Vladimir Putin criticises Greta Thunberg's UN speech on climate change - BBC News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2019
- Russian president, Vladimir Putin, has criticised Greta Thunberg's speech about climate change.
Speaking at an energy conference in Moscow, Mr Putin said: "Nobody explained to Greta that the modern world is complicated and complex."
Ms Thunberg, 16, gave a speech at the United Nations in New York in September as millions of people joined climate strike protests worldwide.
Please subscribe HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
I wouldn't say he is "criticising" her, he is simply pointing out that not everything is as simple as she thinks and cannot be solved as easily... In this case Putin is completely correct
Yes but ultimately greta’s speech is of world powers putting greed first over the constant build of world ecological problems, further cementing the idea that putin says its too hard, costs too much, africa coulda have went solar. No, africa is not a superpower that had invested to make more for generations, greed again :/
Yeah, that is criticism.
There is nothing wrong about pointing things out. Idk why all the defense
I would say that capitalizing on the idea of him "criticising" her is still wrong given that the criticism is very small.... But it obviously seems like it's all criticism because of the BBC editing out all the parts of commending her for what shes done...
Greta thinks it's easy to do all this just because she lives in a rich country with a huge pci. First go learn your economics lessons girl. And boy you don't get industrialization
Putin is usually completely correct.
Basically he is saying not everything is as simple as a 17 year old girl thinks.
She's not 17, she's 12 bruh, and is extremely clueless about the real world
@@Xishnik94 bruh
@@Xishnik94 Shes 12 in the head. Been taught too much conservatism and not enough of anything else. Not trying to bash conservatives but you can't just wish good things into existence because people like Greta think we are entitled to them. That's what uninformed conservatives do unfortunately and we should be teaching people to get into politics after they've studied other things or subcategories that build up to the vastness of knowledge and understanding required for politics. It isnt a simple issue to be resolved with simple answers, that's just not how things work in the real world of desperation like Putin is saying here. People in third world countries cant "have their cake and eat it too" without contributing to these issues because it would cost them their livelihood. Again as Putin said, go try and tell all those people to live in even more extreme poverty for 20-30 years to solve all the environmental and social issues for the future and see what they have to say about it. No one did it for them, why should they?
@@Charlie-nc3cp ROFL she's not a conservative, she's a conservationist. Conservatives are the ones peddling oil.
@@Xishnik94 still conservative on the political scale.
He's not criticizing Greta, he's condemning who's using her
who's using her? what evidence do you have for this?
@@afgor1088 so called Liberal woke politicians & pseudo-liberal activists & media.
@@afgor1088 You think that the girl just popped out from somewhere to speak in UN Climate Action Summit? :D
@@Alexidrum ok cool. So wheres your evidence
@@afgor1088 No need for evidence but common sense.
How right he is. It's a sad state of affairs when, once again, the President of Russia talks more sense and is more honest than any Western leader.
Love him and BHARATIYA PM🇷🇺🇮🇳♥️
It proves the Reality of World hidden by the Western Media.
The Competant and Good Leader is Putin (of course he's not the obky one)
And the terrible and actually evil ones (they're showing their real faces more and more) are the Western ones.
That is a truth that the French have actually woken up to
It isn't sad, it's time to pick our heroes and villains again.
@@iammakbiswas I thought you'd be more fond of the Ukrainian corrupt Nazis in this conflict Adolf?
thats why russia is winning
If a former spy says," people are using her", then it must be right
Was he a spy for the government or something?
@@lucalalsie5653 ya for the Government.
Putin was an old KGB agent
@@generalkenobi5173 kenobi, i thought you said you were not brave enough for politics
@@mangored209 its a new assignment yoda told me to take on i have no choice.
At least he argues with his brains, and not his emotions.
thats why people make him out to be evil, because he is a man of pure logic and facts
I always listen to him before those headshit democrats that hate Russia
People who are heartless cannot be persuaded. They are going to blazes.
Logic dictates we SHOULD do something about it.
Yeah thunberg is a crazy kid
Greta: "You stole my childhood"
Putin, who literally grew up in an 20qm apartment in a poor neighborhood and spent his childhood getting beaten up: "😕"
While she lives in one of the most comfortable countries in the world, with one of the best educations in the world.
@@dxwkx9119 jep, and people don't aknowledge that putin needed to fight hard to get her standard of education. She got it for free and throw away. Everyone can hate or love him, but not many people fought themselves so hard to the top like he did
his father was in the communist party and his grandfather was stalin's personal cook...he wasn't poor.
@@dxwkx9119 Her parents are an actor and a model. They are filthy rich. She's a hypocrite.
I grew up in a slum, where there were very many drugs. I witnessed my neighborhood burn. I think she lives a very cushy life.
Love him or hate him, you cannot deny that Putin knows what he is talking about
This comment aged like milk
@@thecoldcallerguy he's still speaking the truth tho
@@thecoldcallerguy LMAOO
@@chuno7354 He was right for attacking. Why should he let the Us place nukes on his border
In this context
Lol how is he criticising? He is stating facts. Typical BBC.
Facts doesn't exists, just interpretations and views.
Sicko Beats While True to a point. There are things such as Solid Facts. A Biological Male for example is a man and nothing else. A Tomato is a fruit, There are 24 hours in a Day.
Criticism doesn't necessarily mean something bad. Criticism can be healthy and constructive. There is nothing wrong with the title because Putin DID critice the fact that why Greta is doing what she is doing. Stating facts is part of criticism.
He is quite clearly criticising but in a constructive way which is much better than just being plain stupid
His facts are bullshit. These developing countries are not the current issue, but he chose to focus on them, why? Because he wanted to make a straw man. China can still change. The US can still change. Wealth of a country is not determined by carbon emissions, as they are simply a byproduct. A system that is punitive towards high emissions can also be supportive of green solutions. Did Putin mention anything like balance? Or focus on those that can make a change? No. No he just spouted a few pathetic examples, and people lap it up. We have the technology to make the difference needed, and it doesn't all hang on africa using solar!
"People in Africa want to be as wealthy as people in Sweden"
Truth have been spoken.
should be an Asterisk on there because not everyone is poor in Africa LOL.
@@prettyalina7237 Imagine being a billionaire but have no road to drive Lamborghini.
@@tonyb9735 we want a good life (like in Scandinavia and the west) not only food and water
africa is not the reason of global warming and yet we the nes who suffers the most from it
@@tonyb9735 well a lot of africans are dying because of hunger
at this point they don't care about if they gonna "probably" die of global warming in about 20 years,they care about what they gonna eat eat today and what they gonna feed their childrens tomorrow
and here we're talking about Greta and precisely when she said "stole my childhood" if the good childhood that she lived doesn't look good for her,what we can say about african childrens
@@tonyb9735
Lmao, go and explain it to the mother whose child is dying because of hunger!
"we just need to be realistic". Golden words !
We need to be realistic that we are destroying the planet and we don't take any responsibility about it.
We need to be realistic--thats what Greta is doing. There is a problem, acknowledge it and find solution. No one is demanding a solution in a snap of a finger, we all know this problem cannot be solved in a blink of an eye, but atleast our politicians and oil companies will acknowledge the problem and start brainstorming. Just because it is difficult to solve does not mean there is no solution. Elon Musk is doing something, building an E-cars, announced contest in public for best approach for carbon capture proposal, and many more. If oil companies and our government united to commit to find effective approach then we might have saved many lives and properties. I strongly believe there is a cost-effective approach to deal with this problem, we just need to figure it out and stop delaying.
@@hiimain7932
>Greta
>Realistic
LMAO
Sugarcoating bad situation no matter how you like it to be via rose glasses, its like a meme "i am ok with the events that are currently unfolding".
@@haykelg340 Who told you we don't take any responsibility? That's a dumb statement to start with. What does the development of new greener technologies mean apart from us becoming more conscious of our impact on the planet and striving to minimize it? THINK AGAIN.
"You have stolen my childhood dreams!"
[Departs in a sailboat]
This is not a critical. He is raising a valid point.
What is exactly valid about his "point" ? Isn't it what he's saying is that the human ego, wealth, greed, money, power is not itself the big problem of humanity? This is called conditioning. A child understands life better than adults, because a child is actually able to understand and perceive life in an objective and pure manner, rather than the mind's corruption and control everyone is living in. If we want to go even deeper, the problem itself of humanity is this human thinking focused on things such as money and corrupted systems. Also, as a matter of fact, this planet is dying, scientists also know that, then if we want to "explain to people" that they will eventually live in poverty, isn't "poverty" by definition 'living well so another can live in poverty' since there is no equality in this world, and we are all humans ? These are only "superficial" thinking created by the human mind himself which makes him care about 'money', a piece of paper, which is also a human creation. Humans are the ones who've created all these superficial concepts from the very beginning, combined with superficial thinking, that made this planet itself suffer from an unnatural imbalance. So to "explain that people cannot live in poverty" to her, is superficial, because it is a human creation with human concepts and thinking. And as a child who still have an unconditionned vision about life and about how it SHOULD REALLY BE, she is more right than these leaders only thinking about money, wealth and power. If this earth is about to die, what will all this money serve to? They will just die with the dying planet, and all this caring about money and superficial concepts will be totally pointless because their lives will be threatened. Maybe only then, they will realize they've got it all wrong from the very beginning. She questions the corruption itself about how systemes are put and are working, and that's exactly why they disagree with her, because she threatens their influence and power.
Mōrrigan Phronesis look mate ! Let me educate. First of all Planet is not dying. You say scientist agree on it. Well scientist agree on the fact that climate models are inconclusive. And all the models that predicted global warming, have failed.. and were not able to predict the current climate. Climate depends on many factor and CO2 is not one of the fundamental factors. Water vapor is the most important one. And the paper of science you’re referring or the one with 97% of scientist agree that human activities have affected climate change. Was a survey on just 77 scientists. And the extent to which they have consensus about is still debatable and not mentioned. Plus most of the worlds climatologist don’t agree on climate change. Look you may not be from a third world country, but I am. And I cannot stand your hypocrisy while you could be staying on a heated room with all facilities. We don’t even have 24 hours of electricity. And you want the world to slow it’s economic growth. So our countries can remain poor, hungry. Annually 400 billion dollars is separated for climate change. While 30-40 billion dollars can solve poverty. Because of CO2 our planets ecosystem has never been better. Moreover renewable sources of energy is very expensive. Very very unreliable. He raises a valid point ...” because you should go and tell the hungry kids in Africa that they will still be in hunger cause the planet is dying and there’s no money to provide energy or food for them, then you’d know.
Mōrrigan Phronesis never seen a youth being this misinformed, look I don’t have anything against her nor does Putin. Cause the planet is not dying. Just 100 years ago there were more dangerous disasters. And one more thing.. science says the earths climate is a spectrum it warms for a while then cools for a while and then it’s on repeat. Educate yourself mate before arguing with someone who actually knows facts. Rather than being overwhelmed by emotions of the world is dying do something to help the poor.
Mōrrigan Phronesis Renewable sources of energy is a new source for the rich to get richer. “ renewable sources are heavily unreliable “ that’s bill gates words. The rich can afford renewables but the poor can’t. Fossil fuel is a cheap and reliable source of energy. It could have been the backbone of your country economic development. Now, when the developing countries want to do the same thing .. you are like (no no no). Hypocrisy at its finest. Did you know as she mentions people are dying.. did she know “the number of people dying because of cold is 20 times than people dying because of heat. And you want to cool the planet. “ that is by a scientist in Cambridge. Stop being misinformed and go for the real facts. The history of earth doesn’t start at 1970s like you believe. It started millions of years ago and you could ask the scientist personally they will answer “the earth was warmer back then” and people survived. They will also agree on the fact “that the amount of carbon dioxide on the atmosphere in the past was really really high compared to the levels it is now.” So just stop it. I feel sad for her cause she is being weaponized so the people can make money of her.
@@shalombhatta6419 Apparently you're totally missing the point i'm trying to say. I've never said the poor should stay poor, if not the exact CONTRARY. I also come of one of the poorest countries in the world, which actually explains the whole message i'm trying to send, about the world's leaders sucking out people's money. My words are targetting this exact point : The abusive governements. And i was also pointing a bigger point, which is NOT the climate change itself, i think you should read my comment more than once before arguing back about a message you didn't get anything about, if something, you understood the total opposite of it, since you're so focused on "knowledge and information", which, for me, information can always be changed and controlled, by the medias, that are themselves the governement's and leader's puppets.I didn't really talk about climate change in case you didn't notice. :) What i was trying to say all along is that humans are spiritual beings, who lives in a superficial world full of bullshit, poverty, limitations, corruption, and inequality. Climate change is nothing but a triggering subject to actually start ACTING and THINKING to CHANGE the world to a better world for all of us! That was my point, and this has absolutely nothing to do with what you understood from it. Everyone DESERVES to live and have a happy life, and the planet should be protected and cared of. If climate change isn't real for example, POLLUTION is, POVERTY is, HUMAN GREED is, and so on. These superficial ego concepts that makes life for everyone so shitty, especially for an empath as myself. I don't need to be personally touched by a disaster to feel sorry for others, this world's unfairness and stupidity is making me sick, and for me, this child is nothing but a trigger for people to actually start thinking and try to make a real change by becoming themselves the change they want to see in the world. Climate change itself wasn't the issue of my message, because it has a more pacific and harmonious view toward how human life should be, and i despise any kind of superficiality. The issue here is the societies and systems themselves, and liar politicians that aren't caring at all about humanity's or nature's sake. And there is more to life than power, wealth and money, than the superficial views of politicians and governments. We could all live harmonious and happy life, yet the human ego is so blind that he limits himself to such limited and corrupted concepts. THAT, was my message, not what you understood.
BBC is smart they cut the part where Putin says "what if kids in Africa wants to live like thunburg"
they ran out of storage. They use an 240p and 2 GB smartphone.
@@ndave2633 they use nokia 3310
Oh snap
she is basically living the dream, travelling around 'saving the world' it could be a disney cartoon series...
@mcwolfus 1 yes, okay. my little sister once saw a 'save the polar bears' advert on TV. she was convinced it was the biggest problem ever! one that must be sorted immediately! etc etc.
it's a child's point of view, where things are simple. she would have loved nothing more than to go on an adventure to save those polar bears.
would she have considered anything else? the cost of it? accommodation? how to do it? the dangers? that polar bears are not cuddly friendly animals, etc etc?
no she considered none of that. because she's a child. that's greta, living the dream of a little girl, saving the world! it's nonsense. she's a tool for corporations to trick idiots into doing what they want.
I couldn’t agree more with Putin. Common sense and logic.
with an exception that it is not a common sense and logic, since its more than confirmed that people are going to have it much more worse then during covid times due to warming, and what he told that african people want also electric home appliances is a big lie, since Africa is the least contributor to the global warming and greenhouse gasses emissions. Understandable right? So tell me now please, where is that logic.
When Greta opens her mouth, all I hear is BLAH BLAH BLAH! 😏
@@ionphaser7092 what he is saying is that African countries will prioritise the development of the quality of life of their citizens before being concerned about environmental issues (being a developed country usually correlates with concern for the environment). Therefore, it is quite complex as to how to ensure that these countries can develop whilst not exacerbating the effects of climate change over the next 50-100 years. His basic point is that if it were easy to ‘take action’ and solve climate change then it would have already been taken - the issue is that there are so many variables to control for, as well as the fact that the cost of the transition to renewable energy sources will be massive. I think that is a reasonable thing to say, and that tackling climate change should be done in a responsible cost/benefit way so as to protect people’s livelihoods whilst addressing the issue with alacrity
@@NUFCcomps No matter that once africa will want to get more developed, when we have problem now when africa produces 2 percent of global warming contribution and we produce 98 percent of it, so we cant scapegoat 2 percent contributor (2 percents wont save us), no matter how you want to sugarcoat that nonsense, if you thought about it at least for a second.
@@ionphaser7092 I’m not scapegoating them, I don’t know why you’re suggesting that. It’s pertinent to climate change that as these countries develop, they will likely seek out energy sources that are cheaper (fossil fuels). That’s the point, not that African countries are at fault for climate change. If any country is to be blamed, it would be China given that they are the biggest emitter and are making a slower transition in comparison to western countries
Greta: You have ruined my childhood.
3rd world bois: Stop Talking ! I need to study for the entrance exam, it's the only chance I have to escape poverty.
What did she even mean by "ruined my childhood"?
@@sr3821 She is a puppet.
Putin: Be more realistic
Greta: How dare you...
Trump: Have fun Greta, go to the movies...
The Left: Stop bullying!
RC RC how dare you
@@PrimalMiltos I'm left leaning and I can't stand the sight of greta :p so shush, stop bullying me lok
Mansplain
@RC RC well said!
Bbc really? He's pointing out the facts.. He's barely criticising...
They cut this so carefully as well, his full answer is much more factual.
@@radagast1184 how is this relevant to the video?
@@radagast1184 And how is what you asked relevant to what we are discussing?
Hmm ? BBC is actually fair here. Everyone seeing this will agree with Putin. CNN would never show this.
I don't hate Greta nor I'm a big fan of Putin but i'm just stating fact about BBC. If Fox News or Daily Mail posted the exact video everyone would thank them for being fair, not being MSM etc...
@@Sepia1989 Check the full clip sir. They left out what doesnt fit their agenda. They are being more fair than CNN etc that is for certain, but not as fair as they could be.
I just Love him..He is so intelligent, starightforward, and clear in his thoughts. He is realistic and talk facts instead of hipocrisy as shown by westerners
Wtf
this aged like milk inside of a black car on a hot summer day in death valley.
@@calebwinterbottom8787 No it didn't. Not everyone braindeadly and blindly follows Western propaganda into supporting Ukraine. We have our reasons.
@@moss1w are you a cheerleader of death then?
How come children had to die? Do you like innocent people being killed?
You must like children and mothers being killed. How long have you been a supporter of murdering people?
Greta Thumberg is the example of how we live in a foolish time frame where a problematic little girl speak to the UN and high podium speaking like a scientist. Shame on her parent that have been using her for years.
Honestly, Putin is really spitting facts. Couldn’t agree more
Is this Sarcasm?
@@cpulord2685 no bruh, what putin said is real
7Evan - Rainbow Six Siege and More. Not at all. Climate change is gonna cause shit but it’s not easy to change with economic circumstances in places
*song of denise starts*
Anoushka S yes Putin himself decided to tip all that oil in himself didnt he.Yk for the vine.
Greta: I should be in school
Putin: You're damn right
She did so much effort to travel around the Earth and make speeches, just to have an excuse to not going school
@@user-and-id i agree with u
@the7thsea jesus christ probably has a better education then you
😠😠 The world leaders is gonna pay very bad for stand against Greta. AND IS GONNA HURT VERY BAD FOR YOU. I DARE YOU!! WE MUST DO GOOD DEEDS FOR THE CLIMATE CHANGE!!!
@@zvukovinb5581 As much as I hate it. It is true.
when a real life bond villain is the only one in the room making sense!
He's got a hit list! Watch out Greta! 🙈
BUT he is wrong. Australia,China, US, Russia, western Europe, and all these petrol states in the middle east POLLUTE the most and are middle income or rich countries not poor
@@edwardr8826 BUT you are wrong...are have at least misunderstood what he said. I suggest you listen to what he said again. He said Africa is the poorest, not the one with the most pollution....Also western europe is quite clean...and so is Australia I believe. I don´t know too much of russia...but I never heard of them when it comes to massive pollution....that would be mainly China, second india...and to a degree, the USA (though that would be mainly Co2).
@Jim Spencer That is entirely.....
Accurate sir.
@@Enrico_Palazzo_opera_singer don't say China or india because per capita pollution in these countries are lowest in the world
Short,simple,realistic and 100% right! World leaders should admire the man for having the guts to say what he means.(as opposed to just thinking it)
Love him or hate him
He's speaking straight facts here
King Thimio SHO ME DA WAE BRUDDA
@@rameezhalani5593 WE HAVE TO FIND DA QUEEN FELLO BRUDDA
I agree with him
Hate him but he's right this time
@Paul Gurnic Не понял
like it or not, he's spitting straight facts
It's not like we're going to hear a response from a panelist that disagrees with Putin.
Climate change is a problem but if you want to help the world going on some rant explaining how it is morally wrong to continue being ignored is not enough. (well maybe in a society that is under extreme conflict under an issue that is ignoring you deliberately without any good reason however here it is lack of resources and funding) You better act within the law to get things sorted.
@@engineergaming5989 well the issue Putin raises is that climate will be extremely difficult to solve in a way that's perceived as "fair" because it's politically impossible for developing countries to switch to clean energy as it would effectively guarantee them 20-30 years of extreme poverty due to it not being affordable for them while switching to "dirty" energy would allow them to develop much faster. Unless we're willing to provide the absolutely massive amount of funding to allow developing countries to industrialize on *clean* energy, they're going to continue burning coal.
harld kardika he usually does
oh he's clean gangsta
Exactly my thoughts when I heard about Greta. Transitioning to renewable energy overnight is impossible, and berating nations for not being able to do so is both unfair and unrealistic. It's far more complicated than it seems, and to do it in such a rapid pace would mean you have to ask the populace to endure hardship for several years, because you would have to phase out and replace a lot of the existing infrastructure to accommodate the rapid change, hence why the solution to climate change is slow, otherwise it would be too unbearable.
Greta is actually quite the hypocrite. The only reason she can say those things is because she lives a comfortable life. Stole her childhood? Face people who are actually from Africa and Asia, see if you can keep a straight face saying that to them face to face without facing immedaite backlash from the crowd of Africans and Asians fighting everyday just ro survive and demand that they do something about climate change whem they can barely feed themselves.
This is gold. Thanks for your thoughts
She's not talking about poor Asian and African countries tho.
She's talking about rich industrialized countries that are still mining coal and using oil for profit.
Exactly! Instead of blaming everyone for ' Ruining' her childhood, she should visit some parts of Asia and Africa and see what childhood looks like in there. They are literally trying just to survive. And here our the great Greta says, everyone ruined her childhood?! How selfish and ignorant!😑
He is definitely more experienced than a girl who left her schools.
@RadioTSM {Operator Teddy Timis} true.
Yes
She didn’t finish any school
So as most of the leaders and chief Ministers and even prime minister of India!
@@amanhasnoname1052 bro he finished school
This is copied straight from wiki
In 1978 Modi received a Bachelor of Arts degree in political science from School of Open Learning[53] at University of Delhi,[54][55] graduating with a third class.[56] Five years later, in 1983, he received a Master of Arts degree in political science from Gujarat University, graduating with a first class[57][58] as an external distance learning student.[59]
I’m not a huge Putin fan, but I would in no way call this being critical. He brings up a very good point actually.
Mysterious Muffin not really. How does that affect the economies that are causing the majority of the problem (Russia, China, the USA)? Those are the worlds strongest economies. They could all very easily enforce a switch to solar power and wind farms, which would solve a significant portion of the problem. But the answer to that is ‘Africa can’t afford to do it, so we aren’t going to either’. Nope, sorry, that’s just not good enough.
Ultima2876 But the thing is those countries won’t STAY the largest economies if they all switch so drastically, therefore making the situations in Africa and Asia worse. Listen, I’m all for environmental protection and everything, and I consider my politics left wing. However I recognise that it’s not as simple as “let’s just all change and it will all be good”. It’s a gradual process, it took thousands of years for us as a species to even learn to use electricity for example.
Kellen As I said before, I’m not a huge fan of Putin. I’d rather have the former Soviet Union back over him. However you must acknowledge he isn’t being critical of Greta here, in fact he’s supportive of her. However I, as a progressive myself, recognise that sometimes we have unrealistic expectations.
Russia is only the powerhouse that it is now because of Stalin’s rapid industrialisation of the nation during the 30’s. However under his regime millions perished, both directly and indirectly due to his policies. Considering how heavy the toll was to achieve that the Russian people would obviously be extremely weary to see that happen again.
Therefore is installing some solar panels really worth that happening again? As I said before, I support environmentalist movements and the like, however it takes time for a country to change that much, and as we’ve seen throughout history when we rush things disaster strikes.
Miss Fortune The same reply goes for your comment as well.
@@Ultima2876 Tell me what are you gonna do about it ?
This guy speaks less but when he speaks , he speaks to the point .
really? I saw him recently holding a monologue for more than two hours, ranting on and on and on and on about how the West was ruining it all for his ambitions...
"My brother always told me that nothing said before the word 'but' really counts." 😀
Wait this is from got right
Ahh i think you took that from GOT .lol
Well I mean he put in quotation marks so he didn’t technically pass it off as his own?
I didn’t expect to find Tyrion here but I’m glad I did.
"Our abusive mom is dead, but she left us a lot of money." Proved your pseudo wise quote wrong, didn't I?
"You adults have ruined my life"
*lives in a first world country with cleaner air than 90% of the world*
First world problems
@Super Aggressive UA-cam Commentary wanted?
@@mavericksingh835 not her, but the tool kit which she shared on her Twitter is wanted cuz it was clearly misleading and Anti-Indian. So basically, the creator of that tool kit is in the list.
@@devanshsingh3369 ohh ok I think she is just a child and like every teenager she likes attention. She needs a break 😂
It wouldn't surprise me if one of Soros left Thinktanks are pushing her through her parents activities.
He didn’t even criticize her wtf is bbc doing
Bbc is doing what bbc has always done. Propaganda
its called yellow journalism
Just repeating the narrative
Umm... the title doesn't say he criticizes her.... it says he criticizes her speech.
Sorry you can't comprehend english.
Acting like CNN.
at least there's 1 world leader who lives in reality
He is not criticizing, he is spitting out facts that people doesn't not want to realize.
A problem they've turn their head from.
Putin: "The Earth is round";
BBC: "Putin said the earth is flat"
Biased
Bull
Crap
BBC:"Putin criticized the Earth"
What if everything he said was translated false deliberately so that the British who are working will American allies are putting Putin under a bad name, therefore making Putin the one in the wrong.
Janet not at all, translation is correct, and no criticises on it neither
Ok now hear me out for a sec. Just because a person is not sharing generell opinion with someone else, it dont makes all arguments of his opponent false by definition. I dont like Russias Geopolitics, Economics and Putins foreign policy, but I can agree to this: 0:38. Cause his argumentation includs high truth value that I have to accept, untill anyone who has a real solution to this REAL LIFE problem falsifies it. Now sad enough western leftists and far right thugs and trolls cant think that way, and don't present us real solution, but straight up fantasy ideology.
Dang, Putin not only roasts people for using a teenage girl, he also explains that it's not realistic for countries especially poor ones to just go eco friendly.
Going "eco friendly" is not only expensive, it's super inefficient as well, engineers have already explained that solar panels only perform at 30% and most countries clear out fields just to install them, which makes it not green at all, and then there's wind power, it's so obvious that not all parts of the world has a constant gush of wind strong enough to spin the blades of the windmill everyday, and to top all that they're expensive to create and maintain. So here you go, why aren't you forcing the rich countries instead of the poor ones
@@santiagocortez9554humanity has always managed to do the impossible it just takes us time....we already have a lithium-silicon battery than lasts about 25 times more than its lithium ion counterpart....its expected to be in consumer electronics and cars very soon
@@santiagocortez9554 Yeah, honestly we should just go for nuclear energy.
@@santiagocortez9554 You mean solar panels convert 30% of solar energy that would go unused otherwise to electricity. That does not make them more expensive than fossil fuels, in fact it's cheaper (link in comment above).
@@unevilGenius well you're talking about it in a first world kinda sense, it's so expensive here in 3rd world countries where one panel's worth of money can already feed a family for a month, they're most usually not produced in our countries which means they are imported adding more to their already expensive price, you don't understand how much of a load that would be to us poor people
Edited.
Where is the complete speech? UNEDITED, PLEASE.
Only leader in the entire world
Who talks common sense
And is realistic and tells it as it really is
Well said Vladimir
I'm Swedish and I second this 100%. It's ludicrous how much attention Greta has received.
that‘s the interesting part. Why a little girl can receive so much attention？Because she is used by the adult. Maybe some big companies? they know if the words come out from a child, people will be more willing to believe.
@@user-gm7jg6of8j ua-cam.com/video/eZq6F5RkSno/v-deo.html
@Royal Satan and the plight of FaschTube ua-cam.com/video/eZq6F5RkSno/v-deo.html
@Royal Satan and the plight of FaschTube that's right
@Crimson Mist Yep. But people start to waken up. MSM brainwashing alot of ppl worldwide
BBC can't even make putin look bad even if they try lol.
BBC is a fake news channel
XMG3 Do you know anything about how russia under Putin works?
Mate they can trust me anyone can
criticism is not bad, i can critizise anybody, critizism is a way to point mistakes .
@@tiyabharati540 In Russia people beyond the capital and St Petersbourg live and die in poverty, taxes increase, and salaries decrease. for example, teachers earn an average of $ 300. budget places at universities are shrinking. what can this person be respected for? for competent foreign policy? perhaps. but not to the inhabitants of Russia.
I thought that Putin would somewhere say "what color is your Bugatti"🤣🤣
"Vladimir Putin saying straight facts" that should be the title!
A million things you can criticize Putin for, this isn’t one of them. Everything he said was spot on and correct.
Yeah, he says that, but that's not what he does.
His mouth isn't very his money is at
It's weird, listen to him speak on any matter and you'll have a similar reaction. I know he's accused of awful things but he seems to just exude logic, sense and intelligence whenever he speaks.
@@sheev9959 what the fuck
@X O says nope but no evidence to support 👏👏
Why can’t the rest of the world think realistically like this man?
Broken Down GTI because most politicians use Greta’s-like speeches for their own interest.
Because what we have is superficial pretentious human beings thinking they are small little islands floating about the sea
Broken Down GTI because putin don't need votes，so he can say any truths
Because reality is often disappointing.
People feed on unrealistic and unfeasible goals to push a movement. Somehow, those are the ones that get popularized without question.
"She seems to be a very happy girl and is going to have a nice future"
-Donald trump
Putin is as cool as he is right. Greta be like "How dare youuuu!" 🤣
Now this is a real politician
His heart is cold,
And his moves are bold,
His speech? I'm sold.
I'm sorry don't like this
Your rhyme is old.
@@birthdayzrock1426 well ur mom is old L
I feel like i have heard this from somewhere. A music video yes i remmber
@@Texonical lol typical 8 yrs old
Like him or not, he doesn't sound as moronic as our current political leaders.
@@nothingtowatch3708 to clarify, American political leaders.
@@Cw81Deut6n4 Trump is smarter than him, which is why the USA economy is booming and everyone elses is slagging.
right mr. Putin speak truth, we develop country want become like eropa
@@bud389 I supported Trump with my vote. I'm not hating on him. The left though.. goodness. But even Trump says too much. Putin just sounds like a real leader when he speaks. I'm sure we don't hear everything about him that he does or that has happened.
Putin and moronic shouldn't even be used in the same sentence lol
The dislikes are from those who prepared their speeches after watching Greta’s.
I think politicians shouldn’t be considered about what children say, and children shouldn’t have chance of having a speech on UN specially about such an important subject.
UN is nearly useless and not that important anymore.
Unless they from north Korea
Hes right about using children and teenagers as advertisements
The nazis did it
That's funny coming from a guy who used children as a propaganda device for discriminating against gay people.
i feel an argument
She is also an advertisement for the World Economic Forum.
Somehow I don't think her speech was the typical pre-prepared school drama. If it was then she should really consider an acting career.
The real problem is world greed, excess comfort and convenience and the competition to fuel all the greed. People's hearts so hardened except to everything materialistic.
Solve these problems and climate change will solve itself.
He isn't criticizing .....just giving another side of view...which is right as well to certain extent
Ram Chandra Patel this is the most accurate comment i have seen so far
Themcplayer 01
Yeah, sure, a side heard a hundred times: we know we should do something, well, yes, but it costs money, we have more urgent priorities, the situation is not as bad as those scientists say, we have still time, they exaggerate to scare us and manipulate this poor kid. And we cannot deny emergent countries’ desire to have a similar level of comfort as us and to make sacrifices ... and I could go on and on forever. This other viewpoint and accurate comment is just the pretext to inaction that Greta Thunberg has been denouncing since months. So much for nuance !
they just want their side of the climate debate. These fools dont realize that there is a whole world's worth of problems out there and there is no ONE magic hammer to fix them all.
the parents of thunberg dont think they are doing it for their own interest,they might indeed be fanatical ecologists.
Exactly, but this is BBC.
Love him or hate him
He’s speaking straight up Russian there
😂🤘
Putin "schools" Greta, not criticizes! He is absolutely right!
"Go and explain to them that they must live in poverty" Putin has no chill, but he is right. Dudes woke.
Exactly. Wise choice of words he has.
@@pineapplecastella2584 yup
“Chill” is something people assume we need only since millennials have insisted upon it. This is real life...
@@loudane9962 you right
@@loudane9962 Ok boomer
This isn’t him criticizing greta, but instead pointing out it would be a lot harder to do than she thinks
But just because it's hard doesn't mean it shouldn't be done.
@@larsswig912
Yes, just because it's obscenely expensive doesn't mean we shouldn't attempt to annihilate the world economy in pursuit of the small chance of succeeding.
N75911
We are going to have to pay for this no matter what. We will have to adapt. The human race is at stake.
@@N75911_ economies can recover sooner or later, but the earth won't recover unless we do something, it'll keep getting worse and worse.
Lars's Wig agreed
I'm with Putin on this one lol
Greta is saying what everyone's saying but she's saying it with help of a paper!! BTW putin has absolutely schooled her in a classy manner as she said she should be at her school!!!!
PUTIN: She is a girl
MEDIA: Putin slams Greta.
Why aren't the privileged climate activists living and protesting in China and India? which create most of the world's pollution.
@@PeopleHealthTru hello there i think u forgot to include america .
@@atlasknox7514 sorry but USA has strict pollution controls and is cleaner than Europe. Paris Accord just wants USA to pay for everyone else's pollution control.
@@atlasknox7514
ua-cam.com/video/wRk1p8Lzwvo/v-deo.html
Shapiro mentioned that the leading reductor in emissions is the united states.
People Health Truth before I’ve been in US I thought it was polluted af. I’m from Eastern Europe. Except some bigger cities i was way wrong.
Japan is the cleanest country I ever been though.
Putin: points out that it is not easy for developing countries to use renewable energy sources
BBC: Vladimir Putin criticises Greta Thunberg's UN speech
Lol This is so true. Not against her, but she grew in a highly developed country where she lived a quality life. Developing countries need to use non-renewable resources because that's how their economy works and asking them to not do so, is like asking the poor to stay poor.
@@sjegannath6295 i agree
It should be against her. Paper reading, teleprompter little kid who should enjoy being a kid. Her words mean nothing to me at all. Check out the backseat of her free tesla car. Potato chip bags, plastic soda bottles, maybe her choice in foods will let her know that she is nothing to me. Put all your money into saving the earth. Its been thru plate techtonics, bombarded by meteorites, contintental drifts, wildfires, and you think a little plastic bag from the backseat of your electric car is going to save lives? The earth is fine. The earth will just shag us off like a bunch of fleas. Start all over again. Its happened before. The earth is fine, Were the ones who are fucked. Just the earths time to rejuvinate, like flowers in the spring. Or just tell dumbasses to not use pyrotechnics for a baby reveal in a high fire warning area. (I dont care if you have kids or their gender, just dont burn the land.)
@@sjegannath6295 yh but climate change is definitely real
lol😂😂
He’s totally correct in what he’s saying I agree with him
I totally agree with him.
Greta ice thunberg don't know how geopolitics work....how this technologies are not available to everyone...
This isn’t criticism. He’s raising a valid point.
Thats pretty much the definiton of criticism
It's criticism, but its pointed at 'people using the youth for their own interests' not Greta or her speech.
VALIDmir Putin
Okay I’ll leave now
@Obi Dark 14 or 70 if you're going to deliver a speech at the UN, being watched by million be ready to get criticized. And she's 16
@Obi Dark I don't see your ass at the United Nations
I'm not a fan of putin, but he's speaking straight facts.
@jordan belfort His decision killed Litvinenko and the Novichok stuff in England is fishy
Actually I do know a lot about politics, just like you do. Did I ever say that the European leaders and US leaders were angels? no I didn't. In fact, the EU and US leaders are greedy and are causing lots of devastation in The Middle East and Russia is fighting against Daesh and saving Syria from Daesh. But it doesn't change the fact that almost all political leaders have skeletons in their cupboards.
Ethecatlady, also I'll have you know that I would rather live in Russia than live in Europe, I may be moving there soon. I also am Socialist/Communist
@@aspiknf What an argument over a shitty comment.
Arran Vid what a shitty argument
A lot of parts of translation are wrong. Now it doesn’t change anything, but in future for such platform as BBC it may become a big problem. Pay attention to correct translation, please.
Greta: you stole my childhood
Me: kid you live in sweden
I agree with Putin, it is easy for people living in developed countries to say everyone should use renewable energy resources or eco friendly products because they are affordable and easily accessible to them but for others in developing and underdeveloped countries it is not easy or possible as they try to find whatever resources to survive and live a good life.
That’s right not every African can travel on a eco-friendly yacht like she has done. Most of what Greta has said is unrealistic and shows her naïveté.
@@TheChaco31 Correct but it's not just Africa, there are so many countries in Asia and South America as well who cannot afford such amenities but Americans and Europeans like Greta think that they can dictate the world what to do and what not to do just because they feel that they are inferior to others.
Zack Syiem Yes I agree underdeveloped countries should be able to do what they want with their resources. Us in the west have everything. It’s not fair to say what others can make a living with, especially when they have no food or money. She and the people telling her what to say, look elitist and egotistical.
Developing countries causing war in AFRIKA for mineral ! War in Middle EST FOR OIL !
Backward developed nations of abominations !
@@josianenagito4300 First of all, don't blanket all developed nations like that. The US has alot to answer for in regards to their constant involvement in domestic affairs of other countries. And this constant blame on the US that they attacked middle eastern countries for their oil is just stupid. 30-40% of the worlds oil is already produced by the US itself domestically. The wars in the middle east are complicated, extremely complicated and oil might of course play some part in it. But there are tons of other factors aswell, ungrounded beliefs of nuclear weapons, ideological differences, islam extremists, proxy wars and other interests. The world is not black and white. You can't put every issue under one single explanation when there almost always is a ton of different explanations at hand.
"You have ruined my dreams, and my childhood with your empty words"
*lives in one of the most highly-ranked countries in terms of quality of life*
i guess this is where the importance of travel comes in
I don't like Greta either and I share Putin's words in this video, but she doesn't mean only herself with these words.
Uhh, I think it's more like don't ruin my generation's future, but yea sure keep telling yourself that
@@derhoffnungsvolle5122 what did she not get in her life?
@@m4tta i choked out when reading this comment
No script
Off the top of his head 👏
No auto-tune here
Блядь ANYTHING this genocidal dictator has to say.
The last real man left in this hilarious world
I protecc
I attacc
But most importantly
I speak straight facc
Stop with this useless meme! It died ages ago
DNA oh no! Anyway
I was surprised
_By this one_
Yeaaa boiiii
Why? She is like 12 but just a bit older... have mercy on her
So just to be clear: Putin isn’t criticizing Greta or her cause, but rather the mechanism behind the cause? Title should’ve been “Putin questions how realistic the plan is”
UA-cam vids often exaggerate what's really happening for the mad views, that's media for ya
"Putin questions his profits under the plan"
White vs white!🙈🔥
Samantha Ecotothermia SAY THAT...!!! EXACTLY.. COULDNT AGREE MORE
Pov: your here from the putin song
He's not wrong. I wonder how long until the BBC disable the comments.
FUN FACT : When putin installs windows, microsoft accepts his terms and conditions
When putin goes on a website.
Google accepts his cookies
You made my day... 😊
LMFAO! Underrated!
It's not fun fact, it OUR FUN FACT
@Papa Stalin CRAVING ATTENTION i GUESS
is this clickbait or does bbc actually put the wrong title
BBC is insanely bias for the far left
They have to report this one, but they are not capable to twist it
it's intentional. Putin = Russia = big bad boss must be taken down.
Zi Wang He is an authoritarian leader, he may be level-headed but his opinion is redundant by default.
He is easily handed a platform, where he gets to express himself to an audience that practically worships him. Whilst a few other people who may be even more concise and rational are stamped out, wasting enormous potential.
You are all idiots.. Look up the definition of the word criticism, its an accurate title.
Every time I watch Putin speak I realise he is the only true leader of the world. His answers are so concise and thought out that you cannot help but agree with him!
What you wanted to say is correct, what you said is not.
Judge not the speaker. Judge only what was said.
This sounds more like a father pointing out the mistakes of a daughter and teaching her more than anything else
Which undoubtedly Greta'a father failed to do.
@@jayeshjadhav5575 And yours because Greta is right. Sorry if your father taught you feelings trump facts but they don't. Sorry he told you blind worship of a criminal dictator and BS is a good thing.
He seems like he has no ill will, and just wants to give her pointers, I agree
@@jamespyke6764 oof political expert in the building
@@zaidlacksalastname4905 Oof shill and ignorance in the building.
Like him or not, the guy knows his shit and speaks it very intelligently
Reece Longstaff are you a bot?
Facts
@@Name-jw4sj oof, so many blatant bots here.
@@Name-jw4sj Not particularly a bot. Putin is right here, and we hate him in Sweden and the Rus as a whole.
@@monkegang1023 Just because people disagree does not infact, make them a bot dipshit.
This man just explained life to her.
Putin:
"I love ecology, i will blow up every single one of your power plant"
Greta: You stole my childhood!
African young soldier entered the chat searching for water...
Ffs
yes
wtfffff 😂😂😂😂😀😭😭😭😭😭 wait why am laughing 😂😂😀😀😀😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
African soldier : What am i doing in this chat ? There's no water here ?
Lobomyr put me here !... something confusing about Greta...? Please let me go !
Greta enters the chat:
- You're all idiots !
shame to you, bbc. he said "developes fast", not "changes fast". you don t care?
Developing» usually means something gets better. «Change» can be either. That kinda makes a difference ;)
@silverbud obviously, the logics is not your best trait so shouldn't you keep this fact in secret rather than show it to people?
oh they care. they care enough to spin it.
@@simenkunicekream Yeah. "Development" is a progress not just simply an altering process where "change" can be both and interpreted in distinct ways. Putin refers to economic reality and what people in third world actually want.
And here we are in Europe rn eating our words
Why didnt u show the whole speech, instead of cutting from it?
Criticizing!!!!?????
This is nothing but STRAIGHT FACTS!!!
ua-cam.com/video/eZq6F5RkSno/v-deo.html
He is criticizing her, I don't know why there are so many comments denying this. You can criticize someone with straight facts
@@per365 Shut Up.
@@haywoodjblome4768 He’s not criticizing Thunberg. It’s the exact opposite, he’s praising her. He is in fact criticizing the idea which is Greta Thunberg and the adults around her which benefit from it
So criticizing can’t be facts?
i like how he treated her with seriousness. It is not because she is only a teenager you will say "aw, isn't she cute?". Putin stated a problem to be solved, he treated her with the same respect he has for someone who is in charge of something important.
he also kills all dissenters and has his country in a faux democracy where he is a dictator. but sure the speech sounded good I agree
huh The value of his speech is not tangible to what he does, we’re not supporting Putin. Moreover, we’re just agreeing with his speech. Lumping those two makes no sense on that basis. Anyways if you believe America has a true democracy you’d be disappointed to find out how flawed it is.
Yes, but his speech is very specifically and carefully putting blame elsewhere. He says Africa can't invest in renewable energy because they need to pollute to reach our standard of living, which is fine.
The amount of pollution from Africa is negligible.
Renewable energy is (was) expensive, but if you stimulate supply for it, you can easily artificially lower the price substantially. By the the Africa gets close to the standard of living of Eastern European countries, we'll have invested enough in renewable energy to make the transition very easy for them.
Putin is just trying to find an excuse to not have to invest, because that costs money and doesn't directly benefit him.
deckie how miserable must you be to repeat in other people‘s comments?
@@Apollo5752353 ctrl C ctrl V are very efficient tools 😎
Loki listens to Putin and get's nervous.
That commanding sound, especially when he speak without text
It's unethical and unprofessional to cut or censor the speech, put the whole damn speech......!!
@Stonehaven I love how everyone criticises the BBC for being "too left" or "too right". I can sit here and be smug about how stupid all these arguments are because everyone just sees them as the enemy through their jaded eyes.
Stonehaven accept the BBC is run by the conservative government. Of course they’re leftist when portraying Corbyn in pictures it photoshopped itself that he was Russian. The BBC is the running governments propaganda machine.
Arash surosh The complete answer:
ua-cam.com/video/i2U4e9Yjgbo/v-deo.html
I was just settling into what Putin had to say, which I am sure is more worthwhile hearing than any of the b.s dripping from the mouths of leftard activists.
Anyway he was just making a bull-shit argument. It's like someone trying to get off the hook by talking about homeless people, when apprehended for massive tax-fraud: "Why don't you go to the homeless and explain why they need to pay taxes?"
Im impressed as he is a president speaking without the need of a script unlike many others and actually make sense!
Well he does makes sense but Not THINKING of solution is not a valid argument or decision either....the thing remains that if we think about these complex issues we can get a middle ground somewhere but if we throw them for no reason other than we don't think it's possible then I don't know why people are called intellectual.
@@shyamsingla716 he didn't say to throw these ideas out for no reason. He basically said it's more complicated than it seems, expensive, and unrealistic. And you're an intellectual?
He is has stolen billions in corruption as his populace cant afford shoes. Let him speak well, and hide the fact he is one of the most evil people on the planet. He alone has in his pockets more money than the u.s.a solar energy investment(which is greater than any other energy) in the year 2019. Just him. He talks like poor people pay for energy...poor people cant afford light bulbs. Like much of his country cant.
@@danesesse Brainwashed Trump supporter alert. You can tell by the hilarious use of parenthesis xd. YOU WISH American politicans could be so eloquent and straight-forward. Eat up the lies and keep paying them to show your 'support' lol
@@vick7848 i am not american or a trump supporter. Is putin the opposite of trump? You assumption confuse me. I was critizing putin... how does that make me a trump supporter.
Even if you though I was defending the american president, that is Biden not trump.
Are you lost?
I like old Vlad……. He tends to talk common sense.
Putin someone with reasonable thinking vs Greta someone thinking with their emotions
I'm still confused if I should leave a like for the speech or a dislike for the title
In a same dilemma 🤔🤔🤔
They are making him seem like a negative guy when in fact he makes perfect sense
Dislike
If there are many likes, the people will know that putin is right i suppose so i suggest liking. Plus, the title didnt said something wrong about putin's speech, is is 50-50. It just said "criticising" and it's not a bad thing.
Yeah I am confused too, as one of those gen-z's, Greta's view is inspiring but looking at the bigger picture its impractical unless some revolutionary technology comes up, but if we don't even try the technology we are talking about won't come.
He’s not criticizing Thunberg. It’s the exact opposite, he’s praising her. He is in fact criticizing the idea which is Greta Thunberg and the adults around her which benefit from it
ua-cam.com/video/eZq6F5RkSno/v-deo.html
@Nicolas d'Avout stfu
🙌
He is not praising her
When Putin said 20 to 30 years of struggling, he really want to say 200 to 300 years. Easily. The greed of the human being is stronger than the eagerness of sharing wealth.
who's talking about sharing? It's building wealth we're talking about.
@@bguy510 In order to build something from nothing, you need to share from a source, in the form of knowledge, capacities, or capital, to the other location or hub where there is no such thing.
My respect for him has grown several folds