+CHRISTY W. trueeee lol if im not mistaken, luna got in for her dancing. victoria got in for dancing too i believe and i think krystal and sulli got in for acting and their looks right? i know krystal's been modeling since she was a kid and sulli acted before she debuted with fx i think
+smilestream:) I was thinking the same thing. The panel will probably have a hard time guessing her unless they have heard her solo work or are friends with her like Eric Nam.
+Emily Pun that would be so cool!! but lmao they would probably recognize her right quick because of her accent and the low tone of her voice. esp if she went on around the time of her album coming out.... but i would LOVE to see that...
+soph v i saw them at a show name happy together. Henry did mention tat they are work together for a album. I not sure is tat true or i misunderstanding >
+soph v Yes if you have interest for that and ask you may get stuff like that but Luna said she wanted a solo before but still nothing has come out for that. Some F(x) members also said they would love to work in more collabs and do more albums and stuff but again there is nothing but Amber's solo. I have a feeling Amber only got her solo when she asked was because SM was like "Well she already has all the music..." But maybe I'm wrong. Idk
Totally in love with llama's vocals!!She s got this husky low pitched voice wic can suit any kinda pitch n genre!!Way to go llama!!Thank god sm finally realised llama can do magic with her vocals!!
+Divya kolikipudi Truth is, they always knew. Amber was originally cast as... a vocalist. Not as a rapper. So glad she finally gets the attention she deserves. According to me, Amber and Luna are the best of f(x), artistically speaking.
Problem is, Korean audiences exalt high notes more than other groups...on the male and female vocalists alike...so voices like Amber's, or Moonbyul's, or innumerable others, are often relegated to being their group's rapper, especially in previous generations, but still true now in 4th Gen. Singers like Seulgi and Hwasa started making a dent in that bias in 3rd Gen, and 4th Gen has Minnie and Yuqi (among others) to, dare I say, make their pitches to improve the reception of lower tones. It's a work in progress.
Amber's lovely voice always surprises me. Luna, though, omg. Can we please talk about how amazing she controls her voice? It's so clean, pitch-perfect and just so beautiful. Ugh 💖
Come on Amber is a rapper but wow...this song and her vocal...I even forgot to breathe while listening. Luna, no words for her cuz we all know her vocal is just perfect.
Amber is actually a vocalist. She became the rapper because 1) f(x) didn't have a rapper and 2) Her tomboy style would have been too jarring from a vocalist, it's "easier to accept" a rapper
This song really shows off her beautiful voice (and those raspy parts 😱) and it's great sm lets her sing more now with the sm station projects and her album.
Amber's voice is heavenly ; v ; I feel so blessed listening to her sing ;; v ;; She did such a good job and honestly with this big of an improvement, I'll be anticipating for her next comeback.
amber is so good someone help me sm should just make her sing i think her voice can actually be the best in the group with more focus on it. her singing is so emotional and soothing it really touched me
+Taose HunHan Calm it's her/his opinion. we all know that Luna has a wonderful voice, she's an amazing singer. In my opinion Luna is better and has a good technique but if amber trains her voice seriously like luna who knows. , so you saying "probably never" don't be so negative :) LunBer are amazing singers
Amber got chosen for her vocals during audition. But SM placed her as the rapper of the group when she sings perfectly well than she raps. That's their biggest mistake in my opinion. Her live vocals here improved tremendously ever since her solo debut. Her breathing good and overall, it's stable now. I'm so proud of her. I hope she's happier, now that she is more exposed to singing stage than rap. :)
+Minderp Bang in an interview, Amber said that she wanted to try rapping and be the rapper not SM. Both of their mistake is not working on her vocals because she sounds good so far but with more practice I am sure she can be as good as Luna.
+whytedaises exactly, Luna's technique is so good, but mostly because Amber's coach totally didnt train her that much with her singing parts. When she sings on stage she seems a bit weaker than the other vocals, but her emotions and voice are total gold! she raps pretty well too
@@felixslettuuce7153 I think Amber's vocals are not weak, she is in third place in f(x) even many people say that Amber and Krystal's vocal abilities are only slightly different
fyi, Amber here is not feeling well, during rehearsal she looks like she has a cough in many times and some fans said Luna was sick too at that time but they can still perform like this, so professional and so good😁
regardless of who won, both team did a GREAT job and i have never been prouder. thanks sugarman for giving us fans the opportunity to let these gems shine
Amber's singing is pure gold and Luna's voice is just beyond me, they really need to have a album together. My bias is Amber, but both of them together is just woahhh. Love you Amber and Luna. Fx Fighting!!!~
Amber and Luna were the least popular members from f(x) now they finally get to shine with amber's solo projects and Luna's multiple appearances on variety songs! So proud of my UBs hopefully they will Luna will get a solo album and amber will release more songs that show her vocals like borders
i remember when amber and luna sang acoustic nu abo and thinking 'wow this pair should sing together more often'. sm, why did you hid such precious gem that is Luna and Amber?
I only checked this performance because people were hating on mamamoo for winning. Although there wasn't as much money put into mamamoo's stage, they sang with great emotion and showed versatility. Solar showed great control of her voice, and moonbyul delivered a great rap with good slow flow.
+YUANitis They are good but there are some parts they are quite unstable and don't balance very well... And Luna's part before the high note was kinda lacking... I am not an expert on this but yeah it just doesn't sound quite right.
i wanna cry when i hear amber's singing part.. her emotions of sadness was alive when singing this.. !! i feel her expression towards this song love love love
To me, this version by Luna and amber wins, i don't like the original version but i have to say this version is too touched. By the way, i like the original version of ' Like yesterday' but don't like the version by Mamamoo. So strange, right? So sad that they didn't win but it's fine, i really love this version! Luna unie, Amber unie, fighting!!!!
For me I luv lunber more. They not only sing very well but also sing into my heart. Btw Amber surprise me that she can sing that well. Luna always is my favourite vocalist. Lunber should have a unit
+yilinnay nice performance!! though I like Mamamoo's rendition slightly more. but thtz music, we all have difference preferences. (ps. Amber's voice is soso charming, wish to listen to her singing more!)
Well done you two, you guys did an awesome job! Amber/Luna fans- Instead of saying F(x) were more deserving of winning, how about congratulating Mamamoo?! They were both really good. Mamamoo won, as preference of the voters (and I agree). Go and watch Mamamoo's performances and tell me they aren't of of, if not THE, only girl group with extremely good vocal ability across the board instead of concentrated in one member. To all the haters; bye felicia.
good performance. amber is like key in shinee. they r so good at balancing d vocals or harmonizing. tho she seems breathy. she is always like this when she sings. myb her lung capacity is not great. but overall, nice performance from them. Luna, ofc she was great as always. good job.
+Patricia Tirza Lapolwa mmhmm, i know what you mean. With Amber, I think it's a little bit nerves and mostly a lack of vocal training. She's so much better than she used to be - and she sounds great now that she's singing in her range. I think, with work, she's gonna get better breath control and be able to hold those notes longer. With that said, I think her vocal color is a bit airy and breathy, so idt that's gonna change. And Luna...she's just so good. Imo, one of the best vocalists in kpop.
+kisskissbangbang Amber is always breathy since d very beginning. d difference is she is now has d confidence of showing off her vocal. she can sing well. i always knew it ever since i heard her so lil part "in so into u". her vocal color is so sweet airy but a lil bit heavy at d same time. it has charm i must say. she just lack in technique. and also she is always nervous when singing than rapping idk. but im sure she can improve. Luna is always amazing and Krystal's vocal always on point. those two always made a great duet. Amber is d 3rd best singer in f(x) so im very proud she has finally gained d confindence now n delievered such a good show. she did well considering this is like her first most long singing part in live perf with other members
wowww even though i dont understand but wow its really ah just wow luna ur voice amazing ❤❤❤❤ really u r a real super star ,, n Amber is there anything u cant do ? u r just perfect love u both 💖❤❤💙💙
I don't think it is fair to compare a faster paced and livelier song to a slow song. I personally liked f(x)'s Amber and Luna song better because I pref ballads. The song that left a bigger impression won imo. Mamamoo cover probably bought back many old memories for the audiences where as they weren't as familiar with Amber and Luna's song. Yes they were bought into tears and felt touched but to what extent? Whereas in mamamoo's song, the audience were introduced to familiarity. So compare and weight which would you prefer? A song that reminded you of what u are familiar with/ your youth or a song that touched your heart and make you cry. A fast paced song or a slow ballad song? . With that being said, people who said moo won because of "skimpy" clothes, if you are calling long white pants and a turtle neck sweater(long sleeve) skimpy then I don't know what is wrong with you. Stop starting needless fan wars. The audience voted not the artist themselves so leave them alone.
I simply can't describe how amazing this is. My friend said that Amber can't sing, I showed her this and she immediately retracted that statement. THIS IS BEAUTIFUL. I LOVE LUNA. I LOVE AMBER. They are so damn talented.
as much as i love Amber, lets just be real Krystal is better in term of singing. she is not breathy and she's got a strong vocal.. Amber's singing sometime is not stable n she often gets nervous when sings onstage. so maybe that is why krystal is d 2nd singer not Amber u know. both can sing well btw. but on top of that Amber CAN sing so i see nothings wrong with her having a duet with Luna. she did well
That was refreshing. Luna's vocals had me in my emotions. When she held that note while Amber was singing and then took it higher I got the chills and replayed it about 3 more times because it was just a "yes Luna slay" moment. And literally I'm so glad to hear Amber sing. I absolutely love when she sings and I hate that SM makes her rap. She's a better vocalist than she is a rapper. I'm not saying she's a bad rapper but she's a better vocalist and I wish SM would take advantage of that more.
Gosh I keep on coming back and listening to this because it's so amazingly sung! :D (Though it might just be because I'm super Amber biased and am super happy to hear her sing...)
![[ENG sub] The Call 듣자마자 소름! 신승훈x에일리 'Fly Away' [5/12 음원공개] 180511 EP.2](/img/n.gif)
I find Amber's singing much better than her rapping. I mean her voice here is so beautiful.
Amber was the only one of f(x) to get into SM with singing
+CHRISTY W. trueeee lol if im not mistaken, luna got in for her dancing. victoria got in for dancing too i believe and i think krystal and sulli got in for acting and their looks right? i know krystal's been modeling since she was a kid and sulli acted before she debuted with fx i think
Gorjess VIPP krystal and sulli both were in sm since they were 5 for acting
CHRISTY W. wow thats surprising. Hope SM will keep her singing at least some parts in their songs.
+CHRISTY W. Krystal didn't actually sign with SM until 2006, when she was 12, but she was discovered in 2000.
i think amber should go on masked singer
+smilestream:) I was thinking the same thing. The panel will probably have a hard time guessing her unless they have heard her solo work or are friends with her like Eric Nam.
+Emily Pun that would be so cool!! but lmao they would probably recognize her right quick because of her accent and the low tone of her voice. esp if she went on around the time of her album coming out.... but i would LOVE to see that...
nobuko
That's true but it's worth for her to give it a shot. :D
She was actually invited, but turned down the opportunity TT (she talked about it in a live recently)
@@beautifulstranger5136 I think that was "Unpretty Rapper" or something like that
루나는 말할 것도 없고 엠버 음색 미쳤다 진짜,, 스엠 두고두고 후회해라ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Berber your voice is so angelic so touching 😢😢😭😭pls sing more balled 😭❤️
I agree 100%
+picapu C Who tf is berber
+Revel Jung i think she means amber
+Revel Jung lol BerBer is AmBER xD amber fans call her like that sometimes ^^
+picapu C i thought of Bieber when i read you comment lol
I wish amber sang more, im in love with her voice
Their voice make me so emotional, especially Amber. Her voice is perfect for OST.
Their voices collabs so perfect together! Calling for Lunber sub-unit!!!
+soph v i saw them at a show name happy together. Henry did mention tat they are work together for a album. I not sure is tat true or i misunderstanding >
+soph v Why not both?! Lol seriously though can we just have Luna solo and sub-units with F(x) members because they are amazing! Please SM, please!
+soph v Yes if you have interest for that and ask you may get stuff like that but Luna said she wanted a solo before but still nothing has come out for that. Some F(x) members also said they would love to work in more collabs and do more albums and stuff but again there is nothing but Amber's solo. I have a feeling Amber only got her solo when she asked was because SM was like "Well she already has all the music..." But maybe I'm wrong. Idk
the show is flim on 2015. I check again later
+YUANitis Lunber♥
I told you SM ! just debut LunBer sub unit !!!
J Kb they did a duet!!! ^^
Omg! They really should!! So that we get to see them more often!
who are you ? wkwk
The audience looks so hypnotized, it's amazing. I hope Yoo Hee Yeol invites them next time they have a comeback. He seems like he loves them.
why wait for f(x)'s once in a lifetime comeback when they can make subunit in early 2016?
LuvsAmberAndEXO you stepped up my game. I like your thinking.
+LuvsAmberAndEXO I don't think there will be a sub unit tho since Amber will cb for another album and Luna will have solo too.
+annyeong fx i always think positively, I'm totally your opposite, f(x)'s fan
well I was talking about 2016 future f(x) activities. I think it's time for Luna to have a solo tho, she deserves it too.
Totally in love with llama's vocals!!She s got this husky low pitched voice wic can suit any kinda pitch n genre!!Way to go llama!!Thank god sm finally realised llama can do magic with her vocals!!
+Divya kolikipudi Truth is, they always knew. Amber was originally cast as... a vocalist. Not as a rapper. So glad she finally gets the attention she deserves. According to me, Amber and Luna are the best of f(x), artistically speaking.
+SadicMoutExt12 I agree..xD
So true
Even Amber is actually not feeling well here, she coughed a few times during rehearsal but still can perform like this
Problem is, Korean audiences exalt high notes more than other groups...on the male and female vocalists alike...so voices like Amber's, or Moonbyul's, or innumerable others, are often relegated to being their group's rapper, especially in previous generations, but still true now in 4th Gen. Singers like Seulgi and Hwasa started making a dent in that bias in 3rd Gen, and 4th Gen has Minnie and Yuqi (among others) to, dare I say, make their pitches to improve the reception of lower tones. It's a work in progress.
AMBER FOR DRAMA OSTS! WHOS WITH ME? :D
MEEE! her voice is kinda my ideal type. shooting!
OMG yes please .. 😭😆
Hope she sings the ost for the movie she's acting...
+Marah Allen Bilang well it's actually a drama, but I feel the same way her voice is gorgeous
+KPop “asoulmate4every1” CurlyTop yeah :D
Luna Amber sub unit NEEDS TO HAPPEN
Next time if haters say Amber can't sing, I will show them this. Calling for a Lunber subunit!! Amber and Luna together slay!!
tiffany lo RIGHHHTTT SAME
Amber's lovely voice always surprises me. Luna, though, omg. Can we please talk about how amazing she controls her voice? It's so clean, pitch-perfect and just so beautiful. Ugh 💖
Come on Amber is a rapper but wow...this song and her vocal...I even forgot to breathe while listening. Luna, no words for her cuz we all know her vocal is just perfect.
she got into SM by singing lol
+Crystal Cat (Cutie) and Luna got into SM for dancing 😉 how things change...lol
+sandra4408 i know right :)))
Amber is actually a vocalist. She became the rapper because 1) f(x) didn't have a rapper and 2) Her tomboy style would have been too jarring from a vocalist, it's "easier to accept" a rapper
지금 또 보고싶어 우리 에프엑스
most underrated group, yet one of the most talented, love f(x). just an amazing, beautiful performance ♥♥♥
holy sheeeet i knew amber could sing but wow...just wow...
This song really shows off her beautiful voice (and those raspy parts 😱) and it's great sm lets her sing more now with the sm station projects and her album.
She was accepted in SM through singing ;_; my baby llama
+Marah Allen Bilang she was the only one out of F(x) who originally got in for singing
+Kate Roberts I know! Luna was accepted through her dancing ^^
Amber's voice is heavenly ; v ; I feel so blessed listening to her sing ;; v ;; She did such a good job and honestly with this big of an improvement, I'll be anticipating for her next comeback.
srsly tho Amber has such an amazing voice.. I really don't understand why sm gave her the rap position... They need to let her sing more.
ikr . maybe because Amber is a tomboy then SM think she ain't suitable for dat vocalist position ;-;
Just sayin :/
its because f(x) had no rapper so they gave her that position which is dumb because amber is the only member of f(x) to get in for vocals
+Ellen Sundström they gave her an opportunity to showcase her voice through the solo album of hers
+Ellen Sundström if Amber did not fill the position of a rapper, imagine how narrow f(x)'s music versatility must have been.
+Jules Phi True, and she's the only one with the swagger of a rapper in f(x). I couldn't imagine any of the others doing it.
3.32
ohmyyy.. those rough husky high note of Amber!!! love it!!!
Both group have done a good job but I personally like lunber's duet. Have been repeating it nonstop now
same here
same here. like 10x already :)
+mis nis cant get it off my head. haha.. their voices really blend well together. T.T
+Code Zero haha . n i like hear it continuously . then download it as mp3 . save it in my song album n listen to it again
Amber's vocals are so underrated -subunit please-
This is my first time hear Amber singing !! she got beautiful voice .! cryinnnn ...OMG , am i the only one?
+Miyup Sugar Check out her solo album! Its full of her beautiful voice and songs she wrote herself! Also check out her cover on BoA song!
lol no you're not the only one
Go to her singing cover
Check out her song with Eric! It's in english
check out her latest songs, also she sang IJustWanna live with Eric nam at kconla few days ago. I just wanna live was so good!
amber is so good someone help me sm should just make her sing i think her voice can actually be the best in the group with more focus on it. her singing is so emotional and soothing it really touched me
Totally agree !!!😭
She's sung plenty of parts on all of their albums.
+missraindrop22 SM is making her sing, she has plenty of singing lines in the 4 walls album. She's a good singer but better than Luna? Probably never.
+Taose HunHan Calm it's her/his opinion. we all know that Luna has a wonderful voice, she's an amazing singer. In my opinion Luna is better and has a good technique but if amber trains her voice seriously like luna who knows. , so you saying "probably never" don't be so negative :) LunBer are amazing singers
Amber Liu Lol everyone is calm. They weren't being negative they were being honest with their opinion just like the original commenter was.
Amber got chosen for her vocals during audition. But SM placed her as the rapper of the group when she sings perfectly well than she raps. That's their biggest mistake in my opinion.
Her live vocals here improved tremendously ever since her solo debut. Her breathing good and overall, it's stable now. I'm so proud of her. I hope she's happier, now that she is more exposed to singing stage than rap. :)
+Minderp Bang
in an interview, Amber said that she wanted to try rapping and be the rapper not SM. Both of their mistake is not working on her vocals because she sounds good so far but with more practice I am sure she can be as good as Luna.
+whytedaises exactly, Luna's technique is so good, but mostly because Amber's coach totally didnt train her that much with her singing parts. When she sings on stage she seems a bit weaker than the other vocals, but her emotions and voice are total gold! she raps pretty well too
@@felixslettuuce7153 I think Amber's vocals are not weak, she is in third place in f(x) even many people say that Amber and Krystal's vocal abilities are only slightly different
back then, very little Asian female rappers
fyi, Amber here is not feeling well, during rehearsal she looks like she has a cough in many times and some fans said Luna was sick too at that time but they can still perform like this, so professional and so good😁
regardless of who won, both team did a GREAT job and i have never been prouder. thanks sugarman for giving us fans the opportunity to let these gems shine
This is so perfect it hurts, they are so talented, I'm so proud of my babies, f(x) is the best!!
Amber's singing is pure gold and Luna's voice is just beyond me, they really need to have a album together. My bias is Amber, but both of them together is just woahhh. Love you Amber and Luna. Fx Fighting!!!~
Amber and Luna were the least popular members from f(x) now they finally get to shine with amber's solo projects and Luna's multiple appearances on variety songs! So proud of my UBs hopefully they will Luna will get a solo album and amber will release more songs that show her vocals like borders
i remember when amber and luna sang acoustic nu abo and thinking 'wow this pair should sing together more often'. sm, why did you hid such precious gem that is Luna and Amber?
Luna is great as always. But Amber! Dang girl! What the actual f****?!?!?! And tell me again why they lost?
Because people think that MAMAMOO was better!!!
I don't know why but I think f(x) is better not being biased at all but they are my bias
I only checked this performance because people were hating on mamamoo for winning. Although there wasn't as much money put into mamamoo's stage, they sang with great emotion and showed versatility. Solar showed great control of her voice, and moonbyul delivered a great rap with good slow flow.
+Pineapple Buddies People 'think'? And why do they 'think'?
+seulgi bear I agree. Even though this performance was amazing. Also myself being a stan for f(x), I find mamamoo's performance honestly amazing.
+YUANitis They are good but there are some parts they are quite unstable and don't balance very well... And Luna's part before the high note was kinda lacking... I am not an expert on this but yeah it just doesn't sound quite right.
TBH i didn't know Amber can sing! that's so good!
+Jeremy Kwan you should listen to her solo album!
she was casted into SM for her singing skills
+Jeremy Kwan Listen to her solo album. Beyond Shake that Brass is a collection of her singing skills.
Is anyone here now? :'3
Yup
i wanna cry when i hear amber's singing part.. her emotions of sadness was alive when singing this.. !! i feel her expression towards this song love love love
When Amber started singing, she seriously honestly moved my heart. 😭😭❤❤ Amazing duet. ❤❤❤
To me, this version by Luna and amber wins, i don't like the original version but i have to say this version is too touched. By the way, i like the original version of ' Like yesterday' but don't like the version by Mamamoo. So strange, right? So sad that they didn't win but it's fine, i really love this version! Luna unie, Amber unie, fighting!!!!
Fall in love with Amber's singing voice
Amber killing us all and her harmonization with Luna... You guys make an album. NOW!!!!! Good job my babies.
bring this kpop gen back pls
For me I luv lunber more. They not only sing very well but also sing into my heart. Btw Amber surprise me that she can sing that well. Luna always is my favourite vocalist. Lunber should have a unit
when you realize that amber voice is way better than krystal LOL
well Amber has a more angelic, beautiful voice, but Krystal has better techniques in singing
Dude I knew that from the beginning..
she has a very warm and beautiful tone .. really lovely
she's the best for me. Her voice is so soulful and beautiful,,i could listen to her songs all day long.
Frida Ibarra Both Krystal and Amber have quite similar vocal techniques.They are both tied as the second strongest vocalists in f(x).
Three times i watched this , and still looking at amber's jawline ...fight me
tika sartika 😂😂😂😂👌her jawline cuts me❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Yeah x) ,i trust u
Im already bald what else are you gonna do to me 😭😭😭???
Amber and Moonbyul raps are amazing but when they sing is x1000 better. Their voices are so soft
Amber has better style and class than a lot of boys in Kpop lol Loved it so sweet.
i know luna and amber did very welll.but the song is really good.this could have been an OST for a drama
TRUEE
Amber is like a perfect Prince(ss) Charming
엠버 보컬 들을 때마다 느끼는 건데 외국인 아이돌 중에서도 한국어 발음이 진짜 좋은 편 같음 한국어 말할 때도..
To me they won : ) I'm sorry Mamamoo
+yilinnay saaaaaame. LunBer sounded amazing.
+yilinnay me too i like this song more than mamamoo´s rendition eventhough i love both a lot :D
+yilinnay I liked both performances but if I hadn't known the results, I would've thought this one would win. Beautiful performance
Imagine how many songs Luna sang before coming to the show. She must've been so tired. But still she's so bright. 😊
+yilinnay nice performance!! though I like Mamamoo's rendition slightly more. but thtz music, we all have difference preferences. (ps. Amber's voice is soso charming, wish to listen to her singing more!)
What did we do to deserve this little llama?
Well done you two, you guys did an awesome job!
Amber/Luna fans-
Instead of saying F(x) were more deserving of winning, how about congratulating Mamamoo?! They were both really good. Mamamoo won, as preference of the voters (and I agree). Go and watch Mamamoo's performances and tell me they aren't of of, if not THE, only girl group with extremely good vocal ability across the board instead of concentrated in one member. To all the haters; bye felicia.
I'm so into this. So perfect
good performance. amber is like key in shinee. they r so good at balancing d vocals or harmonizing. tho she seems breathy. she is always like this when she sings. myb her lung capacity is not great. but overall, nice performance from them. Luna, ofc she was great as always. good job.
+Patricia Tirza Lapolwa mmhmm, i know what you mean. With Amber, I think it's a little bit nerves and mostly a lack of vocal training. She's so much better than she used to be - and she sounds great now that she's singing in her range. I think, with work, she's gonna get better breath control and be able to hold those notes longer. With that said, I think her vocal color is a bit airy and breathy, so idt that's gonna change.
And Luna...she's just so good. Imo, one of the best vocalists in kpop.
+kisskissbangbang Amber is always breathy since d very beginning. d difference is she is now has d confidence of showing off her vocal. she can sing well. i always knew it ever since i heard her so lil part "in so into u". her vocal color is so sweet airy but a lil bit heavy at d same time. it has charm i must say. she just lack in technique. and also she is always nervous when singing than rapping idk. but im sure she can improve. Luna is always amazing and Krystal's vocal always on point. those two always made a great duet. Amber is d 3rd best singer in f(x) so im very proud she has finally gained d confindence now n delievered such a good show. she did well considering this is like her first most long singing part in live perf with other members
Why is it that every single time I watch this, I end up crying?! 😂😭😂😭
Me too😭
+SYJ 015 😭😭😭😢
Okay,why the hell am I crying!!! Lunber needs an album seriously!!
They should have won. Amber is so amazing here. Love her voice so much!
I love how both Luna's pure voice and Amber's raw voice blend perfectly. That performance was a little moment out of this world =)
What the hell. AMBER NEEDS TO SING MORE OMG.
I'm ok if fx is just amber and luna. these 2 go well together.
I'm so proud of you guys!!! ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
wowww even though i dont understand but wow its really ah just wow luna ur voice amazing ❤❤❤❤ really u r a real super star ,, n Amber is there anything u cant do ? u r just perfect love u both 💖❤❤💙💙
اشتقت لكم اف اكس
I don't think it is fair to compare a faster paced and livelier song to a slow song. I personally liked f(x)'s Amber and Luna song better because I pref ballads. The song that left a bigger impression won imo. Mamamoo cover probably bought back many old memories for the audiences where as they weren't as familiar with Amber and Luna's song. Yes they were bought into tears and felt touched but to what extent? Whereas in mamamoo's song, the audience were introduced to familiarity. So compare and weight which would you prefer? A song that reminded you of what u are familiar with/ your youth or a song that touched your heart and make you cry. A fast paced song or a slow ballad song? .
With that being said, people who said moo won because of "skimpy" clothes, if you are calling long white pants and a turtle neck sweater(long sleeve) skimpy then I don't know what is wrong with you.
Stop starting needless fan wars. The audience voted not the artist themselves so leave them alone.
Love so much Amber Liu and Luna f(x).
OMG THEIR VOICES
LUNBER good job my girls
hello SM! can't u hear their duet?! wht the hell r u waiting for??
I simply can't describe how amazing this is. My friend said that Amber can't sing, I showed her this and she immediately retracted that statement. THIS IS BEAUTIFUL. I LOVE LUNA. I LOVE AMBER. They are so damn talented.
Amber's voice >>>> wall of china >>>> under the sea >>> krystal's
as much as i love Amber, lets just be real Krystal is better in term of singing. she is not breathy and she's got a strong vocal.. Amber's singing sometime is not stable n she often gets nervous when sings onstage. so maybe that is why krystal is d 2nd singer not Amber u know. both can sing well btw.
but on top of that Amber CAN sing so i see nothings wrong with her having a duet with Luna. she did well
+Lost Soul for a reason she is SM's favorite
+Patricia Tirza Lapolwa amber >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> krystal in everything since forever
+aveen sdiq lmao, no and never and never going to be.
+aveen sdiq let's see at the concert. who sings better, who got better breath, who got better voice.
Miss these two together. Amber and Luna have amazing vocals
Amber wow! You blew my mind away!!😍😍😍 Good job both of you!👍👍
I hope amber can sing a lot more and rap less. Luna's voice is so golden♡
간만에 엠버 생각나서 영상 타고 타고 왔는데 진짜 어뜨케 노래 왜케잘해? 랩 하는것만 듣다가 이런거 첨봤는데 와 나지금 좀 충격먹음😲😲😍😍😍
She entered SM because of her vocals but debuted as a main rapper
Miss them so much.
Luna and Amber and f(x) all member.
Luna improved so much! Her voice is so stable and it gives me goosebumps! WOOOOOOOOW!
Amber should totally go into Dramas. i love her so much
I LOVE AMBER VOICE
That was refreshing. Luna's vocals had me in my emotions. When she held that note while Amber was singing and then took it higher I got the chills and replayed it about 3 more times because it was just a "yes Luna slay" moment. And literally I'm so glad to hear Amber sing. I absolutely love when she sings and I hate that SM makes her rap. She's a better vocalist than she is a rapper. I'm not saying she's a bad rapper but she's a better vocalist and I wish SM would take advantage of that more.
best duo
f(x) really talent💜
Wowww Amber voice it's very surprise!!
I'm crying 😹
I want Luna solo next!!! 🙏🏻🙏🏻
2020년에도 듣고 있어요. 루나와 엠버 목소리 보물같음 ㅠㅠ
Wow holy llama's voice is amazing!!! And luna is totally beautiful!!
OMG this is amazing . Amber love you 💕💕
2022년에도 듣고잇음 크으👍👍
I'm listening to Lunber before going to sleep❤ you should try it too, it feels great!
Amber you are my bias!! fighting!! you're voice so beautiful!!! Amazing!!! ;) ☺😍👍💟
so beautiful song and voices of luna and amber... what's the title of this song?
just a love
I love MAMAMOO to bits but personally I liked this performance better
also is it wrong that I think my favourite singer in f(x) is Amber? lmao
OMG I CRIED!! MY BABIESSSSSS
y'all omg. 😍 I swear these ladies don't get the attention and praise they deserve.
Omg lunber that was awseme !!!!Amber your voice is ♥♥♥♥♥♥ i love you
I expected amber to be awesome and she was ... her album showcased her vocals plus her channel does as well. f (x) fighting
Gosh I keep on coming back and listening to this because it's so amazingly sung! :D (Though it might just be because I'm super Amber biased and am super happy to hear her sing...)
Yup back again It's been almost a year and I still keep on coming back to this
omfg amber those vocals made me loose my mind such wow i can't even
엠버 노래진짜 잘한다ㅜㅜ
OMG! three times king of mask singer! Luna is so amazing! especially the way she control her voice and perfect pitch!!
amazing my f(x),my lulu my berber!!!
Luna has an amazing voice. I like the ending when she holds the high note.