Why We Believe in Gods - Andy Thomson - American Atheists 09
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 кві 2009
- Andy Thomson gives his talk titled 'Why We Believe in Gods' at the go in Atlanta, Georgia.
See more at RichardDawkins.net
Also see Richard Dawkins talk from this convention:
• American Atheists 09 -...
Produced by The Richard Dawkins Foundation and R. Elisabeth Cornwell - Наука та технологія
Holy cow this video is 14 years old. The truth never goes out of style. I am so happy I found it. It holds up even today.
we believe in Gods because of Ego, we need the feeling that we are special. we fear not being special.
Yes. That’s because we are very significant and we are smart enough to feel our great loss, however it occurred.
@JohnCahillChapel we are not significant
@@yaboicaden200we are significant enough to be the only species in Known existence with the technological capability we have. We have yet to find anything that can. Rival humanity. Are we the only species to use technology. Of course not. But we have yet to prove it.
@@Re3VxRNxCLAN get with the program
We are special u idiot
I was thirteen years old, crying in my room praying for my late grandfathers wisdom. Then I started to think about what I had been told, how he was always watching, and that made me feel very uncomfortable, the thought that my grandfather was watching my every action and judging me made me feel more shame than comfort. I also knew that a lot of my actions that I was ashamed of were natural. That's when I realized that the whole religion thing must be absolute bogus, I had no reason to feel ashamed and no one was judging me. I've always questioned all forms of authority so there wasn't a big gap between my parents and god. I realized that my perception of a god was the culmination of all the emotions I felt for my parents at a very young age, the reverence, the fear, the anxiety and the anger all stemmed from me building the mental image of a god based on what I was taught. It was a long night and I felt like I had grown a lot but I still find myself falling for the same sense of structure in times of high levels of self doubt. I really wish we could get rid of standard religions, I feel like if we did then it would be so much easier to teach these things, but with the current level of taboo around the subject it feels like we won't be able break past the veil and get to the actual dilemmas. The thought of a god might be comforting, but I feel as if it acts as a distraction from actual problems, which means people keep suffering but in silence rather than with support.
Atheïsm is just a effect of the fall of man.
Jesus = God in fysical form. He was before time was.
Interesting to read what God came to do on this earth....
Healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, hanging on a cross to pay the debtbof our fall, pouring out His Spirit so we can become what we were created to be... walking in the same unselfish love and power He did. Because He is so passionate of what He created you to be.
His Spirit brings forth after His kind.
Born-again. Yay!
www.anewcreationinchrist.nl/english
Pinker wrote a book titled, "The Blank Slate."
Dude your grandmother sees you spank it. She shakes her head in disapproval every time. She and Ghandi and Abraham Lincoln. All discussing what a dirty little boy you are
Religion doesn't mean judgement and shame. Nor does God. The way some people practice it does involve that though. Its pretty broad.
@Mad_S *I know what you were embarrassed about at 13, and I needn't spell it out.* *Your grandfather would have understood dude. He whacked it when he was 13.*
*That is a dumb reason to give up belief in the divine.*
“The argument goes something like this: "I refuse to prove that I exist," says God, "for proof denies faith, and without faith I am nothing” ~ Douglas Adams
Yes, meaning that god only exists in the minds of those who have faith in him.
Translation: "I exist only in your imagination, and without your imagination I would be nothing."
"If God knows what I am thinking why do I have to pray."
Very good question!!!!
Because when u pray you get hope and you're believe in god will increase u need to pray cuz u dont got nothing u and i are completely nothing god give u everything and when you pray u will always remember that there is a god id god will do all things in secret without u talking to him u will not believe that he exists.
Sorry for my bad english
@@znrv3345 I am curious about the mechanism here. Isn't God all powerful? Why would prayer increase belief or knowledge? Why couldn't God reveal himself without prayer?
Yeah right your on the money rajano gray you would be wasting your time
To rephrase the question: Why does God respond differently to words I communicate to him, in a sense that he doesn’t respond to words that just pass through my head?
God knows and you can pray to know
I chose not to be a martyr for my faith; after beating myself up in the second grade because I could not honestly avow to die for my faith, I raised my own daughter without religion and she is one of the most intelligent, kindest, most charitable and empathetic persons I know.
A proud bloody atheist from India...
Well done, Mr. Cho.
Buddhism is atheistic
@@larryparis925Could you help me understand what's REALLY going on with the hundreds of thousands of people claiming to have seen 😈 demons?
I believed in god at about the age of 5, but once I was able to actually differentiate fact from fiction and could start asking questions I became a hard atheist. With a belief that everything could be explained by science given enough time.
Jonathan
I grew up in the midst of the Great Depression.
At 5 heard preachers and said "What the hell is wrong with these people?"
At 85 was saying "What in hell is wrong with these people?"
Jonathan Mcmullen, so science is your religion.
@@TheMrsmiley1980
Science is a tool, fool.
NOT a religion.
@@TheMrsmiley1980 science is not a religion. Religion bases claims off belief not demonstrations. Science demonstrates their claims and changes their claim based on evidence. Dont try to play the word game guy. I will win it
Atheïsm is just a effect of the fall of man.
Jesus = God in fysical form. He was before time was.
Interesting to read what God came to do on this earth....
Healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, hanging on a cross to pay the debtbof our fall, pouring out His Spirit so we can become what we were created to be... walking in the same unselfish love and power He did. Because He is so passionate of what he created you to be.
His Spirit brings forth after His kind.
Born-again. Yay!
www.anewcreationinchrist.nl/english
What was it Mark Twain said? Religion happened when the first con man met the first fool.
you should shame yourself
@@giovannimannelli2158 Myself or Mark Twain? Why so easily hurt?
@@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon Basically..because I'm stuck in the house because of coronavirus.
@@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon May God helps me! :)
@@giovannimannelli2158 I hope that not going close to people and washing your hands often will keep you safe. God didn't do a particularly good job with all those who died, did he? And why would an almighty god see to that a virus like this harms people? Stop thinking like a child.
‘Life is a solution to the problem of death’. Pure genius.
How is it a solution when all life ends with death?
David St. Dennis the whole idea of an afterlife is that it’s a continuation of your consciousness. So to resolve the ceasing of life (death) you suppose an extension of it forever.
A very ignorant remark.
Atheïsm is just a effect of the fall of man.
Jesus = God in fysical form. He was before time was.
Interesting to read what God came to do on this earth....
Healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, hanging on a cross to pay the debtbof our fall, pouring out His Spirit so we can become what we were created to be... walking in the same unselfish love and power He did.
His Spirit brings forth after His kind.
Born-again. Yay!
www.anewcreationinchrist.nl/english
For me death is a solution to the problem of life.
@@ToninoterRessort you post this same shit on every comment.
I rely on myself to overcome any problems and I do ok. 59 now and never been in debt.
That makes two of us, so far, I'm 72 and healthy, trusting in that "invisible Being", is sure to guide one in the right direction. Hooray!!! to your smarts.
I'm 23 and I was just wondering if you believe in any form of a God at any point? And if not what was it like being an atheist in your younger years? Have you noticed a social shift towards or away from religious belief?
@@jaebird3077 I was brought up going to church and at the tender age of around 7 I started to question the validity of what I was being told, I never said anything to anyone it just didn't seem to fit reality
@@garyskinner2422 I stopped believing the bible when I reached sexual maturity. I started being agnostic not long after. Now I do not believe in any god at all. I was more curious about what never believing in a god was like. How it might have changed his life especially 50 years ago
@@jaebird3077 gotcha yea I basically haven't believed in god before 7 I just went to church, Sunday school etc but never believed in it so to speak I was too young at 7 I really started to think what are they saying lol
Am I weird? I was raised in a church going family yet I never remember any time I believed in God. I would listen to them (parents, church people, minister) talk about God and pretend I believed because I didn't want to hurt their feelings by implying I thought they were stupid. This was my earliest memory on the topic, I was 6 or 7.
I was the same way.
Some people catch on very early like that. I didn't, one brother did and another brother thinks he is now called as one of God's most chosen prophets (scizoaffective disorder with OCD). Yes, he ended up hospitalized over it, danger to others, but, I think that was the final straw that finished shaking me awake to the fact that all prophets are a little or a lot off just like him, while some can be simply scam artists, narcissists, psychopaths...
I'm sure glad "god" is no longer keeping tabs on my every move and thought, like a pervert and stalker, gaslighting narcissistic psychopath who demands you obey his moving-target, holy shit-test whims and to be worshiped for it... Worse than marrying a narcissist and staying. What in the hell kind of god is that? Bully, abuser, liar... That IS the hell (complete with Saint'n) they created to go with the god they create in their very own nasty image.
But, cults like that go far beyond religion. They don't needs gods, just narccits, psychopaths hell bent on deceiving and entrapping ewe. Why the free passes? We want or demand saviors to save us from this, that and the other, and they show up to deliver and create as many bogey men as we want, to $ave us from. They threaten and promise just like prophets/profits... Hucksters gonna huck, religious, political, "science," whatever. They get into and take over whatever they can infiltrate, or they create it in the first place to fill the demand from... the sheeple.
The top 5%of the population has that no-conscience segment of human nature, with the top 1% really bad and struggling and punching toward the top to take over, to own and fleece all ewe sheeple. The other 95% are mostly "We the Sheeple" who can't even conceive of such an eternal huckster mindset of their Masters/$aviors who will "$ave them from behind."
If you don't like religion, don't worry, they have cult options to please all who want/demand to be Saved. Perhaps you've tried their Hole-y Churches of Scienceology, Climateology, Vaccineology, Political-Scienceology... just for starters? "Obey Us! Don't Question Us! Don't be a dirty Denier!..."
Sounds just too familiar. No Free Passes to any Authority or Credentials is the type of critical thinking we really need, instead of the current "critical thinking" they have given us. Authority and Credentials using FEAR and wild promises = Hucksters. "you're gonna burn if you question Us or disobey Our Credentials and Authority!" What a rip off on religion, which they love to scare kids with in "schools."
Sadly your six year old selves had far better critical thinking skills than taught in schools today or on the internet "critical thinking" huckster-owned sites which are atrocious, teaching to "question everything," except what they tell you to believe and not believe and what to Not question and to obey and how to regurgitate it and use the word "heretic," er, "Denier!" Do you do that well, or just the religion detection? How do they pull it off so smoothly ("These are not the droids you are searching for."). Most High and Hole-y Prophets? Profits?
The truth is that nobody actually believes in religious text. They simply feel an incredible pressure, both from social and existential places, to blindly accept as much.
Some of us simply cannot discount the fact that reality contradicts our preconceived notions.
@David Anewman Hitler was a Roman Catholic...
@David Anewman annnnd maybe ewe are related to Hitler and just do Not-See?
I love smart rational thinking humans
oh hello, I may not be smart but i think i might be rational?
Alyssa Appleheart really?
Even as a child I was scolded for thinking differently than the rest of THE HERD so to speak, and was warned of the grave dangers of free thinking.I still am troubled by thinking for myself when it comes to religion.I only seek the truth.
@Renee Tate 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Me too .. I wish I was bright enough to do it ....
“Men will never be free until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest." -Diderot
Then Violence rules? Just follow that thought along for a moment,,,
6
@Steve Well said my little Viking! It makes me want to "Shout" that I'm "Head Over Heels" in this "Mad World"
Do you mean people like Fidel Castro, Stalin, Mao , Hitler who were more powerful than any kings of old, but also believed themselves to be not mere priests but gods on Earth?..There is where the path of godless humanism / scientism without the loving guidance of the One and Only God takes "the fool who says in his HEART that there is no God".
And why does it start in the heart , like The Bible says though? People like Dawkins, Krauss, and the so called "New Atheists" bunch are smart enough to realize they are BSing the clueless with itchy ears big time. They realize how little they know about everything; So at best all they believe is pretty much the result of their coonfirmation bias.,if they got caught on their own delusion.. But most of these famous pfofessional atheistic scientists ( like Bernie Sanders does in the field of politics by the way)know they are bloviating their way into lucrative books, paid worldwide conference and tv apoearences, tenure , funding, video sales and if they get lucky a hubristic titled movie like "The theory of Everything" is made about them...Most of them know they are pretty much BSing but still within their hearts they fight the God twho opposes sexual perversion, abortion, escapism into drugs, and their out of touch with reality justification for communism. IT ALL COMES DOWN TO THEIR WANTING TO BE gODS THEMSELVES BUT WITHOUT LEARNIG HOW TO FROM THE ONLY GOD THERE IS . JESUS "THE LOGOS" IN WHOM ALL THINGS WERE MADE. THE ALPHA AND THE OMEGA. THE BEGINNING AND THE END..THE TRUTH, THE WAY AND THE LIFE.
@@alexstewart8097 ALLAH IS THE ONE TRUE GOD AND YOU WILL BURN IN THE PIT FOREVER BECAUSE OF YOUR DENIAL OF THIS ABSOLUTE TRUTH.
"Awareness is known by awareness alone," is the sole irreducible axiom of reality. To put forth a syllable to refute it is to concede.
"If you understand the psychology of the Big Mac meal you understand the psychology of religion" Lol
Never expected to hear those two subjects in the same sentence, but I 'm glad someone made the connection.
You guys actually buy this nuts gibberish you all deserve to buy the part of the Eiffel Tower that I'm selling
A Big Mac Meal is junk food.
Religion is junk philosophy.
@@christophercooper6731 Yep you believe in the Big Bang mythology alright and the evolution delusion. It’s called natural selection nothing gets better over time never been observed or repeated. Same for the Big Bang, you throw out the scientific method for you mythology faith. Just like the Egyptians did with their myths which people believed as real 😂
The bible warns you people not to be fooled: Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, after the rudiments of the world, and not after Christ.
Written 2000 years ago, wow these cave dwellers were so not intelligent like you are 😂
Better Big mac than nothing.
Better a super natural God than nothingness and meaningless.
Better good healty food and better a rational religion than the super natural.
Nothing out of nothingness, this is where the smart academicus whants us to believe this is super super natural. LOL
Because there is a lot of time and space (where that came from?) so it is likely that humans develop from there. That is super natural believe man cant you see that?
Dont go where was God created etc... thats another discussion, and it doenst matter but God if he is good or evil is a fact, or you whant to believe in the supernatural
Plenty of theists with schizoid type personality disorder commenting within these threads, as was to be expected.
Once your parents insert the religious head worms into your ear canal as a child your cognitive bias grows. Your only hope is to read broadly and learn about logic and reason
So do you believe you have free will or you are just a product of your environment? Because if it's the latter as your comment suggests, then nobody should be morally held accountable for their actions.
Also, if you think that majority of current and past humanity are just idiots who don't know better than.you, what does that say about your view of humanity, or.better yet, your arrogance to hold such a belief? You may want to dig deeper into what this God stuff is about when the odds are against you.
Stephen Anthony you are a delusional fool who can’t critically think for yourself.
Uneducated twat living by the law of a comic book written centuries ago, you will never succeed in life apart from being a brain dead sheep. Wake up god is the biggest scam to mankind it’s the richest most successful business on the planet 😂😂😂 but good news is faith is dying. Christianity especially, another 100-200 years the world will be done with fools like you then will we all truly be free!!!
the people will laugh at how stupid people use to be for believing in invisible entity’s with absolutely no evidence.
Logic is limited. Reductionism ended with godels theorem.
They actually do this in Islam, they actually sing "La Ilaha ILLa Lah ... ", meaning there is no God but Allah.
They actually inject it through your ears when you are born
@@xe4me that's child hipnosis.. not good with this song
Short story:
God and man accidently meet
and both shout: "my creator!"
Bruh....
I'm stealing this
@@kenbee1957 just take it
yeah but we make God out to be Frankenstein, and nowhere near what he should be
@@michaeldelaney3587 Sad truth
KEN BEE I’m also stealing this!
I remember vividly the exact moment my doubt, and therefore my journey to atheism, began. I was sitting in Sunday school, about 4 or 5 years old, and the "teacher" (a more appropriate designation would be professional child indoctrinator) began speaking of her opinion on God's presence. How he is everywhere, and sees everything. I wondered, to myself at first, then aloud, "If God is everywhere, why can we not see him right now? I'm sitting in my chair, is God also sitting here?"
The response?
"God is everywhere, even in your seat with you. We cannot see Him, but we can feel Him."
Even to my adolescent brain, this assertion seemed incoherent and unreasonable. From that day forward my doubt increased exponentially with each question I brought forth to the professional indoctrinators that could not be answered to my satisfaction. I was around 13 or 14 when I finally declared myself an atheist.
I was 5 also when my doubts started. I was in Catholic school and asked why dinosaurs were not in the Bible. The nun roughly grabbed my hair and forced me to the front of the room. She beat me with a stick in front of all the other children. I remember thinking what kind of god would beat a child for asking a question. The nuns also taught us that god will punish us for our “thoughts”. Religion is very toxic and dangerous.
Someone said to Christopher Hitchens : ' I'll práy for you !'
And The Hitch answered: '
' And I THINK for yóu !'
What is science first of all.
If i create an equation 2x+4=10
Science is about figuring the equation rather than finding who made it or why I made it.
This universe is a part of a big equation created by God
Only God can say why was it created. God said through revelations and prophets why it is made for us. And asked us to think. God never asked us to worship him by daily but want us to think about our existence and our goals. And told us choose what is better for you. An eternal hereafter or a gloomy sad temporary life in this world.
Congratulations on you that you made your choice
@AllSeeingEye ofGodI will worshop and believe in god just as long as smokes pot and has good taste in music . I couldn't stand it if god was playing this top 40 crap like Beiber and Kanye West on his hifi system all the time .
@@kookamunga2458 Bro, Yeezus is an experimental masterpiece that pushed the boundaries of what popular music could embrace sonically. Check out the Dissect Podcast’s musical analysis of Kanye’s albums to learn how ridiculously deep the level of music production is in his work. It’s stunning, and I think the Kanye is as stupid a douchebag as you can possibly be in this world, but he’s also def a musical genius.
@@cverax383 I am not into the hiphop much because there are so many other styles out there that I have to listen too like jazz , funk and dub . I do have quite a number of hiphop cds and albums ranging from Snoop Dogg, Redman, Flying Lotos, BDP, Cypress Hill mostly old school stuff . I have some Jamacian dancehall like Beenie man , Buju Banton and others . I don't like Kanye West because he is a Donald Trump supporter and Donald Trump supporters don't make very good music .
@@debateon7139 Clearly, you do not understand what science is.
Intelligent, reasoned and spot on.
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.😎😋😋
I have to wonder what kind of "loving" god holds belief as more important than whether or nor you are a good, generous, kind person? What does that say about a god, that he is willing to forgive people for everything up to and including murder... but absolutely will not forgive you if you lived your life well but did not believe he existed?
It says a lot of things. Not a single one of them are good.
Many Christians will ignore their scriptures and say that God let's everybody into heaven EXCEPT OFCOURSE for the "bad" people like Hitler. This i because they don't like him personally.
God wont let Hitler into the club, right? What about Hitler's close friends and family? His kids? They must have liked him as a father. Why don't they get to spend the rest of their eternity with their on father?
Drink for Thought.
FightingTigers
Yeah, that is what happens when you get a ton of people believing in myths... things get twisted and eventually nobody is right and yet nobody is wrong.
I love the way The Big Bang Theory put it: "I don't object to the concept of a deity, but I'm baffled by the notion of one that takes attendance."
JustinMShaw
One of the best lines in the show.
Diviance I haven't even seen that episode and I agree, provided it really is in there. Not doubting Justin's honesty, just withholding judgement until I actually see it.
My mother instilled such a fear and anxiety about this terrifying God individual that it still resonates deep within my subconscious to this day. I realize now that she is just a narcissistic parent and God is her subconscious or domineering side
It’s not real. Never was and never will be. The whole idea is so preposterous that it’s insulting to one’s intelligence. Let your heresy flag fly! 🏴☠️
This is a really encouraging lecture. I'm inspired.
Andy Rhodes check out these:
The Man Behind The Mask: ua-cam.com/video/PMl-Yz2e9WA/v-deo.html
Jesus Messiah or Imposter?: ua-cam.com/video/MThvKguCpN/v-deo.html
The inspirational part is the 11:1 like to dislike ratio.
@Kehnai Bohnyu LOL, terrible video. It’s already been debunked. Sure some believe the lies in that video. Especially those who believe nothing created everything! 😂
@Kehnai Bohnyu here’s an easy debunk, and that’s just one of the many 1) Jesus was never born in December. If you don’t believe this, please show me evidence of this from the bible that it was in December or the 25th. So 1 lie already in that video.
2) God has an enemy and has a lot of knowledge also about God so he can confuse and mix all religions to oppose God and confuse the truth by using some truths mixed with lies. The bible states this very well including Roman Catholicism as the beast of Revelation 13 and mystery Babylon of Revelation 17/18 because it uses mixed pagan religions and pretends to be Christian deceiving millions. God judges also based on the light and best understanding you have also.
From Adam to Jesus they knew the messiah would eventually come and so enemies will make up all kinds of similar stories to twist from the truth to confuse people to unbelief and it’s still going on today, with you believing the lies in the video you shared.
Yes I do believe in Jesus as God in the flesh because it’s scientifically impossible that DNA code can create itself from just magically combining non living matter together. Logic clearly states this as fact.
@Kehnai Bohnyu Lie #2 Horus did not have 12 disciples: strangenotions.com/horus-manure/
this guy is a genius. we need more like him
Matter is conscious. The universe is. He is interesting but doesn't go the extra stretch
Psychosis and mystic revelations go hand in hand - Karl Jasper, V. 1-2 General psychopathology. Now let this guy speak through his ass about psychosis which he has never experienced.
@@zoeyaya9399 thats quite the claim. Where is your evidence to prove all the matter in the universe is conscious..? We'll wait..
@@ChillAssTurtle keep waiting...
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.😎😎😎
Another useful step in calling-out the authority of Religious dogma.
Keep Up The Good Work.
RIP Hitch.
Or any authority or the most impressive credentials. RIP, Hitch for that too - "Why Orwell Matters" not just religious dogma but any $aving authority dogma. We seem to miss seeing all of that, the really dangerous non-religious cults. Enjoy a Cult-a-Cola, on Them, the new fluoridated kool-aid.
I think Hitch died in his sins
@@raysalmon6566 Hell yeah, LMAO. He had no faith in and refused to bow down or bear testimony of any dogma, including the Hole-y Churches, the same con games as the Hole-y Corporatocracy. Hitch refused to be faithful to any anointed cult. No free passes to the only true dogmas. "Why Orwell Matters."
very likely, "hitch" is neither resting nor in peace. most likely suffering Eternally, the worst pain of which is knowing God and knowing that you have wronged God and will never see him again.
@@JPX7NGD You write great fiction, as good as cruci-fiction. Scary stories much?
One of the best sessions that every one on earth has to listen❤️
Nah not really. Saying this is one of the best is a matter of opinion.
Also evolution doesn't actually discredit the existence of the great spirits.
Nor is the idea that every human came into existence in Africa a fully agreed upon belief even in the revolutionary science belief.
Otherwise we are all brothers and sisters and let's be real science already shows what incest does to humans lol.
@saisudheesh *Atheism is total ignorance because one can neither prove nor disprove the existence of God.*
I wonder if children that have imaginary friends are naturally disposed to being religious.
Mainly it’s due to indoctrination by families an the child’s inability of critical thought .
My imaginary friend bullied me.
I gave up the god B.S. about 2 years ago.. Immediately I felt empowered and my mind really opened up and now after 40 years I’m really enjoying life without any chains holding me back
Thank you for that testimony, I am just begining my life without the skyking. I no longer speak to invisible people (I actually feel sane now) or worse make offerings to invisible people in another dimension. 2 years now (best 2 years of my life) It's a great sense of freedom and empowerment.
Funny you two seek out these sites to reaffirm your unbelief. I thought unbelief needed no affirmation. What happens at death? Your not so free are you? Death has very heavy chains and it is unavoidable. What made you accept it's sting? I accepted HIS free offer and HE accepted me. I'm finally free and my life has never been so blessed. Maybe it is not for your eyes, the potter made some vessels not for HIS glory but for destruction, you two sound like those vessels. At least you two will die together. Good day.
Rick Huntling , You sound mad because I don’t believe that atoms burns up forever, research atoms burning up forever and they got nerves connected to them so I can feel the pain. Do that sound stupid? .. Now you go and accept his free gift which is very very important in your faith but your god never mention it once which is mighty suspicious, something so important but never gets mention by your god. You have faith on your side which mean “ belief”I have science on my side which mean “to know” so in essence you are saying you know nothing!! Wake up dude it’s not a sky daddy that’s responsible for your emotions it’s YOU now you go and research and have a good day
Flat Ulence
You just proved yourself stupid or a liar, you pick the appropriate title. "whosoever believeth in ME shall never die" you picked death. "Oh the chains are off I'm free" to sin until the man locks me up or my ass gets kicked. LOL. There are over 40 verses like above but I guess you never bothered to read any of HIS Words.
But science is on my side it always has been on my side. DNA is not good for the evolutionist but your to brainwash to see it is in my corner. Inorganic chemistry is my tool not yours and science of probability is the nails in your coffin. All fairytales begin with a long long time ago. You need more time then eternity to form the first protien but your fairytail only alloted you 4.6 billion years. You believe in miracles by chance. Einstein said GOD doesn't play with dice. Go figure.
Why do you preceive anger in my post? I have a smile as I'm typing even laughter. When you die and are denyed to be in HIS presence you got what you asked for. You win. You will never have to see us again. Isn't that what you believe anyways?
@@rickhuntling7338 , It is NOT polite to call anyone stupid or a liar just because he does not have the same belief as yours.
Why don't you believe in my god?
For the very same reason you don't believe in mine.
God/Jesus exists. I have been, also, an atheist until the vision received.
Few years before the vision, while still being an atheist, I had a NDE.
I had an out of body experience when my heart has stopped for more minutes, in the emergency room of the hospital: at 18 years old, after a saint life, without bad addictions, being a virgin (no sexual involvement until that moment, just platonic), and generally suffering evil from others but not hurting others etc.) when I had my heart stopped in the hospital and my spirit was leaving my body (I raised floating horizontally at about one meter above my dead body, in an infinite happiness that I did not know that exists, and when I was trying to communicate with the nurse next to my bed she was just looking down very sadly, at my dead face, not answering to me, actually not hearing me, while being invisible for her and the other patients from the intensive care room). Then, after that wonderful (extreme happiness) short period of time spent outside of my body (saying continuously loudly about how immense wonderful happiness I feel, but nobody was hearing me), I went down slowly, with the same exact speed, to (into) my body and was back alive.
Anyone can read below, explained in details, how I became a believer (a Christian):
It happened in the first year as a college student. I was an atheist at that time and before, but when I made my girlfriend (actual wife) cry, due to a contradictory discussion about God/Jesus, loving her very much, I ASKED TO GIVE ME A SIGN TO BELIEVE, addressing this from all my soul and from all my heart (it was like "God, if you exist, give me a sign to believe in you"), then, in few days, when I had already forgotten about my demand, I had the vision (please forgive my English, while it is not my native language):
I was like teleported outdoors in complete dark, feeling the wind blowing slowly, and while worrying where I am, and how could be possible such phenomenon, a sphere of light came slowly from the left (later I realized that it came from the house in which I was born, the house of my grandfather, who was a priest, being dead at that moment), and faster while approaching of me, when I was able to recognize the exact place where I was, due to the reflection of light on the houses on one side and another of the road, being in the middle of the street, quite close to the house where I was born (in a small village).
The sphere of light was very bright (the whitest white), diffusing lightly on edges, and in the moment when it touched me, it became like an usual white, decreasing its brightness, as (like) it was defiled by me.
When that sphere of light was coming, I remembered my demand (my words: TO GIVE ME A SIGN TO BELIEVE), and I realized that I can do nothing to escape from that situation (I felt that we people are very small and weak, infinitely more than we realize, against what exists beyond us).
All the time, being inside that light I felt it more like a fluid (it was not an usual light).
After few moments, surrounded by that sphere of light (due to my emotions that have risen dramatically, I was standing up on my toes), I felt it going slowly up, tilting my head up, very kindly, by two very gentle hands (like angelic hands), then going very fast into the sky, like a column of light, remaining looking at the dark night sky filled with stars, IN A COMPLETE SILENCE (that I never experienced). I say "complete silence" because before that moment it was like in this world, with a permanent almost imperceptible background noise, but then the complete silence made me feel out of this world, like I was dead, and I thought that I will hear some words, but no words and I came very abruptly into our usual reality with my heart beating incredible hard, like outside of my body, and the first thing I said was: "Thank You for bringing me back!", then I made my first sacrament (oath) from my entire life: "I will tell to all people whom I find not believing in God that GOD EXISTS AND TO THINK MORE ABOUT THIS!".
_"In the last days, God says, I will pour out My Spirit on all people; your sons and daughters will prophesy, your _*_young men will see visions,_*_ your old men will dream dreams."_ Acts 2, 17
My vision, which turned me from an atheist into a Christian, was an unique 100% real very powerful event at the limit for my heart to resist. If something like that would have happened again later in my life, I would have a heart attack (thanks God that I was very healthy and athletic at that time). Also, I received it because of two main reasons:
1) In spite of the fact that I have been an atheist, besides some mistakes, I have not done evil on purpose, but I have suffered very much evil from others instead, having a life without vices, being virgin until meeting my wife... I was living a life quite close to the one of a saint;
2) I have asked for a sign to believe from all my heart, in the most serious way.
I believe in all gods
David Tucker you said a whole lot of nothing, and don’t know me or my beliefs. I would consider myself more “wise” then most
David Tucker in essence they are all one because they came from a single, it wanted to experience something so it divided itself “like a cell” then there was two creators. Then those creators “birthed” new ideas/creations. Becoming a growing singularity of infinite ideas/creations/dimensions. Yes there is a “one true god” the rest are just copy’s of a copy. But all of “gods” creation is meant for it to be experienced and a learning lesson. “God” lives through each of us. Each human personality is a sliver of gods WHOLE personality. We are all one but different at the same time. That’s why the universe is “expanding” and new ideas are expanding more and more. What is a god? A god is a creator, we are made in gods image, “Ye are like gods” I believe gods had more of a hand in our lives in ancient times, but we are entering the age of Aquarius where humans become gods themselves. Instead of us giving our attention/power away
This was a very intelligent and elaborate way to analyse the need for religion. Thanks a lot for that! Cheers
Quran 19:66 And the disbeliever says, Shall I be raised to life after I die?
19:67 Do ˹such˺ people not remember that We created them before, when they were nothing?
75:3 Do people think We cannot reassemble their bones?
75:4 Yes ˹indeed˺! We are ˹most˺ capable of restoring ˹even˺ their very fingertips.
75:37 Were they not ˹once˺ a sperm-drop emitted?
75:38 Then they became a clinging clot ˹of blood˺,1 then He developed and perfected their form,
75:40 Is such ˹a Creator˺ unable to bring the dead back to life?
This man, Andy Thomson, is a great and clear presenter. Also, the questions at the end were really good quality too. Thanks for the upload.
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.
@@kaylak8478
Thanks, I guess.
omg i had no idea Dawkins had a channel. found by mistake. glad i did
Me too..
God wants you to be an atheist
Me too
Absolutely riveting and what I been trying to (awkwardly) verbalize in this belief-non belief discussion. Really appreciated this!
I'm here because my 78 year old, born again Christian aunt was diagnosed with terminal cancer 3 weeks ago. She was more like my mom than my biological mother. Her name is Elizabeth. I couldn't say her name when I was learning to talk, so I called her Bibba. I'm 50 years old and that's what I still call her today. So does my wife of 31 years, my children, and most of my mother's side of the family. She's always worn that name like a badge of honor because I called her that. Most of the happy childhood memories I have are of the years I spent at her house before I went to kindergarten. From the age of 15 until I was 38 i I was pretty much highor looking for a way to get high. She is married to a minister neither of them ever did anything that felt like judgement. Not once. I was raised in church until I was 13. We stopped going and two years later my parents divorced. I struggled to believe in God, but I never really could. I've tried a couple of times as an adult to go back to church to see if I could find faith. Both ended in disaster and left me with a little less faith both times. I became an agnostic and moved on with my life. I know everyone has to die. I know there are no exceptions, but terminal cancer at 78? Due to illness my uncle spent 3 months in bed a few years ago. When his strength returned enough for him stand it was obvious that he would spend the rest of his life he would be bent at a 90 degree angle. He will never be able to live by himself. They never had children so my wife, kids, and I are all they have. We all work, so that makes what we are
going Tobe able do when my aunt is gone pretty limited. The guilt I feel for hating what they believe is almost unbearable. I hate the people who will say "I will pray for you". I hate the pious motherfuckers who will say, "At least she's not suffering anymore. I hate the people that will say "She's in a better place. Right now I don't know if I'll even be able to go to the funeral because I am literally afraid I will scream if I have to be in the same room with anyone who is going to talk about how merciful their God is. I want to fucking scream just thinking about them. If you read this far, thank you for taking the time. I don't know why I wrote this. Maybe I'm trying to clear my head. Maybe it's so someone else going through something similar will read it and feel better because someone else in the world understands how fucked up the world seems sometimes. All I know right now is I'm not sure about anything.
So sorry about all that. I hope somehow you will find peace. When ppl say things you don't like, they don't mean to offend you. They think they're comforting you. Yeah, the world is fucked up but there's still a lot of good people like your dear Aunt. Thanks for taking the time to share your story. I wish you the Best.
Update:We lost my uncle last Thursday. we lost my oldest aunt the day before. I wrote and gave his eulogy. It was the hardest thing I've ever had to do. He was a very precious man so I was not going to disrespect his God. To comfort his surviving family and mine was my only goal. Now I feel like a fake and a hypocrite for saying I knew he was in heaven. I hope there is, but nobody can prove it. I just wanted to lift the families spirits. We buried him three days ago. My aunt ended up back in the hospital yesterday day. It feels like I'm in a horror movie set in The Twilight Zone.
I found the story about Darwin walking his family to church, dropping them off and going for a walk while they were in church fascinating. The idea that Darwin, through his research and studies, came to a place that put a serious strain on his relationships makes him all the more relatable. He loved his wife more than anything and wanted to keep things civil with her.
The idea that we are naturally programmed for bonding and relationships. Evolutionary programming or intelligent creation. I have heard it both ways now.
Nice lecture. Fundamentalist Christians will won't take your findings until they experience a major paradigm and have an open mind.
I'm disappointed he couldn't find a better wife.
Dam, very well said.
I too agree, fundamentalists must have a major paradigm shift with an open mind to even understand stuff like this.
if evolution was a real thing then everything would not be limited to reproducing after its own specific kind and the process of evolution would not be as perfect as nature is now . creatures of all kinds would be evolving and reproducing with any combination of species and u would have creatures that were part bird part human part dog part lion and part elephant with eyes in the back of their heads and noses on their feet and tails coming from various areas of the body , it would be a total mess . it takes alot of faith to be an atheist and believe that everything reproducing only after its own kind is just a random coincidence .
My mother converted to a fundamentalist “Christian” cult (Jehovah’s Witnesses) after she and my father married (probably because of her father’s suicide). My father was baptized as a baby in the Catholic Church, however, he never attended church, at least while I knew him (he passed away in 2007). However, he loved my mother very much, despite her religious beliefs. They never separated and remained married until his passing and had four children together. After I attended and graduated from college, I left my mother’s cult and no longer subscribe to myths or superstitions, even though I converted to Judaism over thirty years ago. I enjoy the camaraderie, I just don’t read the Tanakh (Bible) as a historical source, but rather as just another piece of literature.
Along with owing an enormous amount of gratitude to the four horsemen of the Apocalypse. I think we all have to thank our creators. Thanks to Frued, Nietzsche, Dostyvesky, Darwin, and many others. Let higher men live long and prosper.
or: save the souls of the minorities
Quran 19:66 And the disbeliever says, Shall I be raised to life after I die?
19:67 Do ˹such˺ people not remember that We created them before, when they were nothing?
75:3 Do people think We cannot reassemble their bones?
75:4 Yes ˹indeed˺! We are ˹most˺ capable of restoring ˹even˺ their very fingertips.
75:37 Were they not ˹once˺ a sperm-drop emitted?
75:38 Then they became a clinging clot ˹of blood˺,1 then He developed and perfected their form,
75:40 Is such ˹a Creator˺ unable to bring the dead back to life?
@@mdfisa4453 yeah raise out of the misery .. the simpleminded seek life in between dead material not noticing that they are breathing .. you wash your face in scripts .. in letters .. and think that repetition brings forth the truth .. but i see only cows eating up again what others did eat up before them
@@schiacciatrollo Quran 56:47 They used to ask ˹mockingly˺, “When we are dead and reduced to dust and bones, will we really be resurrected?
56:48 And our forefathers as well?”
56:49 Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “Most certainly, earlier and later generations
56:50 will surely be gathered ˹together˺ for the appointed Day.
56:51 Then you, O misguided deniers,
56:52 will certainly eat from ˹the fruit of˺ the trees of Zaqqûm,1
56:53 filling up ˹your˺ bellies with it.
56:54 Then on top of that you will drink boiling water-
56:55 and you will drink ˹it˺ like thirsty camels do.”
56:56 This will be their ( deniers ) accommodation on the Day of Judgment.
56:57 It is We Allah Who created you. Will you not then believe ˹in resurrection˺?
@@mdfisa4453 just stupid things to ask and or to fear .. if not people put themselves in such believing light and get dangerous to other people and colonialize them into 'right thinking' .. why would anybody believe in that old smear? isn't it stupid to take life-savings out of a 'cook-book'?
"Who has formed a God, or cast a graven image, without intending to make a profit?"
@Urayis wish l Do you mean Jesus? If so you clearly have no idea what you're talking about at all, especially since you mentioned Buddha too, Buddha was *_not_* a god, he was just a guy, a guy who had some good advice about living your life in a good and helpful way, he was an Indian, his existence is confirmed unlike Jesus (Yeshua) who not only has no evidence of existing at all in actual historical documents but if you actually read the bible and take a step back from the indoctrination and view it as an outsider you'll realise that the character of "Jesus" could actually be as many as 30 or more *_different_* characters! And that's long before you get to actually researching historical documents that not once *_ever_* mention this "Jesus" as described in that book of fairy tales aka "the bible", people need to understand what they're commenting on before making fools out of themselves (hint hint).
I was a Sōtō Zen Buddhist for many years and I am well aware of the fact that Buddhists (specifically Sōtō Zen and Gerug as well as many others) don't even see it as a "religion", it's more a way of life than anything, there are *_no_* gods in these kinds of Buddhism, Gerug is the one headed by Tensin Gyatso, aka The (current) Dalai Lama, he's *_not_* a god, Buddha was *_not_* a god and for anyone to suggest such a thing shows exactly how ignorant they are...
The op mentioned about religions who really only do it for profit so I've gone completely off-topic but I thought it was worth mentioning first before I destroy your "argument":
Christianity is absolutely for profit, no question about that at all! They pass around donation plates, ask for this, ask for that, it's an insult to anyone with half a brain cell! 🤣
Buddhism is absolutely *_not_* about profit, the teachings of Buddhism are to live a minimalist life without the need of material possessions, they rarely, if *_ever,_* accept monetary donations, instead they prefer to accept donations in the form of food 🍲 it's actually an honour to feed a Buddhist and an insult to offer money...
@Zeljko Trifunovic Exactly the kind of response I'd expect from an idiot religitard 🤣
Why bother trying to refute the things I say when you can just throw an insult in instead? 🤣
So mature 🤣
Docta Osiris well said brother
Or just to control others - AND get out of real work.
@@DoctaOsiris The things you commented about, the culture of "Buddhism" are true, but like all great thinkers people will deify them through story telling (word of mouth). Your statement about "Christianity" was also true, due to the centuries of false teachings by religious leaders. The "Bible" 1611. you mention was created in Europe and has nothing to do with The Holy Scriptures (The Torah) which came out of the East. When you stated "there are no gods" well,,,, the whole world must be ignorant because truly the whole world worships a "God" or Goddess in some shape or form. So yes, "Christianity" is absolutely for profit" which is why I made that comment.
'No other creature prays not even a praying mantis'
"Humans can't create a mosquito yet they create gods in thousands" -
Any god, especially any like Hitchens describes, is a human creation.
My puzzle, if Christians do worship that god, why do they clearly not fear His wrath, not worship Him out of fear of punishment, but describe their God as being like the most loving earthly father ever, who delights in lavishing them with gifts?
Why are they calmer? How does the "faith" of genuine followers lead to higher life expectancies, lower stress, greater tolerance and acceptance of others?
Why do the true ones glow?
Where is this quote from? If it's your own then don't be bashful! :)
Human's can clone mosquitos.
Religion is what mankind does to make gods do something . Trust is what mankind relies on to stay sane. Science says a Rembrant masterpiece is pigment and binder smeared on a piece of prepared stretched fibrous material tacked to wood by a descendant from the hominid line. Faith says it is a unique and wonderful uplifting unique and unparalleled creation.
Science describes a rectangle of fibrous paper with ink pressed onto it from a photo lithographic etched metal plate. Faith says that thousand dollar bill has meaning far beyond its physicality. Science says histone proteins allow DNA to fit inside a cell. Faith is astonished that each cell's DNA is 1 meter long, and, in a lifetime, following the laws which govern space, time, matter and energy, your lifetime of strands, end to end, in 70 years reaches 1 light year.
Science cannot tell you that is miraculous. Only faith, trust, wonder.
@@StellaLovesMusic25 Lmao hahahaha, how do you explain natural disasters that your invisible friend is ultimately responsible for, notice i said natural disasters bcuz they are not caused by man, Lmao hahahaha end of the world , im pretty sure the planet has been around billions of years and will be here long after we go,the world doesnt hate God, there is no reason to hate something that doesnt exist, thats just silly
"it has served us well, this myth of Christ" - Pope Leo X
Great, isn't it, to have stupid quips of others to rely on to form our entire conclusions on the subject of God & Christ, eh? Numerous ABSOLUTES of God exist before our "mental eyes", which we can readily "see", as scripture says. There is no alternative for "God IS".
@@greg5023 - You should open your eyes and think for yourself. There is no alternative to understanding that Creator God exists and is the sovereign power of the universe. Besides, I was referring to Bope Leo's anti-Christ quip. He had no business being a fraudulent Bope if he did not even believe in Christ, who is the most well established person in human history, with more written about Him from the middle of the 1st century to this day, than any other historical person.
@demigodzilla - Wow, your contribution is equal to the quality of dog feces, oh brilliant scoffer.
There is no valid alternative to God IS, and He leads every person to Himself that diligently seeks to know Him & His absolutes, which involve time on earth and ETERNITY.
In your wilful ignorance, you choose the path of the lazy godless majority, which includes the mass murdering atheist leaders who have eliminated well over 100 MILLION people over the past 110 years or so.
So, YOUR life choices are truly disgusting at their ultimate best, and, again are equal to the quality of dog feces.
So, project as you desire, but you can't fool me, oh perverse one, as you THINK you are preparing an excuse to offer your Creator in YOUR DAY, when He asks you why you chose to remain ignorant of Him, and to live by the false claims of evil men who promote Pinocchio pseudoscience & anti God rhetoric & hate, without doing YOUR due diligence, which ALL humans are required to do, as concerns God.
Toodles, oh simple scoffer.
.
david77james go find your group and leave others alone. First ,watch the video and then- go get a life.
@@silkyslim2111 - Mind your own biz oh silkyslime. I visit all types of videos, and have done so for over 15 years. You no like? Aaaatsa too bade. Why don't you peel off if you don't like my visits. You said the dumbest thing. What I said involves recognizing "light". Darkness hates the light.
I don's ask people to write to me, but hundreds do. Why is that my fault, just for making comments. These comments are "public comments" and available to the public. Hello?
I know things that lots of others do not know. Are you "afraid" of intelligent opposition? Of course you are, as you prefer to live with your delusions & lies. But that's okay. It's no concern to anyone.
You stole my line - Get a life - So Get a life, and quitcha whining. It's all about my business when a person talks about these subjects. So, buzz off if you don't like it.
I'm a first class good guy.
.
Before you watch any video always keep your headphones off to not be corrupted by commercials. Lets now listen to the program we wanted to.
Religion started when primal hunters wanted to create some sort of competitive advantage over the animals they needed for food, because they realized that sometimes the difference between starving and eating was a matter of good luck or bad luck and tipping the scales in your favor could not hurt and could only help
I think it is much broader than that...gods provided explanation for the powerful forces man could not control, a way to embody the highest values of the clan or society with a price to pay for disobedience, which taught that there are rules you can't ignore to remain in good graces. This prevented each new generation from having to question what laws were still valid, as rebellion destroys societal cohesion.
The 10 C may look ridiculous to atheists, but they have provided a moral and legal framework for societal behavior. US jurisprudence was founded on them. Sad to see moral relativism become the new paradigm.
Would not work well for sports rules or traffic laws...
@@glenliesegang8935as an atheist I agree with this, I think largely religious authority became a great way to pass down knowledge from previous gens in a way that had a built in pro-compliance mechanism
Plus I find the agency argument the prof makes above very compelling.
But I don’t think it’s a statement on the trueness of the religion, just how I think it’s dogma arises, and I think humans should be at a place where we can now analyse the truth of it all
To add to the point, I think religious dogma has always been a reflection of the times in which it is written and then subsequently kept.
I’m sure you don’t think slavery is good, and yet the bible explicitly supports this. You have made a moral judgement to ignore the religious text based on your modern understanding of ethics.
You / society have done this to all parts of the text that is incompatible with modern sensibilities. What’s left are the parts that remain compatible, so why not just drop the religious pretext?
You claim it’s the basis of jurisprudence , I don’t actually agree with that fwiw, justice as we understand it has existed in various forms predating New Testament Christianity, and most us jurisprudence was exported from England - of which it was largely secular in its development
Nice presentation Dr. Andy Thompson. Very informative and captivating.
Intelligence and critical thinking are a beautiful thing
but so rare a thing as to be worshipped as a God
That's why you're ugly.
Berzerker Juice Having an exorcist priest role would be very scary.
watch the devil and father amorth trailer.
Thanks, but I don't argue with believers. Life's too short.
👌🏼👏👏👏💯
I believe if you are able you have a moral responsibility to argue.
Do you not feel your moral sensibility motivating you when you see a friend, pistol to his temple, explaining, "god commands me"?
Same deal.
REDPUMPERNICKEL
I used to fight back. Just today, on Fox News, there's an article about some people seeing Jesus' face in the flames of the Notre Dame cathedral fire. These are the people that I have no time for.
@@Mom_sBasement
I know what you mean.
Undoubtedly we would be more successful in our efforts to awaken others if we could focus only on those who are sleeping most lightly. Try as I might I cannot reliably distinguish light from heavy sleepers so I've adopted a do-what-I-can approach. Can't myself claim to have awoken anyone but have to imagine many of the newly awoken experience some amount of embarrassment over their former credulity and so are understandably unwilling to acknowledge it.
I am encouraged by reports that our numbers are growing rapidly.
I believe this gain is due in part to our collective online efforts and due in larger part to the growth of ordinary secular public education in which so many facts directly contradict pulpit and scripture. (why the religious want their own schools) Also, the simple fact of discovering that large numbers of one's neighbors hold one's religious beliefs to be superstitious nonsense has to induce disturbing ripples in one's reflections about reality. These and many, many elements in modern culture have a cumulative awakening effect. Seems to me there is a good chance that there will be enough of us to something, something... survive.
Cheers and please do carry on, your efforts are appreciated.
I've wasted another day writing comments against the idea of gods. I think Ill do what you have done and just stop, its pointless. May god give me strength not to respond tomorrow when I get replies.
Gawwwd dam, I love this. I always thought that this whole religion thing is very psychological with how the brain/mind works. This is one of the best lectures I’ve watched on it so far. I haven’t explored evolution yet, but seems like it’s onto something.
"Religion began when the first scoundrel met the first fool." Voltaire
Voltaire was deist btw.
Extraordinnary talk. I learned a lot and hope this will be spread.
I grew up in the catholic church, went to catholic schools and don’t remember believing any of it.
Same here 😃
While I understood the catechism, I really couldn't believe in Adam & Eve. I mean a talking snake.👿👿👿
veritas aka Koru you miss the exorcist priest role that is absolutely the best part of it all.
watch the devil and father amorth trailer.
@@robandrews4815 its a metaphor
@@lightbeing8174 this idiot thinks fiction movies are real lol
This is amazing. Thank you.
It is actually bs.
Atheïsm is just a effect of the fall of man.
Jesus = God in fysical form. He was before time was.
Interesting to read what God came to do on this earth....
Healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, hanging on a cross to pay the debtbof our fall, pouring out His Spirit so we can become what we were created to be... walking in the same unselfish love and power He did.
His Spirit brings forth after His kind.
Born-again. Yay!
www.anewcreationinchrist.nl/english
The speaker is sooo assertive with his claims, he is sooo sure that he speaks truth. Its arrogant of him to assume that he is speaking absolute truth.
does he say he's speaking absolute truth? OOOOOORRRR does he prefix the entire speech with "this is the best science we have right now, and here is the evidence?"
He's got the letters behind his name to back it up.
Atheïsm is just a effect of the fall of man.
Jesus = God in fysical form. He was before time was.
Interesting to read what God came to do on this earth....
Healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, hanging on a cross to pay the debtbof our fall, pouring out His Spirit so we can become what we were created to be... walking in the same unselfish love and power He did.
His Spirit brings forth after His kind.
Born-again. Yay!
www.anewcreationinchrist.nl/english
This is one of the best lectures on the subject that I have seen yet.
you are easily impressed.
ua-cam.com/video/zU7Lww-sBPg/v-deo.html
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.😎😎😎
@@bretzajac7986 why so?
Just wanted to say hello to all my AFRICAN Brothers and Sisters....ASE!!!😘
Hello Brother! 😁
ASEE!!!😅😃😁😍😍
RAAAAALUUTE!!!!!
LOVE this :D
You're an idiot! The "Out of Africa" bullsh*t theory has been debunked some time ago!
I wish this talk could be 2 hours long and he really explains some things. My feeble little pea brain is strugglin here & I’m evening taking notes lol
Felt the same way.. didn't understand many of the examples, references or what he was trying to say.. Obviously I don't blame him but my limited knowledge and how I might have gotten "spoiled" by extraordinary lecturers like Richard Dawkins himself and now I pretentiously pretend every lecturer to be as clear explaining as him haha
Excellent suggestion from the last member of the audience. Let's hope someone with the necessary skills hears this and gets on it!! Great talk! 😊
If we were immortal, or at least if we had no consciousness of mortality, there would be no gods. Fear made gods. Hope maintains them.
Actually there are very respectable scholarly understandable history/evolution based theories that account very well for the phenomenon. Here's one...
s-f-walker.org.uk/pubsebooks/pdfs/Julian_Jaynes_The_Origin_of_Consciousness.pdf
I'm granted imortality in my confidence and rest in the Alpha and the Omega. Fear made gods but no one made GOD because HE was and without Him nothing was made.
-
And what after this world?
Rick Huntling Amen brother glad you see the truth amongst the hopeless, faithless atheists
"How did our brains develop capacity?" The same way you build muscles to be able to lift weights greater than you could lift at first ... exercise/practice (the way neuroplasticity strengthens connections between brain-cells the more you use those connections)
I'm agnostic, but is it not possible that God created those areas in our brains so that we would naturally want to worship him?
@@richardmiller249 presupposing god is not a wise beginning.
evolution of organisms is due to physical LAWS ! have laws evolved aswell?
@@tarikbaroudi7852 You're the one who mentioned 'evolution.' If that's what you want to call 'the muscles/neurons natural adaptation to fulfill their usefulness,' you go right ahead.
@@Walklikeaduck111 You look at the writing & do not presuppose a writer? You've got higher faith (in Nothing) than I do (in something else)!
I'll watch this again. Exceptionally well detailed and dissected information.
Me too.
It's too heavy to be disgusted once.
Great explanation
”The majority are afraid of death, do not accept the end and would love to be protected their whole lives by a strong father. That is why so many people believe in God.” - Paulo Bitencourt
Neh. I have a way better reason.
Atheïsm is just a effect of the fall of man.
Jesus = God in fysical form. He was before time was.
Interesting to read what God came to do on this earth....
Healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, hanging on a cross to pay the debtbof our fall, pouring out His Spirit so we can become what we were created to be... walking in the same unselfish love and power He did. Because He is so passionate of what He created you to be.
His Spirit brings forth after His kind.
Born-again. Yay!
www.anewcreationinchrist.nl/english
@@ToninoterRessort Heretic! The true God is the Almighty Thor. Repent now, or face consequences!
@@Liberated_from_Religion The only consequence is living life in the fall of man. Stumbling, for yourself, no presence of God, no healing miracles, no peace, no knowledge of His goodness.
What a choice.
@@ToninoterRessort Ah, shut up and shove it!
@@ToninoterRessort if there is a god, there is no choice for it is claimed that he knows it all. Even if you want to rebuttal with " he knows it all but he lets you choose". Bullshit, impossible, he knew your choice well before you even made it. Therefore, it's his created choice. Sorry to crumble your sandcastle.
Thankfully my parents were and are atheists, so just the school system to survive and again thankfully I attended a none denomination otherwise known as church of England school . People believe in gods because of indoctrination ,it should be left to the individual if they want the faith and not have it forced upon them when they are too young to protest.
Ian Clarke I think people believes in God as the one to grant them fortune and to benefit themselves from the absurdities of our life. So in their ideology God gifted them so they must respect them. Just like your parent when they give you a gift you feel thankful. But the problem is that you ain’t even hearing God and he didn’t even touched you, its all belief made on your mind.
If left up to everyone to choose nobody would choose the gods were indoctrinated with
I wish I was born with at least one parent like that but it was fun reading the Bible and being able to point out the hypocrites they were, and deducing it was all BS by age 12 👌🏽
The bible and other likewise publications should be on the top shelf out of the reach of children like pornography with 18+ on the cover .
although my parents are somewhat religious thank "God" they allowed me to think for myself
BRAVO absolutely a Great scientific speech on the fakeness of religion. Peace.
How so?
You edgelords are so deeply cringey in your belief of the atheism religion. There's nothing quite so funny as your absolute black and white faith. The world cringes at you. I am not religious but damn, you make me want to be out of spite. Don't mind me or my comment, have another mountain dew and discuss why you're so much better than everyone else.
This is all about superiority. How very human of you. How completely tribal. lol I am glad you figured it out. Grats on succeeding where greater minds failed.
@Rakscha theres nothing sad about humanity. We are where we are posting on youtube because of tribalism. I find nothing sad by adhering to natural law and becoming the dominant species. Theres no use in lamating what is.
Lol, fake religions don't equal "no God"...😂
@Rakscha all religions aren't wrong... All but One are out there to mislead, thanks to the enemy. Christianity isnt without it's stumbling blocks either but Jesus is the truth and the ONLY way to our heavenly Father. We know this only by following HIS teachings and the proof that follows believing.
Morality and religion is not the same.😇
A wise man said, "5 minutes after you are born someone chooses for you your name, citizenship, and religion. You will spend the rest of your life defending things you never chose.
wow wow wow! this was incredibly eye opening. ive been searching for answer as to why people whom are much smarter, more educated, and intellectually capable and honest, believe in magic when i do not. i watch allot of videos on this subject and i believe this one to to be the best. or a least ive come away with more from it that any other.
whom are much smarter? I do not , not i do not. I watch, not i watch. A lot. Not allot . I believe not i believe. I've not ive. I am the Grammar God. Believe in Me ( is that me?) and does the question mark locate within the parentheses or outside of the parentheses?
If you thought that was eye opening this book will blow your eyelids clean off...
s-f-walker.org.uk/pubsebooks/pdfs/Julian_Jaynes_The_Origin_of_Consciousness.pdf
Phil blanc
Have you seen the
Piece by hitch slap on
That Albanian lady
Mother Theresa.
Happy info hunting.
Toughen Up, Fluffy nmnmmñmññn
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.😍😎
I never ever believed in a god at all. I have childhoodd memories of me asking how noahs arc was supposed to work then.
Not to sound superior, I never bothered!! It all sounded so stupid even at that age and without social pressure, I was free to reach my own conclusions!!
@Paul Morgan Not sure how that made any difference to me at least! The premise is so preposterous, I don't recall ever having to assess that additional bit of ridiculous trivia!
@Paul Morgan Well there are loads of people that believe the world was literally created in a week, with Sunday as god's day off too!!! That the story was literally lifted from greek mythology AKA greek religious belief until the invasion of monotheism, seems not to bother anybody.
Advancing the human condition is so fraught with pitfalls! WSe have no filter, no "logical module" governing decisions or assessing information. We develop by copying the adults around us and if they believe in flying pigs, so do we even in the face of facts literally thrown in our face that they cannot exist! Case in point the Flat Earthers!! No matter what they are told or shown to the contrary, they just insist we are on a tabletop!!
@Paul Morgan I don't know any personally but they have to be, because they get all that horseshit from the Bible too!!! As for turning it off, they're like roaches and creep up in the weirdest places. A scientist, I think was explaining in YT why photos taken on the moon show no stars in the background, basically an issue that has to do with the way cameras work... and out they came...."because the pics were taken in a studio....etc etc....no one ever made it to the moon etc. etc...
@Paul Morgan Yes, but I think u dwell on this detail a bit too much. it's meant to impress. How logical is it that a guy was told to build a boat on a mountain and literally collect every single animal, lash it into the boat and then let them go in a world that was drowned of plant life, to later go and commit incest for generations to repopulate the world!!!!? Then there is the parting of the waters thing etc.....
Hyperactive Agency Detection
“All of us will mistake a shadow for a burglar.
We will never mistake a Burglar for shadow”
Thanks autoplay feature. I'm glad you thought I'd want to see this. You we're right! Intensional intentionality! 😆
I cannot understand how the USA could be so backward as to not teach about Darwin in all primary schools even in the mid 20th century.
Hedging their Bets. Lucky they did
Yeah. I never learned evolution in school either. I was born and raised In a small conservative majority town in Arkansas. To this day, there are over 100 churches in a our town of roughly 75,000 people + /-. I didnt know we are related to apes until I was 26 years old. I had never heard of evolution, we were taught about mitochondria and DNA, stuff like that. The far right Christian's have a powerful hold on my town , because belief is a big business.
@@charlieclark2609 Well Jay, I love you for being so honest. Thanks. You know, I'm not sure there are 100 churches in the city of Brisbane where I live or, for that matter in London. Although that might be going too far.😅London has been around a long time.
@@toni4729 you're welcome. I'm glad o found my way out of religion , in particular christianity, a few years ago. My life is so much freer that I can think. I'm looked down upon , yes , but its better than being a sheep and thinking everything is a sign of the end times haha
@@charlieclark2609 I just looked up a map of churches in London and you know, there aren't that many churches there at all. I think Londers are all atheists except the coloured ones that are no christians. I suppose they'll learn one day as well.
It's nice to know that Americans are finding their way out of the dark. Have a wonderful life.
Religion.. Where hallucination is deemed acceptable.
What dictates reality from hallucination? To your brain, chemically, theyre exactly the same. The only thing that can distiguish it is conciousness. Why? is that?
Ohwhale
Religious people don't hallucinate dumbass. What kind of hallucinogens have you been taking to make such a dumbass remark?
hallucination
[həˌlo͞osəˈnāSH(ə)n]
NOUN
an experience involving the apparent perception of something not present.
"he continued to suffer from horrific hallucinations"
synonyms:
delusion · illusion · figment of the imaginati
@@rickhuntling7338 hallucination
[həˌlo͞osəˈnāSH(ə)n]
NOUN
an experience involving the apparent perception of something not present.
"he continued to suffer from horrific hallucinations"
synonyms:
delusion · illusion · figment of the imaginati
Punk
Believing in dark matter and dark energy and the universe caused by a causeless nothingness fall into the same definition. The problem is they all have to negate the laws of logic and rely on faith. Evolution has the same definition. You just call your god Dark little "g". My eternal cause is YHWH.
I would guess this has been asked before, but with 15,000 posts to sift through, sorry if it's a repeat!
In the video for Andy Thomson's lecture "Morality: From the Heavens or From Nature?", he mentions that the slides from his presentation were available. I know it's a long time ago, but are the background slides to THIS presentation accessible online anywhere?
I can’t say thank you enough for your dedication to the truth ❤️🌎
@@StellaLovesMusic25 brainwashed human
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.😍😍
@@StellaLovesMusic25The whole hammer thing is THOR, you donut!
The point is that there is one god, and one god only: the flying spaghetti monster.
there is more physical evidence ACTUALLY inside everyone. if you lay out the complete nervous system ( including brain, and eyeballs) on a table... YOU are the spaghetti monster!!
Thanks for the promotion!
+EVZYL THANK YOU for being the noble fighter for TRUTH! Indeed, FSM is IT! And THAT! And EVERYTHING in between! Ramen, my friend.
+EVZYL
Ramen
No, we worship the Flying Spaghetti Monster. We prefer it to Mohammed's flying horse.
I have given up trying to find out the origin of life. All I know is that I am alive now and that I will die although I do not know when I will die. I am NOT AFRAID of death as I know that I have live quite an honest life.
Nice to meet you, Mr.Thomson
Very educating !! As soon as that fog is clear !!
This is such an amazing talk. Thank you for this and all that you do.
The universe created us. It is conscious. Life goes way beyond this man's explanations.
@@zoeyaya9399 yea seems that way. It's nice to take it one step at a time and build our knowledge onto what has already been learned. If society continues our knowledge will hopefully grow with it. Ensuring future generations a wealth of information, and wisdom unparalleled.
Jesus, you sit well in my heart.😎
Why believe? The fear of uncertainty.
plunderpunk2 Uncertainty?
Fear of death and the oblivion it represents. The fear of death is the root of all fears.
@@Jake007123 yes
@David Mack Did you just said that the Moon landing is fake? I didn't need to read more after that, your opinion is not fact based and therefore not worth of our time.
this fear of uncert future is infact true
I remember when I was about 10 years old, I was looking at a crystal figurine of an angel in my grandmother’s cabinet. I asked her what an angel was, and she gave the religious definition of “when people die...,god’s messengers, ect.” I replied “No, but what ARE they?” And she said something along the lines of “God only knows.” In my curious young mind, I was logically trying to figure out their biology. How can humans grow wings? How does their halo defy earth’s gravity? It all felt so wrong to me. This was the spark for me.
I loved this.
There is always this one guy who chuckles every time like: "I know, right"
the most articulate rubbishing of the god story iv'e ever heard ,really deep and challenging material .i must buy his book .
....and whilst you're buying that book, how about a book on grammar, spelling and typing too?
@@jvincent6548 _"....and whilst you're buying that book, how about a book on grammar, spelling and typing too?"_
You forgot the Oxford comma there. 😋
Fear of death.
Uneasyness re lack of justice.
Irrationality of the mind.
Gullibility.
Internalization.
Fear of divine punishment.
The opposite of god: "nothingness", nihilism, lack of protection.
Fear of social/groupal rejection.
We believe in god cuz mental stability is one of the major part of an intelligent specie's survival(or say better survival)
And mental stability is all about satisfaction,happiness,stop asking questions and wandering about the existence,fear of the unknown etc....its big
We see our kids adopt imaginary friends from very young then wonder why adults do....
+C.W P imaginary friends arent imaginary ...its demons talking to children ...
+Aquarian Rising
So you believe in astrology and the invisible man in the sky, and invisible bad guys that live in the ground, and horses that fly and donkeys that talk?
No I don't believe the Bible ...
+MasterAtheistic That was his "Guardian Angel" protecting him from religion! LOL
Considerable evidence does exist supporting the hypothesis that what we call mind and consciousness result from mechanisms in a purely material brain. If we have disembodied souls that are responsible for our thoughts, dreams, personalities, and emotions, then they should not be affected by drugs. But they are. They should not be affected by disease. But they are. They should not be affected by brain injuries. But they are.
As brain function decreases, we lose consciousness, as when under full anesthesia. Why should that be if consciousness resides in an immaterial soul? Brain scans today can locate the portions of the brain where different types of thoughts arise, including emotions and religious thoughts. When that part of the brain is destroyed by surgery or injury, those types of thoughts disappear. Let’s face it; so-called spirituality is all in the head. It’s purely material in nature.
www.huffingtonpost.com/victor-stenger/life-after-death-examinin_b_1428710.html
If I pray that none of my prayers will be answered, will my prayer be answered ?
tedgrant2 No
If God allows it
J Vincenzi And you are proof positive that nobody ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the religious...
Is that your only prayer?
Content doesn't matter, it just won't be.
John Lennon summed the whole thing up in his song Imajine as easy as that.
Queen was better than the Beatles.
When I was a kid, i gathered plant from the backyard to make magic potions. My childhood was characterized as naivete.
“I hope for nothing. I fear nothing. I am free.”- Nikos Kazantzakis
Religion consists of equal measures hope and fear.
Dorian Philotheates And science consists of equal measures observation and ignorance. No one has a clue how we got here or what’s going on here
@@brenttaylordotus No one in science claims to know how we got here or that we have all the answers concerning what's going on here. That's what science is for, to find the actual answers to our questions piece by piece.
Thank God for RICHARD DAWKINS
😆
Thank God for Jimi Hendrix, Chopin, Montogomery and Patton, Winston Churchill, Apple, The Doors, Porsche, Picasso, Warhol, European Union, Clean Water, Microwaves...
@@jvincent6548 not winston churchill the porcine racist warmonger who murdered millions of
Indians...
@@pramilamenon8621 Tell me what, why, how? I am genuinely keen to learn. Though allow me to say this of him. He led a nation, indeed an empire, if I could say that without the attachments of outdated colonialism and racism, through adversity that threatened his nation's existence, with dogmatic and clear-sighted leadership against Hitler's tyranny. The rest of the world were occupied with their own issues, or disinterested in Hitler's nazi conquest of Europe. When all other political leaders in Europe caved in to Hitler or sought appeasement with his corrupt and disfigured regime, Churchill alone growled the only effective strategy: to stand up and stand firm against him. How now the world if not for him?
@@jvincent6548 please read up how he singlehandedly killed Indians....
"Let's build a relegion" game, that's a great idea 💡
Brilliant. Thanks.
“You talk when you cease to be at peace with your thoughts.”
― Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet ,
Preach the gospel always even if it requires words; St. Francis of Assisi.
Lebanon
"the world is flat"
~every major religion ever...
Alpha is God Beth the Beast. The word become flesh, second Buddha of the Book of the Dead.
Imagine NO religion...
-John Lennon
Andy is helping folks who want to understand how religion works. That is good. He is suggesting that the information could be used in conversations with believers. Jonathan Haidt’s work might also be of interest. The Righteous Mind. We are subject to confirmation bias. We accept ideas that align with our thinking. We question and tend to dismiss ideas that threaten out beliefs.
Not to diminish Andy’s work. I really appreciate it. Finding common ground with true believers and moving forward is the next big challenge.
Explained so well
Really interesting presentation, some of the questions were painful lol
Outstanding lecture.
Thank you
@a S u are
This might not seem related, but it actually is. As an Anti-AA activist I'm keenly aware that there is a reason behind why AA and 12 Step feels that people are most receptive to 12 Step (cult) Program when they are at their "bottom," and also why the idea of "powerlessness" is one of the keys to Program (cult) philosophy.
Silver Damsen well said
Tell me more i have been struggling with not allowing myself to be indoctrinated by the big book thumpers love the fellowship just not the program
what is AA et al? I am nowhere near rock bottom but i like answers.
The fear of the faithful to relinquish their faith...is that the self esteem and self confidence that must exist may not be there to call on.
Someone please help me... how do I stop videos from hitting my auto-play??