My highschool band it wouldn't have been the trumpets fighting. It would have been the trombones. Senior Year we got a new freshman, son of the Vice Principal, and he thought he was hot shit because he was 2nd chair and I was 3rd (by choice). I was the only one of us that had a bass trombone and I was taking the low parts because they had notes the little pissant couldn't hit.
as a flute player, we hate the trumpets and will do anything to steal the melody from them (we also complain to the band teacher that they're WAY too loud)
@@taylor_ack I'm a trumpet player, and I actually can't ever hear the flutes play, unless no else is playing. Also, you shouldn't need to tell the band director that the trumpets are playing too loud, since they always tell us to be quieter. And about us stealing the melody, well, I actually feel like the flutes always have the melody, and the trumpets rarely have it (unless it's a marching band song, then we have always the melody). Of course it could just be the songs my band director picks out anyway.
now we gotta see 2 percussionists getting into an argument that would for sure be chaotic. just imagining that the whole percussion section would get into the argument and it would just become pure madness
The *BRASS ATTACK* portion evokes this feeling in me that I cannot explain. As a trombonist, I think it's the low notes that makes me c- I mean enjoy this song
honestly, the part where the horns and tuba entered sounded good. A school near mine had a part that sounded like that in their marching show this past fall.
Now I want to see two French Horns get in an argument! I am a natural French Horn player, and I’d be grateful to see a “Two French Horns Get In An Argument” vid.
That was a really good sequel piece that you’ve made! I noticed that you use the brass section sounds instead of the solo Brass. By the way, can you please now compose a composition titled “2 harps get into an argument?”
Harpist here, just trying to imagine how that would go. Lots of big low rolled chords, glisses and arpeggios, maybe a harmonics battle of who can play faster without going back down the octave, oh and who can change key faster or further without missing a lever if they're lever harps. Plus tapping rhythms on the soundboard with the left hand interspersed with everything else. A rather quieter battle, but just as intense. Though given the difficulty of finding another harpist in-person to have a played argument with, you might end up arguing with yourself.
I’m pretty sure if two flutes got into an argument they would just play the highest, most piercing notes possible at each other until everyone went deaf
This is exactly how it goes in high school band, except for the two trumpets don’t realize that they can’t actually hit the notes that they think they’re hitting.
This is like my friendly rivalry between me (1st chair) and my friend that is second chair Edit: help I can’t stop listening to 1:46 to the end it’s too good
As a trumpet player, I can say this is accurate. Trumpet players have this bipolar personality with each other. We can be the best of friends one moment and literally hate each others existence the next. But no matter what happens, there is one thing we trumpets (and brass) can agree on: Woodwinds will forever be our enemies. When it comes down to it, we will always unite to fight off the Wooden Ones.
I imagined the (two) trumpets in my band doing this, and continued to imagine everyone else who plays each instrument with their parts. We don’t have cool horns to do the beginning “fight fight fight” part so in my mind it was me and the other saxophones
RIGHT HERE! I would gladly hit someone over the head with my slide if it meant they played A flat instead of A natural in Highlights From Harry Potter. *cough cough my friend who sits next to me in band*
As a trombonist, I would like to state it would be over stupid things. For example: "Hey, Its A flat, not A natural." "K" "Dude, Were in E flat key, I just said its A flat, not A natural." "Sorry" "WHY WONT YOU LISTEN TO ME ITS A FLAT NOT A NATURAL!!!!!" "chill the fuck out dude" "YOURE GOING TO GET KICKED OUT IF YOU DONT PLAY THIS NOTE RIGHT." thank you for reading this dramatic re-enactment of me and my friend's argument over 'Highlights From Harry Potter'.
This and the clarinet argument are my favorite videos of all time
I gotta see 2 oboes getting into an argument about who should be the tune setter
this guys my band teacher😎
Knowing my band, the horns and tuba would be playing as the trumpets throw their instruments to the ground and get into a fistfight.
throwing your instruments to the floor will get you removed for the rest of the performance
AND THE CLARINETS WOULD GET KNOCKED OUT BECAUSE THEY TRIED TO BE NICE 😂😂😂
My highschool band it wouldn't have been the trumpets fighting. It would have been the trombones. Senior Year we got a new freshman, son of the Vice Principal, and he thought he was hot shit because he was 2nd chair and I was 3rd (by choice). I was the only one of us that had a bass trombone and I was taking the low parts because they had notes the little pissant couldn't hit.
This is why, as a clarinet player, the trumpet section is my mortal enemy
Guess you gotta avoid me.
(Btw, my sister plays clarinet, and I play trumpet, so...)
as a flute player, we hate the trumpets and will do anything to steal the melody from them (we also complain to the band teacher that they're WAY too loud)
@@taylor_ack I'm a trumpet player, and I actually can't ever hear the flutes play, unless no else is playing. Also, you shouldn't need to tell the band director that the trumpets are playing too loud, since they always tell us to be quieter. And about us stealing the melody, well, I actually feel like the flutes always have the melody, and the trumpets rarely have it (unless it's a marching band song, then we have always the melody). Of course it could just be the songs my band director picks out anyway.
Trombone player here they are my enemy too
I’m a clarinet player and my bestie plays trumpet and she’s the only exception
disappointed, theres no annoying sax interrupting with careless whisper
That's so accurate 😂
as a saxophone player I confirm that this is very accurate
lol i play sax
thats me 🤣
The sax probably saw what happened to the clarinets and decided not to get involved.
As a trumpet I can confirm this is 100% true
Same
yussss
as another trumpet i can back his statement
Bro now you gotta do when 2 percussionists get in an argument, literally committing arson
yes please do
I don’t wanna even hear the bass drum-😂😂😂
@@ThatOneChorusKidSnare gonna rupture our ear *drums.*
@@thefunny1250 I’ll *reed* up on good earplugs to prevent that…
Trumpets in my band are most likely to commit arson
now we gotta see 2 percussionists getting into an argument
that would for sure be chaotic.
just imagining that the whole percussion section would get into the argument and it would just become pure madness
I can confirm that that would indeed be chaos
The timpanis would for sure provoke it. I imagine the kazoo would be that one guy that isn’t supposed to be there but just is
bro playing e^5/4 polyrhythms
As a Percussionist, I can agree with this.
I remember band a lot from last year, it was always so fun to beat ppl up using the sticks 😂
**excessively loud and violent cymbal rolling**
indeed, us tubists always condone high brass violence
So do us trombonists
@@Monochrome_Monoboy true
On that 8th position grind
@@Ferrothorn462 FRFR
The *BRASS ATTACK* portion evokes this feeling in me that I cannot explain. As a trombonist, I think it's the low notes that makes me c- I mean enjoy this song
Ayo 🤨
This is not just a song, it's a masterpiece!
I lost it when the tuba entered LMAO
honestly, the part where the horns and tuba entered sounded good. A school near mine had a part that sounded like that in their marching show this past fall.
The trombones would definitely be either recording or just standing there.
This is very good but confused and scared good job
I love how the exclamation point sounded exactly right.
I love these for the pure chaos.
The Arutunian Concerto motif is a nice touch
Was wondering if anyone else noticed 😂
As a tuba I can say..
This is very accurate 😂
Now I want to see two French Horns get in an argument! I am a natural French Horn player, and I’d be grateful to see a “Two French Horns Get In An Argument” vid.
That was a really good sequel piece that you’ve made! I noticed that you use the brass section sounds instead of the solo Brass. By the way, can you please now compose a composition titled “2 harps get into an argument?”
Harpist here, just trying to imagine how that would go. Lots of big low rolled chords, glisses and arpeggios, maybe a harmonics battle of who can play faster without going back down the octave, oh and who can change key faster or further without missing a lever if they're lever harps. Plus tapping rhythms on the soundboard with the left hand interspersed with everything else. A rather quieter battle, but just as intense. Though given the difficulty of finding another harpist in-person to have a played argument with, you might end up arguing with yourself.
I gotta see 2 oboes getting into an argument about who should be the tune setter
@@Yello96486 I need to see saxes, bassoons, or percussion-
The ending was very well crafted!
Can you do "2 flutes get into an argument?" I'm a flutist, and I'd love to see 2 argue.
Me too
for something like that, it would have to be set to the theme from Carmen
Flautist
Sorry
@@vincentfreddoyle7555 Flautist
Yes
I’m pretty sure if two flutes got into an argument they would just play the highest, most piercing notes possible at each other until everyone went deaf
This is exactly how it goes in high school band, except for the two trumpets don’t realize that they can’t actually hit the notes that they think they’re hitting.
NOT THE CLARKE STUDY 😂😂
0:46: you hear that? It's the beat of war, AND the sound of battle
0:51 the knight horns! Sounds like real life chess
trombone arguement
please
*i beg of you, as a trombonist*
I LOVE EVERY THING ABOUT THIS!!!! If you'll allow it, I'll try to play this on my senior recital!
I desperately need this to be performed on a stage and have the instrument players act out the story as they play
As a tuba player, I was very surprised to see a tuba in here, however it was a great addition!
you should do a bassoon gets into an argument with the whole band because why not
I'm not saying it'd be better in string instruments, but I AM saying that a string version would be MUCH appreciated! Love the work you do!
all i care about, as a trumpet player, is proving to all clarinets i'm better then them. ❤️
Ah yes, the brass section united under one common goal - outplaying the woodwinds
This is like my friendly rivalry between me (1st chair) and my friend that is second chair
Edit: help I can’t stop listening to 1:46 to the end it’s too good
I agree brooooo :)
as a trombone player, brass power ingaged
As a trumpet player, I can say this is accurate. Trumpet players have this bipolar personality with each other. We can be the best of friends one moment and literally hate each others existence the next.
But no matter what happens, there is one thing we trumpets (and brass) can agree on:
Woodwinds will forever be our enemies. When it comes down to it, we will always unite to fight off the Wooden Ones.
As a sax player I walked away from the woodwinds because the flutes- i sound and look like y’all- uhm I’m close enough… mind if I join?
Woodwinds will always be better, brass will always be louder, percussion will always be out of time, it's a delicate balance
@@ThatOneChorusKidpossibly…
the original melodic content is killer!
Thanks!
@@ryanmckennamusic why is it so short though?
This feels like a talkloid without the loid
I want to see two violins getting into an argument next (with a whole orchestra to back them up)
You have perfectly captured Symphonic Band Trumpets
Clarke study and Arban battle sent horrible music school flashbacks lol
The trumpet concerto at 0:31 got me since I’m currently learning how to play it
as a trumpet player... yeah pretty much
AS A TRUMPET PLAYER MYSELF,, THIS IS SO PERFECT OMG
Wait till it's two middle/high school trumpets and they make ear-splitting screeches constantly
as a trumpet player i can confirm this happens on the daily
as a horn player yeah I encourage all of the trumpet vs trumpet fights we have in our band lol
I imagined the (two) trumpets in my band doing this, and continued to imagine everyone else who plays each instrument with their parts. We don’t have cool horns to do the beginning “fight fight fight” part so in my mind it was me and the other saxophones
As a sax, i will join you.
This is genuinely a masterpiece
reply w/ smiley face if i should beg my director to let us play this
I can confirm that this is indeed what happens when I get in an argument with another trumpet player.
And then two percussionists suddenly disagree…
Now do 2 French Horns Get in an Argument.
That is legit a really good concept for a song
excited to see what the rest of the band is up to in this canon
This would be so cool if i had a group to work on with this and perform it for a huge show which my school does every year
Gosh I love that that was amusing as a trumpet player it’s funny because it reminds me a bit of two trumpets in my band rn oh gosh I love this
used to be the only trumpet in my school’s orchestra, so i never really had anyone to scream with
1:45 sheet music jumpscare
You should do "A trumpet and a Mellophone get in an argument"
The Clarke studies and Carnival of Venice... Real
Wow, the new Musescore 4 soundfonts are so incredible
Do two saxophones get into an argument
Tubby the tuba to slay this lot!👏👏👏👏👏👊
Make a song about the low team vibing. We just be vibin like that
That brass attack hits so hard lol this is awesome
as a kid who sits RIGHT in front of 3 trumpets, i can confirm, THIS IS ACCURATE.
I gotta see 2 oboes getting into an argument about who should be the tune setter
0:38
the "!!" is everything
Is the tune at 1:51 an original melody? Sounds very film-score esque, love it!
Make saxophones get in an argument
everybody gangsta till percussion comes in with the tam tam
holy shit my silly comment inspired this mess.
lmao, great job pal
this is somehow the best argument I've ever heard. and I love it
Fr and now they should do 2 violins arguing
As a horn player I am litearlly so honoured you included us here to play a gladiator like melody with our fellow tuba players (WHERES THE TROMBONES)
RIGHT HERE! I would gladly hit someone over the head with my slide if it meant they played A flat instead of A natural in Highlights From Harry Potter. *cough cough my friend who sits next to me in band*
This is amazing! Same with the clarinet one! Can you do one for trombones?
As a trombonist, I would like to state it would be over stupid things. For example:
"Hey, Its A flat, not A natural."
"K"
"Dude, Were in E flat key, I just said its A flat, not A natural."
"Sorry"
"WHY WONT YOU LISTEN TO ME ITS A FLAT NOT A NATURAL!!!!!"
"chill the fuck out dude"
"YOURE GOING TO GET KICKED OUT IF YOU DONT PLAY THIS NOTE RIGHT."
thank you for reading this dramatic re-enactment of me and my friend's argument over 'Highlights From Harry Potter'.
@@Monochrome_Monoboy Yes! Happens every time...
Nobody:
Trombones: Continues on their 8th position grindset
Why is this accurate
Someone should animate this video.
This is funny, hilarious and interesting at the same time
meanwhile me, the flute in the corner covering my ears: make it stoppppp
I love the clarinets a lot
I ate an entire mini bucket of icecream while watching this on loop 😭
The aratunian was nice, but Mahler 5 would have put the icing on the cake.
this was awesome, but I also think low brass instruments getting into an argument would be funny, like tuba or baritone/euphonium
but, why was it so short at only 2 min. into the argument?
As a French horn player, I can confirm that we would play that. We would also play the fanfare that was once played while going into battle
two saxes in an argument next 🙏
As a trumpeter, I usually get into fights with the saxophones.
this is soo true, at least to my last year's band XD
now we wait for the trombone argument
The main thing when you write a piece of music is the form.
this is fantastic
Did they use a sforzando as a finishing move???
Loved the horns part I clicked because I’m a trumpet main tho and that was great
It was a much more civilized age back when those banjos had that duel.
bro that brass power at the end was epic
IMAGINE TWO PIANO PLAYERS! (One of which is emo and the other playing many g-notes-) THIS HAS HAPPENED IN BAND FOR ME 😂😂😂😂
THERE SHOULD BE TWO VIOLINS GET INTO AN ARGUMENT HAHA
BC THATS HAPPENED TO ME
the ending is amazing
I just got switched to the baritone section today and they’re more chaotic than the trumpets :’)
Meanwhile the trombones are seeing who can shoot their slide the farthest
lol there was a bit of arutunian trumpet concerto going on in there (i played that in my audition for an honor band😂)