I feel him. When I was a medic in Afghanistan I honestly knew if I died no one would care. I grew up in foster homes, didn’t have a girlfriend or kid. It’s not a good feeling knowing ur existence doesn’t mean anything to anyone
Your life means so much to the people that you saved in that shithole of a place. Because of you there are people alive today. Your life is meaningful my friend. Take care good sir.
Sanborn admits he needs a son and go back to a normal life while James has a life which Sanborn yearns for, yet Will returns back to war. Contrasting characters among soldiers. Strong message.
Agreed, Sanborn wants everything that Will has. Will obviously has love for his family, but deep down, he's a man that is terribly addicted to adrenaline. A man whose greatest love is the best high known to man, war. I knew guys like Will from my time in the Canadian Armed Forces. He's the guy that enlisted out of high school, and the military gave him purpose, the military turned him from an 18 year old boy into a man, and that way of life, his duty, is more important to him than his family. You can see Will simply doesn't know how to be a "civilian" anymore. He returns home and life is utterly meaningless to him, all he can think about is returning to the middle east. The scene where he's talking to his wife as they prep dinner, and he announces to her "you know.. they need more Bomb Tech's over there..". Almost like he was a child trying to ask permission from his mother to go to a friend's house. What a deep and complex character.
@@romilrh It’s not very well talked about in comparison to other war movies is the point. It was well received and is an incredible movie, but no one seems to bring it up in terms of other war movies, at least in my experience.
That's also what The Deer Hunter is partly about. Getting hooked to the rush of survival. Loosing the numb feeling of safety. Both films are genius portrayals of war ruining the lives of veterans and their loved ones.
@@theswagger3231 That feeling of safety isn't really numb to people who've fought in war. Its more just so out of touch and unfamiliar that they are scared of accepting that they are truly safe and don't have to worry anymore.
The saddest scene for me was at the end of the movie when he's talking to his infant son while they play and I realise what's going on in that head of his, and that he really doesn't want to be there.
That's the whole point in the creation of the VALKYRIES in Scandinavia. Women and children watch their loved ones seduced by her and most likely will never return. War...like the valkyrie, is a home wrecker.
Ironic (I guess) that the most impactful and powerful scene in a war film is in the form of a subdued car ride conversatoin.... Absolutely stunning turns by these two actors in this scene acting out Mark Boal's brilliant words. It just kills me when James asks Sanborn do you know why I am the way I am...
+Bruce Amwake Jr. More than agree. The realm into which James penetrates with his question is higher than ethics itself and, tragically, cannot be properly communicated - only lived and felt from inside. Probably the best scene in the history of cinema. (But one has to watch the entire film to understand it in all its strength.)
Igor Foukzon I love how you refer to this as the best scene in cinema history...! Thank you for the comment. Check out my film blog if you'd like. Still working on my review of 'The Hurt Locker" but there may be some other film reviews (on there) you're interested in reading. filmwake.com
I just watched this again and reread your comment; You are so right about James' question transcending ethics and other inner demons/emotions. The way he begins in an almost exhaustive voice saying, "...I don't know, JT..." The way his eyes flutter intimating vulnerability as he is talking always gets me!
Thank you, Bruce. There is always a moment of true grandeur when art manages (using Tarkovsky's words) to "legally touch the transcendent". Or, more likely - when the latter blesses us by occasionally reminding about itself through our imperfect mediums.
And I like how you - whether intentionally or not - put the ethical and the demonic in the same row. Our deepest rational intuitions ferociously protest it. The deepest religious - are only beginning to emerge at that point.
This scene is actually very sad because Sanborn says he's that no one will give a shit if he gets killed in the war zone. He even says that his parents don't help him out. Sanborn feels alone.
I dont think he means bad about his parent., Just that his parents don't count, as in you take your folks for granted they'll grieve you, but who else? what is your mark upon this world? what, or who is he is truly fighting for, on a personal level? That I think is what's going on in his mind.
The fucked up part is there's so much truth in what he said. The general public is so removed from war and all the worst parts of it that they almost always forget that these are real humans fighting and dying in it
If your a soldier you never forget that the people you served with are like family, like brothers and sisters. they care about you like if you were their own blood. even if it gets splattered on the battlefield.
This is a true example of war..very complex. You have one guy who wants to fight and has fought for our country but feels he has done enough and wants to be a Cilvian again and have a family one day..now he knows what wat feels like, now he wants a sense of normalcy..the other hand you have one guy who people would call him reckless or daredevil or crazy or death wish when in reality he just love war, the idea of war the meaning the mission and the risk of war, who has a family who waits him back at home..but in the cilvian world he feels lost or misplace even if he is married with a kid but at war he feels at peace and home like feeling like he is born there..definitely a message of 2 concepts. The day you born and the day you find out why you was born for..your purpose on God earth
Probably one of the top 5 deepest moments in war movie history. I never asked my brother about any of his battles on his 4 tours in Afghanistan, but I've heard my uncle's tell their friends about Vietnam and what they did and saw. I was probably 7 years old when I heard those stories.
Yep. Right now I'm actually on a spree of watching end scenes of movies I've already watched that give me goosebumps because of the message they convey and the background music. Just watched the last scenes of Rush and Inception before watching this one.
When he said "every time we go out, its life or death, you roll the dice" @ 2:41 I kinda understood the ending for "No country for old men", the villain (Anton's) obsession with flipping the coin and in the end he said "Thats how I got here"
Thats true for everyone that is born. All the sperms that could have lived and only one gets the chance and that happened every generation before you. Like a coin that was flipped with billion to one odds and it happened several times to get to you. In a way you got that lucky that one time.
same thing happened to me a few months back when i was in Japan. had no reason not to be happy. i believe that feeling is a deep primal urge. when your body realises you have no lineage, no one to keep a part of you alive when you're gone. don't waste away the little time you have left. find a bride, make a son, make a family. make a home. i believe nothing in this world is more fulfilling than a family. "i want a son."
I was a medic with the marines in Afghanistan...that monologue followed by a hard cut and now he's at a grocery store is the most powerful scene in the movie. if your a vet you so so now what this feels like
Why do you think james is a sociopath? He has a heart. You can clearly see when he was trying to save the man with c4 straped to his chest and also with Beckham. Sociopath are like psycopath, they dont have feelings of love and empathy.
don't you realize what motivated that behaviour was his adrenaline rush? but i guess u can buy the hero card all you want, no wonder you believe all the stigma about those conditions.
I wouldn’t come close to saying James is a sociopath. He’s an adrenaline junkie. As a fellow adrenaline junkie who used to do something that was dangerous but I loved, I can relate. I wasn’t in war but the job I did was dangerous and involved hanging off the sides of bridges while operating high pressure water jetting equipment. It was a grueling, miserable, nerve wracking job but I loved it. I travelled the country, saw interesting things, and now I’m home everyday doing the normal grind. I miss this job severely. I miss the guys I worked with, the places I went. I love my wife and son but I still feel like that excitement is missing. That’s why James can’t relate. Once you get used to getting your fix almost daily, it’s hard to return back to a normal existence.
Biologically speaking, can we see it as a human being scared so much that he feels very close to death, he then feels the urge to perpetuate his kind and have a child ?
Most of people will think that sgt james is some crazy adrenaline junkie who is addicted to war. But in fact that is wrong. Sgt james has found his meaning of life by helping people and save the innocent. Man without meaning in his life is most likely be unhealthy and will consistently suffers from life. But when you found the meaning of your own life, suffering isn't a suffering and death is not a big of a thing.
Living in that life...its easier. Survival is all ya worry about, it's all ya think about. One day to the next. You might come back you might not, but that's part of the job. It's something ya think about before ya enlist, something ya should think about. I sure as shit thought about it before I enlisted, but I did it anyway because someone has to do it when no one else will.
after seeing this scene with Sanborn i look back to the scene when Jame and him are drinking then when Sanborn gets laid in bed he asks James "do you think i got what it takes to wear the suit" and James tells him "hell no" that hurts so much more
It’s a very hard truth but we need emotionless people. We need surgeons, we need true soldiers, we need lawyers and judges. So they can do the things we can’t. As for everything else, we got it covered.
It's a Holiday. St. Patrick's Day. No matter what the situation is. Stop the nerves. Tell the truth about the game 4. Roll 11. Twins. I know you love him 💘.
I read somewhere that it was fairly common in Iraq to have people use kites as signals to insurgents to initiate attacks / report back if they were successful or not.
I felt like him this year living in Washington state if your a cyclist or pedestrian there you get killed by a drunkin driver or someone texting nobody would give a shit your dead. thank god I am not living in that state I love these scene.
How are you going to be complaining about how much you hate your life but in the same sentence talk about how you want a son. Humans are despicable pieces of shit if his life is so bad then why wouldn’t his sons life be just as bad God I can’t stand humans
I feel him. When I was a medic in Afghanistan I honestly knew if I died no one would care. I grew up in foster homes, didn’t have a girlfriend or kid. It’s not a good feeling knowing ur existence doesn’t mean anything to anyone
I hope things are better for you now
God bless you sir 🙏🏻
Thanks for your service.
I pray to God for your well being.
And I hope things are fine now.
Godspeed to you.
Your life means so much to the people that you saved in that shithole of a place. Because of you there are people alive today. Your life is meaningful my friend. Take care good sir.
Sorry to hear that
Your a real man and a good one
Sanborn admits he needs a son and go back to a normal life while James has a life which Sanborn yearns for, yet Will returns back to war. Contrasting characters among soldiers. Strong message.
Agreed, Sanborn wants everything that Will has.
Will obviously has love for his family, but deep down, he's a man that is terribly addicted to adrenaline. A man whose greatest love is the best high known to man, war. I knew guys like Will from my time in the Canadian Armed Forces. He's the guy that enlisted out of high school, and the military gave him purpose, the military turned him from an 18 year old boy into a man, and that way of life, his duty, is more important to him than his family.
You can see Will simply doesn't know how to be a "civilian" anymore. He returns home and life is utterly meaningless to him, all he can think about is returning to the middle east. The scene where he's talking to his wife as they prep dinner, and he announces to her "you know.. they need more Bomb Tech's over there..". Almost like he was a child trying to ask permission from his mother to go to a friend's house.
What a deep and complex character.
The most touching moment in the movie. Great
You miss war when you are home.. but once you are i war you miss home.
Maybe Sanborn should go to James house and take care of his wife and kids while James is out idk
@@lazyatthedisco Yeah, her pussies a little dry.
One day you're in a warzone constantly getting shot at and exploding bombs, a couple days later you're shopping for groceries.
it's crazy how life works sometimes
Underrated scene.
This scene as true as it can be
Me and Pappa Doc will battle anyone of you
One of the most underrated powerful war movie scenes of all time. Unbelievable acting.
Nothing wrong with loving what you do.
Did you just call a scene from a Best Picture winning film with a 95 on Metacritic "underrated"?
@@romilrh It’s not very well talked about in comparison to other war movies is the point. It was well received and is an incredible movie, but no one seems to bring it up in terms of other war movies, at least in my experience.
Falcon is having a mental breakdown here. and war junkie hawkeye has no ideia what to say to the poor guy.
Rui Fernandes and that is why Falcon joined the veteran therapy session as seen in Winter Soldier
This guy’s a gangsta? His real name’s Clarence.
Lou N 8 Mile reference because Anthony Mackie is in there too
Falcon and Hawkeye jajajaja
Please shut up
this is what the downside to being a war junkie would likely be. once the high goes away, you feel dead inside
That's also what The Deer Hunter is partly about. Getting hooked to the rush of survival. Loosing the numb feeling of safety. Both films are genius portrayals of war ruining the lives of veterans and their loved ones.
@@theswagger3231 That feeling of safety isn't really numb to people who've fought in war. Its more just so out of touch and unfamiliar that they are scared of accepting that they are truly safe and don't have to worry anymore.
The saddest scene for me was at the end of the movie when he's talking to his infant son while they play and I realise what's going on in that head of his, and that he really doesn't want to be there.
That's the whole point in the creation of the VALKYRIES in Scandinavia.
Women and children watch their loved ones seduced by her and most likely will never return. War...like the valkyrie, is a home wrecker.
Ironic (I guess) that the most impactful and powerful scene in a war film is in the form of a subdued car ride conversatoin....
Absolutely stunning turns by these two actors in this scene acting out Mark Boal's brilliant words.
It just kills me when James asks Sanborn do you know why I am the way I am...
+Bruce Amwake Jr. More than agree. The realm into which James penetrates with his question is higher than ethics itself and, tragically, cannot be properly communicated - only lived and felt from inside.
Probably the best scene in the history of cinema. (But one has to watch the entire film to understand it in all its strength.)
Igor Foukzon I love how you refer to this as the best scene in cinema history...!
Thank you for the comment.
Check out my film blog if you'd like. Still working on my review of 'The Hurt Locker" but there may be some other film reviews (on there) you're interested in reading.
filmwake.com
I just watched this again and reread your comment; You are so right about James' question transcending ethics and other inner demons/emotions. The way he begins in an almost exhaustive voice saying, "...I don't know, JT..."
The way his eyes flutter intimating vulnerability as he is talking always gets me!
Thank you, Bruce. There is always a moment of true grandeur when art manages (using Tarkovsky's words) to "legally touch the transcendent". Or, more likely - when the latter blesses us by occasionally reminding about itself through our imperfect mediums.
And I like how you - whether intentionally or not - put the ethical and the demonic in the same row. Our deepest rational intuitions ferociously protest it. The deepest religious - are only beginning to emerge at that point.
This scene is actually very sad because Sanborn says he's that no one will give a shit if he gets killed in the war zone. He even says that his parents don't help him out. Sanborn feels alone.
I dont think he means bad about his parent., Just that his parents don't count, as in you take your folks for granted they'll grieve you, but who else? what is your mark upon this world? what, or who is he is truly fighting for, on a personal level? That I think is what's going on in his mind.
Parents are supposed to love you so they don’t really count, this scene always hits me because besides my grandparents I have nothing too
My life is the same nobody except my parents but like he says your parents do but nobody else don't give a shit
The fucked up part is there's so much truth in what he said. The general public is so removed from war and all the worst parts of it that they almost always forget that these are real humans fighting and dying in it
Even some parents won't care. Sad fact.
Two users. One hitting rock bottom and wanting to change. One admitting he'll never change. And doesn't care.
If your a soldier you never forget that the people you served with are like family, like brothers and sisters. they care about you like if you were their own blood. even if it gets splattered on the battlefield.
This is a true example of war..very complex. You have one guy who wants to fight and has fought for our country but feels he has done enough and wants to be a Cilvian again and have a family one day..now he knows what wat feels like, now he wants a sense of normalcy..the other hand you have one guy who people would call him reckless or daredevil or crazy or death wish when in reality he just love war, the idea of war the meaning the mission and the risk of war, who has a family who waits him back at home..but in the cilvian world he feels lost or misplace even if he is married with a kid but at war he feels at peace and home like feeling like he is born there..definitely a message of 2 concepts. The day you born and the day you find out why you was born for..your purpose on God earth
They both avengers now lols
You marvel shitheads...
Probably one of the top 5 deepest moments in war movie history. I never asked my brother about any of his battles on his 4 tours in Afghanistan, but I've heard my uncle's tell their friends about Vietnam and what they did and saw. I was probably 7 years old when I heard those stories.
Which another 4 deepest moments?
This is the best scene I've seen in a movie in the whole world
louis Garraway no
Yep. Right now I'm actually on a spree of watching end scenes of movies I've already watched that give me goosebumps because of the message they convey and the background music. Just watched the last scenes of Rush and Inception before watching this one.
I mean it's a good scene, but best? That's a strong word when it comes to films
Shows you why war is hell and why we should thank these men and women.
along with this music, this is defiantly one of the most emotional scenes I've seen in a movie.
Falcon/Captain America and Hawkeye having a heart to heart...and then shopping with the Wasp!
Every superhero has to start somewhere.
When he said "every time we go out, its life or death, you roll the dice" @ 2:41 I kinda understood the ending for "No country for old men", the villain (Anton's) obsession with flipping the coin and in the end he said "Thats how I got here"
Thats true for everyone that is born. All the sperms that could have lived and only one gets the chance and that happened every generation before you. Like a coin that was flipped with billion to one odds and it happened several times to get to you. In a way you got that lucky that one time.
Sitting at a lodge in a sky resort, drunk, should be having the time of my life. This part came to mind, I want a son.
same thing happened to me a few months back when i was in Japan. had no reason not to be happy. i believe that feeling is a deep primal urge. when your body realises you have no lineage, no one to keep a part of you alive when you're gone. don't waste away the little time you have left. find a bride, make a son, make a family. make a home. i believe nothing in this world is more fulfilling than a family.
"i want a son."
Do you have son now? It's been while 😅
Jeremy Renner looks SO YOUNG in this scene.
he's about 37 here
Best scene in the entire movie
I was a medic with the marines in Afghanistan...that monologue followed by a hard cut and now he's at a grocery store is the most powerful scene in the movie. if your a vet you so so now what this feels like
That's why I love being a E.O.D operator. Thank you for posting it, keep me doing my job and saving people and military life's some body got to do it.
Thank you for your service.
Tony Rodriguez what unit you with?
Loved*
You got a bf3 pfp you aint no EOD operator
This scenes is about as accurate as you can get to a regular person trying to relate to a sociopath
Why do you think james is a sociopath? He has a heart. You can clearly see when he was trying to save the man with c4 straped to his chest and also with Beckham. Sociopath are like psycopath, they dont have feelings of love and empathy.
don't you realize what motivated that behaviour was his adrenaline rush? but i guess u can buy the hero card all you want, no wonder you believe all the stigma about those conditions.
I wouldn’t come close to saying James is a sociopath. He’s an adrenaline junkie. As a fellow adrenaline junkie who used to do something that was dangerous but I loved, I can relate. I wasn’t in war but the job I did was dangerous and involved hanging off the sides of bridges while operating high pressure water jetting equipment. It was a grueling, miserable, nerve wracking job but I loved it. I travelled the country, saw interesting things, and now I’m home everyday doing the normal grind. I miss this job severely. I miss the guys I worked with, the places I went. I love my wife and son but I still feel like that excitement is missing. That’s why James can’t relate. Once you get used to getting your fix almost daily, it’s hard to return back to a normal existence.
Dialogue not monologue
Biologically speaking, can we see it as a human being scared so much that he feels very close to death, he then feels the urge to perpetuate his kind and have a child ?
True warrior, not many left
One of my favorite parts, thanks for uploading
Sanborn has a Girlfriend,who wants child,james have a wife n kid,but they are divorced but live together
Most of people will think that sgt james is some crazy adrenaline junkie who is addicted to war. But in fact that is wrong. Sgt james has found his meaning of life by helping people and save the innocent.
Man without meaning in his life is most likely be unhealthy and will consistently suffers from life.
But when you found the meaning of your own life, suffering isn't a suffering and death is not a big of a thing.
Should have been nominated for Best Supporting Oscar. He was superb through this entire film.
Supporting Actor*
the most incredible acting i’ve ever seen
Living in that life...its easier. Survival is all ya worry about, it's all ya think about. One day to the next. You might come back you might not, but that's part of the job. It's something ya think about before ya enlist, something ya should think about. I sure as shit thought about it before I enlisted, but I did it anyway because someone has to do it when no one else will.
- How you do it, man ?
- It's simple. I'm a sociopath.
Pretty much. He doesn't fear death, he welcomes it.
"The point is, everybody go through a stretch where folks gonna die on you... just don't meditate on it." -Marcus
I never knew Hawkeye and Sam were together.
And Wasp 😂
Yep, gonna go watch this movie now Devante😂
Anthony Mackie is one of the greatest black actors ever
You join to serve, you become a killing machine, you have all your human feelings but to many leave GOD OUT OF THE EQUATION ✝️🙏🇺🇸☠️
es mi parte favorita de la peli muy buena de las mejores de guerra que he visto
after seeing this scene with Sanborn i look back to the scene when Jame and him are drinking then when Sanborn gets laid in bed he asks James "do you think i got what it takes to wear the suit" and James tells him "hell no" that hurts so much more
*American Eagle & Eagle Eye Share An Existential Crisis Experience*
Hawkeye, Falcon and the Wasp at the end on the same movie
Chio Chan Genocide ikr!? I hope we see them together in Avengers 4 too... lots of talent
Just stfu with these stupid comparisons. Are you really so fucking lost?
Anthony Mackie killed it in this movie. Excellent film even with the slight inaccuracies.
The Falcon and Hawkeye Military Days!
nothing was the same ever since he got bodied by eminem
What
Lmao
You know why, I am the way I am?
Nah I don't.
''Because I love this job.''
Had to look at this to see him playing as Kovacs in Altered Carbon Season 2.....so excited NOW I think he can pull it off💯
the song kickin in at the end is called "Goodnight Bastard - Hurt Locker"
This is what Hawkeye, Falcon and Wasp has been doing before joining the Avengers.
Laughing at the kids throwing rocks at the humvee, future insurgents.
I wasn't a fan of this movie, but this scene was fucking excellent... Fucking goosebump inducing acting from both of them!
I guess,it looks as real as it can look for a movie.
After hearing him talk I go back to the kite part
It’s a very hard truth but we need emotionless people. We need surgeons, we need true soldiers, we need lawyers and judges. So they can do the things we can’t. As for everything else, we got it covered.
It's a Holiday. St. Patrick's Day. No matter what the situation is. Stop the nerves. Tell the truth about the game 4. Roll 11. Twins. I know you love him 💘.
These are the days of Elijah
i love love love this film. Fucking love it. Hollywood producers - make more such movies, pls!! We'll pay!!!! :)
This movie was so much better than avatar
Great scene in just an outstanding movie .
When i see this scene... I hate myselft 🥺..
If you haven't seen it, *watch it!*
These are The days of Elijah
0:24-0:25, 0:38, 0:58, 1:18, 1:39-1:41, 2:20-2:30, 3:02, 3:14-3:39, 3:50, 3:54-3:59
One good man to love us better than we met many million man betrayed us? Right?
Clint and Sam go way back.
Technically a duologue…
The parking brake light is on.
Masterfully written scene
It's funny how the kid on the roof is just flying a kite after a bomb just detonated killing a man
It may be a message.
I read somewhere that it was fairly common in Iraq to have people use kites as signals to insurgents to initiate attacks / report back if they were successful or not.
I am 100th subscriber bro......keep going full support..... Aplod full army movies.....
Certains sont faits pour la guerre, d'autres non...
Kshatriya and shudra.
Fantastic
Diria el negro de pulp fiction: tuve una revelación
Sanborn: O Thanos estalou o dedo o fodeu o Universo
I said I am Black then the mongtagnard beated me terribly in vn. What I must do now in others you love me?
On a funny and friendly note man on right side looks like Jon Jones from UFC?
Haha he does, looks like the Jon Jones who beat Shogun Rua. Young bones Jones.
Why you must loyalty to the one against humanity like me?
What did he drink
vodka and orange juice
Dialogue
Hi
There is an error for the audio when it plays for me.
Does anyone know what song is being played here? Thanks!
they need to make this an anime
جميل
O Danny boy
113
⚜️⚜️⚜️
I felt like him this year living in Washington state if your a cyclist or pedestrian there you get killed by a drunkin driver or someone texting nobody would give a shit your dead. thank god I am not living in that state I love these scene.
115
no audio
Trump feed you ?
This what War does to a Man !
How are you going to be complaining about how much you hate your life but in the same sentence talk about how you want a son. Humans are despicable pieces of shit if his life is so bad then why wouldn’t his sons life be just as bad God I can’t stand humans
115