Islamic banking as an ethical alternative | Made in Germany

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 лис 2012
  • Ugurlu Soylu, a bank manager of Turkish descent who lives in Germany, wants to launch an Islamic bank there. But he does not see it as a niche product solely for Muslim customers. He believes that the banking and financial crisis have spurred demand for a bank in which the investment model is based on goods and services with real commercial value.
    Report by Christian Uhlig.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @suldaanmohamedosman1592
    @suldaanmohamedosman1592 5 років тому +39

    In Somalia our Banks do like that.
    In Islamic religion never allowed Interest.

  • @Accountingplus
    @Accountingplus 5 років тому +45

    Next banker system is Islamic banking system.

    • @macroger3277
      @macroger3277 3 роки тому +2

      In your dreams

    • @irix5093
      @irix5093 3 роки тому

      @@macroger3277 Why? I admit that it is really too ambitious and aware of the social problems. But is it really impossible?

    • @anythingfaizul2519
      @anythingfaizul2519 3 роки тому

      @@macroger3277 transparency in banking system is for all of us,

    • @gabriela3174
      @gabriela3174 3 роки тому +1

      the heathens will be destroy as the is written so shall it be

  • @ahmednaeem5966
    @ahmednaeem5966 4 роки тому +8

    It prohibits lending loose money. Loose money financing is root cause of evils in society.

  • @llaease
    @llaease 11 років тому +12

    Thank you for this informative video that mentioned the details of the islamic banking .

  • @charlessmyth
    @charlessmyth 11 років тому +2

    Thanks :-)

  • @saterdraj6768
    @saterdraj6768 5 років тому +15

    I don't get it. Obviously the 'service charge' will be the same as the interest in other banks. And what does the bank being a partner in the risk mean?

    • @wildwilly4266
      @wildwilly4266 5 років тому +11

      It means nothing - they add the risk to the service fee - pure word tricks to fool Allah

    • @roberthannah7983
      @roberthannah7983 4 роки тому +7

      You are right. Same idea as the bank taking collateral in a conventional mortgage. Same risk profile.

    • @cangjie12
      @cangjie12 4 роки тому +11

      It means that the interest you pay is calculated as a proportion of your future profits, rather than a percentage of the amount borrowed. This means that it takes into account your ability to pay back. So it is good for the borrower. If your business doesn’t do well, you won’t be excessively burdened by interest payments.

    • @abdullahyahia1985
      @abdullahyahia1985 4 роки тому

      The is being a partner in the risk in almost all banking transactions.

    • @notmimul
      @notmimul 3 роки тому +4

      Service charge is better as it shows the full amount you are going to pay them. Interest doesn’t know the amount you have to pay.

  • @Hasansaid51
    @Hasansaid51 5 років тому +8

    At 2:11
    When they state “shares customers risks”
    What exactly do they mean.
    Can anyone help me using the car example
    Please and thank you

    • @samkhodr9975
      @samkhodr9975 5 років тому +7

      Well i don't know exactly what he meant but let me try to give some examples.
      When the bank buys the car then the borrower doesn't have to take the car and can for whatever reason, (such as getting sick, changing his mind or getting struck by poverty) opt out.
      If the man is late for the agreed-upon payment deadline(such as when he is struck by poverty)
      then he doesn't have to pay a penalty or fee(this is riba) and the bank may make a loss.
      If the person saves the money and then the bank decides to sell it someone else, then the borrower can't by the car.
      This is how murbaha works, to my knowledge. Asalalm alaikum.

    • @Hasansaid51
      @Hasansaid51 5 років тому

      Sam Khodr ohhhhhhh I get it

    • @samkhodr9975
      @samkhodr9975 5 років тому +5

      @@Hasansaid51 Fast response,akhi. Hehe
      May allah reward you for trying to seek knowledge.
      Never stop seeking knowledge and go to the people of knowledge (imam/ulema/musheikh) because I am just a layman with very little
      knowledge.
      Asalam aleikum.

    • @Hasansaid51
      @Hasansaid51 5 років тому +1

      Sam Khodr you at least got more knowledge than I lol. Thanks for clarification

    • @samkhodr9975
      @samkhodr9975 5 років тому

      ua-cam.com/video/A8jhfuLJPT8/v-deo.html

  • @ImperialKaiserk
    @ImperialKaiserk 11 років тому +8

    InshALLAH

  • @roberthannah7983
    @roberthannah7983 4 роки тому +5

    If you are really interested in ethics then implement socially responsible investing - ESG investing - environment, social responsibility, and good corporate governance.

    • @Rifatbinmaruf
      @Rifatbinmaruf 3 роки тому

      I'm surprised this is not as popular as it should be

  • @gabriela3174
    @gabriela3174 3 роки тому +5

    so sad to see this. our ancestors fought tooth and nail against this regime. they would be turning in there graves. omg so sad

  • @roch.el_
    @roch.el_ 2 роки тому

    I wonder where he's at today

  • @AjinkyaGaikwad-zc1wu
    @AjinkyaGaikwad-zc1wu 3 роки тому +1

    Caner is spreading in Deutschland

    • @Pajeetkiller.2789
      @Pajeetkiller.2789 Рік тому

      Angry violent vegetarian bot

    • @humzanafees9348
      @humzanafees9348 11 місяців тому +1

      Guys ignore my son here. He’s just a dog who barks constantly 😂

  • @Fundamental_Islam.
    @Fundamental_Islam. 7 місяців тому

    Loopholes?

  • @charlessmyth
    @charlessmyth 11 років тому +3

    Beyond the irregular demand deposit, the money that you can withdraw at any time, banks lend your savings/invested money, to other people, on the basis that you will be compensated for the inconvenience of that money being unavailable to you for a contracted period of time. Outside the Islamic world, you have the right to not bank with an Islamic bank, and/or directly lend or gift money on terms that do not involve coercion. Islamic banking is coercion over your property of money.

  • @wildwilly4266
    @wildwilly4266 5 років тому +5

    Semantics - interest is the same as renting - All banks share in risk

    • @user-im8wb6vn5n
      @user-im8wb6vn5n 4 роки тому +1

      Anas, möge Gott mit ihm zufrieden sein, sagte: "Alles ist schön. Du hast gesehen. Du hast noch nie etwas Schöneres gesehen als den Gesandten Gottes, mögen Gottes Gebete und Friede auf ihm sein."Abu Hurairah, möge Gott mit ihm zufrieden sein, sagte: Ich habe noch nie etwas Besseres gesehen als den Gesandten Gottes, möge Gott ihn segnen und ihm Frieden gewähren, als ob die Sonne laufen würde. Und mit dem Wort: Er kommt aus seinem Gesicht Der Gesandte Gottes, möge Gottes Gebet und Friede auf ihm sein, beschrieb mir: "Mein Sohn, wenn ich ihn gesehen hätte, wäre die Sonne aufgegangen." Und Tariq Bin Ubaid, möge Gott mit ihm zufrieden sein, sagte: Wir kamen mit Dhu'ina mit uns, bis wir uns der Stadt näherten, also kam der Gesandte Gottes, möge Gottes Gebete und Friede auf ihm sein, zu uns.Ich habe noch nie jemanden gesehen, der das Gefühl hat, dass die Haare des Kopfes, die das Ohrläppchen in einem roten Anzug überschreiten, besser sind als der Gesandte Gottes, möge Gott ihn segnen und ihm Frieden gewähren Abu Hurairah, möge Gott mit ihm zufrieden sein, sagte: Der Gesandte Gottes, möge Gott ihn segnen und ihm Frieden gewähren, war das beste und schönste Attribut Und Tariq Bin Ubaid, möge Gott mit ihm zufrieden sein, sagte: Wir kamen mit Dhu'ina mit uns, bis wir uns der Stadt näherten, also kam der Gesandte Gottes, möge Gottes Gebete und Friede auf ihm sein, zu uns. Gott sandte einen Propheten, aber eine gut gesprochene, gut gesprochene Stimme, und dein Prophet war das beste Gesicht und die beste Stimme Ich sah den Gesandten Gottes, möge Gottes Gebet und Friede in der Nacht von Adhyan mit einem roten Anzug auf ihm sein. Ähnlichkeit zwischen ihm und dem Mond Gesicht wie der Mond in der Vollmondnacht von seinem Gesicht, Friede sei mit ihm

  • @jesus-iscoming-soon7665
    @jesus-iscoming-soon7665 4 роки тому +3

    WOW IMAM WITH CROSS ON HIS CHEST !
    FOLLOWING STRAIGHT PATH BUT BACKWARDS 🤣😂

  • @Darkknight-st5md
    @Darkknight-st5md 2 роки тому

    germany is a best country Europe for live with their own relagion..thanqu turkey and germany both

  • @roberthannah7983
    @roberthannah7983 5 років тому +6

    Islamic finance advocates make these vague statements about equity and social justice. However the discussion we see from Islamic scholars revolves around obscure grammatical interpretations of the meaning of riba and whether money is a commodity (an Aristotelian concept!). They also struggle to design sharia compliant copies of conventional instruments that are usually more expensive. Meanwhile, secular regulators do the tough work of ensuring consumer protection, fairness and transparency in disclosure, and efficiency with competition promoting lower costs -- issues that really mean something to consumers.

    • @mohamedalhabsi6948
      @mohamedalhabsi6948 5 років тому

      ua-cam.com/video/mQUhJTxK5mA/v-deo.html

    • @roberthannah7983
      @roberthannah7983 5 років тому +3

      @@mohamedalhabsi6948 Your video seems to be a lot of incoherent conspiracy theory mumbo jumbo.

    • @QF756
      @QF756 4 роки тому

      Robert Hannah
      Stop your bs!

    • @sksiam9102
      @sksiam9102 3 роки тому

      @@QF756 Those are so call Westerns ill nackers

    • @Muhammad_Wahyudhi
      @Muhammad_Wahyudhi 2 роки тому

      Reductionist approach.

  • @charlessmyth
    @charlessmyth 11 років тому +1

    So did Stalin's NKVD, Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge's 'Year Zero' and Hitler's Nazis' 'Kraft durch Freude' social programmes, but that doesn't make 'social responsibility' via coercion right. Right? "Other people's property was used to invest in your personal growth and now you have a problem investing in others?" This is the dramatic irony of the moral hazard of social responsibility via democracy.

    • @AlphaMaverick1111
      @AlphaMaverick1111 3 роки тому

      Banks create the money supply. Professor Richard Werner proved this in an empirical study. Bank deposits are not loaned out.

  • @etakappa
    @etakappa Рік тому

    Halal Pork

  • @charlessmyth
    @charlessmyth 11 років тому +3

    To stay on topic: Turkey's Islamic banking is permitted in Germany, but our banking is prohibited in Turkey. This is akin to Albania under the fist of Enver Hoxha who forcibly prevented his fellow Albanians from suffering the evils of the west.

  • @usmanjaved6412
    @usmanjaved6412 6 років тому +3

    islamic bank give made pakistan all country

  • @hamidhshaikh5707
    @hamidhshaikh5707 5 років тому +5

    It is as rediculous and baseless as Gender Studies.

    • @alphaman7713
      @alphaman7713 3 роки тому +9

      Such baseless as your knowledge

  • @foundthetruth2003
    @foundthetruth2003 2 роки тому +2

    Islam and ethical, isn’t that an oxymoron?