I still have such mixed feelings on Bebe returning on AS3. On one hand, it was amazing to see this legend of the franchise grace our screens once again. But one the other hand, they had to force the jury twist at the end for her to not be in the top 2 as they knew she would’ve destroyed Trixie in that final lip sync.
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudgedWhich honestly, IMO, Bebe was the deserving winner of that season. And before anyone tries to clock me on only saying this because of the Shangela controversy, girl I was in the trenches saying Bebe deserved to win when it released. She killed it!
@@azsazazsa I know how insanely controversial it is, but I stand by Trixie's win. She made it to the end with no favoritism, and realistically deserved 1 more win and 1 less bottom
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudgedIn the episode they called out eureka for not having all her jokes land and Ru told Kylie she did amazing the following episode in the werkroom. Also it's the only snatch game of love where the snachelor specifically didn't pick anyone from the second group, and all of the other picks have been the top 2 of the episode. That's why I think Alexis would've won instead of jujubee also
Detox did better from an aesthetics standpoint, but Katya was very entertaining, plus it's all about branding in Makeovers, or at least it's supposed to be. Katya's brand is Eastern European Communist camp, she followed that perfectly. That's not to say from an aesthetics POV she was even second best, she was more like third best, but her branding her looks so spot on definitely brought up her score. I'd honestly say, Detox and Katya tied because Katya did such a great job at branding, while Detox wore a nice dress that didn't automatically scream Detox. It wasn't out of character for Detox, but I think if she wore something slutty and neon with her sister, it would've translated even better for me.
@@itsgabbybtch5587 completely disagree with everything you just said 😂 Katya’s Mom was in a floor length stretch dress with no padding and hardly any makeup. Detox’s sister was painted the haus down and padded in the biggest heels with the strongest resemblance and the best overall look. She won hands down
I know Kahanna had some amazing looks on AS8 but considering she was second out on S11 and Darienne was top 4 of S6, plus Kasha is on your AS8 cast, there's no way production would cast Kahanna over Darienne.
You forget about the storyline where Kasha is besties [same family] with Darienne, why would they not have them on the same season? You know they milk that type of story.
Hi, so I have been watching you for a long time and I just want to say. I’m so proud of how much growth your channel has reached because I’ve been watching you since you had less than 500 subscribers and I’m so happy you got popular because I love your channel❤.
honestly the biggest thing i disagree with is Derrick not being top 2 in the improv challenge. yall can’t tell me she wouldn’t MURDER a challenge based on TMZ 💀
I strongly considered doing that, but it actually didn't change too much. Geneva plays hers in the ball and Mhi'ya sends home Hershii. Q plays hers in girl groups and Xunami/Plasma sends home Amanda
3:02 I completely disagree because you have to take into account the time that casting was taking place in. At the time, Milk was a huge fan favorite and was getting modeling jobs outside of the show. I hate to say it, but production definitely would've cut either Thorgy or Chi Chi because they both fit the same archetype as the season 8 top 5, or Morgan since she was a bit of a wild card.
A full season with Gia Gunn and a full season with Derrick Barry seems like a dream
dream for us, nightmare for the girls with gia, 'cause imagine
I still have such mixed feelings on Bebe returning on AS3. On one hand, it was amazing to see this legend of the franchise grace our screens once again. But one the other hand, they had to force the jury twist at the end for her to not be in the top 2 as they knew she would’ve destroyed Trixie in that final lip sync.
Someone else said this, but the jury twist was there to both stop Bebe from being the first two time winner and save Ru from having to eliminate her
Yea I think that was also a way for Bebe not being able to win without Ari having to eliminate her as a winner
@@marcusmelancon3426 ariyanka?
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudgedWhich honestly, IMO, Bebe was the deserving winner of that season. And before anyone tries to clock me on only saying this because of the Shangela controversy, girl I was in the trenches saying Bebe deserved to win when it released. She killed it!
@@azsazazsa I know how insanely controversial it is, but I stand by Trixie's win. She made it to the end with no favoritism, and realistically deserved 1 more win and 1 less bottom
I 100% would watch you rejudge 6 all stars seasons
I did that about a year ago, but I think I’ll do it again now that my microphone isn’t a potato
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged HELPP
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged 💀💀💀
Me too!
kylie not winning snatch game... is a choice!!
I felt production would pick the winner from each group. Also they were favoring Eureka all season
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudgedIn the episode they called out eureka for not having all her jokes land and Ru told Kylie she did amazing the following episode in the werkroom. Also it's the only snatch game of love where the snachelor specifically didn't pick anyone from the second group, and all of the other picks have been the top 2 of the episode. That's why I think Alexis would've won instead of jujubee also
Plus ginger and Kylie riffed off each other then whole time it's the season 7 winners all over again. With ginger as well which is funny
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudgedif they were really favoring Eureka, they would've given her her well deserved pink table talk win.
TKB robbed again!!!
Valentina not winning the Makeover or the Acting challenge is so infuriating
I would say she probably would deserve to win the makeover with Naomi, but I don’t think production would ever let that happen
Valentina takes forever to do her own makeup let alone her partner
2:21 Tatianna actually had a verse written for a Rumix and she ended up including it in one of her original songs (she said this in an interview)
Honestly I wanna watch you do this for the rest of the all star seasons ❤
As in rejudging every all stars season?
Yess!! I always find ur vids quite unique ❤❤❤
Katya over Detox who had the best makeover,
Y’all Katya fans are really delusional …
Me when my second favorite is someone else’s first favorite
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudgedI have to agree…. Detox murdered the makeover challenge
Detox did better from an aesthetics standpoint, but Katya was very entertaining, plus it's all about branding in Makeovers, or at least it's supposed to be. Katya's brand is Eastern European Communist camp, she followed that perfectly. That's not to say from an aesthetics POV she was even second best, she was more like third best, but her branding her looks so spot on definitely brought up her score. I'd honestly say, Detox and Katya tied because Katya did such a great job at branding, while Detox wore a nice dress that didn't automatically scream Detox. It wasn't out of character for Detox, but I think if she wore something slutty and neon with her sister, it would've translated even better for me.
@@itsgabbybtch5587 completely disagree with everything you just said 😂 Katya’s Mom was in a floor length stretch dress with no padding and hardly any makeup. Detox’s sister was painted the haus down and padded in the biggest heels with the strongest resemblance and the best overall look. She won hands down
I LOVE how you did this - you have the most solid and logical opinions on Drag Race UA-cam.
respectfully I disagree
Rajah with 5 wins feels correct
I know Kahanna had some amazing looks on AS8 but considering she was second out on S11 and Darienne was top 4 of S6, plus Kasha is on your AS8 cast, there's no way production would cast Kahanna over Darienne.
I factored in Kahanna’s work in drag race live. That’s what put her over Darienne
You forget about the storyline where Kasha is besties [same family] with Darienne, why would they not have them on the same season? You know they milk that type of story.
Kahanna wore a lot of the same.
Hi, so I have been watching you for a long time and I just want to say. I’m so proud of how much growth your channel has reached because I’ve been watching you since you had less than 500 subscribers and I’m so happy you got popular because I love your channel❤.
Thank you so much!
honestly the biggest thing i disagree with is Derrick not being top 2 in the improv challenge. yall can’t tell me she wouldn’t MURDER a challenge based on TMZ 💀
I could see her getting screwed by her desire to break way from Britney impersonation
All chopped queens could form their own AS seasons ❤
I love your closing slide.
"Do you want NON Emmy nominated gay shit?" 😅😅
Jimbo won the lipsync against Kandy, like, let’s be honest…
I would sit and watch you rejudge six seasons 😭
Based off the comments I’ve been getting today, that kind of thing may be on the horizon
Ongina and India should definitley swap in AS5 and also Kasha and James in AS8
I considered that, but I think that from production’s perspective, Ongina had a better reputation than India before the season
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged I think production care more about the drama hence why they casted both of them, in the first place.
Gia Gunn won her talent show episode
And Scarlet > Jan in the Talent Show lets be honest
If ur still making s16 vids you could do a what if Q and Geneva won the immunity potion cause it changes a lot I fear
I strongly considered doing that, but it actually didn't change too much. Geneva plays hers in the ball and Mhi'ya sends home Hershii. Q plays hers in girl groups and Xunami/Plasma sends home Amanda
@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged i could see Plasma MAYBE sending home Amanda but i don't think Xunami would stand a chance to Emergency
That’s fair, but in terms of performance skill I would put Xunami above Q, so I think she could be fine
3:02 I completely disagree because you have to take into account the time that casting was taking place in. At the time, Milk was a huge fan favorite and was getting modeling jobs outside of the show. I hate to say it, but production definitely would've cut either Thorgy or Chi Chi because they both fit the same archetype as the season 8 top 5, or Morgan since she was a bit of a wild card.
Where can I hear the full version of the AS2 rusical
ua-cam.com/video/fDbI-K9dKR0/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
In my French vanilla fantasy Valentina makes top 4 of all stars 4 😭
Gia not placing top on the talent show?
I doubt production would let her get a win in general, especially over someone like Trinity
Cutting james on all star 8 was a choice
Who would you have cut instead?
why does the twist only work with 8 people?
Naomi winning the rumix with her 5 word verse??
Exactly…out of the top 4 she had the worse verse to me
Sooo this does not implement the blocking scenario
Blocking was much harder to predict, and when I tried to do it, there was virtually no impact on the results
I think they would’ve cut kahana over Darinne ngl
Maybe, but I think Kahanna’s work on drag race live would push her over the edge
i don't see kylie beating Ginger in a lip sync, with Rajah it would come down to song
Kylie outperformed Ginger the one time they went head to head
What about all stars 1
Too much guesswork involved, but if I had to guess, Chad. AS1 only had 5 challenges, so I didn’t really have enough information
I’m the first comment
Is it an accomplishment to be the second comment on your own video?