What if Roy had a knife instead of a sword? (Melee Mod)

I purposely made this video not TAS so you could see how crappy Roy would be with a knife sized sword.

[@Aego384]

So you now fixed it to the actual size?

[@TrueTrickster2016]

He turns into the Thief class.

[@Santi-bt7if]

Thief*

[@kian9829]

@Galacta yellow knight it sounded dumb to me idk, i've barely seen any of miitopia so i guess i can't really say much

[@Aerosplinter]

Your profile pic turns into the PHANTOM THIEF class

[@keb9522]

this is unrealistically large compared to his actual range

[@wlfe603]

As a roy main I approve this message

[@Trupera]

Thousand degree knife

[@metaknight2941]

Sylvie Op Fairy Lmao.

[@aclonymous]

Sylvie Op Fairy I remember back when those jokes were funny...
in 2009

[@metaknight2941]

@@aclonymous Hey, you can't talk about 2009 in a negative context.

[@thundermcqueen7523]

@@hairmonster cough cough
Normies cough cough*

[@LiquidenSSBM]

This will be the name of my next roy combo vid

[@mechaman5000]

I don't get it, nothing changed

[@ness7144]

He made the hitbox larger than normal

[@monoko1234]

That's not true. He made a hitbox.

[@rice._.3637]

Its A Mod.

[@AGZhark]

?

[@randomperson4280]

The range is so little That little Max can out range him

[@joseph-yt2qk]

Too effective. Clearly next mod: Scalpel Roy!

[@Catto077]

still too effective, next mod: razor blade

[@mariomythes2807]

@Vincent L, still too effective, next mod: Punaise Roy

[@LeRuseBird]

@@mariomythes2807 nah b where's bee stinger roy

[@AppledirtArchive]

@@LeRuseBird No, we need splinter Roy.

[@GracieJello]

@@AppledirtArchive still to effective, air Roy

[@ddinkins112]

Fire Emblem 6: The Budget Cut Blade

[@RickyJC]

Wow! What an improvement on Roy’s range. I think he just went up a tier

[@Thewolfguys.cartoons2000]

Next up: Roy with a butterknife

[@zacharyjohnson9562]

Is that a stolen comment is see?

[@Thewolfguys.cartoons2000]

@@zacharyjohnson9562 huh?

[@SC13_45]

@@zacharyjohnson9562 actually, this comment came first

[@styxxiii]

that's just normal melee roy

[@viggokan]

A plastic butterknife

[@starman2517]

I always loved how...odd the sword swings and hits sounded in the smash series.

[@Jalongames]

melee melee character using melee with a melee weapon? what

[@craigstruthers8817]

No difference to be honest

[@RaikoEnjoyer]

Nice job making his Sword match his Hitboxes

[@Mastdoa]

Interesting, considering Roy shares his Japanese VA with Joker

[@TilcTac]

Next video:
What if Roy had a needle?

[@5577Step]

Eliwood: Roy, let me see what you have.
Roy: A knife!
Eliwood: NO!
Merlinus: Oh, dear. Why does he have a knife?
Hector: *Snickering*

[@Konic64]

Didn't know Lords could become a Theif class in Binding Blade

[@jakezepeda1267]

Still better than kirby.
also
GIVE LINK TIPPERS.

[@LightningCayo]

But can it still OHKO Jigglypuff? His best matchup

[@flamer_x2885]

1:22 YOOOOOO THATS BROKEN AF

[@metaknight2941]

Ssbfan Ssbfan So Goku actually was an unlockable character after all.

[@burningdryice5422]

I know so crazy it 3-stocked fox

[@FinnKid1]

OH FUCK ROY HAS A
A KNIFE OH GOD OH FUCK

[@aeroblu2002]

Roy's knife: what I think already good enough hit ranges with swords look like
Marth's giant sword: what I think good enough hit ranges for swords should look like
My standards are too high

[@lamian_wan3542]

Next change it to a butter knife

[@Thewolfguys.cartoons2000]

sorry, this comment is already taken (not being rude)

[@mariomythes2807]

Next what if Roy had an Axe instead of Sword? (Melee Mod) also maybe what if Roy’s dash attack and Up-air actually damage opponents?

[@JovialEclipse]

Toothpick Roy would do more damage

[@kennynakawaki]

Puny weapon XD

[@Skrunglygirl]

I didn't know I wanted this but now I know

[@Sickmmaner]

You act like Melee Roy isn't bad WITH a sword.
I know it's a joke you can't whoosh me

[@Star-fr4jz]

Either it sweetspots 99% of the time or it is out of range.
I like it.

[@duwanglover3424]

Roy: “Sorry guys, Marcus said I’m not allowed to bring a priceless legendary sword to the fight. So I brought this knife instead”

[@sbprakamranonymity4780]

Hey, hey Roy haters, HEY!! WHAT!?!? Knife!!! *screams in a panic attack*

[@NonRandomUser]

Why even bother with a weapon?
Just have Roy pimpslap his opponents; same range, same smacking sounds.

[@Rukir]

All the comments are memeing about how nothing changed, but seriously, this gameplay is almost completely normal lmao

[@nimi_dahav]

His sword will have a bigger hitbox

[@frog8175]

Whats funny is that you keep hitting the sour noodle. It'd make more sense if he had a knife that it'd be exclusively the hilt damage

[@xerextw9959]

1,000 Degree Knife vs. Super Smash Bros. Melee

[@MapleMilk]

I'm crying and shaking rn
Roy would never carry a knife

[@JesusMowsMaLawn]

Did Marth not have enough hitbox to go around?

[@zombieguy4444]

What if Ganondorf used Zelda’s magic?

[@Kokorz]

I'd like to see Godslayer Kirby and a Godslayer Kirby TAS

[@tinyclover3849]

i don't understand why he decided to just upload a normal roy montage

[@friendlypunk8975]

*obligatory joke about Crocodile Dundee’s knife*

[@AppledirtArchive]

So you just made the texture actually match the hitbox? Cool, makes it a lot clearer.

[@NagendraShirosagi-he7pd]

Pffft
fear the kitchen utensil master
Roy has unleashed his kitchen knife to show that he means business

[@heartofthefluft8541]

UA-cam recommendations bringed me here...
Not disappointed

[@SSName]

Friend:How does this make him better?
Me:It doesn't

[@tinytoasters3657]

Yo wtf that CPU Link turned up for like 5 seconds

[@cherryb0ng]

I notice no difference. Was this clickbait?

[@Srt_ketchyyy]

You should do a video TAS with ness adventure mode

[@Churly25]

Roy became a Thief class, so he stole Peach's heart :3

[@sabakutheapostle2687]

This would make Roy, a Brawler?

[@DolphinChris]

why are you posting this on no nut november?????

[@JaNKeeeZ]

The next mod should be: math with a big ass spoon

[@abystrous]

Interesting Joker prediction you have here

[@smflow7807]

Why not just remove the knife and make him punch?

[@shinysilverstardust]

What's next? what if Mario had green shoes?

[@agentdiamond9211]

What if Kirby's Up B was 3 times bigger?

[@shakenjacob7946]

Silly gamerfreak5665, he already has a knife.

[@Polariscious]

*Comment about how this is just his regular range here*

[@SweaterPuppys]

So basically FE6's thief class?

[@vexusvtuberpre-dubut3541]

Forget the knife it should be a 1000 degree knife

[@Legit.j4y]

So basically. What if Roy was Shiek?

[@IQBosh]

Im more impressed he still manages to hit sour spots on that 0:28

[@spaghettiman2588]

To me it feels like not much changed, big oof

[@SSDARKPIT]

I see you made it the size of Yoshi's dash grab.

[@saraskyline8331]

So you basically made his sword bigger

[@katchereye]

As if Roy was bad enough in Melee

[@umi2391]

Roy is a broken man without his blade

[@Flip-a-dip-dip]

What if Link had Marth's Sword?

[@KareemHillJr]

He'd essentially be the exact same.

[@LHSMeleeClub]

is this why there are no knife characters in smash?

[@shirehorse7]

The life of the wife is ended by the knife.

[@metalmaple-fluffyhoney54]

How about a sword sized knife??

[@plushblueep]

Fix Marth a sandwich, Roy!

[@WinterWalker_2]

This took a lot of his character away...

[@CopperScott]

I want Knife Roy TAS

[@logg05]

This is so sad. Alexa play Despacito

[@Aego384]

1st
Sorry, doesn't matter

[@crissw1388]

Roy with Dragonslayer pls

[@CharlonTank]

He needs a good grab, a good upair like falcon, a projectile and he would be awesome!

[@wildcard13294]

what do you mean he needs a good grab, his grab is already fantastic

[@helix3036]

Wait i don't get it wheres the difference

[@4sup47]

Has a knife is still overpowered

[@D3oderant]

Wtf I was playing as Project M Snake, who has a knife, and then this video popped up.

[@TDRR_Gamez]

At least Snake's knife was able to K.O reliably

[@D3oderant]

@@TDRR_Gamez lol, right?

[@MercuryPenny]

so...all his moves are his dash attack

[@jan-seli]

You spelled wet noodle wrong in the title

[@ThePi314Man]

What if Roy were a good character?

[@SydneySininen]

This is what Ultimate Marth feels like

[@Superluigi881]

At least it matches the hit boxes now.

[@ate1]

Roy's gigantic sword now

[@vigorouspringle8962]

*WHAT ARE YOU GONNA DO, STAB ME?*

[@technolen2]

roy + knife= 1000 degree knife in melee

[@frkscheeks1528]

A skilled knife can beat any Shine

[@normalhuman78-53]

Roy’s gonna shank some fools

[@flawlessvictory3955]

Roy with a toothpick, please

[@sonicclub1]

I'm not seeing any change

[@eightblockss]

Human not performing well

[@scanvil3766]

still has a sourspot :facepalm:

[@danielvanmaanen4896]

Not much would change.

[@StanleySophana]

What if Marth had a knife?

[@BMZtheNunchuckWarrior]

Looks about the same