@@el.c.8858 Yes.. Her eyes are the best feature of her face.. But all her featured are well defined.. It's really refreshing to watch someone like that when everyone has delicate features.. I bet she'll be so hot than now in 3 years or so...
Her stage presence is just insane. Her position is main vocalist but she nailed the dance too. She also looks enjoying herself being on the stage. Everything about NingNing is just so perfect!
Yess I feel like you can see so much in her eyes, and she inseed seems to enjoy herself so much! I keep trying to put into words what makes her stand out in my eyes amongst the other members and I finally know so thank you😂
Jensetters here to support Red Velvet’s little sister 🥺✨ The baetokki’s and the jensetters have been close friends for as long as we can remember; let’s support NingNing 😍💖
She just debuted but Ningning is so professional. She was bleeding from her knee and her shoes weren’t zipped up all the way, yet she’s still slayed. Honestly it took me a lot of times of watching this fancam to realize all this things were happening but her expressions were on point.
does she bleed on her knee? everytime she put her knee on the floor (2x in the chorus) that spot grows bigger.. but her expression is still the best one.
@@Eireneist I agree, no hate to karina (she’s actually my bias wrecker, ningning is my bias) but the way the debut-and the majority of content leading up to it-has been hyper focused on her seems very favoritism-esque , and that only serves to cause division within the fandom and create member-hating solo stans. But I also heard that the debut is purposely karina focused because every member is meant have their own eras that will focus on them and introduce their ae counterparts, while continuing to establish aespa’s lore and universe. We’ll just have to wait and see what sm has in store i guess .
ningning isn’t just an artist, she's a lifestyle, a reason to breathe, an escape from this cruel world filled with thieves. she's an art, the first gift you open on christmas, a hug from a loved one, everything you’ve ever wanted, everything you need
lol did you steal this, I literally saw the same comment about Wendy under her new ost video from a few days ago... but who knows if that person stole it from someone else as well...
Unpopular opinion: she’s the best dancer in Aespa. Her moves don’t look forced at all. They look smooth and connected. She knows when to put more force in and when to let loose, she doesn’t look stiff at all! The other girls are just as talented as she is but I do think she’s the best dancer in the group.
why is she not the main dancer then? oh because actual professionals that have watched and trained them know she isn't the best lmao y'all LOVE discrediting karina so much
i wouldn't say she is the best dancer rather she executes certain dance moves better and calmer for example this 0:40 all the members looked awkward but ningning is not.
After watching every member fancam, despite being main vocalist, i think ningning dance the best for this black mamba choreo. 1. Her facial expressions is the fiercest, which suit black mamba concept (black mamba being the most poisonous snake) 2. I don't know how to put it, but she put more strength and power at the end of her every move, so her moves looks bigger and carry more strength especially when she did this move 1:38 - 1:40 3. She really exudes confident, despite being the youngest. Maybe because she train the longest among the member. Really love her confident here I wish the cameramen can capture her expression more.
@ nip & clit No her boot's zipper had a problem for sure. they all were wearing the same shoes and she seemed so uncomfortable with them! But still she did amazing
yes, I watched all the fancam, I feel that her dance have the most power out of all members. Maybe she have abit lesser control than Karina . Nevertheless, she is still the QUEEN. Moreover she is still the main vocalist LOL👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
She's dancing more powerfully to hide the fact that her technique is worse than her fellow members', but she's still very good and her vocals....man they're insane, especially for a rookie
@@kkk6281 Winter is definitely the best after Karina (well, she's a lead dancer, after all), and Giselle and Ningning are pretty close but have different strengths and weaknesses I think, so it might be arguable wether NN is 3rd or 4th But I think that NingNing is either first or second in terms of facials (I watched fancams of all girls and thought that her facials are super cool, hers are my personal favs among æspa), which can also make her look like a greater dancer than she actually is:D (same with JinSoul from LOONA, for example)
Just to make sure, are the people under this comment ok? Like I know y’all are biased as sh’t, but are the harsh judgements necessary? Your microaggressive comments and backhanded compliments are what make idols literally break themselves to pieces to satisfy your unrealistic standards. Please save them to yourselves and let everyone else give her genuine praises where deserved.
Didn’t even realize her boots weren’t fully zipped up all the way till now from watching the fancam.. you can see she stumbled a little at the beginning and again at the end, i hope this won’t happen again
Ik, it was the first thing I noticed when I watched it live. You'd think the stylist would of made sure they were zipped since the beginning is like a freeze frame. I wanted to watch her fancam to see if she was having trouble 😔 I didnt even notice her stumble towards the end during the preformance
@@nellydahn254 I noticed a few minutes ago in the full cam, that Giselle has a bandaid on her left knee (but to the viewer it would be the right) at first I thought it was bruise, I was so busy looking at how they dropped and NingNing's shoes that I noticed Giselle 😩 what is going on
Omg i just noticed! I thought it was just the style of her boots! But looking at the other members', ningning's was really unzipped. She was also stumbling (a little bit) during her part in the bridge. It's a good thing her boots stayed despite their choreo (esp in the chorus).
@@TheCarina1201 yea, I think they need to tweak the choreography a little bit, at least not make them drop to their knees because if they keep promoting that could damage their kneecaps. Kinda like how they changed Ice Cream Cake choreo, they made it easier because the dance before includes rolling at the ground
My eyes are so confused. She looks like Victoria, Jennie and Joy at some points. Also during the “the boys” move, her eyes are so piercing and she’s smirking but it looks sweet but deadly at the same time???
Her knee from beginning already has a scar but not bleeding, and dance she dances off to floor TWICE and the bleeding starts, BUT SHE DOESN'T EVEN BUDGE!! HER EXPRESSION, HER ENERGY, I almost focusing on her knee in this video and her legs too keep dancing ENERGETICALLY OMGGGGG NINGNING 😭
I can feel the pain. I remember when we were practicing for our cheerdance and we have a lot of steps that requires kneeling, my knees got bruises on every part of my knee and it's really painful to dance and even though you're in pain you need to perform. Kneeling while having those bruises is really painful what more Ningning's is bleeding already. Ningning showed how pro she is despite being a rookie.
What I like about Ningning is that she's not the typical Idol, she has the chubby cheeks that makes her look cute, her toned and a bit curvy body makes her stand out
NINGNING HAVE A WOUND ON HER RIGHT KNEE PROBABLY BECAUSE OF THE CHOREO PLUS SHE HAVE HER BOOTS UNZIPPED BUT SHE SLAYED THIS PERFORMANCE WITH STAGE PRESENCE UNTIL THE END!!! WE ARE PROUD OF YOU NINGNING!!!
@@speckqlaas8714 just search Ningning predebut, there's an interview with her father. She's so close with him, her father is tone deaf but look where Ningning is now, she can become the main vocalist.
Her facial expression is really good. She looks like she really enjoys performing. Her vocal is really high and she also dances well. I'm so happu she finally debut! Also, I noticed that her knee is bleeding. Take care Ningning!
@@shookedshooky2252 It looks she's maybe still getting comfortable to the heels. The unzipping could be intentional if she felt the boots were were too constricting around here ankles zipped. Still though, there has to be moments where it gets unnerving and too loose - so she is being really professional nonetheless - I mean, it takes a lot to continue dancing with your shoes like that.
NingNing deserves so much support, she's a *monster* *rookie* and an *icon* at the same time. Stan this baby!!! Edit:She actually has a wound on her knee and her boot in the beginning wasn't zipped. I guess I didn't notice it bcs she still slayed.
Ningning, I know that you will come here to monitor your own fancam again to improve in the future. If you are reading this, please know that we love you as well as other members and we will patiently wait for aespa to come back. You did so well for this debut stage and you deserve all the best, my lovely~
I've watched all fan cams of the members, yet from ningning i can't take my eyes from. She's truly mesmerizing and makes you never look away from her. She's amazing, and I think she's my bias.
She is the only one who falls on her arms for that spider man pose. She is the only one among the girls who is capable of putting her whole weight on her arms. She visibly has a lot of body strength as compared to others and I personally love the way she delivers every move❤️
Her heels got problem too.... at 2:18 she couldn't even walk properly because her heels didn't zip...I'm so heartbroken by this. Couldn't even imagine how she cope with all the problems but even managed to smile so brightly. Nobody even noticed abt her shoe's problem...😾
Yeah she does!!! I mean since she was young she dreamed to be an idol and glad that she achieved it just hoping that she will eeceive a lot of love especially Korean fans
maybe she's the reason people believe that there's something lacking in the music industry lately? but she's here to healing them and that's literally eargasm
![[K-Fancam] 에스파 닝닝 직캠 'Armageddon'(aespa NINGNING Fancam) @뮤직뱅크(Music Bank) 240531](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/skUf4baZpHY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[K-Fancam] 에스파 닝닝 직캠 'Armageddon'(aespa NINGNING Fancam) @뮤직뱅크(Music Bank) 240531](/img/tr.png)
ningning doesn't look like a newly debut idol, she's overflowing with confidence!
Yess
She trained for 4 years waiting for this day and she's talented and beautiful
Vote on starplay!!!!!
she was singing at the stage in china ( maybe audition ) before she became sm’s trainee so that’s why
Ikr that is why i like her
난 닝닝이가 제일 좋아ㅎㅎ 처음 봤을때부터 눈에 확 띄었어 화이팅
Ningning main vocalist who’s also a good dancer! Her facial expressions are also good!
True
i know righttt
i agree
omg yess, most vocalists arent really gifted with dancing skills AND THATS ALRIGHT,, but ningning dances so naturally
Lead dance material
She's the only one that really stands out tbh. Visually, vocally, facial expression, & dancing as well.
Right that why she my bias and I love her period she all rounder idol perfection💖💕
she’s such an all-rounder: she has the visuals, dance skills, and vocals. i’m so happy that she finally debuted, hope sm doesn’t waste her potential
And her expressions in that floor step.. She looked like a real snake..
@@mansininixo1441 yeah her eyes are really captivating, it was the first thing i noticed alongside her voice obviously lmao
@@el.c.8858 Yes.. Her eyes are the best feature of her face.. But all her featured are well defined.. It's really refreshing to watch someone like that when everyone has delicate features.. I bet she'll be so hot than now in 3 years or so...
@@mansininixo1441 watch her be one of the hottest idols in the next few years, those haters will eat the things they said.
@@cespaa6599 What?? She has haters already??
She's best in everything, SM won't get worried if she's even doing solo,
stating fact
@@peaches7181 i hope, she's really worth it
@@peaches7181 it might take a few years but they sure will
Yesss
@@peaches7181Sad to say.I think the Chinese members from SM will eventually leave SM and become a soloist in China...
Ningning is the main vocal who dances like main dancer and her visual is ethereal..ningning world domination
In My opinion she has the best stage presence and expressions
Agree
true
Completely agree...she and Giselle deserves much more views than this
Of course
Agree 100%
Her stage presence is just insane. Her position is main vocalist but she nailed the dance too. She also looks enjoying herself being on the stage. Everything about NingNing is just so perfect!
I KNOW RIGHT!!! she definitely deserves more recognition!
her voice is really unique too!!
Yess I feel like you can see so much in her eyes, and she inseed seems to enjoy herself so much! I keep trying to put into words what makes her stand out in my eyes amongst the other members and I finally know so thank you😂
It doesn’t look like she’s dancing a routine, she looks like she’s actually doing what she likes the most and like she’s having the time of her life
I did not expect she can dance this goodd. Goshh she can easily be a main dancer
NINGNING is the combination of Victoria, Joy, and Jennie. A all-rounder idol. So proud of our last SM Rookies
Go go steaming
Trueeee
you forgot minnie
And aisha awwww
finally someone mention jennie TT i can see joy and jennie in her face. cuteee
After watching their individual fancams, I'm really impressed by Ningning's expression when the chorus drops. Her eyes are so fierce!
Ikr! Even the camera is not focused on her, she still have that fierce expression. 🙌
I got gooosebumpp!!
She has the most expressive eyes compared to the other three. I really like her eyes
Trueeee! Her eyes look like Victoria. So fierce!
True indeed. After watching all fancam, she literally caught my attention with her fiercing glare.
No one talking about how strong she is , look she hurt her knee there is blood on it but she still slay the dance
Queen since the debut
yes i see the blood
@@jesslynalicia9929 time stamp on the blood pls
@@johnathanadams7763 well i dont know
@@johnathanadams7763 0:51
@@mariaanamargaritamiguel7227 i don’t see it, i just see the dot on her knee
She's main vocalist but her dance + stage presence and facial expression is really good
Like Wendy, Taeyeon and Luna. Royal SM family
and the fact that she’s the maknae
For me currently she’s the best dancer in the group and her facial expressions and confidence are on a different level
Yes i like her dance. Her moves are queen
That just shows how well rounded this group is
Ikr she's really clean and powerful plus her facial expression is the best
Better than the main dancer?
her stage presence and aura is unmatched. she embodies the whole thing from her insane vocals to her flawless dancing
Jensetter!!!
Jensetters here to support Ningning 🙋♀️💕She looks like JENNIE somehow and she said JENNIE is her favorite member
Jensetters here to support Red Velvet’s little sister 🥺✨ The baetokki’s and the jensetters have been close friends for as long as we can remember; let’s support NingNing 😍💖
Omg ty Jensetters for supporting Ningning 🤍
@@RealEllieGaming np she is a QUEEN just like our Jennie unnie
She just debuted but Ningning is so professional. She was bleeding from her knee and her shoes weren’t zipped up all the way, yet she’s still slayed. Honestly it took me a lot of times of watching this fancam to realize all this things were happening but her expressions were on point.
does she bleed on her knee? everytime she put her knee on the floor (2x in the chorus) that spot grows bigger.. but her expression is still the best one.
the next time SM give her more center time, istg she’ll be everyone’s bias wrecker because this girl has potential🙀
she got my attention but mv was like Karina and girls. I hope next mv would be different
@@Eireneist I agree, no hate to karina (she’s actually my bias wrecker, ningning is my bias) but the way the debut-and the majority of content leading up to it-has been hyper focused on her seems very favoritism-esque , and that only serves to cause division within the fandom and create member-hating solo stans.
But I also heard that the debut is purposely karina focused because every member is meant have their own eras that will focus on them and introduce their ae counterparts, while continuing to establish aespa’s lore and universe. We’ll just have to wait and see what sm has in store i guess .
sm didn't give her much center time yet still being 2nd most popular member😌 her power
@@user-zu5bw7qx6b ikr😌 just wait till she has her own era and boom Ningning the next IT girl
@@user-zu5bw7qx6b who's the most popular member
HER VISUAL HER DANCE HER VOCALS HER ATTITUDE HER EXPRESSION HER EVERYTHING SHE HAS IT ALL NINGNING ACE STAN NINGNING!
She has the most expressive eyes compared to the other three. I really like her eyes
Yes I agree
Ikr!!
Yes her eyes are very captivating
개인적으로 레드벨벳에선 조이가 제일 끌렸는데 에스파에선 닝닝이 너무 예쁨ㅜㅜ
인정이요 ㅜ 사람들은 카리나가 이쁘다고 하는데 닝닝도 미치게 이쁘고 노래도 잘하는데....ㅜ
난줄 나랑 똑같네요
둘이 은근 닮은거 같은데 나만 그런가
헐 나도
저두.. 울 닝닝이 넘 귀엽
She is synching her move and her expression. It makes everything move feel alive
She's really an ACE. Main vocalist with a good dance and facial expressions is really amazing. Our last girl standing from SMrookies. Ningning🦋
ningning isn’t just an artist, she's a lifestyle, a reason to breathe, an escape from this cruel world filled with thieves. she's an art, the first gift you open on christmas, a hug from a loved one, everything you’ve ever wanted, everything you need
lol did you steal this, I literally saw the same comment about Wendy under her new ost video from a few days ago... but who knows if that person stole it from someone else as well...
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 It's very common, I see this comment on like every Facebook post on aespa's page
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 lol this comment is actually everywhere . it is just for fun
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 lol it just a template, u can see that word everywhere in twt.
@@anonymoushue ohh I see, my bad
난 닝닝이 제일 좋더라.. 얼굴이 안정감 있다고 해야되나..? 그냥 얼굴형 너무 예쁘고.. 루키즈 영상 몇년 전 3~4개 본게 다인데 데뷔하자마자 걔 아니야? 하고 알아볼 정도로 개성있음
first ningning’s fancam ever! legendary🤲🏼
Waowww
she's really an angel she is not giving up i love her
If she goes fierce, she goes fierce. I'm honestly impressed by her facial expression. That's the first thing I noticed to her actually.
Unpopular opinion: she’s the best dancer in Aespa. Her moves don’t look forced at all. They look smooth and connected. She knows when to put more force in and when to let loose, she doesn’t look stiff at all! The other girls are just as talented as she is but I do think she’s the best dancer in the group.
as a dancer, i agree 100%
why is she not the main dancer then? oh because actual professionals that have watched and trained them know she isn't the best lmao y'all LOVE discrediting karina so much
She's actually the main vocal 😘
Anyway aespa are aces ❤️
@@rubyjane2993 stonk
i wouldn't say she is the best dancer rather she executes certain dance moves better and calmer for example this 0:40 all the members looked awkward but ningning is not.
After watching every member fancam, despite being main vocalist, i think ningning dance the best for this black mamba choreo.
1. Her facial expressions is the fiercest, which suit black mamba concept (black mamba being the most poisonous snake)
2. I don't know how to put it, but she put more strength and power at the end of her every move, so her moves looks bigger and carry more strength especially when she did this move 1:38 - 1:40
3. She really exudes confident, despite being the youngest. Maybe because she train the longest among the member. Really love her confident here
I wish the cameramen can capture her expression more.
How long she being a trainee?
@@moodywritr406 4 years
@@Bambi-ek7lv i've ever read that winter being a trainee for 5 years. Is that true?
@@Bambi-ek7lv anyway thanks for the answer. Ningning is my bias btw 🥰🥰🥰 i'm so adore her vocal, so strong, high and ofcourse very unique
ho oh setuju
Why nobody’s talking that her shoes were unzipped and she still did a great performance
I think if she zipped up completely, the shoes will hurt her when she went down on the chorus part.
@ nip & clit
No her boot's zipper had a problem for sure. they all were wearing the same shoes and she seemed so uncomfortable with them!
But still she did amazing
No but seriously, she is actually main dancer material. Her power, charisma and attention to details are impeccable.
yes, I watched all the fancam, I feel that her dance have the most power out of all members. Maybe she have abit lesser control than Karina . Nevertheless, she is still the QUEEN. Moreover she is still the main vocalist LOL👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
She's dancing more powerfully to hide the fact that her technique is worse than her fellow members', but she's still very good and her vocals....man they're insane, especially for a rookie
Lisa her dancing is just not as good as Karina and better than other 2
@@kkk6281 Winter is definitely the best after Karina (well, she's a lead dancer, after all), and Giselle and Ningning are pretty close but have different strengths and weaknesses I think, so it might be arguable wether NN is 3rd or 4th
But I think that NingNing is either first or second in terms of facials (I watched fancams of all girls and thought that her facials are super cool, hers are my personal favs among æspa), which can also make her look like a greater dancer than she actually is:D (same with JinSoul from LOONA, for example)
Just to make sure, are the people under this comment ok? Like I know y’all are biased as sh’t, but are the harsh judgements necessary? Your microaggressive comments and backhanded compliments are what make idols literally break themselves to pieces to satisfy your unrealistic standards. Please save them to yourselves and let everyone else give her genuine praises where deserved.
2:17 Ningning's high note right there is what sold this song to me, Aespa is be a world hit
She's only 18 but look so mature. She have a cat like eyes, her aura is something i can't explain.
Yeah
She is just 18 ?
Face
its crazy to think that she's only 18 years old
@@no19key yeah she was born in 2002
She’s not just a main vocal, she’s is both main vocal and Main dancer.
i see...and she's sooo pretty!!
And visual!!!!
Didn’t even realize her boots weren’t fully zipped up all the way till now from watching the fancam.. you can see she stumbled a little at the beginning and again at the end, i hope this won’t happen again
Ik, it was the first thing I noticed when I watched it live. You'd think the stylist would of made sure they were zipped since the beginning is like a freeze frame. I wanted to watch her fancam to see if she was having trouble 😔 I didnt even notice her stumble towards the end during the preformance
@@TheCarina1201 and now the black dot on her knee that wasn’t there before or in any of her fansite pics... I’m so confused
@@nellydahn254 I noticed a few minutes ago in the full cam, that Giselle has a bandaid on her left knee (but to the viewer it would be the right) at first I thought it was bruise, I was so busy looking at how they dropped and NingNing's shoes that I noticed Giselle 😩 what is going on
Omg i just noticed! I thought it was just the style of her boots! But looking at the other members', ningning's was really unzipped. She was also stumbling (a little bit) during her part in the bridge. It's a good thing her boots stayed despite their choreo (esp in the chorus).
@@TheCarina1201 yea, I think they need to tweak the choreography a little bit, at least not make them drop to their knees because if they keep promoting that could damage their kneecaps. Kinda like how they changed Ice Cream Cake choreo, they made it easier because the dance before includes rolling at the ground
She deserve all the position main dancer main vocalist main visual
Agree she perfection period👑💅💖💕💗
The zipper of her boots is too open, luckily she did not lose her balance.
she nearly did at 2:18 ... luckily she didn't fall
@@youn7688 yes i saw it too
She have a scar too 2:18
@@felixsfreckles6787 notice how the scar wasn't there until she went down on her knee in the first chorus... it must've been so painful
@@EX-xb5yd the scab on her knee was already there but i think that she scraped it while dancing :/
My eyes are so confused. She looks like Victoria, Jennie and Joy at some points. Also during the “the boys” move, her eyes are so piercing and she’s smirking but it looks sweet but deadly at the same time???
Her knee from beginning already has a scar but not bleeding, and dance she dances off to floor TWICE and the bleeding starts, BUT SHE DOESN'T EVEN BUDGE!! HER EXPRESSION, HER ENERGY, I almost focusing on her knee in this video and her legs too keep dancing ENERGETICALLY OMGGGGG NINGNING 😭
Ikr!! 😭😭
omg! I hope she's okay!
Omg i didn’t notice. I was too focused on her gaze. Hopefully it doesn’t hurt too much. That move is rough
I can feel the pain. I remember when we were practicing for our cheerdance and we have a lot of steps that requires kneeling, my knees got bruises on every part of my knee and it's really painful to dance and even though you're in pain you need to perform. Kneeling while having those bruises is really painful what more Ningning's is bleeding already. Ningning showed how pro she is despite being a rookie.
And SM had the audacity to not put her in the dance line 🤦♂️
ningning’s visuals are no joke, and she is one of the most expression idols, such a well rounder face, not boring, and unforgetable!
A main vocalist with overflowing energy and charisma. Vocal, facial expression, dancing skills and stage presence on point!
she doesn't even look like a rookie wow look at her presence
Yeah
눈빛 너무 좋다
여유 독기 장난끼 당당함 모든게 다 들어있음
노래도 뚫어뻥인줄 가슴 뻥뚫림
그동안 스엠상에서 볼 수 없던 고양이상임.. 제니랑 전반적 인상이 비슷한듯. 특히 눈이랑 얼굴형
오 진짜 제니느낌 잇다
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
제니+민니 느낌도 있다고 생각함
NINGNING OH MY GOD MY GIRL I WANNA CRY AS SOMEONE WHO’S SUPPORTED YOU SINCE PREDEBUT I’M SO SO PROUD OF YOU
She stands out. Not only her vocals. Her dance is very good too, very powerfull.
Agree. She was the first to catch my eye
This is an iconic debut fancam. Ningning is a goddess I'm so impressed how talented and pretty she is. Support Ningning!
울 닝이가 데뷔한 무대영상 가끔보러오는데 매번신발 지퍼가 저렇게 열려있는데도 실수한번 내색한번 없이 완벽한 무대를 해내려고 뒤에서 얼마나 노력했을까라는 생각이 듦 어린나이에 타국에와서 혼자 꿈을 향해서 노력했을 그 시간이랑 열정들이 대단한것같음 닝아 항상 응원해❤️❤️
I know ningning is so talented and pretty but her expressions, charisma and even her smirk are such another level! 🙌
What I like about Ningning is that she's not the typical Idol, she has the chubby cheeks that makes her look cute, her toned and a bit curvy body makes her stand out
Huhu yes her baby fats well she’s only 18 tho
@@lalisa7865 that's okay, I kinda liking it, not the standard beauty for an Idol but she's still perfectly amazing
Yes, she's so cute (｡･ω･｡)ﾉ♡
True. So pretty
it's the jennie and joy print I love it 🥰🥰🥰
NINGNING HAVE A WOUND ON HER RIGHT KNEE PROBABLY BECAUSE OF THE CHOREO PLUS SHE HAVE HER BOOTS UNZIPPED BUT SHE SLAYED THIS PERFORMANCE WITH STAGE PRESENCE UNTIL THE END!!! WE ARE PROUD OF YOU NINGNING!!!
A true professional queen 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
I was looking for this comment
I stan the right person 💚
I was wondering what that mark was
Wtf that bruish seems painfull
이유는 모르겠는데 자꾸 직캠 뜨면 보러 오게됨ㅋㅋㅋ
I still hate how the camera didn't focus on her when she hit the highnotes. Smh
same with you ㅠㅠ
It happens to Wendy all the time as well! Tje camera man hates Main Vocals 🤣🤣🤣
@@eyebrowstj so true😭 why do cameraman hates main vocalists so much
sameeee t____t
Feel u🥺😭
Wasn’t NingNing super close with her father? Imagine how proud her dad is right now
For all years she is waiting (she even being the only SM rookies same time with Yeri) she deserves the best.
How do you even know that... lol
@@speckqlaas8714 she joined a singing contest in china twice. and her dad is always there to support her
Yeahh must be super proud❤️
@@speckqlaas8714 just search Ningning predebut, there's an interview with her father. She's so close with him, her father is tone deaf but look where Ningning is now, she can become the main vocalist.
Her facial expression is really good. She looks like she really enjoys performing. Her vocal is really high and she also dances well. I'm so happu she finally debut! Also, I noticed that her knee is bleeding. Take care Ningning!
Ningning is so pretty. Her voice is powerful too.
닝닝...이름도 귀여워...닝닝
She's a pro. She wasn't even bothered by the unzipped shoes....
or is it her shoe model?
Proud of u gurl..
Oof you noticed it too..Like yeahhh I mean look at this part 2:11 she’s quite stumbling but she literally just kept moving!! I’m so proud of her
@@shookedshooky2252 Also her small wound on the right knee.
@@shookedshooky2252 It looks she's maybe still getting comfortable to the heels. The unzipping could be intentional if she felt the boots were were too constricting around here ankles zipped. Still though, there has to be moments where it gets unnerving and too loose - so she is being really professional nonetheless - I mean, it takes a lot to continue dancing with your shoes like that.
@@YuKaKariyu that can be truee, either way I’m still proud of her🥰😍🤩
Vote on starplay!!!!
wait did she just danced the whole time without zipping her shoes?!? what a professional rookie
닝닝.... 자꾸 보게 됨... 목소리도 넘 좋고ㅠㅠ
the only bad part of this was the camera man blocking the view
cant wait for fans to be back, they'll stop blocking the view
and the fact that her knee is bleeding rip
음색이랑 페이스 제일 개성있는듯
I think she is the Ace of her group like Jennie Kim. And she is pretty and attractive too.
She is my bias😇
NO AESPA ACE IS KARINA OR WINTER
@@nomore7090 all of then could be ace
@@nomore7090 not karina pls 😭
@@kyutiechangmin2762 why not ?
그냥 미인아니구ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 매력있는 미인 ㅠㅠ💜 어떻게 이렇게 예쁠까
Ningning's the last woman standing from SM Rookies. I'm like a proud mom.
Can't get enough of her. Her charisma and voice are overflowing!
4th generation best vocalist NINGNING. This girl has so much potential. I hope SM will treasure her very well!!
막내미 진짜 낭낭하다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ머글이 봐도 얘는 그룹에서 막내라 생각할듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ넘 귀여워
NingNing deserves so much support, she's a *monster* *rookie* and an *icon* at the same time. Stan this baby!!!
Edit:She actually has a wound on her knee and her boot in the beginning wasn't zipped. I guess I didn't notice it bcs she still slayed.
For me ningning is the best looking likeeee she's literally a queen
NingNing look like she can be an Empress in the Chinese historical drama.
she look like 张韶涵
Hondane Lorde
有点像
jellyjelly
Maybe but her 眼神很像张韶涵
jellyjelly
Fair enough
She has the best facial expression compared to the other members tho. Good job!
MAIN VOCALIST, MAKNAE, GREAT DANCER, FACE OF A DIVA, STAGE PRESENCE. SHE'S PERFECTION! who's doing it like her?
Ningning, I know that you will come here to monitor your own fancam again to improve in the future. If you are reading this, please know that we love you as well as other members and we will patiently wait for aespa to come back. You did so well for this debut stage and you deserve all the best, my lovely~
목소리 진짜 매력있다 ㅠㅠ 눈도 무슨... 얼굴의 반을 차지하고 있어 너무 예쁨 ㅠㅠ
She was made by 3 J's
5 spoons of Joy
3 spoons of Jennie
2 spoons of Jihyo
And *BOOM* Ningning is made.
🤣🤣
Haha true
she’s literally birthed by the biggest gg in 3rd gen...wow
Agree!
Put 5 spoons of Bada too
This girl is so pretty. Not only that, her vocal is insane.
Even if she not a main dancer but her dance skills is amazing
She is always stunning
We finally made it!!!! Congrats for the 2nd 1M fancam Ningning!
She's nominated on tcctandler before her debut, but no wonder, she's pretty af
Oh wow really??
Ikr. She was gorgeous in the music video😍😍😍😍
얘가 제일 매력있게 생겨서 맘에듬
ㅇㅈ.. 비주얼,댄스,보컬,표현력 다 가능한 사기캐..
ㅇㅈ
매력있게 생기긴 함..ㅇㅇ
ㅇㅈ
근데 진짜 웃기다 첨엔 다들 사실 증명도 안 된 루머들로 욕하더니 점점 에스파한테 스며듦 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I've watched all fan cams of the members, yet from ningning i can't take my eyes from. She's truly mesmerizing and makes you never look away from her. She's amazing, and I think she's my bias.
She is the only one who falls on her arms for that spider man pose. She is the only one among the girls who is capable of putting her whole weight on her arms. She visibly has a lot of body strength as compared to others and I personally love the way she delivers every move❤️
ningning makes me double check her position on the group. she's a main vocal but her dancing tho, she dance like a main dancer (^3^)
YESS
YESS
Goshhh yes her moves are cleannn and precise
NINGNING
Dance: YESSS
Vocal: OF COURSE YESS
Facial Expression: DEFINITELY YESSSS
She's so multitalented.. She can act too..
Nining hurt her knees 0:49 but she did so well...i am so amazed by her..not a slight pain she show.....aespa is 4g queens
Yass , i Saw too , and it hurt me 😭😭
Her heels got problem too.... at 2:18 she couldn't even walk properly because her heels didn't zip...I'm so heartbroken by this. Couldn't even imagine how she cope with all the problems but even managed to smile so brightly. Nobody even noticed abt her shoe's problem...😾
@@youn7688 she's amazing, it didn't even affect her facial expressions
@SAFAE Mg At first it was a scar but, because of the drop on the first chorous, ut started to bleed 😞
@SAFAE Mg yeah it was a scratch....but there was a little bleeding also....but still out strong nining didn't show any kind of pain
She’s like a princess she has such a positive aura and those high notes omg
@@ayayast I will fight you
POV: ningning is your bias
닝닝은 뭔가 뚱냥이st라 귀엽고 파워보컬이라 멋있음
와 뚱냥이 인정
뚱냥잌ㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㄹㅇ 너무 귀여움 닝닝이
뚱닝이 ♡
인성 논란 봄..?
@@뽀오옹-f6m 스엠 가수들 정보 팬들한테 돈받고 팔았다는 말이 있긴 해요
목소리 진짜 매력있네
you can tell she's been waiting for this moment she looks so happy to be on stage
Yeah she does!!! I mean since she was young she dreamed to be an idol and glad that she achieved it just hoping that she will eeceive a lot of love especially Korean fans
초반부터 무릎 까져있더니 앉는부분 안무하니까 무릎에 피나네..ㅠㅠㅠ 아팠을텐데 당황하지 않고 끝까지 무대 잘한거 보니까 멋있다 노래도 시원시원하게 잘하네 앞으로 열심히 응원할게 닝닝이 데뷔 축하해❤
맞네요 ㅜㅜ 맴찢이다,.
Ningning commands the stage. Literally no flaw. Her vocals, dance, and visuals are all there. Her dad must be so proud of her!!
im so happy to see her finally debut after all these years! fighting Ningning!
maybe she's the reason people believe that there's something lacking in the music industry lately? but she's here to healing them and that's literally eargasm
중간부터 무릎에 피남 ㅜ
She really has the best facial expression out of the four. Her eyes are very expressive.
에스파 처음에 노관심 이었는데 노래 중독성 ㅠㅠ
닝닝이 제일 좋다 한번 더 보게되구 그 다음 윈터!!!
루키즈 결국 얘하나 데뷔한거야? 몇년전인데 이팀막내라는게.....근성하나는 대단한듯 외국인이..
@@이수만-m2n 예리는 레드벨벳에서 데뷔한거고 윗분이 말하신건 에스파로 루키즈에서 데뷔한애는 닝닝 한명이라고 말하신거같아요!
@@횬렐 ,,닝닝..
@@뽀그리-o2c 앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금봤네욬ㅋㅋㅋ 지적 감사합니닼ㅋㅋㅋ
@@횬렐 넼ㅋㅋ
데뷔한 근성으로 한국 뒷통수만 안치고 잘 활동해줬으면 좋겠음..ㅎㅎ 나이도 어린데 되게 매력 많은듯
Ningning visual is so attractive .