It's such a paradox that even though Edith is quite talented and unique in her own way, has better vocals than Alice(IMHO) she doesn't seem as impressive as Alice was when she was in CC. It's something intangible and inexplicable that Alice had, this crazy energy, I'd say even something childish and ingenuous about her. You can't copy it or fake it. Edith seems a bit forced regardless of her great stage presence and voice. I can't help but miss the band in it's initial lineup. Edith has a great potential, hope she will be successful without CC, as well as Alice. Ethan needs to get what he deserves.
She doesn’t have a great voice either. Not to mention that this is electro punk so what Alice was doing with her voice was the right thing to do. Edith can’t even scream right if that makes sense? She tries to scream and sing at the same time and it sounds very wrong. Her voice is just not good for electro punk and her stage presence is forced and poser like
@@walkingwounded8675 I don't feel that way about my stage performances at all. I would've adjusted the sound board a little & in my defense I was only 3 & sometimes they needle popped me before a show so I wouldn't remember & that messed me up too
How can you not compare the two? Only one of them truly has talent and the other is a hack trying to imitate something original.. Ethan should have called it quits when Alice left and not embarrass CC's legacy
Edith jamás sera Alice glass gracias a Alice glass Crystal castle seguía en la cima pero cuando se fue ella quedó en tremendo flop que tuvo que recurrir a una copia barata de Alice para salir de ese flop 😂
@@blackpinkpavedtheway128La música de Alice sin Ethan es muy distinta a CC, en cambio Ethan y Edith SON Crystal Castles, despues de tantos años se ve que la pieza fundamental siempre fue Ethan
Me gistan mas los gritos de alice y su baile tetrico en los escenarios, pero tenia bajo rendimiento que no podia cantar cnaciones completas algo que edith si puede hacer, se avento todas las rolas y las canta increibles (en vivo)
Because with needle popped me & even stalked me opening a church with some money they stole from me. I was only 3 & they were jealous & kid napped me. They killed my parents when I was a baby & some singers picked me up when I was an infant & teach me to sing. People started bugging out figuring over getting my money & how to get rid of me. Our music isn't the same kind. My music wasn't about love life it's about my parents dying they're so arrogant
@@jhace158anos6 raro que con edith no, LOL te mintieron, ethan nunca pago carcel y el la encontro casi en la calle, le dio la oportunidad de la vida, y cuando queria 100% de los masters por algo que no se merecia, decidio atacarlo de esa forma.
@@kurtsenpai4757me gusta lo que hace musicalmente Ethan, pero la mayoría de versiones dicen que Ethan la estuvo siguiendo por tiempo a Alice para poder formar el grupo, no fue casualidad, la estaba stalkeando, lo mismo que hizo con Edith ya que ella tenía contacto con Alice antes de estar en CC
@@andrevr8317desapareció tras la polémica de Ethan, la ex esposa de Ethan ha dicho que están viviendo juntos actualmente pero no se sabe nada de el ni de edith
De las pocos conciertos que mejor sonido y presentación tuvo Crystal Castle tiene potenciales pero no lo explotan al máximo es una buena banda estilo único pero le falta más
alices vocals, presence and moves on stage is better than ediths. i like some of her songs though. its like i’m watching some cheap rock star instead of crystal castles yknow. but shes still good in her own way, not the same way as alice in crystal castles. damn i just realized nobody asked me that😂 i am extremely high
As a person that isnt in thw genre. I saw both of them preformz They just look to me like 2 white crackheads or pill heads. Idk what you talking bout. *oH sHeS nOt LiKe AlIcE* lmfao kids what can i say
Can people stop comparing Alice with Edith? It's getting annoying since both of them are good. People use the point "Alice was so much more energetic on stage" which is complete bullshit considering that she was drunk most of time during live performances. Edith is just ok, she is doing he best. It's ok to miss Alice but just hating on this poor woman for no reason other than your yearning is not good
PEPE DIAZ DE LOS ANTROS CLASICO POR MI BELINDA NO TE PREOCUPES NO TE CASTIGARE PERO ESA EIZA GONZALES TEN CUIDADO NO SE SU RAYO GEMELO QUE TE HARA ANTONIO MARTINEZ APARICIO 1995 MANZANILLO
Alice has a better voice for this type of music or for what in her beginning was CC. I see Edith's voice more like rock. I'm not saying that Alice has a better voice, I'm just saying that Edith's voice should be in another genre of music.
So the female, she uses a voice distortion electronic thingie. And that thing can make your voice sound like anything you want... so basically anyone could do what she's doing?
no puedes comparar a Alice con Edith , es obvio que Alice es mucho mejor , y no estoy diciendo que Edith sea mala , básicamente edith es buena pero Alice es buenísima
Alice was fearless, and that energy might never come back. Hopefully Edith starts being herself instead of Alice's replacement.. you can't replace raw energy.
Alice has a better voice, because she could sing quiet, relaxing songs like Celestica or sing songs, giving her all on stage like Alice Practice, two things that Edith could never match.
Setlist of Crystal Castles | Reading Festival 2016 - Aug 26, 2016
01 00:32 Concrete
02 04:21 Fleece
03 08:09 Baptism
04 12:07 Suffocation
05 15:36 Intimate
06 20:19 Enth
07 24:30 Crimewave
08 29:02 Frail
09 31:46 Celestica
10 35:37 Not in Love
These drums are incredible
That drumming is 🔥
Fr 🔥
The part where Concrete ends and Fleece begins is amazing.
She looks possessed, so haunted, love it
punk + electronic = magic
It's such a paradox that even though Edith is quite talented and unique in her own way, has better vocals than Alice(IMHO) she doesn't seem as impressive as Alice was when she was in CC. It's something intangible and inexplicable that Alice had, this crazy energy, I'd say even something childish and ingenuous about her. You can't copy it or fake it. Edith seems a bit forced regardless of her great stage presence and voice. I can't help but miss the band in it's initial lineup.
Edith has a great potential, hope she will be successful without CC, as well as Alice. Ethan needs to get what he deserves.
La neta Edith hace un buen trabjo
@@Christoof4 I'm sorry, I don't speak Spanish :)
She doesn’t have a great voice either. Not to mention that this is electro punk so what Alice was doing with her voice was the right thing to do. Edith can’t even scream right if that makes sense? She tries to scream and sing at the same time and it sounds very wrong. Her voice is just not good for electro punk and her stage presence is forced and poser like
You’re right Alice was terrible live
@@walkingwounded8675 I don't feel that way about my stage performances at all. I would've adjusted the sound board a little & in my defense I was only 3 & sometimes they needle popped me before a show so I wouldn't remember & that messed me up too
Everyone talks bad about Edith, she's so good, stop comparing her to Alice, they're both different people. 😢
Fair enough
How can you not compare the two? Only one of them truly has talent and the other is a hack trying to imitate something original.. Ethan should have called it quits when Alice left and not embarrass CC's legacy
Dude what are you talking about? I thought Amnesty was an amazing album, and I've been following them since their first self-titled.@@sleepyCat1111
go listen to Sadist and Chloroform off that album and come back and tell me that's not good as fuck@@sleepyCat1111
edith is in a romantic relationship with kath as of 2020, fuck her.
This Intimate performance is amazing!!!
Nunca me harán odiarte Edith, ni compararte con Alice, las amo a ambas y ambas son auténticas así digan lo que quieran hah.
Dios por favor solo te pido que antes de morir me dejes estar ahi
Legendary 🤩
Me sorprende lo bien que lo hace Edith incluso alice se quedaba callada y solo cantaba por momentos
Edith jamás sera Alice glass gracias a Alice glass Crystal castle seguía en la cima pero cuando se fue ella quedó en tremendo flop que tuvo que recurrir a una copia barata de Alice para salir de ese flop 😂
@@blackpinkpavedtheway128 0 que ver amiga, el que levanto crystal castles sin duda fueron alice y ethan pero ethan fue la pieza fundamental
@@blackpinkpavedtheway128La música de Alice sin Ethan es muy distinta a CC, en cambio Ethan y Edith SON Crystal Castles, despues de tantos años se ve que la pieza fundamental siempre fue Ethan
Love the antiquate 🖤💜
Thanks for uploading, commenting just to help your metrics
12:07 ¿Qué efecto usa en la voz?
Me gistan mas los gritos de alice y su baile tetrico en los escenarios, pero tenia bajo rendimiento que no podia cantar cnaciones completas algo que edith si puede hacer, se avento todas las rolas y las canta increibles (en vivo)
Because with needle popped me & even stalked me opening a church with some money they stole from me. I was only 3 & they were jealous & kid napped me. They killed my parents when I was a baby & some singers picked me up when I was an infant & teach me to sing. People started bugging out figuring over getting my money & how to get rid of me. Our music isn't the same kind. My music wasn't about love life it's about my parents dying they're so arrogant
Estaba drogada y alcohilizada por Ethan, tu que crees que iba a pasar?
@@jhace158anos6 raro que con edith no, LOL te mintieron, ethan nunca pago carcel y el la encontro casi en la calle, le dio la oportunidad de la vida, y cuando queria 100% de los masters por algo que no se merecia, decidio atacarlo de esa forma.
@@kurtsenpai4757creo que conoces un poco mal la historia
@@kurtsenpai4757me gusta lo que hace musicalmente Ethan, pero la mayoría de versiones dicen que Ethan la estuvo siguiendo por tiempo a Alice para poder formar el grupo, no fue casualidad, la estaba stalkeando, lo mismo que hizo con Edith ya que ella tenía contacto con Alice antes de estar en CC
why the crowd is so fucking dead at the front
duhh
Como puede aun gustarme su música y sentirme culpable
No tienes pq sentirte culpable
yo separo el arte del artista ya fue
@@witches3412asi es, lo que haya hecho Ethan como persona no quita lo que hizo en la música
The evolution of Crystal Castles is very notable
This takes me back to the smell of college
This is hyped!!
Legendary, love Edith 😍
Que publico mas FRIO
Can't hold a candle to Alice
Bravaaazo! La Edith me la sube como MRDDDDA! 🤘😎
Edith literalmente la rompió toda! Sabes si está en otra banda o algo?
@@andrevr8317desapareció tras la polémica de Ethan, la ex esposa de Ethan ha dicho que están viviendo juntos actualmente pero no se sabe nada de el ni de edith
This is like Sabbath with Dio rather than with Ozzy. No one can out-Ozzy Ozzy, but…
Why even compare them?
You are so right
The bands right there too
If you asked me. She's right there
amo mtmt
Needs more reverb-
15:38
Edith you are the best! That performance was TOP NOTCH! 10/10
De las pocos conciertos que mejor sonido y presentación tuvo Crystal Castle tiene potenciales pero no lo explotan al máximo es una buena banda estilo único pero le falta más
Bro crees que algún día se vuelvan a juntar? Sus presentaciones son increíbles; con un estilo realmente único como comentaste.
suffocation was beautiful tho
Celestica es todo lo que esta bien ..tremendo rolon , arteeeeee
🔥🔥🔥
I want to be on CC performance
alices vocals, presence and moves on stage is better than ediths. i like some of her songs though. its like i’m watching some cheap rock star instead of crystal castles yknow. but shes still good in her own way, not the same way as alice in crystal castles. damn i just realized nobody asked me that😂 i am extremely high
dont compare them 😉
Not in love is way better with Alice
Para nada
She can't sing
As a person that isnt in thw genre. I saw both of them preformz They just look to me like 2 white crackheads or pill heads. Idk what you talking bout. *oH sHeS nOt LiKe AlIcE* lmfao kids what can i say
where is this concert?
Isso soa muito como um nirvana eletrônico.
Can people stop comparing Alice with Edith? It's getting annoying since both of them are good. People use the point "Alice was so much more energetic on stage" which is complete bullshit considering that she was drunk most of time during live performances. Edith is just ok, she is doing he best. It's ok to miss Alice but just hating on this poor woman for no reason other than your yearning is not good
You have any more dj set videos
Nice
One day Edith will speak her truth about what Ethan did to her.
she's complicit, read autumn's account
@@meravkleinmann3930 oh that's very sad. Can you send through a link?
@@meravkleinmann3930 wdym?
@@makemevomitblood They mean that Edith is in Ethan's mansion enjoying money together. That's at least what Ethan's ex wife claimed...
wheres ethan now?@@lifeisadickjoke
FALTA USTED Y SU SACRIFICIO BELINDA Y PEPE DIAZ
ES DYE FANTASY 3 VERDE ES LA SUPER-CRIPTONITA-PLATA
NO ES LO IMPERFECTO MI PROBLEMA MI PROBLEMA ES EL DOLOR Y LO QUE TE LIMITA
видно что человек устал, но вынужден играть свою роль
28:56
as much as i dont want to like edith in crystal castles that f-117 shirt is badass
edith wasn't even bad
I think im suffering from epilepsy
Hermoso 💚
Baptism, suena mucho mejor¡¡¡
PEPE DIAZ DE LOS ANTROS CLASICO POR MI BELINDA NO TE PREOCUPES NO TE CASTIGARE PERO ESA EIZA GONZALES TEN CUIDADO NO SE SU RAYO GEMELO QUE TE HARA
ANTONIO MARTINEZ APARICIO 1995 MANZANILLO
Valid
e
last song please?
Not In Love
@@lcoaps258 thank you
🥱
she's trying to be alice so bad,..
? its crystal castles what do you expect? both are great and i would argue edith has a much better and versatile voice that fits CC perfectly
As a woman how would u join a bad with him knowing what u did and probably still does?
oh idk maybe cause he didn't do anything
@ get help Claudio!
Alice has a better voice for this type of music or for what in her beginning was CC. I see Edith's voice more like rock. I'm not saying that Alice has a better voice, I'm just saying that Edith's voice should be in another genre of music.
having a seizure watching this
Why don't they just cover more Platinum Blonde songs?
You can't copy Alice personality on stage. Edith sounds a bit forced to me.
You don't get it
Do you?
Nah she’s great
So the female, she uses a voice distortion electronic thingie. And that thing can make your voice sound like anything you want... so basically anyone could do what she's doing?
She just use effects in some songs
I just think that Alice has more angst and pent up emotions than edith. the rawness is missing
Alice era mas desordenada que la chucha para cantar. Edith es mucho mejor.
no puedes comparar a Alice con Edith , es obvio que Alice es mucho mejor , y no estoy diciendo que Edith sea mala , básicamente edith es buena pero Alice es buenísima
Edith es mucho mejor, en todo sentido. Mejor voz, mejor performance.
nunca sera alice
???
Edith tiene su propio estilo
Music is good. "Singing" SUCKS!! No mic control and way off key.
I like how Edith doesn't use the vocoda as much. Like on baptism
Defently not for epilektia
Ella sólo quiere parecerse a Alice
ella es la cantante principal pionera de crystal castle que hablas hermano
@@joseenriquelauracondori0 la principal era alice esta no es
shes better 🤗
Must be weird for her to sing songs Alice wrote.
the crowd is NOT LIT
Это так ужасно, что даже прекрасно.
Alice was fearless...this is just a cheap actress.
Alice was fearless, and that energy might never come back. Hopefully Edith starts being herself instead of Alice's replacement.. you can't replace raw energy.
@@FinnnAndJakeAlice was a 3 year old & those pedo chicks hated her they're so jealous they tried to murder her in child porn
Sorry ist Sounds schit😂😂
sounds fake without Alice you cant fuxkin fool me its my favourite band cc is d3ad forever.
I'm in love with Edith, better than Alice my opinion
im love with her until now 😢
Ethan has given her so many drugs and it's shows as he did with Alice... But Edith is not even in tune she just sounds wasted and it's sad
Ethan should be in jail
What did Ethan do?
I think everyone is talking about the wrong Ethan
Get out of there you sick man
she is a way better performer than Alice
That is Alice isn't it
@@jopa6616 It s Edith.
On the other side though Alice had the better voice
@@BasileosHerodou no she doesn’t, have you seen her live? She sounds nothing like she does on the records
@@israelmaldonado2928 I think you're confusing her with Edith
Que feo suena sin Alice
pasa la pagina
#wesupportethankath
omg edith vocals were horrible. just screaming
This crow sucks
EDITH IS BETTER THAN ALICE . Better Performance & Better Voice.Period.
No and no
Alice has a better voice, because she could sing quiet, relaxing songs like Celestica or sing songs, giving her all on stage like Alice Practice, two things that Edith could never match.
DIOS DE TODO EL METAL HA APARECIDO !
CAUTION !
Leprechaun (film series)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leprechaun_(film_series)
calla