Cette version de L'Égyptienne est à mes yeux la meilleure que j'aie pu entendre, et de très loin, et j'y reviens régulièrement en expérant un jour un disque. Sous les doigts de pianistes ô combien renommés, ce morceau avait traversé mes oreilles sans y laisser de trace. La plupart des virtuoses, en jouant Rameau, se fracassent sur deux écueils : une vitesse excessive qui empêche les lignes de se développer , ou bien une ornementation qui veut rivaliser avec le clavecin et qui empêche aussi la musique de chanter librement. Sous les doigts magiques de la jeune Alexandra, tout devient simple et évident. Simplicité apparente, car il est vraiment TRÈS difficile de pouvoir donner cette illusion que la musique coule de source.
J'adhère complètement à votre analyse sensible et pertinente. Je cours voir si vous avez commenté son interprétation de la "Grande Polonaise Brillante" de Chopin qui me laisse pantois d'admiration...
She outdoes Sokolov and everyone else in this piece, I say this 100% seriously. I went into this video expecting nothing, because child prodigies usually aren't interesting musically. But this girl plays with the sensitivity, elegance, clarity, and confidence of an old school virtuoso who's 5x her age. If I heard this without knowing who played it I would assume that it was a top tier pianist with many decades of specializing in Baroque repertoire. Fantastic pedaling as well. Hopefully she is able to play other music like this, because she could be the next Argerich (or better).
I heard Sokolov talking about her (somewhere on UTube). He recounts that he played a blind recording of her playing (he didn't say what) to his own music agent and asked what what she thought - she said 'it must be one of the greats' ...
Tahle mladá dáma (teď už jí bude za několik dní 17 let) je jedním z absolutně největších drahokamů v současném klavírním světě. Je to klenot, spojení úžasné a nádherné techniky a hlubin duše a čistoty srdce. Kéž taková zůstane.
PLEASE, ARGERICH SUCKS COMPARED TO THIS GIRL, NOT FOR ONE SPLIT SECOND DID I HEAR THIS GIRL COME CLOSE TO MAKING A MISTAKE, FROM ALL ANGLES, MUSICALITY ARTICULATION, DYNAMICS, TEMPO, SHEAR PERFECTION IN EVERYTHING SHE TOUCHES... ALL THAT AND DROP DEAD GORGEOUS TOO, FIND THE RARE VIDEO WHERE SHE SMILES, AND YOU WILL BE DEVASTATED !!! ARGERICH RUSHES EVERYTHING I'VE HEARD HER IN, AND DESTROYS A LOT OF GOOD MUSIC, TRYING TO SHOW OFF HER SPEED, WHERE AS THIS GIRL IS A MONSTER GENIUS, A MILLION TIMES THE SCOPE OF ARGERICH !!!
@@AVIDEOGAL Drop dead gorgeous? She was 11 when this video was made... hope you're talking present-tense but even still she's 17 as I type this. Argerich is a legend, comparison is the death of joy.
Alexandra's musicality is 100% engaged. Her stylistic nuances were subtle and perfectly right for Rameau's era. She's masterful in all her interpretations of all the music she plays. Astounding! The mind boggles to think of what lies ahead of her in her life!
I ADORE Sasha and everything she does. Here she is only 11 years and 2 months old, and plays with the consummate maturity of a maestro. Not just the music, but the bearing, the comportment, the Zen-like stillness and calm, tell us that she will be a force to reckon with in the musical firmament for many decades to come. We love you, Sasha!
de temps en temps il m'arrive d'aller "voir ailleurs" pour écouter l'interprétation d'autres pianistes : et comme à chaque fois, je tombe du très haut de ce que peut nous donner Alexandra Dovgan. Pour me trouver alors, regardez, oui, dans le caniveau (je suis désolé mais bon c'est le jour et la nuit). Et quand on revient sur la musique que nous offre Alexandra, si pure et si profonde : unique, on est terrassé par une émotion irrésistible....
Она просто волшебнца, в еи то возрате, тоакое чувства, такое звучене, просто сколько оттенок зучения, техника превосходна, она от бога послана к нам, онемел, БРАВО!!!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
One can feel a period of music (Baroque Period of Music) from Dovgan’s performance unmistakably, which is the soul of music, the evidence of history and the key to Dovgan’s success. Congratulations!
@@sergeydonotremember925 It is your humble opinion... When I close my eyes when listening to Sokolov, then I hear a perfect performance. Dovgan's performance is different: here I see the image she is playing about. I think that God invented music to create images, but not to demonstrate perfection of technique
If anyone ever doubts the brilliance of this young lady this vid should prove them wrong! a very gifted girl who will only grow in stature musically, (wonderful)
Удивительной красоты произведение исполнено восхитительно этой талантливой девочкой. Браво!!! Дальнейших творческих успехов, находок, лёгкости и счастья в таком тяжёлом труде, Александра!
Astounding and exceptional. Such a beautiful, stylistic, technically mastered and highly musical performance! Thank you for sharing. Big congratulations Alexandra and all the very best!
I think Alexandra's performance would be most recognisable by Rameau, above most if not all others. Others have slightly fancier trills, etc, but the overall clarity is everything.
FINALLY, AFTER NEARLY 40 YEARS A WORTHY CONTENDER FOR THE CROWN KISSIN WEARS !!! (I LIKE HER LOOK WHEN SHE RAISES HER HEAD AFTER THE LAST NOTE, SHE IS A REALLY PRETTY GIRL !!!)
Sublime orgoglio della Tua Maestra! Mira sa che presto oscurerai tutte le altre ! Grande Scuola Russa! Solo la Napoletana può stare al Tuo passo... Alexandra e Beatrice, Interpreti di riferimento per tutti i veri cultori della tastiera! Marco Rotondi
САШЕНЬКА,ТЫ- САМА В ДУШЕ, КАК МИЛАЯ ПТАШКА: И ТВОЯ ТРЕПЕТНОСТЬ,И НЕЖНОСТЬ И ВОЗДУШНАЯ КРАСОТА ЗВУКА- ВСЕ СЛИЛОСЬ ВОЕДИНО В ЭТОЙ ПЬЕСЕ РАМО.❤🦜🕊🐥Спасибо , милая девочка...Рамо был бы счастлив,услышав это исполнение)
In addition to all the other well deserved comments, she also has amazingly long fingers which is a tremendous asset as a pianist, and particularly in this style of music.
I saw her in an interview (some where on UT) in which they commented on her hands. She told she had always had long fingers from being very young and spread her hands to show them - smiling graciously.
This performance is impeccable! You truly have a gift! I love the cleanness and (seemingly) ease of execution of the ornaments and the emotion conveyed here. Well done!
As a long struggling harpsichord student, I find it really rare to hear Rameau performed so magnificently on piano.
I had no idea she was a harpsichordist. but music from that era was basically for the harpsichord, so....
Cette version de L'Égyptienne est à mes yeux la meilleure que j'aie pu entendre, et de très loin, et j'y reviens régulièrement en expérant un jour un disque. Sous les doigts de pianistes ô combien renommés, ce morceau avait traversé mes oreilles sans y laisser de trace. La plupart des virtuoses, en jouant Rameau, se fracassent sur deux écueils : une vitesse excessive qui empêche les lignes de se développer , ou bien une ornementation qui veut rivaliser avec le clavecin et qui empêche aussi la musique de chanter librement. Sous les doigts magiques de la jeune Alexandra, tout devient simple et évident. Simplicité apparente, car il est vraiment TRÈS difficile de pouvoir donner cette illusion que la musique coule de source.
J'adhère complètement à votre analyse sensible et pertinente. Je cours voir si vous avez commenté son interprétation de la "Grande Polonaise Brillante" de Chopin qui me laisse pantois d'admiration...
She outdoes Sokolov and everyone else in this piece, I say this 100% seriously. I went into this video expecting nothing, because child prodigies usually aren't interesting musically. But this girl plays with the sensitivity, elegance, clarity, and confidence of an old school virtuoso who's 5x her age. If I heard this without knowing who played it I would assume that it was a top tier pianist with many decades of specializing in Baroque repertoire. Fantastic pedaling as well. Hopefully she is able to play other music like this, because she could be the next Argerich (or better).
I heard Sokolov talking about her (somewhere on UTube). He recounts that he played a blind recording of her playing (he didn't say what) to his own music agent and asked what what she thought - she said 'it must be one of the greats' ...
She is only herself, it's natural in her, she plays music with the soul!
Tahle mladá dáma (teď už jí bude za několik dní 17 let) je jedním z absolutně největších drahokamů v současném klavírním světě. Je to klenot, spojení úžasné a nádherné techniky a hlubin duše a čistoty srdce. Kéž taková zůstane.
PLEASE, ARGERICH SUCKS COMPARED TO THIS GIRL, NOT FOR ONE SPLIT SECOND DID I HEAR THIS GIRL COME CLOSE TO MAKING A MISTAKE, FROM ALL ANGLES, MUSICALITY ARTICULATION, DYNAMICS, TEMPO, SHEAR PERFECTION IN EVERYTHING SHE TOUCHES... ALL THAT AND DROP DEAD GORGEOUS TOO, FIND THE RARE VIDEO WHERE SHE SMILES, AND YOU WILL BE DEVASTATED !!!
ARGERICH RUSHES EVERYTHING I'VE HEARD HER IN, AND DESTROYS A LOT OF GOOD MUSIC, TRYING TO SHOW OFF HER SPEED, WHERE AS THIS GIRL IS A MONSTER GENIUS, A MILLION TIMES THE SCOPE OF ARGERICH !!!
@@AVIDEOGAL Drop dead gorgeous? She was 11 when this video was made... hope you're talking present-tense but even still she's 17 as I type this. Argerich is a legend, comparison is the death of joy.
Alexandra's musicality is 100% engaged. Her stylistic nuances were subtle and perfectly right for Rameau's era. She's masterful in all her interpretations of all the music she plays. Astounding! The mind boggles to think of what lies ahead of her in her life!
So true Larry !
Probably the brightest talent of our generation.Divine.Dear Gods,protect this Angel.
Her technique is so clean
I ADORE Sasha and everything she does. Here she is only 11 years and 2 months old, and plays with the consummate maturity of a maestro. Not just the music, but the bearing, the comportment, the Zen-like stillness and calm, tell us that she will be a force to reckon with in the musical firmament for many decades to come. We love you, Sasha!
kinda weird you ADORE an 11 year old bro
how yoiu know EXACCTLY her age in this video. Veyr strange.
Isn’t her name Alexandra…?
Изабелла, Саша это краткая форма имени Александра
@@not_isabella. Aleksandra = Sasha in Russian. Aleksandra is formal, Sasha is informal.
also Maria = Masha, Natalia = Natasha, Daria = Dasha.
Alexandra you are not just a pianist. You are Music !
Слёзы на глазах .Лучшее исполнение.
Stunning! Her clarity in execution and musical brilliance is authentic and absolute.
de temps en temps il m'arrive d'aller "voir ailleurs" pour écouter l'interprétation d'autres pianistes : et comme à chaque fois, je tombe du très haut de ce que peut nous donner Alexandra Dovgan. Pour me trouver alors, regardez, oui, dans le caniveau (je suis désolé mais bon c'est le jour et la nuit). Et quand on revient sur la musique que nous offre Alexandra, si pure et si profonde : unique, on est terrassé par une émotion irrésistible....
I wonder if those people know how fortunate they are to see her perform live. I would so love to be there!!
She has hands of an angel; so fluid, majestic, and strong.
I think she is an angel.
Какая нежность и сила в этой девочке! Чудесная, очень талантливая!
This little girl is a miracle !!
Jes Jes Jes
This young girl is a genius.
I strongly like Rameau's music and this piece of sugar called Alexandra played very good with excellent dynamics. Millions of Bravos.
Sweet piece of sugar..
Она просто волшебнца, в еи то возрате, тоакое чувства, такое звучене, просто сколько оттенок зучения, техника превосходна, она от бога послана к нам, онемел, БРАВО!!!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
She does a very good job of conveying Rameau's impression of an Egyptian dancing girl with bell on her fingers hips and toes...
One can feel a period of music (Baroque Period of Music) from Dovgan’s performance unmistakably, which is the soul of music, the evidence of history and the key to Dovgan’s success. Congratulations!
She sounds like his reincarnation
Чистейшее звучание и необычайно передана атмосфера музыки барокко! Браво ,Сашенька,ты очень большая умница! Света и тепла желаю!
She was born for the piano!
Mooi zo licht en lekker vlot gespeeld
I can't imagine this being played any better. Her mordents are amazing.
It's very easy to imagine:) ua-cam.com/video/837kZoZdFp0/v-deo.html
@@sergeydonotremember925 It is your humble opinion... When I close my eyes when listening to Sokolov, then I hear a perfect performance.
Dovgan's performance is different: here I see the image she is playing about. I think that God invented music to create images, but not to demonstrate perfection of technique
All those are pretty good, but of course Pinnock is best ua-cam.com/video/2SUN1egZnbo/v-deo.html
Hello, here my version, I don't pretend be better ^^ ua-cam.com/video/JZm4tbwdX9I/v-deo.html
Matthias Piano ok
I'll bet this young lady even plays the piano in her dreams! Simply AMAZING!!!
If anyone ever doubts the brilliance of this young lady this vid should prove them wrong! a very gifted girl who will only grow in stature musically, (wonderful)
Наверное слушаю тисячи раз не устаю, безразлично отнастраения, браво!!!!
Растёт, растёт поколение! Умница!
Rameau suits her so well (and vice versa, of course)
I thought that, too.
But so does everything else she plays!
Bravissimo !
Amazingly agile playing! Beautifully executed!!
Удивительной красоты произведение исполнено восхитительно этой талантливой девочкой. Браво!!! Дальнейших творческих успехов, находок, лёгкости и счастья в таком тяжёлом труде, Александра!
A genius at play !
Astounding and exceptional. Such a beautiful, stylistic, technically mastered and highly musical performance! Thank you for sharing. Big congratulations Alexandra and all the very best!
Волшебство! Какая лёгкость!!!
Златошвейка!
Умница!
A surprisingly determined and powerful touch.
Beautiful, just perfect.
It's so enchanting. The minor key ends in in a major key, the major key ends in a minor key. Beautiful.
По-настоящему отлично сыграно! Саша так держать!
Beauuuuuuuutiful!
The way she played this piece of musique is just perfect !
Admiration and respect ...
Magnifique ! Une révélation !!!
Это Божественно, Бесподобно и Уникально! Какой Дар и Трудолюбие стоят за таким исполнением! Amazingly talented and hardworking kid, only 11 years old!
Сашенька играет душой! Настолько чутко и трепетно!
I can't stop listening to this...
Absolutely amazing! What a talented girl!!!
Che dire Alexandra...sei la più grande Pianista vivente! Nulla meno di Sokolov in Rameau!
Grande, grande Maestra !
Marco Rotondi
Now I know for sure that Rameau composed this song especially for Sasha Dovgan.
This music is rather melancholic . And the interpretation of Alexandra breathes.
I think Alexandra's performance would be most recognisable by Rameau, above most if not all others. Others have slightly fancier trills, etc, but the overall clarity is everything.
Браво, потрясающе
The sound of genius, from this young Argerich.
This admirable girl is a formidable gem 💎
FINALLY, AFTER NEARLY 40 YEARS A WORTHY CONTENDER FOR THE CROWN KISSIN WEARS !!!
(I LIKE HER LOOK WHEN SHE RAISES HER HEAD AFTER THE LAST NOTE, SHE IS A REALLY PRETTY GIRL !!!)
Спасибо твоим учителям колосальный труд и терпение спасибо большое
Voor my de❗uitvoering van het jaar grandioos dank dank grooten dank
Сашенька умница ! Браво ! 🐦🐩🐀🐤🐑
Sublime orgoglio della Tua Maestra!
Mira sa che presto oscurerai tutte le altre !
Grande Scuola Russa! Solo la Napoletana può stare al Tuo passo...
Alexandra e Beatrice, Interpreti di riferimento per tutti i veri cultori della tastiera!
Marco Rotondi
...un angelo venuto a dirci che i miracoli esistono!!!
Уже пять лет подряд...захожу и слушаю и восхищаюсь ❤ гениально.
Yes ! Miraculous girl ! Talent is here , close to us !!
САШЕНЬКА,ТЫ- САМА В ДУШЕ, КАК МИЛАЯ ПТАШКА: И ТВОЯ ТРЕПЕТНОСТЬ,И НЕЖНОСТЬ И ВОЗДУШНАЯ КРАСОТА ЗВУКА- ВСЕ СЛИЛОСЬ ВОЕДИНО В ЭТОЙ ПЬЕСЕ РАМО.❤🦜🕊🐥Спасибо , милая девочка...Рамо был бы счастлив,услышав это исполнение)
Blyft de mooiste ensprankelte uitvoering dank
¡Por Dios, qué hermoso talento!
Beautiful
великолепно!
Какая же умница!
Clarity for the sound unbelievable!! Beautiful playing.
She has great dynamics too!
Van een hemelse schoonheid dank dank dank
Meer ramaeu kan er niet in gewelbig
Alexandra is a gift for all of us.
Most elegante Alex/. And most enjoyable too/. Best wishes from Sweden/.
Exquisite
We will be watching your career with great interest
Totaal ONBEGRYPELUK wereld klasse dank dank
It's a kind of inexperienced bach territory that you unfold me, So beautiful.
Excellent !
Hoe meer ik het hoor hoe wonderlijke ik het vindt dank grote dank
Stunning tempo & rubato
Het is ONBEGRYPELUK mooi voor die leeftijd talent dank
Naar 16 maal nog steeds ontroerend mooi dank
In addition to all the other well deserved comments, she also has amazingly long fingers which is a tremendous asset as a pianist, and particularly in this style of music.
I saw her in an interview (some where on UT) in which they commented on her hands. She told she had always had long fingers from being very young and spread her hands to show them - smiling graciously.
¡Muy hermosa interpretación! Felicitaciones.
Super klasse
Wow! Just wow!
Mega ! Ein super Talent
Возвращаюсь снова и снова, как к роднику. С благодарностью к Рамо и Александре.
There are no words. Alexandra is by far my favourite living pianist.
The passion in this wonderful young lady is wonderful.
Умничка девочка! Прекрасно!
This performance is impeccable! You truly have a gift! I love the cleanness and (seemingly) ease of execution of the ornaments and the emotion conveyed here. Well done!
A jewel !
It’s like the music is playing itself effortlessly. The music just comes alive
Alexandra Dovgan - Deus te abençoe cada dia PARABÉNS pelo seu talento maravilhoso que você tem
Perfect onbegrijpelijk dank
Talent met grote belofte maak het waar dank
Most wonderful, she is a joy to watch👏👏👏❤❤❤
Creo que en alguna reencarnación, en algún otro planeta, oí tocar el piano así...
OMG😮!! Never heard Rameau with that swing👏
Brava!!!