As a Packers fan who watched him his entire time here: - He took his foot off the gas any time the Packers built a huge lead. This would usually allow opponents to get back in the game. If you remember the Superbowl, Green Bay jumped out to a 21-3 lead and then McCarthy started getting way too conservative. It was only thanks to a forced fumble by Clay Matthews and 2 great throws by Rodgers that allowed the Packers to hold on in that game. This happened time and time again where the Packers would have 20-30 point leads by halftime but then the other teams would slowly chip away at the lead... and the only thing that stopped McCarthy from losing those games would be Rodgers bailing him out. - He couldn't manage the clock to save his life. - His play calling at times was completely asinine. Calling bubble screens to the WR on 3rd and 10 made no sense and never worked. - He kept Dom Capers on his coaching staff about 7 years too long. The Zone Blitz became obsolete around 2011 and Capers never evolved. - He'd be a walking cliché dispenser in press conferences and say stuff like "we're gonna evaluate that" or "we're gonna work on that"... and nothing would actually get worked on. - He'd come into games with absolute garbage game plans and would constantly get bailed out by his high-end talent. - Dom. F***ing. Capers
As a Packers Fan... This is the correct take. "We're gonna get that cleaned up up in practice this week" was the only thing missing from this take.... I'm amazed nobody Nationally remembers this, including you Five, but the loss to Arizona, in Lambeau... to the Immortal future hall of famer Josh Rosen, was the last straw, in a long line of straws..... And Mike was very unceremoniously fired, basically in the parking lot outside the stadium..... And fans rejoiced.... Let's look at Matt LaFleur for a second... Did a young head coach, every walk into a more beautiful situation??? You have an MVP QB, a lot of talent around him, on a wildly underachieving team.... Yeah... Andy Reid could have won 3 more Super Bowls with this team..... Now, true, the GM isn't helping at all... Draft Jordan Love... omg, just give me a gunshot would to the thigh, while you're at it.....
And don't forget hanging onto the a ST coaches too long, and then after he did let them go he would hire the assistant ST coach of the guy he just fired so we would have the exact same issues. The guy would not have been the assistant in the first place if he had a different philosophy than the head ST coach.
Too true, too painfully true. Some of our greatest offensive years came when we had horrible defense and special teams. Too many teams were able to score 40 on us, you’re never gonna win letting that happen.
@@namtrof01 and sometimes now, as much as I hated Wade Phillips, he makes me feel as if he possibly wasn’t as lousy as I thought. He was lousy, but we haven’t become less lousy since. Jerry should spend some of that money that he is so proud of and hire a real leader that he’ll let lay an identity true to themselves. Please convince Sean Payton in the off-season to come to Dallas and let him do his thing without hawking over his shoulder!
I think most cowboys fans have understood that we basically just replaced Jason garret with another Jason garret… because at the end of the day jerry jones is the actual decision maker and he just wants a yes man for head coach.
Most of my opinion on McCarthy came from Aaron Rodgers talking in an interview about how terrible McCarthy's playcalling was and that he audibled out of basically everything
As a Packers fan I hold no ill feeling toward McCarthy, he did get us a Super Bowl win after all. The problem with McCarthy was that his clock management wasn’t great, he was a very conservative play caller, and he failed to evolve/modernize his offensive scheme. This became especially noticeable after the 2014 season. In 2015 the offense struggled in the second half of the season and the Packers came close to missing the playoffs. In 2016 the Packers just straight up did not look good, but ended up making the playoffs because Rodgers played like a god in the last 6 games. In 2017 Rodgers missed most of the season because of an injury, and in 2018 the Packers were straight up just not very good. We ended up firing McCarthy after we lost to the Josh Rosen lead Cardinals at home.
As a Packers fan, I thought he never got enough credit for the way he developed QBs (Alex Smith aside). His game management sucked, but people act like he's a worthless head coach and that simply wasn't the case. He also had a track record of out coaching Belichick whenever their two teams played.
You have won Super Bowl to show for it and you are going to kiss his ass???? That is why the Packers will never win again because of that same fucking mentality you have right there
I can't agree with this, especially post-XLV. The moment he said "We rely on our wide receivers to win their 1-on-1 matchups" when Rodgers was out with the second collarbone, he laid bare that the success of the team was largely due to Rodgers' talent, and the gameplan was an albatross when he was out. I was about two years ahead of the curve on the McC hate, but that was a drum I'd been banging for all that time.
@@chives8980 But there were times that he DID outcoach Belichick. Last loss of 2010 was against the Patriots. Rodgers had a concussion in Detroit and missed the game, so it was Matt Flynn coming into a December game in New England. We lost in the last moments as we were lining up around the 30 yard line because of time management issues, but I'm more focused on earlier in the game. His gameplan kept the Pats defense reeling. There was a designed wheel route for the field to be cleared out for the receiver and it ended up being a huge game. The commentators called it out specifically for being a well designed play. It's why the whole "win their 1-on-1 matchups" line bugs me. With a backup QB, I SAW HIM design plays to get receivers open when Rodgers was out, but a Super Bowl win got him arrogant and inflexible. He's a diva now and he fits in Dallas.
LOL what? He was the one responsible for DEVELOPING that high end talent. Funny how you clowns forget that he was the one who developed Rodgers. Sit down.
At the time when McCarthy was hired by Green Bay I was surprised and skeptical. Not because I'd never heard of the guy before (which to be fair I hadn't) but because they mentioned he was the 49ers OC. That anyone from the 49ers staff could get a head coaching job that year was mind blowing to me because the 49ers were the joke of the league at the time and McCarthy especially seemed to be not very good at his job given that their offense was dead last in the NFL
I can personally explain Garrett, he is personally close to Jerry Jones, his dad Jim was a longtime scout for the Cowboys, and his brother Judd has a longtime director of scouting. Bonus: Bryan Broaddus a longtime critic of Garrett (and also doesn't get along with the rest of the family) believes than Jason Garrett would make excellent college coach.
Why did I tire of McCarthy in Green Bay? His play calling and baffling decisions down the stretch. Like the games he wanted to play for Overtime and Rodgers vetoed it and got them into field goal range. To paraphrase what Aaron Nagler said when he was fired, "He was a good coach whose message and tactics got stale."
As a Cowboys fan, while he hasn't been perfect, he has been a nice change of pace compared to the last decade with Jason Garrett. Does anybody here honestly think Jason Garrett would have won any games with a backup QB? His time management has been questionable at times as was his hiring of his buddy Mike Nolan. At least he realized that was a whiff and hired Dan Quinn (amazing hire).
The biggest problem in Green Bay was that there enough innovation to sustain the success of the packers offense which was their only attempt at masking that god awful defense.
BENGALS FAN, Marvin Lewis is one of those polarizing people throughout the fanbase. Jeff Blake, and Andy Dalton was considered a legit franchise qb, by way too many people.
Trust me when I say fellow cardinals fans (and yours truly), want nothing better to have Kliff Kingsbury out/dismissed including our G.M. here n the desert, both are mediocre.. sure he brought in his philosophy/system to groom our new young QB in Kyler, as well as match the high flying explosive offenses or catchup w/ the evolving league… In some ways can’t help but notice Kliff is holding up Kyler’s potential (similar to McCarthy w/ Rodgers), plus he’s yet to address his clock management issues, predictable play calling, or second half collapses. Always wondered how Kyler would flourish in another system say Sean Payton’s
@@ceebee312 I mean yeah. I would love though if the Cardinals can snag the 49ers Defensive Coordinator for either DC(unless the Cardinals Defense can prove itself this year somehow) or Head Coach. But Sean Payton would be a wonderful replacement if we can get him.
You know who else he helped develop? Rich Gannon. Gannon had said in an interview he was never really taught much about being a QB until he arrived in KC with mike mccarthy among other coaches. Sorry, don't remember the exact interview.
what made me dislike McCarthy was what happened in 2016, and 2018. In 2016 he gave a press conference so startling and so bad that he should've been fired on the spot. It was after the blowout vs Washington that put the Packers at 4-6, forcing them to run the table as Rodgers would state later. McCarthy literally and I paraphrase, I've got nothing, I have no answers. He should've been fired on the spot if he had no idea how to win with Aaron Rodgers. Then, in 2018, he "Ran the numbers", vs Seattle, a team he's only beaten ONCE at Seattle! The man looked like he was trying to get fired by the Packers. The most egregious thing however is his record. Brett Favre under Mike Holmgren and Sherman had 4 12+ win seasons, and 1 with McCarthy in 2007. Under McCarthy, Rodgers could only muster TWO 12+ win seasons, 2011, and 2014. While we may have not won a SB under LaFleur, the fact that we've had 3 consecutive 13 win seasons is reason enough to question why couldn't McCarthy get more out of the Packers let alone Rodgers? I think the reason is that he's a fraud, you mention the QB's he's "coached", none of them lasted long either after they left him or he left them. Iirc he even tried to credit his early QB coaching success with Favre and Montana, late in their careers. You know who that reminds me of? Adam Gase. Aaron Brooks' career after McCarthy left took a sharp nosedive in 2005, so quick that it forced the Saints to sign Drew Brees. Jake Delhomme also fell off the wagon after 2005, mainly due to injuries he suffered in 06 and 07. What makes me dislike McCarthy is that he could've done so much more and just refused to take advantage of it. The fact that he couldn't figure out how to win with Aaron Rodgers, is more than enough reasons for me to dislike the guy.
Me personally as a cowboys fan, if I ever had a say so, the man who threw the challenge flag on the Dez catch (dez caught it) wouldn’t be allowed within 500 yards of my facilities unless he was coaching another team.
That mentality is how you waste the best years of a talented roster. He’ll coach you good enough to win you regular season games, but when the lights are brightest, he’ll coach you into an early grave. This is coming from a Packers fan.
His 2nd year as head coach took a consensus washed up QB in Favre and coached them to a 13-3 record and a conference championship with Favres best season since he won the 97 MVP. Coached Rodgers only Superbowl victory, 4 NFC championship appearances and wins 12 games his 2nd season as Cowboys head coach with the #1 scoring offense. The guy wins whatever his flaws are. Is calling him a terrible head coach justified?
2010 Rodgers wasn’t that spectacular either, less than 4000 yards, 3rd lowest career TD total in a non-injury shortened year (28), second highest career INT total (11) so the argument that Rodgers carried him there doesn’t hold a lot of weight. McCarthy did a great job with that team. I think he’s a flawed head coach, but calling him terrible is just going too far.
Wel let’s see: he only won with a hall of fame top 5 QB of all time, he doesn’t take responsibility for his decisions, and he’s delusional just like almost every other coach!!
What is funny is that all the people who vililfy McCarthy for only one Super Bowl with Rodgers carry Sean Payton around on their shoulders like he is an all time coach. This is despite the fact that: - he only had one Super Bowl with Drew Brees -missed the playoff entirely 3 straight years, something McCarthy NEVER did with Rodgers. -lost the same number of NFC Title games as McCarthy -had a worse postseason record than McCarthy -had a overall win percetnage was only a fraction of a percent better, You should do a video called "Why does Sean Payton get a free pass despite the fact he did worse with a HOF QB than Mike McCarthy did".
This is why I've been saying for months now that when McCarthy gets fired in Dallas (we all know it's coming), Belichick needs to get him as OC for the Patriots. Shit on him all you want, he knows how to win games and develope quarterbacks, Alex Smith aside.
What sets him apart from the great Super Bowl winning coaches, is that he never adapted (at the very least he didn’t in Green Bay). He’d ignore the clear issues on defense and special teams, in favor of having the offense pick up the slack. You’re the head coach, your coordinators work under you, so when they start failing, either tell them to fix it or work with the GM to find someone that will. But doing nothing isn’t an option if you want to win. What we’re seeing with the 2022 Lions is similar to the McCarthy era Packers, it doesn’t matter if you have a high scoring offense if the other team can score just as much or more. The only difference is that you had enough talent on the team to win, but that’s not enough to win the playoffs.
Reason why packers fans are not happy with him. Got lazy let Aaron run the offense installed of taking responsibility. Coasted off talent. The doc rivers of the nfl
McCarthy still coasts on the credit he gets as a QB whisperer, with Rodgers as his most notable success...ignoring the fact that Rodgers was also his *LAST* success. His "QB school" relied on offseason workouts that were gutted in the 2011 CBA, and he never adjusted. And that's the problem with McCarthy, in a nutshell: He never adjusted. To anything. His situational playcalling was routinely atrocious. His clock management was a joke. Dom Capers fell off a cliff, but he still kept him as DC for another half-decade, squandering Rodgers' prime with defensive collapse after defensive collapse in the playoffs (with a side helping of special teams in the infamous 2014 NFC Championship). His offensive scheme stagnated, but he never made any changes, even as the league caught up and surpassed him. Very little seems to have changed since he came to Dallas, even after taking a year off to "update." It's hard to think of a head coach in recent NFL history who has done less with more.
Niners fan. He was our OC during one of our most bumbling offensive seasons. I'll tell you my most infamous, stupid, McCarthy playcalling memory. This took place between the 40s. Our top two running backs were injured that week, so we were down to 3rd string. Niners got it to 2nd & short. He ran it up the middle. Stopped for no gain; 3rd down. Ran it up the middle again. Stopped; 4th down. Now, this is our 3RD STRING running back in the game, and it's NOT WORKING. Do you think the Niners punted? Ran a play action? Tried to draw them off sides for the easy 1st? Heck... A quick slant? NOPE!! Ran it up the middle. Stopped. Turnover on downs. And the Packers took him OFF our hands?! I laughed so f×cking hard.
@@noahudensi8412 It was very likely week 12 against Arizona of 2005. Maurice Hicks. He only started 3 games that year & was the 3rd back on the depth chart behind Kevan Barlow & a rookie Frank Gore. Hicks averaged 1.7 yards that game, so I'm guessing that was the game. I just remember both Gore & Barlow were injured, so he either got the start(he did start that game), or he had to finish the lion share of the game it happened in. But the Niners finished 32nd in most statistical offensive categories that year. They only got higher than 27th in, I think, three. The rest were 30th or 32nd. And somehow that got McCarthy the GreenBay job? Good riddance! But yes, he won one Super Bowl with the best Quarterback the league has seen in decades. He should count himself lucky.
Going from a town like Green Bay, WI, aka Titletown, USA, to a big city like Dallas, TX, which in terms of football is more like (En)Title(d)town, USA, can’t be the easiest change over and/or transition to be made. Can’t be easy on the blood pressure or the nerves to go from the boss in Green Bay being the town which owns the team to now transitioning to working for your new boss, who is also the Owner, President, and General Manager along with his son who is the Vise President of the team. Jerry Jones has to be one stressful guy to work for and with. I really do feel for Mike McCarthy but so far he looks like he has better control of the team this year. So I’m wishing nothing but the best for him.
LOl since when? He was the one who developed ROdgers int he first place. You ignorant Packers fans seem to forget that you were whining an crying that Rodgers was a bust and injury prone his first two seasons. Guess who was responsible for turning that into a HOF QB? McCarthy. So get that "he gets carried by talent" BS out of here.
TLDW: Mike McCarthy is disliked because he basically rode Aaron Rodger's arm to a championship, despite his shitty coaching style. This earned him more goodwill in Green Bay than he deserved, which led to several wasted seasons before Green Bay finally gave him the ax, with Jerry World more than happy to sign him for some reason so that he can do the same in Dallas. I wouldn't be surprised if this is his last season when Dallas flames out in December like they always have.
I'd argue McCarthy is one of the reasons, but not the sole reason. The front office didn't do him any favors with some of their draft classes either. The defense was terrible for a couple years, the running game was non-existent, and the offensive line had more holes than swiss cheese. Worse yet, the front office seemed to refuse to go after free agents, opting to bet on unproven rookies instead. Don't get me wrong, young talent is not a bad thing, but veteran leadership in your locker room is also a good thing.
I'm not sure that's entirely fair. The Falcons were clearly the better team, and even if they get past Seattle it is the Patriots. I will agree on 2018 though. Wasted season.
The Packers weren’t the best team in most of those years, and it’s not like Rodgers didn’t have his chances. The only one where I could say they definitely should have at least made the super bowl was in 2014, but that collapse is at least as much on the players as it was on McCarthy, and even then, there’s no guarantee they beat the Pats. I think McCarthy is a flawed coach but I think it’s going much too far to say he’s the only reason Rodgers doesn’t have eight rings.
To all my fellow Cowboys fans watching this: if you think Jerry Jones needs to fire Mike McCarthy after this season and replace him with someone that will rock the boat and lead Dallas to a Super Bowl, gimme a “Hell Yeah!”
based on Hard Knocks, I think it’s just ‘cause he’s kind of lame. You’re totally right, though. looking at results, it’s completely unwarranted. I feel like Andy Reid had such a mixed reputation before the Mahomes era. Maybe McCarthy’s time is still to come
@@BaldguyWifi now andy has always been considered a great coach. He took the eagles to 4 nfc championships with Mcnabb. Revitalized both Vicks career and Alex Smiths. In which he took both to the playoffs multiple times. Won games in playoffs with smith. Then took mahomes and made that man god like. Give mahomes urban Meyer dude would be out the league in two years. Mahomes has talent but Reid pushed that to the stars.
McCarthy is an amazing QB coach & OC but underachieved & was out coached in big games w/Rodgers. He appears to be strictly a coach for the Cowboys as opposed to truly running the team & his stated new reliance on analytics feels like it was gimmick to get the job. He made lots of money coaching the Packers so why would he want to spend so much time coaching in the NFL when he could possibly go find the next Aaron Rodgers? It’s like he took the Cowboys job to prove he could get another one.
It's a bit disingenuous to suggest the Packers were some kind of dumpster fire when McCarthy got there. Before the 4-12 season they'd been a perennial playoff team under Mike Sherman, who was basically proto-McCarthy in terms of his innate ability to mentally implode in high pressure situations. (The '04 Divisional Round loss to the Eagles is still my all time most miserable defeat as a Packers fan.) McCarthy definitely does not get the credit he deserves for Rodgers' development. If he'd gone almost anyplace else in that draft, I highly doubt he'd have become the player he is today. I've long theorized that if Rodgers had been a 49er and Alex Smith a Packer, their careers might be reversed. Ultimately he's an ok coach who got lucky with the talent he inherited and won at a much higher level than his ability indicates he should.
As a packer fan he was carried by farve and Rodgers now he is getting exposed as a game manager and for a head coach you can’t have that kind of person at the head coaching position why is he hated? Because he never changed and when times changed we were left hanging want to talk about cooper rush but don’t want to talk about that defense that carries them we are most concerned with how Dak has gone from good to dud under mike
Ever since he’s left nobody in green bay hates mike. He’s got a street named after him and we got us our only super bowl in 30 years. I like mike just fine, it was just time for a change and Lafleur is doing great
He certainly gets a lot of hate for sure. Dealing with Favres huge ego, then Rodgers after must have been a nightmare to deal with in GB. He made some questionable decisions over the years and has had some bad luck to boot. Now he is in a situation where J Jones( Al Davis's fraternal twin) is making the decisions. Good luck with that.
He’s hated because he tries to give off Belichick energy but with none of the success. He had Rodgers in Green Bay and clearly he was hiding behind him.
LOL what? McCarthy was the one who developed Rodgers in the first place. It amazes me that people keep spewing this ignorant BS. Rodgers doesn't become what he is without McCarthy. Even Rodgers himself admits it.
I think McCarthy did a great job in greenbay but you can only coach a team for so long before it fizzles out. The problem is that in Dallas it’s way too clear that his coordinators are way more important to the team’s success than he is
GB fan here. He deserves a ton of credit for GB success until the epic choke job against Seattle in 2014. After that the entire franchise went downhill until he was fired, including him/TT/AR. He is a really good coach Mon-Sat especially with keeping a team grinding week to week. Hard to say if he or AR or both ruined that relationship. But he's awful in-game and can't seem to adapt. He took the wrong traits from Marty Schottenheimer!
That game is not on McCarthy Rodgers was complete3ly AWOL in that game when the defense kept giving him the ball back and even then they win the game if an onside kick is recovered.
Cowboys fans are frustrated. After coaches like Landry, Johnson, Switzer, and Parcells, they've had mediocrity with Campo, Phillips, and Garrett. McCarthy just looks like more of the same. The fans really need to look at their owner's box to see where the real dysfunction is. Jerry Jones runs the Cowboys as his hobby. If you were a star coach like Payton, McVey, or Shanahan, would you want to deal with Jerry Jones!?
If Jason Garret could be the cowboys coach for 8 years, go 8-8 4 out of the 8 years and make only 2 playoffs, Mike McCarthy should be able to be Dallas coach until he dies
I think the main reason people don't like him was that he isn't that good in the Cowboys and many think he took undue credit for a Packers Super Bowl win.
Those people are idiots. McCarthy is the one who developed Rodgers which got them to the Super Bowl. Those clowns seem to forget that Rodgers was garbage his first two seasons and also had the":injury prone" label. They have rewritten history to where Rodgers was a HOF'r which he absolutely was not. McCarthy developed ROdgers through his "QB School" which was ended by the CBA that was signed in 2011, coincidentally the season after they won the Super Bowl and where McCarthy had a harder time developing QB's. Anyone says McCarthy doesn't get credit for the Super Bowl win knows jnothing about football ,a Rodgers fanboy, or an ESPN clown.
i want mccarthy to succeed, it just always seems like he’s one step behind whatever team he’s facing, i want to see kellen moore get a shot at hc just bc why not
I always thought he was a good coach, and a lot of the hate is misplaced. With that said a lot of the criticism he gets is extremely warranted. His clock management and challenges are bad. He can instill a great high powered offense and if he has a good roster he knows what do with it. In Green Bay he got complacent
It’s more than just relationships with players or stuff like that. If u watch a Cowboys game, there are constantly small things that always make it a little bit harder. Leading the league in penalties for two years is a coaching/discipline issue that hasn’t been able to be solved by McCarthy. He’s supposed to be an offensive minded HC but when it comes out that he doesn’t know the plays from his own offense, he fires it back to OC Kellen Moore and makes it his mistake and doesn’t own it. During the MNF game two weeks back, half the Giants roster was on the field with 8 seconds left in the half with the clock running, and it was McCarthy that called the TO, giving them a chance to get their personnel on the field to run one more play. If it wasn’t the Giants passing offense, it probably would’ve resulted in points. It’s constant these little things that add up and make it in ear impossible to see anything good coming from him.
To me, the biggest responsibilities for a head coach are clock management and player discipline (and maybe play calling to an extent if they want to have a role in that matter). What are some of the most common issues with McCarthy led football teams? Clock management, player discipline, and very questionable situational play calling. That's why I don't like him. He's the anti of every single thing that a head coach should be doing
The main issue I have with the McCarthy-led Cowboys is the absolutely unacceptable amount of penalties we keep drawing every year. We were worst in the league last year in both the number of penalties and penalty yards given up, and that contributed to our 1st round bounce in the playoffs.
Look most frustration directed at McCarthy is really aimed at Jerry but we know Jerry isn't going anywhere so we hope that there will be a new coach with the backbone to tell Jerry to just sign the checks, tell them they're doing a good job and open a case of scotch when they have a good day.
He's holding us back a wild card appearance, biannual division win and either way a first round playoff exit is all he will ever achieve at the Cowboys. Please just go.
As a Cowboys fan I don't see what McCarthy brings to the team that is beneficial other than consistency? He is not much of an upgrade over Jason Garrett (though McCarthy is absolutely an upgrade over Jason Garrett). The Cowboys are still undisciplined, they still commit a lot of drive killing penalties, and the worst sin of all (at least from the standpoint of Cowboys fans), he hasn't won a playoff game. Cowboys fans will never love a coach who doesn't restore America's Team to its rightful place as Super Bowl competitors. Instead our recent playoff appearances have been largely down to how weak the NFC East has been until the 2022 season. We were practically guaranteed at least 4 to 6 wins a season from playing our division rivals twice (we would sometimes lose the odd fluke game). If McCarthy ever gets the Cowboys to the NFC Championship game at least then I think he will get a bit more credit. Until then he is Jerry's current stooge (you see the real reason we hate Mike McCarthy is because we all hate Jerry but we can't get rid of Jerry so we need to hate someone we can get rid of).
Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today’s video! Get 20% OFF + Free Shipping with my link manscaped.com/five-points
Uh McCarthy wasted a Packers squad from 2010-2014. Could have went to Super Bowl 46, 47, and 49 if Rodgers had a better coach
As a Packers fan who watched him his entire time here:
- He took his foot off the gas any time the Packers built a huge lead. This would usually allow opponents to get back in the game. If you remember the Superbowl, Green Bay jumped out to a 21-3 lead and then McCarthy started getting way too conservative. It was only thanks to a forced fumble by Clay Matthews and 2 great throws by Rodgers that allowed the Packers to hold on in that game. This happened time and time again where the Packers would have 20-30 point leads by halftime but then the other teams would slowly chip away at the lead... and the only thing that stopped McCarthy from losing those games would be Rodgers bailing him out.
- He couldn't manage the clock to save his life.
- His play calling at times was completely asinine. Calling bubble screens to the WR on 3rd and 10 made no sense and never worked.
- He kept Dom Capers on his coaching staff about 7 years too long. The Zone Blitz became obsolete around 2011 and Capers never evolved.
- He'd be a walking cliché dispenser in press conferences and say stuff like "we're gonna evaluate that" or "we're gonna work on that"... and nothing would actually get worked on.
- He'd come into games with absolute garbage game plans and would constantly get bailed out by his high-end talent.
- Dom. F***ing. Capers
That bubble 1 way too accurate wow do I remember those
As a Packers Fan... This is the correct take. "We're gonna get that cleaned up up in practice this week" was the only thing missing from this take....
I'm amazed nobody Nationally remembers this, including you Five, but the loss to Arizona, in Lambeau... to the Immortal future hall of famer Josh Rosen, was the last straw, in a long line of straws..... And Mike was very unceremoniously fired, basically in the parking lot outside the stadium..... And fans rejoiced....
Let's look at Matt LaFleur for a second... Did a young head coach, every walk into a more beautiful situation??? You have an MVP QB, a lot of talent around him, on a wildly underachieving team.... Yeah... Andy Reid could have won 3 more Super Bowls with this team..... Now, true, the GM isn't helping at all... Draft Jordan Love... omg, just give me a gunshot would to the thigh, while you're at it.....
This is accurate to a T.
And don't forget hanging onto the a ST coaches too long, and then after he did let them go he would hire the assistant ST coach of the guy he just fired so we would have the exact same issues. The guy would not have been the assistant in the first place if he had a different philosophy than the head ST coach.
Too true, too painfully true. Some of our greatest offensive years came when we had horrible defense and special teams. Too many teams were able to score 40 on us, you’re never gonna win letting that happen.
Mike McCarthys only redeeming quality: he’s not Jason Garrett
Lmao...But as a Packers fan, its the damn truth!
Can they take Garrett out of the sports. Like his smile is creepy as shit
@@garrett9562 you ARE Garrett!
oddly enough garretts only quality was he wasn't wade Phillips
@@namtrof01 and sometimes now, as much as I hated Wade Phillips, he makes me feel as if he possibly wasn’t as lousy as I thought. He was lousy, but we haven’t become less lousy since. Jerry should spend some of that money that he is so proud of and hire a real leader that he’ll let lay an identity true to themselves. Please convince Sean Payton in the off-season to come to Dallas and let him do his thing without hawking over his shoulder!
I think most cowboys fans have understood that we basically just replaced Jason garret with another Jason garret… because at the end of the day jerry jones is the actual decision maker and he just wants a yes man for head coach.
Yup.
That’s why Jimmy got chased off. Haven’t had a strong coach since.
Yeah that's pretty much the reason why your we're right on the money there.
Jerry doesn’t give a fuck about the team he’s just milking the cowboys brand and living out the rest of his days😂
@@WestCoastCheeseHead a lot of cowboys fans like you have said the same thing just like you.
Most of my opinion on McCarthy came from Aaron Rodgers talking in an interview about how terrible McCarthy's playcalling was and that he audibled out of basically everything
Makes sense now, especially him and Moore.
I can see ScooterMagruder writing a 5 page essay on this topic lmao
That needs to be a Clickbait Punishment
Tom and the Possi warned him lol
As a Packers fan I hold no ill feeling toward McCarthy, he did get us a Super Bowl win after all.
The problem with McCarthy was that his clock management wasn’t great, he was a very conservative play caller, and he failed to evolve/modernize his offensive scheme. This became especially noticeable after the 2014 season.
In 2015 the offense struggled in the second half of the season and the Packers came close to missing the playoffs. In 2016 the Packers just straight up did not look good, but ended up making the playoffs because Rodgers played like a god in the last 6 games. In 2017 Rodgers missed most of the season because of an injury, and in 2018 the Packers were straight up just not very good. We ended up firing McCarthy after we lost to the Josh Rosen lead Cardinals at home.
2016: R E L A X 😂😂😂 "Run the Table" and we lost way too quickly in the playoffs.
Ethan on how the Cowboys 49ers game went down.
Go Giants! #2012playoffs
As a Packers fan, I thought he never got enough credit for the way he developed QBs (Alex Smith aside). His game management sucked, but people act like he's a worthless head coach and that simply wasn't the case. He also had a track record of out coaching Belichick whenever their two teams played.
You have won Super Bowl to show for it and you are going to kiss his ass????
That is why the Packers will never win again because of that same fucking mentality you have right there
I can't agree with this, especially post-XLV. The moment he said "We rely on our wide receivers to win their 1-on-1 matchups" when Rodgers was out with the second collarbone, he laid bare that the success of the team was largely due to Rodgers' talent, and the gameplan was an albatross when he was out. I was about two years ahead of the curve on the McC hate, but that was a drum I'd been banging for all that time.
He was carried by high end talent, doesn't mean he out coached him.
Bro he has no concept of clock management, it’s like he goes brain dead in last 3-2 minutes of the 4th
@@chives8980 But there were times that he DID outcoach Belichick. Last loss of 2010 was against the Patriots. Rodgers had a concussion in Detroit and missed the game, so it was Matt Flynn coming into a December game in New England. We lost in the last moments as we were lining up around the 30 yard line because of time management issues, but I'm more focused on earlier in the game. His gameplan kept the Pats defense reeling. There was a designed wheel route for the field to be cleared out for the receiver and it ended up being a huge game. The commentators called it out specifically for being a well designed play.
It's why the whole "win their 1-on-1 matchups" line bugs me. With a backup QB, I SAW HIM design plays to get receivers open when Rodgers was out, but a Super Bowl win got him arrogant and inflexible. He's a diva now and he fits in Dallas.
Ah, the head coach who gets bailed out by his high end talent.
High end talent like…. Cooper Rush?
@@dansbigfanguitarist Their defense. Rush has been decent but their defense won those games.
To me as a Cowboys fan, seeing my fellow fans constantly trashing their own players, it’s just nice to see someone say they have high end talent.
@@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820 I hate the Cowboys, but I know talent when I see it.
LOL what? He was the one responsible for DEVELOPING that high end talent. Funny how you clowns forget that he was the one who developed Rodgers. Sit down.
At the time when McCarthy was hired by Green Bay I was surprised and skeptical. Not because I'd never heard of the guy before (which to be fair I hadn't) but because they mentioned he was the 49ers OC. That anyone from the 49ers staff could get a head coaching job that year was mind blowing to me because the 49ers were the joke of the league at the time and McCarthy especially seemed to be not very good at his job given that their offense was dead last in the NFL
Take a look at LeFeur's offense with the Titans before he came to GB lol.
I can personally explain Garrett, he is personally close to Jerry Jones, his dad Jim was a longtime scout for the Cowboys, and his brother Judd has a longtime director of scouting.
Bonus: Bryan Broaddus a longtime critic of Garrett (and also doesn't get along with the rest of the family) believes than Jason Garrett would make excellent college coach.
Gross, all that clapping and cowboys talk I am bout to puke
@@teen_laqueefa Sorry get a video on a Cowboys HC, you gonna get Cowboys talk.
who dey lmao go back to ohio
@@fernieu3537 never left, don't worry about me
Don't forget that Jason himself was Aikman's back-up for a few seasons during their '90s run, too.
Why did I tire of McCarthy in Green Bay? His play calling and baffling decisions down the stretch. Like the games he wanted to play for Overtime and Rodgers vetoed it and got them into field goal range. To paraphrase what Aaron Nagler said when he was fired, "He was a good coach whose message and tactics got stale."
As a Cowboys fan, while he hasn't been perfect, he has been a nice change of pace compared to the last decade with Jason Garrett. Does anybody here honestly think Jason Garrett would have won any games with a backup QB? His time management has been questionable at times as was his hiring of his buddy Mike Nolan. At least he realized that was a whiff and hired Dan Quinn (amazing hire).
He's so disliked because he doesn't use Manscaped.
Mccarthy and GB's management had 2 hof qb's and only 1 ring!?! Smh. They wasted Rodgers prime years by keeping capers as DC amongst other issues.
The biggest problem in Green Bay was that there enough innovation to sustain the success of the packers offense which was their only attempt at masking that god awful defense.
Sometimes I think NFL fans take certain players/coaches and develop this level of irrational hatred out of a molehill of reasons.
BENGALS FAN, Marvin Lewis is one of those polarizing people throughout the fanbase. Jeff Blake, and Andy Dalton was considered a legit franchise qb, by way too many people.
Trust me when I say fellow cardinals fans (and yours truly), want nothing better to have Kliff Kingsbury out/dismissed including our G.M. here n the desert, both are mediocre.. sure he brought in his philosophy/system to groom our new young QB in Kyler, as well as match the high flying explosive offenses or catchup w/ the evolving league… In some ways can’t help but notice Kliff is holding up Kyler’s potential (similar to McCarthy w/ Rodgers), plus he’s yet to address his clock management issues, predictable play calling, or second half collapses. Always wondered how Kyler would flourish in another system say Sean Payton’s
@@ceebee312 I mean yeah. I would love though if the Cardinals can snag the 49ers Defensive Coordinator for either DC(unless the Cardinals Defense can prove itself this year somehow) or Head Coach. But Sean Payton would be a wonderful replacement if we can get him.
You know who else he helped develop? Rich Gannon. Gannon had said in an interview he was never really taught much about being a QB until he arrived in KC with mike mccarthy among other coaches. Sorry, don't remember the exact interview.
The Packers can win with no coach. Aaron Rogers is a coach on the field. McCarthy is a lousy coach.
what made me dislike McCarthy was what happened in 2016, and 2018. In 2016 he gave a press conference so startling and so bad that he should've been fired on the spot. It was after the blowout vs Washington that put the Packers at 4-6, forcing them to run the table as Rodgers would state later. McCarthy literally and I paraphrase, I've got nothing, I have no answers. He should've been fired on the spot if he had no idea how to win with Aaron Rodgers. Then, in 2018, he "Ran the numbers", vs Seattle, a team he's only beaten ONCE at Seattle! The man looked like he was trying to get fired by the Packers. The most egregious thing however is his record. Brett Favre under Mike Holmgren and Sherman had 4 12+ win seasons, and 1 with McCarthy in 2007. Under McCarthy, Rodgers could only muster TWO 12+ win seasons, 2011, and 2014. While we may have not won a SB under LaFleur, the fact that we've had 3 consecutive 13 win seasons is reason enough to question why couldn't McCarthy get more out of the Packers let alone Rodgers?
I think the reason is that he's a fraud, you mention the QB's he's "coached", none of them lasted long either after they left him or he left them. Iirc he even tried to credit his early QB coaching success with Favre and Montana, late in their careers. You know who that reminds me of? Adam Gase. Aaron Brooks' career after McCarthy left took a sharp nosedive in 2005, so quick that it forced the Saints to sign Drew Brees. Jake Delhomme also fell off the wagon after 2005, mainly due to injuries he suffered in 06 and 07.
What makes me dislike McCarthy is that he could've done so much more and just refused to take advantage of it. The fact that he couldn't figure out how to win with Aaron Rodgers, is more than enough reasons for me to dislike the guy.
They Love you when You're Winning but Hate you when You're Losing! I would rather never makes the Playoffs then to Lose in the Playoffs!
he wins and they dont like him
Me personally as a cowboys fan, if I ever had a say so, the man who threw the challenge flag on the Dez catch (dez caught it) wouldn’t be allowed within 500 yards of my facilities unless he was coaching another team.
Reverse Robin Hood killed me oh my lord😅🤣 You always have the funniest way of putting things my man
He's won three straight games with Cooper Rush. I'm not saying the guys a top 5 head coach but it's still impressive they're 3-1
I think that's more of an indictment of Dak than it is proof McCarthy knows what he's doing.
@@Riley_Mundt Indictment of Dak? You people are fucking ridiculous.
That mentality is how you waste the best years of a talented roster. He’ll coach you good enough to win you regular season games, but when the lights are brightest, he’ll coach you into an early grave. This is coming from a Packers fan.
Tbf Dallas defence is quite good even if Micah Parsons is now shit
@@lrkcm373 He won you a SB. One super coach has yet to do that.
His 2nd year as head coach took a consensus washed up QB in Favre and coached them to a 13-3 record and a conference championship with Favres best season since he won the 97 MVP. Coached Rodgers only Superbowl victory, 4 NFC championship appearances and wins 12 games his 2nd season as Cowboys head coach with the #1 scoring offense. The guy wins whatever his flaws are.
Is calling him a terrible head coach justified?
2010 Rodgers wasn’t that spectacular either, less than 4000 yards, 3rd lowest career TD total in a non-injury shortened year (28), second highest career INT total (11) so the argument that Rodgers carried him there doesn’t hold a lot of weight. McCarthy did a great job with that team. I think he’s a flawed head coach, but calling him terrible is just going too far.
He’s the Doc Rivers of the NFL 💀
Preach
He doesn't do anything. Tell me what he does? Play call? No
Time management? No
What is he in charge of?
Wel let’s see: he only won with a hall of fame top 5 QB of all time, he doesn’t take responsibility for his decisions, and he’s delusional just like almost every other coach!!
Good one
If he wasn't coaching he would be running his own donut factory making jelly donuts
What is funny is that all the people who vililfy McCarthy for only one Super Bowl with Rodgers carry Sean Payton around on their shoulders like he is an all time coach. This is despite the fact that:
- he only had one Super Bowl with Drew Brees
-missed the playoff entirely 3 straight years, something McCarthy NEVER did with Rodgers.
-lost the same number of NFC Title games as McCarthy
-had a worse postseason record than McCarthy
-had a overall win percetnage was only a fraction of a percent better,
You should do a video called "Why does Sean Payton get a free pass despite the fact he did worse with a HOF QB than Mike McCarthy did".
This is why I've been saying for months now that when McCarthy gets fired in Dallas (we all know it's coming), Belichick needs to get him as OC for the Patriots.
Shit on him all you want, he knows how to win games and develope quarterbacks, Alex Smith aside.
What's funny is that people ignore the act that McCarthy was the only one in the 49ers organization that wanted Rodgers.
What sets him apart from the great Super Bowl winning coaches, is that he never adapted (at the very least he didn’t in Green Bay).
He’d ignore the clear issues on defense and special teams, in favor of having the offense pick up the slack. You’re the head coach, your coordinators work under you, so when they start failing, either tell them to fix it or work with the GM to find someone that will. But doing nothing isn’t an option if you want to win.
What we’re seeing with the 2022 Lions is similar to the McCarthy era Packers, it doesn’t matter if you have a high scoring offense if the other team can score just as much or more. The only difference is that you had enough talent on the team to win, but that’s not enough to win the playoffs.
Reason why packers fans are not happy with him. Got lazy let Aaron run the offense installed of taking responsibility. Coasted off talent. The doc rivers of the nfl
Excellent video as always!! Hope everyone is having a great week!!
Fellow wisconsinite here... 2 words why the fan base turned on him, PLAY CALLING
McCarthy still coasts on the credit he gets as a QB whisperer, with Rodgers as his most notable success...ignoring the fact that Rodgers was also his *LAST* success. His "QB school" relied on offseason workouts that were gutted in the 2011 CBA, and he never adjusted.
And that's the problem with McCarthy, in a nutshell: He never adjusted. To anything. His situational playcalling was routinely atrocious. His clock management was a joke. Dom Capers fell off a cliff, but he still kept him as DC for another half-decade, squandering Rodgers' prime with defensive collapse after defensive collapse in the playoffs (with a side helping of special teams in the infamous 2014 NFC Championship). His offensive scheme stagnated, but he never made any changes, even as the league caught up and surpassed him.
Very little seems to have changed since he came to Dallas, even after taking a year off to "update." It's hard to think of a head coach in recent NFL history who has done less with more.
Niners fan. He was our OC during one of our most bumbling offensive seasons.
I'll tell you my most infamous, stupid, McCarthy playcalling memory. This took place between the 40s.
Our top two running backs were injured that week, so we were down to 3rd string. Niners got it to 2nd & short. He ran it up the middle. Stopped for no gain; 3rd down. Ran it up the middle again. Stopped; 4th down. Now, this is our 3RD STRING running back in the game, and it's NOT WORKING. Do you think the Niners punted? Ran a play action? Tried to draw them off sides for the easy 1st? Heck... A quick slant?
NOPE!!
Ran it up the middle. Stopped. Turnover on downs.
And the Packers took him OFF our hands?! I laughed so f×cking hard.
Well, he won a Super Bowl with the Packers, but your anecdote tracks.
When did that game happen
@@noahudensi8412
It was very likely week 12 against Arizona of 2005. Maurice Hicks. He only started 3 games that year & was the 3rd back on the depth chart behind Kevan Barlow & a rookie Frank Gore. Hicks averaged 1.7 yards that game, so I'm guessing that was the game. I just remember both Gore & Barlow were injured, so he either got the start(he did start that game), or he had to finish the lion share of the game it happened in.
But the Niners finished 32nd in most statistical offensive categories that year. They only got higher than 27th in, I think, three. The rest were 30th or 32nd. And somehow that got McCarthy the GreenBay job? Good riddance!
But yes, he won one Super Bowl with the best Quarterback the league has seen in decades. He should count himself lucky.
@@DoobieKeebler 😂😂😂😂 thanks
Going from a town like Green Bay, WI, aka Titletown, USA, to a big city like Dallas, TX, which in terms of football is more like (En)Title(d)town, USA, can’t be the easiest change over and/or transition to be made. Can’t be easy on the blood pressure or the nerves to go from the boss in Green Bay being the town which owns the team to now transitioning to working for your new boss, who is also the Owner, President, and General Manager along with his son who is the Vise President of the team. Jerry Jones has to be one stressful guy to work for and with. I really do feel for Mike McCarthy but so far he looks like he has better control of the team this year. So I’m wishing nothing but the best for him.
Can you do an explainer video on Josh McDaniels. I'm only now slowly learning about why Broncos fan hate him so much.
He already did
The reason I don’t like him (other then he couched the Packers) is because he gets carried by talent and is incompetent.
LOl since when? He was the one who developed ROdgers int he first place. You ignorant Packers fans seem to forget that you were whining an crying that Rodgers was a bust and injury prone his first two seasons. Guess who was responsible for turning that into a HOF QB? McCarthy. So get that "he gets carried by talent" BS out of here.
Mike McCarthy is the Doc Rivers of NFL
Except players like Doc
Damn.. you just gonna copy a comment like that💀
Favres last year with GB is not his best year. His first year with the Vikings is.
TLDW: Mike McCarthy is disliked because he basically rode Aaron Rodger's arm to a championship, despite his shitty coaching style. This earned him more goodwill in Green Bay than he deserved, which led to several wasted seasons before Green Bay finally gave him the ax, with Jerry World more than happy to sign him for some reason so that he can do the same in Dallas. I wouldn't be surprised if this is his last season when Dallas flames out in December like they always have.
He’s the reason why Aaron Rodgers only has one ring instead of eight.
I'd argue McCarthy is one of the reasons, but not the sole reason. The front office didn't do him any favors with some of their draft classes either. The defense was terrible for a couple years, the running game was non-existent, and the offensive line had more holes than swiss cheese. Worse yet, the front office seemed to refuse to go after free agents, opting to bet on unproven rookies instead. Don't get me wrong, young talent is not a bad thing, but veteran leadership in your locker room is also a good thing.
I'm not sure that's entirely fair. The Falcons were clearly the better team, and even if they get past Seattle it is the Patriots. I will agree on 2018 though. Wasted season.
Packers need to stop throwing all the money at the QB if they want to have enough talent to go all the way.
You mean the reason McCarthy only has 1 ring instead of 8 was because of Rodgers
The Packers weren’t the best team in most of those years, and it’s not like Rodgers didn’t have his chances. The only one where I could say they definitely should have at least made the super bowl was in 2014, but that collapse is at least as much on the players as it was on McCarthy, and even then, there’s no guarantee they beat the Pats. I think McCarthy is a flawed coach but I think it’s going much too far to say he’s the only reason Rodgers doesn’t have eight rings.
To all my fellow Cowboys fans watching this: if you think Jerry Jones needs to fire Mike McCarthy after this season and replace him with someone that will rock the boat and lead Dallas to a Super Bowl, gimme a “Hell Yeah!”
HELL YEAH
based on Hard Knocks, I think it’s just ‘cause he’s kind of lame.
You’re totally right, though. looking at results, it’s completely unwarranted. I feel like Andy Reid had such a mixed reputation before the Mahomes era. Maybe McCarthy’s time is still to come
Mahomes saved andy Reid’s legacy. Now andy Reid is considered a genius
I thought Andy Reid was always pretty great as an Eagles coach but they botb clearly needed a new breath of fresh air.
@@BaldguyWifi now andy has always been considered a great coach. He took the eagles to 4 nfc championships with Mcnabb. Revitalized both Vicks career and Alex Smiths. In which he took both to the playoffs multiple times. Won games in playoffs with smith. Then took mahomes and made that man god like. Give mahomes urban Meyer dude would be out the league in two years. Mahomes has talent but Reid pushed that to the stars.
The fact McCarthy only won 1 SB with Rodgers is the largest robbery/biggest lose is atrocious
McCarthy is an amazing QB coach & OC but underachieved & was out coached in big games w/Rodgers. He appears to be strictly a coach for the Cowboys as opposed to truly running the team & his stated new reliance on analytics feels like it was gimmick to get the job. He made lots of money coaching the Packers so why would he want to spend so much time coaching in the NFL when he could possibly go find the next Aaron Rodgers? It’s like he took the Cowboys job to prove he could get another one.
It's a bit disingenuous to suggest the Packers were some kind of dumpster fire when McCarthy got there. Before the 4-12 season they'd been a perennial playoff team under Mike Sherman, who was basically proto-McCarthy in terms of his innate ability to mentally implode in high pressure situations. (The '04 Divisional Round loss to the Eagles is still my all time most miserable defeat as a Packers fan.)
McCarthy definitely does not get the credit he deserves for Rodgers' development. If he'd gone almost anyplace else in that draft, I highly doubt he'd have become the player he is today. I've long theorized that if Rodgers had been a 49er and Alex Smith a Packer, their careers might be reversed.
Ultimately he's an ok coach who got lucky with the talent he inherited and won at a much higher level than his ability indicates he should.
Fans trying to blackball him lol
As a packer fan he was carried by farve and Rodgers now he is getting exposed as a game manager and for a head coach you can’t have that kind of person at the head coaching position why is he hated? Because he never changed and when times changed we were left hanging want to talk about cooper rush but don’t want to talk about that defense that carries them we are most concerned with how Dak has gone from good to dud under mike
3:16 Reverse Robin Hood 😂😂😂😂😂
Just got off work opened UA-cam first thing I see fivepoints Vids. Bout to light a blunt. It’s gonna be a great day
McCarthy makes so many excuses, especially since he’s been with Dallas, it’s annoying. I’d scream if he coached my team.
Ever since he’s left nobody in green bay hates mike. He’s got a street named after him and we got us our only super bowl in 30 years. I like mike just fine, it was just time for a change and Lafleur is doing great
I think mike McCarthy is a good coach but he needs quality offensive and defensive coordinators, not a very good sceamer
He certainly gets a lot of hate for sure. Dealing with Favres huge ego, then Rodgers after must have been a nightmare to deal with in GB. He made some questionable decisions over the years and has had some bad luck to boot. Now he is in a situation where J Jones( Al Davis's fraternal twin) is making the decisions. Good luck with that.
10:00 Lol. No conference championships from 1996 to today
At least he could be carried by talent. McDaniels and Hackett can't even do that right.
He’s hated because he tries to give off Belichick energy but with none of the success. He had Rodgers in Green Bay and clearly he was hiding behind him.
LOL what? McCarthy was the one who developed Rodgers in the first place. It amazes me that people keep spewing this ignorant BS. Rodgers doesn't become what he is without McCarthy. Even Rodgers himself admits it.
Mike McCarthy is a overweight NFL coach playing his role in the Matrix
I think McCarthy did a great job in greenbay but you can only coach a team for so long before it fizzles out. The problem is that in Dallas it’s way too clear that his coordinators are way more important to the team’s success than he is
GB fan here. He deserves a ton of credit for GB success until the epic choke job against Seattle in 2014. After that the entire franchise went downhill until he was fired, including him/TT/AR. He is a really good coach Mon-Sat especially with keeping a team grinding week to week. Hard to say if he or AR or both ruined that relationship. But he's awful in-game and can't seem to adapt. He took the wrong traits from Marty Schottenheimer!
That game is not on McCarthy Rodgers was complete3ly AWOL in that game when the defense kept giving him the ball back and even then they win the game if an onside kick is recovered.
Everything went wrong that game. Still worst loss I've ever seen as a fan. Rodgers was part of it too.
Cowboys fans are frustrated. After coaches like Landry, Johnson, Switzer, and Parcells, they've had mediocrity with Campo, Phillips, and Garrett. McCarthy just looks like more of the same. The fans really need to look at their owner's box to see where the real dysfunction is. Jerry Jones runs the Cowboys as his hobby. If you were a star coach like Payton, McVey, or Shanahan, would you want to deal with Jerry Jones!?
He is the poster child of incompetence
Mike McCarthy only won a Superbowl because he had Aaron Rodgers. The Packers won despite having a trash head coach. McCarthy is a terrible HC.
Why is Mike McCarthy so disliked?
Answer: gone off the deep end in recent years. Dudes lost his touch. He isn't what he was.
Great vid btw
You my boi Five, I bet you got enough fromundercheese to make a pizza.
“Let’s state the facts: I’m a highly successful NFL coach" Coach McBlunder.
If Jason Garret could be the cowboys coach for 8 years, go 8-8 4 out of the 8 years and make only 2 playoffs, Mike McCarthy should be able to be Dallas coach until he dies
I think the main reason people don't like him was that he isn't that good in the Cowboys and many think he took undue credit for a Packers Super Bowl win.
Those people are idiots. McCarthy is the one who developed Rodgers which got them to the Super Bowl. Those clowns seem to forget that Rodgers was garbage his first two seasons and also had the":injury prone" label. They have rewritten history to where Rodgers was a HOF'r which he absolutely was not. McCarthy developed ROdgers through his "QB School" which was ended by the CBA that was signed in 2011, coincidentally the season after they won the Super Bowl and where McCarthy had a harder time developing QB's.
Anyone says McCarthy doesn't get credit for the Super Bowl win knows jnothing about football ,a Rodgers fanboy, or an ESPN clown.
i want mccarthy to succeed, it just always seems like he’s one step behind whatever team he’s facing, i want to see kellen moore get a shot at hc just bc why not
Mike nolan probably had more to do with ruining Smith than Mccarthy
I think being the coach of the Packers and Cowboys is pretty much just asking to be hated every season you don't win a Superbowl.
Yeah I don’t understand how cowboys fans can trash Mike McCarthy… when their previous coach was Jason Garrett
"Reverse Robin Hood" so simple, so good
McCarthy has his fair share of faults, not least of which was sticking by Dom Capers for far too long. But he does get more shit than he deserves.
2:58 trust me, coming from a Cowboys fan you didn’t break any news
This reality will HURT the Packer FANS - Aaron Rodgers won’t win another SUPERBOWL--so he better go ahead and appreciate MCCARTHY
Long answer- He’s trash
Short answer- He 🗑
it’s basically “what have you done for me lately?”
Lets also not forget that time he went after a ref at a high school basketball game in green bay
I always thought he was a good coach, and a lot of the hate is misplaced. With that said a lot of the criticism he gets is extremely warranted. His clock management and challenges are bad. He can instill a great high powered offense and if he has a good roster he knows what do with it. In Green Bay he got complacent
The reverse robin hood comment cracked me up lol
I just need to note that I had to pause and rewind at 6:18 because I misinterpreted “125-77 Record” as “1-25-77 record”
Getting 300+ wins: Amateur hour
Getting 77 ties: GOAT
It’s more than just relationships with players or stuff like that. If u watch a Cowboys game, there are constantly small things that always make it a little bit harder. Leading the league in penalties for two years is a coaching/discipline issue that hasn’t been able to be solved by McCarthy. He’s supposed to be an offensive minded HC but when it comes out that he doesn’t know the plays from his own offense, he fires it back to OC Kellen Moore and makes it his mistake and doesn’t own it. During the MNF game two weeks back, half the Giants roster was on the field with 8 seconds left in the half with the clock running, and it was McCarthy that called the TO, giving them a chance to get their personnel on the field to run one more play. If it wasn’t the Giants passing offense, it probably would’ve resulted in points. It’s constant these little things that add up and make it in ear impossible to see anything good coming from him.
Hey Bald! Has the Groosie Poosie passed you yet?
I like Mike McCarthy because I’m an Eagles fan and I want them to keep him for a long time.
To me, the biggest responsibilities for a head coach are clock management and player discipline (and maybe play calling to an extent if they want to have a role in that matter). What are some of the most common issues with McCarthy led football teams? Clock management, player discipline, and very questionable situational play calling. That's why I don't like him. He's the anti of every single thing that a head coach should be doing
Still shocked he never won another super bowl with the packers
I'll say this, the Packers and Cowboys are my number one and two most hated teams in the league so it's pretty easy for me to dislike him
The main issue I have with the McCarthy-led Cowboys is the absolutely unacceptable amount of penalties we keep drawing every year. We were worst in the league last year in both the number of penalties and penalty yards given up, and that contributed to our 1st round bounce in the playoffs.
True however they’ve been a lot better in that regard as of right now.
As a saints fan who watched him as our offensive coordinator, he has one way to play offense and it’s 4 verticals and it makes the QB look good
Look most frustration directed at McCarthy is really aimed at Jerry but we know Jerry isn't going anywhere so we hope that there will be a new coach with the backbone to tell Jerry to just sign the checks, tell them they're doing a good job and open a case of scotch when they have a good day.
He's holding us back a wild card appearance, biannual division win and either way a first round playoff exit is all he will ever achieve at the Cowboys. Please just go.
Mike McCarthy is my favorite part of going to the circus. Best clown in the country
Imagine having all the talent in the world, and you can only win 1 super bowl with 2, maybe 3, hall of fame qbs
rodgers was on the verge of being cut before mccarthy got hired in 2006 if it was for mccarthy rodgers wouldnt of had the career hes had
As a Cowboys fan I don't see what McCarthy brings to the team that is beneficial other than consistency? He is not much of an upgrade over Jason Garrett (though McCarthy is absolutely an upgrade over Jason Garrett). The Cowboys are still undisciplined, they still commit a lot of drive killing penalties, and the worst sin of all (at least from the standpoint of Cowboys fans), he hasn't won a playoff game. Cowboys fans will never love a coach who doesn't restore America's Team to its rightful place as Super Bowl competitors. Instead our recent playoff appearances have been largely down to how weak the NFC East has been until the 2022 season. We were practically guaranteed at least 4 to 6 wins a season from playing our division rivals twice (we would sometimes lose the odd fluke game). If McCarthy ever gets the Cowboys to the NFC Championship game at least then I think he will get a bit more credit. Until then he is Jerry's current stooge (you see the real reason we hate Mike McCarthy is because we all hate Jerry but we can't get rid of Jerry so we need to hate someone we can get rid of).
Because people love fat shaming
Where you at Scooter?!