NotebookLM Shakes Up Research, Yet Has Flaws

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @Google
    @Google 10 днів тому +56

    Thanks for the shoutout! Excited to see how everyone learns with NotebookLM!

    • @mert_dikmen
      @mert_dikmen 10 днів тому +4

      Does not hallucinate like other LLMs and gives citations(!). Podcasts are REALLY good. It is amazing that it is free!

    • @ALXStrikers
      @ALXStrikers 6 днів тому +1

      Thank you Google ❤

    • @Kori_INJN
      @Kori_INJN 17 годин тому

      People need to be made aware that notebookLM changes the content and injects its own ideas on what it believes should be stated. It completely deviates from the uploaded content and injects information from other sources. I uploaded a 2-page document that I wrote so I was fully aware of what it contained, the topic was focused on Christianity. It total contradicted the content and began to state a wider perspective, the sad part is it kept saying that the new information was contained in the document. What if I had uploaded 6 large PDFs that I didn't read, I would have left with what notebookLM wanted me to hear and not what the documents actually contained. The think should not be injecting its own ideas into uploaded content worst its actually tell people what it believes they should hear

  • @jrennickemd
    @jrennickemd 13 днів тому +50

    This tool has been absolutely game changing for me. Not in a “do my work for me“ type of sense, but interacting with a topic. Being able to synthesize multiple papers and interact with them all at once is truly amazing. This is the first tool that finally made me realize the way we have learned is going to change forever with AI.

  • @ElvenStone
    @ElvenStone 14 днів тому +6

    I can't thank you enough for this. I've been looking for a way to consume my ever-growing list of articles to read and was waiting for something like this. The lit review it produces, the way it answers questions... it's the best I've seen so far regarding technical subjects. And the podcast generation is like a bonus on top, even if just for fun. It... blew my mind honestly.

  • @ameerracle
    @ameerracle 14 днів тому +35

    The podcast voices over the material is crazy.

  • @yashsharmaauthor
    @yashsharmaauthor 14 днів тому +12

    I just found out about this yesterday and look, you made a video about it! Thanks! 😉

  • @humbleambition
    @humbleambition 13 днів тому +5

    Flippin wish i had this when i was doing my phd and writing my review paper!!!

  • @dr.heikefranz6663
    @dr.heikefranz6663 14 днів тому +29

    It's 6 AM, and I was just scrolling to procrastinate on my work. I need to write am article about a topic (Emotional Eating), and have to summarize most recent literature. Then I saw your new video, just at the right time. It's exactly what I need to get started with my article. Thank you, Andy. This (the video) was the equivalent of three cups of strong coffee and really woke me up. BTW: where do you get your lovely and colorful t-shirts?

    • @DrAndyStapleton
      @DrAndyStapleton  14 днів тому +11

      Please to help you. I make most of my t-shirts myself :)

  • @farzadjahanfard
    @farzadjahanfard 14 днів тому +11

    I am dyslexic and the audio is ground breaking fir me ❤❤

  • @sabrina_marktech
    @sabrina_marktech 7 днів тому +1

    I use Nothbook for other things but didnt think about it for my academic. Try to create a notebook with your resume, all your work experience, published papers, etc.. and listen the podcast of it. Its so cool.

  • @CosmicCells
    @CosmicCells 14 днів тому +10

    So many people hearing of this for the first time... Its been around for 5-6 months now, hyped for the podcast integration since 2-3 months...

    • @dbreardon
      @dbreardon 11 днів тому

      Google has done a terrible job at promoting this Ai app. Heck, they don't even have an Ai side panel in their browser for their own Gemini LLM! You have to load up a Chatgpt extension for goodness sake.

  • @vugar_ibrahimov
    @vugar_ibrahimov 13 днів тому +2

    Hi, Andrew. Great tutorial as usual. This is definitely one of the bests I have been checking so far.
    As you mentioned, one of the issues is that it can refer to the false part of the document. But that does not mean that generated text is itself wrong but it is based on another part of the document which you should manually search.
    If they fine-tune, this tool will be a very useful one.

  • @1999Jerod
    @1999Jerod 13 днів тому +3

    I just started college and found this tool. I really hope it’s good enough to give me all of the information I need from all of the reading

    • @gregnixon1296
      @gregnixon1296 10 днів тому +2

      Yes, it will be sufficient. Tape your prof’s lectures and upload as an audio file. Make an outline and create your own discussion questions for study.

  • @suansh1
    @suansh1 14 днів тому +5

    Holy PAKODAAS!! Question: Is now the best or the worst time to be a PhD student/resarcher? Podcast is the highlight 👏

  • @hagelslag9312
    @hagelslag9312 12 днів тому +2

    The ONLY thing I am scared about - the ONLY negative - is the people who have dangerous ideas to use it against science etc. It's easy to manipulate the sources, then create something believe able anew. That's my only sincere worry.
    Regardless, wonderful tool. Will definitely be using it. I wished I had this curing college, so I would be able to record my teacher and the book I was learning from (as I already did), but instead of relistening to his words again as I got on my train ride back, have it spilled into an enjoyable podcast. It would have made learning much easier. The podcast one will absolutely be a game changer.
    I know what I will be helping my child with as they go to school.

  • @stephane1623
    @stephane1623 13 днів тому +3

    That’s one of my secret weapons. I love it so much ❤

  • @architech5940
    @architech5940 13 днів тому +5

    This is great, however; if I'm working on sensitive research in statistics, physics, and perhaps a new mechanism for artificial intelligence, I don't want to share this data with Google. That would be my primary concern when using tools such as this one

  • @aleks0_o879
    @aleks0_o879 11 днів тому +3

    The only elements it requires to be more complete are folders and tags, and able to upload images to make it complete

  • @TheNourabou
    @TheNourabou 13 днів тому

    Thank you so much! It helped me prepare my paper.

  • @williamcattr267
    @williamcattr267 7 днів тому +2

    THIS IS AWESOME! And it's free??? Can't beat that. This will save loads of time generating papers for my graduate program.

  • @denerluizdasilva
    @denerluizdasilva 12 днів тому

    Really incredible!! Thanks for sharing Andrew!!

  • @AxionSmurf
    @AxionSmurf 14 днів тому +5

    I think it's funny when people are skeptical of using AI / use W/As to avoid using it. They're going to be the old person who can't do anything useful because they can't deal with change or an adjustment to their personal pride that they had to let a tool do a lot of the driving. Part of the rat race is adapting to the times. Funnier is when people think they can stop AI. You can't close pandora's box.

  • @DorothyBrown-e8q
    @DorothyBrown-e8q 9 днів тому

    This video gave me so much insight!

  • @aravindan4804
    @aravindan4804 14 днів тому +2

    Thank You so Much for sharing this content....I would like to hear Audio 😉😘😚

  • @nitsua803
    @nitsua803 13 днів тому +2

    I was wondering when you would review this tool. I have been playing around with it for a while.

  • @MagnusItland
    @MagnusItland 13 днів тому +1

    Right? This is one of those tools that makes me go, "Is it 2040 already?" because that's when I used to expect this kind of tool to be in the wild.

  • @trevorwilliams5687
    @trevorwilliams5687 14 днів тому +5

    The perfect tool to avoid reading or thinking. Great - just what my students need.

    • @emmanuelchikeluba2360
      @emmanuelchikeluba2360 14 днів тому +2

      😂🤣 😂😂. At this rate, AI might take over teaching soon.

    • @finchbevdale2069
      @finchbevdale2069 14 днів тому

      ​@@emmanuelchikeluba2360Soon? I'm already using it to create private lectures on all manner of topics that are delivered to me through my car audio system in the professional voice of my choice.

  • @AxionSmurf
    @AxionSmurf 14 днів тому +1

    That audio review is way better than my home llama's TTS plugin. How can I rob Google for their TTS and how much extra VRAM does it take 😁

  • @weamadam
    @weamadam 13 днів тому

    Amazing as usual Andy 👏🏻👏🏻

  • @anitawoolvett7172
    @anitawoolvett7172 11 днів тому

    Gracias!!!😊

  • @drm.mayseitanidi2339
    @drm.mayseitanidi2339 10 днів тому

    I love your shirt! What are the cartoons on it and where might one get a similar one? Thank you! Apologies for the random question :) and BTW I also love the tool!

  • @michen25
    @michen25 10 днів тому

    7:35 that’s my idea. I always thought about macking such videos.

  • @dbreardon
    @dbreardon 11 днів тому

    I would like to be able to make and save various prompts to a prompt library I can use and have access to other people's prompts in a prompt library. I believe users can now also make podcast that targeted various listener types......casual, professional, fun and easy (I think there are 4 types) which can be found under the ellipses in the podcast box.

  • @vincenzhog8347
    @vincenzhog8347 13 днів тому

    pretty awesome, thanks 👍

  • @ahmedamin3429
    @ahmedamin3429 14 днів тому

    Respected Dr. Andy, Are there any AI tools available that can assist with mechanical design and analysis, as well as check for plagiarism?

  • @coldlyanalytical1351
    @coldlyanalytical1351 13 днів тому

    Do you have a link to that generated audio? Tx.

  • @coldlyanalytical1351
    @coldlyanalytical1351 13 днів тому +1

    Can you analyse the files for common themes and relationships?

  • @username42
    @username42 13 днів тому +1

    can it also access to internet in addition to these sources you upload?

    • @gregnixon1296
      @gregnixon1296 10 днів тому

      Yes, but you must give it a website address to source.

    • @username42
      @username42 9 днів тому

      @@gregnixon1296 so pubmed and etc can be given for academic search?

  • @jamescambray5595
    @jamescambray5595 12 днів тому +1

    Now I'm wondering if this whole channel is generative AI

  • @consultcorpgroup1231
    @consultcorpgroup1231 14 днів тому

    Wonderful 👍🏻

  • @2012Opus
    @2012Opus 11 днів тому

    I'm not sure about this. You still have to comprehend everything that is written and you are still responsible for every word that you use that is generated from this. That means you still have to verify all the claims which means reading, wrestling with the text, and understanding. In the end, is it really saving you time if you really want to learn?

  • @Matlockization
    @Matlockization 14 днів тому

    AnDi, thank you for helping me complete my 3rD pHd which is based on renewable tinga mi bOObs !

  • @autohmae
    @autohmae 13 днів тому

    That's pretty cool and very cheap too. 🙂

  • @ahmedamin3429
    @ahmedamin3429 14 днів тому +1

    Great 👍

  • @bobsalita3417
    @bobsalita3417 13 днів тому +1

    I've enjoyed the podcast so much that I've unsubscribed from your channel because I prefer to listen to Andy 2.0 ft Andrea.

  • @Leto2ndAtreides
    @Leto2ndAtreides 13 днів тому

    Supposedly, its API form - illuminiate - is already better than this.

  • @MrBokkyboy
    @MrBokkyboy 11 днів тому

    Google & free in one sentence hmmmmmm....really? Nice tool but I think we need a * before the word free 😅

  • @buggi666
    @buggi666 3 дні тому

    This is not how a literature review works in science....

  • @scottmiller2591
    @scottmiller2591 14 днів тому

    Is there an option to a make a podcast that isn't stupid naddering by midwits?

  • @febryantmasulili1156
    @febryantmasulili1156 13 днів тому

    Naughty little what?? 😅

  • @diodio520
    @diodio520 14 днів тому

    How can this be considered a work/brainchild of an academic? 🤦🏼

  • @ChemCoder404
    @ChemCoder404 14 днів тому +1

    I’m skeptical of using AI for lit review and writing. Skeptical of people who use it too.

  • @AxionSmurf
    @AxionSmurf 14 днів тому

    Now ask it how to make infrared solar panels produce a non-comical amount of usable energy

  • @thelonenoob2489
    @thelonenoob2489 14 днів тому

    Meow

  • @finchbevdale2069
    @finchbevdale2069 14 днів тому +2

    The podcast sounds completely natural and extremely annoying. I dont want ro listen to a svience podcast delivered by morning drivetime radio jocks

  • @zkireh
    @zkireh 14 днів тому +1

    It makes publishing an SLR paper, not something to be proud of.

    • @fkxfkx
      @fkxfkx 13 днів тому

      You have a limited imagination

  • @denijane89
    @denijane89 13 днів тому

    Yeah, good luck with math notations...