THE OFFICIAL "HBA" MERCH IS HERE: thelifeoftinos.myspreadshop.ie/ Go grab your "HBA" merch with 15% off to celebrate this occasion! (There is a special gift for all my Indonesian friends) 🇮🇩🇨🇾
In some of their interviews, they said the song was written, when they were 14-15 years old. At that time, they talked to their band mentor who is also their school teacher about their anxiety about the bullying they experienced when they were just learning metal music. Then their mentor/teacher said, "Hey, you guys have God.. so try asking permission and begging your God.". And then they created this song at a young age. In fact, there are many women in the hijab who play metal music in Indonesia. I will mention two, maybe later you will react. The first, a band called GUGAT, the vocalist wears a hijab with screaming technique in her vocals. The second is a solo guitarist named MelSickScreamoAnnie. Salam.. stay healthy always bro..
There two perception on music in Islam. 1. You can play music.its ok what ever genre you play, just dont forget your praying time. 2. You can't play music. Music here not just Metal but from every genre Even qasidah (muslim music). And yeah what ever our choice we never ever fight for that. That lyric just for song only. My english bad, hope you understand
This song was created, there was an inner upheaval in the Vob. Because in Indonesia, many religious (Islamic) leaders state that music is prohibited. Semangat VOB 💪 .maju terus.baceprot.iam muslim support you
Sebagian pendapat ulama yg menghalalkan dan ada yg mengharamkan tentang musik namun bukan masalah musiknya tetapi lebih ke genre yg dibawakan VOB terkesan sudah dicap negatif di. Kultur masyarakat Indonesia apalagi berbau agama dipandang berprilaku buruk seperti mabuk2an, perkelahian dll dan berpenampilan urakan dan tdk sopan seperti setan. Sebelum VOB banyak group musik di Indonesia dgn berbagai genre seperti nasyida ria (qasidahan), soneta group ( dangdut ), gambus bahkan band2 Indonesia banyak membawakan atau menciptakan lagu religi. Jadi VOB dilagu ini menjawab kritikan dari orang yg mem-bully-nya. Aing Urang Garut Ngarojong terus VOB💪🙏
Yes, because metal music for some people is not only in Indonesia but in many countries the environment is considered too wild, rough and brutal, it is influenced by the stage style and the environment of its predecessors, so the response becomes irrelevant to a normal lifestyle, especially those who are hijabers. Even some parents don't really give a good response if their children are on rock music paths, especially those with a more religious appearance.
Indonesia is a country with the largest Muslim population in the world, Indonesia has a music culture but recently there are some Islamic teachers who say that music is not allowed because of sin, not all Indonesians agree with that teaching including VOB, that's why VOB made this song
Your new youtube intro is nice. Thanks for always add music knowledge in your every reaction. That makes me know better about Indonesian Musician. I wear hijab and I almost listen to all kind of music. And we just don't have to explain to other why do we listen or play it. "It's My Life" Bon Jovi ☕ Kopi Mana Kopi 😎
Woooy.... Kopi mana kopi ☕😁 mantaaap jiwa 👍 Nice react, tinos stay 01.10.2021 alfy rev chanel reales next wonderland Indonesia new reales 'SPIRIT OF PAPUA'. #TORANGBISA
next you have to see the Indonesian rockabilly band that has toured las Vegas, the name of the band is The Hydrant ... or try to see the Shaggydog band entitled from the doc to the dog
In Indonesia, Muslims are moderate, very open to all kinds of music, including metal, only a few have different views about music being haram. interpretation of music itself in Islam is still a lot different. but Islamic culture itself in its history has often used music in all media of da'wah. Kanjeng Sunan Kalijaga uses music to preach in the spread of Islam. and Kyai Kanjeng Caknun also uses music as a propaganda tool. always success Indonesian music #musicindonesia#muslimindonesia #music #voiceofbaceprot
Selamat petang sahabat ku 👏👏👏 Kopi mana kopi bro ☕☕☕ If all are Muslim, they can sing and play music...But they must also Their song must be a good song but the clothes it must be safe to use 👍👍👍☕☕☕😷😷😷
Wacken 2022, vob Will be there...tinos in many place brother there is always two kind of people, first people that Will always supporting you and other Will be againts you...to stuff like that, i follow the Joker, about life why you ll. Be so seriously haha...enjoy life brother, drink coffee and hit the button...stay safe and peace...
In Indonesia, there is currently a radical Islamic group that has similar views to ISIS or the Taliban. In their doctrine, music is forbidden or not allowed. They are few in number but very noisy. These girls are only voicing the reality which is very likely their personal experience where they have experienced pressure, blasphemy and bullying just because they, women in hijab, play music, especially metal music.
*VOB* (Provinsi Jawa Barat Kota dodol GARUT daerah wilayah SINGAjaya🤝🇲🇨🤟. Voice Of Baceprot ----------------------------- Di awal main band mereka : (virdaMarsya+Widi+Siti) Mendapatkan tantangan dari lingkungan orang tua dan beberapa guru di sekolah, 1). virdaMARSYA vocal&guitar : Beberapa kali mendapatkan ancaman pembunuhan dan pernah di lempar batu bocor di kepala, 2). WIDI basis : Pernah sebulan dilarang pegang bas dan itu membuatnya depresi, 3). SITI drummer : Pernah di kunci di toilet untuk menghentikannya bermain drum, dan... Sampai sekarangpun ujaran kebencian atas nama agama, masih sering mereka dapatkan, *Tapi di Indonesia ada banyak pihak yang terus Mendukung dan Melindungi mereka(VOB)🤝Jadi mereka(VOB) Aman. Banyak Komunitas yang Menjaga mereka(🤗VOB🤗).* God bless all Amen.🤝🙏
7:10 I agree a million percent. But, in fact, there's some people judging and act like GOD for some innocent person. IMO, the lyrics not for god indeed. Keep rockin' girls 🤟🏻
Sebagian pendapat ulama yg menghalalkan dan ada yg mengharamkan tentang musik namun bukan masalah musiknya tetapi lebih ke genre yg dibawakan VOB terkesan sudah dicap negatif di. Kultur masyarakat Indonesia apalagi berbau agama dipandang berprilaku buruk seperti mabuk2an, perkelahian dll dan berpenampilan urakan dan tdk sopan seperti setan. Sebelum VOB banyak group musik di Indonesia dgn berbagai genre seperti nasyida ria (qasidahan), soneta group ( dangdut ), gambus bahkan band2 Indonesia banyak membawakan atau menciptakan lagu religi. Jadi VOB dilagu ini menjawab kritikan dari orang yg mem-bully-nya. Aing Urang Garut Ngarojong terus VOB💪🙏
Makaud dari lagu ini adalah jangan membatasi kreatifitas musik manusia hanya karna dia dari golongan tertentu dan jangan dianggap aneh atau melanggar peraturan karna sejatinya musik adalah kebebasan berekpresi
Thanks for ur support... In our religion (mosleem) in our country, some preach that music is bad (like a devil) expecially for woman.... But I'm not agree for that. And peoples of Indonesian love music. Music is universal language... Give peace a chance GBU.
There is just little different of argue about music in Muslim People.... But many muslims may to play'music as just as no make they are forgoted they God and life objevtive so far...
Mendengar lagu ini ingin menangis, seolah olah ingin keluar dari semua belenggu yang selama ini yang mengikatnya untuk bebas dengan ke inginan dirinya dan ingin bebas
There is a popular perception that music is generally forbidden in Islam. However, such a prescriptive statement elevates the issue to one of faith. The answer to the question is open to interpretation. The first consistent scholarly attack on music dates to the mid-10th century, and seems to be in response to illicit behavior tied to music, rather than to the music itself. No Islamic scholar would argue that Qur’anic recitation (qira’at) is forbidden, and many would argue that the Qur’an should be recited as beautifully as possible. To a person unfamiliar with qira’at, the sound would resemble music. However, in an Islamic legal framework the recitation is not music, and to call it so is insulting. The problem is that the term “music,” representing some combination of instruments and voice, does not map well onto the Arabic term musiqa; musiqa is one kind of audio art in the Islamic legal tradition; qira’at is another. The debate among Muslims is not about the permissibility of audio art, but about what kind of audio arts are permissible. The Qur’an, the first source of legal authority for Muslims, contains no direct references to music. Legal scholars use the hadith (saying and actions of Prophet Muhammad) as another source of authority, and have found conflicting evidence in it. The consensus that has emerged is that the audio arts fall into three broad categories: legitimate, controversial, and illegitimate. Qira’at, the call to prayer, religious chants and the like are all considered legitimate. Controversial audio arts include almost all other types of music. Illegitimate audio arts are considered to be those that take people away from the commandments of the faith. Music that leads to drinking or licentious behavior is considered illegitimate. Depending on the community of interpretation, one can find devotional music legitimate, controversial, or illegitimate.
Just for information 1st - The Outfit they use is Muslimah (Muslim women) clothes or Gamis (They Love To Use It). 2nd - There is a view that the God of Muslims forbids playing music, there are also those who do not forbid it. 3rd - They are Muslimah and Love Music. 4th - They do need a permission from GOD not from Humans They obey their god's will and they like it. They just want people to stop the HATRED to Muslim women who like to play music or singing. In my view for the last sec of the VM 5:28 - That kind of appearance is what the general public expects to Muslim women, obedient, not very vocal. and act like other women in general. And if you notice, that flames is their Boundary Y_Y. And you now what happend when we got fire ^_^. Great Reaction. And btw im Muslim to.
THE OFFICIAL "HBA" MERCH IS HERE: thelifeoftinos.myspreadshop.ie/
Go grab your "HBA" merch with 15% off to celebrate this occasion! (There is a special gift for all my Indonesian friends) 🇮🇩🇨🇾
thank brother.. you respon my request
NEXT please reaction sweet as revenge - potret kehampaan
the life of tinos sudah ngopi belum?
Tinos..reaction vob whose title is age oriented ua-cam.com/video/wgvXJRe8fCs/v-deo.html
Keren
In some of their interviews, they said the song was written, when they were 14-15 years old. At that time, they talked to their band mentor who is also their school teacher about their anxiety about the bullying they experienced when they were just learning metal music. Then their mentor/teacher said, "Hey, you guys have God.. so try asking permission and begging your God.". And then they created this song at a young age.
In fact, there are many women in the hijab who play metal music in Indonesia. I will mention two, maybe later you will react. The first, a band called GUGAT, the vocalist wears a hijab with screaming technique in her vocals. The second is a solo guitarist named MelSickScreamoAnnie.
Salam.. stay healthy always bro..
Even, they were rejected by their parents, before their parents know that they can make money from music...😄
It is a symbol of resistance by the young girls, for discrimination over women and music has been branded as haram ( restricted ) in Islam.
Kmu benar
There two perception on music in Islam.
1. You can play music.its ok what ever genre you play, just dont forget your praying time.
2. You can't play music. Music here not just Metal but from every genre Even qasidah (muslim music).
And yeah what ever our choice we never ever fight for that.
That lyric just for song only.
My english bad, hope you understand
This song was created, there was an inner upheaval in the Vob. Because in Indonesia, many religious (Islamic) leaders state that music is prohibited. Semangat VOB 💪 .maju terus.baceprot.iam muslim support you
But it is True...islam not allowed moslem to practise music...these Girls were definitely "line up for hell"....but let God be the judge!
Sebagian pendapat ulama yg menghalalkan dan ada yg mengharamkan tentang musik namun bukan masalah musiknya tetapi lebih ke genre yg dibawakan VOB terkesan sudah dicap negatif di. Kultur masyarakat Indonesia apalagi berbau agama dipandang berprilaku buruk seperti mabuk2an, perkelahian dll dan berpenampilan urakan dan tdk sopan seperti setan. Sebelum VOB banyak group musik di Indonesia dgn berbagai genre seperti nasyida ria (qasidahan), soneta group ( dangdut ), gambus bahkan band2 Indonesia banyak membawakan atau menciptakan lagu religi. Jadi VOB dilagu ini menjawab kritikan dari orang yg mem-bully-nya. Aing Urang Garut Ngarojong terus VOB💪🙏
" Haram music is the sound of our plates, forks & spoons. when people around us are hungry. " ️ 🤟😎 🇮🇩
Their live performance is so neat tidy...
All of lyrics have deep meaning as well for this wakanda country
next year they will have a concert in Europe, first in Germany.
This December they will perform in France
They sing this song for people who think that he worships the devil, in fact they are diligent in worshiping their religion
Wacken Lineup 🔥🔥🔥
WOA august, 2022
Yes, because metal music for some people is not only in Indonesia but in many countries the environment is considered too wild, rough and brutal, it is influenced by the stage style and the environment of its predecessors, so the response becomes irrelevant to a normal lifestyle, especially those who are hijabers. Even some parents don't really give a good response if their children are on rock music paths, especially those with a more religious appearance.
Indonesia is a country with the largest Muslim population in the world, Indonesia has a music culture but recently there are some Islamic teachers who say that music is not allowed because of sin, not all Indonesians agree with that teaching including VOB, that's why VOB made this song
VOB success always... Salam baladceprot Indonesia... 🤘🏻👍🏻🙏🏻
Indonesian have metal girl band and go to international...respect for the life of tinus and saluuuudd buat kalian VOB 👐👐👐👐👐
Yeahh.. it's my Favourite METAL band 💕🤘🏻🇮🇩🤘🏻💕
Beautiful and relevant lyrics. Good reaction, Bro. Music for the soul!!
I appreciate that
Who's gonna be the first band I interview? the girls from VOB!!in person too . So awesome, so excited and a little stressed I have to say.
YES REVOLUSI time of change, keep going, young people of INDONESIA
Hi...hi... welcome back...selamat malam too, keep healthy, keep spirit... thank's for watching three metal girls...i like that 💪👍
Yeah...... rock never die 💪👍👋 🇮🇩
Keren keren ...mantap jiwA,☕☕👍👍❤️❤️
Your new youtube intro is nice. Thanks for always add music knowledge in your every reaction. That makes me know better about Indonesian Musician. I wear hijab and I almost listen to all kind of music. And we just don't have to explain to other why do we listen or play it. "It's My Life" Bon Jovi ☕ Kopi Mana Kopi 😎
7:53 "not 'rona wkwk" had me laughing lmao, that's a nice touch for your Indonesian viewers, well played
Music its my soul..like all, TBD for All 🤟
Massage : " do... what want you do, cause your talent a real gift from your god"
Just be your self and keep strong
Some news said:
This end of the years Vob will do a Europa tour on 4 countries. Nederland, Belgium, France and Switzerland.
Woooy.... Kopi mana kopi ☕😁 mantaaap jiwa 👍
Nice react, tinos stay 01.10.2021 alfy rev chanel reales next wonderland Indonesia new reales 'SPIRIT OF PAPUA'.
#TORANGBISA
VOB #GETIHGARUT# MANG SOK GASS KEUN, HATUR THANKS U MANG SALAM🤘 BALADCEPROT GARUT ❤️🇲🇨🙏
I love your reaction, because you know the lyric means
They'll perform this December in Rennes (France)
That's the true story song of the vob band bro
in our country (Indonesia) there are still many people who consider metal music or the like that sounds loud as misleading music..
finally i'm waiting for this 🤘
next you have to see the Indonesian rockabilly band that has toured las Vegas, the name of the band is The Hydrant ... or try to see the Shaggydog band entitled from the doc to the dog
Widi the Queen of slap 🤘
VOB goes to wacken open air in 2022 🤘🤘
Mantap 👍👍.☕☕☕.Always successful and healthy. 🙏🙏
Mantap ...pisan .
Kopi mana kopi .
Baladceprot tangerang hdir..
V.O.B from Indonesia 🙌🙌🙌🙌🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🙌🙌🙌🙌
Nonton lagi and lagi
Lagu nya V.O.B mantap
And
Penyampian yang ga buat bosen untuk di tonton...
Mantap
Kopi mana kopi😂
Wow...amazing idea ..kopi mana kopi 😊
Thx tinos to supported this gals...
Amaze with "kopi mana kopi......."
Mantap mantap mantap.
Thanks to your reacts bro.
In Indonesia, Muslims are moderate, very open to all kinds of music, including metal, only a few have different views about music being haram. interpretation of music itself in Islam is still a lot different. but Islamic culture itself in its history has often used music in all media of da'wah. Kanjeng Sunan Kalijaga uses music to preach in the spread of Islam. and Kyai Kanjeng Caknun also uses music as a propaganda tool. always success Indonesian music #musicindonesia#muslimindonesia #music #voiceofbaceprot
Karena ada VOB 🤘😎
Thanks you to react VOB girl band from Indonesis....Salam hormat from Indonesia❤❤
Mantaaaaap 🙏❤🇲🇨
Vob the best 🤘
Josss mantap bos. Semoga musik metal bangkit kembali dengan adanya Bandung ini
VOB... Wow amazing 😮😯😳 peace from Indonesia 🚩🚩 ✌❤😍
high class music...🤘🤘🤘
Yeahh terima kasih sudah buat Vidio ini
Mrinding dengar liriknya.. keren
Luar biasa 3 wanita asal garut👏👏👍👍
Waoo nice vob, amazing
VOB
Talenta Langit
Bukan mustahil
Grammy Awards
Aamiin
🇮🇩🙏🙏🇮🇩
Kopi mana kopi...
Thanks your reaction...
Kopi mana kopi 😄 nice song for V.O.B thanks brothers..
Even music is not a religion... But music make us be a unity...
VOB, SALUTE.,.,👍👍👍
VoB.. metal band wearing hijab .. Garut Indonesia... success for them .. good
FYI TINOS...VOB WILL PLAY ON WACKEN OPEN AIR IN GERMANY 2022
Waw you very cool bro, react this band...
Mantap...
Selamat petang sahabat ku 👏👏👏
Kopi mana kopi bro ☕☕☕
If all are Muslim, they can sing and play music...But they must also Their song must be a good song but the clothes it must be safe to use 👍👍👍☕☕☕😷😷😷
Hatur Nuhun VOB 👍👍
the coffee is almost finished my brother, please add more and enjoy
🤣🤣😄😄😄
Wacken 2022, vob Will be there...tinos in many place brother there is always two kind of people, first people that Will always supporting you and other Will be againts you...to stuff like that, i follow the Joker, about life why you ll. Be so seriously haha...enjoy life brother, drink coffee and hit the button...stay safe and peace...
In Indonesia, there is currently a radical Islamic group that has similar views to ISIS or the Taliban. In their doctrine, music is forbidden or not allowed. They are few in number but very noisy.
These girls are only voicing the reality which is very likely their personal experience where they have experienced pressure, blasphemy and bullying just because they, women in hijab, play music, especially metal music.
Wahabi otak CINGKRANG sumbu pendek
*VOB* (Provinsi Jawa Barat Kota dodol GARUT daerah wilayah SINGAjaya🤝🇲🇨🤟.
Voice Of Baceprot
-----------------------------
Di awal main band mereka : (virdaMarsya+Widi+Siti)
Mendapatkan tantangan dari lingkungan orang tua dan beberapa guru di sekolah,
1). virdaMARSYA vocal&guitar : Beberapa kali mendapatkan ancaman pembunuhan dan pernah di lempar batu bocor di kepala,
2). WIDI basis : Pernah sebulan dilarang pegang bas dan itu membuatnya depresi,
3). SITI drummer : Pernah di kunci di toilet untuk menghentikannya bermain drum,
dan...
Sampai sekarangpun ujaran kebencian atas nama agama, masih sering mereka dapatkan,
*Tapi di Indonesia ada banyak pihak yang terus Mendukung dan Melindungi mereka(VOB)🤝Jadi mereka(VOB) Aman. Banyak Komunitas yang Menjaga mereka(🤗VOB🤗).*
God bless all Amen.🤝🙏
7:10 I agree a million percent. But, in fact, there's some people judging and act like GOD for some innocent person.
IMO, the lyrics not for god indeed. Keep rockin' girls 🤟🏻
Thank you sir for your reaction
Thank you for reaction for music indonesia
Legendary pop rock INDONESIA 80-90 NIKE ARDILLA - BINTANG KEHIDUPAN
Mantap
INDONESIA....For you.....
VOB in concert UK
WED 27 JULY 2022
THE DEAF INSTITUTE
MANCHESTER
THU 28 JULY 2022
BOSTON MUSIC ROOM
LONDON
Mantuuuulllll.
Mantap friend👍💖🇲🇨
Kopi dulu 👍🙂
Wow mantapp...👍
Matur nuwun juga 😁
💪🇮🇩❤️❤️❤️saya sudah subscreb mas bos 👍👍👍
yes....V.OB. mantul
Garrruuutttt caddaassss.....🤘
2:25 coffee that drives you crazy or the snare drum?😂
Sebagian pendapat ulama yg menghalalkan dan ada yg mengharamkan tentang musik namun bukan masalah musiknya tetapi lebih ke genre yg dibawakan VOB terkesan sudah dicap negatif di. Kultur masyarakat Indonesia apalagi berbau agama dipandang berprilaku buruk seperti mabuk2an, perkelahian dll dan berpenampilan urakan dan tdk sopan seperti setan. Sebelum VOB banyak group musik di Indonesia dgn berbagai genre seperti nasyida ria (qasidahan), soneta group ( dangdut ), gambus bahkan band2 Indonesia banyak membawakan atau menciptakan lagu religi. Jadi VOB dilagu ini menjawab kritikan dari orang yg mem-bully-nya. Aing Urang Garut Ngarojong terus VOB💪🙏
I love vob
great bro i like your style bro
Their music is solid
Amazing VOB!!🔥🔥🔥🇮🇩🇮🇩🤘
Succes vob
Makaud dari lagu ini adalah jangan membatasi kreatifitas musik manusia hanya karna dia dari golongan tertentu dan jangan dianggap aneh atau melanggar peraturan karna sejatinya musik adalah kebebasan berekpresi
Thanks for ur support... In our religion (mosleem) in our country, some preach that music is bad (like a devil) expecially for woman.... But I'm not agree for that. And peoples of Indonesian love music. Music is universal language... Give peace a chance GBU.
There is just little different of argue about music in Muslim People....
But many muslims may to play'music as just as no make they are forgoted they God and life objevtive so far...
Waoo Amazink
Mendengar lagu ini ingin menangis, seolah olah ingin keluar dari semua belenggu yang selama ini yang mengikatnya untuk bebas dengan ke inginan dirinya dan ingin bebas
God loves everyone who making peacefull and pray to God as long as you live
There is a popular perception that music is generally forbidden in Islam. However, such a prescriptive statement elevates the issue to one of faith. The answer to the question is open to interpretation. The first consistent scholarly attack on music dates to the mid-10th century, and seems to be in response to illicit behavior tied to music, rather than to the music itself. No Islamic scholar would argue that Qur’anic recitation (qira’at) is forbidden, and many would argue that the Qur’an should be recited as beautifully as possible. To a person unfamiliar with qira’at, the sound would resemble music. However, in an Islamic legal framework the recitation is not music, and to call it so is insulting. The problem is that the term “music,” representing some combination of instruments and voice, does not map well onto the Arabic term musiqa; musiqa is one kind of audio art in the Islamic legal tradition; qira’at is another.
The debate among Muslims is not about the permissibility of audio art, but about what kind of audio arts are permissible. The Qur’an, the first source of legal authority for Muslims, contains no direct references to music. Legal scholars use the hadith (saying and actions of Prophet Muhammad) as another source of authority, and have found conflicting evidence in it. The consensus that has emerged is that the audio arts fall into three broad categories: legitimate, controversial, and illegitimate. Qira’at, the call to prayer, religious chants and the like are all considered legitimate. Controversial audio arts include almost all other types of music. Illegitimate audio arts are considered to be those that take people away from the commandments of the faith. Music that leads to drinking or licentious behavior is considered illegitimate. Depending on the community of interpretation, one can find devotional music legitimate, controversial, or illegitimate.
Agree..
Maybe devotional music (nasheeds) with musical instruments are considered illegitimate based on interpretation by salafists.
enak banget buat temen tidur
HATUR NUHUN ABAHHHHH.......
Maturnuhun..
Just for information
1st - The Outfit they use is Muslimah (Muslim women) clothes or Gamis (They Love To Use It).
2nd - There is a view that the God of Muslims forbids playing music, there are also those who do not forbid it.
3rd - They are Muslimah and Love Music.
4th - They do need a permission from GOD not from Humans
They obey their god's will and they like it.
They just want people to stop the HATRED to Muslim women who like to play music or singing.
In my view for the last sec of the VM 5:28 - That kind of appearance is what the general public expects to Muslim women, obedient, not very vocal. and act like other women in general.
And if you notice, that flames is their Boundary Y_Y. And you now what happend when we got fire ^_^.
Great Reaction.
And btw im Muslim to.