Nephi you can see other her performance now at golden memories asia 2019 and she won that competition .this competition there are Philipina singer too as contestans
It's fascinating to remember that she sung that song like one year after it's released. (Kelly won idol : 2002, this song released : 2003, Joy sung this song and won idol : 2004) First winner of each country.
Indonesian Idol Season 1 1st - Joy Tobing 2nd - Delon Thamrin Indonesian Idol season 2 1st - Mike Mohede (passed away) 2nd - Judika Sihotang Indonesian Idol Season 3 1st - Ihsan Tarore 2nd - Dirly Indonesian Idol Season 4 1st - Rini Wulandari 2nd - Wilson Indonesian Idol Season 5 1st - Aris Runtuwene 2nd - Gisella Anastasia Indonesian Idol Season 6 1st - Igo 2nd - Citra Scholastika Indonesian Idol Season 7 1st - Regina Ivanova 2nd - Kamasean Matthews Indonesian Idol Season 8 1st - Nowela 2nd - Hussein Alatas Indonesian Idol Season 9 1st - Maria Simorangkir 2nd - Ahmad Abdul Indonesian Idol Season 10 1st - Lyodra 2nd - Tiara Season 1-2-7-9-10 are the best IMHO
I saw her singing this song on Indonesian idol 2004..it was amazing....even the judges said that they could not sing this song the way Joy sang it....i am proud of her.
North Sumatra produces a lot of festival or singing competition singers. Many of them are also very famous from time to time :) You know what singing is a part of their cultures. You should visit North Sumatra one Day to personally experience their cultures also their breathtaking scenery :)
yes. diana nasution, rita butar butar, titi dj, joy tobing, eka deli, judika sihotang, sammy simorangkir, maria calista, novita dewi marpaung, and the list goes on....
Emang ya dooonk...!!! Pokoknya, Orang Batak nggak perlu diragukan lagi dalam Olah Vocal yg banyak Meraih Gelar WINNER & RUNNER UP dalam Ajang Pencarian Bakat Vocal di berbagai Event yg diadakan NKRI...!!! Semuanya pasti setuju dong yaaa...!?! I'M PROUD OF YOU "JOY BORU LUMBAN TOBING"
She was the very first Indonesian Idol and yes she is also from North Sumatera (Bataknese). Now she is a gospel singer where most Bataknese are Christian and can sing.
By far, she is the best of idol winners. Her voice is so matured and the confidence and the performances... nailed them all! Its so sad, powerful singers are so underrated here in Indonesia. Maybe there's no suitable song for their voices, unless they sing western songs. Nice reaction 👍
Nephi thank you to make my day.. FINALLY theres someone react her.. she the Best Indonesian Idol n nobody can beat her.!! Gosh if you looking for the best singer on Indonesian Idol you should watch all her performens nephi i tell you.. 😁♥️😇
@@abimanyuabimanyu4486 hehe iya byk yg mengutamakan selera mata drpd selera telinga. Buat aku seh untuk nyanyi, selera telinga dulu baru selera mata,wlpn dlm show itu 1 paket. Tp joy menyikapinya dengan gerakan tubuh yg sgt bagus saat nyanyi sndiri, saat duet, dan dengan kemampuan dance dan gerakan dipanggung yg jago bgt mnrt sy.
@@babyangel.jpg_ Joy jagoan saya dari awal muncul. Cantik, iya. Dan menarik. Cuma sekarang kan muncul penyanyi penyanyi muda yg kadang cuma modal cantik atau trend
Another north sumatra's singer. Thankyou for react her. Singer from north sumatera (has bataknese blood): Judika, Sammy Simorangkir, Lea Simanjuntak, Maria Simorangkir, Novita Dewi Marpaung, Joy Tobing, Rita Butarbutar, Marcel Siahaan, Ello, Indra Sinaga (Lyla band), Narova Morina Sinaga (momo geisha), Doni Sibarani (ada band), Nowela, Lyodra Ginting, Berliana Hutauruk, Titi DJ, Fatin S. Lubis, Andre Taulany (has bataknese blood), and many more.
Indo ayo subscribe chanel ini .. biar lebih banyak penyanyi indonesia diperkenalkan, thanks naphi you reaction rita butar butar., hehe rita indo batak legend singer...
after winning, she had problem with contract policy, and the runner up took her place as a first indonesian idol, and that's impact to her career as a singer and no further contract with other recording label
I always love your reaction so excited 😂. "Yesss!", "Oh My Gosh!"😂😂. Anyway that's your style bro. Just a suggestion from me try to react male singer from Indonesia. Such as Ahmad Abdul when she perform at Indonesian Idol from elimination until spectacular session always giving something different especially his tone. Indonesia also has great male singer if u want to explore. Thank u Nephi.
This song become more grande sang by Joy than original singer kelly clarkson, and Indonesian musicians know what kind song to make it difference from original and make it more love to hear
Please react to Joy feat Delon : The Prayer on Golden Memories Indosiar. They are the very first Idol winner and runner up. They had so good performance even without doing the rehearsal.
yesss... She from north sumatera.... You must React her ft Hetty Koes Endang 2019 performance in golden memories Asia..... Im guarantee you must be crazy... she is the winner in golden memories Asian... song Damai Tapi Gersang... please...
Oh my goshh! She’s from North Sumatra too????? 😱😱😱 I’m done y’all! 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼
Yes, she is from North Sumatra
Please react joy tobing feat hetty koes endang grand final golden memories asia - Damai tapi gersang -
yes she is!
Nephi you can see other her performance now at golden memories asia 2019 and she won that competition .this competition there are Philipina singer too as contestans
React please another joy tobing video with delon the prayer
Because of this video, now I'm a big fan of JOY TOBING!!
Huge different from the original version by Kelly Clarkson ... Joy made it like her own single ... Spectacular ... Well done ...
It's fascinating to remember that she sung that song like one year after it's released. (Kelly won idol : 2002, this song released : 2003, Joy sung this song and won idol : 2004) First winner of each country.
Indonesian Idol Season 1
1st - Joy Tobing
2nd - Delon Thamrin
Indonesian Idol season 2
1st - Mike Mohede (passed away)
2nd - Judika Sihotang
Indonesian Idol Season 3
1st - Ihsan Tarore
2nd - Dirly
Indonesian Idol Season 4
1st - Rini Wulandari
2nd - Wilson
Indonesian Idol Season 5
1st - Aris Runtuwene
2nd - Gisella Anastasia
Indonesian Idol Season 6
1st - Igo
2nd - Citra Scholastika
Indonesian Idol Season 7
1st - Regina Ivanova
2nd - Kamasean Matthews
Indonesian Idol Season 8
1st - Nowela
2nd - Hussein Alatas
Indonesian Idol Season 9
1st - Maria Simorangkir
2nd - Ahmad Abdul
Indonesian Idol Season 10
1st - Lyodra
2nd - Tiara
Season 1-2-7-9-10 are the best IMHO
Yess, I agree with you.. And the worst is season 3,5 and 6.. sorry just my opinion..hehe..
Season 1 is the best. Semua Jawara Jawari yg kehilangan kompetisi besar Asia Bagus bertahun2 tiba tiba dapat panggung.
Langsung serbu Indonesian Idol.
1_2_7_8_9_10
THE BEST WINNER OF INDONESIAN IDOL EVER
I saw her singing this song on Indonesian idol 2004..it was amazing....even the judges said that they could not sing this song the way Joy sang it....i am proud of her.
Joy Tobing Penyanyi kelas International Indonesia .atau macan Festival.the best Singerbof Indonesia.
joy tobing is the winner of Indonesian Idol season 1. u must react Joy tobing in Golden memories 'cinta jangan kau pergi'. Thank u Nephiiii
North Sumatra produces a lot of festival or singing competition singers. Many of them are also very famous from time to time :) You know what singing is a part of their cultures. You should visit North Sumatra one Day to personally experience their cultures also their breathtaking scenery :)
yes. diana nasution, rita butar butar, titi dj, joy tobing, eka deli, judika sihotang, sammy simorangkir, maria calista, novita dewi marpaung, and the list goes on....
She is one of my favourite singer.
Joy tobing and rimar.the best winner idol ever
YOU HAVE TO SEE HER SING "THE PRAYER" SHE IS THE WINNER OF GOLDEN MEMORIES
Up
Come on help me up this comment me so that he can give reaction for Joy tobing
Up.
Yes, it's absolutely recommended
Yes, This is the Link ua-cam.com/video/9qpKlYaswE0/v-deo.html
she became a gospel singer now...she is so powerful ...
Mungkin ini teknik vokal terbaik yang pernah tampil di Indonesian Idol. Luar biasa.
SETUJUUUU
Emang ya dooonk...!!!
Pokoknya, Orang Batak nggak perlu diragukan lagi dalam Olah Vocal yg banyak Meraih Gelar WINNER & RUNNER UP dalam Ajang Pencarian Bakat Vocal di berbagai Event yg diadakan NKRI...!!!
Semuanya pasti setuju dong yaaa...!?!
I'M PROUD OF YOU "JOY BORU LUMBAN TOBING"
Setuju bgt , joy adalah Juara terbaik semua idol
Betul. Gk bosan2 gw dengar ni ....
ini Tehnik Tinggi !
Joy Tobing is the best Singer of Indonedia.
She was the very first Indonesian Idol and yes she is also from North Sumatera (Bataknese). Now she is a gospel singer where most Bataknese are Christian and can sing.
Finally react to joy tobing, thanks nephi.....she is the one. Proud to her, and proud to north sumatera.
And you know she's the one and only in INDONESIA, and we're never forget even one seconds of her moments... She always doneee it all....
Joy tobing is the winner of Indonesian idol season 1 and Golden memories Asia
Wkeksk juseeeee keren bangat😁
By far, she is the best of idol winners. Her voice is so matured and the confidence and the performances... nailed them all! Its so sad, powerful singers are so underrated here in Indonesia. Maybe there's no suitable song for their voices, unless they sing western songs. Nice reaction 👍
Her performances in Golden Memories are great too~ she's one of my fav singers~ thank you for your reaction 🙏
Wowwww....i've been waiting so long for ur reaction Joy Tobing. Wow..She killed that song, great singer. Thank you.....
Joy Tobing from the 1st Indonesian Idol.. I love Joy's voice 👏🏻👏🏻❤️😍
She's from North Sumatra..😎👍
Nephi thank you to make my day..
FINALLY theres someone react her.. she the Best Indonesian Idol n nobody can beat her.!! Gosh if you looking for the best singer on Indonesian Idol you should watch all her performens nephi i tell you.. 😁♥️😇
She also Bataknese. 😍
pipang man help me to share Damai tapi gersang. Joy ft Hetty yo nephi.... Please
Her duet with Delon The Prayer one of the best duet in Indonesian Idol history
Joy Tobing is one of the best singer in Indonesia and the best Indonesian Idol until now, 2020.
Setuju banget
Nah ini fakta. Secara kualitas vokal yaa... (Netizen Indo nanti bandinginnya ke outfit atau fisik lagi 🤣)
@@abimanyuabimanyu4486 hehe iya byk yg mengutamakan selera mata drpd selera telinga. Buat aku seh untuk nyanyi, selera telinga dulu baru selera mata,wlpn dlm show itu 1 paket. Tp joy menyikapinya dengan gerakan tubuh yg sgt bagus saat nyanyi sndiri, saat duet, dan dengan kemampuan dance dan gerakan dipanggung yg jago bgt mnrt sy.
@@abimanyuabimanyu4486 Lah joy juga cantik kok
@@babyangel.jpg_ Joy jagoan saya dari awal muncul. Cantik, iya. Dan menarik. Cuma sekarang kan muncul penyanyi penyanyi muda yg kadang cuma modal cantik atau trend
pls react Joy Tobing and Delon - The Prayer. they are the winner and 1st runner up Indonesian Idol 1st season 2004
Up
Up
Up
Up
Up
Indonesian idol has set the International standard since 2004 until 2020
No,until 2021
Next please Maria Calista. She's also from North Sumatera and have amazing vocal too 🙏
Yes,agree
Yes please
B ajah
up up up
Ok om falen
Always love your reaction
Thanks bro...!!! My request has been reacted ...awesome!!!!!😂💪💪❤👌👏👏
Just Take a look at Clarissa Dewi Singing same song At Xfactor Indonesia Judge's Home editions. 👍☝️
Yes,Agree
Yes plzzz and Clarissa Dewi audition too, chandelier
Joy#1
Yaah.... Finally... Joy Tobing
She is like Indonesian Kelly Clarkson
this is my req,,thank u
I want you see her sing "the prayer" at golden memories show.. i like your reaksion... well done👍👍👍👌
Joy tobing is my idol forever.. Tks nephi
Another north sumatra's singer. Thankyou for react her.
Singer from north sumatera (has bataknese blood): Judika, Sammy Simorangkir, Lea Simanjuntak, Maria Simorangkir, Novita Dewi Marpaung, Joy Tobing, Rita Butarbutar, Marcel Siahaan, Ello, Indra Sinaga (Lyla band), Narova Morina Sinaga (momo geisha), Doni Sibarani (ada band), Nowela, Lyodra Ginting, Berliana Hutauruk, Titi DJ, Fatin S. Lubis, Andre Taulany (has bataknese blood), and many more.
nonton dahsyadnya Joy Tobing, bersama semangatnya Nephi, Asyikkkk...
Thankyouuuu
Plis reaction Joy Tobing ft Delon .. The prayer .. Final Indonesian Idol..
Up
Up
Up
Up
Up
Up up up
up
Up
Finally you react to her, she's the one of the best singer from North Sumatera and the winner of 1st Indonesian Idol
I love Joy Tobing
I think she’s the best so far
For me she is the best Indonesian idol ever together with mike and judika
Joy Tobing 💓💓💓💓
Thanks Nephi.. 👍..
Joy Tobing the best Dinger of Indonesia until right now on. Bravo joy Tobing.
Many Monster of festival from North Sumatera
Joy Tobing winner Indonesia idol 1
I love Joy Tobing..
Indo ayo subscribe chanel ini .. biar lebih banyak penyanyi indonesia diperkenalkan, thanks naphi you reaction rita butar butar., hehe rita indo batak legend singer...
Still the best WINNER Indonesian Idol until now
Finally my Idol. Thnk U so much Nephi...... Please reaction too Novita Dewi and Jamhine Douglas "Helo"
Indonesia always out of the box
Dr semua penampilan peserta indonesian idol dr semua jaman ini pling bombastis n trus maria never enaugh n kmudian lyodra n judyka prayer....
She was also competing with other Idols winner from Southeast Asia, included Philippines and also Jaclyn Victor from Malaysia at that time.
Kompetisi apa? Saya baru tau
No she wasnt. Mike Mohede was.
after winning, she had problem with contract policy, and the runner up took her place as a first indonesian idol, and that's impact to her career as a singer and no further contract with other recording label
So proud of you
Joy tobing dan Hetty koes endang di Golden Memories Asia....itu spektakuler
She is The WINNER of first INDONESIAN IDOL
Nephi lama" penasaran sama penyanyi batak tp ngak papa karena penyanyi batak ( sumatra utara ) suaranya bagus" god lack ya nephi semoga terberkati
Yessss!!!!!!
Suara penyanyi indonesia memang gk di ragukan lagi.. Klo di asia tenggara suara terbaik indonesia dan philipines
She is the winner of the first Indonesian Idol
Amazing singer.
Nothing to say.., U'r my fav bro 👍🙏👍
I always love your reaction so excited 😂. "Yesss!", "Oh My Gosh!"😂😂. Anyway that's your style bro. Just a suggestion from me try to react male singer from Indonesia. Such as Ahmad Abdul when she perform at Indonesian Idol from elimination until spectacular session always giving something different especially his tone. Indonesia also has great male singer if u want to explore. Thank u Nephi.
Ini lah penampilan yang paling specta seluruh penyanyi indonesia.
Joy Tobing it's a Whitney Houston Indonesia 💪🏾💪🏾 💕💕💕
lebay gak jg...
Yes she is the first Indonesia idol of the first season
Yeeessss nephy you made it!!! God bless u
Halo nephi joy tobing from sumatera Utara...
Joyyyyyyyyyyy 😍😍😍😍👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍👍🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Joy legend Indonesia Idol. She is the best winner until now
OhmyGod! This is epic!!!
She full of soul..
Proud of u north sumatera
Yes she is the first of indonesian idol winner (2004)
I like song semua karena cinta live performance
Finnaly!!!! God bless u nephy
This song become more grande sang by Joy than original singer kelly clarkson, and Indonesian musicians know what kind song to make it difference from original and make it more love to hear
Yyyyaaaasss She is JOY TOBING IDOL SEASON 1 😆
react, joy tobing feat hetty koesendang. De golden memori Indosiar
Whattt....it is awesomè
endless love by her is good too to react
She is the winner of indonesian idol season 1
I like you reaction 🔥
Thanks bro 😍
Emang Joy Tobing full power 😍
1st winner Indonesian Idol in 2004
Please react to Joy feat Delon : The Prayer on Golden Memories Indosiar. They are the very first Idol winner and runner up. They had so good performance even without doing the rehearsal.
Joy tobing juara pertama indonesia idol asal medan
Another north Sumatera singer, yeayyyy🤗
More than half of Indonesian Idol winners are related to North Sumatera.
No.1, 3, 5, 8, 9 the last one no.10 Lyodra.
yesss... She from north sumatera.... You must React her ft Hetty Koes Endang 2019 performance in golden memories Asia..... Im guarantee you must be crazy... she is the winner in golden memories Asian... song Damai Tapi Gersang... please...
You must watch joy tobing feat hetty koesendang
now that's the real winner quality.
NEPHI, pse react Joy tobing - Seandainya aku punya sayap