ScienceCasts: Colliding Atmospheres - Mars vs Comet Siding Spring

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @Thermospecialist
    @Thermospecialist 10 років тому +1

    I have my own theory about the density of planet atmospeheres, which explains why Titan and Venus have far denser atmospheres than what their own gravity can account for. The mechanism behind must be that those planets formed while being surrounded by a massive gas cloud. While part of it initially was attracted by the planet's own gravity, the gas density around the planet's surface increased and by that its own gravity, attracting the planet (mind Newton's gravity law, containing the product of two masses). This became a snowball-effect, by which so much mass of gas was collected, fhat the product of gas and planet masses created enough gravity to form a very dense and stable atmosphere.
    Mind, that this is only atmosphere-to-planet gravity, not the total gravity, that hardly changes, beause the planet's mass is far greater than the atmospheric mass.
    For Mars there was too little gas around, so an initially not dense enough atmosphere faded away into space during millions of years, and what remained is mainly due to the planet's own gravity. Mars is too far away from the Sun that solar wind could have had the main impact - Venus is the prove of that (apart from the effects of a magnetic field).
    Earth was not surrounded by enough gas to form a super dense atmosphere, whilte Titan and Venus were. Nonethless, also Earth's atmosphere creates its own extra gravity to remain as a stable one. In other words, a planet's own gravity is not a measure for its atmosphere's density. Titan is the prove of that, having less gravity than our moon, but an atmosphere that is five times denser than Earth's.

  •  10 років тому

    Ojalá pudieran hacer la transmisión en vivo.

  • @vegassims7
    @vegassims7 10 років тому +1

    This is so very exciting for those of us on earth that study astrophysics. I am truly amazed at how close this comet is coming to the surface of the planet mars. There might be some interaction, but IMAGINE the view from the surface of Mars!!! This giant comet covering the entire length of the sky from horizon to horizon is going to be most impressive. It will be interesting to see what the robot rovers, opportunity and curiosity will see from the ground level.
    Crossing fingers that this will be a grand show.

  • @beatrizmartino680
    @beatrizmartino680 10 років тому

    Les deseo un Gran Exito en la observacion del Cometa, y Q/nos puedan contar muchas novedades!!!!

  • @SapaHollidaySaparonia
    @SapaHollidaySaparonia 10 років тому

    Amazing that when Velikovsky wrote about comets colliding with Mars he was astrocised, and still is by the scientific community

  • @RobertAnthonyPitera
    @RobertAnthonyPitera 10 років тому

    Such an amazing, once in a lifetime event. Not sure why this isn't making the traditional mass media but I'm really excited to see what the effects are and glad that NASA was able to position themselves to record such important data.

  • @KevinHurleyDr
    @KevinHurleyDr 10 років тому

    @larry silver and @mike wade. The way to make progress in science is not to call competing theories BS. You take current observations, construct or find a theory that is consistent with as many of them as possible then use that theory to make predictions that differ from the competing theories in some given scenario and then observe and see which theory was correct. The "losing" theory is either abandoned as inconsistent or modified to take account of the new data and then used to make new predictions to test it.
    Please cite testable predictions for this encounter using either the electric universe or dirty snowball theory and then lets see which one stands up to observation.
    The argument should not be phrased like"your theory is BS" but more like: "your theory predicted aurora and we didn't see any" or "your theory predicted planet-wide meteor showers but we didnt see any"

  • @CitediTeleseries
    @CitediTeleseries 10 років тому

    Interesante simulación virtual, gracias a estas recreaciones virtuales se puede reflexionar acerca de estos acontecimientos y sus posibles daños

  • @serbiangamer
    @serbiangamer 10 років тому

    19. October 2014 Comet will fly near to Mars and it will maybe cause some effects on that planet.
    Other than that, some nice 3D animations are to be seen in this video, and they are very well done.

  • @DARSHANCHANDEKAR
    @DARSHANCHANDEKAR 10 років тому

    i like the way devastated magnetic field is shown here... also i see comet or asteroids if they have ice and water too can trigger the martian environment one day or we may push/hurl one towards Mars to trigger Martian Atmosphere into a habitable one..

  • @lightsidemaster
    @lightsidemaster 10 років тому +1

    I wish I could be on Mars when this happens

  • @makotomikami
    @makotomikami 10 років тому +5

    Maven Blackbriar funded this? D:

  • @brasildocara
    @brasildocara 10 років тому

    I have a Question::: If here in earth we have the strongests ManMade magnets several times more powerful than the earths magnet... is it possible (if we could take to mars two of these) to create an earth's like magnetic field?

  • @Axterrix
    @Axterrix 10 років тому

    Thank you!

  • @OOOMIXZPIXTZKOOL
    @OOOMIXZPIXTZKOOL 10 років тому

    17 days to go until 19th Oct.

  • @ronjackson7365
    @ronjackson7365 10 років тому +1

    @ 0:32 "Coment" instead of "comet" ??? Lol

  • @FollowingTheSon
    @FollowingTheSon 10 років тому

    Question for NASA: If Comet Siding Spring is that close to Mars atmosphere, will the gravitational pull between the two bodies change the direction of the comet?

  • @AndiYagudayevalt
    @AndiYagudayevalt 10 років тому

    this always happen, the Earth and most of the planets are within the outer atmosphere of the sun, which causes the Earth Auroras when the sun unleashes it's flares.

  • @teresadelatorreeijo3403
    @teresadelatorreeijo3403 10 років тому

    mi pensamiento en este momento es de admiración hacia la nasa y toda la investigación del espacio

  • @moiseschamorro4999
    @moiseschamorro4999 10 років тому

    Excelente información con relación al recorrido de este cuerpo celeste, gracias a la NASA y a su investigación tenemos conocimiento de los avances de la ciencia.

  • @raulcastro4133
    @raulcastro4133 10 років тому +1

    Hola saludos cariñosos para todos mis amigos dios los bendiga hoy y siempre

  • @beatrizmartino680
    @beatrizmartino680 10 років тому

    Gracias, interesantisimo

  • @theguy4u7773
    @theguy4u7773 10 років тому

    can debris from the impact move to EARTH?

  • @brasildocara
    @brasildocara 10 років тому

    Cool!!! boy. you should deviate rocks in order they crush on mars, get more mass and more gravity and do not leave escape water.

  • @williamcousert5110
    @williamcousert5110 10 років тому

    How would a direct impact by Comet Sliding Spring affect Mars?

  • @iamateurg
    @iamateurg 9 років тому

    It is about cosmos.It is about the life planet ,our homeland. Just take care of it. When we expand our scope enough, we could see more accommodation to our original life.Thanks to NASA!!

  • @scottcorrigan4396
    @scottcorrigan4396 10 років тому

    WELL??? It's way past time; 10/22. How did it look? What did we learn? Care to make a video as good as this promo?

  • @kencassyh
    @kencassyh 10 років тому

    Why don't you understand when mars lost it's spinning molten core, do to the largest volcano in this solar system constantly blowing out molten lava. Mars spinning core stooped do to the loss of the lubricating magma, and it's magnetic's left and the atmosphere blue away.

  • @NJJ96
    @NJJ96 10 років тому

    this beat be molten, molten like lava yes i got that fire

  • @raularredondonava5535
    @raularredondonava5535 10 років тому

    Bravo for NASA, I´m surprice for the development of this proyect.

  • @OverlordZephyros
    @OverlordZephyros 10 років тому +1

    Too bad it wont REALLY collide ... Boom!! a even better show ... and who knows maybe it will form a lake and be used for the first colonists.

  • @hankscorpio3851
    @hankscorpio3851 10 років тому

    Redirect the comet to hit mars. Maybe get enough of them together and rebuild Mars' atmosphere. We are going to over populate this planet, good to have a backup.

  • @ashleylaw
    @ashleylaw 10 років тому

    NASA still punting out the clockwork model to continue to support the creation story (Big Bang - which big bang they never say).
    The Universe is Electric.

  • @seeingatruth
    @seeingatruth 10 років тому

    LOL, I guess that gigantic gash along Mars side has nothing to do with a catastrophe? LOL, this is why I can only take these spaced out scientists with a big grain of salt.

  • @larrysilver9866
    @larrysilver9866 10 років тому +4

    I think the dirty snowball concept is such b.s. It's Electric yo. Look it up at Thunderbolts.info.

    • @01wadder
      @01wadder 10 років тому +3

      The electric universe is total BS!!!

    • @FollowingTheSon
      @FollowingTheSon 10 років тому +1

      mike wade
      The sun has more in common with a light bulb than it does molten lava! Why do you think CME's shut down the power grid? Electric universe is real!

    • @apopheniacMCMLXXXIX
      @apopheniacMCMLXXXIX 10 років тому +3

      Syncr0sity There isn't a word for how confused you are.

    • @FollowingTheSon
      @FollowingTheSon 10 років тому +1

      Lord Xenu
      Yes Lord Xenu, I'm confused Lord Xenu, that was a great comment Lord Xenu. (SIC) "Electric Universe" agrees with me. Google it!

    • @01wadder
      @01wadder 10 років тому +3

      Syncr0sity The sun isn't molten lava you moron it's plasma! and the idea of the E universe is still flawed.

  • @miskee11
    @miskee11 10 років тому +2

    ROFL THE DUDES NAME IS BRAIN!!!!!! AND HE WORKS AT FRICKIN NASA!! LOL
    but yeah cool

  • @urdum2
    @urdum2 10 років тому

    We used to live on mars... And had to move to earth ... Cause we caused all the co2.....and now we are doing the same thing to this planet but no where to go this time... IMHO

    • @serbiangamer
      @serbiangamer 10 років тому

      how do you know that?

    • @Zlatnikmk
      @Zlatnikmk 10 років тому

      The god told him/her! :D :P

    • @larrysilver9866
      @larrysilver9866 10 років тому +1

      Lmao

    • @StonesDunedin
      @StonesDunedin 10 років тому

      urdum2 .. Mars doesn’t have strong magnetic fields to help protect the planet. Therefore the solar wind stripped it of gases like hydrogen, helium, and oxygen ions, leaving the higher-mass molecules like carbon dioxide. The atmosphere of Mars has about 96% CO2. .... Earth's atmosphere has about 400 parts per million of CO2. That's only 0.04% of the atmosphere. (By the way, CO2 levels were many times that percentage in the distant past.) .. Anyway, humans do not "cause" or "make" all of the CO2. The carbon and oxygen atoms are already on Earth as part of the 'Carbon Cycle'. Also, CO2 is an essential part of photosynthesis. Life on Earth cannot exist without it.

  • @jaimecoronado7226
    @jaimecoronado7226 10 років тому

    Todo lo que. La NASA haga en sus intentos de descubrir, y de dar explicaciones a las cosas que Dios padre hace, nunca lo aclararán, porque su sabiduría es corta, divisoria, y limitada

  • @jeremiecroussette6323
    @jeremiecroussette6323 10 років тому

    How to make things seems boring, thank you NASA and RIP, that's why you don't get many money from the government...

  • @paulstevenson789
    @paulstevenson789 10 років тому

    Things that the average mug tax payer may want to know would be things like:
    Will the comet be visible from Earth with the naked eye or is it worth, for this once in a Million year event, to pop out and buy some cheap binoculars etc
    I remember with disgust and deep disappointment when the shoemaker Levi comet event was being (not) televised and seeing a large group of overfunded technocrats intently looking into their
    personal monitors and then watching their fat little bodies bear hugging each other. Huzzar!!! We, the cork on the fork taxpayes then got to see some computer animations of what had just taken place. A Resounding Hurrah!!!
    You never know, if the comet does hit Mars we may all get a light show that will indeed be eye opening! Pizar Power and further more Shazam!

  • @ravishekaranm3263
    @ravishekaranm3263 10 років тому

    Nasa excellent space

  • @smarv81
    @smarv81 10 років тому

    FIRST!