The other problem with the shade of red that they chose for Halle Bailey’s Ariel is because the ocean is already so dull, it causes her hair to look like it blends into her skin. Making her hair a much more vivid red would have added more color and contrast, and made her more of a fantasy character.
the art made by fans of her with red hair and all the dresses in the animation is a thousand times better than the film, it gives the impression that she is a real Ariel
I may be completely off topic here but.... eh. The most stupid thing they did is to make the sea not vibrant at all. Including swapping species for the two friends (one became a land crab and the other not an albatross). Sea life is so vibrant they can make you look at zoos pitifully. Even Shark Tale can be referred if they do any homework with existing 3d sealife movies, or if they just take a look at actual sealife documentaries. It's a shame. Not to mention now there will be no Melody existing in the future because now Ariel is asexual.
Honestly, I always liked Cinderella’s live action dress the most but also felt like something was missing that I couldn’t put my finger on… you NAILED it!!!
I agree, I did think she was the best representation of all the live action films thus far and seeing the accessories and updo made the look even better!😄😊
This was the best of all your redesigns IMO. You didn’t do much to the dress, but everything you did made it look closer to the original! Standing ovation here! 👏
They cgi’d the dress into the darker blue that’s in the movie, so the actual dress that was made for the movie looks sort of like the redesigned one if I remember correctly. I think the original dress almost looked like it was painted with watercolors.
Disney really did Halle dirty. They should have kept the scene when king triton makes her human and she has the sparkly dress, the costume department would have had a field day making Halle something amazing to wear.
It’s almost as if they stirred up controversy on purpose to get people talking about the movie, in order to sell it. It’s unethical, but a lot of brands do this these days to sell their products - intentionally create controversy to get people talking about their products. As some people say, “all press is good press”. Just think of people like The Kardashians, or Trump - they do this too. Unfortunately, though, when corporations use people like Halle for such purposes without telling them about their plans, innocents like her get caught in the crossfire. And she had to put up with a lot of stress and racism as a result, and didn’t get the fair treatment that she should have received as a Disney Princess. Ariel wears several beautiful dresses in the film, and has gorgeous hair. They didn’t give her any of that. Her costumes for the marketing were good, but that was about it. And she tried very hard. I personally didn’t like the film, and I definitely prefer everything about the original to the remake, even including the songs (I know that a lot of people like Halle’s voice, but I felt that she did not receive good direction, and prefer the original songs). However, I don’t blame Halle for that, and no one should. I blame Disney. Anyone who blames Halle for the film failing is vicious, and probably quite prejudiced. I definitely think that this was a case of Disney intentionally trying to make their film controversial, to drum up interest. Controversy just equals free advertisement for them. They stopped caring about the quality of their films long ago, and Halle ended up being a scapegoat for their unethical practices. It’s a hard lesson for her to learn, but at least she has made a name for herself now and has lots of fans, and hopefully she can navigate the industry wisely from here on out. I personally had a horrible experience in the industry when I was younger, and it caused me to leave all of my dreams behind, right when I was on the precipice of attaining them. I realised how awful Hollywood is, and how much they use and abuse young women. So I hope that she at least understands that her fame has now given her power to protect herself from those who would use her and cause her harm. And that she learns to differentiate between studios who are passionate about making movies for the sake of art, and those who are interested in making movies because they are creepy, pretentious, greedy, or interested in using her in some way without telling her - just as she was used here by Disney.
Omg yesss. I’ve been saying the same thing. It’s one of the most iconic and memorable moments in the animated movie. Why didn’t they translate that into the live action. + they didn’t give her pretty outfits in the live action.
I agree with Mulan's redesign. Idk how accurate this is but red strikes me more as a royal color while Mulan is just a soldier. Would've loved to see a mere footsoldier in green kick some hhigh-ranking butt.
If you want the best Mulan live action watch the Vicky Zhao's one. To me she IS Mulan. And yes she wore everything (no freestyle banshee hair, no hidden inherited Qi BS, no witch archenemies), like in this PS version.
I have enough interest in Chinese culture that i started to leave a comment, and then i wasn't sure about stuff so i googled, and honestly I'm just gonna c+p the wiki section on the color red in Chinese culture (note i also know enough to know this is not fully comprehensive of all red's historical associations etc but it'll do) Red (红; 紅 hóng), vermilion (丹 dān), and crimson (赤 chì) are associated with masculine yang energy and fire, good fortune and joy. Red is the traditional color used during Chinese New Year and other celebrations, including weddings and wedding gowns. Chinese reds are traditionally inclusive of shades English might consider orange or warm brown. A hongbao, a red envelope stuffed with money, now frequently red 100 RMB notes, is the usual gift in Chinese communities for Chinese New Year, birthdays, marriages, bribes, and other special occasions. The red color of the packet symbolizes good luck. Red is strictly forbidden at funerals as it is traditionally symbolic of happiness.[7] The names of the dead were previously written in red,[citation needed] so it is generally somewhat offensive to use red ink for Chinese names in contexts other than official seals. In the People's Republic of China, red remains a very popular color and is affiliated with and used by the Communist Party and the government. Meanwhile from the section on blue/green (there's not a distinction between blue and green in Chinese) "[blue/green] was associated with health, prosperity, and harmony." Plus everything with like, jade and stuff. So honestly, green is a WAY better fit on every level lmao. Also i now feel weird knowing they always put Mulan in red text.
Belle's redesign looks too victorian. The golden hue is perfection but the gown should look more like something out of Marie Antoinette's wardrobe. The Snow White redesign looks really neat, I love how simple yet elegant it is. Apparently a lot of that movie is being reworked in reshoots, so it is likely that costume design will change a bit as well.
I think in the animated original movie, indeed, Belle’s gown IS victorian. It’s gorgeous but absolutely not history accurate. (In fact Cinderella’s gown from the live action is like the original’s Belle one but blue, without the « puffy fabric over the skirt ») and yes, it would have been great if it was more Marie-Antoinette like. Like the side characters, figurants dancing at the end.
The silhouette and style of Belle's gown is definitely more victorian in silhouette, which doesn't match the historical setting of the rest of the movie.
@@jahanshadi1934that’s why Disney movies are set in a fantasy world with its own history and everything, so that’s why we can’t say something is historically accurate when it’s a parallel/different universe
5:20 I didn’t realize I could love the Cinderella look even more. This is absolutely gorgeous and spot on! Cinderella 2015 is my favorite of the live actions, and this look would have been perfect in it!
@@lilachodan4941 I think they are talking about the actual dress not the tail . She only had two dresses and they pretty much were the same dress just different colors
I dont know, i guess this is inspiration ? Bollywood style is full of songs, dances and colors, it fits with Disney cartoons. I guess it can be some reasons.
@@asimnegi5078 It’s not ancient Chinese… it’s from a thousand and one nights, the name Aladdin is literally Arabic. In some versions of the story, it starts with “In a faraway land called China”, but the story itself isn’t actually Chinese and even then it’s only a few versions that start that way. Even if it was an ancient Chinese story (which it wasn’t), what would that have to do with Bollywood movies? China is in east Asia not South Asia.
@@-Theo- It’s really odd and wonky as to where the Aladdin story is supposed to take place (I mean the OG fairytale, not the Disney version). The narrative did say it took place in China originally, but they still used Arabic terms and gave us an Arabic feel for, well, the whole setting. So it’s confusing, but I’ve always gathered that it actually is supposed to be Arabic.
I think casting Emma Watson was the huge mistake consider how much she ended up changing the plot and the dress, we would have had a Cinderella gown 2.0 but instead we got this monstrosity of a dress
She complained about the weight of the dress so they CGId it to makei t look fuller and you can really tell . . . EDut: such an emma, thing to do, she did it with harry potter hence the infortunate loss of curls and school uniform in the latter movies. Its a shamme how she single handedly thwarts the potentially great costume design of every movie she featuresin Edit: 105 likes tysm guys 💖
@@Heejinbunnyyeah which is stupid because I think Lily talked about how her dress surprisingly way lighter than she thought it was gonna be, even though she did sort of get a little cinched and a little bit more than she should’ve
And Lily at least wore the damn corset ! Emma was too “feminist “ to do so ! On top of visually destroying Belles gown ! They gave her WAY too much lead way .
Emma Watson cast to play hermione Granger - loves books, spends a majority of her time in the libray Belle - loves books spends a majority of he time visiting the towns booktore/libray 🤔 These characters have far too much in common and they both resemble each other in looks
@@jesslockwood7978 the issue is she didn’t play Belle good or represent what Belle means really , even down to the dress . We don’t care if she looks like her . She was PERFECT as Hermoine tho .
Controversial opinion, but I adore Cinderella's and Jasmine's live action gowns. I haven't seen the 2nd movie but Aurora's costume in the first movie made sense to me. She had no idea she was royalty, she was raised as a poor commoner in the woods so it makes sense to me that her clothing doesn't look as lavish and expensive.
@@TheGreekPianist Cinderella’s is definitely a beautiful dress but I agree with the creator of the video, making it just a bit lighter blue helps make it more like the animated dress, which is what the creator was going for. I also like Jasmine’s outfit but the mesh looks a little funny and the colors are a bit flat without something to break up the flatness. I think even having it a different fabric, maybe something shimmery, might give the shirt and pants some depth 😊
Piss yellow 😂😭 stawwwp yes it's not golden but that is still a very important and lovely shade of yellow okayyyy?! (Coming from a person that wouldn't be caught dead in or by yellow-only maybe the muted pastel ones maaaybe, but this is a slight joke too)
I actually like Cinderella's and Jasmine's costumes. Cinderella has the most beautiful dress in a disney remake. I totally agree with you on Belle's dress. It's so bad. I love the one you designed for her
Thank you for fixing Cinderella's look. I always thought that the lack of accessories made the focus be on the dress and not on Cinderella herself. That was a problem.
Hmm, it's funny how your designs depart more from the source material and yet capture the essence of the characters far better than the cheapish designs we actually got in the live-action films.
Right the only thing she really needed tweaked (like all woc) is the mesh so that the illusion was there. Actually there, not party city or something. I also wanted her to actually have just a two piece set (no mesh nothing flowy all that) like the one from the animated movie but I thought it was still pretty.
same but i also loved the redesign. as bad as the live action film was the costumes and outfits were amazing. i even loved her outfit when she was in the shop where she first met aladdin
@@commanderwolffeex Wait wait wati... you didnt like the live action remake?? what did you not like about it? i admit, i didnt love how Jasmine was (so girl-powery, and just feminist and slightly obnoxious) but i thought pretty much everything else was spot on. I actually loved Will Smith as the genie, and Aladdin was just perfect. i loved the costumes and the sets, and also... i mean jafar was perfect for that role! 😏 To be fair, i didn't really grow up with the old one, so i can understand if you have like nostalgia about the old one, but i think it's one of the best live action remakes (after cinderella of course 😁) sorry for the rant!! 🙃🤦♀
The original looks a lot more like traditional Indian clothing, I love all the jewellery in it. The edited image didn't remind me of India at all! Would've maybe kept the hair, though, it looks good when it's down.
I love that specific shade of red you chose for Ariel. It immediately strikes as something ad familiar and ‘out of place’, yet still good enough to look natural a bit more.
I am so happy ariel finally got her princess moment! Your redesigns of her really made her ariel to me, especially that pink dress and the brighter red hair!!!! STUNNING!
The Little Mermaid was just such a great example of how the remakes focus on the wrong things. You primarily identify Ariel by her hair and they just ignored it
☺️ Our leading ladies definitely deserved higher quality fabrics and classy shades given the budgets of their films. Your ideas are true to the heart of each Disney fairytale while reaching the sophisticated standards of the real world.
Belle's gown: 💕 Jasmine's outfit: ❤ I'm a sucker for gauze. Ariel's looks and outfits: Yessss ❤ Mulan: Nice, nice. That movie disappointed me overall. Cinderella's gown: Not a bad alternative Snow White: I'm praying for you Ms Zegler. First she had to deal with Snow and now this.
As a merman (someone who’s in the Mermaid community) and long time Little Mermaid fan sense I was born I actually loved that they made Ariel’s top apart of her body. It slightly makes her more fishy especially with the added faint scales they put on her shoulders and arms. Sometimes sea shell tops in real life can look either bulky or very funny looking and it’s hard for me to take seriously. They should have just went with the original prototype top design because it makes her look even more like a mermaid and it is creative how it’s done (almost like her nipples are scales that fade into her body). I hope that makes sense, if you seen the screen test I think you know what I mean. But yeah I agree with everything else about Ariel!
It was the actresses' choice though. The one for Belle (Emma Watson) complained about the original dress and in subsequent films the actress playing the princess was given control over her costuming. For Ariel, that included the dull brown dreadlocks, the pink head band and both the dresses.
The little mermaid is a Danish story it’s one thing if they did a retelling like the classic story the frog prince/princess story like princess and the frog but no they just race swap the character how unoriginal and you can only do so much with dreadlocks
@@kirayoungblood Those were a bad choice in general. The live action movie has alot of issues, the leading actress being a one of them. She's not good at acting and her singing is not Ariel (She butchered Part of that world). She can't even emote when she has no voice. There's plenty of other issues (story, lore, music, the CGI, and most of the other actors), but they really needed to find another actress to be Ariel. At least one who wanted to become the character
@@kirayoungbloodthis isn't the "danish" story. since when does denmark have jamaican singing crabs, a tropical caribbean themed setting, or calypso music?
@@kirayoungblood You’re full of shit. The story of The Little Mermaid has absolutely nothing to do with Denmark or Danish culture. Even the animated movie took place in either a fantasy world or just an unspecified corner of the world. Ariel’s story had nothing to do with being white. You’re just looking for an excuse to be mad. Take your racist BS elsewhere.
Susan Egan's gold/white ballroom and gold/red rose finale dresses in Beauty and the Beast on Broadway are the best Belle dresses ever made and I will die on this hill.
The moment I saw Cinderellas dress in 2015, I knew Belles dress was going to be changed. Cinderellas dress is the exact same silhouette as Belles animated gown. While everyone was cheering, I was crying because I knew that Belles dress was the best Disney princess gown. I didnt think Disney had the imagination to pull off something better in live action. And I was right.
This. ALLLLLL of this. Cinderella got the dress that Beauty and the Beast deserved. Not to mention, it will never not piss me off that the OG gown in the animated movie was SILVER and because of princess marketing, it was abandoned.
Gotta confess, Belles' dress was always my least favorite as a kid. It reminds me of the 90s and early 2000s prom dresses with pickups and made of overly shiny polyester. I always personally disliked pick up skirts. Whenever I watched the animated movie, I always thought of prom dresses.......
The original design was done on purpose. First of all, they followed the concept art from the 1950 version. Ella didn't wear her hair up, wear gloves or jewellery because the designer wanted her to stand out from all the other women who were dressed that way. Every detail was done on purpose and for a reason.
I loved Halle as Ariel, yet, you're right. I don't understand why they decided to take away all those details that made Ariel be Ariel. I would love her to see her with red hair, and keep the colors of the tail and bra.
i just wanna say smthn about the jasmine costume, the live action actually does a half better job than the animation, of course jasmin's costume in the animation is the worst representation of what arab princesses wore, it looks more like what the slaves wore, the live action did a better job at atpeast giving her jewellery and details which is accurate to that time had she been a slave rather than a princess, i'm sorry yours isn't very accurate either but it's ok cuz even we as arabs tend to make our own culture more aesthetic than it actually was, i personally couldn't careless as long as it's enjoyable to watch but i should make it more known
Isn't that the point? That Jasmine was basically a slave to the patriarchy and a prisoner in her own home? She's forced to wear that outfit to show off her beauty to her suitors and is expected to be nothing but a trophy wife. That's why she hates being a princess. Also, none of the princesses have ever worn authentic apparels. They're meant to be reflect the beauty standards of the time their movies came out. Crop top popularity peaked in the early 90's, that's why Jasmine wears one.
Oh my gosh i love cinderellas dress! I never really got the hype behind the one in the movie, it always seemed a bit off. I think the softer blue fits Lily James so much better and the gloves, necklace, and updo make it look way more complete!
They need to hire you. Love your dedication to doing photoshop jobs, theyre visually very effective and absolutely communicate your point, on top of the redesigns just being much better overall
it's incredible how just simple color and fabric changes can totally elevate the looks. cinderella was stunning, snow white stunning, and a huge improvement for the little mermaid. i have no idea why they didn't make her hair red in the first place.
I could've agreed more! Belle is so GORGEOUS! Belle's dress is my most favorite of them all since I was child. So when Emma Watson was casted I felt so excited but then I got SO DISAPPOINTED AND ALWAYS RANTING ABOUT HER DRESS! I don't care if they tried to be realistic atleassstttt do the iconic dresses right! Its FANTASY!
I know I'm in the minority but I truly felt that Halle did have the Ariel vibe, petite and hour glass with a cute innocent face and beautiful voice, I truly think she was the perfect choice and your redesigns show that they just let her down with styling
Trust me, you’re not nearly as much in the minority as you think you are. The internet is just chock-full of racist trolls who want to find excuses to be mad. There are plenty of people out here who see Halle’s merit and how well the role suits her. ❤
Halle was the perfect choice to be Ariel. Yet, Rob Marshall's decisions were totally wrong in certain aspects. He had to keep the red hair in her and the colors of the tail and the bra.
@@sethzarandona2325 Please stop that nonsense. No one cares about the fact that Ariel was black. It's the reasoning behind her casting that irritates people. Disney is a heartless corporation now that only cares about money. It's no longer actually about making a good movie and making kids happy it's all about the cash. Because of woke culture, minority representation in a movie = CASH. Don't you get it? Disney didn't actually want Halle for her talent. They ONLY wanted her for her black skin because they knew that a black Ariel would appeal to black audiences thus boosting sales. They used her for a cash grab and they used her as a SHIELD. Because that right there, what you're doing is exactly what they knew would happen. Everyone is always accused of being racist or prejudiced in some other way just because they disagree with something or don't like it, if it happens to have a minority or other oppressed type of person involved. We aren't allowed to say one bad word about this movie without people like YOU calling us a racist. Even if our criticism are about other things in the movie that have nothing to do with Halle (like Prince Eric's autotune singing and the terrible dark dreary look of the film) you still insist that we're racist and just hate Halle. More importantly, we aren't allowed to criticize Disney for doing that to Halle because they "gave us what we wanted". They gave us a black princess to admire and look up to so we're not allowed to criticize them or anything they do ever again (Even though they literally already did that 15 years ago with Princess Tiana. A hardworking black woman who is family, career and goal oriented and takes care of herself. All little black girls were inspired greatly by her). Don't be disrespectful and just throw the word racist around for no legitimate reason just because Disney has got you fooled.
She wasn't, there are hundreds of girls who would fit the vibe, but for some reason they chose one that looks NOTHING like ariel. Neither is the same ethnicity.... Yikes
Today I went to Disneyland. I saw so many people dress as Snow White and everyone look way better than the official live action. Their dresses are all darker and less vibrant. They feel like those old fairytale designs.
Ariel in her pink dress!! Wow I didn't expect to CRY with nostalgic little-girl princess longing at this one. I catch myself watching vaguely grumpy takes on "modern Disney" here and there, and usually just share the vague grumpiness without getting worked up about it all. But... Seeing Ariel in her gorgeous PINK princess dress, I just shocked myself by bursting into tears! I didn't know how much I needed to see that "Princess Moment." Sincere thanks from a red haired lady who was 10 years old in 1989. ♡
I once saw a guest dressed up at disney for the Halloween party, and she was wearing the live action Cinderella dress, but with the hair and accessories of the animation and it was BEAUTIFUL
Loved all your reworks a lot! I just like the movie Jasmine costume more. I think the blue one was very beautiful. Besides that, you made the Cinderella dress absolutely perfect! And the Snow White one was really good too.
Live action Ariel not getting the animated film's pink dress is a crime. The pink looked kind of bad on 2D Ariel with the rest of her palette but it fits really well on a darker skin tone.
These are actually really well done and I love the commentary. It's constructive and you praise the things that were good while giving good reason as to why the bad things are bad. Really wish they'd given Belle a fancier dress.
Omg I loved everything you did!! All the live action movies (apart from Cinderella) are SO disappointing! You really brought to life the fantasy and extravagance that a Disney Princess should have. Please please take over disneys designer!!
How about Abigail Cowen as Ariel? She was perfect and she sings... they raceswap her on purpose they eve changed her now and the trailer haves more dislikes than likes.. just create new charactes
Your redesign of Ariel is basically how I imagined it ever since the live action was first announced. Like I was pretty excited for this movie until I saw the teasers, the promos, the ads, the posters….It just ahh broke my heart. The colours were completely muted. The cgi looked questionable at times and my poor girl Ariel was done so dirty that I’m convinced they did it on purpose. They give her cheap ass looking clothings. They gave her brownish braids when they know darn well they could’ve given her a vibrant red that still compliments her skin tone and the worst travesty of all, they didn’t give her her iconic pink dress AND that sparkly dress at the end. I mean come on. I’m sorry for ranting too much but listen, it’s fair 💙.
The Little Mermaid is my favourite film in general, and the live action is my favourite live action film, but the costume choices did irk me. I get it, they weren't expecting a guest, but even so, the dress they did give her could have been way more regal, and you did a fantastic job capturing what I imagined her blue dress to look like.
Love the redesigns ! 🌸 I’m a fashion student, I personally think the Cinderella one is lovely, just the gloves are a little much, it takes the concentration off the dress itself 👐🌸
This! All of this! (Yes, even the Mulan costume) “how the mighty have fallen” is right. My finest compliment to you… except for Aurora’s. Make it blue!
I am genuinely so shocked at how the mighty icon of a designer for the Cinderella dress did the Snow White one… HOW DO YOU GO FROM THAT GORGEOUS PIECE OF ART TO THAT MONSTROSITY SCARIER THAN THE PLAUGE?! WHAT DO YOU MEAN😭
I've always imagined Aurora's hair to be a little bit like Elle Woods; fluffy, thick, largely rounded at the ends, golden/white blonde hair that bounces and almost floats on its own. BUT, you did an amazing job redesigning everything. I wish disney would pick up their slack. I refuse to spend any more money on them and their new stuff. Bring old disney back :(
IDK BUT SHE DOES LOOK LIKE LOLA FROM SHARK TALE Even better he character is literally Ariel THE MERMAID. (Compliment because Lola is an icon and she's gorgeous 😭💖)
While some of the costumes are better in the various movies than others, I do agree that Cinderella set the bar high in terms of all the costumes in that movie being pure, extravagant fancy and that the other live action movies have struggled to get to that point.
Your redesigns for Snow White ans Belle are glorious! Mulan and Belle's changes aren't severe to the point where I needed a redesign, and I love Cinderella as-is (they avoided being a literal remake, so that helped). Not crazy about Ariel's redesigns, but they're much better than what we got, and obviously the skinbearing on Jasmine (and Aladdin) are something I'm glad the remake avoided, given the critiques Jasmine has received as being sexualized and Aladdin was confirmed to be sexualized for the female audience (which reads bad to me since his story could be a metaphor for maturing, and being sexualized isn't the best thing to include in that, imo).
I think Ariel's sisters had a bit of the right idea in their mermaid forms. Their tops and tails look like they were scales that's part of their skin. This gives the perfect excuse to not use she'll bikini. It's actually a bit odd why she's the odd one out in that type of design.
I thought Jasmine's outfits in the remake were actually great. Way better than what this person made, at least. Back then they didn't exactly have pastel color palettes, everything _was_ extremely vibrant and colorful and since certain dyes were expensive, having vibrant colors were also a sign of wealth and status. Jasmine absolutely _should_ be wearing vibrant colors with many small details and embroidery to show the fact that she is a princess! And she would likely _not_ be showing any skin or wear pants *which is why Disney changed it for the live action.* They were actually _trying_ to be historically and culturally accurate!! And yet her outfit still definitely feels like Jasmine.
In defense of the live action Mulan (and I haven't seen it nor do I plan to; I gave up on these after Aladdin), I know what they were going for, but Western audiences do not understand it. Okay, so I saw the preview and immediately understood the reference because I LOVE Chinese fantasy dramas about gods and goddesses and spirits. THAT is what they did. They literally changed the character to be more like those goddess or spirit characters. One of my favorite Chinese fantasy dramas is "Eternal Love" (aka "Ten Miles of Peach Blossoms"). They did a movie version, which is shorter by...hours, and they did a TV "mini"series (their miniseries are very long, this one is 43.5 hours long). The main character is a Nine-Tailed Fox Spirit. It's common in these dramas to do those acrobatic aerial movements and fights. They also are gods/goddesses/spirits and don't always wear armor. That's why they did that. The problem is...most Americans do not watch those shows (they should, they are AWESOME). I doubt most Europeans watch them. So, Western countries don't know those tropes. That's why the costumes were that way as well as the movements. I think it was ridiculous to change the character since she is human, but Disney was sucking up to China. That movie was trying to appeal to Chinese audiences and failed since they also didn't like the changes. Mulan is not a goddess in China. Put aside the fact that most Chinese people are atheists, she's not in their mythology as a goddess or a spirit. Rant over. Look up the "Eternal Love" drama if you have several days to kill! It's not dubbed, but you can find it with subtitles. It is worth the 43.5 hours! It's an amazing story that is woven so well. Or watch the movie version.
I agree the 2015 Cinderella dress was beautiful. I think it was also probably the best life action remake they did too. The actor was beautiful they gave her such an elegant personality and the theme of kindness was more emphasized and so was the loss of her parents. And the dress was really really pretty. It’s on of the only expeditions to changing what the dress looks like in my opinion because in the other movies they changes what the original outfit looked like and it didn’t work but in Cinderella they could have said okay let’s just copy the original but instead they said let’s do what we’re doing but do it correctly this time and it showed. I do agree on the lighter colors considering her original dress in the movie was not blue it was silver but looked blue in lighting but I loved the little butterflies and cgi they did for it and you did a great job at touching it up.
jasmine dresses in the live action is amazing. its one of the top 3 live action dresses for me. Belle and Ariel on the other hand. i really like the redesign more . and i agree with you on mulan and cinderella and Aurora
I like Ariel’s looks in the movie but I do think it’s weird Vanessa has maybe 3 minutes of screen time and more variety to her outfits than Ariel gets- and no big I am a human glittery dress? I agree that Belle’s dress is the biggest offender but it’s tricky to picture just right because I feel the film does a lot wrong like mishandling the visual of Belle and beast as the only characters in blue and her colour palettes warming as she warms to the beast. Something that was great visual story telling in the cartoon the live action just dropped entirely- like that’s WHY her dress is gold why she wore green and pink before then. But in the live action you can tell they didn’t apply that level of thought it was just hey she wore yellow in the cartoon so let’s make a yellow dress here. And I could almost forgive it being simple lacking structure and volume and being the most basic outfit of the whole movie… could have genuinely been fine with it IF they didn’t add the terrible glitter details on that look like glue and glitter for a kids project.
The Ariel designs are absolutely beautiful. Such a shame that they made her color palette so dull in the final film. Even early concept art and screen tests showed her with a more vibrant orangeish red hair color, not the ginger-blondeish brown they gave her final look. Halle deserved that striking Disney princess look.
Ok, I love how you DESIGN Cinderella's dress but I'll still prefer the look they go in the live action. First the style lily's hair in a sort of tiara look without using an actual jewelry
For the Cinderella argument...it is less that she is intended to look "simple", and more that she is intended to look eye catching. Cinderella worked because not only was the design gorgeous and still undoubtedly looked elegant, royal and refined, it also lacks the patterns and detailing on most of the other dresses, it lacks the elaborate accessories intended to display wealth, it lacks the formal tying your hair up which was the norm back in this time. The choice to make her design not have any accessories, complicated patterns, or a formal updo is what set her apart visually from the other ball attendees. She wasn't a princess, but she was about to become a queen. Oh and by your logic of simplicity, I'm pretty sure the cost of Lily James's peasant costume, home set, peasant accesories, peasant hair and makeup, should ALSO make her rich, but it doesn't. Why? Because that's not something in universe. Nobody in the movie (as far as I remember) described her dress to be containing Swarovski crystals, and we're not even sure if they'd be aware of the worth of something like that, or even its existence (assuming it was named after someone after their period?). This opposition is a bit of a fallacy to me, but I can see the point about the dress being extravagant nonetheless. That's absolutely a princess dress.
I'd like to add : I absolutely LOVE your version of the Cinderella design, it's definitely more true to the original. Though I think I prefer the current movie as it is.
While I didn’t have an issue with most of the outfits (I did with Ariel’s a little bit but I overlooked because I was more concerned about the storyline) I LOVE your redesigns. VERY exquisite!
tbh I thought snow white's dress was so cheep and ugly, until I saw that image with the dwarves shown at 5:40 , which make it just make sense! It goes so well with the atmosphere and the colours of the set it looks like a charming little children's storybook, rather than rich, elegant, expensive, and unattainable that the others go for. I just don't think that's the vibe they want to go for in this film. It's set in a humble cottage not a diamond castle. It just looks so fun and innocent and delightful! Since the designer, I'm assuming the bright colours on the dress were totally done on purpose and there'll be some CGI magic
That “see you in hell, Rob Marshall” is too real like I am LIVID for how they did my gurl😭
They wasted Halle's ethereal beauty!
The other problem with the shade of red that they chose for Halle Bailey’s Ariel is because the ocean is already so dull, it causes her hair to look like it blends into her skin. Making her hair a much more vivid red would have added more color and contrast, and made her more of a fantasy character.
... That's the whole point of a mermaid and siren is to be ethereal and fantastical that was the entire
plot of the movie, no offense
the art made by fans of her with red hair and all the dresses in the animation is a thousand times better than the film, it gives the impression that she is a real Ariel
I may be completely off topic here but.... eh.
The most stupid thing they did is to make the sea not vibrant at all. Including swapping species for the two friends (one became a land crab and the other not an albatross). Sea life is so vibrant they can make you look at zoos pitifully. Even Shark Tale can be referred if they do any homework with existing 3d sealife movies, or if they just take a look at actual sealife documentaries. It's a shame. Not to mention now there will be no Melody existing in the future because now Ariel is asexual.
@@MollyHJohns I know, it looked so dull and boring.
Wait her hair was supposed to be red in the film?? It just looked brown to me, I figured they just decided to not follow the original design at all
Honestly, I always liked Cinderella’s live action dress the most but also felt like something was missing that I couldn’t put my finger on… you NAILED it!!!
I agree, I did think she was the best representation of all the live action films thus far and seeing the accessories and updo made the look even better!😄😊
This was the best of all your redesigns IMO. You didn’t do much to the dress, but everything you did made it look closer to the original! Standing ovation here! 👏
The thing missing is that gorgeous winter silver color that all of the dresses lack.
same... i can hardly find anything wrong with the 2015 Cinderella- but i have to admit this was better in reality. so good!!!
They cgi’d the dress into the darker blue that’s in the movie, so the actual dress that was made for the movie looks sort of like the redesigned one if I remember correctly. I think the original dress almost looked like it was painted with watercolors.
Disney really did Halle dirty. They should have kept the scene when king triton makes her human and she has the sparkly dress, the costume department would have had a field day making Halle something amazing to wear.
The sparkly dress is so iconic for me, the fact they didn't recreate it for the live action made me so sad.
It’s almost as if they stirred up controversy on purpose to get people talking about the movie, in order to sell it. It’s unethical, but a lot of brands do this these days to sell their products - intentionally create controversy to get people talking about their products. As some people say, “all press is good press”. Just think of people like The Kardashians, or Trump - they do this too.
Unfortunately, though, when corporations use people like Halle for such purposes without telling them about their plans, innocents like her get caught in the crossfire. And she had to put up with a lot of stress and racism as a result, and didn’t get the fair treatment that she should have received as a Disney Princess. Ariel wears several beautiful dresses in the film, and has gorgeous hair. They didn’t give her any of that. Her costumes for the marketing were good, but that was about it. And she tried very hard.
I personally didn’t like the film, and I definitely prefer everything about the original to the remake, even including the songs (I know that a lot of people like Halle’s voice, but I felt that she did not receive good direction, and prefer the original songs).
However, I don’t blame Halle for that, and no one should. I blame Disney. Anyone who blames Halle for the film failing is vicious, and probably quite prejudiced.
I definitely think that this was a case of Disney intentionally trying to make their film controversial, to drum up interest. Controversy just equals free advertisement for them. They stopped caring about the quality of their films long ago, and Halle ended up being a scapegoat for their unethical practices. It’s a hard lesson for her to learn, but at least she has made a name for herself now and has lots of fans, and hopefully she can navigate the industry wisely from here on out.
I personally had a horrible experience in the industry when I was younger, and it caused me to leave all of my dreams behind, right when I was on the precipice of attaining them. I realised how awful Hollywood is, and how much they use and abuse young women. So I hope that she at least understands that her fame has now given her power to protect herself from those who would use her and cause her harm. And that she learns to differentiate between studios who are passionate about making movies for the sake of art, and those who are interested in making movies because they are creepy, pretentious, greedy, or interested in using her in some way without telling her - just as she was used here by Disney.
Yes! I was so pissed about the ending being so borinh
Omg yesss. I’ve been saying the same thing. It’s one of the most iconic and memorable moments in the animated movie. Why didn’t they translate that into the live action.
+ they didn’t give her pretty outfits in the live action.
@@justanotherhappyhumanist8832 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
I agree with Mulan's redesign. Idk how accurate this is but red strikes me more as a royal color while Mulan is just a soldier. Would've loved to see a mere footsoldier in green kick some hhigh-ranking butt.
I do remember one of Xiran's videos on Mulan that mentioned that Chinese Emperors apparently used to wear red and black before it changed to yellow.
If you want the best Mulan live action watch the Vicky Zhao's one. To me she IS Mulan. And yes she wore everything (no freestyle banshee hair, no hidden inherited Qi BS, no witch archenemies), like in this PS version.
I have enough interest in Chinese culture that i started to leave a comment, and then i wasn't sure about stuff so i googled, and honestly I'm just gonna c+p the wiki section on the color red in Chinese culture (note i also know enough to know this is not fully comprehensive of all red's historical associations etc but it'll do)
Red (红; 紅 hóng), vermilion (丹 dān), and crimson (赤 chì) are associated with masculine yang energy and fire, good fortune and joy. Red is the traditional color used during Chinese New Year and other celebrations, including weddings and wedding gowns. Chinese reds are traditionally inclusive of shades English might consider orange or warm brown.
A hongbao, a red envelope stuffed with money, now frequently red 100 RMB notes, is the usual gift in Chinese communities for Chinese New Year, birthdays, marriages, bribes, and other special occasions. The red color of the packet symbolizes good luck. Red is strictly forbidden at funerals as it is traditionally symbolic of happiness.[7] The names of the dead were previously written in red,[citation needed] so it is generally somewhat offensive to use red ink for Chinese names in contexts other than official seals.
In the People's Republic of China, red remains a very popular color and is affiliated with and used by the Communist Party and the government.
Meanwhile from the section on blue/green (there's not a distinction between blue and green in Chinese) "[blue/green] was associated with health, prosperity, and harmony." Plus everything with like, jade and stuff.
So honestly, green is a WAY better fit on every level lmao. Also i now feel weird knowing they always put Mulan in red text.
Red, not just any red, but a specific shade, as well as Gold/yellow, were colors reserved for the Emperor and the Empress.
Belle's redesign looks too victorian. The golden hue is perfection but the gown should look more like something out of Marie Antoinette's wardrobe. The Snow White redesign looks really neat, I love how simple yet elegant it is. Apparently a lot of that movie is being reworked in reshoots, so it is likely that costume design will change a bit as well.
Definitely think they need to take note from 2015's "Cinderella," both visually and in terms of writing.
I think in the animated original movie, indeed, Belle’s gown IS victorian. It’s gorgeous but absolutely not history accurate. (In fact Cinderella’s gown from the live action is like the original’s Belle one but blue, without the « puffy fabric over the skirt ») and yes, it would have been great if it was more Marie-Antoinette like. Like the side characters, figurants dancing at the end.
The silhouette and style of Belle's gown is definitely more victorian in silhouette, which doesn't match the historical setting of the rest of the movie.
@@jahanshadi1934that’s why Disney movies are set in a fantasy world with its own history and everything, so that’s why we can’t say something is historically accurate when it’s a parallel/different universe
Agree. Too much
5:20 I didn’t realize I could love the Cinderella look even more. This is absolutely gorgeous and spot on! Cinderella 2015 is my favorite of the live actions, and this look would have been perfect in it!
They did Halle so dirty! Still better than Belle's Ballgown, brought to us by Ross: Dress for Less. Let's hope they do better by Tiana and Rapunzel!
If those live action will actually be released,since Bob Iger is canceling some projects
@@lindaarrigoni6737 lets hope they get canned.
I don’t want live action Tiana , give us the damn 2D series follow up , and heavy on the “2D” . Don’t live action , Don’t sequel . Don’t 3D !
No the tail is so beautiful
@@lilachodan4941 I think they are talking about the actual dress not the tail . She only had two dresses and they pretty much were the same dress just different colors
I think for Jasmine they wanted to do something like Bollywood movies, full of colors and jewelries
But Aladdin is a middle eastern fairy tale, why would they want to make it look like Bollywood??
I dont know, i guess this is inspiration ? Bollywood style is full of songs, dances and colors, it fits with Disney cartoons. I guess it can be some reasons.
@-Theo- alladin is actually ancient Chinese in origin . So the costumes being culturally south Asian makes sense .
@@asimnegi5078
It’s not ancient Chinese… it’s from a thousand and one nights, the name Aladdin is literally Arabic. In some versions of the story, it starts with “In a faraway land called China”, but the story itself isn’t actually Chinese and even then it’s only a few versions that start that way. Even if it was an ancient Chinese story (which it wasn’t), what would that have to do with Bollywood movies? China is in east Asia not South Asia.
@@-Theo- It’s really odd and wonky as to where the Aladdin story is supposed to take place (I mean the OG fairytale, not the Disney version). The narrative did say it took place in China originally, but they still used Arabic terms and gave us an Arabic feel for, well, the whole setting. So it’s confusing, but I’ve always gathered that it actually is supposed to be Arabic.
I think casting Emma Watson was the huge mistake consider how much she ended up changing the plot and the dress, we would have had a Cinderella gown 2.0 but instead we got this monstrosity of a dress
She complained about the weight of the dress so they CGId it to makei t look fuller and you can really tell . . .
EDut: such an emma, thing to do, she did it with harry potter hence the infortunate loss of curls and school uniform in the latter movies. Its a shamme how she single handedly thwarts the potentially great costume design of every movie she featuresin
Edit: 105 likes tysm guys 💖
@@Heejinbunnyyeah which is stupid because I think Lily talked about how her dress surprisingly way lighter than she thought it was gonna be, even though she did sort of get a little cinched and a little bit more than she should’ve
And Lily at least wore the damn corset ! Emma was too “feminist “ to do so ! On top of visually destroying Belles gown ! They gave her WAY too much lead way .
Emma Watson cast to play hermione Granger - loves books, spends a majority of her time in the libray
Belle - loves books spends a majority of he time visiting the towns booktore/libray
🤔
These characters have far too much in common and they both resemble each other in looks
@@jesslockwood7978 the issue is she didn’t play Belle good or represent what Belle means really , even down to the dress . We don’t care if she looks like her . She was PERFECT as Hermoine tho .
Controversial opinion, but I adore Cinderella's and Jasmine's live action gowns. I haven't seen the 2nd movie but Aurora's costume in the first movie made sense to me. She had no idea she was royalty, she was raised as a poor commoner in the woods so it makes sense to me that her clothing doesn't look as lavish and expensive.
Not controversial at all 😊 I think Cinderella’s dress in the 2015 film is stunning. I actually love it more than the cartoon original!
@@TheGreekPianist Cinderella’s is definitely a beautiful dress but I agree with the creator of the video, making it just a bit lighter blue helps make it more like the animated dress, which is what the creator was going for. I also like Jasmine’s outfit but the mesh looks a little funny and the colors are a bit flat without something to break up the flatness. I think even having it a different fabric, maybe something shimmery, might give the shirt and pants some depth 😊
Yeah I have no problems with Aurora and Cinderella's dressing at all.
i completely agree
The fact that Disney made Bell’s dress piss yellow will never not be funny.
Piss yellow 😂😭 stawwwp yes it's not golden but that is still a very important and lovely shade of yellow okayyyy?! (Coming from a person that wouldn't be caught dead in or by yellow-only maybe the muted pastel ones maaaybe, but this is a slight joke too)
It's even more funny when you find out that they put A LOT of research and money into getting the "perfect" yellow for Belle's dress!!! 😂
In the original, the color of Aurora's dress was constantly changing, lol.
True
Loved your redesign of Snow white, looks soooo much better
I actually like Cinderella's and Jasmine's costumes. Cinderella has the most beautiful dress in a disney remake.
I totally agree with you on Belle's dress. It's so bad. I love the one you designed for her
Cinderella and Jasmine should be the standard for the rest of the remakes
Belle's and Snowhite's surely classify as crime.
I can't believe they actually thought they were alright.
Also, you made Ariel actually be Ariel.
Holy cow. Never even considered an updo on the Cinderella actress, but it makes such a difference. She looks the part completely !
Thank you for fixing Cinderella's look. I always thought that the lack of accessories made the focus be on the dress and not on Cinderella herself. That was a problem.
No.
The jewellery made her look evil or something.
@@TedEhioghae
In what world did you grow up in where jewellery makes a person look evil?
@TedEhioghae H O W???
Damn that’s so true about jewellery, it brings the focus back to you
Hmm, it's funny how your designs depart more from the source material and yet capture the essence of the characters far better than the cheapish designs we actually got in the live-action films.
Ariel and Cinderella are just yes yes yes!!!
Disney should hire you as a designer
I agreed with all but Jasmine. I think the colors and style were beautiful and went with the story very well
Right the only thing she really needed tweaked (like all woc) is the mesh so that the illusion was there. Actually there, not party city or something. I also wanted her to actually have just a two piece set (no mesh nothing flowy all that) like the one from the animated movie but I thought it was still pretty.
same actually!!
same but i also loved the redesign. as bad as the live action film was the costumes and outfits were amazing. i even loved her outfit when she was in the shop where she first met aladdin
@@commanderwolffeex Wait wait wati... you didnt like the live action remake?? what did you not like about it? i admit, i didnt love how Jasmine was (so girl-powery, and just feminist and slightly obnoxious) but i thought pretty much everything else was spot on. I actually loved Will Smith as the genie, and Aladdin was just perfect. i loved the costumes and the sets, and also... i mean jafar was perfect for that role! 😏
To be fair, i didn't really grow up with the old one, so i can understand if you have like nostalgia about the old one, but i think it's one of the best live action remakes (after cinderella of course 😁)
sorry for the rant!!
🙃🤦♀
The original looks a lot more like traditional Indian clothing, I love all the jewellery in it. The edited image didn't remind me of India at all! Would've maybe kept the hair, though, it looks good when it's down.
If I was a Disney producer, I'd hire you.
I love all the costumes.
No doubt about it, yours are the best!
Hard agree!
I love that specific shade of red you chose for Ariel. It immediately strikes as something ad familiar and ‘out of place’, yet still good enough to look natural a bit more.
I am so happy ariel finally got her princess moment! Your redesigns of her really made her ariel to me, especially that pink dress and the brighter red hair!!!! STUNNING!
The Little Mermaid was just such a great example of how the remakes focus on the wrong things. You primarily identify Ariel by her hair and they just ignored it
☺️ Our leading ladies definitely deserved higher quality fabrics and classy shades given the budgets of their films. Your ideas are true to the heart of each Disney fairytale while reaching the sophisticated standards of the real world.
I like aurora’s live action outfits, they’re supposed to look medieval
Belle's gown: 💕
Jasmine's outfit: ❤ I'm a sucker for gauze.
Ariel's looks and outfits: Yessss ❤
Mulan: Nice, nice. That movie disappointed me overall.
Cinderella's gown: Not a bad alternative
Snow White: I'm praying for you Ms Zegler. First she had to deal with Snow and now this.
Damn....u gave Snow White's a glow up. The original felt like they weren't trying
I adore what you did for Ariel! Halle deserved better smh
The Snow White one..WOW. You actually managed to make her look good!
Disney needs to hire more fans who actually care to make it a good movie and good designs and good story
You’ve very right about Bella’s gown I never paid attention to the live action design like that before
As a merman (someone who’s in the Mermaid community) and long time Little Mermaid fan sense I was born I actually loved that they made Ariel’s top apart of her body. It slightly makes her more fishy especially with the added faint scales they put on her shoulders and arms. Sometimes sea shell tops in real life can look either bulky or very funny looking and it’s hard for me to take seriously.
They should have just went with the original prototype top design because it makes her look even more like a mermaid and it is creative how it’s done (almost like her nipples are scales that fade into her body). I hope that makes sense, if you seen the screen test I think you know what I mean. But yeah I agree with everything else about Ariel!
Disney, come get this fella, he surely knows more about designing and style 😊❤.
Love all of these but especially Ariel’s. Belle’s ball gown was horrible but they did all of Ariel’s looks dirty.
It was the actresses' choice though. The one for Belle (Emma Watson) complained about the original dress and in subsequent films the actress playing the princess was given control over her costuming. For Ariel, that included the dull brown dreadlocks, the pink head band and both the dresses.
The little mermaid is a Danish story it’s one thing if they did a retelling like the classic story the frog prince/princess story like princess and the frog but no they just race swap the character how unoriginal and you can only do so much with dreadlocks
@@kirayoungblood Those were a bad choice in general. The live action movie has alot of issues, the leading actress being a one of them. She's not good at acting and her singing is not Ariel (She butchered Part of that world). She can't even emote when she has no voice. There's plenty of other issues (story, lore, music, the CGI, and most of the other actors), but they really needed to find another actress to be Ariel. At least one who wanted to become the character
@@kirayoungbloodthis isn't the "danish" story. since when does denmark have jamaican singing crabs, a tropical caribbean themed setting, or calypso music?
@@kirayoungblood You’re full of shit.
The story of The Little Mermaid has absolutely nothing to do with Denmark or Danish culture. Even the animated movie took place in either a fantasy world or just an unspecified corner of the world.
Ariel’s story had nothing to do with being white. You’re just looking for an excuse to be mad. Take your racist BS elsewhere.
Susan Egan's gold/white ballroom and gold/red rose finale dresses in Beauty and the Beast on Broadway are the best Belle dresses ever made and I will die on this hill.
The moment I saw Cinderellas dress in 2015, I knew Belles dress was going to be changed. Cinderellas dress is the exact same silhouette as Belles animated gown. While everyone was cheering, I was crying because I knew that Belles dress was the best Disney princess gown. I didnt think Disney had the imagination to pull off something better in live action. And I was right.
Literally.
This. ALLLLLL of this. Cinderella got the dress that Beauty and the Beast deserved. Not to mention, it will never not piss me off that the OG gown in the animated movie was SILVER and because of princess marketing, it was abandoned.
Gotta confess, Belles' dress was always my least favorite as a kid. It reminds me of the 90s and early 2000s prom dresses with pickups and made of overly shiny polyester. I always personally disliked pick up skirts. Whenever I watched the animated movie, I always thought of prom dresses.......
The original design was done on purpose. First of all, they followed the concept art from the 1950 version. Ella didn't wear her hair up, wear gloves or jewellery because the designer wanted her to stand out from all the other women who were dressed that way.
Every detail was done on purpose and for a reason.
i disagree with your version of Jasmine
Me too 😢
Not even historically accurate
Yeah. The original's so much better!!
I loved Halle as Ariel, yet, you're right. I don't understand why they decided to take away all those details that made Ariel be Ariel. I would love her to see her with red hair, and keep the colors of the tail and bra.
i just wanna say smthn about the jasmine costume, the live action actually does a half better job than the animation, of course jasmin's costume in the animation is the worst representation of what arab princesses wore, it looks more like what the slaves wore, the live action did a better job at atpeast giving her jewellery and details which is accurate to that time had she been a slave rather than a princess, i'm sorry yours isn't very accurate either but it's ok cuz even we as arabs tend to make our own culture more aesthetic than it actually was, i personally couldn't careless as long as it's enjoyable to watch but i should make it more known
Isn't that the point? That Jasmine was basically a slave to the patriarchy and a prisoner in her own home? She's forced to wear that outfit to show off her beauty to her suitors and is expected to be nothing but a trophy wife. That's why she hates being a princess.
Also, none of the princesses have ever worn authentic apparels. They're meant to be reflect the beauty standards of the time their movies came out. Crop top popularity peaked in the early 90's, that's why Jasmine wears one.
Oh my gosh i love cinderellas dress! I never really got the hype behind the one in the movie, it always seemed a bit off. I think the softer blue fits Lily James so much better and the gloves, necklace, and updo make it look way more complete!
They need to hire you. Love your dedication to doing photoshop jobs, theyre visually very effective and absolutely communicate your point, on top of the redesigns just being much better overall
For jasmines the final result looks like a bunch of clear plastic bags taped on her
🤣
U know what else is funny u stole this comment from someone🤣🤣
3:31 omg she looks so darling!! We were robbed 😭😭
Jasmine didn't really need to be on the list. She was one of the ones who i think did quite well in design and looks!
Yo, someone who agrees with me
This was brilliant. I hope Disney gets ahold of it. Loved the music as well.
it's incredible how just simple color and fabric changes can totally elevate the looks. cinderella was stunning, snow white stunning, and a huge improvement for the little mermaid. i have no idea why they didn't make her hair red in the first place.
I could've agreed more! Belle is so GORGEOUS! Belle's dress is my most favorite of them all since I was child. So when Emma Watson was casted I felt so excited but then I got SO DISAPPOINTED AND ALWAYS RANTING ABOUT HER DRESS! I don't care if they tried to be realistic atleassstttt do the iconic dresses right! Its FANTASY!
I know I'm in the minority but I truly felt that Halle did have the Ariel vibe, petite and hour glass with a cute innocent face and beautiful voice, I truly think she was the perfect choice and your redesigns show that they just let her down with styling
Trust me, you’re not nearly as much in the minority as you think you are. The internet is just chock-full of racist trolls who want to find excuses to be mad.
There are plenty of people out here who see Halle’s merit and how well the role suits her. ❤
Halle was the perfect choice to be Ariel. Yet, Rob Marshall's decisions were totally wrong in certain aspects. He had to keep the red hair in her and the colors of the tail and the bra.
Same. I don't get the critizing
@@sethzarandona2325 Please stop that nonsense. No one cares about the fact that Ariel was black. It's the reasoning behind her casting that irritates people. Disney is a heartless corporation now that only cares about money. It's no longer actually about making a good movie and making kids happy it's all about the cash. Because of woke culture, minority representation in a movie = CASH. Don't you get it? Disney didn't actually want Halle for her talent. They ONLY wanted her for her black skin because they knew that a black Ariel would appeal to black audiences thus boosting sales. They used her for a cash grab and they used her as a SHIELD. Because that right there, what you're doing is exactly what they knew would happen. Everyone is always accused of being racist or prejudiced in some other way just because they disagree with something or don't like it, if it happens to have a minority or other oppressed type of person involved. We aren't allowed to say one bad word about this movie without people like YOU calling us a racist. Even if our criticism are about other things in the movie that have nothing to do with Halle (like Prince Eric's autotune singing and the terrible dark dreary look of the film) you still insist that we're racist and just hate Halle. More importantly, we aren't allowed to criticize Disney for doing that to Halle because they "gave us what we wanted". They gave us a black princess to admire and look up to so we're not allowed to criticize them or anything they do ever again (Even though they literally already did that 15 years ago with Princess Tiana. A hardworking black woman who is family, career and goal oriented and takes care of herself. All little black girls were inspired greatly by her). Don't be disrespectful and just throw the word racist around for no legitimate reason just because Disney has got you fooled.
She wasn't, there are hundreds of girls who would fit the vibe, but for some reason they chose one that looks NOTHING like ariel. Neither is the same ethnicity.... Yikes
Today I went to Disneyland. I saw so many people dress as Snow White and everyone look way better than the official live action. Their dresses are all darker and less vibrant. They feel like those old fairytale designs.
All of your redesigns are so perfect especially snow white except jasmine where i feel like the original is sm better
Omg I'm in love with that golden Belle dress😍😍😍
I think jasmines attire are fine as it is ... And cinderalla too though i like the way you tied up Cinderella's hair
The rest you made are gorgeous :3
Ariel in her pink dress!!
Wow I didn't expect to CRY with nostalgic little-girl princess longing at this one.
I catch myself watching vaguely grumpy takes on "modern Disney" here and there, and usually just share the vague grumpiness without getting worked up about it all. But...
Seeing Ariel in her gorgeous PINK princess dress, I just shocked myself by bursting into tears! I didn't know how much I needed to see that "Princess Moment."
Sincere thanks from a red haired lady who was 10 years old in 1989. ♡
I wish they made Ariel's hair more of a dark red. Kind of like Cat's from Victorious.
I once saw a guest dressed up at disney for the Halloween party, and she was wearing the live action Cinderella dress, but with the hair and accessories of the animation and it was BEAUTIFUL
The snow mejore was very healing as she’s my favorite and the beef I have over it is VERY personal
Loved all your reworks a lot! I just like the movie Jasmine costume more. I think the blue one was very beautiful. Besides that, you made the Cinderella dress absolutely perfect! And the Snow White one was really good too.
Ohhh, your Cinderella dress is perfection!! 😍
It is just what I wanted for the live action to look like. Nailed it!
Live action Ariel not getting the animated film's pink dress is a crime. The pink looked kind of bad on 2D Ariel with the rest of her palette but it fits really well on a darker skin tone.
These are actually really well done and I love the commentary. It's constructive and you praise the things that were good while giving good reason as to why the bad things are bad. Really wish they'd given Belle a fancier dress.
Omg I loved everything you did!! All the live action movies (apart from Cinderella) are SO disappointing! You really brought to life the fantasy and extravagance that a Disney Princess should have. Please please take over disneys designer!!
Ariels first screens with the glitter top was perfect
They do realize that the lil mermaid is about A LITERAL MERMAID AND A FLIPPING OCTOPUS WITCH?
THEY SHOULD'VE GAVE HALLE RED HAIR 😭 SHE'D LOOK AWESOME!
How about Abigail Cowen as Ariel? She was perfect and she sings... they raceswap her on purpose they eve changed her now and the trailer haves more dislikes than likes.. just create new charactes
@@nataliaberrios3155 No.
@@Feral-Werecat how lazy..
@@nataliaberrios3155 And how pathetic of you to have nothing better to do than post racist comments…
Your redesign of Ariel is basically how I imagined it ever since the live action was first announced. Like I was pretty excited for this movie until I saw the teasers, the promos, the ads, the posters….It just ahh broke my heart. The colours were completely muted. The cgi looked questionable at times and my poor girl Ariel was done so dirty that I’m convinced they did it on purpose. They give her cheap ass looking clothings. They gave her brownish braids when they know darn well they could’ve given her a vibrant red that still compliments her skin tone and the worst travesty of all, they didn’t give her her iconic pink dress AND that sparkly dress at the end. I mean come on.
I’m sorry for ranting too much but listen, it’s fair 💙.
The Little Mermaid is my favourite film in general, and the live action is my favourite live action film, but the costume choices did irk me. I get it, they weren't expecting a guest, but even so, the dress they did give her could have been way more regal, and you did a fantastic job capturing what I imagined her blue dress to look like.
Adding the updo and gloves to Cinderella OMGGGG!!!
“could not be purchased in a mall” and “adds pop to a dull-looking film” killed me 😭😭😭
Love the redesigns ! 🌸 I’m a fashion student, I personally think the Cinderella one is lovely, just the gloves are a little much, it takes the concentration off the dress itself 👐🌸
This! All of this! (Yes, even the Mulan costume) “how the mighty have fallen” is right. My finest compliment to you… except for Aurora’s. Make it blue!
I am genuinely so shocked at how the mighty icon of a designer for the Cinderella dress did the Snow White one… HOW DO YOU GO FROM THAT GORGEOUS PIECE OF ART TO THAT MONSTROSITY SCARIER THAN THE PLAUGE?! WHAT DO YOU MEAN😭
Belle's dress was always my favorite, I was really disappointed with the live action one
I've always imagined Aurora's hair to be a little bit like Elle Woods; fluffy, thick, largely rounded at the ends, golden/white blonde hair that bounces and almost floats on its own. BUT, you did an amazing job redesigning everything. I wish disney would pick up their slack. I refuse to spend any more money on them and their new stuff. Bring old disney back :(
Love your changes! I still love Cinderella's film look, but your recreation is also gorgeous. The rest are fantastic. They should hire you.
2:53
It's giving Lola from Sharktale and I'm here for it 😭
IDK BUT SHE DOES LOOK LIKE LOLA FROM SHARK TALE
Even better he character is literally Ariel THE MERMAID.
(Compliment because Lola is an icon and she's gorgeous 😭💖)
Sand Beige costume will always look better that what Disney gave us.
While some of the costumes are better in the various movies than others, I do agree that Cinderella set the bar high in terms of all the costumes in that movie being pure, extravagant fancy and that the other live action movies have struggled to get to that point.
Your redesigns for Snow White ans Belle are glorious! Mulan and Belle's changes aren't severe to the point where I needed a redesign, and I love Cinderella as-is (they avoided being a literal remake, so that helped). Not crazy about Ariel's redesigns, but they're much better than what we got, and obviously the skinbearing on Jasmine (and Aladdin) are something I'm glad the remake avoided, given the critiques Jasmine has received as being sexualized and Aladdin was confirmed to be sexualized for the female audience (which reads bad to me since his story could be a metaphor for maturing, and being sexualized isn't the best thing to include in that, imo).
I think Ariel's sisters had a bit of the right idea in their mermaid forms. Their tops and tails look like they were scales that's part of their skin. This gives the perfect excuse to not use she'll bikini.
It's actually a bit odd why she's the odd one out in that type of design.
I like how you actually had good criticism of their dresses and I didnt just skip to the reveals because it was sort of funny haha
i actually like aurora’s dress in Maleficent. it reflects the time period and its very accurate
Feels very accurate to the 1400s.
Your Cinderella redo is WOW. That would have been stunning!!!
I thought Jasmine's outfits in the remake were actually great. Way better than what this person made, at least. Back then they didn't exactly have pastel color palettes, everything _was_ extremely vibrant and colorful and since certain dyes were expensive, having vibrant colors were also a sign of wealth and status. Jasmine absolutely _should_ be wearing vibrant colors with many small details and embroidery to show the fact that she is a princess! And she would likely _not_ be showing any skin or wear pants *which is why Disney changed it for the live action.* They were actually _trying_ to be historically and culturally accurate!! And yet her outfit still definitely feels like Jasmine.
And yet live action Jasmine did not look any more authentic. Especially since the actress isn't even an Arab.
I agree about the colors but nothing about the live action costumes was culturally accurate. And the purple outfit she wears at the end had pants
0:38 wait your actually so right, it genuinely looks like it could be in Harry Potter 💀
Man you really know your stuff! I am a total loser when it comes to fashion sense so this was a very insightful video!
Your designs are perfect, even cindrella look seems fresh
In defense of the live action Mulan (and I haven't seen it nor do I plan to; I gave up on these after Aladdin), I know what they were going for, but Western audiences do not understand it. Okay, so I saw the preview and immediately understood the reference because I LOVE Chinese fantasy dramas about gods and goddesses and spirits. THAT is what they did. They literally changed the character to be more like those goddess or spirit characters. One of my favorite Chinese fantasy dramas is "Eternal Love" (aka "Ten Miles of Peach Blossoms"). They did a movie version, which is shorter by...hours, and they did a TV "mini"series (their miniseries are very long, this one is 43.5 hours long). The main character is a Nine-Tailed Fox Spirit. It's common in these dramas to do those acrobatic aerial movements and fights. They also are gods/goddesses/spirits and don't always wear armor. That's why they did that. The problem is...most Americans do not watch those shows (they should, they are AWESOME). I doubt most Europeans watch them. So, Western countries don't know those tropes. That's why the costumes were that way as well as the movements. I think it was ridiculous to change the character since she is human, but Disney was sucking up to China. That movie was trying to appeal to Chinese audiences and failed since they also didn't like the changes. Mulan is not a goddess in China. Put aside the fact that most Chinese people are atheists, she's not in their mythology as a goddess or a spirit.
Rant over.
Look up the "Eternal Love" drama if you have several days to kill! It's not dubbed, but you can find it with subtitles. It is worth the 43.5 hours! It's an amazing story that is woven so well. Or watch the movie version.
I agree the 2015 Cinderella dress was beautiful. I think it was also probably the best life action remake they did too. The actor was beautiful they gave her such an elegant personality and the theme of kindness was more emphasized and so was the loss of her parents. And the dress was really really pretty. It’s on of the only expeditions to changing what the dress looks like in my opinion because in the other movies they changes what the original outfit looked like and it didn’t work but in Cinderella they could have said okay let’s just copy the original but instead they said let’s do what we’re doing but do it correctly this time and it showed. I do agree on the lighter colors considering her original dress in the movie was not blue it was silver but looked blue in lighting but I loved the little butterflies and cgi they did for it and you did a great job at touching it up.
jasmine dresses in the live action is amazing. its one of the top 3 live action dresses for me. Belle and Ariel on the other hand. i really like the redesign more . and i agree with you on mulan and cinderella and Aurora
I like Ariel’s looks in the movie but I do think it’s weird Vanessa has maybe 3 minutes of screen time and more variety to her outfits than Ariel gets- and no big I am a human glittery dress?
I agree that Belle’s dress is the biggest offender but it’s tricky to picture just right because I feel the film does a lot wrong like mishandling the visual of Belle and beast as the only characters in blue and her colour palettes warming as she warms to the beast. Something that was great visual story telling in the cartoon the live action just dropped entirely- like that’s WHY her dress is gold why she wore green and pink before then. But in the live action you can tell they didn’t apply that level of thought it was just hey she wore yellow in the cartoon so let’s make a yellow dress here. And I could almost forgive it being simple lacking structure and volume and being the most basic outfit of the whole movie… could have genuinely been fine with it IF they didn’t add the terrible glitter details on that look like glue and glitter for a kids project.
The Ariel designs are absolutely beautiful. Such a shame that they made her color palette so dull in the final film. Even early concept art and screen tests showed her with a more vibrant orangeish red hair color, not the ginger-blondeish brown they gave her final look. Halle deserved that striking Disney princess look.
The live action Snow White dress is so awful it's comical. It looks like a dress I would wear on Halloween. Your design is so much better!
Ok, I love how you DESIGN Cinderella's dress but I'll still prefer the look they go in the live action. First the style lily's hair in a sort of tiara look without using an actual jewelry
For the Cinderella argument...it is less that she is intended to look "simple", and more that she is intended to look eye catching. Cinderella worked because not only was the design gorgeous and still undoubtedly looked elegant, royal and refined, it also lacks the patterns and detailing on most of the other dresses, it lacks the elaborate accessories intended to display wealth, it lacks the formal tying your hair up which was the norm back in this time. The choice to make her design not have any accessories, complicated patterns, or a formal updo is what set her apart visually from the other ball attendees. She wasn't a princess, but she was about to become a queen.
Oh and by your logic of simplicity, I'm pretty sure the cost of Lily James's peasant costume, home set, peasant accesories, peasant hair and makeup, should ALSO make her rich, but it doesn't. Why? Because that's not something in universe. Nobody in the movie (as far as I remember) described her dress to be containing Swarovski crystals, and we're not even sure if they'd be aware of the worth of something like that, or even its existence (assuming it was named after someone after their period?). This opposition is a bit of a fallacy to me, but I can see the point about the dress being extravagant nonetheless. That's absolutely a princess dress.
I'd like to add : I absolutely LOVE your version of the Cinderella design, it's definitely more true to the original. Though I think I prefer the current movie as it is.
Fun fact: The real dress from the Cinderella remake is actually similar in color to the original. In the movie, for some reason, they painted it blue.
While I didn’t have an issue with most of the outfits (I did with Ariel’s a little bit but I overlooked because I was more concerned about the storyline) I LOVE your redesigns. VERY exquisite!
tbh I thought snow white's dress was so cheep and ugly, until I saw that image with the dwarves shown at 5:40 , which make it just make sense!
It goes so well with the atmosphere and the colours of the set it looks like a charming little children's storybook, rather than rich, elegant, expensive, and unattainable that the others go for. I just don't think that's the vibe they want to go for in this film. It's set in a humble cottage not a diamond castle. It just looks so fun and innocent and delightful!
Since the designer, I'm assuming the bright colours on the dress were totally done on purpose and there'll be some CGI magic
I desperately wanted Ariel’s silver sparkly dress from the end and they just put her in the same blue dress again 😢