant cause it sounds funny
@@randog93some people with dementia get really delirious when the sun starts to go down
@@randog93sundowning syndrome is when a patient with alzheimer’s confusion/restlessness/irritability gets worse when the sun sets!
i screamt
It made me laugh out loud because it caught me so off guard 💀
these titles just keep getting stranger
How?
LIO FOTIA LIO FOTIA LIO FOTIA
Are you sacred of liquid milk?
Are you scared of the "are you scared" title?
Reminds me of the movie Me, Myself, and Irene
"Thats illegal!!"
"... yeah. Kidnapping IS illegal"
Omg that cracked me up
I currently live in Sheboygan and nobody has ever told me the story. I even toured the Asylum, yet it was never mentioned.
I think it depends which owner you toured with (I know it changed not many years back) or if it was one of the tour guides hired for the season. Personally I thought it was from a diff asylum not in WI 😅
It’s from the no sleep subreddit. I don’t think it’s a real urban legend which is a shame because Wisconsin does have a lot of urban legends. Source- I’m from Milwaukee
It’s just a story sent in I think
There's no way that the person who wrote the story is even from Sheboygan, probably not even from Wisconsin.. based on the fact that they think people in Milwaukee and Madison don't know that Sheboygan exists. Dude, everyone in the entire state knows about Sheboygan! If only because of how fun it is to say 😉 but also because it's really not that small; it almost makes the top ten biggest cities. So I wouldn't worry that, being from Sheboygan, you haven't heard this story.
@@wayward.philosophercan confirm as a Minnesotan whose uncle lives near Sheboygan and would always mention the town when he visited it always stuck out as a kid because it's one of those words that is spelt exactly how you think it would be and it's very fun to say
Shane and Ryan are having too much fun with the “Newyork accent” 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I love seeing them so happy lmao
Shane doing everything to keep Ryan from getting cancelled after he said he was slow😂😂
I was dying at that 😂 is that actually something he would get called out for? Not being obtuse, genuinely didn’t know that was cancellable!!
@@AccessizzyI feel hesitation at rendering a verdict with the language of cancelling in a sincere way; to answer what I think you’re asking people have historically called folks with perceived or diagnosed develop/mental disorders “slow” as in a thing you are, not a descriptor of an action you take, like your brain itself is “slow” in a pejorative way. Like calling someone “special” not phrased as a good thing. In addition to that I’d also say folks can have trouble processing as quickly as others regardless of whatever measure of intelligence so at most charitable interpretation it’s not very aware of human variety
and after trying to cancel him for talking about zoos, too
People also use “slow” as a code word for disabled (similar to the way some people will describe something as “urban” when they mean Black)-it treats disability/disabled as taboo when in reality it’s a part of the breadth of human experience
Is Ryan slow?
“…in Chicago?”
“No, Sheboygan… very big in Sheboygan!” 😂
Thank you. I was searching for this comment.
Polka polka polka 🪗
"We sold 623 copies of that".
@@robertwilliams9010 The Kenosha Kickers
Love the Home Alone call back! 😂
19:37 JUSTICE FOR MARK!!!! Shane ran away first at Waverly!
On Buzzfeed Unsolved's Almost 70th Episode special, during Mark's interview segment (7:40), he says that the most scared he had ever been was in Waverly because it was creepy and that was the first time Shane got scared (Shane mentions that everybody was a little terrified there; Ryan adds that Waverly is "comically horrific"). Mark goes on to remember that they were in the body chute hearing weird croak noises, and he was okay thinking it was just a frog. But then, Shane goes "what's that noise?". Mark's camera moves around a bit and the footage gets dark, then the light is back on and you can see Shane running way ahead of Mark (9:02). Mark says, "And if Shane runs and I'm left behind, I'd be terrified because if Shane is afraid, I gotta be", to which Ryan agrees saying that "It must be something real then."
Shane, you absolutely left Mark behind 😭
This is my favorite story so far! Well written, good characters, decently creepy. And it had an ending!
Agreed!
“And whispered” “AT AMAZON WE HAVE DEALS!” Worst ad timing 😂
"They got in and out in the asylum???😮 I didn't know doordash delivered to those places"
😮💨 Lemme tell you... We do.. I once delivered to a place that was essentially a prison for children and I've never felt more downtrodden in my life after leaving somewhere 😢
give us STORY
@@greasymoth4172 basically I roll up to this place that's kinda far away from everything else in town and has a long "driveway" to get to and tall fences and light posts outside but the light posts have cute paintings on them like butterflies and stuff like that and behind the fences I can see playgrounds. I immediately get this weird feeling in my stomach and when I drop off the food there's a guy outside that's like a janitor and I straight up ask him "what is this place?" And he kinda hangs his head a little and avoids eye contact and gets a little choked up and says: 😭🥺" a children's correctional facility."
Listen I know kids do bad stuff and get in trouble sometimes but something about seeing the actual playground and paintings and knowing they're in jail... Idk man it broke something in me and obviously in that guy too. It's a different kinda sad... 💔
@@sunflowerglo1771 lots of kids get tried as adults too - people too young to drive or vote getting treated as grown ass adults by the law. it's really fucked up, and people don't want to change anything because they think punishment is the same as justice.
@@lorendaemon7945 that's not okay and it really breaks my heart 💔
@@sunflowerglo1771 there's lots of non-profits that try and advocate for incarcerated children! You should do some research, there might be something for children in your area.
As someone from Wisconsin, we have a weird mix of the most normal people combined with unhinged weirdos. My theory is the miserable winter months driving us insane.
New England here and I can say the same. But then again there is "FL man", but people who go through 4 seasons seam to have an edge to them the south doesn't.
And the raging alcoholism and drinking culture id imagine
Yeah, but also, that mix is true of everywhere. Saying that from experience.
I mean isn’t that most states? Although I will say I did see a guy riding a tractor while walking his dog (like the dog was walking on the side of the road and he was in his tractor)… so maybe you’re right
@@Aw-ns1qxid imagine never ending summers and hurricanes probably have similar affects on the mind as long winters, and as a resident of Ohio I can confirm we get the worst of both sides and thus our people are the worst
Me shouting at the tv when you didn’t realise Hans knocked him out to save him! Hans is the only clever one, Hans ain’t slow!!! 😅
Exactly
Hans was the only one in the story who actually tried to make or made reasonable decisions
Clever Hans? Was this a reference?
@@JosephDavies let it go, let it go....
As someone who has had several concussions, I hate when characters have "mild concussions" after being unconscious for at least several minutes if not hours. Of course Jimmy doesn't remember anything that happened, he has permanent brain damage.
This!!!
As someone with permanent brain damage, this comment resonated so hard with me.
What are you up to getting "several" concussions?
Are you saying if someone gets knocked out for more than a few seconds then it'll be really serious?
@@chuckmaddox6725 Honestly, I'm just clumsy
Well, I don't know but I'm lactose intolerant
Lacktoadsintolerant
This is the funniest comment I’ve ever read
Lactose intolerants unite 💪🏻
My mom used to tell me there's a crocodile under my bed and if i don't sleep on time, it'll eat me. Maybe i should be more aware now xD
I know about Sheboygan because there was an episode of the Beetlejuice cartoon where he tells himself a joke. He mumbles quietly and then yells “SHEBOYGAN!” and laughs hysterically
It's the way I went "SHEBOYGAN!" In the same tone from Beetlejuice when they said the story took place there 😭😭😭
@@incognitochinchillea another individual of culture 🍷🧐
Ha! So glad I’m not the only one that thought of this!
I love UA-cam
ua-cam.com/video/VUvIhsq0sKQ/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
Yes! I always wondered why it cracked him up so much
This is probably one of the most unhinged episode of Are You Scared yet 😂
Shane doing everything in his power to keep Ryan from saying the wrong things only for him to double down is crazy
As someone from Milwaukee…saying “Sheboygan is just a little town no one knows about us owo 🥺” is crazy. There’s a lot of National boat racing competitions and surfing competitions there because of Lake Michigan having big waves. That’s the craziest part of this story
Yeah, I thought the same thing that that was the weirdest part of the story! No way the author is even from the state IMHO. Also, I think those surfing competitions are international level. I thought I'd read it was the freshwater surfing capital of the world.
it's also a bit strange that for the asylum to just... let a baby crawl around unattended eating scraps
The intro had several weird bits like that; not sure why they try to break the reader's engagement right from the start. Thankfully the rest, once it gets into the story proper, was solid.
"we don't think about them" IS CRAZYYY
We don't
@@CourtZilligenreally? Bear's fans coined the term cheese heads, not us. We just rolled with it. Also, a ton of you use WI as tax haven and come to our lakes on the weekend. But, sure, you don't think of us 😉
@@wayward.philosopherbecause you're too thick to understand that "cheese head" is an insult and everyone is laughing at you
@@wayward.philosopher LMFAO not yall actually beefing in the comments😭
I was laying down listening to this and my head has never snapped up faster when I heard my hometown Sheboygan
The asylum is only 3 min away from my house
is milk white a real story from there ?
@@saraharmstrong6442nope :P
@@saraharmstrong6442no it’s from the no sleep subreddit. Someone made it up. There’s other urban legends from Wisconsin tho like boy-scout lane, bloody bride bridge, the phantom man, siren bridge, hogsback road, u of madison mass murder, rhinelander hodag, beast of bray road, etc. Surprised they haven’t been to the famous asylum where Rosemary Kennedy was forced to live in after her lobotomy called St. Coletta’s. We really are famous for our serial killers, dairy, alcohol, and asylums.
@@saraharmstrong6442I personally have never heard of it
the ending broke my heart wow even though Hans was so scared he still managed to save his friends' life and yet he was made into the bad guy
0:01 thank you for the call back to Julian Smith’s video Malk. (Julian’s ‘Jellyfish’ should also be noted as legendary)
Did you know that Malk is an actual brand now?!
Gettin too old for this😂
Who? What?
I think that was legitimately top 3 stories on this show. I have to go rewatched the other two and see what place it was. I had no idea what the twist could have meant until the last sentence. And it was actually funny and scary. 10/10
I grew up in Sheboygan Falls, right outside of Sheboygan. My dad’s grandpa was a barber at the asylum, my dad talks about it sometimes. I drive there sometimes and sit along the road and sing (outside the fence, the owners are known for not being forgiving to trespassers). It was my favorite place to drive when I was in high school, the south side Walmart parking lot is close by and we didn’t exactly have much to do. The asylum is actually a peaceful place in the middle of the country. As a mentally ill person, it reminds me of how far we’ve come. That being said, the owners made it into a haunted attraction. It makes me sad tbh. I’ve always wanted to explore there. Sheboygan is a small and fairly tight knit community. Everyone knows everyone somehow. I feel a special kind of community with those who were treated there. Also, never heard of milk white lol
Glad you have good memories of growing up there, but Sheboygan itself is not that small, at least not now. It's almost 50,000 people and the 13th biggest city in the state. Also, Milk white was clearly made up by someone not from there... i.e. they claimed people in Milwaukee and Madison don't know Sheboygan exists.. ridiculous!
@@wayward.philosopheryeah lol I figured out they didn’t actually live there as soon as they said the hospital was right off the highway. It’s really really not lmao. It is fun to hear a different perception of my hometown from someone else :3
Listening to this walking home from work in madison wisconsin 👍🏼
Ryan if you want to have your mind blown, my art teacher in high school would do a prison art program. She taught Ed Gien how to paint.
This might be my favourite episode so far. And yay they're bringing back viewers' stories! 25:46
Me: I shouldn't watch creepy stories before my bedtime...
Are you scared: *uploaded*
the notification for this vid popped up right as I was telling my friend about Are You Scared LMAO
The twist of Hans sacrificing himself is actually heartbreaking and scary because it leaves you to imagine what exactly happened to him. The horror of being dragged away while your friends are unconscious.
The whole exchange with the New York accents was incredible 😂
This, too many spirits, ghost files and mystery files are my fav content on yt!! I can’t wait for the next season of ghost files >.
Seems to be everyone’s favorite shows, they should devote all there resources there, instead of sending people to other countries to try food
Amidst all the fowl scandals hitting UA-cam recently, Can we please all take a moment to thank the social media gods that Watcher's biggest scandal has been the time they tried to switch to a monthly subscription model? We stan
Man tell me about the bird scandals I wanna know
@dis8791 that took me a minute, then i cracked up. I will never forget the difference between foul and fowl again, thank you 😅🤣
When you guys bring back Mystery Files can you please do episodes on the following:
-Where is Canadian Clubs hidden whiskey?
-Where are the hidden Gems of the Book "The Secret"?
-The Kentucky Alien invasion in the 1950's
-The mysterious birds of Audubon's "Birds of America" book
-The Montana Hyena
-The mysterious abandonment of Portlock Alaska
-The theories of what is behind the Missing 411 cases in the US.
-Kasperov vs Deep Blue computer
-What hit Officer Val Johnsons Car?
-Why are there Piranhas in Americas Waterways?
-Dalnegorsk Spaceship remnants.
-What did Captain Mantell encounter over FT. Knox?
-Who were the Sea People that collapsed the Bronze Age Civilizations?
-The strange encounter between Woodrow Derenburger & Indrid Cold.
-Did Patience Worth write poetry from beyond the grave?
-The Green Children of Woolpit
-What flew over Washington DC in July of 1952?
-Shag Harbor incident
-Flight 2501 & the Michigan Triangle
-Meat Rain of Coach farm
-The Clairvoyance of Lady Wonder
-Americas First bank heist with Pat Lyons
-The blue people of Kentucky
-What guards the treasure of the Superstition Mountains?
-What scared the Herrman family in 1958?
-Ted Serios' "Thoughtographs".
-What causes the "Third Man Effect"?
-Where is the City of El Dorado?
-Where is the Gold of the Cara Nevada?
-Could Charles Hatfield make it rain?
-How did Alfred Hobbs pick the Bramah lock?
-What caused the sinking of the M/S Estonia?
-What was the substance that inspired "The Blob".
-What caused the "La Pain Maudit" incident?
-Who was the Real Shakespeare?
-Gef the Mongoose
-The disapperance of Lisa Marie Young in Nanaimo, Canada
-The disapperance of the Hell's Angels chaper President Zeke Mickel
-The Beast of Bladenboro (I especially want Shane to do this one).
- Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego?
so far this is actually the best episode
“Born in captivity” was craaaazy lmao
This was one of the funniest episodes of this series I was cackling the entire time
need Jimmy to fight all ghosts and demons with that accent LOOL he gotta be the funniest character in these stories yet ...need him to comeback fr LOL
12:13 shane trying so hard to not get them canceled is so funny bc ryan’s j not catching on
im glad someone else noticed this lmaooooo
i hadn't been enjoying this series for a while, but man this season really brought back the feeling i got from the first seasons. Pretty cool stuff
I read the title as "White Mike" and i honestly just went with it because this is Watcher
coming here to say, as a long time watcher (lol) I appreciate y’all putting in the effort to finding an area where folks can still support the Watcher train even if they’re not able to subscribe individually.
For what it’s worth, ads drive me crazy but when I see UA-camrs (especially y’all) make some light joke about ads in the guise of selling an idea or service, it literally puts everything back into touch
The fact that we’re all just people doing what we can to get by
I wholeheartedly support you & thank you for doing what you do
One day when I make it (probably around the same time y’all offer business & economic videos on your channel) I will be subscribing & supporting the artists that have made my life better, in whatever way I’m able
Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhb am I scared of milk white? Only if it becomes the only color I get to experience ✨ cheers to y’all
Also please go and investigate the State Schools in Belchertown MA; they’re slowly demolishing the buildings & turning the land into an “acccesible” park & walkways geared towards elderly folks; I’ll never forget the day I was first invited to explore there, I couldn’t even enter the building I was so on edge from something
Thanks For this Guys! You always carry me through rough days. You're the Best 😊😊😊😊
Shane and Ryan with their witty sarcasm never ceases to make me cheerful.
I've been to that asylum!!! They have actual ghost tours sometimes with a local ghost hunting team. It was so much fun and taken very seriously. We didn't hear the story of Milk White but there were a lot of very creepy stories about the asylum. Highly recommend, from a fellow Wisconsinite.
Also Spotted Cow & Mars Cheese Castle are GOATED 🙌
6:44 as someone who was a psychiatric hospital patient i can confirm we did once order ubereats/deliveroo/etc to the gate
Guys I cant with this seasons titles
I just randomly got Buzzfeed on my wall, saw they posted your comp. videos, then was reminded of your new channel, in which I loved this series as well and have many to catch up on. YIPPEE. thank you guys y'all are hilarious. ❤️❤️
I have been watching this series since the first one came out and one of the first few was Wall Man is still my favorite, every time I see watcher posted a new watcher episode I always get excited and almost never fails to disappoint. Hope this series last another 4 years!
Omg I THOUGHT I LOST YOU GUYS!! 😭❤ IM SO GLAD I FOUND YOU'RE CHANNEL!!!!!🎉
Next Too Many Spirits should be read in Jimmy's accent. Do it Ryan, do it!!!
The moment Hans struck the narrator I was like "He makes them go to sleep. Smart." and suddenly Shane and Ryan start to screech. That was a whiplash.
Good story!
19:22 Shane getting scared by a frog!! Why wasnt THAT in the Unsolved episode?!?!? 😂😂
Just in time for my lunch
Lunch? Where you from lol it's 8:35pm where I'm from
Me too !!
@@Jaygazzilli I'm guessing you're somewhere in the UK. I'm in the States, it's lunch time for many of us here
@@lixiahuang6838 nice! It's 4am where i'm from. Just in time for my bedtime 😁
Same, opened up yt and saw it was posted an hour ago
As someone from Milwaukee Wisconsin can confirm the crazy. A house I walked by (more times I could count and even to school all alone) few blocks from my childhood house. A dude lived alone in this house, turns out he was kidnapping women and children and chopping them up....putting them in suitcases and putting the suitcases all around the state. So yeah, people sometimes would just show up dead. I have tons of Wisconsin horror stories lol.
do share !
Wtf is wrong with your state
@jalapeno1119 The cheese is reeeeal good okay.
@cherubmius Another one me and my family nick named it "the streak". So we have a pretty popular state fair....a mom and son (son was 23) were walking back from the state fair (everyone would because it's Milwaukee and walking home drunk is the norm). The accident happened at midnight. The mom had way to many drinks and was in a blackout state. She passed out right outside a cremation center (no it's not going that way it's worse). The son went home....got into his car and drove back. He then parked in the road....got his mother who was passed out and put her in the middle of the road. Got back in his car, backed up and just proceeded to run her over till there wasn't much left. Then fled the scene. The blood streak from the cars tires ran from the crime scene and down the streets where everyone usually walked to get to the State Fair...for 4 blocks. Each block slightly less red. Next day me and my friend walk over to the state fair and start seeing the "pink" marks. We thought it was spray paint so we sadly walked on it....until we got to the crime scene, stopping as we saw all the police caution tape and what was remaining of the woman. (They "cleaned" it up) but there was no way they could remove "everything". That was the summer of me and my friend stopped going to the State Fair.
Loved this story, big Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark vibes
I’m so glad Shane and Ryan make things less scary. I’d honestly be having a panic attack because of like, half of these stories.
I have such a hard time with normal scary content because it genuinely gets to me -- I can only watch it with The Boys softening the scares with their sh*ts and giggles 🥹
Usually these leave me creeped out or a little scared, but this one just left me sad. Poor Hans.
Actual episode starts at 2:26 by the way
Bless you 🙏
"His brain's no good. He's Sundowning!!" LOLOLOGOGOOLOLOL
Sheboygan is mentioned in Home Alone, and it's the home of the greatest surfer ever known, Chicken Joe. Why does the author think nobody has ever heard of Sheboygan?
His bio says he moved to Arizona to do college online and he got an associates from the university of Phoenix LMFAO
So many of these stories give me the impression of being written by an alien trying desperately (and mostly failing) to convince us it's a Normal Human Person with Human Experiences.
The story was actually written by New Yorker Jimmy
Im not ready for the season to be over. I need an encore story. PLEEEEEASE 🙏
people saying that those in larger cities like MKE and madison dont even know that sheboygan exists is like people who are more than comfortable financially claiming to be poor. sheboygan is the 13th largest city in wisconsin according to the 2020 census and there are A LOT of cities. sincerely, someone who lives in a bigger WI city than sheboygan.
im from a larger wiscansin city and always aware of sheboygan cuz it contains storybook gardens
You're right, literally everyone in the entire state knows about Sheboygan. The author clearly is not from here, meaning anywhere in the state, much less Sheboygan! 😂
I know about Sheboygan because it's fun to say
Easily one of the best ones you have ever gotten. Props to the crew who finds the stories!!!
I need a clip of them saying "nipple nipple nipple" for my ringtone now
Shane and Ryan are the best❤
Truly one your best boys!!!! Watched it during my morning workout and couldn’t stop laughing, best start to the day! Hear hear to the big boys 🫡🫶🏼
I initially read "Are You Scared of Milky White?" and I was like "why would I be scared of that damn cow"
OMG INTO THE WOODS REF SPOTTED ‼️‼️‼️
are you scared is one of the best shows watcher has going on !! i absolutely love it and the podcast version on Spotify is literally the only thing i can listen to while studying, hoping they post new episodes (on Spotify)
I love how Ryan matched his watch to Shane's jacket today 😜.
Shane’s Unsolved Mysteries bit is everything I didn’t know I needed.
I love Shane’s jacket
Wow, this is definitely the best written story in this series so far! Also with the ambiguous ending. Really good.
Are You Scared videos are slowly becoming the only _true Watcher_ contents after the paywall slip-up. This type of content is why we're here, not the podcast!
Wow!!!! That story was so well written! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 best story so far!!!
just got done making food, literally perfect timing
As someone who isn't American and is so terrible at American geography that I thought Chicago was a state until 2 years ago: I have definitely heard of Sheboygan before.
I have semi-frequent insomnia, and the best way to fall asleep I've found is to pretend there's a woman on my ceiling, who watches me. She'll Get Me if she knows that I know she's there, so I can't lay awake and stare at the ceiling.
That sounds like a horrible way to fall asleep.
@@DannyBlissOfficial Wdym? sounds like a riveting experience. How many people can say they play a game of "Hide and Don't Seek (to not be murdered)" to fall asleep every night 😭😭
Was excited for sleep tips. I dont think I'll be using it but I'm glad it works for you lol sounds horrifying
@@DannyBlissOfficial You don't like Ceiling Lady? My most helpful friend?
Im so glad i found yall again! Ive been looking for yall since Unsolved Mysteries ended. One of these videos popped up today & i got so excited!
14:15
Shane: good season finale
Me: season what now?
That surprised me too!
I’ve been on a binge of all the old episodes of are you scared and honestly I forgot that they are still making them lmao this notification was a pleasant little surprise for me
thannk you shane, as an autistic person that was called slow many times growing up, thank you
you know, I have tried to watch these videos at night so that I could have a good scare before going to bed... but it never happens. Yeah, I watch them at night. That happens for sure. but I never get scared because the second I get into the mood, you guys crack me up with your comments here and there!
A milk minion is crazy lmaooooo
That's what they call my uncle☠️
The art in these episodes are one of my favorite parts. It reminds me a bit of the Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark books.
I made my name "cheesehead" on Soulseek in the 2000s and an angry Wisconsin person messaged me relentlessly for taking it. I just really liked cheese.
😂😂sorry on behalf of the state! The Packers fans especially take "Cheesehead" very seriously because Bears fans tried to insult us with that name and instead we took it, ran with it, and turned it into very profitable merchandise that is worn with great pride. In other words, we take our cheese very seriously, but that's no excuse to be rude! Haha!
my peanus
I agree
Yeah this guys peanus.
In the stripped club, straight up Jorking it, by “it” haha well let’s justr say my peanits
What a profound utterance
This is probably the most well written story in this series, I loved it.
Okay but Ryan and I were thinking the same thing on how do they not notice this guy bringing dead kids into the place 🤣🤣
Having severe anxiety, and an absolute hatred of the horror genre, I have avoided this series for so long. I only recently got up the courage to watch them, and I’m so glad I did. If I’d known they were so hilarious I would have started watching sooner!! 😂😂😂
I’ve been waiting for the next one 😂
thank yall i love this series🙏❤️❤️