CONTROVERSIAL EXPERIMENTS PART 3
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 жов 2024
- so I realized as it was uploading this is actually PART 3 not part 2, oops my bad, but I still hope that you enjoy!
PART 1:
• CONTROVERSIAL PSYCHOLO...
PART 2:
• CONTROVERSIAL PSYCHOLO...
references
the monster study:
www.nytimes.com...
the rosenhan study:
www.bonkersinst...
(I can't find the original article for the Landis study, but google "Landis facial expression study" to read more about it.)
try the method I personally use for online counseling | www.tryonlinet...
------------------------------------------------------------------
e m a i l | sarahhawkinson@gmail.com
h o r r o r . c h a n n e l | bit.ly/1h7ZKUF
v l o g . c h a n n e l | / @sarahhawkinsonvlogs7150
t w i t t e r | #!...
s n a p c h a t | sarahhawkinson
i n s t a g r a m | / sarahhawkinson
d e p o p | www.depop.com/...
------------------------------------------------------------------
c a m e r a | canon rebel t5i
e d i t o r | adobe premiere pro cs5.5
FTC | not a sponsored video :)
The second experiment reminded me of when I was admitted to a mental hospital as an emergency case. On my discharge papers they got my name wrong (not just the spelling it was a different name in some sentences), my height (which combined with my actual weight made me anorexic), wrote I had a drinking problem because I drank on some friday nights, diagnosed me with selective mutism (it's actually social anxiety but hey close enough right), ...
Btw when I talked to a therapist who actually bothered to listen to me I got diagnosed with depression, borderline personality disorder, bulimia and social anxiety. The hospital got none of those right.
wow. thats fucked up. I dont think that would ever happen in my country.
@@rory4623 what country?
@@spoiltmilk6511 New Zealand. I have never heard of a story like this happening here but I hear things like this happening in America a lot. Maybe I'm wrong though
@@rory4623 I'm inclined to think there is just not as much publicity of these sort of things there wether they happen or not but I couldn't tell you without doing proper research. I really don't know anything about the mental health infrastructure there
To be fair, BPD (I am diagnosed with it as well) can be misdiagnosed as various things depending on what you’re putting on at the time (not sure if I am phrasing that right...) some of my BPD symptoms are emulating other people’s personalities and constantly changing my personality, so sometimes I’d have very different mental symptoms and would change on a dime from having severe anxiety to not at all, having hyperfixations or not, etc. I’m a lot better now
Honestly your videos have really made my interest for psychology skyrocket.I think i'm going to take a class on that next semester
Sapphire C same
yay that's so awesome! you'll love it :)
Sarah Hawkinson what are jobs that you can get with this major
the second study is my faaaaaavourite from psych class! i think its important to emphasize that it was done to highlight pathologising normal human quirks and seeing the illness rather than a multifaceted human being.
the best part was when doctors were outraged by the study cuz they felt tricked so the researchers were like "k we'll do it again, this time you have a warning that we're sending test subjects ok?" and the doctors found hundreds of fake patients but in reality, the researchers never sent any more subjects and the fake patients were all regular misdiagnosed people
ywoy I thought it was so interesting that even though they were sent no pseudo patients the hospitals identified 42 as pseudo patients confidently, and suspected another 42 (I learned about it in my psych class this year)
Reminded me of this one time in middle school when we had a substitute bus driver that obviously didn't know the route. It was in the morning and we were on our way to school, and obviously we decided to take the opportunity to skip some classes and gave her the wrong directions. She got more and more lost, and the bus was very close to capacity, so it started to stress her out a lot. We noticed it, (she was running her hands through her hair, scratching her neck, constantly leaning over the wheel or adjusting her sunglasses, etc.) and I think someone even went so far as to mention that she was getting nervous. We cheered it on and started working together to make things harder for her. She got confused again at a very fast moving intersection where she didn't have a lot of time to consider all the options, and we talked with each other and decided to give the right direction knowing she would turn the opposite way. She did exactly that and noticed so when we cheered over it. I think she eventually radioed for directions and we got to school around the end of second period. I sill feel really bad about and think about it sometimes, but overall, middle schoolers really are evil huh.
Y'all were doing experiments before you knew it was even an experiment!
Can you make a video on conversion "therapy" if you can't I understand
yes I'm going to include that in my next "controversial treatments" video!
Sarah Hawkinson thank ILYSM
Sarah Hawkinson Thank you I still don't really understand the thought process behind it
Sarah Hawkinson can you plz make this!
I'm so obsessed with your videos! You are so eloquent and intriguing to listen to! Keep it up :)
ahh thank you so much girl! :)
Lmao!!!!!
Almost 2 years late to the party, but I'd like to add, as someone that stutters: stuttering isn't something you're necessarily born with. For a lot of people it is, but there are other reasons why someone can acquire a stutter, including a brain injury, certain medications, or severe psychological stress. It's just that for that last type, the psychological aspect isn't surrounding idea of stuttering, it's more that it'll be a manifestation of something separate going on psychologically, often some type of major trauma.
Love that lipcolour!
I have it actually, Matte looks better than i thought lol
i think it might be salem from lime cime (not sue though)
hearing the stuttering controversy was so strange to me haha. I went to speech therapy for years bc of my stutter and I would be annoyed if some guy was trying to tell me it was a psychological thing. Anyone who has a stutter knows that it's such a distinct physical feeling when you stutter- like the word/syllable is a tangible object stuck back of your throat- it's so strange.
Honestly you're so great, like your makeup videos are good, your no makeup Monday videos are perfectly chill and then your phycology videos are super interesting. How to more people not know about you?!
aw you're the sweetest! :)
your makeup is awesome. and that is not sarcastic. your makeup IS awesome.
I love these videos because I don't know most of these studies in detail. I'd never kill an animal for a freaking experiment.
Thanks for centering your channel around you and your interests instead of putting them aside to post content that is "trendy" or would get the most views. I've been a subscriber of yours since Day 1 and I've always loved how honest and real you are. Much love!! Xoxo
I always find these types of videos so interesting, I'm currently at uni studying counselling psychology. Your skin looks flawless btw! ✨
Love seeing someone who actually enjoyed their degree! The videos are really interesting, I always thought I'd go into psychology, but ended up with something else, so It''s great getting a glimpse into what you've found fascinating!
I love how your make up and hair all just go together it's beautiful lol
Sarah, thank you so much for sharing all these things on mental health! As someone who has some mental health problems, it just makes me so happy to see someone educating people on the brain of a person with difficulties. Keep up the awesome work!
You look beautiful! Also, you're the first youtuber who's 20-30 minute videos I sit through and watch, without any effort on my part to try to stay awake and without resisting to skip the video. You're awesomeeeee!
The thing about taking psychology is, you can't ever look at a person on a surface level again. I know I can't anymore.
Loved this, Rosenhan's study really fascinated me in high school! Also, still waiting for a tutorial on this look :)
your hair looks fantastic here! and please make more of these videos they're so fun to watch
These are my favourite videos ever!! Ahhh they're so interesting!!!
I love your videos! I'm always so excited when you upload. And your eyes are super pretty, a beautiful blue. The red tones in your makeup and hair really make them pop!
i've always had an interest in psychology and the minds of serial killers and things like that, but since i found your channel it's gotten so much more! and now i'm honestly so intrigued that i'm thinking of taking a psychology class!
I learned about the rosenhan study in my psych class this year! it was so interesting to see that they were diagnosed even though when they were admitted to the hospital they acted normally, and showed that they were labelled so they weren't taken seriously and were just classed as mentally ill.
I adore your makeup and your videos. This particular series is extremely interesting to me and I can't wait for more! What's your lip color, by the way?
i love the controversial videos, i found your channel a few days ago and now i already want to prepare for my psychology a-levels (british exams before college/uni) around 3 years in advance
I wish you’d make more of these. I started with the first one and I’m hooked. I could watch these for hours. The first one was really long and in-depth and I kinda hope the next one is. THERES A NEXT ONE RIGHT?! 😅😅
seligmans learned helplessness study is real sad but also really informative when understanding depression, also the genie the wild child study makes me cry every time we talk about it in psych, dr. money too
Honestly I would love to stick my hand in a bucket of cute little or big frogs!
Edit: WAIT HOW DARE THEY BEHEAD A RAT! RATS ARE SO CUTE AND SWEET
So interesting ! I could listen to you all day, so yes please a part 4 will be enjoyable !
ok so far ive only seen some of your no makeup monday videos but girrrrrrl youre makeup skills are on point
ah your videos are always so interesting! could you talk about the russian sleep experiment sometime? i've always found it really interesting. thanks!!
girl what lipstick is that? It looks so good on you! You're doing amazing sweetie.
I have a stutter, I gave it to myself, I wanted one when I was little so I acted like I had one and now I do
I just found your channel and I can't stop watching your videos! I've binged your videos today and I've always been very interested in psychology and I find your videos so interesting and it had really showed me how interested I am in this topic!
Yes!! I clicked so fast when I got the notification! I love your videos , I learn a lot , that's why u are my favorite UA-cam r ❤️
Thank you for making videos Sarah. They really distract me from my problems.
i recently learned about the Roesenhans study in my psych class and its my favorite study so far. I can use your videos for revision! :)
favorite series of yours! your psychology videos are the best
I don’t know if there are any more experiments you could do, but I’d love a part 4.
Love your psychology videos! Can you make a video about your favourite psychology books? What are your MUST reads??
im in love with that hair and makeup *-*
These are so fascinating! I love them. Make more!
i remember in kindergarten i had such a bad stutter. it started when i thought that this kid was cool and he had a stutter... so i started doing it. but it stopped after a little bit kind of suddenly.
In your next video on this could you talk about Dr Money's Bruce Reimer case study please? I find it so fascinating and so few people know about it.
It would be awesome if you could cover David Reimer's story in these series!
love your videos! you have really knocked it out of the parked with this one. also just an observation you look so much like Nicole Kidman in the thumbnail, I was SHOOK 😄💖 hope you have a great day!
Is this video titled controversial experiments part 3!!?? I thought she said this was part 2
yes sorry! I thought it was part 2 until I was uploading this video haha
A really interesting and controversial experiment that you should definitely discuss in the next video is the Tearoom Trade experiment! I was so fascinated by it when I first learned about it.
Could you make another "serial killers I'd like to have coffee with" ? I loved that video and it's so interesting hearing about it x
I'm about to graduate in a year as a speech pathologist, so I found the first study you mentioned especially interesting! There is still so much about stuttering that we don't understand
I'm starting college in 2 months and all of these videos make me so excited to start my psych class my first semester. I'm a premed freshman and I'm thinking about majoring in psychology.
thank you sm for all of these interesting videos!! definitely helped me with my decision in what i wanna do in the medical field lol
no joke, i was walking home from highschool today and i couldnt wait to get home because i was hoping youd upload today! i dont get enough sarah
pasta is good I- is your profile picture alex?
I remember reading about "The Monster" study it was a really eye-opening experiment to how much thew BSP has changed how researchers are able to conduct experiments.We learnt about Rosenhan during our studies on Schizophrenia and I loved it! I never heard of the last one though, it sounds really interesting.
Your makeup matches your hair in this lighting! the eyeshadow matches the top part/roots of your hair and your lipstick matches the ends of your hair! You look gorgeous :)
omg i subscribed today and i was marathoning your vids and i love this series. i was super excited to see you posted this!
I seriously love your vids! your voice is so soothing lol
New to your channel btw. Have you ever done a video on the Szondi test? That's always been a study that's facinated me (or really any study on the subconscious is interesting to me)
This series is so awesome! Thank you for making these videos!!
As somebody who had a stutter since age 5 I can imagine the shame these kids in the first experiment went through... without even having a problem
Your hair color looks SO NICE omg (also, great video as always!)
Love your channel, I feel like it's the perfect match between ethics and science. You inspired me to write an essay on using the image of the mentally ill person in horror movies and books. I got to say that thanks to that I got an A on my ethics course. Keep doing such amazing content!!
I just found your channel, love it ! So interesting and refreshing.
next school year (which starts in about 3 months) I'm studying psychology and your videos will help me a lot 💞 also, some of them gave me ideas for projects on that class, so thank you 😘
These videos are so interesting and yet scary because most of this wasn't too long ago. I also wonder if the people experimenting didn't realize how controversial it was what they were doing, or if they just didn't care? I don't know what would be worse, but knowing these people could actually do this makes me wonder how much of it could still happen today, in secret or not.
I watch your videos when I wanna learn something lol I took psychology and I learn more watching you than my actual class
These videos are my favorite! Thanks Sarah 🙏❤️
Holy sh-t! This series is so great!!!! Sub'd AF! Thanks for sharing this!
these are literally my favourite videos ever omg
Have you ever thought of doing a podcast about this? I think you’d be great!
The first experiment hits home for me because I stutter and have tourette syndrome. I feel so badly for those children.
literally binge watching your videos 😂 love your vids
I’m doing about Schizophrenia in psychology atm and when talking about issues with the diagnosis of it we spoke about Rosenhan and I agree it’s super interesting.
OK but why kill a rat lmfao if the facial expression he wanted was horror or disgust there is plenty of others ways he couldve gotten that lol wtf
I actually wrote essays on the first two experiments in college (I'm from england) love these videos I find them so interesting
what a great series! changed my perception on psychology in general and the first one in particular helped me to make sense of the mindset behind soviet concentration camps, which I had been trying to grasp for the last month
I would personally be very interested in seeing you do videos going into the structures of obedience like army, jail, mental hospitals, etc.
love the video! and what's that lipstick cause I love it
totally off topic but can you please upload a tutorial of the makeup look you're wearing right now. you look so amazing
Kind of random but what lipstick is that?! It’s so freaking pretty!
I’d love more of these
i couldve sworn that was tana mongeau in the thumbnail photos of the mugshots lol. love u sarah
First of all I love hearing you talk about psychology because it's very evident how passionate you are about the subject. I love that I can always come to this channel to escape the boring norm of UA-cam.
Secondly, when you were editing this video did you have a difficult time focusing because your beauty is so distracting? Like I want to build a fort in your hair and live in it forever. You're a babe and a half.
I really find these videos fascinating!!
omg your makeup is literally so goooooddd!!!!
Hey what about your bullet journal videos? I loved them
Can you maybe talk about whether or not it is ethical to use the results from these kinds of experiments? I've read a lot of arguments for and against using results of the experiments that took place during WWII, and I think it's very interesting.
Hi Sarah! Can make a video giving your opinion in the case of Michelle Carter?
“He did recruit another graduate student named Mary Tudor” Ah, Bloody Mary II of course she’s messed up
Bonus fact: I go to the University of Iowa and our speech pathology building is named after Wendell Johnson despite the fact that he ran the monster study. I think it's technically called the Wendell Johnson Speech and Hearing Center or something similar.
im gonna take psychology because you made it pretty cool ngl. also show us ur cat pls.
This is old but whatever that lip color is, it is made for you! Looks amazing!
I was told I stuttered as a child and it only comes out when I'm stressed
(now only comes out when I'm stressed)
I know this is about psychology buttttt.... makeup grwm on this look or????? Back to psych: I find all your videos really interesting and you've actually helped me pick some Essay/Research Paper topics for school- thanks girl! Lmao, I love ya!! 🖤🤓
Some of these experiments yes are controversial now but if they hadn't been done we probably wouldn't know certain social and psychological outcomes of their experiences
I love these videossss I'm bingeing your channel hi
The "basic facial expressions" that are nowadays widely accepted to portray certain emotions aren't actually universal - there are differences from person to person and between cultures. This entails some issues when this is applied in situations like court or job interviews.
So glad I found your channel 🙌🏼
Your lipstick fits so well with ur hair ♡
There was a guy who claimed to be insane to avoid criminal punishment (even though it was a small crime) he claimed to have universally know symptoms (hearing voices, “wanting to see women die” etc) eventually he tried to tell them that he had lied, and he wasn’t insane, but it was written off as him being a psychopath (manipulative,lying etc) eventually he had served more time in the hospital than he would have in prison. The journalist who spoke to him researched mental illnesses and saw how they can be put onto anyone no matter how sane. He even spoke to “sane” people and saw “symptoms” It was a tedtalk called “strange answers to the psychopath test”
I've been looking into taking psychology but I was looking into things when I get to college but I think I absolutely want to know