They complain to us, as they understand our mindset , it buys them sympathy, and they believe that Israel, as a last remainder of colonisation will stop being a Jewish entity once it is considered a the paria nation, same as South Africa stopped being a colonial state once the world turned against it.
That is a marketing, it's not a contradiction... The number of death is proportional to the pity from the West, which is proportional to hate towards the Jews
Q: *What are some lessons that Muslims need to learn?* A1: *Wrong book leads to wrong results!* A2: *Actions have consequences!* A3: *Losing a war you started is called Defeat, not Genocide!*
Thank you Yirmiyahu Danzig, for coming to this podcast! 🙏🏼 we need more voices like yours, talking about the ancestry in the land of Israel and maybe, just maybe, that will help against the ignorance plaguing Hamas supporters
His knowledge and perspective is so helpful. There are few people able to put this conflict into such a humanist view. He’s quite incredible. I like his podcast, but it’s very much aimed at people who have little understanding. It’s certainly a great service to his country and his people; but I haven’t seen him light up with the fire of a vision the way he does in this conversation. I hope he will do more conversations like this on his channel. I also love that he is clearly a feminist. He talks about women in a way that makes me want to cry with relief. He definitely understands the utter devastation I felt when I saw Shani Louk’s body being treated that way; and how angry I was when I saw people trying to minimise or justify that as some kind of revolutionary act.
One of the things I love about your podcast Yasmine is that you attract such good people. I hadn't heard of Yirmiyahu Danzig and now I'm following him on Instagram. I love what he said about people in Israel who want peace to learn Arabic and to learn Hebrew to be able to cross over to that heart level of communication that's so lacking right now. This kind of conversation provides much needed (even if cautious) hope.
It goes something like this 😓: Israel: October 7 was one of the worst massacres committed against Israeli citizens World: October 7? What happened to Israelis on October 7??
@@enzopubg77 a directive that was meant to prevent hostages from being taken to Gaza by terrorists. Eliminating the terrorist with the risks involved because the hostage will likely be killed in Gaza.
I grew up in Houston, Texas in the 1980's and my best friends came from Muslim familues, who were always so lovely to me. They were the best students then, throughout high school and university. The huge Farsi-speaking professional community hosted the sophisticated Iranian Film Festival every year, and Pakistani doctors and engineers made education a number 1 priority for their kids too, along with those of their Indian friends. My friends had match-makers in their mosques but it was not forced, more like organized in ways in which the women also had a say, and none of my friends were against it; it was a help in finding the right person. I went to many Henna nights and weddings and never was I treated with anything but affection (and to amazing cuisine). Years later I moved to Europe and was shocked to see a totally... different kind of group here - one with people like those I knew, but as a minority within a greater community with a very different set of priorities and way of life. It pains me to see what can happen to what I knew to be a wonderful, open, educated, affectionate, respectful culture. You give me hope that there is still hope for different peoples to get along and even be friends! Thank you for every precious episode from this lazy Catholic!
Short anecdote about trying to reach across and talk to Palestinians: I tried. I had Palestinian students that I liked a lot. I started chatting up a young Palestinian who worked in my building, after months of short conversations, I had one deeper. Within five minutes, he told me gays cause earthquakes, and if his brother came out of the closet, he would hunt him down. He started asking if I was gay. Obviously not all Palestinians are like that, but that had very quickly turned into a much scarier scene
They grew up in lies(Palestine the identity was created by Yasser Arafat and KGB using the Standard Islamic Narrative and the colonial Roman name Syria Palestina, because Arafat was a criminal in both Jordan and Syria he created a nation out of nowhere) of course they speak nothing but lies.
Sometimes our experience of a conversation is different to the other person’s. Actually, when someone gets angry in a conversation like this, it’s often because a nerve has been struck; and the acting out is the cognitive dissonance when they see an idea for the first time. Please don’t feel that you need to do anything different or pursue conversation which is unsafe (not in a feeling sense but in an existential sense). I think this does trickle down into consciousness. Whether you think about it this way or not, you’ve posed the question “if you want me to care about you as an equal, why don’t you extend that to other people?” Ultimately anyone who has a personal social justice cause, and genuine humanitarian sentiment will find themselves questioning this; and it’s the cumulative effects of podcasts and conversations like you had that helped someone like Mossab Hassan Yousef make the life changing course corrections that they choose. People who haven’t yet seen it his debate with Marc Lamont Hill pls watch ua-cam.com/video/5XW-ohDnPgM/v-deo.html&pp=ygUhbW9zc2FiIGhhc3NhbiB5b3VzZWYgZGViYXRlIHdpdGgg Also I’m about to watch this new one, even though Cenk makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up with his arrogantly flippant attitude toward people he disagrees with, I’ll watch it because Mossab deserves everyone’s ear.
@@freedahlogic8368 The fact Cenk still puts out all the propagandic news slop, it, in my opinion, proves clearly that the anti-Israel (the ones who don't necessarily support Hamas directly) crowd's main argument, "Criticism of Israel is banned", is utter lies.
Not to genocide. God is not a murderer and didn’t say to kill innocent Palestinians more than 100k , destroy the city of 2 million people, starve them to death people in return for kidnapping 1000. This is wrong and by the way Israel is the name God gave Jacob and his ancestors and Abraham was a righteous man not a murderer. Israel are a people that lived on a land, not the land. And God created all of us, no one is more or less. Israelies are not worth more to God than Palestinians that is their big ego.. God will deal with them who have made him look like an evil person when He is the God of justice.
Really? Apart from his understanding of the migrations of peoples and world history, which is excellent, when he speaks of rapprochement, he is DELUSIONAL.
@@leslielandberg5620 his view is intergenerational, nothing he says insists on a timeline or specific metrics. He is talking about an attitude. This is his actual life and extended family he is talking about. Unless you also are living this in real time it’s kinda rich to be insulting.
I'm learning so much from your channel Yasmine, as I did from your book. Thanks again for platforming these smart, knowledgeable and empathetic voices 🙏🏻💜🍀 Great Q&A, too! Big hug from Mexico.
Yasmine try to reach also Sam Arnow, he knows a lot of Jewish history and has a channel of his own where he did a serie of Jewish history from the earliest period possible to our days. Fascinating serie And it would be very very interesting to talk to him. He knows a lot and he busted a lot of myths (also abot the Ethiopian Jews), even though i thought i knew what happened, he managed to change my point of view in each subject he talked about. He collaborated also with Henry Abramson, also a Jewish historian from Canada. (Also very interesting person you could talk with)
I JUST DISCOVERED Sam. I'm transfixed. I'm of Jewish ethnicity and don't know any of this. I watched the Pale of Settlements video. That's my grandfather's story, but I never asked him about it because I was too young and stupid to care about that rich history, and he never told me, maybe because it was painful and he was just leaving it behind.
@gg_rider my grandparents survived the holocaust and never spoke to my mother about it until late age. This generation wanted tovmove forward, the past was too painful to even think about.
I noticed that Yirmiyahu Danzig got constructive pushback from a Nigerian Non-Muslim and an Iranian ex-Muslim. Sarah also dipped into the "non-identity" aspect of being Persian, not Arabic, and being 1000% unwelcome in any Muslim country the moment she would step foot in one. My personal experience is with two young Palestinian students i met in the US. One was kind, conservative, and dismayed by White Women at University coming on to him to have sex with them and cheat on his wife, who was overseas, and then being ANGRY because he wouldn't cheat on his marriage. (I was frankly surprised at that degree of cultural bigotry.) His story was of living in Gaza and being unjustly victimized by Israeli rule. What I couldn't tell him at the time was that blowback from the violent intifada seemed unfair, but understandable in light of the suffering. Yasmine has spoken about the freedom that her father enjoyed in Gaza and Israel before terrorism begin boiling. The other Palestinian guy stealthily physically injured me, when his friend wasn't looking. Not a serious injury, but enough to let me know. He knew I was of Jewish ethnicity, he knew I was an activist on his side, and he knew I was invited to smoke tobacco in a hookah. Yet his RELIGION told him he had to "shove me to the side of the road" in his living room, as this was Muhammad's example for how to deal with Jews. I believe now is that this threat of Islamic fundamentalist restoration will never completely go away, and it will always be on the back burner, ready to emerge and rampage against Jews. I would love to be wrong.
Well, actually, as we speak israelis are massacring palestinians, not the other way around. We also know that israelis are taught / brainwashed to hate palestinians & arabs since child. Have u seen the movie zone of interest? That's actually what happens right now between israel & gaza
Its believed that there were jewish settlements in Kerala, India from the time of King Solomon. We belong to St. Thomas Christians from 1st Century. Kerala used to be the spice center since ancient time. Our Jews were called Cochin Jews
To all lovely Yasmine's group members: I find all of you so incredibly wonderful! I wish you were all my neighbors, and that I could invite you over for coffee and cake and just talk and learn and exchange thoughts. There is no one like any of you where I live in Germany and that is such a shame. But please know that you are all deeply appreciated and esteemed. Sarah, I congratulate you on your graduation! Sara, you are right, you cannot build a bridge with someone who wants to kill you. What a beautifully gracious guest, and what a precious community.
Amazing conversation. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU for showing a way to talk about this! I’m feeling quite emotional to hear such honest and assertive compassion. It’s something special. All of the people speaking here are absolute gems of intelligent, respectful dialogue and I hope you can do more podcasts of this particular flavour Yasmine. This dialogue you are having with Yirmyahu has been so powerful that I keep stopping it to take notes.
Fun fact about the first Judean commonwealth and the Caribbean: Columbus was trying to get to India. Knowing that some of the Jews were exiled from the first commonwealth to east Asia, some historians believe that he took a Jewish translator with him, to speak Hebrew with the local Indian Jews. Possibly some of the dumb things Columbus believed about the Caribbean he "discovered" is due to that failed attempt to translate
There is an a lot of lore surrounding Columbus and Jews. Nothing as far as I know is definitive but lots to suggest he had quite a few on his 1492 ships.
It’s hard to listen to pro-Palestine aka Hamas supporter’s response when someone points out things to think about, would rather stick to the propaganda rather than check it out. Reason it’s annoying, is that the propaganda is very limited, yet they talk as if they need to educate you even though you’ve heard the same rhetoric from pro Palestine aka Hamas supporters.
Those are the virtue signalers. If they really cared they would invest the time & energy to learn about the issues, people, and history. They won’t because they really don’t care.
That's how you know it's propaganda. Because it's narrow minded slogans and they have emotionally attached to it without realising. It's good to keep general communication and debates alive to not leave the stage only for the bullies.
Yirmiyahu is a gem. God ordained and purposed. I just kept thinking of his parents and how God brought them together knowing that He would make and use Yirmiyahu for His good purposes. The way God created him with all these "identities" connections, the peaceful calm way of expressing thoughts and truths, the ability to comprehend and sit in all the sides, the desire and courage to be vocal and do something about it, the intelligence to think and understand and articulate and recount history and information and the compassion to hear and hold stories from all sides. It's all the things I wish I was! Absolutely brilliant. I want to keep praying for you, your family and your calling because it's a high one. Through God's help you are doing an immense and great work. Thank you. Yasmine, I appreciate you having him on your show to encourage and inform your listeners. mutual flourishing. We need more voices like yours Yirmiyahu.
Hi Yasmine I am from the Caribbean and have had an encounter with a female Jew that have changed my life and I love your interview with this guest Yirmiyahu. It is interesting also that his name contains the abbreviation of Yahuah and I wonder if he has a divine calling which has not yet been revealed. May Yeshua bless him with an understanding of the truth of the Jewish Messiah to be a voice of truth to the nations. Shalom x
I can see that Yirmijahu is a beautiful soul and individual. And maybe I'm just a tired cynic, but I can no longer buy into his rosy picture. Skip this whole interview and go right to Tochi Osuji's comment... someone needs to start telling the full truth and focusing at the right altitude on the real problem which is global...and existential. 1:05:46
Arabic people should leave Gaza and Israel to the the Jewish people. There are seven member states of the Arab League in the region: Bahrain, Kuwait, Iraq, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates. A huge area of the middle east is Arabic. Leave the tiny state of Israel and Gaza to the Jews!
The majority of Palestinians are not Arabs. They speak and identify as Arabic because of the Arab Islamic invasion.. many Muslim Palestinians were Jews at some point before ottomans forcibly converted them.. you should learn more about the region before making absurd statements
@@nick_k.6000they are definitely not Jews who have been converted...they in fact ARE Arabs, mostly from Egypt and Jordan. There was always Jewish presence in Israel, even after the exile..and yet they were never intertwined with these Arab groups who pogromed them.
@@nick_k.6000 All you need to do is asked them for their surnames, and you can place the Arab country they came from. No matter how you repeat lies, it won’t turn to the truth, as long as there are facts to counter it.
Talking is good. Talking is the foundation of society. In this case though, I don't have much hope as long as there are people with an agenda to exterminate their perceived enemy as described in old and outdated books that should have been made obsolete a long time ago. Someone is gaining from the game of Divide and Conquer, but it's not the ordinary humans. Everybody has to do a deep soul-searching evaluation, but I have a hard time believing that those with a rigid mind and settled view of the world will do that. So we are back at square one on this. One huge thing - thanks to Yirmiyahu for speaking of it - is the opinions and indulgent ignorance of the not so innocent bystanders. Sun Tzu said it best more than 2000 years ago: to win the war you need to know both yourself and the enemy. Too many individuals in the West still believe democracy and/or capitalism won, and that everybody wants to live the American Dream. That is very far from the truth. To win this war against medieaval thought patterns of conquest and oppression due to what someone or other said 1500 years ago, is what we need to do. And that requires us to go beyond ingrained indeological programming and see ourselves and The Other in all our glory and disgrace. Not a conquest of the minds of our enemies to make them into copies of ourselves. There are psychiatric terms for that kind of behaviour. Can we heal ourselves and regain our humanity?
Loving your channel, and I knew Yerimiyahu from other channels, it's a long one but looking forward to it. Also being Jewish but having a friend who's family is Palestinian, it might help.
around 28:00 to around 30:00 it is inaccurate to have said that the problem is that people ie Arabs living in the Land and near have not met a Jew or Jews. Well about 20,000 people came from Gaza daily for work including thousands working in The Envelope the 22 or so communities which were violently assaulted on Oct 7, 2023. Further it is known that at least 100s of those workers had been working for more than a year to provide detailed maps and information about virtually every house, building, family so that the marauders, rapists, murderers, vile violent 3000 men could carry out the attacks on that day. This single oversight in your communication is a mere hint that a LOT of this well-intended conversation has some VERY wrong about it. The guest should have spoken up to clarify that multiple 1000s did not only meet but knew and worked with 1000s of Jewish people on a daily basis. Your well-intended conversation illustrates that even you two too live in a Cognitive Dissonance bubble.
0 seconds ago I wish I didn't have to agree, but I do. Unfortunately October 7th showed all of this optimism and idealism to be unfounded in reality. Perhaps you can get individuals who are truly constructively minded, but the problem is that you can't tell who they are and the consequences for guessing wrong are very severe
Exactly. That bothered me too! Yirmiyahu seems to be full of wishful thinking, and that could be dangerous if people don't see the Islamists for what they are. He also talked about all belief systems being malleable (or words to that effect) but Islam is not able to be 'modernised' in the same way that other belief systems have been. The Quran is believed by Muslims to be the *immutable* word of Allah. We have to educate Muslims to question Islam until apostasy reaches a tipping point, and then the whole ideology will come falling down. At 1:05:46 the Nigerian caller Tochi made a lot of sense to me too! This is a global issue and it can't be solved by well-meaning Israelis alone.
Great discussion Yasmine and Yirmiyahu. Thank you both 🙏. At 1:05:46 the Nigerian caller Tochi made a whole lot of sense to me! The Islamic #jihad is a global issue and it can't be solved by well-meaning Israelis like Yirmiyahu alone.
When I was in uni I participated in a dialogue group. It made me realize how vastly different the narratives are. At one point we were encouraged to offer ideas for further activities. I was happy to participate in activities that would educate me regarding the expiriences of Arabs/Palestinians in the 48 war for example, but when I offered an activity like a hiking group that would provide a neutral setting for people to get to know each other on a human level, that was shot down. I felt really disheartened. I thought the idea was bridging the gap and creating relationships but I realized that anything that wasn't about recruting Jews to the pre-established Palestinian narrative was not seen as acceptable, and any Jew who wasn't doing the talking points of the nationalism of the other side was not seen as an ally anymore... and let me be clear, we were all considered the most far left individuals in our society, but that wasn't good enough unless we erased our own self regard and experiences. I came out from it with the feeling that they didn't care about us on a human level but only as tools to further their agenda.. which made me understand that I had no place in their vision for this land.. and I gave up.
Thank you again for a fscinating interview Yasmine. It seems that there are more pro palestinian (as in support the development of the palestinian people towards independence and self realisation) on the israeli side than on those who call themselves "pro palestine".
An even stronger brand name, identity Q: would it be acceptable for people who live in Gdansk to start calling their city "Nazi Danzig?! That's what "Palestine, " is. Yirmiyahu is correct about the attemp to shrink the civil space of Jews, Israelis & Zionism hear that the Edu Dept of NYC prints outs or uploads info in many languages--NOT in Hebrew. 'Abything be done about that?
@liatsotto1378 before 1948, Jews were ‘Palestinians’. Miss Palestine was Jewish, the 1930s Palestinian Football Team had all Jewish players with Star of David on shirts (played against Australia in 1939), the Palestinian flag had a Star of David on it….Palestinian businesses were Jewish: Palestinian Railways was founded by a Jewish man, Palestinian Airways was founded by Jews, Palestinian Travel Agency was Jewish, Palestinian Electric co and Palestinian Foundry and Metal ere Jewish etc etc….Palestinian cultural institutions were Jewish: Palestinian Post, Palestinian Symphony Orchestra, Palestinian Broadcasting etc etc…After 1948, the old greco-roman ‘Palestina’ that Romans renamed JUDEA ND SAMARIA, cradle of Jewish civilisation, became the legally re-established sovereign Jewish state called ISRAEL
@Sarah with an H. Obama's ancestors came from Europe, on his mother's side, and incidentally owned over 100 slaves. People who say Jews with European ancestry aren't Jews would NEVER say Obama or Tyra Banks or Beyonce or Vanessa Hudgens or Zoe Kravitz or Megan Markle are NOT REALLY BLACK.
I have yet to hear - almost universally - what the impact of modern scholarship is going to have on Islamic culture. I would predict troubles ahead. Disciplines of literary criticism are right now (!) in the process of dissembling the story and roots of Islam. I expect that, as Imams and other Islamic scholars lose intellectual ground, extreme muslims will dig in.
You are beautiful people with beautiful views, but there is so much discussion about the rationalization, rather then the core values that led to it. One always gets lost discussing rationalization, because it's ever changing and expressed differently by different people. Look at the actions, and core values that support them.
Thanks to Sara Ghorbani for pointing out the distinctions when it comes to islam and the legal status of the apostates, those who have left this ideology (not religion: it is a legal system, a social system and a so called spiritual system). I know a few muslims. Nice and caring mostly, but I have also seen some of them showing a very different face when they think I don't see them, and that has been something to make me aware and keep a distance. I'm sure there are genuinely friendly muslims out there, but the thing is, an outsider cannot know the true hearts and minds of them all, and anybody can study history and see the trends over time in relation to average percentages of muslims in any non-muslim society. We can't know what is hudna or taqqiyah, or a genuine wish to evolve their faith to become a constructive force in cooperation with people outside of their ummah. Neither are we helped by the ignorant or stupid leftists who cooperate with them on the grounds that they have a common goal of destroying western civilisation.
I haven't watched the whole thing yet, but I follow Yirmiyahu on different platforms and he's amazing. Personally my answer to the question in the title is: if I serve you 10 cups of something to drink, and told you only one of them has poison in it that could kill you, would you still drink it? I mean the majority of them are just fine, they won't harm you, only one... what's the problem?
The part when Jasminse told about how muslim twisting stories about how their victims (slaves & captured jewish women) love them so much, reminds me about how they said that the hostages were happy and even fell in love with their kidnappers ...
Calling Arabs "Palestinians," which is not an Arab name is fueling the Jihadi ideology for which the brandname was devised. Once things settle down... eventually, Inshallah, perhaps Dr Kedar's Arab tribal enirates (like the UAE) might work. Call it West Ordon Emirates, or whatever. But dont call them "Let's demolish the Jewish State" (which is what "Palestine" means to millions). Arab-Israelis is an altogether differnt entity, an equal-rights minority. To distinguish from Normalization Peace, which was created for the Abraham Peace Accords, by contrast, Islamist Peace = totalitarian, total Submission. Another important nuance to rememeber.
We can't really unify the Israeli education system since we are geographically divided with few exceptions like Lod, Jaffa, Acre, and even there, the neighborhoods are sub divided. We really do most things together, but I leave in one side of the road and they on the other. Jews wouldn't enjoy much the 5am loudspeaker call of the Muezzin, also Arabs hate parking cars at 90° or in a single parking lot.
The education system is not just fractured by geography, there are real difference in what students learn in school. In the Galil, students bus to school typically outside of their town or village. They travel to a secular school, religious school, or to Arabic speaking school of their region. All of whom have different educational content, and whose students have different images of what their future will be (secular Jews know they will be drafted). I don't think its that far fetched for there to be a more unified system. Of course self-segregation happens, like anywhere else in the world.
@@happinin07 I completely agree with you, yet at home we are quite different and it's a beautiful thing. October 7th Israeli Arabs reaction tells a success story, there is a extremely delicate situation and I would not touch a thing. Israeli Arabs are integral to Israel society. They don't openly identify with Hamas nor it shows by their actions and I completely trust it's not another peace fantasy. Shared system could very easily be used by agitators as a Zionist tool of silencing or indoctrination, currently it's not perfect and far from it, but if ain't broken don't fix it. After the October 2000 events, as a Galilee resident, we all got shocked to the core to see how volatile this harmony can be shattered, it was traumatic for Arabs and Jews alike.
very disappointed in the woman saying the third narrative is only one narrative. they have brought on people from all walks of life and have done good work. other than that great interview
Can we clone Yirmiyahu like a million times over? Even 1000X. Articulate, knowledgeable, speaks from deep experience, empathetic and focused on resolution. We need to hear from a Palestinian and an Arab who have the same focus. Solutions…we need people who can see the path to realistic and viable solutions through the crazy. We all know it will take a lot of time to get from A to B. That’s not the issue.
No one has ever denied that Jews have lived in the holy land for thousands of years. However, it has ALWAYS been inhabited by others as well, including the Palestinians and their descendants. The Jews don’t get to claim it as theirs alone.
Arabian peninsula belongs to Arabs, just like Judea and Samaria belongs to the Jews. The fact that other people lived there doesn’t give them the right to the land. It belongs to the Jews, that is an eternal decree. Either you believe it, acknowledge it or not. The return of Jews to the land of Isreal was foretold thousand of years ago, and this time, never to be displaced again. People can sneer at it, but no group of people have that unique identity and history. The more you delve into it, the more astounded the history of Isreal is. And am a gentile, not a Jew.
@nadilene789 YERUSHALAYIM, Holiest city of the Jewish people was 80% Jewish in 1864 (Ottoman Turk occupation census) before massive @rob (feudal clans, tribes, nomads from all over) came flooding in by the hundreds of thousands 1880+ after Jews bought and developed the land (improved agriculture etc) and also came after the fall of Ottoman Turk occupation during the British Mandate….500,000+ @rob migrants came (many illegals) even in the 1930s+ according to the 1937 Peel Commission
And so why do the numerous ethno-religious states surrounding Israel "get to claim it as theirs alone" when the Arab Muslim majorities achieved power and dominance by ethnic cleansing and "disappearing" the older cultures and religions there/ My God....just look at the demongraphics for the indigenous Greek, Armenian and Assyrian Christians of Anatolia, now Turkiye. Look at what is happening to the Copts of Egypt, Yazidis, Zoroastrians, also Jewish communities who had been living in those countries for thousands of years were exterminated from Yemen, Iraq, Morocco.. I am not Jewish or Muslim, but I cannot no longer bear the hypocrisy of the claims made against Israel by those who are silent when it comes to other nations that when judged by the same standards, have FAR LESS RIGHT TO EXIST than Israel.The Islamic Republic of Pakistan, look what they did to the much older Hindu population there. Your logic has a couple problems: first when you say "the Palestinians and their descendants ALWAYS inhabited it. This shows that you do not even know the history of this region, otherwise you would not make such a claim. But it's hard to blame people like you when the Pro-P propaganda goes from one very desperate and obvious lie ("Jesus was a Palestinian"....you mean the most famous Jew who ever lived, in JUDEA (Land of the Jews) before it was ever called Palestine, was a Palestinian? Furtthermore, the Jews don't claim it as their own. And they more any any other ethno-religious group in world history, would have every justification to only allow Jews to live there. They had their capital cty and holy temple destoyed by foreign invaders, were forced from their homeland to live as usually second class citizens around the world, at the mercy of a majority ready to scapegoat them for every problem, subject them to pogroms, camps and other horrors. Despite this incredibly awful way to be treated, when the Jews began returning to their ancestral homeland, they made every effort for peace. The Mslms rejected this at every turn, because while they can take the entire middle east by far more violence than Israel has done, how dare those Jews want a tiny piece of land that represents 0.4 percent of the middle east, to create another sovereign Jewish state like the ancient kingdoms of Judah and ISRAEL, so that they will not continue to be blamed for every social ill and continue to be expelled, attacked and erased. Yes, how incredibly selfish of the Jews for wanting this. Did you know that in Israel, 20 percent of the population is Arab Muslim? Who have the exact same rights as Jewish Israelis, who have been appointed to the highest positions in government, military, and judiciary? You will not find this same equality in any Islamic state, from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan to Egypt. I am so sick and tired of the constant lies being spread about Israel and the Jewish people, the constant attempts to question their right to a sovereign state in their ancestral homeland-a reality for many other nations around the world take for granted, because they are not surrounded by nations steeped in 1400 of J hatred. I am so sick and tired of the double standards to which Israel is held to account. How other nations that have recently and are still commiting ACTUAL genocides, are completely ignored by the mainstream media and selective outrage "humanitarian" protestors, who never bothered to get off their asses for the Syrians, Yemen, what Azerbaijan did to the Armenians, the Uyghur camps in China. Only when Israel and the Jews are involved, even though yet again they did not start this war, do anti-Semites around the world get exicted and think they can cloak their ancient hatred of the J in the guise of "humanitarianism' and "de-colonization". Well, the pro-P anti-Israel crowd have succeeded so far in that they have my attention. I live in a very woke progressive city.The day after news broke around the world of the carnage that Hamas had unleashed on Israeli civilians, a protest had already formed on a bridge in the downtown area. The Israeli people were still reeling in shock and trauma, and these (I will get banned for the names I want to call them) did not even have the humanity to put their unhinged hatred on hold for even one day: they were celebrating. I saw on social media, again in the days before Israel entered Gaza thousands of comments saying "Happy October". That same day in Sydney Australia, a crowd of thousands chanted "Gas the J, F the J". I cannot stand these people, and it is disturbing to see how many woke "progressive" protestors who preach about hate speech, minority rights stand hand in hand with the Islamists openly calling for essentially a repeat of October 7, but on a much larger scale. From seeing interviews of these useful idiots around the world on what they know about the history of the region and the current conflict, a majority of them cannot answer the most basic facts. They are happy to hold up signs and protest about a subject they know very little of. For myself, the kaffiyeh now represents the swastika, and that's coming from non-Jewish secular gay man. This has only strengthened my resolve to do whatever I can to refute the lis being told. Oh, and one more thing. Those so-called indigenous :"Palestinians" were never referred to as such until the 1960's; they were referred to as Arab Muslims by every state that ruled the region (Ottomans, Mamluks, etc), but after they attacked Israel, and were defeated yet again, they decided to rebrand themselves as a distinct ethnic groups, so that now Israel, always a minority, were now seen as the majority oppressor. Most of the "palestinians" came from Egypt, Jordan and other countries during the Zionist movement because the Jews turned what was an inhospitable land full od swamps and desert, into a thriving state, so Arabs began moving there for economic opportunities. And these "palestinians" have been offered their own state at least five times, and turned it down every time. So who is the true obstacle to peace here? It isn't Israel or the Jews. At the very least, this horrible tragedy has opened the world's eyes to the depravity on display by the pro-P protests. Unlike the Russia Ukraine protests, where were focused solely on the Putin administration, the pro-P crowd has repeatedy attacked Jewish people in their own communities around the world. I stand with Israel and the Jewish people, and after everything I have witnesses since last year, it is clear that the majority of these people don't know the history and given the chance, they would celebrate another Oct 7 on a nauinal scale.
wow. I learned so much. While my skin is white, my 23andMe test reveals that I am genetically indigenous to Israel, through something called my maternal haplogroup. From my mom's side, going all the way back.
An Enlightenment needs to come to Islam just as it has mostly happened to all other major religions where they take the best parts and drop the ideas that don’t work in the 21st Century.
*"If a cult loves death more than their opponent loves life, why are they complaining about high death count?"*
They complain to us, as they understand our mindset , it buys them sympathy, and they believe that Israel, as a last remainder of colonisation will stop being a Jewish entity once it is considered a the paria nation, same as South Africa stopped being a colonial state once the world turned against it.
Hamas doesn't care but they know the west does care so they have to tell the world so the west will stop israel from destroying hamas
ABSOLUTELY
That is a marketing, it's not a contradiction... The number of death is proportional to the pity from the West, which is proportional to hate towards the Jews
Because they know the West falls for that, especially, Wokefied Jews.
Q: *What are some lessons that Muslims need to learn?*
A1: *Wrong book leads to wrong results!*
A2: *Actions have consequences!*
A3: *Losing a war you started is called Defeat, not Genocide!*
Well said, everyone should be conscious that their actions bear consequences ... this is called karma or more simply common sense
Why ashkanazi jews come to middle East? Why colonized muslim land?
Why killed arab Christian and Muslim?
You going to completely ignore the past 75 years? Apparently
Thank you Yirmiyahu Danzig, for coming to this podcast! 🙏🏼 we need more voices like yours, talking about the ancestry in the land of Israel and maybe, just maybe, that will help against the ignorance plaguing Hamas supporters
His knowledge and perspective is so helpful. There are few people able to put this conflict into such a humanist view. He’s quite incredible. I like his podcast, but it’s very much aimed at people who have little understanding. It’s certainly a great service to his country and his people; but I haven’t seen him light up with the fire of a vision the way he does in this conversation. I hope he will do more conversations like this on his channel. I also love that he is clearly a feminist. He talks about women in a way that makes me want to cry with relief. He definitely understands the utter devastation I felt when I saw Shani Louk’s body being treated that way; and how angry I was when I saw people trying to minimise or justify that as some kind of revolutionary act.
*"If you recite the Quran, you are Muslim!*
*If you understand the Quran, you are Ex-Muslim!"*
🤣can't say I have ever heard this one before but it makes sense
Well said bravo!
What a joke hahahahahahahahaha met recht een plaat voor je kop
One of the things I love about your podcast Yasmine is that you attract such good people. I hadn't heard of Yirmiyahu Danzig and now I'm following him on Instagram. I love what he said about people in Israel who want peace to learn Arabic and to learn Hebrew to be able to cross over to that heart level of communication that's so lacking right now. This kind of conversation provides much needed (even if cautious) hope.
Two of my favorite people speaking out. Nice collab ❤
It’s ☀🧠 🔥 🥤 ❤🌱🕊🌍 It’s everything human about this.
*"Terrorism has no religion, but one Evil Cult has monopoly over Terrorism!"*
It goes something like this 😓:
Israel: October 7 was one of the worst massacres committed against Israeli citizens
World: October 7? What happened to Israelis on October 7??
Hannibal directive
@@enzopubg77 a directive that was meant to prevent hostages from being taken to Gaza by terrorists. Eliminating the terrorist with the risks involved because the hostage will likely be killed in Gaza.
@@enzopubg77 are you an Israeli military commander? Or just a Tik Tok rabble-rouser?
@@DianeMonahan killing civilians is terrorism or not?
@@enzopubg77war
I grew up in Houston, Texas in the 1980's and my best friends came from Muslim familues, who were always so lovely to me.
They were the best students then, throughout high school and university.
The huge Farsi-speaking professional community hosted the sophisticated Iranian Film Festival every year, and Pakistani doctors and engineers made education a number 1 priority for their kids too, along with those of their Indian friends.
My friends had match-makers in their mosques but it was not forced, more like organized in ways in which the women also had a say, and none of my friends were against it; it was a help
in finding the right person.
I went to many Henna nights and weddings and never was I treated with anything but affection (and to amazing cuisine).
Years later I moved to Europe and was shocked to see a totally... different kind of group here - one with people like those I knew, but as a minority within a greater community with a very different set of priorities and way of life.
It pains me to see what can happen to what I knew to be a wonderful, open, educated, affectionate, respectful culture.
You give me hope that there is still hope for different peoples to get along and even be friends!
Thank you for every precious episode from this lazy Catholic!
I love Tochi's perspectives! It is always so enriching to hear him too.
He’s incredibly intelligent, and has a very clear moral compass.
Short anecdote about trying to reach across and talk to Palestinians: I tried. I had Palestinian students that I liked a lot. I started chatting up a young Palestinian who worked in my building, after months of short conversations, I had one deeper. Within five minutes, he told me gays cause earthquakes, and if his brother came out of the closet, he would hunt him down. He started asking if I was gay.
Obviously not all Palestinians are like that, but that had very quickly turned into a much scarier scene
They grew up in lies(Palestine the identity was created by Yasser Arafat and KGB using the Standard Islamic Narrative and the colonial Roman name Syria Palestina, because Arafat was a criminal in both Jordan and Syria he created a nation out of nowhere) of course they speak nothing but lies.
Most are stamped out of this mold, their upbringing ensures it. Son of HAMAS could tell you that.
@@leslielandberg5620funny because the beautiful woman you’re watching, yasmine mohammed, is a palestinian woman. don’t judge.
Sometimes our experience of a conversation is different to the other person’s. Actually, when someone gets angry in a conversation like this, it’s often because a nerve has been struck; and the acting out is the cognitive dissonance when they see an idea for the first time. Please don’t feel that you need to do anything different or pursue conversation which is unsafe (not in a feeling sense but in an existential sense). I think this does trickle down into consciousness. Whether you think about it this way or not, you’ve posed the question “if you want me to care about you as an equal, why don’t you extend that to other people?” Ultimately anyone who has a personal social justice cause, and genuine humanitarian sentiment will find themselves questioning this; and it’s the cumulative effects of podcasts and conversations like you had that helped someone like Mossab Hassan Yousef make the life changing course corrections that they choose.
People who haven’t yet seen it his debate with Marc Lamont Hill pls watch ua-cam.com/video/5XW-ohDnPgM/v-deo.html&pp=ygUhbW9zc2FiIGhhc3NhbiB5b3VzZWYgZGViYXRlIHdpdGgg
Also I’m about to watch this new one, even though Cenk makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up with his arrogantly flippant attitude toward people he disagrees with, I’ll watch it because Mossab deserves everyone’s ear.
@@freedahlogic8368 The fact Cenk still puts out all the propagandic news slop, it, in my opinion, proves clearly that the anti-Israel (the ones who don't necessarily support Hamas directly) crowd's main argument, "Criticism of Israel is banned", is utter lies.
What an amazing guest and an incredible host❤❤ I'm so so happy to see you both!🎉
*Love and Support to Israel from Bharat!* 🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱
I see your love and support and raise you with an invite to Seder 💙🤍💙
India is the best friend of Israel ... they have known for centuries what islam really means ... unfortunately they are not yet fully rid of it 😢
Not to genocide. God is not a murderer and didn’t say to kill innocent Palestinians more than 100k , destroy the city of 2 million people, starve them to death people in return for kidnapping 1000. This is wrong and by the way Israel is the name God gave Jacob and his ancestors and Abraham was a righteous man not a murderer. Israel are a people that lived on a land, not the land. And God created all of us, no one is more or less. Israelies are not worth more to God than Palestinians that is their big ego.. God will deal with them who have made him look like an evil person when He is the God of justice.
Yasmine Mohammed, cool video keep up the great content
Such a fantastic episode! Thanks to you both.
One of the very best conversations I have heard yet on the subject!
Really? Apart from his understanding of the migrations of peoples and world history, which is excellent, when he speaks of rapprochement, he is DELUSIONAL.
He is not delusional. He acknowledged the timing is very far off for several reasons given. He may see things you don’t, consider that.
@@leslielandberg5620 his view is intergenerational, nothing he says insists on a timeline or specific metrics. He is talking about an attitude. This is his actual life and extended family he is talking about. Unless you also are living this in real time it’s kinda rich to be insulting.
This man is so interesting to listen to, really appreciate these wonderful people you bring on your show Jasmine. Thank you again.
Love That_Semite! Such an inspiration, such vast knowledge and such a talent for presenting information
Thank you! You are beautiful people, maybe there is hope for this world
I'm learning so much from your channel Yasmine, as I did from your book. Thanks again for platforming these smart, knowledgeable and empathetic voices 🙏🏻💜🍀 Great Q&A, too! Big hug from Mexico.
Yasmine try to reach also Sam Arnow, he knows a lot of Jewish history and has a channel of his own where he did a serie of Jewish history from the earliest period possible to our days. Fascinating serie
And it would be very very interesting to talk to him. He knows a lot and he busted a lot of myths (also abot the Ethiopian Jews), even though i thought i knew what happened, he managed to change my point of view in each subject he talked about.
He collaborated also with Henry Abramson, also a Jewish historian from Canada. (Also very interesting person you could talk with)
I JUST DISCOVERED Sam. I'm transfixed. I'm of Jewish ethnicity and don't know any of this. I watched the Pale of Settlements video. That's my grandfather's story, but I never asked him about it because I was too young and stupid to care about that rich history, and he never told me, maybe because it was painful and he was just leaving it behind.
@gg_rider my grandparents survived the holocaust and never spoke to my mother about it until late age. This generation wanted tovmove forward, the past was too painful to even think about.
Thank a lot Romero..!
Yes, make it happen please!!! I'm not a Jew, but I love his channel and how he tells about the rich and complex Jewish history
I noticed that Yirmiyahu Danzig got constructive pushback from a Nigerian Non-Muslim and an Iranian ex-Muslim.
Sarah also dipped into the "non-identity" aspect of being Persian, not Arabic, and being 1000% unwelcome in any Muslim country the moment she would step foot in one.
My personal experience is with two young Palestinian students i met in the US. One was kind, conservative, and dismayed by White Women at University coming on to him to have sex with them and cheat on his wife, who was overseas, and then being ANGRY because he wouldn't cheat on his marriage.
(I was frankly surprised at that degree of cultural bigotry.) His story was of living in Gaza and being unjustly victimized by Israeli rule. What I couldn't tell him at the time was that blowback from the violent intifada seemed unfair, but understandable in light of the suffering.
Yasmine has spoken about the freedom that her father enjoyed in Gaza and Israel before terrorism begin boiling.
The other Palestinian guy stealthily physically injured me, when his friend wasn't looking. Not a serious injury, but enough to let me know. He knew I was of Jewish ethnicity, he knew I was an activist on his side, and he knew I was invited to smoke tobacco in a hookah. Yet his RELIGION told him he had to "shove me to the side of the road" in his living room, as this was Muhammad's example for how to deal with Jews.
I believe now is that this threat of Islamic fundamentalist restoration will never completely go away, and it will always be on the back burner, ready to emerge and rampage against Jews. I would love to be wrong.
Well, actually, as we speak israelis are massacring palestinians, not the other way around. We also know that israelis are taught / brainwashed to hate palestinians & arabs since child. Have u seen the movie zone of interest? That's actually what happens right now between israel & gaza
@yogirizky8290 反串，你要高级黑也不要太明显吧。 很无语。暴露了
Its believed that there were jewish settlements in Kerala, India from the time of King Solomon. We belong to St. Thomas Christians from 1st Century. Kerala used to be the spice center since ancient time. Our Jews were called Cochin Jews
To all lovely Yasmine's group members:
I find all of you so incredibly wonderful!
I wish you were all my neighbors, and that I could invite you over for coffee and cake and just talk and learn and exchange thoughts. There is no one like any of you where I live in Germany and that is such a shame.
But please know that you are all deeply appreciated and esteemed.
Sarah, I congratulate you on your graduation!
Sara, you are right, you cannot build a bridge with someone who wants to kill you.
What a beautifully gracious guest, and what a precious community.
Amazing conversation. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU for showing a way to talk about this! I’m feeling quite emotional to hear such honest and assertive compassion. It’s something special. All of the people speaking here are absolute gems of intelligent, respectful dialogue and I hope you can do more podcasts of this particular flavour Yasmine. This dialogue you are having with Yirmyahu has been so powerful that I keep stopping it to take notes.
Fun fact about the first Judean commonwealth and the Caribbean:
Columbus was trying to get to India. Knowing that some of the Jews were exiled from the first commonwealth to east Asia, some historians believe that he took a Jewish translator with him, to speak Hebrew with the local Indian Jews. Possibly some of the dumb things Columbus believed about the Caribbean he "discovered" is due to that failed attempt to translate
There is an a lot of lore surrounding Columbus and Jews. Nothing as far as I know is definitive but lots to suggest he had quite a few on his 1492 ships.
It is my understanding that there were six confirmed Marranos (Cryptic-Jews) on Columbus’s first voyage.
They can never be trusted, never……..
clicked IMMEDIATELY excited for this one
It’s hard to listen to pro-Palestine aka Hamas supporter’s response when someone points out things to think about, would rather stick to the propaganda rather than check it out. Reason it’s annoying, is that the propaganda is very limited, yet they talk as if they need to educate you even though you’ve heard the same rhetoric from pro Palestine aka Hamas supporters.
Those are the virtue signalers. If they really cared they would invest the time & energy to learn about the issues, people, and history. They won’t because they really don’t care.
That's how you know it's propaganda. Because it's narrow minded slogans and they have emotionally attached to it without realising. It's good to keep general communication and debates alive to not leave the stage only for the bullies.
Opportunities like this that encourage peaceful dialogue is wonderful
Yirmiyahu is a gem. God ordained and purposed. I just kept thinking of his parents and how God brought them together knowing that He would make and use Yirmiyahu for His good purposes. The way God created him with all these "identities" connections, the peaceful calm way of expressing thoughts and truths, the ability to comprehend and sit in all the sides, the desire and courage to be vocal and do something about it, the intelligence to think and understand and articulate and recount history and information and the compassion to hear and hold stories from all sides. It's all the things I wish I was! Absolutely brilliant. I want to keep praying for you, your family and your calling because it's a high one. Through God's help you are doing an immense and great work. Thank you. Yasmine, I appreciate you having him on your show to encourage and inform your listeners. mutual flourishing. We need more voices like yours Yirmiyahu.
Wow. Enlightening! Thank you. ❤
*"Women defending Izlam is like Chickens defending KFC!"*
Hi Yasmine I am from the Caribbean and have had an encounter with a female Jew that have changed my life and I love your interview with this guest Yirmiyahu. It is interesting also that his name contains the abbreviation of Yahuah and I wonder if he has a divine calling which has not yet been revealed. May Yeshua bless him with an understanding of the truth of the Jewish Messiah to be a voice of truth to the nations. Shalom x
Amazing interview. I'm so excited you got together. Very knowledgeable guest
Again, fantastic episode, thanks!
Thank you for this ❤
brilliant pod cast
I can see that Yirmijahu is a beautiful soul and individual. And maybe I'm just a tired cynic, but I can no longer buy into his rosy picture. Skip this whole interview and go right to Tochi Osuji's comment... someone needs to start telling the full truth and focusing at the right altitude on the real problem which is global...and existential. 1:05:46
Thank you for this
I loved this so much!!!
Arabic people should leave Gaza and Israel to the the Jewish people. There are seven member states of the Arab League in the region: Bahrain, Kuwait, Iraq, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates. A huge area of the middle east is Arabic. Leave the tiny state of Israel and Gaza to the Jews!
the arabs are not the issue ,islam is the problem
People would scream ethnic cleansing then
The majority of Palestinians are not Arabs. They speak and identify as Arabic because of the Arab Islamic invasion.. many Muslim Palestinians were Jews at some point before ottomans forcibly converted them.. you should learn more about the region before making absurd statements
@@nick_k.6000they are definitely not Jews who have been converted...they in fact ARE Arabs, mostly from Egypt and Jordan. There was always Jewish presence in Israel, even after the exile..and yet they were never intertwined with these Arab groups who pogromed them.
@@nick_k.6000
All you need to do is asked them for their surnames, and you can place the Arab country they came from. No matter how you repeat lies, it won’t turn to the truth, as long as there are facts to counter it.
Thank you both!!!
Yasmine, thanks for everything you do👍👍
Big up. 🇬🇾🇬🇾🇬🇾. Caribbean people must support each other.
Palestinians must learn to learn.
Most Humans start to learn at the age of 7/8.
Islam is way later.
Wel,if they ever start with it.
Isreal most learn about haloucost and 1492 in spain
Talking is good. Talking is the foundation of society. In this case though, I don't have much hope as long as there are people with an agenda to exterminate their perceived enemy as described in old and outdated books that should have been made obsolete a long time ago. Someone is gaining from the game of Divide and Conquer, but it's not the ordinary humans. Everybody has to do a deep soul-searching evaluation, but I have a hard time believing that those with a rigid mind and settled view of the world will do that. So we are back at square one on this. One huge thing - thanks to Yirmiyahu for speaking of it - is the opinions and indulgent ignorance of the not so innocent bystanders. Sun Tzu said it best more than 2000 years ago: to win the war you need to know both yourself and the enemy. Too many individuals in the West still believe democracy and/or capitalism won, and that everybody wants to live the American Dream. That is very far from the truth. To win this war against medieaval thought patterns of conquest and oppression due to what someone or other said 1500 years ago, is what we need to do. And that requires us to go beyond ingrained indeological programming and see ourselves and The Other in all our glory and disgrace. Not a conquest of the minds of our enemies to make them into copies of ourselves. There are psychiatric terms for that kind of behaviour. Can we heal ourselves and regain our humanity?
Loving your channel, and I knew Yerimiyahu from other channels, it's a long one but looking forward to it. Also being Jewish but having a friend who's family is Palestinian, it might help.
Thank you for this.
Love you both 💙
around 28:00 to around 30:00 it is inaccurate to have said that the problem is that people ie Arabs living in the Land and near have not met a Jew or Jews. Well about 20,000 people came from Gaza daily for work including thousands working in The Envelope the 22 or so communities which were violently assaulted on Oct 7, 2023. Further it is known that at least 100s of those workers had been working for more than a year to provide detailed maps and information about virtually every house, building, family so that the marauders, rapists, murderers, vile violent 3000 men could carry out the attacks on that day. This single oversight in your communication is a mere hint that a LOT of this well-intended conversation has some VERY wrong about it. The guest should have spoken up to clarify that multiple 1000s did not only meet but knew and worked with 1000s of Jewish people on a daily basis. Your well-intended conversation illustrates that even you two too live in a Cognitive Dissonance bubble.
0 seconds ago
I wish I didn't have to agree, but I do. Unfortunately October 7th showed all of this optimism and idealism to be unfounded in reality. Perhaps you can get individuals who are truly constructively minded, but the problem is that you can't tell who they are and the consequences for guessing wrong are very severe
Exactly. That bothered me too! Yirmiyahu seems to be full of wishful thinking, and that could be dangerous if people don't see the Islamists for what they are. He also talked about all belief systems being malleable (or words to that effect) but Islam is not able to be 'modernised' in the same way that other belief systems have been. The Quran is believed by Muslims to be the *immutable* word of Allah. We have to educate Muslims to question Islam until apostasy reaches a tipping point, and then the whole ideology will come falling down. At 1:05:46 the Nigerian caller Tochi made a lot of sense to me too! This is a global issue and it can't be solved by well-meaning Israelis alone.
Cognitive dissonance bubble, 🫧lnmdeed .
Great discussion Yasmine and Yirmiyahu. Thank you both 🙏. At 1:05:46 the Nigerian caller Tochi made a whole lot of sense to me! The Islamic #jihad is a global issue and it can't be solved by well-meaning Israelis like Yirmiyahu alone.
Such a beautiful interview ❤
When I was in uni I participated in a dialogue group. It made me realize how vastly different the narratives are. At one point we were encouraged to offer ideas for further activities. I was happy to participate in activities that would educate me regarding the expiriences of Arabs/Palestinians in the 48 war for example, but when I offered an activity like a hiking group that would provide a neutral setting for people to get to know each other on a human level, that was shot down. I felt really disheartened. I thought the idea was bridging the gap and creating relationships but I realized that anything that wasn't about recruting Jews to the pre-established Palestinian narrative was not seen as acceptable, and any Jew who wasn't doing the talking points of the nationalism of the other side was not seen as an ally anymore... and let me be clear, we were all considered the most far left individuals in our society, but that wasn't good enough unless we erased our own self regard and experiences. I came out from it with the feeling that they didn't care about us on a human level but only as tools to further their agenda.. which made me understand that I had no place in their vision for this land.. and I gave up.
omg!!!!!! i love you guys
Thank you again for a fscinating interview Yasmine.
It seems that there are more pro palestinian (as in support the development of the palestinian people towards independence and self realisation) on the israeli side than on those who call themselves "pro palestine".
Man, I was really feeling Sara’s pain. 😢 I feel for the Iranians as well as the Palestinians and Israelis.
Having separate achools is NOT helpful at all - Yasmine is so 100% right about that!
It just creates Other problems.
An even stronger brand name, identity Q: would it be acceptable for people who live in Gdansk to start calling their city "Nazi Danzig?! That's what "Palestine, " is.
Yirmiyahu is correct about the attemp to shrink the civil space of Jews, Israelis & Zionism hear that the Edu Dept of NYC prints outs or uploads info in many languages--NOT in Hebrew. 'Abything be done about that?
@liatsotto1378 before 1948, Jews were ‘Palestinians’. Miss Palestine was Jewish, the 1930s Palestinian Football Team had all Jewish players with Star of David on shirts (played against Australia in 1939), the Palestinian flag had a Star of David on it….Palestinian businesses were Jewish: Palestinian Railways was founded by a Jewish man, Palestinian Airways was founded by Jews, Palestinian Travel Agency was Jewish, Palestinian Electric co and Palestinian Foundry and Metal ere Jewish etc etc….Palestinian cultural institutions were Jewish: Palestinian Post, Palestinian Symphony Orchestra, Palestinian Broadcasting etc etc…After 1948, the old greco-roman ‘Palestina’ that Romans renamed JUDEA ND SAMARIA, cradle of Jewish civilisation, became the legally re-established sovereign Jewish state called ISRAEL
Exactly
Q: *Why do Sunni and Shia Muslims kill each other?*
A : *Because they believe their sect is the right one, and the other sect is the wrong one!*
Such a peaceful, tolerant religion
You really give me hope!
Yirmiyahu makes some of the best, more informative Israel Palestinian educational videos out there. Truly recommend!
1:22:40 "We'll have to keep the guards up, we don't leave in Switzerland", That became outdated and for the exact same reason: Islam.
Love this thank you!
I love Yasmine and yimiyahu . They are so smart and generous of spirit.
Thank you young man for speaking up!!!!
@Sarah with an H. Obama's ancestors came from Europe, on his mother's side, and incidentally owned over 100 slaves.
People who say Jews with European ancestry aren't Jews would NEVER say Obama or Tyra Banks or Beyonce or Vanessa Hudgens or Zoe Kravitz or Megan Markle are NOT REALLY BLACK.
Thank you Sarah for being pragmatic about the root of the problem.
Someone make a clip of Yasmine's rant at 1:12 to around 1:14 and make it go viral
The short answer is no , the long one is no
You're not listening didn't add or subtract.
then get the fuck out of Palestine.
I could listen to you two every day for hours!!! As a white European, I have so much respect for you both. Keep going!
I have yet to hear - almost universally - what the impact of modern scholarship is going to have on Islamic culture. I would predict troubles ahead. Disciplines of literary criticism are right now (!) in the process of dissembling the story and roots of Islam. I expect that, as Imams and other Islamic scholars lose intellectual ground, extreme muslims will dig in.
You are such a class act, Yasmine. I have so many conflicting opinions on Israel, and I appreciate your good faith in your interviews.
Great video!
Our Lord Jesus was born in Jerusalem so no wonder the Israelites and Jews are so humble. May God bless Israel and the Jews. Blessings to all .
Love this!
Great interview what a great guy!!
You are beautiful people with beautiful views, but there is so much discussion about the rationalization, rather then the core values that led to it.
One always gets lost discussing rationalization, because it's ever changing and expressed differently by different people.
Look at the actions, and core values that support them.
Thanks to Sara Ghorbani for pointing out the distinctions when it comes to islam and the legal status of the apostates, those who have left this ideology (not religion: it is a legal system, a social system and a so called spiritual system). I know a few muslims. Nice and caring mostly, but I have also seen some of them showing a very different face when they think I don't see them, and that has been something to make me aware and keep a distance. I'm sure there are genuinely friendly muslims out there, but the thing is, an outsider cannot know the true hearts and minds of them all, and anybody can study history and see the trends over time in relation to average percentages of muslims in any non-muslim society. We can't know what is hudna or taqqiyah, or a genuine wish to evolve their faith to become a constructive force in cooperation with people outside of their ummah. Neither are we helped by the ignorant or stupid leftists who cooperate with them on the grounds that they have a common goal of destroying western civilisation.
I haven't watched the whole thing yet, but I follow Yirmiyahu on different platforms and he's amazing.
Personally my answer to the question in the title is: if I serve you 10 cups of something to drink, and told you only one of them has poison in it that could kill you, would you still drink it?
I mean the majority of them are just fine, they won't harm you, only one... what's the problem?
The part when Jasminse told about how muslim twisting stories about how their victims (slaves & captured jewish women) love them so much, reminds me about how they said that the hostages were happy and even fell in love with their kidnappers ...
Calling Arabs "Palestinians," which is not an Arab name is fueling the Jihadi ideology for which the brandname was devised. Once things settle down... eventually, Inshallah, perhaps Dr Kedar's Arab tribal enirates (like the UAE) might work. Call it West Ordon Emirates, or whatever. But dont call them "Let's demolish the Jewish State" (which is what "Palestine" means to millions). Arab-Israelis is an altogether differnt entity, an equal-rights minority.
To distinguish from Normalization Peace, which was created for the Abraham Peace Accords, by contrast,
Islamist Peace = totalitarian, total Submission. Another important nuance to rememeber.
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
The guy looks Dominican for sure 2:11
This sounds like the Jim Crow South south.
your content is pretty but the prettiest thing on this channel i have ever seen is you😍🙈
Best channel on UA-cam
We can't really unify the Israeli education system since we are geographically divided with few exceptions like Lod, Jaffa, Acre, and even there, the neighborhoods are sub divided. We really do most things together, but I leave in one side of the road and they on the other. Jews wouldn't enjoy much the 5am loudspeaker call of the Muezzin, also Arabs hate parking cars at 90° or in a single parking lot.
The education system is not just fractured by geography, there are real difference in what students learn in school. In the Galil, students bus to school typically outside of their town or village. They travel to a secular school, religious school, or to Arabic speaking school of their region. All of whom have different educational content, and whose students have different images of what their future will be (secular Jews know they will be drafted). I don't think its that far fetched for there to be a more unified system. Of course self-segregation happens, like anywhere else in the world.
@@happinin07 I completely agree with you, yet at home we are quite different and it's a beautiful thing. October 7th Israeli Arabs reaction tells a success story, there is a extremely delicate situation and I would not touch a thing. Israeli Arabs are integral to Israel society. They don't openly identify with Hamas nor it shows by their actions and I completely trust it's not another peace fantasy. Shared system could very easily be used by agitators as a Zionist tool of silencing or indoctrination, currently it's not perfect and far from it, but if ain't broken don't fix it. After the October 2000 events, as a Galilee resident, we all got shocked to the core to see how volatile this harmony can be shattered, it was traumatic for Arabs and Jews alike.
very disappointed in the woman saying the third narrative is only one narrative. they have brought on people from all walks of life and have done good work. other than that great interview
Can we clone Yirmiyahu like a million times over? Even 1000X. Articulate, knowledgeable, speaks from deep experience, empathetic and focused on resolution. We need to hear from a Palestinian and an Arab who have the same focus. Solutions…we need people who can see the path to realistic and viable solutions through the crazy. We all know it will take a lot of time to get from A to B. That’s not the issue.
No one has ever denied that Jews have lived in the holy land for thousands of years. However, it has ALWAYS been inhabited by others as well, including the Palestinians and their descendants. The Jews don’t get to claim it as theirs alone.
Arabian peninsula belongs to Arabs, just like Judea and Samaria belongs to the Jews. The fact that other people lived there doesn’t give them the right to the land. It belongs to the Jews, that is an eternal decree. Either you believe it, acknowledge it or not.
The return of Jews to the land of Isreal was foretold thousand of years ago, and this time, never to be displaced again. People can sneer at it, but no group of people have that unique identity and history. The more you delve into it, the more astounded the history of Isreal is. And am a gentile, not a Jew.
@nadilene789 YERUSHALAYIM, Holiest city of the Jewish people was 80% Jewish in 1864 (Ottoman Turk occupation census) before massive @rob (feudal clans, tribes, nomads from all over) came flooding in by the hundreds of thousands 1880+ after Jews bought and developed the land (improved agriculture etc) and also came after the fall of Ottoman Turk occupation during the British Mandate….500,000+ @rob migrants came (many illegals) even in the 1930s+ according to the 1937 Peel Commission
@@DianeMonahan I looked this up. A complete fabrication like ALL zio fantasy propaganda.
@@DianeMonahan Do you know how easy it was for me to look this up and discover that it’s entirely fabricated?
And so why do the numerous ethno-religious states surrounding Israel "get to claim it as theirs alone" when the Arab Muslim majorities achieved power and dominance by ethnic cleansing and "disappearing" the older cultures and religions there/
My God....just look at the demongraphics for the indigenous Greek, Armenian and Assyrian Christians of Anatolia, now Turkiye. Look at what is happening to the Copts of Egypt, Yazidis, Zoroastrians, also Jewish communities who had been living in those countries for thousands of years were exterminated from Yemen, Iraq, Morocco..
I am not Jewish or Muslim, but I cannot no longer bear the hypocrisy of the claims made against Israel by those who are silent when it comes to other nations that when judged by the same standards, have FAR LESS RIGHT TO EXIST than Israel.The Islamic Republic of Pakistan, look what they did to the much older Hindu population there.
Your logic has a couple problems: first when you say "the Palestinians and their descendants ALWAYS inhabited it. This shows that you do not even know the history of this region, otherwise you would not make such a claim. But it's hard to blame people like you when the Pro-P propaganda goes from one very desperate and obvious lie ("Jesus was a Palestinian"....you mean the most famous Jew who ever lived, in JUDEA (Land of the Jews) before it was ever called Palestine, was a Palestinian?
Furtthermore, the Jews don't claim it as their own. And they more any any other ethno-religious group in world history, would have every justification to only allow Jews to live there. They had their capital cty and holy temple destoyed by foreign invaders, were forced from their homeland to live as usually second class citizens around the world, at the mercy of a majority ready to scapegoat them for every problem, subject them to pogroms, camps and other horrors.
Despite this incredibly awful way to be treated, when the Jews began returning to their ancestral homeland, they made every effort for peace. The Mslms rejected this at every turn, because while they can take the entire middle east by far more violence than Israel has done, how dare those Jews want a tiny piece of land that represents 0.4 percent of the middle east, to create another sovereign Jewish state like the ancient kingdoms of Judah and ISRAEL, so that they will not continue to be blamed for every social ill and continue to be expelled, attacked and erased. Yes, how incredibly selfish of the Jews for wanting this.
Did you know that in Israel, 20 percent of the population is Arab Muslim? Who have the exact same rights as Jewish Israelis, who have been appointed to the highest positions in government, military, and judiciary? You will not find this same equality in any Islamic state, from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan to Egypt.
I am so sick and tired of the constant lies being spread about Israel and the Jewish people, the constant attempts to question their right to a sovereign state in their ancestral homeland-a reality for many other nations around the world take for granted, because they are not surrounded by nations steeped in 1400 of J hatred.
I am so sick and tired of the double standards to which Israel is held to account. How other nations that have recently and are still commiting ACTUAL genocides, are completely ignored by the mainstream media and selective outrage "humanitarian" protestors, who never bothered to get off their asses for the Syrians, Yemen, what Azerbaijan did to the Armenians, the Uyghur camps in China. Only when Israel and the Jews are involved, even though yet again they did not start this war, do anti-Semites around the world get exicted and think they can cloak their ancient hatred of the J in the guise of "humanitarianism' and "de-colonization".
Well, the pro-P anti-Israel crowd have succeeded so far in that they have my attention. I live in a very woke progressive city.The day after news broke around the world of the carnage that Hamas had unleashed on Israeli civilians, a protest had already formed on a bridge in the downtown area. The Israeli people were still reeling in shock and trauma, and these (I will get banned for the names I want to call them) did not even have the humanity to put their unhinged hatred on hold for even one day: they were celebrating. I saw on social media, again in the days before Israel entered Gaza thousands of comments saying "Happy October". That same day in Sydney Australia, a crowd of thousands chanted "Gas the J, F the J".
I cannot stand these people, and it is disturbing to see how many woke "progressive" protestors who preach about hate speech, minority rights stand hand in hand with the Islamists openly calling for essentially a repeat of October 7, but on a much larger scale. From seeing interviews of these useful idiots around the world on what they know about the history of the region and the current conflict, a majority of them cannot answer the most basic facts. They are happy to hold up signs and protest about a subject they know very little of. For myself, the kaffiyeh now represents the swastika, and that's coming from non-Jewish secular gay man. This has only strengthened my resolve to do whatever I can to refute the lis being told.
Oh, and one more thing. Those so-called indigenous :"Palestinians" were never referred to as such until the 1960's; they were referred to as Arab Muslims by every state that ruled the region (Ottomans, Mamluks, etc), but after they attacked Israel, and were defeated yet again, they decided to rebrand themselves as a distinct ethnic groups, so that now Israel, always a minority, were now seen as the majority oppressor. Most of the "palestinians" came from Egypt, Jordan and other countries during the Zionist movement because the Jews turned what was an inhospitable land full od swamps and desert, into a thriving state, so Arabs began moving there for economic opportunities.
And these "palestinians" have been offered their own state at least five times, and turned it down every time. So who is the true obstacle to peace here? It isn't Israel or the Jews. At the very least, this horrible tragedy has opened the world's eyes to the depravity on display by the pro-P protests. Unlike the Russia Ukraine protests, where were focused solely on the Putin administration, the pro-P crowd has repeatedy attacked Jewish people in their own communities around the world.
I stand with Israel and the Jewish people, and after everything I have witnesses since last year, it is clear that the majority of these people don't know the history and given the chance, they would celebrate another
Oct 7 on a nauinal scale.
Not even going to listen. The answer is NO
You're not listening didn't add or subtract.
@@imisstoronto3121 they denounced their humanity that day.
Islam is rampant and that fact should be acknowledged
wow. I learned so much.
While my skin is white, my 23andMe test reveals that I am genetically indigenous to Israel, through something called my maternal haplogroup. From my mom's side, going all the way back.
An Enlightenment needs to come to Islam just as it has mostly happened to all other major religions where they take the best parts and drop the ideas that don’t work in the 21st Century.
Its not just about the Palistinians, it about Islam
Geeat interview
💌u Yasmine
No, it is impossible
I am South African
ABSOLUTELY NOT…Never again