Iron-Air Batteries: Storing Energy In Rust | Answers With Joe

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @nickandersonco
    @nickandersonco 2 роки тому +1313

    For the record we like getting different takes on the same thing. And I really like your take and presentation style.

  • @UndecidedMF
    @UndecidedMF 2 роки тому +519

    I knew I missed something in my video. Well done sir.

  • @akumabito2008
    @akumabito2008 2 роки тому +718

    Nahh Matt can do his own thing. You're my go-to guy for all things batteries and existential dread. Good times!

    • @BlueCubeSociety
      @BlueCubeSociety 2 роки тому +13

      Me when Joe talks about Matt (in my best Thanos voice): "I don't even know who -you are- he is."

    • @kayakMike1000
      @kayakMike1000 2 роки тому

      Would like to see Joe review Apocalypse Never.

    • @snakekiller667
      @snakekiller667 2 роки тому

      Ditto

    • @thulyblu5486
      @thulyblu5486 2 роки тому +14

      Matt doesn't care about scientific accuracy at all, it's mostly "look at this and be blown away wooooaaahhh" . Mostly garbage. Joe is at least somewhat skeptical, has a woo-woo alert system ;) and warns about exaggerated promises, etc. Way more honest.

    • @JJs_playground
      @JJs_playground 2 роки тому +6

      Matt doesn't do existential dread.

  • @interferon4800
    @interferon4800 2 роки тому +28

    11:55 you got those two backwards. Watt-hours is the measure of total work done. Watts are the *rate* at which work is being done.
    It is really unfortunate that we decided to use watt-hours instead of joules for energy. It makes it very confusing and people confuse watts and watt-hours all the time because they sound the same.

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 роки тому +2

      I went through tons of math and science education throughout college and still get power, energy, and their various units confused.

    • @mrleenudler
      @mrleenudler 2 роки тому

      kWh is a useful units as it's really easy to calculate from watts or kilowatts. Also Joule is a really small unit, so you'd quickly need to brush up on those large prefixes, like peta- and exa-

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 роки тому

      @@mrleenudler
      A Joule and a kiloWatt-hour are linearly related, it's just 3.6*10^6 (kilo = 1000, hour = 3600 seconds). So, yes, that does insta bump you up a couple orders of magnitude, but we're now already pretty used to tera- and peta- for hard drives, and exa- is around the corner. If we used the Joule, people would acclimate quickly.
      And his point about watts and watt-hours being confusing is very much the case.

    • @josepeixoto3384
      @josepeixoto3384 2 роки тому +1

      You are so right;
      same with Amperes and Amperes-hour; the first is electric CURRENT, the 2nd is ENERGY,when multiplied by the Volts, becoming Watts-Hour;
      The problem,yes,is that the names are so similar; kind of ...their and there...and they're...

    • @mathiaspinto4197
      @mathiaspinto4197 Рік тому

      I understand that form energy anounces to deliver 1 MW and 150 MW per hour or 150 MW x h ; not the same as 150 h of working or MW/h (that doesn't exist)
      It's mean they can deliver 1 MW at maximum discharge rate for a quantity of energy of 150MWh as a day has 24 hours, they can deliver energy for 6.25 days because the flow rate is slow (not because they have lot of capacities)
      It's a cross product with same proportions : 150 -> 1 so 24 -> 6.25
      (if mistakes pardon my "enghlish speaking / writing", I'm french)

  • @idrunn8764
    @idrunn8764 2 роки тому +352

    hey Joe, know it was just a bit, but I just wanted to say I actually prefer your presentation style to Matt's despite how slick his videos are. Your humor is an irreplaceable part of it as well so please keep doing what you do, even if it happens to be what matt did a week ago.

    • @anonymeese
      @anonymeese 2 роки тому

      Nice pfp

    • @zinckensteel
      @zinckensteel 2 роки тому +1

      Absolutely agree!

    • @nitehawk86
      @nitehawk86 2 роки тому +3

      It also helps that Joe didn't come out and make the baseless claim that "this is the future of batteries".

    • @klincecum
      @klincecum 2 роки тому +4

      Absolutely. Joe's humor is so bad it makes it special.

    • @thesephiam
      @thesephiam 2 роки тому +2

      Also, this video with the poppies is hard mode. It was legitimately hard to pay attention at points.

  • @davidmende3409
    @davidmende3409 2 роки тому +176

    "Just cut to an animation and pretend it never happend" got me good. Joe, if you're reading this THAT is the reason i keep on coming to this watering hole of knowledge and humor in the often dry desert called youtube.

    • @yahnnobber5096
      @yahnnobber5096 2 роки тому +12

      Had me tearing up with laughter, that one. I was even bored by the overly long bit as well before he transitioned to the Betty White explanation. Legend.

    • @joescott
      @joescott  2 роки тому +63

      I figured that bit would either crack people up or significantly lower my sub count. Kinda looking like both at the moment. :)

    • @davidmende3409
      @davidmende3409 2 роки тому +16

      @@joescott worth it, from what i saw so far, to seasoned subs love it 😂

    • @GeekTheGamer
      @GeekTheGamer 2 роки тому +3

      Puppies are gone now

  • @chuckweb66
    @chuckweb66 2 роки тому +71

    Got it! Puppies are energy storage from oxygen. My question, when the puppies grow up and eventually become older dogs, how does that effect their changing cycles?

    • @ivoryas1696
      @ivoryas1696 2 роки тому +3

      @@samarnadra
      And about cats? Mine has quite a bit of energy to give but he takes a while to recharge...

  • @fukemnukem1525
    @fukemnukem1525 2 роки тому +9

    You're channel is SO GOOD man. Learning and laughing..... Well done.... One of my absolute favorite channels on UA-cam.

  • @joeyveldink4902
    @joeyveldink4902 2 роки тому +14

    While Matt's video's are very clean and definitely worth a watch, it's nice to have different takes on the subject. I like your videos a lot because you're really good at explaining complicated topics in a way most folks can understand. Combining that with a healthy dose of humor makes for a great video that can teach us something in a fun and interesting way, and sometimes give us existential dread. Keep up your great work!

  • @auckalukaum
    @auckalukaum 2 роки тому +164

    The number one reason I started watching Matt in the first place was to find out what Joe would be talking about next week.

  • @willofone2120
    @willofone2120 2 роки тому +50

    5:11 I have never seen such a brutal attack from a pack of vicious animals. Those carful coordinated strikes seem devastatingly effective.

    • @squirlmy
      @squirlmy 2 роки тому +2

      The horror! the horror!

    • @jeroenk3570
      @jeroenk3570 2 роки тому +4

      Yeah, that poor lady didn't stand a chance.

    • @nolan412
      @nolan412 2 роки тому +1

      With puppy teeth.

  • @scilamaccagno2206
    @scilamaccagno2206 2 роки тому +36

    No disrespect to Matt, but you are my go to guy. I love your videos & your content. The puppies were an adorable bonus. Thank you.

    • @Animaniac-vd5st
      @Animaniac-vd5st 2 роки тому +2

      They are both great.
      Matt is a bit more dry (except for a bazillion dad-puns) while often going a bit more into details.
      Joe is way more entertaining and easier to understand the basics, but sometimes leaves out a bit of the more interesting details.
      Watching both channels even if it's just for entertainment value if its too much overlapping.
      (except some of the more gruesome Joe videos - i skip those, but i know that many love them)

    • @supermaster2012
      @supermaster2012 2 роки тому

      Full disrespect for Matt who keeps spreading scientific misinformation: ua-cam.com/video/-8NQkOeRNpg/v-deo.html

  • @SubnetMask
    @SubnetMask 2 роки тому +204

    Literally laughed my ass off through the whole phone scene. Trust me you've no reason to worry about Matt !

    • @brindlebucker4741
      @brindlebucker4741 2 роки тому +4

      That was 8% of the video. Time is precious.

    • @SubnetMask
      @SubnetMask 2 роки тому +4

      @@brindlebucker4741 In that case make sure you spend enough time arguing in youtube comments! :)

    • @ivoryas1696
      @ivoryas1696 2 роки тому +1

      @@brindlebucker4741
      Dang, did you do that calc yourself? -What parameters were the beginning and the end?-

    • @nenmaster5218
      @nenmaster5218 2 роки тому +1

      @@brindlebucker4741 The Science of Dreams would be an interesting Topic for soon.
      Why do we dream and more importantly:
      When is the much-needed Tech discovered that makes you sleep dreamless? Me and others really need it.

  • @benstanfill363
    @benstanfill363 2 роки тому

    I've never heard of Matt. Please don't skip posting something because someone else covered it. You're my connection to this whole world.

  • @ryankohnenkamp8946
    @ryankohnenkamp8946 2 роки тому +6

    9:03 Is no one talking about how the acronym (as shown in the logo) for "Form Energy" is "Fe"? That is brilliant!

  • @andoletube
    @andoletube 2 роки тому +149

    The puppies are a definite win for you, Joe. I had to watch twice: once for the batteries, once for the puppies.

    • @MartijnMuller
      @MartijnMuller 2 роки тому +10

      Keep getting distracted, but I want to bet the gist is a mix of hope and dread so I'm just going to enjoy the pretty views (and the puppies).

    • @gingernutpreacher
      @gingernutpreacher 2 роки тому +3

      @@MartijnMuller Yep distraction for me

    • @veramae4098
      @veramae4098 2 роки тому +2

      I keep urging "Dr. John Campbell" channel to add kittens. The only / best source on Covid.

    • @eplumer
      @eplumer 2 роки тому +3

      I had to look away from the screen to actually concentrate on the content ;-)

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 роки тому

      @@gingernutpreacher
      It was a distraction during the boring recap of relatively common baseline knowledge that we all need before coming into the video proper.

  • @edwardfletcher7790
    @edwardfletcher7790 2 роки тому +111

    Hey Joe, I hope you solar setup goes well, 35% of houses here in South Australia have solar now 👍

    • @bknesheim
      @bknesheim 2 роки тому +2

      Not having adequate storage for solar generated electricity is also the main reason why you have price that can differ 300-400% in a 24 hours period. The mega packs from Tesla help to stabilize your electrical grid, but on their own they last a very short time. Have follow development in Australian solar for some time and had hope that there had been a similar development in storage, but storage is falling way behind what is needed.

    • @edwardfletcher7790
      @edwardfletcher7790 2 роки тому +5

      @@bknesheim I agree. But our Right Wing Australian Government is only interested in helping the electricity companies make bigger profits at whatever cost to the consumers.
      A huge number of ex Liberal Party (Right Wing) politicians serve as board members of oil, gas & electricity companies in Australia.

    • @Arkantos117
      @Arkantos117 2 роки тому +7

      @@edwardfletcher7790 Right wing? lmao

    • @kensmith5694
      @kensmith5694 2 роки тому +3

      In Texas, there is a danger that the state will outlaw solar. It is a place that makes its money from oil and natural gas.

    • @squirlmy
      @squirlmy 2 роки тому +6

      @@Arkantos117 The PM blaming 2019-20 fires on imaginary arsonists while going on vacation in Hawaii..., well maybe you're right because "right wing" implies an ethos. Australia has a government of selfish, narcissistic nihilists! (yes, I'm referencing The Dude)

  • @emmabrown1270
    @emmabrown1270 2 роки тому +1

    I look forward to your videos every Monday and Thursday. After a rough day of being a senior in college I enjoy learning the way that you present it with humour and not a monotone dead like voice… like my professors. Keep going!

  • @wallykramer7566
    @wallykramer7566 2 роки тому

    The puppies were a great warm up act. But what really rotated my grok was the _babe_ with the puppies! Such a natural beauty!
    Also very much appreciate your acknowledgement of Matt Ferrel. Very gentlemanly of you!

  • @InservioLetum
    @InservioLetum 2 роки тому +1

    I watch both you and Matt, Joe, and I can assure you your humour and facial antics blow matt's graphics ABSOLUTELY out of the water.

  • @crislabossiere6234
    @crislabossiere6234 2 роки тому +127

    Deadpan, irony, and the morbid / cerebral humour combo. Love it all. And the science, love the science. Chair spin is a keeper too. Though I'd like to see some science kittens. Cat people are people too.

    • @phuckpootube6231
      @phuckpootube6231 2 роки тому +6

      No, cat people are just weird.

    • @jackrichards1863
      @jackrichards1863 2 роки тому +1

      @@phuckpootube6231 I believe that may be true

    • @InservioLetum
      @InservioLetum 2 роки тому +1

      LIES!! Your cat overlords are forcing you to say this by threatening your laptop with a potted plant from above!

    • @dwes3824
      @dwes3824 Рік тому +1

      I am pawsitive there were some cations in this video somewhere.

  • @robertsparks3685
    @robertsparks3685 2 роки тому +63

    Puppies? Hey, I am happy to see all the items on your shelves: Toys like He-man, Dr. Who and the antiques like the typewriter. But really you make the topics interesting, entertaining and informative. I look forward to each new video. Thanks

  • @garretthazlett9116
    @garretthazlett9116 2 роки тому +26

    Awesome video. I loved it. Speaking of matt, a colab between you two would be awesome! I feel like you guys could create some awesome stuff together.

  • @stephendavidson7256
    @stephendavidson7256 2 роки тому +1

    I been watching your videos for so long, and I just feel like joe is like the coolest friend to have, he seems smart, funny, down to earth and fun to hangout with. I don't get even a tiny vibe of selfishness from Joe and that's rare today, keep up the great videos and dont change the great work you do man.

  • @brycebeckett6654
    @brycebeckett6654 2 роки тому

    Joe. I like your take on things. Don't ever feel discouraged. Your work has value to me. I haven't ever done anything original and what I do had tremendous value. 🙏❤️

  • @TagiukGold
    @TagiukGold 2 роки тому +60

    Good job Matt, this was one of your best videos, and an excellent hommage to your mentor and idol Joe Scott.

    • @drippingwax
      @drippingwax 2 роки тому +2

      Did you intend to post this on Matt's video?

    • @jamesowens7176
      @jamesowens7176 2 роки тому +10

      @@drippingwax I'm 100% sure this is humor :-)

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 роки тому +2

      @@jamesowens7176
      "...your mentor and idol Joe Scott."

    • @InservioLetum
      @InservioLetum 2 роки тому +2

      WILDLY underrated comment, guessing this level of humour is over most people's heads.

  • @tigershirew7409
    @tigershirew7409 2 роки тому +47

    The puppies were wonderful and a great reminder to support your local animal shelter in honour of the legendary Betty White. Plus the info about the batteries was interesting too.

    • @ilfrich
      @ilfrich 2 роки тому +1

      What info about batteries? :D I only saw puppies :>

  • @bob1498
    @bob1498 2 роки тому +14

    Joe, if I had the choice of going for coffee with you or Matt, you would be the guy. Keep 'em coming.

  • @wpgtech
    @wpgtech 2 роки тому +2

    That was really good, Joe. Humble and entertaining, yet informative at the same time, while respecting another creator. Well done, and thanks!

  • @rethix5955
    @rethix5955 2 роки тому +1

    I appreciate the dedication to the puppies.

  • @helloprettiii
    @helloprettiii 2 роки тому +29

    Never fail to make me smile, Joe. Keep up the amazing work. My depression finds reprieve and knowledge in your videos. 🙏

  • @mousermind
    @mousermind 2 роки тому +31

    I don't know who this Matt guy is, but he can't be as great as you are, Joe! Keep up the great work!

  • @XanderBudnick
    @XanderBudnick 2 роки тому +27

    Talking to yourself on the phone bit was hilarious! Congrats on the 666th Video you Heathen

    • @I-am-stevo
      @I-am-stevo 2 роки тому +1

      When is your next video dropping? The siberian logs where cool

    • @joescott
      @joescott  2 роки тому +9

      For real, is that how many videos are on the channel now? I was wondering exactly what the number was.

    • @XanderBudnick
      @XanderBudnick 2 роки тому +2

      @@I-am-stevo this morning

    • @XanderBudnick
      @XanderBudnick 2 роки тому +1

      @@joescott I just happened to see it when I searched your channel for my Monday dose of Joe Scott :)

  • @malcolmhiggins7005
    @malcolmhiggins7005 2 роки тому +1

    I'm "undecided" as to which of these videos I like better! I watch a lot your videos a few times each and learn something new everytime. I don't mind seeing several videos on the same topic. I would say his is more informational and yours is more entertaining. Both fantastic

  • @lexscarlet
    @lexscarlet 2 роки тому +1

    I watch both you and Matt without fail. Regardless of what Matt or anyone else has covered, release the content. I've been watching your videos for quite a while and you've only improved on every measurable metric. Even if Joe Scott only did videos of previously covered content, I would still watch every one for the writing alone.
    It's like having all good sets at the comedy club: just a good solid uninterrupted stream of entertainment.
    Oh and also education.

  • @OGPedXing
    @OGPedXing 2 роки тому +43

    Joe, keep in mind most solar installs are grid tie and don't work when the grid is down. You have to have additional interlock switches set up to prevent solar from back feeding the grid and possibly electrocuting line workers. If you want solar off grid, you need to manually disconnect from the grid, which may not be doable due to code regulation in your area.

    • @veramae4098
      @veramae4098 2 роки тому +2

      My 9 solar panels have interlock. Oh, and give me credit on my electric bill, and home battery. I was ripped off by installer $$ tho they did do a good job.

    • @squirlmy
      @squirlmy 2 роки тому +15

      one thing Texans don't have to worry much about is code regulations. I'm pretty certain Joe looked into this, as thousands of Texans have. Lack of regulation is part of what got them in the polar vortex mess in the first place.

    • @OGPedXing
      @OGPedXing 2 роки тому +1

      @@squirlmy unfortunately general regulations, or lack thereof, are different from the NEC...all cities in Texas follow some recent version of the national electrical code.

    • @supermaster2012
      @supermaster2012 2 роки тому +3

      @@squirlmy regulations are a commie cancer whose only purpose is to make the beneficiary of the corruption some politician instead of the company providing the service.
      Taxation is theft and so is regulation.

    • @bmsg1
      @bmsg1 2 роки тому +3

      just don't pay for energy, they WILL take your house off grid

  • @kathytoy5055
    @kathytoy5055 2 роки тому +18

    Matt is all about the puns; Joe is all about the pups.
    Great video, Joe. Thanks.

  • @gutobernardo7457
    @gutobernardo7457 2 роки тому +11

    I got totally distracted by the puppies. I'm not even mad ❤️

  • @shake3039
    @shake3039 Рік тому

    I literally saw your video in my recommended while watching Matt Ferrell’s video on the same thing and switched to this video because I prefer your style.
    Not who does it better but who does it best for their audience. Keep up the good work Joe!❤

  • @russellsirolli3247
    @russellsirolli3247 2 роки тому +7

    Hey Joe, another part to consider for these battery videos is Micro grids, i work for an energy company and the plan now is to take the fringes of the network and disconnect them from the main grid to cut down on infrastructure and maintenance costs, so this would potentially service dozens of customers or more per micro grid. Large scale batteries like this will play a massive role in regional communities in the future.

    • @SLLabsKamilion
      @SLLabsKamilion 2 роки тому

      Makes sense; residential needs are generally very different than commercial or industrial. The most annoying thing about off-grid or grid-tie setups is the peak power for cooking if you want to avoid fossil fuel use entirely. That's where micro grids come in. The biggest problem I have right now is that 90-99% of the grid is dumb as a box of rocks and has no method of communicating past, current, or future loads to the grid, micro or regional. In fact, if done improperly, a lot of people would be screaming their heads off about privacy and government espionage of the populace. But that's the problem I think needs solving foremost: homes should be able to track their energy usage and present the grid with a historical and future projection.
      This sort of communication should be of an specification that is open and international. (So, like IEEE perhaps...?) But that circles back to the most age old problem in secure computing; authentication is required for security. Who holds the keys? And to what? There's low level communication links to secure, medium level tunnels to secure, and high level accounting to secure. Game development demonstrates why the client should never be trusted. Then we have the Vehicle to Grid infrastructure to deal with; with 50A AC feeds and 200A DC feeds; and all of them are predominantly one way and just as dumb as the grid about who is where and being billed how.
      For example; most car computers have no idea what their own license plate reads; but they know their VIN. Current chargers are dumb pilot signals purely for safety; all the billing side is done at a terminal charger-side, with a relay to disconnect the cable leading to the vehicle. Good luck getting a charger that supports a billing network on private property; chargepoint's contracts are out of reach unless it's a condo or apartment building. And even those aren't two-way yet, when the grid needs energy in an emergency, it has no way to ask the vehicles to discharge.
      And yet again; we have an authentication issue. Whom can request such a thing? We definitely want hospitals and other medical facilities to be able to do so, but I'd be rather angry to find my vehicle's battery being discharged to keep a refinery hot during an outage, preventing it from having to shut down for a week. That should be their storage problem, not mine. Sorry for the meandering reply; but you seemed like someone who might stand to benefit from the free ideas.

    • @jamesowens7176
      @jamesowens7176 2 роки тому

      Cool info on the future of microgrids! I can see where it makes a lot of sense! Decentralization is easier with wind, solar, and maybe even small modular fission reactors, so it follows that keeping hundreds of miles of transmission lines going might prove to be less efficient than multiple microgrids.

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 роки тому +2

      @@SLLabsKamilion
      I started to read that until..... paragraphs; they are your friend.

    • @SLLabsKamilion
      @SLLabsKamilion 2 роки тому

      @@kindlin Uh, there's only one paragraph there. It's just a particularly short one compared to the papers I typically read.

    • @kindlin
      @kindlin 2 роки тому

      @@SLLabsKamilion
      Have it your way. Let's just say it's _less than conducive_ to typical internet banter. I would try and find more concise veins of through and work on those to make a compelling argument, than whatever that thing was.

  • @paincult7121
    @paincult7121 2 роки тому +71

    The grid failure in Texas wasn't inevitable or an accident, it was deliberate negligence on part of both the companies, the regulators and the powers that be. (Edit: To be specific, the power companies were provided guidelines on how to prepare for conditions like these-they didn't).

    • @ADogNamedStay
      @ADogNamedStay 2 роки тому +5

      Facts

    • @dewiz9596
      @dewiz9596 2 роки тому +13

      “Don’t Mess with Texas”. Roughly translated “We can mess ourselves up”

    • @macdietz
      @macdietz 2 роки тому

      @@dewiz9596 har

    • @BTScriviner
      @BTScriviner 2 роки тому +2

      Because "freedumbs!"

    • @kensmith5694
      @kensmith5694 2 роки тому +2

      Yes, it was a lot of the natural gas infrastructure failing in the cold that made the grid fail. Even if the power plants had be weatherized, the fuel supply would still have been a problem.

  • @greggjohnson621
    @greggjohnson621 2 роки тому +21

    Congrats on the home solar!
    (Matt beat you to that too… but it still counts.)

  • @JohanDippenaar
    @JohanDippenaar 2 роки тому +7

    I'm sorry that I can't support you financially but I really love your video's Joe!

    • @squirlmy
      @squirlmy 2 роки тому +1

      you can give $1 per month on Patreon. I almost didn't, just because it's hard to keep track of lots of small subscriptions, but I do it for Joe anyways.

  • @mikedrop4421
    @mikedrop4421 2 роки тому +1

    Listen man I absolutely love your commitment to the bit. Like that one time you played a warning sound for way way way longer than was funny until it flew past rage inducing and landed right in the hilarious zone.

  • @cameronshaw4597
    @cameronshaw4597 2 роки тому +2

    Love the video joe! You’re my go to guy for anything science/energy related. Love your style of delivery. You bring character to it 👍

  • @jorgenjohnson2168
    @jorgenjohnson2168 2 роки тому +6

    If you're welder who uses aluminum than yes you have seen aluminum. Argon gas is the most popular welding gas and it protects the welding process from oxidization just long enough to be able to weld any type of metal.

    • @dancoroian1
      @dancoroian1 2 роки тому +1

      ... hence why he said "probably"?

    • @trunkage
      @trunkage 2 роки тому

      So, generally only seen under a visor

    • @mirkofernd
      @mirkofernd 2 роки тому

      does it look particularly different though?

  • @davidhammond8308
    @davidhammond8308 2 роки тому +49

    I seldom watch Matt but after his "energy storage breakthrough" video on hydrogen storage, it feels like he's more interested in putting out videos instead of putting out legitimate science. Just my take though. Keep doing you Joe!

    • @travcollier
      @travcollier 2 роки тому +15

      Joe is "I want to believe", Matt just believes. I really can't stand watching Matt anymore. He seems like a nice enough person, but the signal to noise (or bullshit) ratio is way too low.

    • @matthewmccall551
      @matthewmccall551 2 роки тому +2

      Hilariously, that was the first video of Matt’s that I saw! Needless to say it’s also the only one, there were a lot of legitimate perspectives left out in that video.

    • @eulachonfish
      @eulachonfish 2 роки тому +11

      @@travcollier Totally agree, I feel like Matt beats Joe to the scoop because he doesn't do the research to look for the downsides or potential issues. I also think he seems like a nice guy, but his videos have a lot more hype than science.

    • @lolbro8701
      @lolbro8701 2 роки тому

      well, hydrogen is easily one of the most dense energy media we know of, it slaps lithium ion out of the sky and in terms of large energy storage its unparraleled even now, no doubt with more research into storage and more infrastructure it will an extremely large use case, most noteably trucks, theoretically hydrogen can be compressed to the point the electrons form an ocean, increasing its density to 0.7kg/L at a density of 120MJ/kg vs lithium ions 0.3MJ/kg theres a reason just 5kg of poorly compressed hydrogen can easily rival BEVs with 1 tonne batteries in terms of range, the infrastructure isnt there but neither was gasoline infrastucture when ICE vehicles first came onto the scene. Im convinced anyone that puts down hydrogen has done essentially 0 research on the topic and forms their opinions around elon musks, HEV could very easily compete and outmatch BEVs in range, its a matter of refueling and use, theres not much more a HEV could do that a BEV cant, but when we get to trucks, a cross continent trip with a BEV would be one of the most inefficient things you could imagine, the sheer weight of the battery would a very significant part of the cargo not to mention the recharging "just set up battery swaps" then the system needs additional infrastructure, just like hydrogen. the base 2 components of hydrogen are water and electricity, and in the extremely likely abundant energy future, not using hydrogen for larger vehicles would be a joke, much like how using them for small EVs is a joke today.
      TLDR: hydrogen is a lot better than you realise and will almost certainly be the future for larger vehicles that operate outside of constant available electricity (planes, cargo ships, trucks) basically everything that makes the economy go round

    • @KyleHatch21
      @KyleHatch21 2 роки тому

      @@matthewmccall551 how do you know his signal to noise ratio if you've only seen one of his videos?

  • @technoe02
    @technoe02 2 роки тому +24

    Your writing just keeps getting better and better. That skit had me doubled over laughing. Especially when you said, "cut to an animation and pretend it never happened". Then did EXACTLY that. #ded.

  • @Lazarosaliths
    @Lazarosaliths 2 роки тому

    I rarely what's Mat, and thats why he is so serious about stuff. I like to watch answers with joe, and feel like a conversation, feels like we are friends and you are not a news outlet.
    Plus you make all this funny cringe dad jokes, that really grinde my gears.
    I have watched every single one of your videos, you're the best man. I started listening to conversations with joe too, i got hooked. I even got nebula. To watch you there. Keep it up Joe

  • @benwilliamson4328
    @benwilliamson4328 2 роки тому

    I really love the crane battery idea. Joe talked about it quits awhile ago but it is always on my mind when interesting battery ideas come up

  • @trevorstanleyclark2143
    @trevorstanleyclark2143 2 роки тому +6

    I really love both of your channels. Matt as well as yourself makes great content. He does do a great job on the grid level storage and power generation. I truly hope your not bitter. Didn't he guest host for you while you were away. Love the banter.

    • @squirlmy
      @squirlmy 2 роки тому

      where did you get the idea he's "bitter"? He has a link to Matt's video for goodness' sake!

  • @TheAdeybob
    @TheAdeybob 2 роки тому +186

    Matt often doesn't stop to question some of the stuff he highlights.
    Honestly, some of it goes straight from the fevered dream of a scammer, through a media team, and then publicised by Matt...who sometimes just doesn't stop to think about the lack of science behind the snake-oil he all too often helps to peddle.
    If he was as concerned with the scientific basis of what he showcases as he is with getting hits on his channel, then he'd have a great show.
    As it is..? Meh.

    • @Revnge7Fold
      @Revnge7Fold 2 роки тому +29

      Yeah, Thunderfoot did a video on solid hydrogen BS that he fell for....I lost all respect for him. ua-cam.com/video/-8NQkOeRNpg/v-deo.html

    • @c.augustin
      @c.augustin 2 роки тому +17

      Well put regarding Matt. I would always just wait a week to get a video from Joe. Much more realistic most of the time. And I just like Joe's presentation style … 😁

    • @TheAdeybob
      @TheAdeybob 2 роки тому +15

      @@c.augustin I feel the same. Joe's output is better written, and better researched. He doesn't rely on a talking point guide provided (with graphics) by a media company, like many seem to do.
      Just Have A Think is good for well-researched and balanced breaking-science output too.

    • @TheAdeybob
      @TheAdeybob 2 роки тому

      @@user-es4iq9yy5h Keep on truckin' man. Thanks for the cool output.

    • @maxwyght1840
      @maxwyght1840 2 роки тому +16

      Yeah, I used to follow Matt, but over time I noticed that he was peddling utter bullshit with no grounding in reality for clicks and views

  • @mysticwolf1636
    @mysticwolf1636 2 роки тому +4

    You had me at Puppies!!!!

  • @Fishrokk
    @Fishrokk 2 роки тому +2

    I'm glad we have the choice to watch both you and Matt. If I absolutely-gun-to-the-head-had-to choose one or the other, I don't think I'd miss Matt all that much.

  • @jabeavers
    @jabeavers 2 роки тому

    I don't watch that other guy's videos, only yours!
    You're the best!!!!

  • @cxldbleach5213
    @cxldbleach5213 2 роки тому +6

    Came for batteries, stayed for puppies. Nice video, keep up the great work!

  • @danieldennett5523
    @danieldennett5523 2 роки тому +5

    I enjoy Matt’s videos but you are so much more entertaining. I was pretty distracted by the cuteness, then I had the laugh when you made the switch. Good show!

  • @videosbymathew
    @videosbymathew 2 роки тому +4

    There's always more information (and ways to present it that's more receptive to someone else) than a single video can ever hope to incorporate, so your video is just as important and needed as his. Look at it this way, now that he posted, you can grab his follows too for another take ;).

  • @laurenprato2777
    @laurenprato2777 2 роки тому

    Oh my you are just the medicine I needed - laughter ! LOVED the puppies ,… sooo clever Jo!💙🙏👁

  • @ruinenlust_
    @ruinenlust_ 2 роки тому +1

    I LOVE the phone bit. Absolutely boldering with laughter here. Holy shit

  • @deslomator
    @deslomator 2 роки тому +7

    Matt's videos feel like press releases in video format, no matter how absurd the proposed tech is. There, I said it.

    • @stephanieschaffer2133
      @stephanieschaffer2133 2 роки тому

      My biggest gripe is he doesn't bother to explore all pertinent sides of his topics. He pretends to be impartial and balanced but in the same breath readily draws conclusions and neglects to even mention obvious concerns or downsides. My personal favorite was his video about fungus-based building insulation in which he failed to mention water performance or exposure issues which IS THE #1 CONCERN WITH ANY BUILDING TECHNOLOGY. Like, duh? He also didn't bother to address concerns about fungal allergies for fungus grown packaging. These are very obvious oversights and I haven't watched any of his videos since. I'm not interested in being corralled into anyone else's myopic way of thinking. 🙄

  • @GalvayraPHX
    @GalvayraPHX 2 роки тому +3

    Yes, I can already see the utility companies investing untold millions into extra battery storage just in case something happens. Because we've seen how good they are at getting ready for unexpected events. Like the ones in Texas.

    • @brownwhale5518
      @brownwhale5518 2 роки тому

      What happened in Texas is not as simple as you seem to think or imply.
      Most Americans don’t save for or invest in the future so you think they’d financially support hardening of the grid?
      It’s easy to look back but don’t kid yourself, few want to pay for what ifs.
      Damned if you do damned if you don’t. It doesn’t get much simpler than that.

    • @GalvayraPHX
      @GalvayraPHX 2 роки тому

      @@brownwhale5518 I agree that the Texas issue is more complicated, however - it is a fact that the utility companies did not take precautions against very low temperatures, which did contribute to the avalanche of issues. Mind you, I don't expect they could have justified the required expenses to their shareholders before this happened. This kind of pattern has been increasingly visible in USA - let things get worse and worse without doing anything, then when it all comes crashing down, everyone jumps on the bandwagon and starts pointing fingers at "guilty" parties. At the same time, yes the progressing consumerism culture does trend to not look at the future. What I'm saying is, it's naive to expect investment in grid storage that's not in actual use and is just "in case something happens".

    • @brownwhale5518
      @brownwhale5518 2 роки тому +1

      @@GalvayraPHX good discussion and thanks for the civil reply

  • @bazoo513
    @bazoo513 2 роки тому +12

    11:25 - It would be nice to mention at this point that coal powered plants _also_ failed during that epic blackout, because their cooling systems froze, and that wind turbines can bu bought with or without cold-weather and snow protection - guess which ones were installed in Texas?
    11:55 - that was a very vague (and wrong) explanation of distinction between energy (measured in J or Wh) and power (W).

    • @IronmanV5
      @IronmanV5 2 роки тому +1

      And natural gas fueled plants as well, in addition to gas supply infrastructure freezing up.
      The one that got me was STP nuclear SW of Houston having a reactor go down due to "cold weather issues".
      Their turbines and generators are out in the open🙄

    • @alvarofernandez5118
      @alvarofernandez5118 2 роки тому

      @@IronmanV5 I think the nuclear issue was due to the water inlet temperature being lower than some arbitrary cutoff in the software. "That can't be right! Shut it down!" I recall reading it FWIW.
      And look, we're not built for true *lasting* cold. Texas gets chilly in the winter, and really cold a day or two at a time. I mean, our apartments have stairs on the outside. When there's a freeze they're death traps. I know.
      But it's only cold like that a day or two tops, and not every winter. Look at apartments in California. Same at Texas. Apartments in Wisconsin? Always on the inside. Our bus stops? Open. Wisconsin? Closed. Etc.

    • @IronmanV5
      @IronmanV5 2 роки тому

      @@alvarofernandez5118 The natural gas fired power plants down my way, RGV, have the turbines & generators enclosed.
      The Braunig & Calaveras power plants on the south side of San Antonio also have them enclosed.
      The San Miguel power plant south of Pleasanton also has them enclosed.
      The fact that STP, located on the coast, doesn't in an area where Hurricanes are a somewhat regular possibility sounds like some stupid cost cutting to me.
      Same with Comanche peak SW of Ft Worth. In Tornado Alley.
      If they cheap out on something like that, what else did they cheap out on?

    • @alvarofernandez5118
      @alvarofernandez5118 2 роки тому

      @@IronmanV5 not trying to absolve them, thats for sure. But complicated systems fail in complicated ways. There is not one cause. One cause is certainly being cheap/cost saving - or smart spending, which is what it's called when it works out. :-)

  • @jackrichards1863
    @jackrichards1863 2 роки тому

    Hey the puppies were working. It was great & I will return for more next time I spot an Answers with Joe video! Thank you for making a difference. 😊

  • @jay2aussie
    @jay2aussie 2 роки тому

    The puppies, the phone, I love this channel. You’re informative and also a brilliant comedic writer.

  • @michaelfrench3396
    @michaelfrench3396 2 роки тому +10

    And don't feel bad about Matt getting videos out faster than you. At least you do your research. For example, he totally fell for the startup that said they were going to be able to store hydrogen on tape. And it was going to revolutionize energy. He also falls for everything Elon musk puts out. Being fastest does not usually mean that you're the best it just means that you're the fastest.

    • @michaelfrench3396
      @michaelfrench3396 2 роки тому +2

      And better 3D renderings do not make good content. Good factual information conveyed in an understandable way makes good content. There's a reason I'm subscribed to this channel and not that Matt guys'.

    • @remliqa
      @remliqa 2 роки тому

      You have proof that the hydrogen tape start up is a scam?

    • @Revnge7Fold
      @Revnge7Fold 2 роки тому

      @@remliqa ua-cam.com/video/-8NQkOeRNpg/v-deo.html

    • @curiodyssey3867
      @curiodyssey3867 2 роки тому

      That's the same thing my girlfriend keeps telling me

    • @remliqa
      @remliqa 2 роки тому

      ​@@Revnge7Fold
      Thunderfoot isn't a credible source when it comes to battery tech and/or science . He's far too agenda driven to the point he misrepresent facts and data to support his stance.
      That video you linked is no different .

  • @Michael-lz9ic
    @Michael-lz9ic 2 роки тому +20

    If there is one thing I have learned in recent months it is to remain calm, especially when it comes to investments in cryptocurrencies. Learn not to sell in a panic when everything goes down and not to buy in euphoria when everything goes up. I advise y'all to forget predictions and start making a good profit now because future valuations are all speculations and guesses. The market is very unstable and you can't tell if it's going bearish or bullish. While myself and others are trad!n without fear of making a loss others are being patient for the price to skyrocket. It all depends on the pattern you follow. I was able to make 9 BTC from 3.1 BTC in just August from implementing trades with tips and info from Wayne Thornton.

    • @druidsmerkel7265
      @druidsmerkel7265 2 роки тому

      My portfolio just recorded a massive increase despite the current downswing in BTC. Wayne Thornton is a skilled Pro Trader who has been properly managing my investments and generating me ROIS in return. I literally don't trade myself I just earn. I wish he would show me the ropes tho😂.

    • @luciajeriq1051
      @luciajeriq1051 2 роки тому

      Just perfect, I have been telling everyone how he gave me a ray of hope after I thought I had lost it all, now I have not only learned how to use signals but also how to make market analysis.

    • @eyrlgudjensen6822
      @eyrlgudjensen6822 2 роки тому

      I stopped panicking about my BTC the very moment I started working with Wayne Thornton last year, his confidence and skills is on a maximum level.

    • @jerrypaige3296
      @jerrypaige3296 2 роки тому

      @@eyrlgudjensen6822
      I would like to know how I can contact this broker for more information. I think I've heard this man mentioned several times in the office. I know he is a pro trader, but how do you do business with him?

    • @shellymarc9298
      @shellymarc9298 2 роки тому

      People are ignorant of the high profitability in crypto and that has been the major issue limiting their profitability.

  • @mdavid1955
    @mdavid1955 2 роки тому

    Mr. Fusion is the answer! I enjoy your presentation style, Joe.

  • @Kaiserland111
    @Kaiserland111 2 роки тому

    I actually like listening to both you and Matt (and others) talk about the same topics because (1) you all offer slightly different perspectives, and (2) I remember the information better hearing it multiple times.
    P.S. The puppies were cute.

  • @pedromello7510
    @pedromello7510 2 роки тому

    Thank you Joe
    I was not expecting puppies
    And it helped my day so much

  • @travismalinich1954
    @travismalinich1954 2 роки тому

    I am going to have to listen to this video later. I watched it this morning but I was a little distracted during the first half.
    Beat.
    Video.
    EVER.

  • @danielkushner5963
    @danielkushner5963 2 роки тому

    The puppy @3:31 is definitely the cutest

  • @BillMarion
    @BillMarion 2 роки тому

    You're really doing the puppy bit. Bravo, Joe. Bravo. (standing up clapping) Hysterical!

  • @foksigen3957
    @foksigen3957 2 роки тому

    Matt freaking Ferrell, made my day...
    Also he is really just about the information...
    You Joe on the other hand make your videos hilarious and I love that...

  • @jonathanbradley9676
    @jonathanbradley9676 2 роки тому

    Puppies and future tech! Two of my favorite things! Thanks Joe

  • @Bassotronics
    @Bassotronics 2 роки тому +1

    @ 0:43 lol!
    Reminds me of that girl meme who’s face is like “wtf”.

  • @taigaforova6008
    @taigaforova6008 2 роки тому

    Having multiple things to focus on makes it easier for me to listen. ADHD can be like that and the puppy videos were greatly appreciated.

  • @liamredmill9134
    @liamredmill9134 2 роки тому

    Good for very heavy style grid back up ,best simple invention of 2021 for the iron industry

  • @PierreH1968
    @PierreH1968 2 роки тому

    Loved air-puppy powered batteries video... Genius!

  • @boskahunter-hannan4054
    @boskahunter-hannan4054 2 роки тому

    I'm usually just a lurker, but I was compelled to leave a comment on this video. Your presentation style and timing is "the teats" and, if I'm being honest, I don't even know who that other person is. Thanks for being you!

  • @brotatochimp
    @brotatochimp 2 роки тому

    bro, I watch your videos, because I want to hear your jokes and witty banter. The educational info is just a bonus.

  • @joshuawayne9811
    @joshuawayne9811 2 роки тому

    I love Matt's videos, but I love yours more. You've got the chops kid, you make the laughs and we all love you!

  • @enragedgoop
    @enragedgoop 2 роки тому

    Joe... I never even heard of Matt. I love you bro

  • @gillsmoke
    @gillsmoke 2 роки тому

    LOL the puppies in the in picture, mmmm perfect. Matt will never top that I'm sure.

  • @Cwcompanion
    @Cwcompanion 2 роки тому

    This is one of the greatest things I've ever seen!

  • @thomasc8888
    @thomasc8888 2 роки тому

    I really enjoy your videos, your delivery is fantastic! Keep it up! Sorry competition on yt is pain sometimes. Just keep head up and continue sharing your energy and charisma with the world!

  • @GreatBigBore
    @GreatBigBore 2 роки тому

    I watch you both, and enjoy both equally. I hope sixty thousand other people have already said that❤️ You deserve to hear it 60k times

  • @onerimeuse
    @onerimeuse 2 роки тому

    Like others have said, I specifically clicked your video to get your take on it. I think this may be the third or fourth video I've watched on the subject, actually. But, for the record, I subbed your channel waaaaay before any of the others. Your presentation style is awesome. Both optimistic, but grounded. And always funny. : )
    ...
    Man, really ran with those puppies, didn't you... 😂😂

  • @KimdraStBiryukova
    @KimdraStBiryukova 2 роки тому

    When you said "In a cave," I went "With a box of scraps!" right when you did. That was amazing.

  • @thesoppywanker
    @thesoppywanker 2 роки тому

    I appreciate the commitment to the puppies bit

  • @busdriver428
    @busdriver428 2 роки тому

    Hey Joe I had never heard of Matt Ferrell until this video. You will always be my first choice for science news! But, I'm definitely going to check out this Matt guy.

  • @familywilliams4058
    @familywilliams4058 2 роки тому

    I have seen both your video and Matt's, I appreciate them both. I also find your puppies to be excellent substitutes for better graphics. They are more than just acceptable, they are adorable! The phone call was funny though.

  • @elijiahcage
    @elijiahcage 2 роки тому +1

    The puppy gimmick is ridiculous and fantastic. 😂

  • @busdriver428
    @busdriver428 2 роки тому

    Hey Joe, I can't wait until you are able to report on some of these great new battery technologies that are actually coming to market. You are definitely one of the great youtubers. Thank you for all your hard work!!

  • @Levomatic
    @Levomatic 2 роки тому

    Matt and you both create great content in quite different ways. I appreciate what you both bring to the table. the puppy bit was hilarious btw.

    • @nenmaster5218
      @nenmaster5218 2 роки тому

      The Science of Dreams would be an interesting Topic for soon.

  • @ianm1049
    @ianm1049 2 роки тому

    Hey if it makes you feel better Joe, Although i love Matt's videos I always pay more attention to yours.

  • @PolarBearon
    @PolarBearon 2 роки тому

    I enjoy Matt's content, but i watch your videos more regularly. So, you got that going for you.

  • @tian320i
    @tian320i 2 роки тому

    I'd rather listen to you Joe. Great vid!

  • @WhirlybirdFlyer
    @WhirlybirdFlyer 2 роки тому

    Love Matt Ferrel, he is a very punny guy but your videos are def better Joe. I love the comedy style you have been leaning into over the past year. Keep it up and thanks!

  • @bertilhatt
    @bertilhatt 2 роки тому

    “I don’t have to do the whole thing, but… that’s less.”
    No, you absolutely have to do the whole thing. That’s the best bit.