Karate Culure, muchas gracias por el video, no practico Jiujitsu, pero me va a servir mucho para reforzar mis técnicas de Karate, sobre todo en el Kumite, también se puede utilizar como defensa personal, muchas gracias!!!
How come when this is performed as a kata it looks like the partitioners are constipated but when you're doing it with another person it's all fluid and loose?
Notice the guys took the time to put a little heart on my comment but didn't answer the question. I know you don't have to answer these but I'm just really anxious on knowing why when this pummeling drill is performed in saison they look so fucking tense but when you're doing it with a person or partner it's so fluid and loose? It's one of the things that I am still wondering about why the karate katas are so stiff-looking compared to other fighting styles especially when considering that in a real fight you need to be relaxed and loose.
it's like firing a gun at a range, you want to be as exact and robotic as possible to make the lines as perfect as possible. Because under stress and in a real situation it'll never be that perfect. You fall to your training under stress, you don't rise up to the occasion. Kata is one piece of the picture, I train kata in hundreds of variations - slow and stiff, fast and fluid, legs only, hands only, hips emphasis, etc. the list goes on and on. On the other hand, Those who over emphasize kata, without training with a partner and without adding resistance will start focusing on the wrong things. They over emphasize correctness cause that's all they know. And they might overemphasize details (hand angle, knee bend, etc) that they don't understand why but it was shown to them so they just pass it on without question. Most of those adjustments came from a practical application but if they're not training to see why it's practical then it just becomes choreography. Sometimes you have to be tense even with another partner. If you watch wrestling, both people are under tension the entire time. It might look loose but when they're clinched up it's completely rigid and tense. They only sprint and are fluid when an opening happens. and then it's back to pushing and pulling. At the end of the day, kata is a framework. You either use it to train with another partner or you use it for solo training, or both. You either take it at face value cause it's shown to you by a higher rank. Or you question it constantly cause you're on your own journey. I'm a BJJ black belt, karate black belt, and on my way to being a Judo black belt. At the end of the day it's my journey. And in my eyes it's all just human movement. Seeing karate in that lens has allowed me to cross train in tons of different arts without any ego. A white belt I meet for the first time can teach me something new because he moves in a different pattern than I'm used to. And that's the beauty of it all, yin and yang. I've seen the tenseness of a white belt overcome techniques of an upper belt, and I've seen an old man move around the rigidness of a strong young man. It's all data, knowledge, things that become your martial DNA. I'm grateful I can see anything - sports, a child walking, animals fighting, trees blowing in the wind - and see martial movements. I hope this channel helped others do the same. Martial arts, Karate, everything is as individualistic as it is holistic. I stand on the shoulder of those who came before me, but I carry my journey of martial arts. Questioning others is beneficial but criticizing without understanding is childish.
Karate Culure, muchas gracias por el video, no practico Jiujitsu, pero me va a servir mucho para reforzar mis técnicas de Karate, sobre todo en el Kumite, también se puede utilizar como defensa personal, muchas gracias!!!
Very cool!👊🏻🥋😎
How come when this is performed as a kata it looks like the partitioners are constipated but when you're doing it with another person it's all fluid and loose?
Which kata has that move ?
@@daniel-zh9nj6yn6y Seisan
@@Helltown66 Thanks !
Notice the guys took the time to put a little heart on my comment but didn't answer the question. I know you don't have to answer these but I'm just really anxious on knowing why when this pummeling drill is performed in saison they look so fucking tense but when you're doing it with a person or partner it's so fluid and loose? It's one of the things that I am still wondering about why the karate katas are so stiff-looking compared to other fighting styles especially when considering that in a real fight you need to be relaxed and loose.
it's like firing a gun at a range, you want to be as exact and robotic as possible to make the lines as perfect as possible. Because under stress and in a real situation it'll never be that perfect. You fall to your training under stress, you don't rise up to the occasion. Kata is one piece of the picture, I train kata in hundreds of variations - slow and stiff, fast and fluid, legs only, hands only, hips emphasis, etc. the list goes on and on. On the other hand, Those who over emphasize kata, without training with a partner and without adding resistance will start focusing on the wrong things. They over emphasize correctness cause that's all they know. And they might overemphasize details (hand angle, knee bend, etc) that they don't understand why but it was shown to them so they just pass it on without question. Most of those adjustments came from a practical application but if they're not training to see why it's practical then it just becomes choreography. Sometimes you have to be tense even with another partner. If you watch wrestling, both people are under tension the entire time. It might look loose but when they're clinched up it's completely rigid and tense. They only sprint and are fluid when an opening happens. and then it's back to pushing and pulling. At the end of the day, kata is a framework. You either use it to train with another partner or you use it for solo training, or both. You either take it at face value cause it's shown to you by a higher rank. Or you question it constantly cause you're on your own journey. I'm a BJJ black belt, karate black belt, and on my way to being a Judo black belt. At the end of the day it's my journey. And in my eyes it's all just human movement. Seeing karate in that lens has allowed me to cross train in tons of different arts without any ego. A white belt I meet for the first time can teach me something new because he moves in a different pattern than I'm used to. And that's the beauty of it all, yin and yang. I've seen the tenseness of a white belt overcome techniques of an upper belt, and I've seen an old man move around the rigidness of a strong young man. It's all data, knowledge, things that become your martial DNA. I'm grateful I can see anything - sports, a child walking, animals fighting, trees blowing in the wind - and see martial movements. I hope this channel helped others do the same. Martial arts, Karate, everything is as individualistic as it is holistic. I stand on the shoulder of those who came before me, but I carry my journey of martial arts. Questioning others is beneficial but criticizing without understanding is childish.