Agreed with everything but Jiwoo is better then ryujin in dance And finally someone who appreciates haewon's dancing , why dosent she have a dance position ? Jyp what are u doing😭
Vocal - LILY & NINGNING Dance - YEJI & CHAERYOUNG Rap - GISELLE & KARINA FOR ME 🥰🥰🥰🥰😘😘 But Kyunjin & Jinni is better than Haewon at dance Kyunjin same to Yeji Jinni same to Chaeryoung My dance rank 1.Chaeryoung 2.Yeji 3.Jinni 4.Kyujin 5.Jiwoo My bias :YEJI, KYUJIN & KARINA
i kinda get what you mean cause lily has a different vocal colour compared to ningning so in your opinion lily would be higher but i think it would still be ningning first technique wise
I just wanna say this NINGNING IS A BETTER VOCALIST THAN LIA , KARINA , GISELLE AND LILY . AND WINTER IS AN AMAZING LEAD VOCALIST I FEEL LIKE SHE DESERVES THE 3RD POSITION AND LILY ALSO DESERVES THE 2ND POSITION SINCE NO DOUBT SHE VOCALS ARE AMAZING BUT NINGNING'S VOCALS ARE BETTER AND STRONGER. AND PLUS LILY AND NINGNING ARE BOTH ROOKIES THEY BOTH HAVE SO MUCH TIME TO IMPROVE THERE VOCALS.
Some people gonna say that I am a toxic my after reading this so lemmie clear this. First of I am Not a my I just watch a lot if ningning's singing voice and some of live performances and I can that she is a better vocalist and have a clearer voice I'm not hating on anyone is this video I'm just trying to say my honest opinion and feel free to disagree and give your opinions also.
@@purva_4 that's ok your opinion is completely respected. That's just my opinion, lia might not be better than karina since karina is the main dancer of aespa but I feel like lily and lia dance the same just that lia dance moves are clean.
Bae as of now is the lowest in her group. as she is leaning toward being a Stylistic vocalist Karina>Ryujin>Kyujin Jiwoo>Yeji Giselle>Karina>>>>>>>Ryujin>Yuna Can I ask how did you guess the freestyle scores for Giselle, Ningning, and others who didn't show their freestyle yet?
@@fromista_sn2140 Lily's vocal rank is Decent vocal now in same vocal rank w Wendy and Ningning is above to arange vocal which is lower rank than Lily and Wendy
♡Vocal (based on technique): 1. Lily (B-) ♕ 2/3. Haewon (C+) 3/2. Ning (C+) 4.Winter (C) 5.Karina/Giselle/Kyujin (lower C) 6.Sullyoon/Jinni D+ 8.Lia (D) 9.Jiwoo (E+) 10.Bae (E) 11/12.Yeji (F+) 12/13.Chaeryeong (F+) 14.Yuna (F) 15.Ryujin (F) ♡Rap: 1.Giselle ♕ 2.Ryujin/Karina 3.Yuna 4.Jiwoo 5.Jinni 6.Kyujin 7.Yeji 8.Chaeryeong 9.Winter 10.Lia 11.Ning ♡Dance(by a dancer): 1.Chaeryeong 9.4/10♕ 2/3.Jinni 9.3/10 3/2.Yeji 9.2/10 4.Haewon 9/10 5.Kyujin 8.9/10 6.Karina 8.7/10 7.Ryujin 8.4/10 8.Yuna 8.2/10 9.Jiwoo 8/10 10/11. Winter 7.6/10 11/10. Lily 7.5/10 12.Bae 7.2/10 13.Sullyoon 7/10 14.Ning 6.6/10 15.Giselle 5.6/10 16.Lia 5/10 ♡Stage presence: 1.Ryujin ♕ 2.Yuna 3.Kyujin 4.Yeji 5.Jinni 6.Jiwoo 7.Lily 8.Ning/Lia 9.Giselle 10.Sullyoon 11.Bae 12.Haewon 13.Karina 14.Chaeryeong 15.Winter Visual (based on KBS): 1.Sullyoon 100% (arguably because many people said that she fits all the standards but I'm not sure about her fitting hourglass body or golden ratio) 2.Yuna 90% (doesn't fit hourglass body) 3.Winter 80%-90%(doesn't fit the height and the golden ratio but the height is debatable because people said that Winter confirmed that she is 1.66) 4.Karina 80% (doesn't fit hourglass body and golden ratio) 5.Bae 80% (doesn't fit V shape jaw and golden ratio) 6.Kyujin 80% (doesn't fit hourglass body and golden ratio) 7.Jinni 70% (doesn't fit V shape jaw, hourglass body and golden ratio) 8.Haewon 70% (doesn't fit hourglass body, the height and the golden ratio) 9.Yeji 70% (doesn't fit hourglass body, double eyelids and golden ratio) 10.Lia 60% 11.Jiwoo 60% 12.Ryujin 60% 13.Lily 60% 14.Chaeryeong 60% 15. Giselle 50% 16.Ning 50%
@@jeanpierreveraalvarado7329 Lmaoo Karina being better than Lia, Haewon, Sullyoon, Bae and Giselle in stage presence is the best joke. Idk what is special in her stage presence?? All what she does are the same expressions and nothing new. After seeing Giselle stage presence in Coachella I will never place Karina above her. I don't mean to hate Karina but sorry there is nothing special in her stage presence for me. Her vocal is good, her rap is good and her dance is good but her stage presence?? Sorry one of the worst for me. Also she has 90% in Korean beauty because we counted the 10 main standards and each standard has 10% so Karina doesn't fit just one standard so this is why she has 90%.
@@inyochayacha548 SP is arguable, Lia sometimes look tired or bored, Sullyoon looks so shy, alike Bae. Well Giselle and Haewon are in the same line ay Karina. Besides that for the visual, in every single video of KBS she fits 90% I don't know what you are trying to say. Btw we all know she is the most beautiful idol. Her Body Proportion Is one of the Best in Kpop combinated with her unreal face. Unmatchable.
Rankings = Thumbs down Rankings are part of toxic fan culture. Only toxic fans compare and rate and rank idols. Only toxic fans feel the need to say one person is better at something than another.. Just like what you like, enjoy what you enjoy, do not compare it to anything or anyone else. There are enough toxic fan ranking and rating channels YT does not need a new one.. What YT does need is more fan support channels that make fun and funny compilations of videos of idols they adore. I suggest you go that route. This is a toxic fan wake up call. None of these groups in the video I did not watch, need or want toxic fans making these kinds of videos.
I feel like your taking this a little too seriously. 1: in not a toxic fan at all i love all the girls in this video and they all have something there good at. 2: this is just fun silly ranking. dont take it to heart. i made this video because i was bored and needed something to do. 3: not every person that does these types of videos are toxic. Most are actually really nice people. They love things/know a-lot about dancing or singing and want to evaluate their favorite groups on them, not because their hating on some members and praising others. Anyways thanks for the comment and the opinion😄
@@chuuclose2657 toxic fans rank things. Regardless of bored or what ever. The fact you don’t see comparisons of idols and putting one over another as toxic just means you are in denial. Toxic fans never think they are the toxic ones. Just trying to let you know. It’s your choice to be toxic. I can’t force you to stop. Super toxic fans make YT videos of their rankings. Evaluation of your favorite is toxic. Just enjoy it. Don’t read anything else into it. Enjoy it or don’t. But you don’t need to evaluate and rank it. That is 100% what toxic fans do.
@@incheonguy 1: I dont know if you have taken a second to even look at my channel but if you did it might spark your common sense and help fix your answer. If you look at my channel and the videos i have posted you would see that 2 out of the 8 videos I have posted( not including shorts) are rankings. Which will tell anyone that clearly has a mind that this isnt a ranking channel or that I dont refrain to only posting rankings. 2: if you feel some type of grudge or have a problem with rankings than dont watch them, comment on them ect. As long as no ones hating on anyone or dragging a idol down for no reason let people do what they wanna do. You know how many videos there are where idols are being ranked and not a single one is hurting anyone.
@@mywordsfact.6000 lily's highnote looks like she's struggling doing it while Ningning does it easily. Take as an example of "if I Ain't got you". They both sang it and Ningning did it better
The transition from haewon to yeji in the same song in dance ranking was so smooth
Agreed with everything but
Jiwoo is better then ryujin in dance
And finally someone who appreciates haewon's dancing , why dosent she have a dance position ? Jyp what are u doing😭
Ningning is litrally mini bada😭❤️her vocals 😭❤️
Intro: Get it by PRISTIN V
Edit: ty for the likes
Actaully both Yeji, Lia, and Chaeryoung have sub rapper lol, so if you rank one, you have to rank the other ones lol.
Vocal - LILY & NINGNING
Dance - YEJI & CHAERYOUNG
Rap - GISELLE & KARINA
FOR ME 🥰🥰🥰🥰😘😘
But Kyunjin & Jinni is better than Haewon at dance
Kyunjin same to Yeji
Jinni same to Chaeryoung
My dance rank
1.Chaeryoung
2.Yeji
3.Jinni
4.Kyujin
5.Jiwoo
My bias :YEJI, KYUJIN & KARINA
Nice video, I liked the addition of the rank within the group :)
To be honest I feel like Lily should’ve got first on vocals and NingNing get second
only you feel it
Sorry but Ningning is like in top 3 best vocalists in the K-pop world
@@k-day1 not in the industry, only in 4th gen
@@k-day1 let’s not take it that far
i kinda get what you mean cause lily has a different vocal colour compared to ningning so in your opinion lily would be higher but i think it would still be ningning first technique wise
I just wanna say this
NINGNING IS A BETTER VOCALIST THAN LIA , KARINA , GISELLE AND LILY .
AND WINTER IS AN AMAZING LEAD VOCALIST I FEEL LIKE SHE DESERVES THE 3RD POSITION AND LILY ALSO DESERVES THE 2ND POSITION SINCE NO DOUBT SHE VOCALS ARE AMAZING BUT NINGNING'S VOCALS ARE BETTER AND STRONGER. AND PLUS LILY AND NINGNING ARE BOTH ROOKIES THEY BOTH HAVE SO MUCH TIME TO IMPROVE THERE VOCALS.
Some people gonna say that I am a toxic my after reading this so lemmie clear this. First of I am Not a my I just watch a lot if ningning's singing voice and some of live performances and I can that she is a better vocalist and have a clearer voice I'm not hating on anyone is this video I'm just trying to say my honest opinion and feel free to disagree and give your opinions also.
Agreed but lia definately isn't a better dancer then Karina and lily
@@purva_4 ok fine she may not be a better dancer than Karina but she's better than lily in dancing.
@@imtherevolution1386 as a dancer , sorry but she isn't lily is way better
@@purva_4 that's ok your opinion is completely respected. That's just my opinion, lia might not be better than karina since karina is the main dancer of aespa but I feel like lily and lia dance the same just that lia dance moves are clean.
Bae as of now is the lowest in her group. as she is leaning toward being a Stylistic vocalist
Karina>Ryujin>Kyujin
Jiwoo>Yeji
Giselle>Karina>>>>>>>Ryujin>Yuna
Can I ask how did you guess the freestyle scores for Giselle, Ningning, and others who didn't show their freestyle yet?
So true !
omg its minty sana hi lol, i watch your videos
Mintyyyyyy
Love the video! Also the intro is awesome! Get it by Pristin V is so good!
Real rank
Vocal
1. Lily
2. Ningning/Haewon
3. Sullyoon/Winter
4. Kyujin
5. Karina
6. Jiwoo
7. Giselle
8. Jinni
9. Bae
10. Lia
11. Yeji
12. Chaeryoung
13. Yuna
14. Ryujin
Dance
1. Chaeryoung
2. Yeji
3. Jinni
4. Haewon
5. Kyujin
6. Ryujin
7. Karina
8. Lily
9. Sullyoon
10. Jiwoo
11. Yuna
12. Bae
13. Lia
14. Winter
15. Ningning
16. Giselle
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ryujin
4. Yuna
5. Jiwoo
6. Kyujin
7. Winter
8. Chaeryoung
9. Jinni
It's FACT
But Ningning has a better technique than Lily xd
@@fromista_sn2140 Lily's vocal rank is Decent vocal now in same vocal rank w Wendy and Ningning is above to arange vocal which is lower rank than Lily and Wendy
@@seeya5622 facts:
Lia being better at dancing than anyone 😂
Ryujin will be main dancer if she are in another group
I'm so glad that Lia have improve a lot on her dance now^_^
I think the vocals are 1.ningning/Lily because they are both good, very talented in my opinion
I only disagree with dance amd rap
Dance-Karina>ryujin>kyujin.
Jiwoo>yeji
Rap-Giselle>>karina>>>>ryujin>>yuna
I respect your opinion tho
No My Opin Dance Yeji>Kyujin>Ryujin>Karina>Jiwoo
@@차산니 idgaf about ur opinion
@@Devikapk3 Ouh Oky
@@차산니 yeah I agree with you
Not y’all forgetting about Chaeryeong what is this
♡Vocal (based on technique):
1. Lily (B-) ♕
2/3. Haewon (C+)
3/2. Ning (C+)
4.Winter (C)
5.Karina/Giselle/Kyujin (lower C)
6.Sullyoon/Jinni D+
8.Lia (D)
9.Jiwoo (E+)
10.Bae (E)
11/12.Yeji (F+)
12/13.Chaeryeong (F+)
14.Yuna (F)
15.Ryujin (F)
♡Rap: 1.Giselle ♕
2.Ryujin/Karina
3.Yuna
4.Jiwoo
5.Jinni
6.Kyujin
7.Yeji
8.Chaeryeong
9.Winter
10.Lia
11.Ning
♡Dance(by a dancer):
1.Chaeryeong 9.4/10♕
2/3.Jinni 9.3/10
3/2.Yeji 9.2/10
4.Haewon 9/10
5.Kyujin 8.9/10
6.Karina 8.7/10
7.Ryujin 8.4/10
8.Yuna 8.2/10
9.Jiwoo 8/10
10/11. Winter 7.6/10
11/10. Lily 7.5/10
12.Bae 7.2/10
13.Sullyoon 7/10
14.Ning 6.6/10
15.Giselle 5.6/10
16.Lia 5/10
♡Stage presence: 1.Ryujin ♕
2.Yuna
3.Kyujin
4.Yeji
5.Jinni
6.Jiwoo
7.Lily
8.Ning/Lia
9.Giselle
10.Sullyoon
11.Bae
12.Haewon
13.Karina
14.Chaeryeong
15.Winter
Visual (based on KBS): 1.Sullyoon 100% (arguably because many people said that she fits all the standards but I'm not sure about her fitting hourglass body or golden ratio)
2.Yuna 90% (doesn't fit hourglass body)
3.Winter 80%-90%(doesn't fit the height and the golden ratio but the height is debatable because people said that Winter confirmed that she is 1.66)
4.Karina 80% (doesn't fit hourglass body and golden ratio)
5.Bae 80% (doesn't fit V shape jaw and golden ratio)
6.Kyujin 80% (doesn't fit hourglass body and golden ratio)
7.Jinni 70% (doesn't fit V shape jaw, hourglass body and golden ratio)
8.Haewon 70% (doesn't fit hourglass body, the height and the golden ratio)
9.Yeji 70% (doesn't fit hourglass body, double eyelids and golden ratio)
10.Lia 60%
11.Jiwoo 60%
12.Ryujin 60%
13.Lily 60%
14.Chaeryeong 60%
15. Giselle 50%
16.Ning 50%
Kyuji, Karina, Giselle, sullyoon, jinni are all D+.
@@zeroc00k14 Vocal trainee told me that Karina, Kyujin and Giselle are lower C
You are underrating Karina, she is 90% in visual
And why she is so low in SP? She is even better than Giselle, Lia, Haewon, Sullyoon, Bae.
@@jeanpierreveraalvarado7329 Lmaoo Karina being better than Lia, Haewon, Sullyoon, Bae and Giselle in stage presence is the best joke. Idk what is special in her stage presence?? All what she does are the same expressions and nothing new. After seeing Giselle stage presence in Coachella I will never place Karina above her. I don't mean to hate Karina but sorry there is nothing special in her stage presence for me. Her vocal is good, her rap is good and her dance is good but her stage presence?? Sorry one of the worst for me. Also she has 90% in Korean beauty because we counted the 10 main standards and each standard has 10% so Karina doesn't fit just one standard so this is why she has 90%.
@@inyochayacha548 SP is arguable, Lia sometimes look tired or bored, Sullyoon looks so shy, alike Bae. Well Giselle and Haewon are in the same line ay Karina. Besides that for the visual, in every single video of KBS she fits 90% I don't know what you are trying to say. Btw we all know she is the most beautiful idol. Her Body Proportion Is one of the Best in Kpop combinated with her unreal face. Unmatchable.
🔥Nmixx 🔥all-rounder 🔥
Haewon is main vocalist
Facts
Rankings = Thumbs down Rankings are part of toxic fan culture. Only toxic fans compare and rate and rank idols. Only toxic fans feel the need to say one person is better at something than another.. Just like what you like, enjoy what you enjoy, do not compare it to anything or anyone else. There are enough toxic fan ranking and rating channels YT does not need a new one.. What YT does need is more fan support channels that make fun and funny compilations of videos of idols they adore. I suggest you go that route. This is a toxic fan wake up call. None of these groups in the video I did not watch, need or want toxic fans making these kinds of videos.
I feel like your taking this a little too seriously. 1: in not a toxic fan at all i love all the girls in this video and they all have something there good at. 2: this is just fun silly ranking. dont take it to heart. i made this video because i was bored and needed something to do. 3: not every person that does these types of videos are toxic. Most are actually really nice people. They love things/know a-lot about dancing or singing and want to evaluate their favorite groups on them, not because their hating on some members and praising others. Anyways thanks for the comment and the opinion😄
@@chuuclose2657 toxic fans rank things. Regardless of bored or what ever. The fact you don’t see comparisons of idols and putting one over another as toxic just means you are in denial. Toxic fans never think they are the toxic ones. Just trying to let you know. It’s your choice to be toxic. I can’t force you to stop.
Super toxic fans make YT videos of their rankings.
Evaluation of your favorite is toxic. Just enjoy it. Don’t read anything else into it. Enjoy it or don’t. But you don’t need to evaluate and rank it. That is 100% what toxic fans do.
@@incheonguy 1: I dont know if you have taken a second to even look at my channel but if you did it might spark your common sense and help fix your answer. If you look at my channel and the videos i have posted you would see that 2 out of the 8 videos I have posted( not including shorts) are rankings. Which will tell anyone that clearly has a mind that this isnt a ranking channel or that I dont refrain to only posting rankings. 2: if you feel some type of grudge or have a problem with rankings than dont watch them, comment on them ect. As long as no ones hating on anyone or dragging a idol down for no reason let people do what they wanna do. You know how many videos there are where idols are being ranked and not a single one is hurting anyone.
its really biased
tbh in vocals
1.lily
2.haewon
3.ning
4.winter
5.kyujin>=karina
6.sullyoon
7.giselle
8.jinni
9.lia
10.bae
11.jiwoo
12.yeji>=chaeryeong
13.yuna
14.ryujin
and chae defo ain't 9.6 in dance she's under 8.6
Haewon is not better than ningning lily yes but haewon no
LILY IS A BETTER VOCALIST THAN NINGNING, AND LIA THAN GISELLE & KARINA.
LIA IS A BETTER DANCER THAN GISELLE AND YUNA THAN KARINA
I AGREE!!!!
Yesss!
Ningning has a more developed voice than lily. Lia needs practise, Lia struggles with dance , yuna can't outdance karina
@@ixx77702 lily is A5,while Ning is AA,so Lily is better
@@mywordsfact.6000 lily's highnote looks like she's struggling doing it while Ningning does it easily. Take as an example of "if I Ain't got you". They both sang it and Ningning did it better
Nmixx haters gotta realize that they will become the most popular group someday lol
tell me when o.o reaches 100 million views
@@aespaworlddominationae1 not just o.o lmao
@@Mayarmageddontank? haha you’re so funny XD
@@aespaworlddominationae1 bro you use XD I can tell you’re 9..
This not fair
I prefer ITZY
You ranking them in Vocal without technical side Funny 🤡
LOW-MIX-HV
1.Lily - G3-D5/Eb5-G5 [High -AA]
2.Haewon-G#3-C5/C#5(D5-Eb5)-Eb5/E5 [AA]
2.Ningning- F#3-C5/C#5(D5/Eb5)-E5 [AA]
3.Winter-G3-/B4(C5) possible can go higher support [A-AA]
4.Kyunjin-G#3-Bb4/B4-D5 can do HV [Low A]
5.Sullyoon-A3-B4 [W-A]
6.Karina-G#3-Bb4(B4) [W-A]
7.Jinni-A3/Bb3-Bb4 [W-A]
8.Gissele- A3-A4(Bb4) [W-A]
9.Jiwoo-A3-A4(Bb4) [W-A]
10.Lia-A3-A4[W-A]
11.Bae-(A4) [W]
12.Yeji [W]
13.Chaeryoung [W]
14.Yuna [W]
15.Ryujin [W]
Jinni rap'te nasil 9??
Chaeryeong*
How biased you this to be
Creator :
Ur showing them for too long geez
Haewon and lily are stronger than winter & nignig
for vocal: lia>>sullyoon>giselle
Nahh giselle/sullyoon(idk her properly)>>giselle
Nah Giselle is literally better than sullyoon and lia
Lol you're aespa stan
=))) omg sucks