MY THOUGHTS ON WHY DR.UMAR LEFT ISLAM.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 41

  • @masjidtafsirkathir6094
    @masjidtafsirkathir6094 Місяць тому +1

    I’ve Been Muslim For 10 Years Going On 11 Years Come Spring

  • @lemonadelemon1960
    @lemonadelemon1960 Місяць тому +4

    Umar had a really good point. Islam is an Arab centered faith. The Arabs have an air of superiority to them when it comes to the faith, and not only is the language everyone has to learn Arabic, the prophet and the place Islam was founded is Arabia. It tells you the only culture that is valid is that of Arabians had in the 7th century. In the Hadiths, black people are used as a bad omens or slaves. And the hair rules seem to be geared toward making sure no black culture creeps it’s way in. For example, braids are seen as “unpermissible” or “wild” but when the prophet did it it’s “permissible” but only the same way he wore his. So if Mohamed was wearing dreadlocks in 7th century, dreads wouldn’t be seen as “Rasta” or “like the Jamaicans” what’s wrong with being Jamaican? If Mohamed was black instead of a white man, the “haram” list would not consist of things that have to do with black culture.

    • @thelordofnuggets629
      @thelordofnuggets629 Місяць тому +3

      Please send the hadith in which black people are bad omens or slaves, because this is blatantly untrue along with what else you said.

    • @lemonadelemon1960
      @lemonadelemon1960 Місяць тому

      @@thelordofnuggets629 concerning the dream of the Prophet (ﷺ) in Medina: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "I saw (in a dream) a black woman with unkempt hair going out of Medina and settling at Mahai'a. I interpreted that as (a symbol of) the epidemic of Medina being transferred to Mahai'a, namely, Al-Juhfa."Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 7039
      In-book reference : Book 91, Hadith 53
      USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 9, Book 87, Hadith 162. Why is he seeing a black person as a bad omen? As for the slaves: There came a slave and pledg- ed allegiance to Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) on migration; he (the Holy Prophet) did not know that he was a slave. Then there came his master and demanded him back, whereupon Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) said: Sell him to me. And he bought him for two black slaves, and he did not afterwards take allegiance from anyone until he had asked him whether he was a slave (or a free man)Reference : Sahih Muslim 1602
      In-book reference : Book 22, Hadith 152 reference: Book 10, Hadith 3901

    • @lemonadelemon1960
      @lemonadelemon1960 Місяць тому

      @@thelordofnuggets629 and then we have the black again being a bad omen, this time it’s the black dogThe prayer is severed by a woman, a donkey, and a black dog, if there is not something like the handle of a saddle in front of a man.” I (‘Abdullah) said: “What is wrong with a black dog and not a red one?” He (Abu Dharr) said: ‘I asked the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) the same question, and he said: “The black dog is a Shaitan (satan).”Grade: Sahih
      Reference : Sunan Ibn Majah 952
      In-book reference : Book 5, Hadith 150
      English translation : Vol. 1, Book 5, Hadith 952

    • @Solopernuer1
      @Solopernuer1 Місяць тому +1

      false , indoniesa is the largest muslim country , islam is for anybody .

  • @minnieloca5951
    @minnieloca5951 Місяць тому +2

    Very well said. Alhumdulillah,, Islam came to relinquish any racism or prejudices on any people especially the woman and the oppressed,, such as the darker skinned people who were always treated unfairly within society. Prophet sws gave a message from The Source that told the people to behave in kindness to all so yess slavery was of different levels and not such as the brutal cattle slavery of the Americans. Slavery is even a word that means something harsh in English whereas the same negativity doesn’t apply in the language of Arabic and other languages. Arabic is a very specific and definitive language with no room for misinterpretation or distortion. On top of house maids and mates being a normal part of society to pay off debts and other reasons,, Islam had strict rules for treating right hand possessions with fairness with even reasonable ability to become free of their owner. Some would want to stay because the relationship was very well,, such as with the Zubair. He was the slave of the prophet gifted to him after Zubair was stolen from his parents. When the parents finally found him,, Zubair wanted to stay with Nabi sws and not return home. I think Alaiyhi Salaam sought permission to adopt him and Zubair stayed as his son. That goes to show an aspect of what slavery was “back in the day”. There were different acceptable cultural practices all over the world that would change and develop,, then and now. Islam is definitely not about Arab culture,, racism,, or even slavery in the western viewpoint at all. In Quran Allah has allowed Alaiyhi Salaam to dictate to us that the language of Arabic is the language of the heavens and that we will all be speaking Arabic in the heavens. For whatever reason Allah has chose Arabic as the language for reaons that the Muslims don’t know. But studying language and etymology I can surely gain an understanding of why it was chosen in comparison to other languages. Arabic is by far the most accurate and definitive language there is being able to accurately describe something without misinterpretation. Also learning Arabic and the use of the body to perform the sounds of the language are some what of a workout,, especially when you’re new to it - making yu aware of your better and fuller potentials of speech and communication. Quran Arabic is an even higher form of Arabic so that when it’s recited it’s soothing to the heart no matter the language of the listener,, unless the listener is not a listener fr and yu playing that baqaqrah ! 🤭 But otherwise the the way Allah be freakin the Arabic verses of Quran is beautifully deep intricately and amazingly calmly intriguing. Islam would only organize Dr Umars theories and further his platforms. He’s truly missing out on so much by denouncing the bodies natural and pure re alignment (religion) lifestyle of Islam. He should kno the verses that say Whomever Allah guides no one can lead astray,, and whom Allah leads astray no one can guide. That verse is mad dope in that the way Allah even made our bodies is that the last thing to fully develops is the first thing to start to deteriorate in our bodies. When we lay down (especially for the final time) our bodies literally spell out Muhammad in Arabic. Noting the deepness of Allahs perfection. Prophet Muhammad sws is the epitome of mankind,, so the only way to enter them pearly gates of Jannah til Firdous,, we have to please Allah and do what the Tribal African/Desert Arab fair skinned long haired (sometimes braided sometime loc’d) Prophet of Allah did and speak how he spoke ! Some forms of question isn’t inquiry but persistent challenge. Allah knows us well even closer than our jugular vein. So we need not to fret ourselves over those who choose not to accept understanding,, especially when they claim to seek understanding. Our only duty is to give the message,, the rest is the task of Allah swt ! 🤌🏽✊🏾🤲🏽🫶🏽✨

    • @jaiafrica6112
      @jaiafrica6112 Місяць тому

      Not like the brutal american slavery? are we talking about the same ppl that castrated their male slaves in large numbers, many of whom died painfully and kept black women as sex slaves lmaooooooo. Be for real. Slavery was just outlawed within the last century in saudi arabia and many arab countries still treat their non arab workers like slaves today. Arabs and whites both oppressed the black race.

    • @salj.5459
      @salj.5459 25 днів тому

      Al-Jahiz, a well respected Muslim scholar living in Arabia in the 8th century, showed that Arab racism became worse after the advent of Islam. In his response to anti-Black racism from Arabs, "The Glory of the Blacks over the Whites"

  • @MrSalaam100
    @MrSalaam100 Місяць тому +1

    As Salaam Alaakum. Modern day table manners, came from Islamic educates. The affects that Islam had on the world, is countless. You can start with the Mathematic .

  • @sheriffimraan6284
    @sheriffimraan6284 Місяць тому

    Well said bro. Jazzaaka LLAAHU Khayran and wish our beloved brother gets cured from the current spiritual constipation his currently suffering from.

  • @kassimabdilatif1802
    @kassimabdilatif1802 Місяць тому +2

    Bro tel Dr Umar that the the African Muslims for example the West African Muslims like the Fulani , Hausa and others had their own culture and way of dressing even though they practiced Islam. For example the thobes or robes they wear is distinct from those of the middle East and North African Arabs so what is Dr Umar talking about. Also eating with your right hand is not an Arab culture. In Islam you can eat with a spoon or folk or chopsticks whatever as long as it is your right hand as the prophet instructed. This was not an Arab thing as the prophet forbade a fellow Arab from eating with his left hand as we saw in the hadith.
    Clearly Dr Omar is ignorant and is speaking without knowledge. Lastly there is no such thing as black culture or white culture or Arab culture. Communities have their own individual cultures and traditions whether Africans, Arabs , whit or Asians. For example not all black people keep dreadlocks so how can you say it's a black culture.

  • @surendirenparthasarathy9087
    @surendirenparthasarathy9087 Місяць тому +1

    Islam is against ancestors veneration and worship. Why would a pan africanist adopt a worldview which is against his culture. Why are people making so much fuss when there is no compulsion in religion.

  • @utmost6722
    @utmost6722 Місяць тому +2

    One thing I agreed with El hajj El Malik shabazz said keep your religion at home. The Arabic language is not the original language it's like 5th in place Aramaic is older than arabic, syriac language is older, phonecian, medu neter etc. But arabic is related to the original languages. Umar Johnson right now is a bunch of talk. He has been collecting money from the people using the idea of a school to get money, umar has been duking the people for 15 years, that's wrong!

    • @salj.5459
      @salj.5459 25 днів тому +1

      He already bought the school buildings and shows videos on him walking inside of them all the time. If he was scamming, why would he have bothered buying the schools and painting them?

    • @utmost6722
      @utmost6722 25 днів тому +1

      @@salj.5459 check out the information it's been over 15 years and his hasn't enrolled not one child it's a scam. What's the use of having a building for 15 years a theres no teachers no students. And on top of that 7 times out of 15 years he lies and says the school will be opened and it hasn't opened yet, he lies about the school opening every year for at least 7 years. It's a scam bruh.
      Hey 15 years ago umar was on top of it he's a good public speaker bur that's all he is a good talker. CHECK THE RECORD

  • @victorylapp
    @victorylapp Місяць тому

    Islam is Arabism .

  • @Solopernuer1
    @Solopernuer1 Місяць тому +2

    he was tested by Allah and failed the test . may Allah guide him back to truth . sometimes educated people are to smart fie thier own good nobody knows better than Allah almighty

  • @KHiy-sj2ko
    @KHiy-sj2ko Місяць тому +2

    Without lies, Islam dies

  • @targetedindividualR1B
    @targetedindividualR1B Місяць тому

    Over 60% of all English words have Greek or Latin roots.The Semitic languages are a branch of the Afroasiatic language family. They include Arabic, Amharic, Tigrinya, Aramaic, Hebrew, Maltese and numerous other ancient and modern languages. And, Arabic is closely to Aramaic, considering prophets and disciples spoke either one.

  • @A7la1Kandri
    @A7la1Kandri 22 дні тому

    Did he know that most Muslims nonaran than Muslims Arab 😂😂😂

  • @targetedindividualR1B
    @targetedindividualR1B Місяць тому

    Bilal was half African, first person to call for prayers, before the disciples fled to Aksum in East Africa. I don't get Dr Umar's point.

    • @robertyoungblood3740
      @robertyoungblood3740 Місяць тому

      No bilal was African from Ethiopia . A black man and don't forget it.

    • @salj.5459
      @salj.5459 25 днів тому

      You people always bring up Bilal as your token Black person.

  • @deeqahmed2291
    @deeqahmed2291 Місяць тому

    The truth already came out. He was never Muslim. He changed his name to sound more black.

    • @salj.5459
      @salj.5459 25 днів тому

      What lies are you spreading? He was born Jermaine Shoemake, but his Muslim father changed his name to Umar Johnson. The only name change Umar made was from Umar Johnson to Umar Ifatunde Oguntade

  • @farahabdirahman1778
    @farahabdirahman1778 Місяць тому +2

    Brorher he is not intelligent at all. Be aware of who you take information from and dont make your skin/identity into a religion

    • @timojazz6829
      @timojazz6829 Місяць тому

      He's intelligent and articulate and 100% correct in his analysis of the relationship of Islam to the black man's struggle. Spirituality is not found in any book.

  • @deeqahmed2291
    @deeqahmed2291 25 днів тому

    You’d be hard pressed to find anyone that takes what Umar Charlatan Johnson says more seriously than Malcom X’s experience within Islam. Just compare the 2 and you’ll have your answer clearly

  • @elaineleslie3006
    @elaineleslie3006 Місяць тому

    Youre talking alot but not addressing Dr Umars comments.
    In the uk the black African muslims worth seperste from the Indian muslims..There is segregation within

  • @Solopernuer1
    @Solopernuer1 Місяць тому +2

    nobody with real knowledge leaves islam . its those with wrong undetstanding . no way you leave the haqq

  • @ajibadesheriff7133
    @ajibadesheriff7133 Місяць тому +1

    I am born Muslim. Alhamdulillah for the kind of parents i have. Thanks to them I read the translated Quran and Bible and learned to read about anything of interest. Arabs are probably the most racist race on earth. But our most beloved prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him was never racist. Through the teachings of Islam is where i learned Moses and Jesus are blacks. Hajara was black and Lukman was black as well.

  • @TheQuranExplainsItself
    @TheQuranExplainsItself Місяць тому +1

    Dr Umar is right sunnism is Arabism. People confuse the Quranic Islam which is universal with sunnism which is absolutely Arabism.