Intellectual talk reminds me of East Pakistan. My homeland Dacca used to be the second capital of Pakistan. I haven't forgotten till today, that terrible midnight operation in Dacca on 26th March in 1971. Just one night, one hundred thousand innocent sleeping people were killed by the Pakistan army. Searchlight-operation's pain can never be forgotten. Bangladeshi people, 26th March observed as violence and horrors remembrance and independence day.
India and pakistan become free country with inhertance of same british law. But both have choosen different path. India has choosen secular and democrstic path while pakistan has choosen very nerrow religion based path. India has taken very dradtic land reforms, reservation for oppressed class, fredom to follow any faith inspite of many problem india had successfully conducted fair elevtion, hold its judiciary systum, fredom of press set up educational dystem though there were some sort comming but move on in slowly but in right direction. In India, there is always peaceful transfer of government after election.
India has chosen to continue European Ideology with hatred for Hindu Civilization. Hindu Culture and Customs are made to felt inferior by English Educated Hindus benefited from Nehru ideology. Nehru has claimed he wants to make New India as a India who is ashamed of its civilization and proud of European civilization. He also claimed he looks Indian but thiniks like a British.
Dear Dr. Hoodhboy thank you so much for your work, your struggle and this beautiful interview with the great Mr. Khattak. He’s a national asset for us.
Punit Pania, an Indian comic said about India, "Till today, the biggest achievement in this country is to leave it!" This applies just as well to Pakistan and the other neighboring countries. The simple idea of "live and let live" has had an excruciatingly difficult time in gaining a foothold in South Asia.
The students you taught would been very Fortunate sir, if possible kindly think about teaching atleast as a guest lecture at Indian Universities also sir! 🙏
Someone has to tell Orya MJ that nations learn from history as these both intellectuals discuss the gray areas of our politics and weak constitutional institutions.
@@anartaroy711 Well that's OK, so you did not make a point. But then why feel the need to type anything at all? And your emojis! You must be a teenager.
@@anartaroy711 I was talking about your "mental age". That you are a PhD candidate in the US, does not show in your language or the points you put forth. Look up Paxton on the map and lemme know where it is. Forgot to mention, I have a PhD (Physics) from MIT (1996).
Sir, Fauj ke hote hue nahin,Fauj ki vajah se hua 71 ka sanah. Khamosi itni asani se nahin tutegi Sir. Establishment is led by Army but includes whole lot of beaurcracy judiciary and top officials from all domains of Pak. Do Take care.
a message of Dr. AQ Khan on this treacherous Hoodbhoy "Sir Gen Zia wanted to throw him out knowing that he was a CIA and Indian agent. but hameeda khuro begged him to spare as it would annoy the Americans. I was member of syndicate and so was she. no doubt he was a foreign agent all the time talking against our nuclear program. Nobody knows him for his academic achievements. Students used to say he was a staunch ahmadi. Dr. AQkhan."
We must sensitize our nation specially youth that only democratic govts. can better lead. Military and judiciary must limit their role as per constitution. Unfortunately still our politicians look to be acceptable of establishment then how we'll change the policies. Now Pak is an isolated country in the world and people and Govts. don't trust us. Big reason to worry for people of Pak.
Militaries-with-countries like the German Empire and Pakistan are quite cool though. I liked reading about Zia ul Haque’s era. But its also true that this is an inferior form to Countries-with-militaries
British vacate india on agreement that whoever fight for British support British will b protected and rewarded in new state no land will b ceased our share was 70% of British army so army will rule pakistan directly or indirectly.
What a tragedy that to make a false equivalence you can equate the 2 countries.. human rights, freeing land from zamindars, minority commission, delimitations, increasing the reach of health and education across the nation.. if u think india and pakistan is the same, please go and live there as a hindu.
China is a progressive socialist dictatorship? How can progressive and dictatorship coexist? No doubt China has made economic progress but at a cost which is not known. It's a police and surveillance state quite similar to George Orwell's Animal Farm.
@@poorvasharma3881 they talked about laws which both countries inherited from the British and neither changed them. Thus being colonial in spirit these laws have caused hardships for people on both sides of the border, hence they are same.
@@akshaysingh3922 same at some extent India is quite better than us in almost every aspect like education,tourism, finance etc but both of them cannot eradicate haters and I wish both our country have to be friendly with each other. Indo Pak relationship may restore but I don't think 😄😀😀 Modi aur Imran k daur ma to ni hogi 😉
No India was not a nation in past it was ruled by dynasties fighting with each other to take control. There was no one country or centralized empire like Greece, Rome, Israel, Persia or ottoman. China also had central government. Southern part of India was ruled by different dynasties and Northern also. That's you had rajputana, maratha, khalsa, dogra, not one unified empire like ottoman/ France or UK. It's the British who had unite India into one single country
@@zia4550 there was never one Greek empire, they fought with each other so are others. English, Scotland, Wales and Ireland fought each other before becoming a nation. It is a modern concept which will evolve to something else as wold progress or digress.
I am astonished to see, that none of the two dared compare their selves with India, which basically is their own denomination. They gave examples of China, Iran but not their own ie. the civilization of their own ie. The Indian Civilization. I see the biggest issue with the Pakistanis is that they don't consider themselves a part of civilization which was predominantly there before 74 years.
India have more poor than all Africa combined, it's utterly unhygienic nation and Indian have the same 3 world underlying tribal culture just like sub Saharan Africa and Pakistan,. Religion might differ. China is advanced that went into culture revolution and bring western values and transform itself from Africa like existence to great nation. What India had achieved so that other can learn from. It's poor, backward, third world country like Pakistan. We learn from someone above than us not below or at the same level.
@@zia4550 how about you compare with Bangladesh first? If you want to follow the Chinese model then are you suggesting getting ride of Mullahs and Military control? Are you willing to trade with India as China does? As one American diplomat in Pakistan was told without Islamic ideology Pakistanis are nothing but Indian. Jinnah was basically British who knew that he will die very soon and wanted to become a ruler created a state with a 'Direct Action' but failed with his death. I agreed that India has more poor but it manages own population and Indians abroad manage large corporations than Chinese. It is a slow progress under democratic rule than authoritarian rule but India is still heading in a right direction regardless who is running. It is not uncommon in West that many preferred closer to India than other South Asian countries but definitely not China😁😁😁
@@zia4550 if you were under the “progressive” regime of china, you would’ve been rotting in a re-education (concentration) camp for criticising the regime! Ask the Hong Kong pro democracy protestors where are they and how are they living ? If the richest man in china Jack Ma had to be removed and silenced from public eyes for three months and had to abolish his grand IPO of his new venture Ant group just for criticising the banking system think of ordinary citizens there.
@@rahuketu2484 China's per capita is 5 times of India, they have job, well built cities and democratic India is just chaocratic, dirty and poor. Progress is above democracy or any other political system.
@@zia4550 😂😂😂 yes we are not as rich as China as a whole, but we don't cry about it nor we beg from the world. Anyway my point was you've always liked something/someone other than what you are..and that's why you are at a verge of being a failed state.
قائد اعظم محمد علی جناح نے اسلام کے نام پر بھانومتی کا کنبہ جوڑدیا۔ کہیں کی اینٹ کہیں کا روڑا یوں کنبہ جوڑا۔ پاکستان میں حكومت کرنے والے ہندوستان سے اءے تھے۔ جن علاقوں میں پاکستان بنا وہاں کی ساری انتظامیہ ہندو اور سکھوں کے ہاتھ میں تھی جو تقسیم کے بعد ہندوستان چلے گئے۔
Haan bhai kesa Dia phir? Taliban ujjad ganwaar molvio ne Tumharay highly advanced abu ko bhaga Dia phir 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 kesa Dia? Acha nai dia? Ignominious defeat 😂😂😂😂😂
No not balance sheet.. Balance sheet can be falsified.. you should have named it cash flow statement. It give accurate picture of the country or business.. It can’t be falsified, if falsified, it can be caught in this quarter/year or the other.. than the proper investigation can be done and each and string can be pulled out if wanted..
No need to have these peripheral discussions. Your main problems are 1. You are ashamed of your past (ie Indian past) 2. You are ashamed of your language. Punjabi, Sindhi etc. 3. You are ashamed of your culture Keep discussing
I wish we had such level of discussions on our hindi channels . This is just master class . We have also ruined our country since Modi and his Andh-bhakts have taken over the reigns of India.They have erased all the good foundations laid by Congress government... Especially by P.V Narsimha Rao. We should have learned from Pakistani mistakes. And not go into this shitty territory of religious bigotry and Hindutva fundamentalism....I wish...but alas !!
Cursed face targeting hijab, hiding in the face of freedom of expression ironically needs to know about freedom of expression and respect for everyone.
@@sk-4464 kiyun bay yeh Teri maa Ka fucker hay hood Bhoy Jo iski fikar hay tujhay pareshan na ho yeh mar giya to iski Jaga main Teri ma ko service provide Kar Sakta hoon
Intellectual talk reminds me of East Pakistan. My homeland Dacca used to be the second capital of Pakistan. I haven't forgotten till today, that terrible midnight operation in Dacca on 26th March in 1971. Just one night, one hundred thousand innocent sleeping people were killed by the Pakistan army. Searchlight-operation's pain can never be forgotten. Bangladeshi people, 26th March observed as violence and horrors remembrance and independence day.
@Global Revolution Respect and love you from Germany.
Please acknowledge the contribution and sacrifices made by India to Secure Independence and liberation of Bangladesh.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
India and pakistan become free country with inhertance of same british law. But both have choosen different path. India has choosen secular and democrstic path while pakistan has choosen very nerrow religion based path. India has taken very dradtic land reforms, reservation for oppressed class, fredom to follow any faith inspite of many problem india had successfully conducted fair elevtion, hold its judiciary systum, fredom of press set up educational dystem though there were some sort comming but move on in slowly but in right direction. In India, there is always peaceful transfer of government after election.
India has chosen to continue European Ideology with hatred for Hindu Civilization. Hindu Culture and Customs are made to felt inferior by English Educated Hindus benefited from Nehru ideology. Nehru has claimed he wants to make New India as a India who is ashamed of its civilization and proud of European civilization. He also claimed he looks Indian but thiniks like a British.
Such a progressive guest for discussion. Sir afrasyab khattak.
Dr. Saheb, Aap ek world citizen hain. Sukriya.
Dear Dr. Hoodhboy thank you so much for your work, your struggle and this beautiful interview with the great Mr. Khattak. He’s a national asset for us.
Love from Afghanistan 🇦🇫🙏
Love to listen Dr. Hoodbohy
You are a gentleman and a scholar. May God bless you.
Good conversation 👌, Especially for YOUTH of Pakistan.
May Aallah SWT Guide you
Good thoughts of both personalties for Pakistan .
Punit Pania, an Indian comic said about India, "Till today, the biggest achievement in this country is to leave it!" This applies just as well to Pakistan and the other neighboring countries. The simple idea of "live and let live" has had an excruciatingly difficult time in gaining a foothold in South Asia.
What a knowledgeable intellectual conversation.
The students you taught would been very Fortunate sir, if possible kindly think about teaching atleast as a guest lecture at Indian Universities also sir! 🙏
Love you Sir Pervaiz Hoodbhoy,
We all love u .pervez hood bhoy
Khattak sahib is incredibly intelligent person
Someone has to tell Orya MJ that nations learn from history as these both intellectuals discuss the gray areas of our politics and weak constitutional institutions.
But our history was written not occured
@@humhum4347 lol 😂
This channel is like " How to think "
Very nice and informative talk 👍
No medals in Olympics because the organization is headed by retired General for last 20 years
अमेरिका का मोस्टवांटेड अफ़ग़ानिस्तान का गृह मंत्री बना यानि पाकिस्तान के दोनों हाथ घी में और सिर कढ़ाई में ।
Great discussion 👏👏😊😊
👍👍
Bangladesh is gdp wise richer than Paxton. In other words solving equations is not enough 😂😂.
Can you make a point coherently?
@@ahmedhusseinny I do not feel responsible to do that. 😂 Every country needs to figure out their own local problems themselves.
@@anartaroy711 Well that's OK, so you did not make a point. But then why feel the need to type anything at all? And your emojis! You must be a teenager.
@@ahmedhusseinny No I am not a teenager. I am a PhD student in US. A pakistani friend told me see this. Its interesting. 😂
@@anartaroy711 I was talking about your "mental age". That you are a PhD candidate in the US, does not show in your language or the points you put forth. Look up Paxton on the map and lemme know where it is. Forgot to mention, I have a PhD (Physics) from MIT (1996).
Sir, Fauj ke hote hue nahin,Fauj ki vajah se hua 71 ka sanah. Khamosi itni asani se nahin tutegi Sir. Establishment is led by Army but includes whole lot of beaurcracy judiciary and top officials from all domains of Pak. Do Take care.
Good Conversations Two Intellectual Person 🙏🙏🙏
Very good presentation.
a message of Dr. AQ Khan on this treacherous Hoodbhoy
"Sir Gen Zia wanted to throw him out knowing that he was a CIA and Indian agent. but hameeda khuro begged him to spare as it would annoy the Americans. I was member of syndicate and so was she. no doubt he was a foreign agent all the time talking against our nuclear program. Nobody knows him for his academic achievements. Students used to say he was a staunch ahmadi. Dr. AQkhan."
Prof Hoodbhoy, please consider posting a continuing series of videos on “hot” topics in physics at a popular level in English. Enough of politics.
Super Conversation..Lajawaab 👍👏👏
We must sensitize our nation specially youth that only democratic govts. can better lead. Military and judiciary must limit their role as per constitution. Unfortunately still our politicians look to be acceptable of establishment then how we'll change the policies. Now Pak is an isolated country in the world and people and Govts. don't trust us. Big reason to worry for people of Pak.
Militaries-with-countries like the German Empire and Pakistan are quite cool though. I liked reading about Zia ul Haque’s era. But its also true that this is an inferior form to Countries-with-militaries
British vacate india on agreement that whoever fight for British support British will b protected and rewarded in new state no land will b ceased our share was 70% of British army so army will rule pakistan directly or indirectly.
Sir kya balancesheet dikhayenge ??? Asset se liability jyada hi rahega.
Tally nahin karega
kuch assets kaafi valuable h pakistan k jaise terrorist organization
Can someone tell me exact Law no which afraisab is talking about 109 because I can't find it
Same situation on both sides yet the partition. Who became better then?
What a tragedy that to make a false equivalence you can equate the 2 countries.. human rights, freeing land from zamindars, minority commission, delimitations, increasing the reach of health and education across the nation.. if u think india and pakistan is the same, please go and live there as a hindu.
@@poorvasharma3881 Exactly
China is a progressive socialist dictatorship? How can progressive and dictatorship coexist? No doubt China has made economic progress but at a cost which is not known. It's a police and surveillance state quite similar to George Orwell's Animal Farm.
@@poorvasharma3881 they talked about laws which both countries inherited from the British and neither changed them. Thus being colonial in spirit these laws have caused hardships for people on both sides of the border, hence they are same.
@@akshaysingh3922 same at some extent India is quite better than us in almost every aspect like education,tourism, finance etc but both of them cannot eradicate haters and I wish both our country have to be friendly with each other. Indo Pak relationship may restore but I don't think 😄😀😀
Modi aur Imran k daur ma to ni hogi 😉
When you talk about the old nation, You can talk about India. Which has a written history of more than 3000 years old.
Muslims ruled India, so sit down
13000BC se history chronological order me Likha hua hai refer vedveer arya
No India was not a nation in past it was ruled by dynasties fighting with each other to take control. There was no one country or centralized empire like Greece, Rome, Israel, Persia or ottoman. China also had central government. Southern part of India was ruled by different dynasties and Northern also. That's you had rajputana, maratha, khalsa, dogra, not one unified empire like ottoman/ France or UK. It's the British who had unite India into one single country
@@zia4550 there was never one Greek empire, they fought with each other so are others. English, Scotland, Wales and Ireland fought each other before becoming a nation. It is a modern concept which will evolve to something else as wold progress or digress.
@@mikewhiddett8795 So you consider Christian rule on India too? Turks ruled over Greeks for 400 years but they are still orthodox Greek.
I am astonished to see, that none of the two dared compare their selves with India, which basically is their own denomination. They gave examples of China, Iran but not their own ie. the civilization of their own ie. The Indian Civilization. I see the biggest issue with the Pakistanis is that they don't consider themselves a part of civilization which was predominantly there before 74 years.
India have more poor than all Africa combined, it's utterly unhygienic nation and Indian have the same 3 world underlying tribal culture just like sub Saharan Africa and Pakistan,. Religion might differ. China is advanced that went into culture revolution and bring western values and transform itself from Africa like existence to great nation. What India had achieved so that other can learn from. It's poor, backward, third world country like Pakistan. We learn from someone above than us not below or at the same level.
@@zia4550 how about you compare with Bangladesh first? If you want to follow the Chinese model then are you suggesting getting ride of Mullahs and Military control? Are you willing to trade with India as China does? As one American diplomat in Pakistan was told without Islamic ideology Pakistanis are nothing but Indian. Jinnah was basically British who knew that he will die very soon and wanted to become a ruler created a state with a 'Direct Action' but failed with his death. I agreed that India has more poor but it manages own population and Indians abroad manage large corporations than Chinese. It is a slow progress under democratic rule than authoritarian rule but India is still heading in a right direction regardless who is running. It is not uncommon in West that many preferred closer to India than other South Asian countries but definitely not China😁😁😁
@@zia4550 if you were under the “progressive” regime of china, you would’ve been rotting in a re-education (concentration) camp for criticising the regime! Ask the Hong Kong pro democracy protestors where are they and how are they living ? If the richest man in china Jack Ma had to be removed and silenced from public eyes for three months and had to abolish his grand IPO of his new venture Ant group just for criticising the banking system think of ordinary citizens there.
@@rahuketu2484
China's per capita is 5 times of India, they have job, well built cities and democratic India is just chaocratic, dirty and poor. Progress is above democracy or any other political system.
@@zia4550 😂😂😂 yes we are not as rich as China as a whole, but we don't cry about it nor we beg from the world. Anyway my point was you've always liked something/someone other than what you are..and that's why you are at a verge of being a failed state.
You are good and blunt. Nice conversation
Sir Great hai aap acharya ki tarh hai na ki muslim ki Tarah
Pervez Sahab kash aap hamare desh me hote. We love you
lejao ise
@@muhammadhussain5854 ek din pura pakistan lenge beta tu bhi ek din indian banega. ultimately you are an indian
قائد اعظم محمد علی جناح نے اسلام کے نام پر بھانومتی کا کنبہ جوڑدیا۔ کہیں کی اینٹ کہیں کا روڑا یوں کنبہ جوڑا۔ پاکستان میں حكومت کرنے والے ہندوستان سے اءے تھے۔ جن علاقوں میں پاکستان بنا وہاں کی ساری انتظامیہ ہندو اور سکھوں کے ہاتھ میں تھی جو تقسیم کے بعد ہندوستان چلے گئے۔
Highly intellectual thought behind it
I am Rajesh kulkarni l am wacting your u Tub Chanal Sir
Mr. Khattak is still alive 😮 , after his recent diatribe on Taliban , thought for sure he was six feet under.
Pakistan army also involved
Haan bhai kesa Dia phir? Taliban ujjad ganwaar molvio ne Tumharay highly advanced abu ko bhaga Dia phir 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 kesa Dia? Acha nai dia? Ignominious defeat 😂😂😂😂😂
مشکل یہ ہے کہ پاکستانیوں نے قاءد اعظم کو بہت اونچا درجہ دے دیا تھا۔
پاکستان میں سب زیادہ کرپشن عدلیہ میں ہے۔
Military
No not balance sheet.. Balance sheet can be falsified..
you should have named it cash flow statement. It give accurate picture of the country or business.. It can’t be falsified, if falsified, it can be caught in this quarter/year or the other..
than the proper investigation can be done and each and string can be pulled out if wanted..
spoken like a true accountant :)
No need to have these peripheral discussions. Your main problems are
1. You are ashamed of your past (ie Indian past)
2. You are ashamed of your language. Punjabi, Sindhi etc.
3. You are ashamed of your culture
Keep discussing
Aapki es discussion ka koi fayda nahi. Kyunki esko koi Pakistan me accept nahi karega
Use a better mic
Sir, you graduated from MIT. I want to know how you got into MIT
I wish we had such level of discussions on our hindi channels . This is just master class . We have also ruined our country since Modi and his Andh-bhakts have taken over the reigns of India.They have erased all the good foundations laid by Congress government... Especially by P.V Narsimha Rao.
We should have learned from Pakistani mistakes. And not go into this shitty territory of religious bigotry and Hindutva fundamentalism....I wish...but alas !!
14 August zandabad
Abe professor tu to gora hye be lekin tera surname kyun HoodBoy hye be?kalaa hota to samjh main ataa HoodBoy surname lekin gora hoke HoodBoy?
Cursed face targeting hijab, hiding in the face of freedom of expression ironically needs to know about freedom of expression and respect for everyone.
Itni age ho gai hay abhi tak physically fit ho budhay ho ab mar bhi jau hood Bhai, kitnay log budhay ho gay aur mar gay Tu bhi mar Jaan Chor ab ,
@@sk-4464 kiyun bay yeh Teri maa Ka fucker hay hood Bhoy Jo iski fikar hay tujhay pareshan na ho yeh mar giya to iski Jaga main Teri ma ko service provide Kar Sakta hoon
@@sk-4464 wesay BHI tum logo main yeh Sab comon hay maa apnay yar k sath behn apnay yar k sath
lanat hy tum pe