Chromatic Lantern gives your lands a new activated ability to tap for any colour. When you activate that ability Hall of Gemstone will replace the effect and you will only produce your chosen colour.
Also the hall doesn't let colourless lands tap for coloured mana. It just replaces the colour of mana produced, if it's not coloured in the first place it's not replaced.
I just wanted to say, I love watching these games. Hella entertaining and also I really think watching these is making me a better player. Not only do you guys give me new ideas for commanders and spells, but seeing the tactics and how much removals / counterspells / protection you run is really the key to getting those combos going. I’m quite a new player but it’s really cool how you can learn so much just by watching other people play - and also the way you play the game. Very friendly and good banter but also spicy and high power. You guys play the game in the right spirit in my opinion. Thanks again!
10:05 I'm not sure if Larry's comment "I'm really excited about my colorless lands producing green" was sarcastic or not, , but it doesn't work that way. Hall of Gemstone says "lands tapped for mana produce mana of the chosen color instead of any other color". However, colorless is not a color, so when producing colorless mana with a land it will still be colorless. That is also mentioned in the Gatherer rulings of the card. EDIT: Probably not sarcastic, because I can see him making that mistake at 23:00 when paying for Aftermath Analyst (costs G after Emerald Medallion's reduction) with Drownyard Temple, which only produces C, not G.
Hall of Gemstone might be the nicest version of blood moon there is. Interestingly I think the Utopia sprawl does actually produce green considering it's a triggered ability of the enchantment that's making the mana, not the land. On the flipside, I'm pretty sure Hall of Gemstone just trumps Chromatic Lantern entirely.
Larry reminds me of the guy that won the lottery while re-creating how he won the lottery 😅 don't judge till you watch it, deadset it has to be Larry 😂
10:02 "I'm really excited about my colorless lands producing green" Not true. Lands that tap for colorless will still produce colorless. It only replaces colored mana with the chosen color. 15:50 "I'll still have to choose a color. My lands will still only ~~ for that color, but then Chromatic's gonna give my lands the ability to now tap for any color" Not true. Your lands have the ability to tap for any color...which is the chosen color instead. I don't think these came up in the game as Lynch was just using black anyway and had 2 mana rocks that could produce other colors if needed, and Larry would be fine using his colorless sources as colorless.
Thanks for the clarity. Magic has so much depth. It's great to learn constantly and it's very humbling. Seeing interactions vary so drastically depending on what cards are played. I'm glad that as you said, I was still only using it for the Black mana, besides the time I used my mana rock for the blue. Larry had plenty of mana in his colors as well. Sorry we mis spoke, but glad again that with the mistaken info we played with in the rules of what Hall does, not ruining the interaction. Larry and his green and I was only using black, the colors we choose. Appreciate learning. Thanks again. We try to get judges on the set to help. It's always better when they are there. And even sometimes things still get missed. It's magic sometimes a lot is going on. We try not to film without one, but if a scheduling conflict occurs with guest, since our show is about playing with friends, the judge is on the phone when needed. We really do want to play the game properly and have a lot of fun doing it. We'll keep working to do better. I promise.
@@IHateYourDeck Don't worry about it. If you've ever had to play against Contamination, you know how that bullshit can go. I was very pleasantly surprised when you got it right with the Utopia Sprawl as that's a triggered mana ability (the source of which is the aura) and only the mana from lands is affected. It allowed the guy (twice) to make plays that other tables might have missed and THAT would affect the outcome. Truly, the important thing is that a mono green deck won.
@@IHateYourDeck Hey, everyone makes mistakes. Don't feel down! The game is complicated. I would've pointed out these interactions myself if nobody had because people use these videos to learn the game. These comments can be very instructive. But even knowing the rules, people make rules mistakes all the time - it's not a big deal. (While we're at it, just so you know for next time you play the deck: you know the creatures Etrata steals are cloaks, right? You don't have to use Etrata's ability to turn them face up: if they're creatures, they can be flipped face up by paying their actual mana cost. You could've flipped that small creature near the end of the game for just a single white mana.)
Not trying to be a hater , I enjoy most of the games that are uploaded here but imo this game was boring and very anti fun with the hall of gemstone. Personally I want to see all the players do their thing as a viewer or in my own personal games. Don't get it twisted interaction , counters , some stax pieces, removal , board wipes is all fine but tweaking everyone's Mana production early on, while totally viable as a way to get ahead just feels obnoxious. It often can just prevent players from playing the game. It for sure pivots the entire hand kept , options available etc and makes for a boring game of sitting and watching the solitaire player more often than not. Great that things could progress in this particular game in some way but still pretty boring and lost interest personally early on. *Rules q.* Hall of Gemstone , it's an old card but I assume it puts the ability on the stack at upkeep , so instant speed in response could remove it utilizing your Mana however it actually is before turned into mono colored mana ? Afterword the active player I believe would still have to play with the limited color restriction for the turn if it's an ability put on to the stack rather than a passive state based action kinda thing. I also understand artifacts get around this card but my opinion as it is remains. Just an opinion as a random viewer. The intention of sharing this opinion is to state I think playing cards like hall of gemstone, at the very least so early into a game just leads to a pretty uninspired boring watch. Ofc view numbers and likes etc. will speak for itself just felt like sharing personal critique.
Hall of Gemstone: At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses a color. Until end of turn, lands tapped for mana produce mana of the chosen color instead of any other color. So Chromatic Lantern does NOT give you access to WUBRG & from Hall's rulings "Any colorless mana that's produced isn't affected." so those utility lands aren't fixed either. So you played that as poorly as you could. Guys no one is rushing you while you produce these episodes, it's not that difficult to go check how your cards work.
Rather disappointed, I must say. Watched to see how Hylda played in action because I just built her, but I saw the only multicolored player get mana-screwed in a whole different way and not cast a single blue spell or Hylda.
so annoyed how "full send" became a thing players say now when opting to draw all the cards and pay all the life off of Black Market Connection and now Sylvan Library apparently 🙄 you're not "sending" anything anywhere so wtf even say that. ugh
"the phrase “full send” means to play 100 percent aggressively and to charge full force toward the enemy players." "Going full send means to take any action without giving much thought to its consequences" So taking all the options in black market and taking all the cards from sylvan makes sense.
Lynch, seeing how often Larry is on the show and how beloved he is, he needs to be a co-host.
I agree
I full support Co-host Murder Mustache.
Best comment of the game "He's feeling murderous. His moustache is twitching."
It's a pretty good one.
Twas a good one
"im the only one stuck in jail, i thought i was the police"
Such a commander mood. Underrated quote
Two episodes in a row with the magic moustache? We are truly blessed 🙏
We are living in the age of Aquarius for sure.
Larry and Mono-Green. My two favourite things.
Chromatic Lantern gives your lands a new activated ability to tap for any colour. When you activate that ability Hall of Gemstone will replace the effect and you will only produce your chosen colour.
Also the hall doesn't let colourless lands tap for coloured mana. It just replaces the colour of mana produced, if it's not coloured in the first place it's not replaced.
I just wanted to say, I love watching these games. Hella entertaining and also I really think watching these is making me a better player. Not only do you guys give me new ideas for commanders and spells, but seeing the tactics and how much removals / counterspells / protection you run is really the key to getting those combos going.
I’m quite a new player but it’s really cool how you can learn so much just by watching other people play - and also the way you play the game. Very friendly and good banter but also spicy and high power. You guys play the game in the right spirit in my opinion.
Thanks again!
I dont know why, but if i see kevin, i have to think off Mclovin.😅
when i see kevin, i need to think of that guy who farts and says im a race car.
pretty cool they got mclovin for this episode
Underrated comment 😂
Chromatic lanter doesnt work against Hall of Gemstone. Lands still produce only chosen mana.
That's why Shane said "it's like a Black rainbow"
Leisure suit Larry is back! Hope he never leaves the show and stays as co-host
Kevin wearing the Kublai Khan shirt. Sick asf
Scary Larry!
Kevin with the Kublai Khan t shirt is dope what a cool dude
Monkey see monkey do....
Just started the episode but LFG Kevin in the Kublai Khan shirt!
Larry with the landfall finisher but awesomeness happened here 👍👍
very sad the Hylda deck didnt got much play
Liked and subscribed as soon as i saw that Kublai Khan t-shirt
IDK what it is about Kevin, but I really like the cut of his jib.
Need an archenemy game with Larry as the Archenemy
Soon as i saw thrun that would have been my target in the game let alone hall of gemstone
10:05 I'm not sure if Larry's comment "I'm really excited about my colorless lands producing green" was sarcastic or not, , but it doesn't work that way.
Hall of Gemstone says "lands tapped for mana produce mana of the chosen color instead of any other color". However, colorless is not a color, so when producing colorless mana with a land it will still be colorless.
That is also mentioned in the Gatherer rulings of the card.
EDIT: Probably not sarcastic, because I can see him making that mistake at 23:00 when paying for Aftermath Analyst (costs G after Emerald Medallion's reduction) with Drownyard Temple, which only produces C, not G.
Nice to catch y’all live !!
Here for the Tool shirt
44:00 video... this is going to be goooooood
Hall of Gemstone might be the nicest version of blood moon there is. Interestingly I think the Utopia sprawl does actually produce green considering it's a triggered ability of the enchantment that's making the mana, not the land. On the flipside, I'm pretty sure Hall of Gemstone just trumps Chromatic Lantern entirely.
how did Larry sacrifice the 2 lands when hall of gemstones is in play? 12:20
Larry reminds me of the guy that won the lottery while re-creating how he won the lottery 😅 don't judge till you watch it, deadset it has to be Larry 😂
Love seeing Hylda! Favorite card in mine has to be Public Enemy
Hey Great video, but where are the zombies from field of the dead 22:43 ?
cool commanders all around
love seeing larry
Larry for co-host! 👍
Great episode
KILL LARRY WORLD PEACE
Wonderful Game. I have a secret Titania deck within Omnath Locus of the Roil! Titania is MEAANNN
larry on titania?! hell yeah my favorite guest on my favorite commander
Im a simple man i see scary Larry and i klik
I see Titania, I click! Most fun deck I built in a while
A Zur, eternal schemer deck would be awesome to see! Cool angle and not a super common archetype, and absolutely zero attachment to the commander 😅😬
I love my Zur deck
Babe wake up, Larry is back on IHYD
Anyone know which game tracker Lynch uses on his phone?
Mono green doing mono green things makes my heart happy
Lynch dipped in to the gummies 😆
Thrun, my beloved mean green machine.
Would love to see Larry's deck list!
“One of us!” 😂😂😂😂
Here for the stan bush reference
Shane got done dirty
rule nº 1 on IHYD, KILL LARRY FIRST.
10:02 "I'm really excited about my colorless lands producing green"
Not true. Lands that tap for colorless will still produce colorless. It only replaces colored mana with the chosen color.
15:50 "I'll still have to choose a color. My lands will still only ~~ for that color, but then Chromatic's gonna give my lands the ability to now tap for any color"
Not true. Your lands have the ability to tap for any color...which is the chosen color instead.
I don't think these came up in the game as Lynch was just using black anyway and had 2 mana rocks that could produce other colors if needed, and Larry would be fine using his colorless sources as colorless.
Thanks for the clarity. Magic has so much depth. It's great to learn constantly and it's very humbling. Seeing interactions vary so drastically depending on what cards are played. I'm glad that as you said, I was still only using it for the Black mana, besides the time I used my mana rock for the blue. Larry had plenty of mana in his colors as well. Sorry we mis spoke, but glad again that with the mistaken info we played with in the rules of what Hall does, not ruining the interaction. Larry and his green and I was only using black, the colors we choose. Appreciate learning. Thanks again. We try to get judges on the set to help. It's always better when they are there. And even sometimes things still get missed. It's magic sometimes a lot is going on. We try not to film without one, but if a scheduling conflict occurs with guest, since our show is about playing with friends, the judge is on the phone when needed. We really do want to play the game properly and have a lot of fun doing it. We'll keep working to do better. I promise.
@@IHateYourDeck Don't worry about it. If you've ever had to play against Contamination, you know how that bullshit can go.
I was very pleasantly surprised when you got it right with the Utopia Sprawl as that's a triggered mana ability (the source of which is the aura) and only the mana from lands is affected. It allowed the guy (twice) to make plays that other tables might have missed and THAT would affect the outcome.
Truly, the important thing is that a mono green deck won.
@@IHateYourDeck Hey, everyone makes mistakes. Don't feel down! The game is complicated.
I would've pointed out these interactions myself if nobody had because people use these videos to learn the game. These comments can be very instructive. But even knowing the rules, people make rules mistakes all the time - it's not a big deal.
(While we're at it, just so you know for next time you play the deck: you know the creatures Etrata steals are cloaks, right? You don't have to use Etrata's ability to turn them face up: if they're creatures, they can be flipped face up by paying their actual mana cost. You could've flipped that small creature near the end of the game for just a single white mana.)
@IHateYourDeck i would love to see larry rock General Ferrous Rokiric
Bro showed up to play stax just to learn what true stax is
Wait you all do this live
22:18 cut me more than it should 😢
Deflecting swat uses one red mana, Lynch chose black, how did he cast it?
Because I had my commander out I could cast it forever free. Normally it’s 3 mana total one of that being red.
17:35 Did you really make a reference to Metallica's One intro?
Thats a cool titania
Trap Runner is a card I've never seen anyone but me play. Wassup with that!?
SCARY LARRY BABY
Kevin looks like mclovin
you should give life tap ago
Hylda! Yes!!!
6:47
Shane lfg my boy!!!
seems like mono green lands deck is good, who would have thought. I hate playing against lands goodstuff, its like cheating
Poor Shane
Shutting off mana aint it. Don't play trash like Hall of Gemstone
Came here to see Hylda gameplay... there was no Hylda gameplay....
Not trying to be a hater , I enjoy most of the games that are uploaded here but imo this game was boring and very anti fun with the hall of gemstone.
Personally I want to see all the players do their thing as a viewer or in my own personal games. Don't get it twisted interaction , counters , some stax pieces, removal , board wipes is all fine but tweaking everyone's Mana production early on, while totally viable as a way to get ahead just feels obnoxious. It often can just prevent players from playing the game. It for sure pivots the entire hand kept , options available etc and makes for a boring game of sitting and watching the solitaire player more often than not. Great that things could progress in this particular game in some way but still pretty boring and lost interest personally early on.
*Rules q.* Hall of Gemstone , it's an old card but I assume it puts the ability on the stack at upkeep , so instant speed in response could remove it utilizing your Mana however it actually is before turned into mono colored mana ? Afterword the active player I believe would still have to play with the limited color restriction for the turn if it's an ability put on to the stack rather than a passive state based action kinda thing.
I also understand artifacts get around this card but my opinion as it is remains.
Just an opinion as a random viewer. The intention of sharing this opinion is to state I think playing cards like hall of gemstone, at the very least so early into a game just leads to a pretty uninspired boring watch. Ofc view numbers and likes etc. will speak for itself just felt like sharing personal critique.
I wanted to see a hylda deck and this was just a "old cards are busted" game. Lame
Hall of Gemstone:
At the beginning of each player's upkeep, that player chooses a color. Until end of turn, lands tapped for mana produce mana of the chosen color instead of any other color.
So Chromatic Lantern does NOT give you access to WUBRG & from Hall's rulings "Any colorless mana that's produced isn't affected." so those utility lands aren't fixed either.
So you played that as poorly as you could. Guys no one is rushing you while you produce these episodes, it's not that difficult to go check how your cards work.
I know Lynch is trying to branch out and be a UA-camr more, but he needs to dial it back, just be his natural self.
Oh it’s edited
1st comment again!!! Let's go
Rather disappointed, I must say. Watched to see how Hylda played in action because I just built her, but I saw the only multicolored player get mana-screwed in a whole different way and not cast a single blue spell or Hylda.
Looks like we won't see Kevin anytime soon.
He’ll be back!
bring back kevin
so annoyed how "full send" became a thing players say now when opting to draw all the cards and pay all the life off of Black Market Connection and now Sylvan Library apparently 🙄 you're not "sending" anything anywhere so wtf even say that. ugh
"the phrase “full send” means to play 100 percent aggressively and to charge full force toward the enemy players."
"Going full send means to take any action without giving much thought to its consequences"
So taking all the options in black market and taking all the cards from sylvan makes sense.
ikr memes aren't for having fun they're for
Loving this episode, attempting to go weekly?? I can support that 🫡 hope you get the chance to make it happen
Hoping so, if we get enough support to make it happen. But it's a dream right?
Let's make it happen!