i feel completely desensitized to the titans now since we know their origin and the extent of their power, thats part of the reason the fourth season didn't compare to one through three. sure the politics were entertaining, but that was what carried season four, and now we're overly familiar with that as well. I don't know what is left to amaze us in a genre based almost entirely on the initial suspense and fear it instills.
@@xum0007I think that’s what would make it interesting, they don’t have the same powers we’re used to seeing from the main anime, regular titans instill pure despair in the characters.
The story indicates that there is something about Kuklo which makes him a little superhuman He heals super abnormally fast Has an uncanny sense of direction and hearing
i think the "experiments" used to create the ackerman bloodline may have been similar to what happened with kuklo.. like the titan genes had somehow been absorbed by a pregnant woman and the offspring carried them.. just some food for thought 😄
Since the MCs are so young and they were only 57 years before the main story, it begs the question if they’re still alive as elderly or passed away shortly before the attack on the wall, and who their descendants might be.
I really loved Before The Fall, and it really needs to be animated. It's crazy good. It's not about titan-shifting or anything, it's just amazing as fuck and manages to really fill in the details that we never got about what life was like on Paradise and how things came to be.
if they do animate it tho wit studio needs to do it the scenes would look so fluid i remember reading before the fall years ago and playing it was animated one day
I was thinking this - a great read, great characters - I reckon that this will be made into an anime. After all, it's really about the $$$$$$ and AOT fans will love this
Before the Fall is a perfect example of early AOT’s appeal. That being the scariness and absurdity of the world in AOT. Which makes me glad it was made because AOT goes a lot grander than that and focuses a lot more on its themes and message and drama than the level of its absurdity.
@@KingBullet123Isn't the story supposed to be happening 55 years before the fall of the walls ? an 18 year old then would be 73 by the time wall maria fell and 82 by the time of the rumbling.
I think the walls existed even longer than over 100 years. I know the narrator at the beginning said the walls were created a 100 years ago but keep in mind that the narrator is Mikasa who doesn't know the truth of the world at the time and only knows the lie fed to them by king fritz.
Hey man I see youre a big fan of AOT and is willing to explore fan projects that expand on the lore, Im one of those myself and I have some recommendations of works that I think youd like: 1. "The Illustrated guide to the Glorious Walled Cities" - a travel guide for the locations in the walls written 25 years before The Breach, it adds to the worldbuilding in the walls pre-breach and explain things like where the special-bred horses come from, and the special traits and trades of each district along with a reveal at the end. 2. "We Are The Nine" - a masterfully written fanfic that not only talks in detail about things that werent mentioned in the main story such as Kruger's backstory and Grisha's daily struggles, it also talks about the entire history of the Eldian Empire, from how they discovered how inheriting titans work, to the first shifters of each titans, to how the empire created the Ackermanns, its a long read but I assure you its good quality. Hopefully you like these works i mentioned and maaaaaaybe make videos about them because frankly more people should see these hidden gems.
Sharle (and by extension Kuklo) were upper class and would not stick around in Shiganshina. That's if Kuklo even got to have a baby with her, he probably just got eaten by a Titan on one of the missions.
@@codemancz798 well this is not a cannon story, it's entirely fan made so even if they author of this spin off said they were, they wouldn't be in the main series.
Hope they animate Before the Wall I always wondered who invented the ODM gear it’s never mention nor how it’s made or the swords they use it’s never mention how they are made either a lot of things could be answered with this prequel series
I want to see a story based around the attack Titian and its users plus how the attack titan users managed to stay hidden for 100 years since the fall of the Eldian empire. where all the others were captured.
Oh my God someone else who knows about Before the Fall? I was starting to think I was the only person who's ever read this, I love Kuklo and Sharle so much. I really wish more people would read this.
If there ever is more Attack On Titan media animated, it should be as a series of OVAs instead of a wide-released TV series. Follow the example of Lost Girls and No Regrets, making them world-building flavor text instead of mandatory viewing. Since the mainline series is over now, these stories won’t be as popular; but with enough care, time and attention from a select team of artists and animators, they can be a true passion project that will reach the audience that wants them the most.
I would like it to be this way, when the main aot ends, they show us that Armin has been succesful in his negotiations with the paradis military, and then a random guy comes recognises them asks for them to come with them, that random guy is none other than old kuklo(I wish), and then it ends off in a cliffhangar for a new season, before the fall.
The titan 'Ogre was TERRIFYING and wasn't a dumb titan.. he thought and calculated.. throwing the heds of victims back into the wall to taunt humans.. makes you wonder
Maybe this guy is the father of Eren Kruger or maybe a long-lost relative? since I think the anime didn't mention who's the predecessor that gave him the Attack Titan's powers. Pretty interesting to see this theory for Kuklo's connection to the main series.
"Official" not really, theres a lot and I mean A LOT of plot holes and things that weren't possible in the main series that are or vise versa, things that can't happen here that happen in the main series. so while it's not really canon, it's still pretty good. edit: the Survey Corps didn't exist during this time for example.
You do realize it got concluded before the original manga did right? And to answer your question, no it doesn't have any evidence of a possible AOE since this took place 50 years before the fall of shiganshina
@@deja-vuatfirstsight7020 that isn’t relevant as the soundtrack from all the in season 1 already foreshadowed the ending an future plot points in the story anyway. The time period isn’t even relevant either.
@@DT25659 what does the S1 OST have to do with the manga prequel?, unless the prequel gets an adaptation (-which very likely won't happen btw) it has absolutely nothing to do with the S1 OST
Next Part II
ua-cam.com/video/g2ZXm9eecA8/v-deo.html&lc=UgxNlgTL_OqnFokrxSR4AaABAg&ab_channel=KingBullet
a whole year later what took so dam long...
THIS should be the sequel anime once main AOT gets done this year.
The birth of the ODM gear is too special to not be animated.
totally agree... th the anime will, however need more titan hunting.. somehow
Yeahhhh I was searching who came up with it. If it was even mentioned in the manga...
*prequel
i feel completely desensitized to the titans now since we know their origin and the extent of their power, thats part of the reason the fourth season didn't compare to one through three. sure the politics were entertaining, but that was what carried season four, and now we're overly familiar with that as well. I don't know what is left to amaze us in a genre based almost entirely on the initial suspense and fear it instills.
@@xum0007I think that’s what would make it interesting, they don’t have the same powers we’re used to seeing from the main anime, regular titans instill pure despair in the characters.
Before the Fall is some incredibly underrated Attack on Titan spin off media I'd like to see it animated one day
It definitely needs an animation piece, Kuklo and his times are too great for it to not happen
It would give early AOT vibes, when titans were actually scary...
i like eren more but kuklo would be a pretty cool chapter
@@NM-ej3xw Pure Titans in Before The Fall make the main series ones look family-friendly.
How bout a spin off about the great titan war?, it'll be cooler and show the dark past between eldians and marleyans
So crazy this shit dropped a decade ago and I had no idea. It makes more sense why I don't hear more ppl talking about it now tho
The story indicates that there is something about Kuklo which makes him a little superhuman
He heals super abnormally fast
Has an uncanny sense of direction and hearing
i think the "experiments" used to create the ackerman bloodline may have been similar to what happened with kuklo.. like the titan genes had somehow been absorbed by a pregnant woman and the offspring carried them.. just some food for thought 😄
Miche and Sasha also have those uncanny senses. He could be an Ackerman, as they seem to heal very fast.
Ackerman come to mind
He’s an Ackerman
@@own4801that’s bcuz they’re chad farmers
Since the MCs are so young and they were only 57 years before the main story, it begs the question if they’re still alive as elderly or passed away shortly before the attack on the wall, and who their descendants might be.
if you go to the aot wiki and search each character scroll down to status and it says alive
@SordidusFellatio *Jean boy*
I really loved Before The Fall, and it really needs to be animated. It's crazy good. It's not about titan-shifting or anything, it's just amazing as fuck and manages to really fill in the details that we never got about what life was like on Paradise and how things came to be.
Yeah and it’s cool how the eldians have that sword design and then 85 years later they gave it two triggers for odm
@@emmanuelmacias6959looks like they still have that sword design on the cadet corp insignia
if they do animate it tho wit studio needs to do it the scenes would look so fluid i remember reading before the fall years ago and playing it was animated one day
Currently reading Before the fall myself if they don’t make it into an anime than they will have missed a great opportunity
I was thinking this - a great read, great characters - I reckon that this will be made into an anime. After all, it's really about the $$$$$$ and AOT fans will love this
If we do get it animated we probably won’t see it until 2026 or something with the way they did us dirty with the last episodes 🤣🤣💀🙏🏾
Where to read?
Ogar is genuinely scary to look at for me. I would love for this to be animated a as an OVA or something
I agree. He was terrifying
ogre funnily enough had brains... he thought
Makes you wonder.
Ogre is literally a abnormal titan, when i was first reading i thought he was just fat (like Mammon) but no hes more muscular than eren's attack titan
9:27 You literally can't tell me that these two aren't inspired by guts and griffith💀
literally bro💀
that's what I'm saying 😭😭
i always wondered what kuklo would think of the events in aot as an old man if he is still alive at that time
AOT is a type of series who would hv already shown old kuklo..... we fans just didnt recognize him
I need an fanart or fanfic of Eren and Historia meeting old Kuklo and Sharle!
@@PedroLucas-mg5je Why will historia meet him 🤔
Isnt she queen of paradi
@@rahulverma8774 They could've both visited Kuklo and Sharle during their day-breaks off-screen!
Isayama: “This is my main character”
Eren whispered: “ Eren is your main character”
Isayama: “ Eren is my main character”
😂
Before the Fall is a perfect example of early AOT’s appeal. That being the scariness and absurdity of the world in AOT. Which makes me glad it was made because AOT goes a lot grander than that and focuses a lot more on its themes and message and drama than the level of its absurdity.
Just finished reading this spin off. Really good and I was not expecting a satisfying ending.
Where can i read it online
@@codgamez4125 holy- sry I didn’t get the notification until now. You can find the manga on mangasee
I wonder if these characters lived long enough to hear Eren’s telepathic message as he starts the Rumbling.
Probably not since they’d have to be well over a 100 years old
@@KingBullet123Isn't the story supposed to be happening 55 years before the fall of the walls ? an 18 year old then would be 73 by the time wall maria fell and 82 by the time of the rumbling.
I think the walls existed even longer than over 100 years. I know the narrator at the beginning said the walls were created a 100 years ago but keep in mind that the narrator is Mikasa who doesn't know the truth of the world at the time and only knows the lie fed to them by king fritz.
Whoever held the Attack Titan most definitely would have.
Hey man I see youre a big fan of AOT and is willing to explore fan projects that expand on the lore, Im one of those myself and I have some recommendations of works that I think youd like:
1. "The Illustrated guide to the Glorious Walled Cities" - a travel guide for the locations in the walls written 25 years before The Breach, it adds to the worldbuilding in the walls pre-breach and explain things like where the special-bred horses come from, and the special traits and trades of each district along with a reveal at the end.
2. "We Are The Nine" - a masterfully written fanfic that not only talks in detail about things that werent mentioned in the main story such as Kruger's backstory and Grisha's daily struggles, it also talks about the entire history of the Eldian Empire, from how they discovered how inheriting titans work, to the first shifters of each titans, to how the empire created the Ackermanns, its a long read but I assure you its good quality.
Hopefully you like these works i mentioned and maaaaaaybe make videos about them because frankly more people should see these hidden gems.
Man I hope this series gets an anime adaptation
My belief is that Eren's mom is a descendant of the MC and the girl.
Illogical unfortunately.
Sharle (and by extension Kuklo) were upper class and would not stick around in Shiganshina. That's if Kuklo even got to have a baby with her, he probably just got eaten by a Titan on one of the missions.
@@codemancz798 well this is not a cannon story, it's entirely fan made so even if they author of this spin off said they were, they wouldn't be in the main series.
@@hawks7111 Iceburst stones appeared in this before the main manga.
@@hawks7111Technically, he said they won't be in the main series. As an anime, he didn't deny and said that they weren't cannon.
Gun fact: Around this time ymir became a titan and roamed the walllllllllllllss
Oh yeah that true
@@KingBullet123 YOU REPLIED OMG😭
Hope they animate Before the Wall I always wondered who invented the ODM gear it’s never mention nor how it’s made or the swords they use it’s never mention how they are made either a lot of things could be answered with this prequel series
i enjoyed all the twists and turns they put into what could have been a straightforward origins story..
He deserves more material
Good video man keep it up 👍
I want to see a story based around the attack Titian and its users plus how the attack titan users managed to stay hidden for 100 years since the fall of the Eldian empire. where all the others were captured.
Oh my God someone else who knows about Before the Fall?
I was starting to think I was the only person who's ever read this, I love Kuklo and Sharle so much. I really wish more people would read this.
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO IS TALKING AB BEFORE THE FALL
If there ever is more Attack On Titan media animated, it should be as a series of OVAs instead of a wide-released TV series. Follow the example of Lost Girls and No Regrets, making them world-building flavor text instead of mandatory viewing. Since the mainline series is over now, these stories won’t be as popular; but with enough care, time and attention from a select team of artists and animators, they can be a true passion project that will reach the audience that wants them the most.
a lot of this makes me think he's just like eren but if he chose to protect others from what he experienced rather than taking it out on the world.
I loved it, make another part.
The reason why these titans looks so unique because they were made by the king who made the walls
Bruh Kuklo can beat the shit out of Founding Eren with his bare hands.
Imagine entering this time period and spoiling the ending of AOT for these characters.
"Tatakae"
70 years before the Fall in 845, which means the prequel is set in the year around 775
Its actually 55 years before the (2nd) fall of shiganshina, 70 years is during kukuro's birth
The story was good read it a year ago I hope it gets animated one day
well AOT is about to end... and people like money so...
I would like it to be this way, when the main aot ends, they show us that Armin has been succesful in his negotiations with the paradis military, and then a random guy comes recognises them asks for them to come with them, that random guy is none other than old kuklo(I wish), and then it ends off in a cliffhangar for a new season, before the fall.
YESS AND THEN ITS CALLED AFTER THE FALL : THE AFTERMATH OMGGGGG
@@Skotchaintsimp123 cringe
Would be really cool if we get an anime show based on this.
The art is amazing. And the story is really great
How do titans keep their teeth white 😳
They bite but they don't grind their food for some reason.
Connie brushes them
They use listerene advnaced white
@@KingBullet123 LMAO
Colgate bruh
Now I start to think kuklo is the mirror man
the mirror man? is he the guy from lost girls??
@@aalvarooyeah but I don’t think he’s the mirror man but I wonder who their kids are
This is a solid prequel
Great enemies and great atmosphere
The titan 'Ogre was TERRIFYING and wasn't a dumb titan.. he thought and calculated.. throwing the heds of victims back into the wall to taunt humans..
makes you wonder
@@Annie1962might’ve been the armoured titan
@@london8615i think its more that ogre was a person turned into a mindless by the founder to make the story seem real
Forgot this existed tbh, im glad it’s actually getting some recognition
Great vid, if I had some constructive criticism, you talk a little fast. Great work!
"All I ever wanted to do was save your life, I never wanted to grab the knife, I swear" - Rumbling
Now that aot is over wonder if they will make prequel content
If this gets animated, Angel will immediately be the most simped for character in AOT
just finished this yesterday, it was a fun read..
crazy how many people don’t know about this..
I remember starting this manga awhile back but I never finished it. I remember enjoying it quite a bit not sure if the quality stayed good though.
Am i the only one that doesn't know that there is a "Before The Fall" version
same
Some heat
i remember reading this
was really good
So based for using the westworld OST, I was listening to some bangers just moments ago ;D
great spin ofd, although one thing i dont really like about it, is how the ending was so rushed
Underrated story or series
why it's not animated series yet?
I will do anything to see this to be animated ✊
So glad I gave before the fall a chance.
hope this gets made and maybe even going further back
Why am I just now finding out about this and why isn't it animated???????
kuklo is one of my favourite anime husbandos 💕💕🙏🏻🙏🏻
the outtro music bro
Animate this asap cause I ain’t satisfied yet
pre stuff of aot kinda want to see what the world look like under the titan shifters control before king frietz screwed up big time lol.
Much better than eren(139)
lol can’t complain
fr
Thank you!!!
the main character reminds me of Guts in a way
defo inspired by him, practically look the same + similarities in stories
@@london8615 yup
Bro just spoiled me with Berserk out of nowhere
They need a 16th century marley vs eldia before the fall
Eren's drive to be free would make total sense if he was Kuklo's reincarnation.
Was that a Peter Dinklage titan?
me when the video started: tetsuo no tama giseiginoshowmay tsureanecaba
I hope isayama make another story before eren era like ymir
Maybe this guy is the father of
Eren Kruger or maybe a long-lost
relative? since I think the anime
didn't mention who's the
predecessor that gave him the
Attack Titan's powers. Pretty
interesting to see this theory for
Kuklo's connection to the main
series.
How would Kruger be on Marley though?
DID I HEARD SOMEONE NAMED DARIO?
Yeah Sharle’s father
i rember reading this it was dope
The Errand lore goes deep ngl
the main character could have been good for the main story of AOT. Cause the way they ended it, seems like... a "filler" way to end an arc
Is the ending we get in the anime the original ending or the changed one. I prefer the original, I think it fits the tone and story.
It's basically the same..
It's the same, except for Armin and Eren's convo in the paths slightly altered to make more sense
Imagine if the Ogre gains either the Armored Titan or Attack Titan.
"Official" not really, theres a lot and I mean A LOT of plot holes and things that weren't possible in the main series that are or vise versa, things that can't happen here that happen in the main series.
so while it's not really canon, it's still pretty good.
edit:
the Survey Corps didn't exist during this time for example.
wish they made it to an OVA
Hmmm, would guts be happier in aot or in berserk?
Probably AOT if I’m being honest
lol "George" looks more like "Horhay". Good video though got me thinking, Shinganshina District - Kuklo... Karla? Maybe Erins grandaddy
whats the name of the background song?
its from westworld sounds similar to reveries from S1 ost but can't find which version it is
i thinks its " Dr. Ford" from westworld
This guy's is guts in attack on Titan 😂
@@Venuesbee pretty much
this gonna be animated
holy shit man slow down I cant process shit that fast
Funny how we now know that bro literally manipulated time
I wonder if this lore has any more AOE evidence
You do realize it got concluded before the original manga did right?
And to answer your question, no it doesn't have any evidence of a possible AOE since this took place 50 years before the fall of shiganshina
Kuklo is mirror man.
@@deja-vuatfirstsight7020 that isn’t relevant as the soundtrack from all the in season 1 already foreshadowed the ending an future plot points in the story anyway. The time period isn’t even relevant either.
@@DT25659 what does the S1 OST have to do with the manga prequel?, unless the prequel gets an adaptation (-which very likely won't happen btw) it has absolutely nothing to do with the S1 OST
@@deja-vuatfirstsight7020 So Kuklo would be around 60 by the beginning of the series. I wonder if he survived
I thought titans didn't digest?
Wish they made with Ova
Same
The titan reminds me of Brian from Tekken ngl
PS there is a silentP in 'corps'
I figured
corps party
🤓
I thought "jorge" was pronounced as "yorge"
can someone tell me what manga name
AOT Before the Fall
So this mf is basically guts in attack on titan
It’s fucking GUTs.
If he was in a aot franchise.
am i the only one who thinks that eren and kuklo looks alike.😅
Corps is pronounced Core not corpse
I’d watch this anime (and read obviously)
where is part 2 ?
Sometime this year.