Kyle's nowhere near the worst left-wing UA-camr, but the moment he talks about anything other than modern internal US politics, it's like he instantly develops mad cow disease. I don't know why he's so deeply uncurious about the world.
The dude probably still believes Russia didn't do anything wrong. Even after the Muller report made it clear Trumo was surrounded by russian agents, he disn't bother to read a fucking page of it.
He's actually wrong about domestic issues a lot. You might agree with many of his domestic takes, but that might signify that you need to reassess your positions.
@@dv4497 I think he makes questionable arguments for otherwise legitimate social-democratic positions on domestic policy (though I am generally more of a liberal/moderate myself). Regardless, he is incomparably stronger in that field than in anything foreign policy-related.
@@dv4497 we should all constantly re-assess our positions and not hold on to any of them too dogmatically I think, but which domestic issues do you take particular issue with, and for what reason specifically
@@squatch545 Kyle said that the United States is at war with Yemen, he has predicted a war with Iran for months now and it still hasn't happened and he said that due to the war in Ukraine the world is on the brink of nuclear war. There's some to start with.
@@squatch545 how would anyone source that to your satisfaction? Even if they sent you a dozen chronological examples of Kyle being hilariously wrong, you'd ask for two dozen. There's no way to "source" that anyway; it's an opinion. You don't agree and that's ok. Calm down
I had slowly become less of a Kyle fan for a few years but after he started talking about October 7th and things that have happened after, my support fell off a cliff.
@@Azdroc96 _really?_ You *_really_* think that the problem is that he "has no thought process"? Humans are a little more complex than that lol, I don't like Kyle at all but let's be real for a moment at least..
I don't think this is entirely fair. The issue isn't literally that the IDF has been massacreing civilians in the West Bank in this particualar operation, it's that, under the backdrop of a huge increase in IDF violence and settlement building in the westbank, the IDF is once again commiting air power and heavier ground units to a territory that is straightforwardly occupied. Additionally, this operation is actually quite unique. The vast majority of deaths in the West Bank, at least up to 07/23, were civilians killed in demonstrations and riots, both according to the OCHA database and the various parent reports from the red creasant etc..... I don't really deny that Kyle isn't a good source, but I do think that we should condemn the Israeli behavior in the west bank, and see this operation in its broader context 10:15 No, but they are absolutely increasing settlements to undermine the position of both the PA and international institutions who want a two state solution. They evidently aren't going to bulldoze Jenin, but nobody who isn't a total moron thinks they are 13:30 Nvm the caller literally just took the words out of my mouth lol Edit: Also I think that since the video was uploaded that UNRWA (yes I know it's not a phenomenal source) and HRW have claimed civilian cadualties
Gotta love how Kyle makes some bold assertion like "There is no Hamas in the West Bank" with all the confidence that I can say there's a Toyota Corolla parked outside my house.
Kyle is like the 19 year old girl who read a paragraph from a Noam Chomsky book and saw a reddit atheist meme and now thinks that she is a ground breaking intellectual.
It's pretty funny how kyle is so americabrained he's like "torture is illegal! duuh". He's one of those who would cry out for their amendments while in a foreign country lmao.
Torture IS banned worldwide. Israel is a party of the UNCAT. Of course, state parties violate it all the time. But torture is both banned by customary international law of armed conflict and by the aforementioned treaty.
Also incredible how the same people who chanted "by any means necessary" on October 7th are suddenly concerned about human rights and international law.
LonerBox I just want to say thank you for doing this video. I haven’t even watched it yet but as a former subscriber of Kulinski I have seen him spew nonstop misinformation and one sided propaganda about this topic. I’d like to see you or Destiny debate him on it because he gets no pushback from it and most of his propaganda goes completely unchecked.
I'm so distracted by the ad in the top-right by the beginning, at first I thought Loner had a pic of his dogs there cause of some stream goal or smth xd
Kyle likes to talk to people so go to his show and educate his ass. I actually like Kyle but he is so out of his dept on this matter that it is absurd.
I have unsubscribed to Kyle over this whole war. I always thought his foreign policy takes were unbelievably ignorant and I finally just gave up on him. It’s a shame because idk Kyle is bad faith but his brain shuts off when he talks about the Middle East. Oh and as far as Kyle and Iran. I’m for liberating Iran from the Islamic theocrats and handing the country back to its people who are overwhelmingly pro-western and pro-democracy. I like standing with my allies internationally which the rest of the left no longer does but I’m old fashioned.
I would say Kyle was correct in calling Israel the aggressor in the West Bank. Not only was the West Bank conquered in a War of Aggression, ICJ in 2004 concluded that an occupier can not invoke UN Charter regarding Self-defense. Further: ICJ has this year branded the occupation itself as illegal. As for Lebanon, the Al Jazeera monitoring of attacks to and from Lebanon shows that israeli attacks precedes Hezbollah attacks. Lebanon also claims that the Shebaa Farms, occupied by Israel, are lebanese. A claim UN investigation has found credible.
@@hakanpetersson2662 Yes, and have those armed groups disarmed? Do you understand, from Israel's perspective, how empty, hypocritical, and meaningless anything the UN says is in light of Hezbollah having spent years launching rockets at Israel literally under the UN's watch? Al-Jazeera is directly funded by the government of Qatar, a government that _literally hosts and protects the leaders of a militant group ideologically sworn to the destruction of Israel and murder of Jews._ And this is apparently supposed to be the (non-Israeli) source we look to for Middle Eastern news. I don't understand.
That's not even accurate... they both definitely have their fair share of problems, but they're _very_ different. Kyle is pretty libbed up and loves the U.S., Hasan is not libbed up and does not like the U.S. at all. These things influence their worldviews accordingly. FWIW, I don't think Hasan is _actually_ much of a tankie, if at all. He just reeeaaaaallly hates the U.S. lol
@@nathanl4083: Tankie definition: Tankie is a pejorative label generally applied to authoritarian communists, especially those who support acts of repression by such regimes or their allies. More specifically, the term has been applied to those who express support for one-party Marxist-Leninist socialist republics, whether contemporary or historical. I would argue someone who perpetuates the Gaza as being perpetual victims and supports Hamas as some sort of resistance group is indeed a definitional tankie. He supports continued and perpetual terrorism against Israel.
@@boofclouds199cause he's a dumb loser who uses all his brain power to focus on dumb loser points that have little meaningful impact in the grand scheme of things. Bro is a literal embodiment of losing the forest for the trees. He'd make a great state department spokesperson.
@@tylerloving7132 Nah, Kyle has been spitting out bad takes for FAR longer than that. He's been like this for years as far as I can tell, he's not a very smart dude
Kyle's nowhere near the worst left-wing UA-camr, but the moment he talks about anything other than modern internal US politics, it's like he instantly develops mad cow disease. I don't know why he's so deeply uncurious about the world.
The dude probably still believes Russia didn't do anything wrong. Even after the Muller report made it clear Trumo was surrounded by russian agents, he disn't bother to read a fucking page of it.
straight up antisemitic, payed by qatar, or payed by russia
He's actually wrong about domestic issues a lot. You might agree with many of his domestic takes, but that might signify that you need to reassess your positions.
@@dv4497 I think he makes questionable arguments for otherwise legitimate social-democratic positions on domestic policy (though I am generally more of a liberal/moderate myself).
Regardless, he is incomparably stronger in that field than in anything foreign policy-related.
@@dv4497 we should all constantly re-assess our positions and not hold on to any of them too dogmatically I think, but which domestic issues do you take particular issue with, and for what reason specifically
Kyle manages to radicalize his audience with every video. Yet, he is constantly wrong and bad faith on the subject
@@squatch545 Kyle said that the United States is at war with Yemen, he has predicted a war with Iran for months now and it still hasn't happened and he said that due to the war in Ukraine the world is on the brink of nuclear war. There's some to start with.
@@squatch545 how would anyone source that to your satisfaction?
Even if they sent you a dozen chronological examples of Kyle being hilariously wrong, you'd ask for two dozen. There's no way to "source" that anyway; it's an opinion. You don't agree and that's ok. Calm down
@@squatch545 you didn't watch the video you're commenting on? Good one
nah he's good faith. your guy is destiny.
I had slowly become less of a Kyle fan for a few years but after he started talking about October 7th and things that have happened after, my support fell off a cliff.
Kyle is generally pretty knowledgeable on domestic policy but his foreign policy is usually so bad.
That's the leftist special, unfortunately.
Kyle has no thought process. He'll spout for universal health care but he wouldn't be able argue why it is better in principle.
Reminder that he did not know what farms looked like and asked twitter what the squares with different shades of green were on his photo.
@@Azdroc96 _really?_ You *_really_* think that the problem is that he "has no thought process"?
Humans are a little more complex than that lol, I don't like Kyle at all but let's be real for a moment at least..
@@idontwantahandlethough If Kyle is complex he has a weird way of showing it.
Kyle should stick to what he's good at domestic politics because holy shit his foreign takes are beyond dumb
agree with me : GOOD
disagree with me : BAD
I don't think this is entirely fair. The issue isn't literally that the IDF has been massacreing civilians in the West Bank in this particualar operation, it's that, under the backdrop of a huge increase in IDF violence and settlement building in the westbank, the IDF is once again commiting air power and heavier ground units to a territory that is straightforwardly occupied.
Additionally, this operation is actually quite unique. The vast majority of deaths in the West Bank, at least up to 07/23, were civilians killed in demonstrations and riots, both according to the OCHA database and the various parent reports from the red creasant etc.....
I don't really deny that Kyle isn't a good source, but I do think that we should condemn the Israeli behavior in the west bank, and see this operation in its broader context
10:15 No, but they are absolutely increasing settlements to undermine the position of both the PA and international institutions who want a two state solution. They evidently aren't going to bulldoze Jenin, but nobody who isn't a total moron thinks they are
13:30 Nvm the caller literally just took the words out of my mouth lol
Edit: Also I think that since the video was uploaded that UNRWA (yes I know it's not a phenomenal source) and HRW have claimed civilian cadualties
Yes, it's crazy that the caller actually confirms what Baddar is saying but somehow this gets swept under the rug.
Kyle "I'm allergic to the facts" Kulinski
Makes sense considering he’s a chomskytard
Lonerbox looks like the "you cant handle my potions" guy
lol I can see it
Gotta love how Kyle makes some bold assertion like "There is no Hamas in the West Bank" with all the confidence that I can say there's a Toyota Corolla parked outside my house.
Kyle is like the 19 year old girl who read a paragraph from a Noam Chomsky book and saw a reddit atheist meme and now thinks that she is a ground breaking intellectual.
why does it have to be a girl and not just a 19 yo in general?
Because it’s a stereotype
@@TriggeredCulture College girls are more susceptible to far left brain rot. 19 year old boys are more prone to far right brain rot
@@TriggeredCulture Because 19 years old boys don't read books or go to college on average? It is a much bigger stereotype for girls 🤷
I sense an internalized misogyny here
It's pretty funny how kyle is so americabrained he's like "torture is illegal! duuh". He's one of those who would cry out for their amendments while in a foreign country lmao.
Torture IS banned worldwide. Israel is a party of the UNCAT. Of course, state parties violate it all the time. But torture is both banned by customary international law of armed conflict and by the aforementioned treaty.
Also incredible how the same people who chanted "by any means necessary" on October 7th are suddenly concerned about human rights and international law.
He's the epitome of Western naiveté. That said, torture is an abomination and officially recognized as such by nearly every country.
@@zachs370kyle is not one of them.
LonerBox I just want to say thank you for doing this video. I haven’t even watched it yet but as a former subscriber of Kulinski I have seen him spew nonstop misinformation and one sided propaganda about this topic. I’d like to see you or Destiny debate him on it because he gets no pushback from it and most of his propaganda goes completely unchecked.
I’m still frustrated that so much of the online Left continue to give validity to this frosted-tip doofus
Kyle's understanding of middle east politics is pathetic
I'm so distracted by the ad in the top-right by the beginning, at first I thought Loner had a pic of his dogs there cause of some stream goal or smth xd
Kyle likes to talk to people so go to his show and educate his ass. I actually like Kyle but he is so out of his dept on this matter that it is absurd.
it's like this guy lives in an alternate reality
I watched Kyle for years. As soon as shit went down with IP I bailed so hard. Cringy takes.
Hey, imagine if he is payed to say that. Not like that ever happened in the very recent times..
Kyle looks like Ethan Klein in the thumbnail
Kyle needs to eat more pizza and garlic bread to morph into Ethan's body type
Wade Bogg's Carpet World
WE'RE ON A SHOW WITHIN A SHOW!
MY REAL NAME IS TRACY MORGAN!!
I have unsubscribed to Kyle over this whole war. I always thought his foreign policy takes were unbelievably ignorant and I finally just gave up on him. It’s a shame because idk Kyle is bad faith but his brain shuts off when he talks about the Middle East.
Oh and as far as Kyle and Iran. I’m for liberating Iran from the Islamic theocrats and handing the country back to its people who are overwhelmingly pro-western and pro-democracy. I like standing with my allies internationally which the rest of the left no longer does but I’m old fashioned.
you know considering droners definition of genocide i wonder if he’d be a holocaust denier saying it wouldn’t count
Political aggression.
lonerbox knows what he's talking about.
And it's so refreshing
Please speak to Kyle, he's not a bad dude and I think he'd at least concede on specific facts
Heyy it's Kyle! tbh still like Kyle, I just think he gets a bit overzealous
I'm an Israeli that tired to hear bs , please can I debate Sav?
kyle isn't that great at his job.
:-)
I think he is amazing at his job. Just like his wife or genks nefew.
Thank you🙏🏿
12:38 - lol, thousands of thousnds of dollars a month?
"Well, you have to target crime"
-LB, referring to an airstrike
Why does lonerbox look like the "potion seller" guy
Maybe because you're racist
Kyle "There is no Hamas in the West Bank"
IDF raises eyebrow*
Bonerlox
my least favorite kind of bagel topping..
@@idontwantahandlethough Mossad paid him to change his name to this.
I would say Kyle was correct in calling Israel the aggressor in the West Bank. Not only was the West Bank conquered in a War of Aggression, ICJ in 2004 concluded that an occupier can not invoke UN Charter regarding Self-defense. Further: ICJ has this year branded the occupation itself as illegal.
As for Lebanon, the Al Jazeera monitoring of attacks to and from Lebanon shows that israeli attacks precedes Hezbollah attacks. Lebanon also claims that the Shebaa Farms, occupied by Israel, are lebanese. A claim UN investigation has found credible.
Uh huh, and uh what did the UN have to say about UNSC Resolution 1701?
@@Snacks256 Among other items it called for respect of the Blue Line. It also called for disarmanent of all armed groups in Lebanon.
@@hakanpetersson2662 Yes, and have those armed groups disarmed? Do you understand, from Israel's perspective, how empty, hypocritical, and meaningless anything the UN says is in light of Hezbollah having spent years launching rockets at Israel literally under the UN's watch?
Al-Jazeera is directly funded by the government of Qatar, a government that _literally hosts and protects the leaders of a militant group ideologically sworn to the destruction of Israel and murder of Jews._ And this is apparently supposed to be the (non-Israeli) source we look to for Middle Eastern news. I don't understand.
Kyle is a useless UA-camr
Kyle is like Hasan...a tankie propagandist
Kyle isn't a tankie. That's just not accurate.
He's just as anti-west and lazy as Hasan is on foreign policy. He's not quite cozying up with the likes of SecondC*nt just yet.
That's not even accurate...
they both definitely have their fair share of problems, but they're _very_ different. Kyle is pretty libbed up and loves the U.S., Hasan is not libbed up and does not like the U.S. at all. These things influence their worldviews accordingly.
FWIW, I don't think Hasan is _actually_ much of a tankie, if at all. He just reeeaaaaallly hates the U.S. lol
Tankie doesn’t just mean a leftist you disagree with you know?
@@nathanl4083: Tankie definition: Tankie is a pejorative label generally applied to authoritarian communists, especially those who support acts of repression by such regimes or their allies. More specifically, the term has been applied to those who express support for one-party Marxist-Leninist socialist republics, whether contemporary or historical.
I would argue someone who perpetuates the Gaza as being perpetual victims and supports Hamas as some sort of resistance group is indeed a definitional tankie. He supports continued and perpetual terrorism against Israel.
Stupid
LoserBox
LoverBox
Why u hating?
@@boofclouds199cause he's a dumb loser who uses all his brain power to focus on dumb loser points that have little meaningful impact in the grand scheme of things. Bro is a literal embodiment of losing the forest for the trees. He'd make a great state department spokesperson.
Lagerbox
Because this channel acts like the same russian simps it criticizes but for israel. @@boofclouds199
👏🙂
I'm always surprised at myself that I used to follow Kyle Kulinski and the Young Turks everyday.
Thank goodness for Loner and Destiny.
Ever since October 7th…. Crazy shit
I do not think that Destiny is an actual upgrade.
@@tylerloving7132 Nah, Kyle has been spitting out bad takes for FAR longer than that. He's been like this for years as far as I can tell, he's not a very smart dude
@@idontwantahandlethough oh I was talking leftist people in general.
First
lonerbox? more like yahodibox
A zinoist BS channel