Kuch log ko confusion hai ki suspend to department hi kar skta hai… are bhai ese ho fansi (death penalty) bi jallad hi deta hai, judge thodi na aata hai fansi dene… Thing is that the Judge has authority to dictate the department for the said action against any officer. Otherwise department will have to clarify with proper explanation in the court.
Judge cannot dictate. Judge can only recommend. Usually the recommendations are accepted but they are not binding. For example, a sessions court in Gujarat had directed the SP of a district to initiate departmental inquiry against a constable and dismiss him from service. The SP didn't take action and contempt case was filed. It was quashed by the Gujarat High Court, which noted that the decision to initiate inquiry and dismiss/suspend can only be taken by the appointing authority, therefore the decision of the learned sessions Judge was bad in law.
@@Seriouslyfunny1 that’s right brother. But I was clearing the confusion. Because again any sentence or even the death penalty can be quashed by Supreme Court. I know order of departmental inquiries are not binding. But people has assumption that because of this logic Judge has no authority over govt servant. And that assumption is totally wrong due to ignorant attitude and lack of awareness of people. I was talking about authority of law. Now that’s different matter that to what extent that authority is binding. In some cases even authority of SC is also not absolute.
Physically army officer . In terms of power justice of high court Actually you have a very mere almost negligible chance to become mr justice of the honourable high court of the state or honourable Supreme Court a civil judge has high chances to retire as a district judge or a very mere chance to hold the post of additional justice of the honourable high court . On the contrary most of the bureaucrats of the country are presented before the high court or Supreme Court or in some cases district court. In army matters cases are heared at court martial . If you want to become mr justice of the honourable high court of the state or the Supreme Court start to practice time will come as well the promotional aspects of judicial magistrate may increase with the introduction of all india judicial services. Best of luck, Jay Hind!
Civil judge has given the direction to collector for partition of agricultural land in accordance with section 54. But collector's subordinate tehsildar are hands-on-gloves with the other party and they are intentionally not executing the decree since three years and it's completely frustrating and now they are submitting the non-compliance report. Is this contempt of court and what steps should I take further as I haven't get the possession of land as per court's decree of section 54 of partition suit.
@@japnoorsingh3845 But why should MLA be intervened as this is a judicial order. I am going to file contempt petition based on the available reports by Tehsildar and collector
@@japnoorsingh3845 I have already paid 1,66,000 rs for demarcation and for police protection 10k. It's a government receipt. पैसे क्या झाड पे उगते है क्या
A66a tu ias ips nhi ban paya toh humesha ye kya karta hain comparison don't compare anyone would you compare Mukesh Ambani vs Virat Kohli vs Albert Einstein ye kya hain
@@Brodragon2225 bro jaane doe yeh inko nhi pta 90 percent lower judges wo hote hai jo upsc cse mae fail hogai aur 3 saal law krkae fjm ban gaaye yeh bas power power kehlte hai yeh nhi kehte 400 saal ka backlog hai court mae . ab bolenge executive kei galti udaipur wallle ka video hai proof hai open and shut hai lekin aaj tk kya kuch aaya faisala
Excellent video. Please keep it up
Thanku
Bhiya how many guards did a civil judge get, and did they have power to call an Ias officer in his court room.
Kuch log ko confusion hai ki suspend to department hi kar skta hai… are bhai ese ho fansi (death penalty) bi jallad hi deta hai, judge thodi na aata hai fansi dene…
Thing is that the Judge has authority to dictate the department for the said action against any officer. Otherwise department will have to clarify with proper explanation in the court.
Judge cannot dictate. Judge can only recommend. Usually the recommendations are accepted but they are not binding. For example, a sessions court in Gujarat had directed the SP of a district to initiate departmental inquiry against a constable and dismiss him from service.
The SP didn't take action and contempt case was filed.
It was quashed by the Gujarat High Court, which noted that the decision to initiate inquiry and dismiss/suspend can only be taken by the appointing authority, therefore the decision of the learned sessions Judge was bad in law.
@@Seriouslyfunny1 that’s right brother. But I was clearing the confusion.
Because again any sentence or even the death penalty can be quashed by Supreme Court. I know order of departmental inquiries are not binding. But people has assumption that because of this logic Judge has no authority over govt servant. And that assumption is totally wrong due to ignorant attitude and lack of awareness of people.
I was talking about authority of law. Now that’s different matter that to what extent that authority is binding. In some cases even authority of SC is also not absolute.
विभाग के प्रमुख को ही सस्पेंड करने का अधिकार है आईएएस और आईपीएस अधिकारी को।
SIr,
can a magistrate can take an extra life insurance policy apart from the govt. provided??
Yes
Do comparison on advocate/judges vs indian army. Who'll win in fight and what will happen if judges started to abuse indian army.
see video on youtube high court judge angry on army officer
Itna mat soch faltu thinking mat kr bhai sambhavnao ke wo sawal mt kro jo ho nhi skta uska delusion mt paal
@@Indian4thpillar we all know when army get angry consequences will be unimaginable.
Physically army officer . In terms of power justice of high court
Actually you have a very mere almost negligible chance to become mr justice of the honourable high court of the state or honourable Supreme Court a civil judge has high chances to retire as a district judge or a very mere chance to hold the post of additional justice of the honourable high court . On the contrary most of the bureaucrats of the country are presented before the high court or Supreme Court or in some cases district court. In army matters cases are heared at court martial . If you want to become mr justice of the honourable high court of the state or the Supreme Court start to practice time will come as well the promotional aspects of judicial magistrate may increase with the introduction of all india judicial services.
Best of luck,
Jay Hind!
Thankyou for the information sir👍
🙏🇮🇳
Judge hai vo, juban se poncha lagvayega 😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍
Aree murk civil judge ko suspend ka power nahi rahta sirf high court aur supreme court ke pass power rahta hai
Civil judge has given the direction to collector for partition of agricultural land in accordance with section 54. But collector's subordinate tehsildar are hands-on-gloves with the other party and they are intentionally not executing the decree since three years and it's completely frustrating and now they are submitting the non-compliance report. Is this contempt of court and what steps should I take further as I haven't get the possession of land as per court's decree of section 54 of partition suit.
Any answer, Sir?
@@shubhamshinde1520 MLA se baat kijiye
@@japnoorsingh3845 But why should MLA be intervened as this is a judicial order. I am going to file contempt petition based on the available reports by Tehsildar and collector
@@shubhamshinde1520 bhai ye india hai , yaha Parr law se sab kaam nahi Hote , yaha par har**mi 😄 log hai , yaha par kaam Isse Hota hai 👉 💰💸💲🪙🤑
@@japnoorsingh3845 I have already paid 1,66,000 rs for demarcation and for police protection 10k. It's a government receipt. पैसे क्या झाड पे उगते है क्या
ye to sec509 ipc ki defination jasi h same.... criminal contempt..
Bhadiya bhaiya ! Bhaiya what if koi judge court mai bhul jaye koi section wagera saja dete time toh usko kaise handle krenge judge sahab?
Bare act hote hai unke pas
@@half-civil-judge ohh thanku bhaiya
#SaveShwetabhGangwar
Bhai please ek video bana do ki civil judge kaa transfer home court me ho sakta hai please 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️
Sir avi njpc kaha lagu hua apki video dekha njpc related but avi tak hua nhi ig
Nxt month se milne lag jaye ge ...in Rajasthan
@@half-civil-judge acha sir but har state ke civil judge kliye laagu hua hai kya
Apki videos bhut achi hai I'm also doing law from nlu delhi and a judiciary aspirant
Bhaiya mere 10th me 44% aaye the kya me qualified hu civil judge ke riye?
Ha. Bhai
Beginning civil judge ki kitne salary hote h monthly????
Watch this video ua-cam.com/video/oEbogUAqH8c/v-deo.html
2 lakh
@@Nikhil.77777no 1.30
Must
A66a tu ias ips nhi ban paya toh humesha ye kya karta hain comparison don't compare anyone would you compare Mukesh Ambani vs Virat Kohli vs Albert Einstein ye kya hain
Phle to bolna shikh lo...sb apni jgh pe sahi hote h
@@videowithsongsandmotivatio4073 tum tarafdari karna chod do
@@Brodragon2225 bro jaane doe yeh inko nhi pta 90 percent lower judges wo hote hai jo upsc cse mae fail hogai aur 3 saal law krkae fjm ban gaaye yeh bas power power kehlte hai yeh nhi kehte 400 saal ka backlog hai court mae . ab bolenge executive kei galti udaipur wallle ka video hai proof hai open and shut hai lekin aaj tk kya kuch aaya faisala
@@AbhiSingh-qr1li haa sahi bol rhe ho tabhi to curruptiion krte h iAs wale aur aam janta ko presan karte h
@@Brodragon2225 sabse jadya koi curruptiion h to wo iAs h aajkl
Gr8
What is ACR ??
Annual confidential report
Bhai seedhe seedhe ye batao....Civil judge ...Ips ias ki esi tesi krr sakta hai ki nhi
bar coucil ke pass b bahut power hoti hai yha chalti hai pitics
Sir kya judge ki baat ips ko maanni padti hai
Ha Bhai ga..d fad dete hain judge
Sir agar sp baat nhi Mane to 🙄🙄
Tumhare views ias ips kaa naam lekr milte h
Upsc me fail judge.
bhai aapki sari baat se sehmat hu but na nau mn tel hota hai radha nachegi
Pls reply kriyega
Bhai please ek video bana do ki civil judge kaa transfer home court me ho sakta hai please 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️
Ha bhai Bana du ga...
Bhai please ek video bana do ki civil judge kaa transfer home court me ho sakta hai please 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️
Bhai Aaj bana du ga...