How Much Protein You Really Need (According to Science)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,1 тис.

  • @Gaspa79
    @Gaspa79 Рік тому +479

    Recreational exercise: 1gram of protein per kg of bodyweight.
    Middle distance athlete / consistent gym goer: ~1.2-1.4 g/kg of bodyweight
    Active muscle building phase: ~1.7-2.0 g/kg of bodyweight.
    Muscle maintenance phase: ~1.6-1.8 g/kg of bodyweight.

    • @balb4903
      @balb4903 8 місяців тому +5

      Thanks

    • @perpetualengine
      @perpetualengine 7 місяців тому +5

      Thank you, just listened to this while getting lunch for the kids, now I don't have to hunt down the right timestamp.

    • @healthworm
      @healthworm 6 місяців тому +5

      Should lean bodyweight be considered or bodyweight along with body fat?

    • @codywirth8190
      @codywirth8190 6 місяців тому +6

      It also gets complicated though because if someone is bulking, they actually don't need as much protein proportionally to carbs and fats as when they're cutting. So yes a person needs to get plenty of protein when trying to add muscle, but because there are protein sparing effects of carbs and fats they dont need as much percentage wise.

    • @ruslan8820
      @ruslan8820 6 місяців тому +2

      @@healthworm yeay me interesting too

  • @markryan9323
    @markryan9323 Рік тому +882

    It's cool to have protein intake range explained with broader point of view, but in a simple way. Very helpful. Thanks!

    • @kandy5129
      @kandy5129 6 місяців тому

      @H-jb4tf Gorillas aren't humans. Humans evolved the way we did by eating cooked meats. You're stupid for making the comparison with gorillas because they use different amino acids to build those muscles too. Also they eat loads of bugs, which are animals, which is technically meat

  • @ryanlangford7283
    @ryanlangford7283 Рік тому +310

    Surprisingly hard to find simplified protein information. This was plainly laid out and easy to understand. Thank you very much for your explanatory, educationa-based approach. Thumbs up!

    • @11235Aodh
      @11235Aodh Рік тому +1

      Dr. Milton Mills and dr. John mcDougall both have a lecture on protein that is very good.

    • @EhurtAfy
      @EhurtAfy Рік тому +1

      Brad Schoenfeld is probably the most qualified and respected person on the planet regarding muscle hypertrophy. It really doesn't need to be more complicated than 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight per 24 hour period. It probably helps to spread protein throughout the day, but the big thing is getting the total amount of protein

    • @anoarabibi5341
      @anoarabibi5341 Рік тому

      Best

    • @silviu.pădure
      @silviu.pădure Рік тому +1

      WRONG & MISLEADING.
      Q1 Where the excess of protein is going?! Exactly, is converted into FAT. So if you trying to lose cut your protein intake.
      Q2 What is happening with the recycled protein in the body?! Exactly, is reused to create new proteins, so more than 1g/kg of protein is an overkill.
      Q3 What is the No. 10 cause of death accounted for almost 75% of all deaths in the U.S.?! Exactly, kidney disease.
      Although high-protein diets continue to be popular for weight loss and type 2 diabetes, evidence suggests that worsening renal function may occur in individuals with-and perhaps without-impaired kidney function. High dietary protein intake can cause intraglomerular hypertension, which may result in kidney hyperfiltration, glomerular injury, and proteinuria. It is possible that long-term high protein intake may lead to de novo CKD. The quality of dietary protein may also play a role in kidney health. Compared with protein from plant sources, animal protein has been associated with an increased risk of ESKD in several observational studies, including the Singapore Chinese Health Study. Potential mediators of kidney damage from animal protein include dietary acid load, phosphate content, gut microbiome dysbiosis, and resultant inflammation. In light of such findings, adopting current dietary approaches that include a high proportion of protein for weight reduction or glycemic control should be considered with care in those at high risk for kidney disease. Given the possibility of residual confounding within some observational studies and the conflicting evidence from previous trials, long-term studies including those with large sample sizes are warranted to better ascertain the effects of high protein intake on kidney health.

    • @futuristicgear5336
      @futuristicgear5336 7 місяців тому

      @@silviu.pădure It is true that excess calories, whether from protein, carbohydrates, or fats, can contribute to weight gain, including fat accumulation. However, the statement that excess protein is directly converted into fat oversimplifies the process. Protein is not efficiently converted into fat in the body. Instead, excess protein can be metabolized for energy or stored as fat, but the process is less efficient compared to the conversion of carbohydrates and fats into fat. Whether reducing protein intake is necessary for weight loss depends on the individual's overall caloric intake and energy expenditure.
      The statement that more than 1g/kg of protein is an overkill is a generalization. Protein needs vary depending on factors such as activity level, muscle mass, and overall health status. While the body does recycle protein for various metabolic processes, individuals engaged in regular physical activity, particularly strength training, may have higher protein requirements to support muscle repair and growth. The recommended protein intake ranges provided by health authorities consider these factors.
      There is evidence to suggest that high protein intake may have implications for kidney health, particularly in individuals with existing kidney disease or compromised kidney function. High dietary protein intake can increase the workload on the kidneys and may lead to issues such as intraglomerular hypertension, glomerular injury, and proteinuria. However, it's important to note that the relationship between high protein intake and kidney health is complex and may depend on various factors, including the source and quality of protein, overall diet, and individual health status. Not all individuals will experience adverse effects on kidney function from high protein intake, but those with pre-existing kidney conditions should monitor their protein intake and consult with a healthcare professional if necessary.

  • @tomasma4896
    @tomasma4896 Рік тому +54

    That whiteboard arrow showing range of protein intake is pure gold. Finally it makes sense to me, even I am quite active person for quite some time it was always endless debate how much protein. Now it is super clear, thanks a lot ! :)

  • @MasterCandyMan456
    @MasterCandyMan456 Рік тому +51

    From someone who was consuming 220g a day for 8 months along with pre ever day and was hospitalized for “over doing it”. Great video!

    • @goingtocalifornia
      @goingtocalifornia 9 місяців тому +13

      Well it wasn’t your 220 grams of protein a day that did it unless you have some sort of other health concern. Clearly something else was going on.

    • @G.Anderson205
      @G.Anderson205 9 місяців тому +4

      It could’ve been because of too much protein, like in the video you really don’t need more than 2g per 1kg of body weight so if you overdo it it’ll have a negative effect on your body and organs, especially kidney, my coworker had to get his stomach pumped for eating too much protein

    • @goingtocalifornia
      @goingtocalifornia 9 місяців тому +6

      @@G.Anderson205 I’m sorry that’s just objectively not true. This is likely the worst part of general practice and emergency care.

    • @MagicMicah85
      @MagicMicah85 9 місяців тому +5

      @@goingtocaliforniaUnless OP comes in and specifies, protein poisoning is a thing that can happen when your protein ratio is much higher than your carbs/fats.

    • @madhatter113
      @madhatter113 9 місяців тому +3

      How did you reach 220g? What were you eating? I'm 160lbs and can't get to 2g per 1kg of bodyweight.. This is a lot, I mean a lot of protein. Do I need to eat like 400g of chicken breast each day + a protein shake. I'm not a lion man

  • @Parker_Miller_M.S.
    @Parker_Miller_M.S. Рік тому +702

    I have the dunford and doyle text being used as reference for the video and agree mostly with the values and ranges given even in the context of having more recently published data available. One area that I think is important to emphasize is that at and above approximately 1.6g/kg the source of one's protein (i.e., animal or plant) does not appear to matter any more as there are a sufficient amount of the 9 indispensable amino acids present to maximize protein synthesis.
    Additionally, its worth noting that older adults are very likely to need more protein whether sedentary or active, as anabolic resistance is a noted occurrence with older age. Its been proposed across the past decade that older adults should aim for 1.2g/kg to help preserve muscle mass and strength and up to the 1.6g/kg value is again likely to support maximal or at least very near maximal protein synthesis.
    Sources:
    Bauer, J., Biolo, G., Cederholm, T., Cesari, M., Cruz-Jentoft, A. J., Morley, J. E., ... & Boirie, Y. (2013). Evidence-based recommendations for optimal dietary protein intake in older people: a position paper from the PROT-AGE Study Group. Journal of the american Medical Directors association, 14(8), 542-559.
    Morton, R. W., Murphy, K. T., McKellar, S. R., Schoenfeld, B. J., Henselmans, M., Helms, E., ... & Phillips, S. M. (2018). A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength in healthy adults. British journal of sports medicine, 52(6), 376-384.
    Nunes, E. A., Colenso‐Semple, L., McKellar, S. R., Yau, T., Ali, M. U., Fitzpatrick‐Lewis, D., ... & Phillips, S. M. (2022). Systematic review and meta‐analysis of protein intake to support muscle mass and function in healthy adults. Journal of cachexia, sarcopenia and muscle, 13(2), 795-810.

    • @FOH3663
      @FOH3663 Рік тому +23

      Much appreciated ...

    • @melusine826
      @melusine826 Рік тому +103

      I love this community- even the comments have proper references 😁

    • @naughtiousmaximus7853
      @naughtiousmaximus7853 Рік тому +20

      Always felt this was true. By these calculations 125g is max protein I need, which is awesome.

    • @Parker_Miller_M.S.
      @Parker_Miller_M.S. Рік тому +27

      @@naughtiousmaximus7853 yeah it's really reassuring and makes daily nutrition much less stressful. I used to worry about eating 200+ grams of protein each day now I'm chilling with 160ish which also saves money.

    • @naughtiousmaximus7853
      @naughtiousmaximus7853 Рік тому +17

      @@Parker_Miller_M.S. Money is the biggest concern. Protein is expensive and I also enjoy carbs much more. So its a win win for me.

  • @Thiol_Mercapto
    @Thiol_Mercapto Рік тому +2194

    U will never regret watching his videos

    • @ammarnapata2193
      @ammarnapata2193 Рік тому +17

      Why?

    • @arbre_mystique
      @arbre_mystique Рік тому +74

      @@ammarnapata2193 because they’re educational?

    • @jimdolan4327
      @jimdolan4327 Рік тому +4

      @@ammarnapata2193 I’ aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa asàsaaA Avaz m

    • @AJohnSmith
      @AJohnSmith Рік тому +9

      You*

    • @ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked
      @ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked Рік тому +10

      :3 Just out 11 hours ago. We had taken a poll for the the next topic, and most of us chose protein. Hehe. Also, best gains for vegans with 30% more absorption of BCAAs from vegan/plant-based protein, vegan creatine is the most popular and vegans get the most enhancement from it than anyone else, several weightlifting records for any group have been broken by fellow vegans/plant-based people, many of the very best runners are vegan/plant-based, long-term swimming record broken by a vegan, Formula One champion is vegan, the tennis twins are mostly plant-based (they go plant-based on their best games, and whatever else), many of the best NBA players going vegan/plant-based, etc.

  • @loriannquinn6540
    @loriannquinn6540 Рік тому +716

    This is really helpful! I’ve been dieting and didn’t realize I was burning protein in addition to the stored body fat. Appreciate the info. Love your videos.
    Side note: my daughter is in Med School and watches your videos to supplement her learning. Thank you!

    • @Yupppi
      @Yupppi Рік тому +23

      Yup, slight increase in protein intake and at least maintenace volume on weight training helps in trying to counter the muscle loss during weight loss program, since body is somewhat happy to burn unnecessary muscle protein, it being very expensive form of tissue and less important for survival. It's a common disappointment for people who decide to drop weight to look better while not exercising and eating plenty of protein, when they end up looking just smaller and still unfit.

    • @klootenviool
      @klootenviool Рік тому +24

      Increasing your protein intake while dieting also makes dieting easier, as high protein ingredients are more satiating for the amount of calories they deliver.

    • @ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked
      @ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked Рік тому +1

      :D The viral fake janitor, fake old man, and fake nerd gym trainer, Anatoly, a beast powerlifter, not bodybuilder, who is really Vladimir, is viral, and you should check him out if you haven't already.

    • @hannahmitchell87
      @hannahmitchell87 Рік тому +10

      If you don't already, consider incorporating resistance training while dieting. Even just some bodyweight exercises will preserve muscle mass & help you avoid the 'skinny-fat' look.
      Fasting is arguably better than prolonged calorie restriction too, metabolically & for encouraging a greater proportion of fat instead of muscle loss.
      Hth!
      (Edit typos)

    • @rizzwan-42069
      @rizzwan-42069 Рік тому

      @@ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked simp

  • @FlinckShinesOn
    @FlinckShinesOn Рік тому +14

    As someone getting more serious in the gym and also studying to become a nurse - This gives clear answers to the lingering questions I still had

  • @5Nathi
    @5Nathi 11 місяців тому +347

    Rest of the world: Thanks for using Metric System

    • @MrMikekydd
      @MrMikekydd 4 місяці тому +4

      Americans are ok with grams per pound though. Lol

    • @MBL2210
      @MBL2210 4 місяці тому +14

      @@MrMikekydd you said it.. per pound.
      lmao

    • @ToneyCrimson
      @ToneyCrimson 3 місяці тому +20

      Americans loves metric system, they use 9 mm in school all the time.

    • @Will-tm5bj
      @Will-tm5bj 3 місяці тому +1

      Me, an average American, was just thankful to weigh the same as the good presenter dude😂

    • @Insanetheproducer
      @Insanetheproducer 2 місяці тому +2

      @@ToneyCrimsonmore like 5.56

  • @izzysmart
    @izzysmart Рік тому +20

    I am vegan 50, menopausal and 70-71kilos, I average 100-120 grams a day to body build. Still gaining. I work out 4 times a week in gym hour and half to 2. I walk on average 12,000 a day, average 2500 cals

    • @barmiro
      @barmiro Рік тому +4

      That's a great routine, stay active! Fellow vegan here, 24M/72kg, long-distance cyclist. One thing I love about having to eat 4000kcal a day is that it's hard NOT to eat enough protein haha

    • @izzysmart
      @izzysmart Рік тому +3

      @@barmiro totally hear you. And love cycling myself. I am more mountain bike and with camera, few stops along the way lll. Love being out with nature.

    • @bigotonbrand
      @bigotonbrand Рік тому

      I ll hit it

  • @rottenrobbie8466
    @rottenrobbie8466 Рік тому +404

    Can we all just take a moment to appreciate the unknown individuals who were kind enough to donate their bodies to science. 🙏🙏🙏

    • @the1stmetalhead
      @the1stmetalhead Рік тому +6

      are those real bones and muscles? I thought they were 3-D printed.

    • @IPoopOnYouEveryLastOneOfYou
      @IPoopOnYouEveryLastOneOfYou Рік тому +10

      No one more so than the guy from the board game Operation. He died for our sins!

    • @crimsonscapes1
      @crimsonscapes1 Рік тому +9

      @@the1stmetalheadThey are real. Cadavers.

    • @malcolmUCH
      @malcolmUCH Рік тому

      You’re welcome bro

    • @angrytater2456
      @angrytater2456 5 місяців тому

      Yes, giving your body to science is a good thing. But did we really need the cadaver show in this video? If we are talking about body structure, bring out the cadaver. For this? C'mon, mane.

  • @eaglenebula2172
    @eaglenebula2172 Рік тому +87

    Summary of 15 mins talk in ~3 sentences:
    -Bodybuilding: 2 to 2.5gr of protein per kilo of body weight per day are the optimal and safe ratios, above that it can build toxicity for no significant extra gains. Can decrease to 1.8 gr for maintenance.
    -Other active ppl/athletes: 1.2 - 1.4 gr/body kilo/day for mid distance runs/consistent gym going.
    -Ultra endurance athletes: can go up to 2gr/bkilo/day cuz they breakdown lots of protein to sustain their energy supplies.

    • @UnfilteredCactus
      @UnfilteredCactus 8 місяців тому

      Thank you for your service

    • @nightwalker6932
      @nightwalker6932 7 місяців тому

      How about boxer?

    • @akiotatsuki2621
      @akiotatsuki2621 7 місяців тому

      I don’t think you watched the video, his chart didn’t even go above 2.0

    • @eaglenebula2172
      @eaglenebula2172 7 місяців тому +3

      @@akiotatsuki2621 if there's one person that didn't watch the video it'd def be you not me.
      Watch from 12:20 onward.
      Next time double check before calling people out and don't waste their time.

    • @akiotatsuki2621
      @akiotatsuki2621 7 місяців тому

      @@eaglenebula2172 Look Whom is wasting Who's time, i even got you to timestamp it, get better control of your emotions my guy ;)

  • @Retiredtraveler1961
    @Retiredtraveler1961 7 місяців тому +1

    I watch a lot of your videos, I also am retired, 63 and I weight Lift every day along with cardio. I watch the other video about the breakdown of food to protein synthesis. Excellent videos keep up the good work.

  • @holyghost718
    @holyghost718 Рік тому +33

    In the 1950's Steve Reeves was 6'1" and weighed 220 lbs. He was known to consume around 140 grams of protein per day and was able to build arguably the greatest natural physique of all time.

    • @mannyblackstar
      @mannyblackstar 4 місяці тому

      Don't believe in reel life, son.
      Yes u need nearly 3/3.2grams per kilo of bodyweight

  • @ArterieVayne
    @ArterieVayne Рік тому +168

    Thank you for using the metric system so the rest of the world can understand! Would be interesting to know if there’s a maximum amount of protein that can be absorbed at once per meal as I’ve been told there’s no point consuming too much protein after a workout since it won’t be absorbed

    • @Katjaneway
      @Katjaneway Рік тому +2

      Same question for me!

    • @roobsrooby6589
      @roobsrooby6589 Рік тому +2

      @@kari991199irak I believe you will find that the maximum amount of protein that can be absorbed in one meal is 30 grams. This is why bodybuilders eat upto 6 meals a day to get their total amount of protein into their body.

    • @10thletter40
      @10thletter40 Рік тому +1

      Using the metric system?
      I didn't watch the video but in the U.S. we use grams 😅
      If you mean his use in kg, that is probably a direct result from that use

    • @martinmuzik7429
      @martinmuzik7429 Рік тому +12

      There is no upper limit uptake per meal, just hit your daily goal in whatever amount of meals per day

    • @martinmuzik7429
      @martinmuzik7429 Рік тому +21

      ​@@roobsrooby658910 year old bro science

  • @bryonyvaughn2427
    @bryonyvaughn2427 Рік тому +36

    This is helpful! I'm on a weight loss diet and my doctor told me to increase my protein (without giving me a gram or percent of calories goal!) These numbers really help me to realize I should bump my protein up a bit more. Thanks!

    • @piyushdwivedi7195
      @piyushdwivedi7195 Рік тому +1

      Hey. If you don't know how many calories to consume to lose weight then start with a number from an online calorie calculator. Then monitor your weight for a week. If the average weigh in of all days of the week is lower than the initial weight then you lost weight. If it is the same then you need to lower the calories.

    • @grenzzgernascoticlas390
      @grenzzgernascoticlas390 Рік тому

      Not yet cause not same into needed protein max to body goals.

    • @Ottoni174
      @Ottoni174 Рік тому +4

      nutritionists usually prescribe more protein than you need on a diet to lose weight because it digests slower than carbs and fats, making you fuller and keeping muscle mass, its also harder to eat, making you eat each meal for a little longer which is great to feel full without actually being stuffed with food

    • @bryonyvaughn2427
      @bryonyvaughn2427 Рік тому +4

      @@Ottoni174 , I appreciate your sharing that contextual information. It helps me make more mindful choices.

  • @yijuntey
    @yijuntey Рік тому +229

    Thanks for including a whole section for endurance athletes. As an endurance athlete (triathlete), most videos and websites online that talks about nutrition often disregard the protein requirements for endurance athletes and only focus on the strength/power athletes which is kinda weird cuz I feel like it takes the same or even more amount of protein and rest to recover from a high intensity endurance training/race as a body builder aould after a gym session.

    • @latecheckout11
      @latecheckout11 Рік тому +3

      I did a lot intensive work for around 2 years.
      I had hard manual job usually 7 to 8 hours.
      I had 2 hours workout at home gym (heavy but not too heavy) and another to 2 to 3 hours intensive bike ride.
      I used mass protein for energy sources.
      I done it 5 days a week while weekend I spend around 12hours riding 10h on Saturday and 2h on Sunday including 1 hour recreational pool time.
      I was able to maintain my wait of 75kg to 80kg to 6'0.
      I built great endurance and good amount of mussels with almost triple the size of my legs.
      I want to note that I didn't monitor my diet just focus on to add protein intake for avoiding gassing out.
      it's definitely taking protein is on a plus note when it comes to one day intensive activities over long and consistent period of time.

    • @Wonkess_Chonkess
      @Wonkess_Chonkess 11 місяців тому

      ​@@latecheckout11 jeez, you must be a beast

  • @fernygd
    @fernygd Місяць тому

    Talking about protein intake info, this is the best, informative , clear , simple very valuable, short and practical video, congratulations! 👏

  • @PyroGonz
    @PyroGonz Рік тому +470

    I was consuming 210 grams of protein a day in 2022 (bulking). This year I’m consuming around 150 grams of protein and surprisingly I’m still gaining muscle mass 😁

    • @seankurtmanalo294
      @seankurtmanalo294 Рік тому +6

      same here!

    • @hustlerrr4889
      @hustlerrr4889 Рік тому

      How come

    • @6j6666
      @6j6666 Рік тому +25

      At what weight

    • @PyroGonz
      @PyroGonz Рік тому +12

      @@Its_Steeeve You should be fine with that amount. Don’t be afraid to eat more if you wanna get bigger.

    • @Its_Steeeve
      @Its_Steeeve Рік тому +1

      @@PyroGonz thanks brotha.

  • @PartyALLNighTCrew
    @PartyALLNighTCrew Рік тому +5

    Agree and just want to echo what I'm seeing other people comment. This is the second video I watch from this channel and it's really amazing how you included key information and made the video digestible (not pun intended), easy to understand, and reliable. Great job. Subscribing.

  • @GG-qr2mp
    @GG-qr2mp Рік тому +6

    Jonathan: Thank you for the trustworthy videos but this sparked questions in my mind about fasting. What’s happening during a fast since no protein is coming in? Do we still have nutrients in our digestive tract to go on? What’s happening to muscle during different fasting lengths? Is there a practical way to figure out a person’s particular protein level requirements?

    • @mikafoxx2717
      @mikafoxx2717 Рік тому +4

      Growth hormone goes up which is muscle sparing, and much of fat cells are also proteins, excess skin, and such are consumed more than muscle when fasting, which is why weight loss from fasting has far less skin issues.

  • @Robert_Byland
    @Robert_Byland Рік тому +16

    As always, your videos continue to improve my health and life! Thank you, Jonathan!

  • @tommytomtom7929
    @tommytomtom7929 Рік тому +6

    Video Number Quick Notes
    -RDA: 0.8g/kg (0.36 g/lb) 3:38
    -Freedom Units conversion: Body weight in pounds/2.2= Weight in Kilograms 4:09
    -Protein Range Chart (g/kg): 0.8-2.0 and what is recommended for your activity and desired outcome 6:04
    Edit: Added timestamps

  • @UPIL.INDONESIA
    @UPIL.INDONESIA Місяць тому

    4:04 THANK YOU! We all grateful that you consider that most of your viewers (the entire world) uses METRICS.

  • @takudzwakanombirira6022
    @takudzwakanombirira6022 9 місяців тому +4

    As a 4th year med student, l can safely say that you nailed your explanation

  • @betterlivingonabudget
    @betterlivingonabudget Рік тому +14

    Thank you for the detailed protein intake explanation - definitely the best I've ever come across.

  • @spider9053
    @spider9053 Рік тому +1269

    0% drug
    0% crime
    100% protein

    • @stocktonjoans
      @stocktonjoans Рік тому

      sounds boring AF, get out of the gym and get a life

    • @6996Gunslinger
      @6996Gunslinger Рік тому +126

      0% crime ? protein aint free brotha

    • @kingbad5105
      @kingbad5105 Рік тому +19

      How does a man supposed to get the protein from?

    • @amanda.collaud
      @amanda.collaud Рік тому +52

      @@kingbad5105 eat the vegans up ^^

    • @BKScience812
      @BKScience812 Рік тому +44

      @@amanda.collaud But vegans are kinda low in protein, aren't they?

  • @BiNumLi
    @BiNumLi Рік тому +2

    Useful information. This assumes the liver and kidneys are in good working order, there are no other chronic conditions causing imbalances in body chemistry, and energy is amply available via carbs and fat. As an older individual with some medical conditions it gets tricky knowing where the balance is. As long as the elimination organs are working I would err on the high side. It seems likely to me some protein ingested simply passes through partially undigested or unabsorbed. Especially protein from vegetable sources where amino acids are a mixed bag: some higher than needs, some lower than needs. Thanks.

  • @gabrielestes7236
    @gabrielestes7236 Рік тому +26

    These videos are absolutely amazing! I’m a new subscriber but I’m so impressed by the digestible evidence based approach to daily issues like nutrition and health. You guys rock!

    • @silviu.pădure
      @silviu.pădure Рік тому +1

      WRONG & MISLEADING.
      Q1 Where the excess of protein is going?! Exactly, is converted into FAT. So if you trying to lose cut your protein intake.
      Q2 What is happening with the recycled protein in the body?! Exactly, is reused to create new proteins, so more than 1g/kg of protein is an overkill.
      Q3 What is the No. 10 cause of death accounted for almost 75% of all deaths in the U.S.?! Exactly, kidney disease.
      Although high-protein diets continue to be popular for weight loss and type 2 diabetes, evidence suggests that worsening renal function may occur in individuals with-and perhaps without-impaired kidney function. High dietary protein intake can cause intraglomerular hypertension, which may result in kidney hyperfiltration, glomerular injury, and proteinuria. It is possible that long-term high protein intake may lead to de novo CKD. The quality of dietary protein may also play a role in kidney health. Compared with protein from plant sources, animal protein has been associated with an increased risk of ESKD in several observational studies, including the Singapore Chinese Health Study. Potential mediators of kidney damage from animal protein include dietary acid load, phosphate content, gut microbiome dysbiosis, and resultant inflammation. In light of such findings, adopting current dietary approaches that include a high proportion of protein for weight reduction or glycemic control should be considered with care in those at high risk for kidney disease. Given the possibility of residual confounding within some observational studies and the conflicting evidence from previous trials, long-term studies including those with large sample sizes are warranted to better ascertain the effects of high protein intake on kidney health.

    • @Battle-Fiercely
      @Battle-Fiercely 11 місяців тому

      @@silviu.pădure Does your advice benefit human beings with apex predator digestive tracts?

  • @BobRumohr
    @BobRumohr Рік тому +32

    How does age affect protein intake? Would particularly be interested in 65+ age related protein needs for somebody with a VO2 max of 50 and with high volume and intensity of aerobic training 5 days per week. Really appreciate your videos.

    • @shoot-n-scoot3539
      @shoot-n-scoot3539 Рік тому +4

      Sarcopenia is your new enemy as you age.

    • @Vel1ar
      @Vel1ar Рік тому +1

      with age protein absorption decreases, but actual numbers vary a lot from person to person. Good thing is, if you have healthy kidneys and liver, you will be ok eating way above recommended value. I can't remember name of the paper, but I read study with people eating 4g/kg daily with no health consequences.

    • @STapia-hf7vp
      @STapia-hf7vp Рік тому +1

      ​@@Vel1ar , That is the clincher for me. Kidneys throttling me down! Boo.

    • @BobRumohr
      @BobRumohr Рік тому +2

      @@shoot-n-scoot3539 Yeah - at 67 kg and 68 yo, I struggle to maintain muscle mass. Strength and mobility training along with yoga are incorporated into my weekly routine. Plant based diet requires protein supplement but I'm not consistent in consuming protein shakes of my own making.

    • @brianbadonde8700
      @brianbadonde8700 Рік тому +3

      protein needs increase at that age due to anabolic resistance, so basically you need more protein and luecine to get the same anabolic muscle building/maintenance response as when you were say 25, look up Gabrielle Lyon she's an expert in protein needs and ageing, if 20 grams of animal protein was enough in one meal to flip the mtor switch which is the muscle building process then at 60 plus you'd probably be better off with 40 grams per meal

  • @AdamScottfit
    @AdamScottfit Рік тому +10

    Great video and breakdown. Eric Helms put out a great estimate at 1g of protein per cm of height. I'm 193cm, that puts me at 193g and that is achievable for me at around 213lbs (97kg).

    • @Hyper_DX
      @Hyper_DX Рік тому

      193g of protein is too much and pretty much useless if you are natural

  • @whatfun99
    @whatfun99 Рік тому +8

    Nicely done. I've been reading around this subject for a while trying to get a handle on it. This is by far the clearest explication I've come across. Thank you!

    • @yizzynightingale138
      @yizzynightingale138 10 місяців тому

      I totally agree with you! This was well said and learned a lot from him!!

  • @affordable-art9501
    @affordable-art9501 7 місяців тому +2

    Super! Thank you for being short, clear and sufficiently deep.

  • @Konic_and_Snuckles
    @Konic_and_Snuckles Рік тому +24

    Shouldn't the recommendation be 1 g protein per 1 kg LEAN body mass (aka fat-free mass)? There is a huge difference in protein needs for a 100 kg person with 35% body fat vs a 100 kg person with 8% body fat. I almost never see this mentioned in the literature.

    • @AG-yl2iv
      @AG-yl2iv Рік тому +5

      Exactly! I look for this in every video/article about protein. I know not everyone wants to get a dexa-scan, but there are plenty of ways to estimate lean body mass, and 25-35% less protein a day adds up quick.

    • @andrewmochu6445
      @andrewmochu6445 Рік тому +3

      A very good comment/question. I want to lose fat and gain muscle at the same time, with a body fat of about 25%. So I am not sure how to calculate my protein requirements.

    • @Paul-om1zs
      @Paul-om1zs Рік тому +2

      @@AG-yl2iv I think you're totally right because protein is very expensive. Which ways are there to estimate my lean body mass without dexa-scan?

    • @AG-yl2iv
      @AG-yl2iv Рік тому +1

      @@Paul-om1zs It's best to do as many as you can and average the results; tape measurements/ratios that the military uses, skin-fold calipers, bio-electrical impedance (you can find them built into some scales), and hydro-static weighing.

    • @Paul-om1zs
      @Paul-om1zs Рік тому +2

      @@AG-yl2iv wow, thank you I am going to try that! 😄

  • @imacomputer1234
    @imacomputer1234 Рік тому +24

    Great video. I always tell people how important protein is. It's not just for our muscles, besides water and fat we're mostly made of protein! Tendons, ligaments, cartilage, bones, skin, and hair all need protein to grow and repair. I believe adequate protein intake is the number one way to combat the signs of aging!

  • @cameronf3343
    @cameronf3343 Рік тому +6

    I’m actually really grateful for this video I mean that. I’m 23 and have been on and off weightlifting since I was 13/14, and on/off because I never really put on size and got seriously discouraged. I’m 6’2 and I know of course that has a play in it but you legitimately can’t tell looking at me that I can barbell curl 135lbs.
    Seeing this I think I just haven’t been having enough proteins through my life for putting on size

  • @AndreasIreland
    @AndreasIreland 4 місяці тому

    Tack!

  • @JuniorDesrosiers-ob4ev
    @JuniorDesrosiers-ob4ev Рік тому

    The way you pay this out man it's like when I was learning the English alphabet pretty straight forward. Keep up the good work.

  • @johnnyboy4ever
    @johnnyboy4ever Рік тому +129

    This is very helpful, but I wish you talked about protein intake for different types of jobs as opposed to different types of activities... Many physical 40+hour a week jobs, would be all over this chart, and it would be nice to gain perspective as to how to either maintain/gain/lose muscle mass or weight, with activities that you do 40 hours a week as opposed to activities you do for fun for far less hours per week.

    • @ericeaton2386
      @ericeaton2386 Рік тому +19

      At a guess, I would say for physically active jobs it would fall somewhere in the ultra-endurance athlete range, but it really depends on the activity. If you're exhausted every day, I'd be willing to bet it should be towards the higher end, but if you've gained the strength where it's just what you're used to doing and you're not building *more* muscle constantly, then towards the lower end.

    • @amorfati4927
      @amorfati4927 Рік тому +9

      Completely anecdotal but I’m a cement mason by trade (horizontal concrete work so very physically demanding) AND I work out 3-6 days a week (just depends on work but I aim for 6 but most of the time only end up doing 3).
      My workouts were CrossFit but I have recently (for the last 8 months or so) went to bodybuilding hypertrophy style lifting because I wanted to get more size and strength back that I had before CrossFit (for the average non-competition person, CrossFit classes are just too randomized and not periodized for growth if you come from a traditional lifting base).
      Aaaaaaaanyways… I’m currently 5’11” and 190LBs with a six pack. I usually bulk in the winter but my top 4 abs are always visible and if I really feel like dialing in an 8 pack in the summer.
      My protein take is around 225G daily. So that’s right around the 1.2.
      I’m gaining size and strength at a rate I am very happy with.
      Could I grow more with more protein? Possibly? Could I grow as much with less protein? Definitely possible…
      This just seems like the sweet spot and really reflects my over all protein intake for a long time. My meals are timed so I never feel overly hungry just waiting on a meal. I drink A LOT of water. It’s just right for me.

    • @hhooppyy34
      @hhooppyy34 Рік тому +19

      @@amorfati4927 225g protein for a 190 lb individual is more like 2.6 g/kg (1.2 g/Ib)--so quite a bit above the 2g/kg they talked about during most of the video.

    • @ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked
      @ReligionAndMaterialismDebunked Рік тому

      O.o The viral fake janitor, fake old man, and fake nerd gym trainer, Anatoly, a beast powerlifter, not bodybuilder, who is really Vladimir, is viral, and you should check him out if you haven't already.

    • @Meverynoob
      @Meverynoob Рік тому +3

      For more physical jobs, protein obviously helps because the job provides the muscle stimulus. But more likely you're gonna be concerned about carb intake because you need to continuously replenish your energy sources.

  • @ana419
    @ana419 Рік тому +4

    This was one of the most excellent, informative and trustworthy science-based videos I've seen! Thank you so much! Do you have more on nutrition, types of exercise, effects and building muscle?

  • @abdullahalsaggaf8140
    @abdullahalsaggaf8140 Рік тому +241

    Amazing to watch this!.
    I remember in 2020 I increased my protein intake from 2g per kg up to 3g per kg. My body reacted within like 2 months with bad acne all on my face, and I only realized the reason for the acne after 4 months. Took me more than 6 months to recover from the bad acne that I had on my face.
    New bodybuilder be careful 🙏😁.

    • @xx-no3le
      @xx-no3le Рік тому +38

      as for my own hypothesis.... at least 50% of ur protein source was plant and dairy based right? in my own experience these 2 gave my also acne, since i get the most protein by meat and eggs no acne anymore 🙂

    • @ed-te1fp
      @ed-te1fp Рік тому +22

      It's not the protein. If you're getting acne, inflammation-related or auto-immune issues, temporarily switching to carnivore helps because it acts as an excellent 'safe' elimination diet that lets you identify what's causing the problem as you carefully re-introduce risky foods to see what causes the reaction. And I'm sure you know that meat contains plenty of protein. So you did something wrong; perhaps you got your protein from non-meat sources that contributed to your acne. (Example: some people get reactions from plant-based foods or excessive amounts of whey protein shakes. Ignore the body-building food supplement hype and don't OD that stuff. And it goes away when they eat normal food like lots of steak and eggs (which contains plenty of protein) and low to moderate amounts of shakes. )

    • @xx-no3le
      @xx-no3le Рік тому +5

      @@ed-te1fp i suspected the source of the protein and not the protein itself dude, also im not carnivore , i eat everything but 60% of that is eggs and meat

    • @ed-te1fp
      @ed-te1fp Рік тому +9

      @@xx-no3le My post to the OP was effectively agreeing with you

    • @hoompaloompaa
      @hoompaloompaa Рік тому +20

      Did you take a shower after working out?

  • @obfuscatid
    @obfuscatid Рік тому +1

    From what I read once, the RDA of protein for most people (not weight lifters, body builders, Olympic athletes) was calculated from studies and a number was produced, and then 2 standard deviations added to produce a "safe" number of grams/milligrams per kilogram of body weight. Bioavailability of protein source is important, amongst other variables.

  • @Viga7
    @Viga7 Місяць тому

    I am learning so much from your videos, they are so well-structured and easy to understand. Thank you and congratulations.

  • @Sunflowersarepretty
    @Sunflowersarepretty Рік тому +31

    It's such a delight learning from this channel. I fully understand everything here which makes me regret of not choosing medical field a couple a years ago. Again goes to how awesome teachers these guys are. ❤❤

  • @mrmosty5167
    @mrmosty5167 Рік тому +12

    Cool! I would to see an explanation on how the body processes simple water and why it's so necessary. Like if you drink a glass, where does it actually go and how is the waste processed?

    • @grenzzgernascoticlas390
      @grenzzgernascoticlas390 Рік тому

      Relative smooth to explained increase your body goal.?

    • @w0ttheh3ll
      @w0ttheh3ll 6 місяців тому

      there is no waste. water is very chemically stable (hard to change), our bodies don't split or transform it in any way.

    • @w0ttheh3ll
      @w0ttheh3ll 6 місяців тому +1

      BTW, food is the opposite of water in this respect. it's chemically instable (easy to change, especially to burn) and you actually produce lots of water as a byproduct ("wasteW) when digesting food.

  • @nm2064
    @nm2064 Рік тому +6

    I always have the same question: I'm on a weight loss quest, do I need to calculate according to my target weight or my current weight. My current weight is a plenty more than it should be, so it'd be ridiculously high, it would make more sense that the calculation is for target weight

    • @fitoza739
      @fitoza739 Рік тому

      I would suggest you to get your body composition done. You can just consider the body muscle tissue weight( bf% - the today weight) to calculate your protein intake. Incase you need more help reply me here i can help you create a diet to obtain your desired result.

    • @thefire-nanceguy4440
      @thefire-nanceguy4440 Рік тому

      @@fitoza739 yes i just asked this question too. How do I know what the body muscle tissue weight is please?

  • @gingerayyle
    @gingerayyle Рік тому +2

    Earned a sub from this video-love the concise presentation and credibility

  • @burningroses2399
    @burningroses2399 7 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for providing amazing content and increasing access to education/health promotion.

  • @Falconnner
    @Falconnner Рік тому +10

    Thank you for this consistent explanation! This is very true. Nitrogen balance is the best way to explain how much protein we need. But going one step deeper, taking enough protein, we have to keep in focus essential amino acids we can’t synthesize. Just for better understanding the difference between protein sources.

    • @BandiGetOffTheRoof
      @BandiGetOffTheRoof Рік тому

      I agree! Some protein sources have a much better amino acid profile... all too often, I think people just look at the grams of protein. Beans for example... 10 grams of protein wouldn't have the same combination of essential amino acids, that 10 grams of protein in eggs, meat, fish, etc.

  • @Reticulosis
    @Reticulosis Рік тому +12

    As always, awesome video. It was a great Human Nutrition class review.
    Funny story, back in the service I would lift weights anywhere from 1-2 hours a day and on days off (not working) I’d go for a 16 mile trail run or a 10 mile 25-35lbs ruck run. I always noticed if I left my cloths sitting a day or two later they smell of urea. My body was burning protein an excreting it via sweat

  • @davincidamaster5311
    @davincidamaster5311 Рік тому +10

    Great video! I was wondering, how does the water intake requirement vary with increase in protein supplement?
    And how much water should we be drinking daily in order to reduce chances of intoxication, as mentioned with the increase in nitrogen intake?

  • @hawg427
    @hawg427 10 місяців тому +1

    Many lifters forget to count the regular food they eat in their protein intake, not just from their protein powder, which can be hard on the kidneys. Great video.

  • @chrism8699
    @chrism8699 Місяць тому

    Thankyou for confirming what's been on my mind for a really long time. I just started working out again. I want to gain SOME moderate amount of muscle and get into shape but I'm not looking to get jacked. 1 gram per lb is a hell of a commitment. I knew there had to be a spectrum.

  • @sophiaisabelle027
    @sophiaisabelle027 Рік тому +20

    The content here never lacks in information. Keep up the good work.

  • @brandonmcintosh1398
    @brandonmcintosh1398 Рік тому +6

    Love all your videos. As a visual learner this helps way more than textbook learning. It would be cool to see a video about what the body goes through while deep sea diving

  • @stevanavich
    @stevanavich Рік тому +88

    Don't apologise for using the metric system; embrace it, normalise it, adopt it.

    • @BERMUDALINE
      @BERMUDALINE 5 місяців тому +4

      now some products on amazon says kilo, they had to. The american system is the worst for many things.

    • @JasMcKenzie
      @JasMcKenzie 3 місяці тому

      We use it for unpopular sports like track and field and swimming. Sodas come in two liter containers, milk comes in quarts, eggs come in dozens. Steaks are measured in lbs and ounces and damn well always will be.

    • @karlhungus545
      @karlhungus545 3 місяці тому

      @@JasMcKenzie Yes, Americans will always be behind the rest of the world, you're right.

    • @Shiva-jf2gd
      @Shiva-jf2gd Місяць тому

      ​@@JasMcKenzie not in the normal world.

    • @JasMcKenzie
      @JasMcKenzie Місяць тому

      @@Shiva-jf2gd wth are you taking about?

  • @yourperfectdemise
    @yourperfectdemise Рік тому +2

    This video was the best video I’ve seen on beak down of proteins 👌🏻

  • @oorjaamantrawithpoojak2623
    @oorjaamantrawithpoojak2623 Рік тому +2

    Thank you so much, this was such a comprehensive and precise video!

  • @mattas007
    @mattas007 Рік тому +5

    At what frequency should one consume protein? Like how much protein can the body absorb in one go? And does this matter depending on what typ of protein source it comes from?

    • @Jake-dt2gr
      @Jake-dt2gr Рік тому

      My same question. He should do another video on this topic

    • @lisanul7863
      @lisanul7863 Рік тому

      you can have it however you want throughout the day, it does not matter where the source is from. For example, i can have from 60g up to 90g of protein per meal, and i mix around my sources so i don’t get bored.

    • @mattas007
      @mattas007 Рік тому

      @@lisanul7863 And what are you basing this on? What I'm after is a scientific answer: what is the rate the body can absorb and utilize protein. So lets say I drink 20g protein form a shake. How much of that protein is my body going to use and what is the cap of protein intake in a singel consumption and in in the video it was said that the body gets rid of excess. And also what I'm wondering is how to maximize ones protein intake while not wasting it by overconsuming it in one go.

  • @ysa9
    @ysa9 Рік тому +6

    Please do a detailed series of endocrine system especially thyroid

  • @ChristineWaters
    @ChristineWaters Рік тому +38

    This video was very helpful for me. I've been an ovo-lacto vegetarian for over 26 years and describe my fitness level as intermediate (e.g., hiking 3-10 miles per week, walking at least 7,000 steps daily, and doing about 45 minutes of strength/flexibility workouts about 5 days per week). As a vegetarian, I've been through many recurring nutrient deficiencies over the years, including iron, B12, folic acid, and Vitamin D. Cardio exercises are very tiring and difficult for me, particularly when I have an undiagnosed nutrient deficiency. Even at this level of experience, it takes me a few months to realize my fatigue is a nutrient deficiency and not just stress from work. I recently learned that I have low protein. This video was helpful, because I was surviving on the myth that is the opposite of what you learned from body builders in college... The vegetarian community often claims that most people get more protein than they need from their diet. However, since incorporating at least one pea-protein shake a day and a protein (i.e. nuts, tofu, or beans) with every meal, I have been feeling a lot better. The nutritionist has me keep track of what I eat with an app, and I'm still struggling to incorporate the minimum amount of protein. The video helps to know that I probably won't OD if I have a second shake some days, particularly since I have an active lifestyle. Thank you.
    On another note, you mention fats, and I'd love it if you also covered this. My tracking app has shown me that I do not get enough fat in my diet. Do athletes need more fat in their diet than nonathletes?

    • @joeychen3946
      @joeychen3946 Рік тому +3

      I would love a video on fats too! I have friends who think dietary fats are always bad, but I heard that dietary fats are necessary for effective weight loss. Is that true? And why?

    • @K0YOT3
      @K0YOT3 Рік тому +3

      I'm on the other side of the spectrum
      I have been lacto-vegetarian for 5 years, never had any deficiencies, I practice calisthenics and run 1 hour and half/2 hours a day
      Never needed to supplement and lost 40 kg without ever needing to count calories/macros or professional help
      Are you getting enough calories? The only time I felt weak was when I tried to severely restrict rice. Now I proudly eat 3 cups a day, it fuels my training

    • @K0YOT3
      @K0YOT3 Рік тому +4

      It's been a year since I haven't eaten a single egg and my athletic perfomance has only increased. Rice, corn, oats and pinto beans are my main source of protein, and rice is the bulk of my diet

    • @Papagajidomitas
      @Papagajidomitas Рік тому

      I ate chicken breast, full grain pasta and vegetables near all day for years ((+ sugars, cake etc..(6 times a week training in the gym), and I felt tired all the time. All I changed is added 80-100g peanut butter (50% fat) to the menu, and I feel like extremely powerful.

    • @jean-baptistehartmann5879
      @jean-baptistehartmann5879 Рік тому +7

      Hey, I'm vegan for 7 years and bodybuilding, no deficiencies. Dont' give up, focus in nutritious fresh whole foods in large quantities. Bests.

  • @sherylvitale4997
    @sherylvitale4997 10 місяців тому +2

    Love this channel! Glad I found it!

  • @LatentAxis
    @LatentAxis Рік тому

    I love the fact I can get the information I need from a no BS, scientific point of view. Trying to find the answer from gym buffs UA-camrs, and they all tell you different things, or even give you the wrong answers. This is great!

  • @felipearbustopotd
    @felipearbustopotd Рік тому +8

    Dear Johnathon and co, if you get to read this - please consider mentioning (maybe in a future upload) how much protein can be synthesized by the muscle after working out.
    According to Dr Donald Layman the max that can be synthesized at any one given time is topped at 50g. The next best refeed for muscle synthesis when eating protein is some what ambiguous (so he says) but many sway on the side of caution and eat 4 if not up to 6 meals containing protein.
    Dr DL also mentions that the 1st and last meal should be the focus on protein intake, i.e. 50g max.
    Other meals can be less protein orientated,
    Caveat - he did say that HIS priority was not on bulking up,
    Mike Menzter said - if you are bulking up - the focus should be, carbs @ 60%.... protein @ 25% and fats @15%
    ****
    As always - very informative.
    Thank you for uploading and sharing.
    🥰
    If anyone can see errors in my post - then please do reply.

  • @spiritualtaurus7942
    @spiritualtaurus7942 Рік тому +7

    Thank you sir. I follow many like you but this is something I needed to know. I'm 38 and still fit n shredded, but always had issues with him holding muscle n body weight. This really helped me understand protein better. So I need more on the regular cos I'm very athleticly built, I've always experimented over the years but never quite got it right. Hopefully this information implement into my lifestyle will give me some different results. Much appreciated.🙏💯🇬🇧

  • @HeatherHolt
    @HeatherHolt Рік тому +7

    Really finding it tough to get enough protein as a vegan new to working out (and who doesn’t like sweet stuff like protein shakes/bars) and this info is nice to have. I hear a lot of 1g/pound of body weight, and at 145lbs, that was tough. But if I look at it more as .75/lb or 1.6/kg then that’s a much more manageable ~100g of protein a day.
    My problem is trying to be in a calorie deficit while also getting enough protein, but now that I’m 5-10 lbs away from my target weight, I’m more looking for getting stronger instead of smaller. It would be nice to be 5’10 135 like I was pre baby, but I’m ok with 5’10 145 if that means I am strong enough to toss my toddler in the air.

    • @ranzigerkaefer
      @ranzigerkaefer Рік тому +5

      Peas, Beans, Lendrils. Its easy, man... Make yourself a chili sin carne family sized meal and you are fine. There are so many ways to reach your goal.

    • @koznar9496
      @koznar9496 Рік тому +1

      Tofu is great, basically water and protein, marinate that tofu and cook it

  • @mashaalsaif2646
    @mashaalsaif2646 10 місяців тому

    This video is fantastic.
    It would be wonderful if you could create another video discussing the feeding window concept. Specifically, could you address whether we should divide our daily protein intake into smaller portions for each meal, especially for individuals who only eat one or two meals a day? Additionally, is there a limit to the amount of protein our bodies can absorb during each feeding time?

  • @NB-qy7ku
    @NB-qy7ku 9 місяців тому

    Protein needs:
    3:40 0.8 gram per kilogram of body weight
    3:47 .36 grams per pound
    Mild exercise:
    4:44 1.2-2 grams per kilograms

  • @tdc3rd
    @tdc3rd Рік тому +7

    Awesome. Would love a part 2 that addresses how much protein we should intake at one time and other related factors. E.G., I’ve always heard ingesting protein (how much of the rec. daily amt?) within 30 min after a workout is best because your body can process more at that time, but now I see commercials for amino acid makers that say you need to ingest protein (or rather the broken down amino acids) BEFORE a workout so they’re available to repair workout-damaged cells right after the workout. Don’t know who to believe…

    • @robm6803
      @robm6803 Рік тому +2

      Not important at all. That is all just to make money. Your body doesn’t care.
      Of course you can digest only that amount of protein in say one hour. But guess what, it remains in your digestive system and is processed later. Ever pooped pure protein power because it was „too much in one go“? Don’t think so.. ;)

  • @Scrappsta
    @Scrappsta Рік тому +5

    I think it’s safe to say that 1g-2g of protein per pound of muscle mass/lean body weight is more ideal than per pound of body weight. I think per pound of body weight is way too much. If a person is 280lbs, your basically saying that this individual will need over 560grams of protein a day (at 1g per lb of body weight) to build muscle. This is wayyy too much. Just calculating calories per gram of protein, that’s 2,240 lbs of protein calories not including all the other excess calories you’d get from FAT and Carbohydrates which are 9 calories per gram of FAT and 4 Cal per gram of Carbohydrates. Even for a big eater, getting that many grams of protein would be crazy. I have managed to build extreme amounts of muscle and lose weight by only consuming a little over half of my body weight in terms of 1g/protein per lb of body weight. I suggest you go by 1g of protein per lb of lean muscle mass and if your really trying to build muscle, when you lift, progressive overload is the key. Don’t over bloat your body.

  • @LeviAkarman-yz4vh
    @LeviAkarman-yz4vh Рік тому +6

    0.6-0.8 gr per kilogram body for sedentar adult and around 1.6 for active people

    • @Parker_Miller_M.S.
      @Parker_Miller_M.S. Рік тому

      No that's likely lower than what would provide the best muscle and strength sparing effect. 1.2g/kg has been often suggested over the past decade as the new minimum people, especially older adults, should arrive for.

    • @LeviAkarman-yz4vh
      @LeviAkarman-yz4vh Рік тому

      @@Parker_Miller_M.S. 1.2 gr per kg/corp is exaggerated for un desedentary adult, lowe protein intake is show to increase longevity

    • @Parker_Miller_M.S.
      @Parker_Miller_M.S. Рік тому

      @@LeviAkarman-yz4vh based on what data? I'm well aware of "blue zones" but Im not at all convinced that low protein intake is a casual effect for the longevity seen in these regions considering we know how important muscle mass and strength are for longevity. We have copious data from prospective cohort studies showing those with more muscle mass and strength are less likely to die from all causes and from specific causes like cancer. Even COVID hospitalizations are shortened by having more muscle mass and strength. So again, I'll ask for your data.

    • @LeviAkarman-yz4vh
      @LeviAkarman-yz4vh Рік тому

      @@Parker_Miller_M.S. I don't have data, i say what i read on another places. If we eat a healthy balance diet the protein intake or any nutrient intake isn't a concern

    • @randomanda
      @randomanda Рік тому

      It’s not just longevity by itself that’s important though… living to 100 but being weak, fragile and having osteoporosis vs living to 90 but being fully functional and having an active life- what should be the best goal?

  • @antonnette1612
    @antonnette1612 Рік тому +2

    Im currently in nursing school and they teach us as a baseline 0.8g of protein per kg of body weight. Then adjust as needed depending on an individuals needs or health. Still learning what works best for my body 😅

    • @orchidmuse
      @orchidmuse 9 місяців тому

      US carnivore community says 0.8-1g per lbs, which is like x2 more. I had my pain with that at first, but after researching for some months I am coming to a conclusion they have a point, saying that 1g per 1kg is only enough to survive. They found out who were those scientists, and how they came to the given number per kg. Interesting research! I would suggest reading and listening to Dr. D. Laymann.

  • @NEVERAGAIN-rz1ep
    @NEVERAGAIN-rz1ep Рік тому

    Great video! Finally someone who doesnt just says their own opinion but actually speaks facts

  • @Katjaneway
    @Katjaneway Рік тому +8

    My only question is what about having to limit the amount of protein PER MEAL? I keep reading about how the body can only process so much per meal (around 30g I think) and anything over that would be stored as fat (or maybe excreted?). Any science behind that theory?

    • @AbrahamsYTC
      @AbrahamsYTC Рік тому +2

      Think I saw an RenaissancePer/other videos on that. From what I remember, it's better to break down your total protein in chunks. Although I don't think 30g is the "max" amount. I aim to get 40-60g in a main meal/post workout and usually get 20g snacks throughout the day every 2-3 hrs. Been working for me.

    • @seleciaa
      @seleciaa Рік тому +1

      I don't think 30 is the max :o I regularly eat over 30g per meal, and I'm nowhere near overweight. 73g per day is the minimum I aim for

    • @mikafoxx2717
      @mikafoxx2717 Рік тому

      Watch high intensity health's videos on omad/ one meal a day, and you'll see that's all false. The more food you eat in a meal, the longer it takes to digest, so you effectively still only process the same amount at a time, and the fasting raises growth hormone and other things so it works extra effectively when you do feed it.

  • @adriaanmorosan
    @adriaanmorosan Рік тому +27

    Went from eating 1.5 grams per lbs a day to 0.75g per lbs a day and I saw no difference in strength and size..
    The only difference I noticed and it was a very clear one aswell.. that weight dropped more steadily during a weightloss when having more protein compared to less.
    To the people actually caring about health I’d worry more about having enough micro nutrients and enough healthy fats (0.4-0.5g/pound) in your diet..
    comes from 14 years of experience :D

    • @robm6803
      @robm6803 Рік тому +9

      I am completely on your side. The myths around protein and these exorbitant amounts one should consume exist purely to support a whole industry of selling supplements. No money extra to make if people would just eat normally and still gain muscle. ;)

    • @adriaanmorosan
      @adriaanmorosan Рік тому +2

      @@robm6803 Amen to that brother😎

  • @SEAKPhotog
    @SEAKPhotog Рік тому +6

    Good stuff. How does age impact these numbers? I've read that the older we get the less efficient we use proteins/EAAs, so we should factor that into our daily protein intake requirements. I'm a 60 year old gym rat trying to maintain and even still build muscle/strength. I'm adhering to the 1gr protein/1lb body weight formula. It seems to work if I do my part and maintain my consistency and effort at the gym.

    • @ryanjones7202
      @ryanjones7202 Рік тому +2

      Your friendly neighborhood Dietitian here! As we get older we typically need more protein and generally have lower calorie needs (this can change depending on health status and issues) and around age 65 to 70 the needs are around 1.2-2grams if protein per kg of body weight. So it depends on illness/health status, presence of disease, and activity level/type of activity but the general range is 1.2 to 2 grams.

    • @KhaledMehamdia-y1b
      @KhaledMehamdia-y1b Рік тому

      الحفاض على الوزن

  • @samj923
    @samj923 Рік тому +1

    This channel is exciting to watch.

  • @elck3
    @elck3 Рік тому

    The point about people losing weight in caloric deficit needing MORE Protein is super insightful and important!!!!

  • @juliakbrown
    @juliakbrown Рік тому +6

    Are there differences in how the body uses protein between men and women? Or is it really just body weight? Also, I’m curious as to what is known about how this changes in pregnancy with the needs of the fetus. Thanks for all the informative videos, love your channel!

    • @furyberserk
      @furyberserk Рік тому +2

      Not a doctor, but I heard women have 4 hormone cycles and it affects the body in different cycles. Water intake muscle growth, etc. That's all I can say.
      Ted talk talked about it. New info may be out.

    • @djamal869
      @djamal869 Рік тому

      As the rda says women needs 0.5 0.6 of grams per kg of body weight

  • @masonprophet6396
    @masonprophet6396 Рік тому +7

    Fantastic video. I have learned all of this information over the last year, and I figured I would watch this just to see if there was anything I hadn't, yet. Not much new to me, but this video was laid out and structured perfectly.
    All of the information you could really need when it comes to protein intake. Good job on this one.👍

  • @pigeneguerra
    @pigeneguerra Рік тому +17

    2 things I've heard that I'd to see addressed: 1. You need more as you get older since your body can't use the protein as efficiently. 2. Protein source matters -- plant protein isn't as bioavailable as animal protien so you need more for the same impact

    • @Phil-mw7xy
      @Phil-mw7xy Рік тому

      Good points.

    • @benja_mint
      @benja_mint Рік тому +1

      i've never understood this point about why some protein sources should be more or less available. is it talking about the ratios of the essential amino acids (e.g. peanut butter is theoretically almost 30% protein but its kind of a bad ratio so its effecively more like 15%) or is it talking about the efficiency at which the body can access the existing amino acids regardless of ratio

    • @Phil-mw7xy
      @Phil-mw7xy Рік тому +1

      @@benja_mint Proteins are made of sequences of different amino acids. Plant based proteins don't have a complete sequence like animal-based proteins (they have lower essential amino acid content, particularly leucine) and are often harder to digest making them less bioavailable.

    • @LumieX
      @LumieX Рік тому +1

      ​@@Phil-mw7xyLol clueless. It's the other way around bud. Meat is much harder to digest because plants have enzymes to help you digest them.

  • @kissenklauer7011
    @kissenklauer7011 Рік тому +1

    great video, even though some things weren't convincing to me. an endurance runner breaking down an increased amount of muscle during an extended run doesn't necessarily mean the body is able to recover an increased amount. running a lot still won't provide a sufficient stimulus for a lot of muscle growth and increasing protein intake might not change that. also I would have appreciated a few words about the limited stability of amino acids in the blood stream. there's no protein depot in the human body like there is for glycogen and fats, which makes timing your protein intake pretty important, which is especially relevant for intermittent fasters. another thing that would be interesting is certain amino acids (leucin) triggering metabolic pathways in the human body (MTOR) which is relevant for (muscle)growth.

  • @kiefershanks4172
    @kiefershanks4172 10 місяців тому

    I'm pretty much learning I have not been eating nearly enough to meet my fitness goals. I always thought I ate enough but now I'm finding out I pretty much have to double my protein intake which is pretty mindblowing to me. I think my early adult years when my income was really low normalized my habit of eating just enough to get by. I was always astonished how it seemed so easy for some people to exercise consistently and intensely when I found myself barely able to do so twice a week. It seems silly to me now, but I genuinely didn't clue in that my lack of food was holding me back. Now that I have a decent income, I can afford to eat to build muscle. It is a privelege to be able to eat this much and build a great physique. I'm looking forward to finally getting some results.

  • @LadyAxe13
    @LadyAxe13 9 місяців тому +4

    It was great to hear someone speak in terms of the metric system. Too many videos still use the archaic, outdated pounds and ounces from half a century ago. Most of the world has moved on, so kudo's for using metric measurements.

  • @Str8UpFax
    @Str8UpFax Рік тому +4

    I really hoped you would go into depth about absorption too, i keep hearing you cant take too much protein at once or your body just wont absorb it

  • @Veci_RigVeda
    @Veci_RigVeda Рік тому +36

    Very interesting topic 💪🏼 I’d love to see a video on how the diaphragm operates. Trying to brace my abs while inhaling correctly to maintain spinal compression on my big lifts and having some difficulty to imagine how the diaphragm engages in this activity 😅 Could use some reinforcement on my mind muscle connection on this 🙏🏼

    • @patrikbjorling4391
      @patrikbjorling4391 Рік тому +1

      You must mean when exhailing? All my lifts are stabilized to the MAX when doing that. When inhaling your chest expands and bracing your core is near impossible.

    • @Veci_RigVeda
      @Veci_RigVeda Рік тому +1

      @@patrikbjorling4391 nope, I definitely meant while inhaling. I’ve no problem maintaining spinal compression on the concentric explosive part of the big lifts, the eccentric slow part however while inhaling causes spinal movement if not attentively breathing through the chest (diaphragm function) and with incorrect bracing of the core.

    • @shay_3859
      @shay_3859 Рік тому

      So upon achieving a rididulous amount of mobility while in a backbend position, I came to understand that my diaphragm had been fully contracted and my belly size had shrunk, as if I was doing a stomach vaccuum. That's when I noticed that I was able to perform a full range of motion vaccuum. When I began training my backbend, breathing was not easy due to being locked into a position of contracted abs which I lacked mobility to maintain. Now, I am able to breathe a lot easier. After reading your comment, this all made sense, and I also tested if I was able to contract my abs and then breath deeply in and out and maintain spinal posture. I was able to do so with ease. I believe this is because it mimicks the backbend position.

    • @Veci_RigVeda
      @Veci_RigVeda Рік тому +1

      @@shay_3859 that’s amazing! Thanks for sharing. I was also experimenting on full ROM with breathing focusing on the concentric/eccentric part of the diaphragm with contracted abs to maintain spinal compactness on my big lifts. Basically most bodybuilders use belts to cue themselves for proper spinal form but I assume wearing a belt on big lifts is unnecessary when one can consciously use their abs and use a correct breathing pattern with full range of motion to maintain spinal posture. I’d be dying to see a video on this particular topic 😋

    • @shay_3859
      @shay_3859 Рік тому +1

      @@Veci_RigVeda Took me a while to find this comment😅. Thanks, and I agree, but I feel like if there is a video on it, it wouldn't be easy to find. Good information on UA-cam is not always easy to come across, maybe try an article if you're interested.

  • @vladyslavshokhel8893
    @vladyslavshokhel8893 Рік тому +1

    I love math and calculations. So, do not apologize. It was the most important part of this study

  • @SwingVoter-hz6nn
    @SwingVoter-hz6nn 10 місяців тому

    Thank you for the informative video. I will say that the one where you did fat metabolism and were showing visceral fat in a cadaver has made me redouble my efforts in the gym. 40 lbs down at 45 years old and still gaining muscle!

  • @bibilove6277
    @bibilove6277 Рік тому +12

    All I know is that at 49 I was losing muscle more noticeably then ever. I was told to increase my protein to my height per weight ideal. So I started consuming 120g of protein. My hair stop falling, my nails got stronger. The lunar in my nails return and I started firming up . Just doing weights a twice week. It’s been a chancer.

    • @atomic3325
      @atomic3325 Рік тому +1

      Yeah one of the wrinkle's in this video is as you age, you need more protein because efficiency decreases.

    • @bibilove6277
      @bibilove6277 Рік тому

      @@atomic3325 exactly!!

  • @Zanuka
    @Zanuka Рік тому +6

    Thanks for the video. Has this channel talked about different protein types already (e.g. plant vs animal, plant raw vs plant cooked/soaked, etc)? Also does timing matter (e.g. post workout)?

    • @xisotopex
      @xisotopex Рік тому +1

      protein is protein. a given amino acid is the same molecule regardless of whether it came from a bean or from beef.

    • @thegrinderman1090
      @thegrinderman1090 Рік тому +3

      @@xisotopex While that's true, I've read things in the past about the bioavailability of protein being lower in plant foods than animal foods (and in raw vs cooked). i.e. just because a food contains x amount of protein, your body cannot necessarily extract 100% of x, and this is lower in plant foods. I don't know how accurate that is though.

    • @xisotopex
      @xisotopex Рік тому +1

      @@thegrinderman1090 no you are right, that is correct, in that all the different proteins need to be in correct ratios, or they will not all be utilized completely.... you could very easily eat a plant diet that combined different sources to make the complete profile and it would all be utilized...
      I misunderstood you.... it might be something to pay a little bit more attention to when planning meals if you are completely plant based. some types of beans are very close, so you figure out what is deficient in the bean, and eat something else that has more of that

    • @thegrinderman1090
      @thegrinderman1090 Рік тому +2

      @@xisotopex I think we're talking about slightly different things. You're right that there are many plant foods with incomplete amino acid profiles, whereas that isn't the case with meat, so a plant-based diet requires more attention to which specific foods are eaten.
      However, I've also heard about nutrient 'bioavailability', which is how easy it is for the nutrients to be extracted from a food by our body. And it's been suggested that the protein in plants may be less bioavailable than animal products, meaning we may have to consume more to absorb the same amount.

  • @zz3709
    @zz3709 Рік тому +9

    Love your videos, and this one is very timely as i recently started resistance training (to build muscle and lose fat) and I'm trying to increase my protein intake. Would love to know about different types of protein (animal vs. veg), as I'm mostly getting mine (~0.7g/lb) from lean turkey, chicken, salmon & eggs, but the (several) vegetarians in my life give me grief about how I'd be better off being vegetarian, citing many issues with animal protein. I just can't get the protein-to-carb ratio i want with veg protein, and AIUI animal proteins are easier absorbed (utilization).

    • @dsoul1305
      @dsoul1305 Рік тому

      What issues? There are zero problems with animal protein. It's THE source, the species main source since the caves. Vegetarians usually have misinterpretations of scientific papers. They rely on associative or epidemiological studies that only find correlations, but can't find causation.
      Ex.: In summer, more people drown and eat ice cream, but despite summer's correlation to these statistics, it's not the season who causes the drownings or the ice cream consumption. In cold climates this correlation couldn't even exist, because there is no real heat, or in a hot climate even, without the ice cream as a available food and the lack of big bodies of water.
      Would you regulate your ice cream consumption in summer based on the fear of increasing your risk of drowning? I'm guess no because you know there is no relation of cause between this data. Same with animal protein.

    • @Althamenes
      @Althamenes Рік тому +3

      As a vegetarian, if they shame you for not being vegetarian instead of giving you solutions, then they're not nice people. I get a lot of my protein from lentils, cottage cheese, tofu, soybeans, etc. I think it's easier to achieve the protein intake as a meat eater because you don't have to eat the quantities that a vegetarian has to, especially if aiming for hypertrophy.
      If you do want to be mindful of what you eat, I would recommend picking ethical sources (grass fed, free range) than jumping straight into the vegetarian diet. You can experiment with Asian and Mediterranean diets as they have balanced things very well for some people that I know.

    • @hellothere4765
      @hellothere4765 Рік тому

      Animal protein has more amino acids, red meat in particular which also has more minerals and other micronutrients. I also use collagen peptides instead of ordinary protein powder to add even more amino acids.

  • @framebuyframe2493
    @framebuyframe2493 11 місяців тому

    Truly excellent video discussing a very important topic for general health and especially for anyone exercising.

  • @yellowcatmonkey
    @yellowcatmonkey Рік тому

    oh thank u 🙈💖thank you jonathan 4 using metrics this is precious tysm love this channel w all my heart 🍀💕u r the best 🌻✨

  • @misskhalesi3334
    @misskhalesi3334 Рік тому +8

    Can you tell us healthy way to eat breakfast

    • @antisad
      @antisad Рік тому +2

      eat what u want

  • @petrdvoracek670
    @petrdvoracek670 Рік тому +4

    2:12 these bodies in a plastic bags in the background make me uncomfortable

  • @hayleyedwards9137
    @hayleyedwards9137 10 місяців тому

    Thank you! Clearly laid out and well explained. Excellent work.

  • @MrZiyad-pb2yy
    @MrZiyad-pb2yy Рік тому

    One of the best videos about fitness ever made

  • @pierrepisu1704
    @pierrepisu1704 Рік тому +4

    I would have appreciated that you also broke down the differences between animal and plant proteins regards the process called gluconeogenesis. Not to mention the incapacity of the body storing protein but instead converting into fat and carbs. Don’t get me wrong, I’m a huge fan of your videos and the invaluable quantity and quality of information you give us and can’t thank you enough for that.

  • @dzymslizzy3641
    @dzymslizzy3641 Рік тому +4

    There is always so much emphasis on meat being the "best" source of protein. Truth is, you don't need to eat muscles to build muscles. In fact, the only person to win the Ironman Triathlon not once, but THREE times, was a vegan!!
    I'm a vegetarian (have been since the mid 1980s), and currently trying to transition to vegan. However, I'm not into body building; I'm probably more active than a lot of people my age (75), but I'm also "allergic" to exercise, per se. My exercise has to be fun...playtime...and incidentally is exercise. ;-)