Discussion under Rule184 on Motion to withdraw decision to allow FDI in retail: Smt. Sushma Swaraj

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
  • Discussion under Rule184 on Motion to withdraw decision to allow FDI in retail: Smt. Sushma Swaraj: 04.12.2012

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @itsnaanee
    @itsnaanee 12 років тому +9

    Excellent Speech Sushma ji. Very detailed speech with detailed analysis. You showed real the difference between Leaders & speech readers.

  • @gauravzerogravity
    @gauravzerogravity 12 років тому +3

    She is such an awesome Speaker, marvelous and historic speech ever

  • @gauravzerogravity
    @gauravzerogravity 12 років тому +4

    even if the NDA lost Poll on FDI, but they won the Debate and a Huge Support from a common man, no doubt Sonia was pounded by Wallmart for FDI, mindblowing speech,

  • @basantitekam899
    @basantitekam899 4 роки тому +7

    12:50 FDI investment
    16:10 about retailers
    17:40 FDI favour in farmers
    18:40 EU parliament declaration failed
    18:50 farmers protest
    20:40 about farmers
    22:10 potato & tomatato wala dard
    25:30 middle man khtm , bicholiya khtm
    27:10 ganna mil ka dard
    31:35 gramin arthvyavastha
    33:40 gramin economy , bicholiya khatam

    • @PratikLawate
      @PratikLawate 4 роки тому +1

      Now her own party going against her

    • @jsreeram
      @jsreeram 3 роки тому

      Solution is MSP that is going to be there because of which Canada complained in the United Nations . I don't know much please educate me regarding the flaws as I didn't search it was on my feed on Sushmaji birthday.

    • @jsreeram
      @jsreeram 3 роки тому +1

      But yes opposition should be like this .

  • @ShwetaMehtaOmanaThampuratty
    @ShwetaMehtaOmanaThampuratty 12 років тому +1

    Mam, you are working and thinking for common man, I am one of the example, I can't forget you till the last breath of my life. Mam, please never give in, keep going on, we all are with you, Widows Welfare Trust having 253 members, we will work for you in the coming LS election. Thank you Mam, Shweta Mehta

  • @belivekeepsugoing1184
    @belivekeepsugoing1184 12 років тому +4

    i have nothing to day ...... i can only bow my head in SUSHMA JI respect !!!

  • @MrKarannanda
    @MrKarannanda 12 років тому +2

    this is once again a fabulous performance by smt sushma swaraj ji on fdi and true reality

  • @kamalgupta1214
    @kamalgupta1214 12 років тому +1

    " FDI vikas ki sidhi nahi vinas ka ghadda hai" awesome, an eye opener speech on FDI.... as usual she did homework very well... in depth knowledge of the subject with all the facts and figures.

  • @anvivek
    @anvivek 12 років тому +1

    Powerful speech from Sushmaji... such a great orator... in BJP Atalji, Advanji, Arun Jaitleyji and Sushma Swaraj ji are really a very good orators with in-dept knowledge on the topic they speak.

  • @aakankshas01
    @aakankshas01 12 років тому +2

    Sushma swaraj ji. this is the best speech ever hear from a female.. :)

  • @nanjeshigowda3395
    @nanjeshigowda3395 3 роки тому

    So great speaking to parliament Sushma Swaraj Amma, godbless you all Indians Bharath maataki Jai Hind,.

  • @nanjeshigowda3395
    @nanjeshigowda3395 3 роки тому

    So great speaking with indian farmer
    Sushmamma in parliament India MP,
    Bharath maataki Jai Hind Jai soldiers and farmers All godbless you all Indians,.

  • @palsuryapal
    @palsuryapal 11 років тому +5

    Sushma ji welldone

  • @DipankarKumar09
    @DipankarKumar09 12 років тому +1

    shushma ji your speech is just awesome..........in few politician u are one of them who is great speaker.

  • @nehavin
    @nehavin 12 років тому +2

    wonderful Sushma ji ... amazing speech...

    • @mcmeasylife
      @mcmeasylife 4 роки тому

      Maine b ye speech dekhi thi...... Per aaj 2020 mein ...dukh hota hai.... Aj chota dukandar khatam Ho raha hai.... Per Sawal hai ki kya satta mein aane k baad party Sab bhool kyon gai

    • @mcmeasylife
      @mcmeasylife 4 роки тому

      Aaj to inki party iska ulta kar rahi hai

    • @HarshRaj-qy1hm
      @HarshRaj-qy1hm 3 роки тому

      @@mcmeasylife Narendra Modi's economics is very different from Sushma Swaraj's economics. Uss time Gujarat me bhi unki alag policy thi.

  • @niteshrathi02
    @niteshrathi02 12 років тому +1

    just wonderful....... enlightening .......

  • @vishalkch52565
    @vishalkch52565 11 років тому +1

    Hats off!! to Susmaswaraj,most brilliant leader of India.

  • @shrutishah6008
    @shrutishah6008 5 місяців тому +1

    supremely learned!

  • @siddharthj275
    @siddharthj275 12 років тому +1

    प्रधानमंत्री मनमोहन सिंह और वित्तमंत्री चिदंबरम air conditioned room में बैठकर गरीबो , किसानो , आम आदमी के बारे में नीतियाँ बनाते हैं. इन्हें क्या पता की आम आदमी की समस्या क्या है ये तो कभी किसी गाँव में भी नहीं गए .
    sushma ji Hats off to you!!! you are the real indian among these foreign agents.

  • @karansingh5058
    @karansingh5058 12 років тому +2

    After Mr. Vajpayee, she is the most sensible BJP leader.

  • @prad2491
    @prad2491 12 років тому +2

    EXCELLENT SUSHMA JI

  • @ganeshmore4585
    @ganeshmore4585 5 років тому +2

    Great job!

  • @pradyanath7044
    @pradyanath7044 12 років тому

    It's another historic speech of u. Save the retailer, save the poor

  • @Manziit
    @Manziit 4 роки тому +6

    bhajpa walo modi ji ko suna do ekbar...kisan adhyadesh

  • @vishalkch52565
    @vishalkch52565 11 років тому +3

    A masterpiece from susmaji's mouth

  • @navneetsingh7353
    @navneetsingh7353 4 роки тому +1

    I think MPs were barking on that time when she was speaking to interrupt her.She was well educated not illiterate like congress MPs

  • @anvivek
    @anvivek 12 років тому +1

    Shocked to hear PEPSI and Mc-Donald stories.... Really an eye opener

  • @AquariusLoveCancer
    @AquariusLoveCancer 11 років тому +2

    In Walmart most of the products are from foreign countries...electronics and most of the goods are from china, clothes are from Indonesia and Bangladesh...These countries are near to us...So WalMart will be one more middle man between India-China, India-Bangladesh, India-Indonesia trading...This government is just a crap..this is all happening because of that one Rand called Sonia... Better the India will be Sooner she will be out of Parliament and India.My pain go to my Indian Kisan.Jai Hind...

  • @anvivek
    @anvivek 12 років тому

    very well explained on why FDI in retail cannot create 40 lakh jobs...

  • @vimal1444
    @vimal1444 11 років тому +2

    gre8 speech

  • @MNSNaidu
    @MNSNaidu 11 років тому +1

    Yes. FDI is good thing, when it comes to Hi-Tech Manufacturing where such products are not maded locally. But not for 'Trading'. India was a country where it is "locally produced, locally traded, and locally consumed". There was NO necessity to have large storage & so-called supply chain, as FCI was taking care of large food grains storage for years. In China, it has become a hub for manufacturing. Americans/Europeans are trying convert India as new consumer base for their product.

  • @snoopy004002
    @snoopy004002 11 років тому +2

    So you are saying they are trying to convert India into a new consumer base for China's product? I don't think so, India already receives goods from china. What they want is cheap indian labor, world economy is competitive, if India can produce the same goods as china more cheaply then India has an advantage. As you know China is a one party so laws change really fast there; they want a balance which India can provide, they don't want all eggs in one basket. This is a good for people w/o jobs.

  • @adtipatel
    @adtipatel 12 років тому +2

    Hats Off to her..!!

  • @worldonthetable
    @worldonthetable 12 років тому +1

    hai koi bhrat mein aurat ..hain koi dusri party mein in jaisi...................koi nahi pta nahi fir bhi log kyu khujli aur dusri parties ka support kertey hain

  • @anvivek
    @anvivek 12 років тому +1

    Nicely took Soniaji for a task... ha ha very nice :-)

  • @pujastudios7710
    @pujastudios7710 2 роки тому

    Sare jaha se aachha Hindu sita hamara hamara ham bulbule hai unke jisne hame banaaa sansar sarkar Mera Bharat mahan pustak sarswati sisu vidhya mandir ganga yamuna sarswati Laxmi bhagya laxmi bhagya bidhata original sanskar puja vidhi vidhan

  • @raviprakashmishra8432
    @raviprakashmishra8432 3 роки тому

    In 2021 agar B j p me Sushma Swaraj g hoti to kya yahi tark deti ?

  • @rahulranjankashyap8078
    @rahulranjankashyap8078 5 років тому

    I have seen 100s of lokasabha discussion but never I have seen a rulling party behaves like that same on you congress people..

  • @talkhimanshu59
    @talkhimanshu59 12 років тому +1

    1 wallmart per Intersection in india

  • @sahil1990garg
    @sahil1990garg 12 років тому +1

    1:04:00 to 1:08:00 awesome

    • @mcmeasylife
      @mcmeasylife 4 роки тому

      Aaj 2020 mein inki party iska ulta kar rahi hai

  • @talkhimanshu59
    @talkhimanshu59 12 років тому +1

    what a average,
    good

  • @snoopy004002
    @snoopy004002 11 років тому

    then tell me why doesn't india have a decent supply chain system yet? And no they are not going to gift it to INDIA...but walmart has a clear incentive to make this work. Again look what happened in CHINA....more jobs were created. FDI is a good thing even from a economics stand point and you can't deny that.

  • @abcd10566
    @abcd10566 12 років тому

    Does anyone know what was muted at 45:45?

    • @ar6176
      @ar6176 5 років тому

      Sabse jyada SME se unemployment aayega

  • @yashnorules
    @yashnorules 12 років тому

    suprlky.....

  • @creataccounts9520
    @creataccounts9520 2 роки тому

    Good

  • @anvivek
    @anvivek 12 років тому

    A class in government primary school in the worst connected remote village anywhere in India will behave more decent than some of these MPs.. shame on them .. sorry...

  • @manvendrakothari5753
    @manvendrakothari5753 4 роки тому +1

    सत्यानाश हो मदन लाल शर्मा का हर बार बीच-बीच में व्यवधान डालता रहता है

  • @mahajanravish
    @mahajanravish 3 роки тому

    BJP should make a point . People are using this video to mislead people and farmers.She is talking about FDI in farming. But current Bill talks about India's private sector involvement in farming. I don't know if this current bill is boon or not but don't compare current bill with Sushma swaraj speech. It's different.
    Don't mislead people

    • @vaibhavmahobiya9129
      @vaibhavmahobiya9129 3 роки тому

      You are right he is is talking about fdi but pahale inhone fdi ko badha diya hai 100% tak kar di hai aur abb private sector ko allow kar diya obvious bat hai ke ab bahar se India me company aynengi and farmer ko exploit karengi

    • @mahajanravish
      @mahajanravish 3 роки тому +1

      @@vaibhavmahobiya9129 YES , farmers ke paas choise he. Agar company MSP se bhi zyada de rahi he to problem kya he. Aur agar nhi de rahi he to Mandi abhi bhi khuli he. Hamare yaha to kisaan mandi ke gate ke bahar hi fasal bech dete he.
      😂
      Kyoki gate ke andar mandi tax lagega.

  • @raviprakashmishra8432
    @raviprakashmishra8432 3 роки тому

    Kya ab ye video B J P leader nahi dekhate hain ?

  • @snoopy004002
    @snoopy004002 11 років тому

    LMAO, tell this lady that small business that was promoted in US 2012 is not small business she is thinking off. She gives examples of developed nations where companies like walmart went....she doesn't talk about developing countries like china, where income of people is some what similar to the people in INDIA...her comparison are biased. And India does not a robust supply chain... and really needs one. And what competition does is help consumers...and helps the overall economy.

  • @nanjeshigowda3395
    @nanjeshigowda3395 3 роки тому

    Karnataka MP Veerappa moyli & Kamal nath China model member s
    Use and throw ( AICC in members)
    Getlost saithan sale you assembly,.

    • @jsreeram
      @jsreeram 3 роки тому

      People are telling they did what they opposed even I too am feeling same.

  • @_SangmitraKushwaha_A
    @_SangmitraKushwaha_A 4 роки тому

    aaj yhi baat koi bjp ko bhi samjha do 🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @ravindermehra5985
    @ravindermehra5985 Рік тому

    ❤❤👏👏👏👏✌️✌️

  • @ankitrpm619
    @ankitrpm619 12 років тому +1

    Baith jaiye.....Baith jaiye.....Baith jaiye.....

  • @nanjeshigowda3395
    @nanjeshigowda3395 3 роки тому

    Congress parti 420 members (mp) sit down 2012 assembly , thurdclass beggars fellow you this mentality person you get lost daridra shethan,.

  • @vishalkch52565
    @vishalkch52565 11 років тому

    50-56,its all about America.

  • @nanjeshigowda3395
    @nanjeshigowda3395 3 роки тому

    Fdi 420 party why 2o02 Congress, answer me know what you think you
    Another funny moments AICC in members of parliament Congress,.

  • @MNSNaidu
    @MNSNaidu 11 років тому

    ha.. ha..! So, those 'covering' chains can not be created within India by India!?!. Only Walmart / FDI alone can create those chains and gift it to poor India!?!... Where u ppl learning such a 'rubbish knowledge' ...

  • @gautmimehra
    @gautmimehra 12 років тому

    A TIGHT SLAP FROM HER FDI (Fully Disgusting Investment)..

  • @aniltanejaa9040
    @aniltanejaa9040 3 роки тому

    A

  • @nanjeshigowda3395
    @nanjeshigowda3395 3 роки тому

    Choor sowbees number Congress parti India 420 number in politics AZ index of life getlost saithan sale Congress parti beggars getlost loffur s members all keep salience OK,.

  • @mcmeasylife
    @mcmeasylife 4 роки тому

    Ab kahan gai Desh bhagati

  • @HimanshuSingh-gd2hz
    @HimanshuSingh-gd2hz 4 роки тому

    Aaj ye he kaam BJP khud kr rhi h same on every party and politics

    • @vaibhavmahobiya9129
      @vaibhavmahobiya9129 3 роки тому

      Rajiv dixit ji said that yeah sabhi party ek hi thali ke cahtte batte hai

  • @vinay77ep
    @vinay77ep 12 років тому +1

    1 dislike from sonia hehheh

  • @studiotech95
    @studiotech95 12 років тому

    Jo sunna nahin chate un sansdo ko to utha kar bahar phenk de jana chaiye

  • @PALASHGOYAL1
    @PALASHGOYAL1 12 років тому

    Sushma Swaraj : "hum keh ke lenge .. !!"
    Mannu (Man Mohan) seems to be high on weed n listening to Coldplay :P

  • @rajneeshsaini
    @rajneeshsaini 11 років тому +2

    Sushma is worst BJP leader , speaks in parliament but zero at ground level.

    • @Mohit-ou4yb
      @Mohit-ou4yb 5 років тому +1

      Shut up.........

    • @bishwajitkalita4689
      @bishwajitkalita4689 5 років тому +3

      ground me kom karneke lia. sif road road ghumnese nhi hota... sushmaji kitna kam karsakti he desh k lia. last 5yr me lia dia. She is a Best minister of MoDi government.....

    • @venkatkumar812
      @venkatkumar812 5 років тому +1

      that shows ur ignorance or arrogance!! She is one of the best persons and ministers in BJP

    • @uddeshyavaishya2555
      @uddeshyavaishya2555 5 років тому

      Sharam aana chahiye ye bolte hue

    • @helloamit048
      @helloamit048 5 років тому

      Papu mutra piya hai