alll mammals have ears perfecly aligned with thier eye line, so hearing smelling and sound are close together, hence where we have ears is where cats have them.
I think I’ve said it on every one of these, but the Harry Potter movies would be cool to dive into. Specifically monsters like the basilisk, buck beak, werewolf, dementors...the list goes on
They would look better with cat noses. People noses don't look good on cats. Even in the Broadway show they altered the noses to look like cat noses. If they do that, I think people wouldn't be so weirded out by it
Credit to this comment : Danielle Williams Original comment on the trailer of Cats : When taylor swift said "I'll be the actress starring in your bad dreams", she was trying to warn us.
"Some things are bad because they fail at what they set out to do. Others are bad because they succeeded, because what they set out to do was gross and dumb" -Ben 'Yahtzee' Croshaw
Lion King 2019 Trailer: The VFX looks great, but the animals could probably use some more human characteristics to help them emote. Cats Trailer: TOO FAR, TOO FAR, GO BACK!
"This is the worst musical ever" And by far the hardest to preform! You have to be a perfect triple threat (a dancer, actor, and singer!) be able to sing and dance for 3 hours straight, and do 8 shows a week!
Lily Flowers Dolls right!?! I love broadway and no cats isn’t my favorite but it’s so interesting and it puts the audience in a different view so I think that it’s pretty awesome. And yes those performers are putting 100% into their performance and I appreciate it.
I also think this movie takes a little from that aspect. Because it's such a hard and demanding show to do, you end up appreciating the performances much more than when they're actors covered in fake fur and general cg, because they register in your mind like amazing human feats, actual people doing things without the aid of visual effects technology, while in this the cg takes center stage. I don't know if I explained it well but i tried hahah
One thing I've noticed in the Cat characters is that while they have human faces, they don't have human ears on the side, the side of their head is empty and it's creepy as hell.
"All the reactions here have nothing to do with the technical execution. This isn't about the visual effects. It's about the art direction" Say it one more time for all the Disney CG remake apologists!
My problem with Cats: The stage costumes are already good...why make them... What ever this is... And the way the actors move... It just looks like someone dropped an ice cube down their shirt. The movement doesnt look natural. Its too over the top for a film. That kind of movement is fine on stage where everything needs to be over the top so people can see it clearly, but when you are in front of the camera it doesnt work. When you are shooting something the movement needs to be more suddle, more natural. How to fix it: Dont make it live action. Do it as animation. I dont know why people are allergic to animation now a days. Not everything fits as live action movie. Cats being one of them.
The honest fact is you won’t get actors like Ian McKellen into a makeup chair for over 4 hours every day for an almost 8-12 hour shoot with some of the most difficult choreography ever that happened in film. In makes more sense from both a money perspective, a safety perspective, and an artistic perspective to do this movie with CGI
I do think that animation would work, but i would go like a style similar to samurai jack, no outlines and very stylized, that and stoo motion would go really nicely with some of the visuals, you could even keep some od the more theatrical stuff
The film was originally a 2d animated film in the same vain as Renaissance Disney and was directed by Speilberg, but the animation studio shot down during production. You can find storyboards and character designs readily online
also my favorite "sci fi older actor went into exile because of the rise of an evil empire and the new generation of hero's must convince him to save the day while also learning valuable lessons about themselves" movie
Can you please talk about Shark Boy and Lava Girl/Spy Kids, those were some of my favourite childhood films and part of what got me interested in VFX and they aged...interestingly
My favourite thing about this series is when someone is explaining something with their hands and everyone else just rocks around the couch listening awkwardly
@Rizzo Grant exactly, it should either be the same costumes from the show and NO CGI or just literal CGI cats. Honestly, I prefer neither and for this movie not to exist at all, but both are preferable to mutant pygmy cat-people.
My problem with the Cats movie is that they tried to literally adapt a broadway stage show to a movie screen. This lead to a lot of inconsistency because what we have to use to portray animals and creatures on stage does not translate to film. The same goes for books, video games and other media. I think it would have been so much if they made actual CG cats that could dance and stuff like the "live asction" lion king animals... or even Puss In Boots from shrek? I mean Lion King The Musical is great, but there is a reason disneu didn't do what Cats did for the live action version agh. It just did such injustice to the actual story that Cats tells of llife and rebirth and spirituality and the natural world.....
with todays computers that would take a week to a whole month to render, none of them is cgi unless they are time travelers from the future with powerful computers
Best episode of this show so far. Good on you for listening to feedback and making the VFX breakdowns in this one way more substantive. Very informative! Real fun intro sketch too. Great work guys 👍
woah hold one, Jogwheel?! you guys are the ones who made that old hit series Is It A good Idea To Microwave This I had no idea you were still active on youtube, that's really cool! huge fan of your work!
And it doesnt help when they have cartoony proportions with an art style that is photorealistic thusly making it jarring, like with that battle angel movie
Man of Steel. The opening Krypton sequence has everything from digital characters, water sims, destruction sims, digital suits, Kelor's metal bead display thingy! Phenomenal artistry.
As a Furry, you might be right... HOWEVER, furries don't mostly have human characteristics. Furries are anthropomorphic animals, meaning animals with human characteristics, like Zootopia characters. They walk on two legs, still look like an animal but talks like a human and thinks like a human. They still have their animalistic face and or limbs. THIS MOVIE HOWEVER, is just about humans that barely look like cats! The arms and face and legs are the same as normal humans. All they did was just stick some fur on their skin and add a tail. Not to mention the addition to whiskers. Long story short, IF you wanna make a movie about animals with human characteristics, do it like Zootopia. Wanna make it realistic? Make it less cartoony, and do it right. But if you wanna make a musical featuring HUMANS with ANIMAL characteristics, seek help because nobody would like to see that. I bet even if you make fun of the furry fandom and say that everyone in it would want to see the movie, you're wrong. Trust me.
@@elementartsofficial68 I think it'd look a lot better if they did it with actual theatre costumes, like the video said. But apparently that's not allowed in movies? Have to use CGI just for the sake of being different. A lot of people out there don't seem to get how audience immersion works.
@@kingBenTheBadger how is he a credit thief? His performance is all we really care about. Gollum/PoTA is the only films where the Visual Effects outshine his talent
James Corden seems so dumb when he says ”these are people but these are cats, actually blowing my mind” as if he never saw a photo from the broadway show
@@kayden2119 this video literally just said that its not the cgi which looks good but is still unfinished. its the movement choices and uncanny valley designs.
That analysis of the 2012 scene is exactly what keeps me coming back to this channel. Such an insightful examination that I would have never even thought of.
Technically it's OK I guess, pretty good in some scenes. The thing is you can always tell you're looking at a full CGI caracter and it just removes you from the story, wich isn't great in the first place.
@@musguelha14 I actually kept forgetting she was CG, I was only reminded that she's not real when she were in shots next to real characters. I honestly didn't expect the CG to be that good, but it was. The benefit of having James Cameron as producer, I suppose.
@@musguelha14 I agree with what Arcian said. But I didn't even think about it in the scenes where Alita stands next to real characters. Of course there are scenes that are obviously CG, but those were made in such a stylistic way, that they still fit pretty well and weren't distracting at all. But you can see, since we already have different opinions here, that it would be awesome to see the guys talk about it in a future episode :D
On John wick, we made real firearms for the film. I was on the small crew making the rifles, pistols, and shotguns. They were real weapons (that's as far as I know if they used blanks, or just cg flashes) But we hand built and modified the guns
Thanks for watching er'body! If you want to watch this entire show from the beginning you can do that here ►
ua-cam.com/video/_4WrKeoeZhk/v-deo.html
How come you commented this 2 years after posting?
One of the main sticking points is the director didn’t know how to direct for/around cgi. He never done it before
alll mammals have ears perfecly aligned with thier eye line, so hearing smelling and sound are close together, hence where we have ears is where cats have them.
"Most of the effects we're seeing right now are unfinished"
And they still are.
They never finished it lol
no one cared about this until it was pointed out like a week later.
Hungry Hedgehog I saw it days after the alleged “patch” and plenty of effects were still bad
Same, I still see a lot of skin toned feet and hands.
Little did they know how bad it would get
My God, Clint doing a siren noise has earned my like, that cracked me up hahahaha
Pesterenan I died 😂
What you mean? That was just clint doing his mating call.
lmao
Same!! I had to pause I was laughing so hard!
I dont think any video can top that moment
I'm glad you guys take emergencies like this so seriously.
I really wish the likes had stayed at 420
THEIR PLANET NEEDS THEM!! They are called to duty! They are doing their part!!
Do not play with the urgency of a MSTK
0:32 very seriously
Just doin there job
"They walk like cats."
I never seen my cat stand on her 2 back feet, and did that weird motion with her front arms...
I have O.o
is that profile photo from "more semen please"
Enchanter110 ye, but you should use the japanese name to make finding it ‘easier’, “Itadeki Seiki”
Of course they mean they walk with catlike movements, nos AS a cat.
Haven’t you heard of the cat walk💁🏻♂️
I legit don't know if that alarm was truly Clint or a sound effect.
For real, I completely lost it when he started howling like that.
Roach DoggJR pretty sure it was clint🤔
Yes.
*meow*
4:41 Clint adjusting his glove as an excuse to put his arm behind Wren
I don't think I've laughed harder at a Corridor moment than Clint popping up with the sirens LMAO
Arcade Productions i thought i was the only one😂
Omg me too.
If you look closely you can see him trying to hold in his laugh
And i don't even know what's funnier - him suddenly doing it, or how good he's doing it 😂
My favorite was when he jumped on the couch and just ATE IT lol
Came for the Cats trash talking, stayed for Clint's siren.
M e E o O w
I literally hit the like button because of his siren lol
That siren part is way too funny
I laughed at that part.
And the glass blowing rant
Clint: (high-pitched siren wail)
Also Clint: *deep MEOW*
Took me a while to realize that Clint was the siren
Clint is a very diverse actor 🤓
He’s got great range
Impressive right?! I think he did that deep meow on the inhale but I might be wrong
I think I’ve said it on every one of these, but the Harry Potter movies would be cool to dive into. Specifically monsters like the basilisk, buck beak, werewolf, dementors...the list goes on
I'm thinking of how the Quidditch scenes hold up and how they improved over time.
I second this!
Totally! Especially with how those effects changed over the course of the movies.
Those are just regular boring cgi
There's tons of tasty CGI in Harry Potter. To the top you go!
"Nobody asked for this." Best description of this movie ever.
you deserve every like and even more
That also describes 90% of all movies that come out of hollywood these days
DangerZone no kidding...
They were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, they didn’t stop to think if they should
this comment is gold
Perfect explanation 👏
One day, extraterrestrials will build a monument on Earth in memory of the human species... On this headstone will be etched these words.
I love how he sounds EXACTLY like alarm siren, the whole intro sequence made my day.
*Cats Releases Trailer*
VFX Artists: I sense a disturbance in the force
As if millions of people cried out in terror before suddenly... silence
@@arandompasserby7940 , that was perfect 🤣
They would look better with cat noses. People noses don't look good on cats. Even in the Broadway show they altered the noses to look like cat noses. If they do that, I think people wouldn't be so weirded out by it
Exactly what I have been saying.
A lot of them have bare human feet as well which kind of freaks me out.
if they had cat noses, people would freak out even more..
@@yuka7.999 Depends on how they do it.
Ideally, they'd all be wearing practical costumes enhanced by CGI.
When Taylor Swift said "I'll be the actress starring on your bad dream", she wasn't kidding.
I’m not sure what you mean
@@greatlife1047 its the lyrics to one of her songs look what you made me do
Well when people watched the trailer, their faces are a BLANK SPACE.
Credit to this comment : Danielle Williams
Original comment on the trailer of Cats : When taylor swift said "I'll be the actress starring in your bad dreams", she was trying to warn us.
you cant get away with this
"Some things are bad because they fail at what they set out to do. Others are bad because they succeeded, because what they set out to do was gross and dumb"
-Ben 'Yahtzee' Croshaw
The Clint siren was the best laugh I've had all weekend. amazing.
Same!!! LMAOOOOO like why was that so accurate lol
Lion King 2019 Trailer: The VFX looks great, but the animals could probably use some more human characteristics to help them emote.
Cats Trailer: TOO FAR, TOO FAR, GO BACK!
aye sly cooper
Gotta have a balance there.
But for real the weirdest thing there are the HUMAN NOSES
I wonder if that would've solved it.
Let's talk about those human hands... instead of paws...
Yep this is what Ive been saying, if they just used cat noses it would look really good and I would of gone to see the film... same for many others.
and the mouth
But the Grinch had weird cat noses and were weird.
"This is the worst musical ever" And by far the hardest to preform! You have to be a perfect triple threat (a dancer, actor, and singer!) be able to sing and dance for 3 hours straight, and do 8 shows a week!
Lily Flowers Dolls right!?! I love broadway and no cats isn’t my favorite but it’s so interesting and it puts the audience in a different view so I think that it’s pretty awesome. And yes those performers are putting 100% into their performance and I appreciate it.
Just beacuse it was hard, it doesnt mean it have to be good.
hard doesn't equal good, it doesn't matter how much effort was put into it if it's still shitty in the end.
Still sucks
I also think this movie takes a little from that aspect. Because it's such a hard and demanding show to do, you end up appreciating the performances much more than when they're actors covered in fake fur and general cg, because they register in your mind like amazing human feats, actual people doing things without the aid of visual effects technology, while in this the cg takes center stage.
I don't know if I explained it well but i tried hahah
One thing I've noticed in the Cat characters is that while they have human faces, they don't have human ears on the side, the side of their head is empty and it's creepy as hell.
Area 51 cats boi
I was thinking that too! I found that the cat ears seemed more like hair than ears.
@Polite Gordon Ramsay lol that would be weird and creepy as fuck
they don't have fur on the nose either
They would have 4 ears then
"It's like glass blowing art - nobody asked for it." I'm crying over here
I fear no man
But that thing
*cats movie trailer*
It scares me
NO!
NNNO!
OH GOD PLEASE NO!!
NOOO!
*NNNOOOOOOOO!!!!*
I love how passionate Niko is about muzzle flashes. The best haha
"All the reactions here have nothing to do with the technical execution. This isn't about the visual effects. It's about the art direction"
Say it one more time for all the Disney CG remake apologists!
The first time I saw Wren I thought to myself “Man, this guy looks like he’d be into glass blowing.”
I'd Bet Niko Over Wren For Blowing Glass!
I've known Wren's parents for a long time, so it's not too surprising that he's defending glassblowing.
Between the Alex Jones clip and the screaming siren, IDK what made me laugh more...
😂 The siren was hilarious
Minion:Bee bo bee bo bee bo🎶🚨
My problem with Cats:
The stage costumes are already good...why make them... What ever this is...
And the way the actors move... It just looks like someone dropped an ice cube down their shirt. The movement doesnt look natural. Its too over the top for a film. That kind of movement is fine on stage where everything needs to be over the top so people can see it clearly, but when you are in front of the camera it doesnt work. When you are shooting something the movement needs to be more suddle, more natural.
How to fix it: Dont make it live action. Do it as animation. I dont know why people are allergic to animation now a days. Not everything fits as live action movie. Cats being one of them.
PickleMan cats don’t move like that. They move stealthy and quietly. They move like they’re uncomfortable
@@adrian-ej8mv have you ever seen a cat move?
The honest fact is you won’t get actors like Ian McKellen into a makeup chair for over 4 hours every day for an almost 8-12 hour shoot with some of the most difficult choreography ever that happened in film. In makes more sense from both a money perspective, a safety perspective, and an artistic perspective to do this movie with CGI
I do think that animation would work, but i would go like a style similar to samurai jack, no outlines and very stylized, that and stoo motion would go really nicely with some of the visuals, you could even keep some od the more theatrical stuff
The film was originally a 2d animated film in the same vain as Renaissance Disney and was directed by Speilberg, but the animation studio shot down during production. You can find storyboards and character designs readily online
Alita: well the eyes look a little weird
Cats: hold my beer
Hold my milk*
Hold my CatNip
Hold my dead cat jacket*
Hold my cat drone*
@@ChuckNorris-qy4rn I don't wanna go to jail!
Literally no reason why they couldn't just wear real costumes.
The kids lo:vvvvvvve cg
@@mygamepowerdotcom what kid would watch this monstrosity?
This is more scary than Annabel
then how are they gonna burn the rest of the millions of budget?
the reason is money. they have too much of it.
I love Wren's reaction to Clint's opinion on glass art. And rightfully so!
The most disturbing thing to me about cats is that they have human looking jugs
And human noses.
If they're cats shouldn't they have like 8 nipples?
@@SuckMyKiss420 Six, actually.
@@midgetwthahacksaw Google told me between 4 and 10 but I'm not picky.
@@SuckMyKiss420
410.
Bruh, when Clint popped up doing the siren sound... 😂💀
I'm pissing my self xD
AND THEN THE MEOW
Funniest part of the whole video
i'm so happy that 2012 is getting the recognition it deserves as a VFX masterpiece
Same!
I remember when it was brand new and how real it looked. Super scary. It still holds it’s own pretty well today!
@zephyra That is true.
Conclusion: just watch the 1998 recording of the stage musical.
Fun Fact:
The behind the scenes of 2012 was also called "blowing up our supercomputers".
When sonic says "uumm..... Meow...??" he actually foreshadowing this movie
Meowth that's wight!
@@vivek7154 STFU
meow
@@craurd*the fuck you say to me you little shit*
@Mr. Gigan no you times *infinity*
If these creatures are in Area 51 then I’m siding with the army
Yes, but I'd be turning my gun not on the raiders, but on the cat mongoloids.
Jared Devan nah there’d be ground forces too
Jbomb 360 Air Force has ground forces😂 they actually have the most out of every branch
have they done district 9 yet
@@theblazingblight cat mongoloids, hahahaha
I could listen to Niko explaining CGI and physics of animations for ever
Tron Legacy. Greatest 90 minute Daft Punk music video ever made!
also my favorite "sci fi older actor went into exile because of the rise of an evil empire and the new generation of hero's must convince him to save the day while also learning valuable lessons about themselves" movie
AS Gerner. Yes, because the other movie in that category sucked.
That's my goto movie when I'm drunk and don't want to go to sleep just yet ;) I've seen it like 50 times, 5 of em sober ;)
Interstella 5555 is the greatest but Tron can be the second !
H T Watched that aaaaall the time when I was a kid - I had the dvd stolen by some fucker, though. I gotta find it somewhere again.
I nearly pissed myself laughing when the dude did the sirens screech!! LOL
Clint? Great guy he is, so is the rest of the crew
"The dude"
@@Gj4 The Dude abides !
According to a review, Cats is the worst thing to happen to cats since dogs.
🤣🤣😂😂
my brain hurts
Remember when the most we had to worry about is how bad cats was
Then we got punched in the face by covid 19
STILL WAITING ON THE STUNT REVIEW VIDEO OF ONLY JACKIE CHAN STUNTS!!! YOU CANNOT IGNORE THIS. I SHALL PERSONALLY TYPE THIS IM EVERY NEW VIDEO
that is great but please check for typos before you send, also check ur caps please 🙏
Hi Every New Video!
I shall support your comments too sire. Your quest is a noble one.
SENPAI(s) FUCKING NOTICED!
there is so many video about this, why you need another one?
"They went to Cat school.
I'm not kitting..."
Well played...
👌
Hi not kitting I'm dad
shoulda said “out standing move”
Ok that intro was comedy gold - I lost it at the "siren" xD
Also this series is SO entertaining! You guys are wonderful.
LOVED IT!! Saw it like 10 times 😂
When Clint popped up I died 💀
*Clint*
WEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
Where can you buy these sirens? I need one.
Draedaja this introduction is necessary
The fact they spent probably a whole day filming a 40-second intro sequence just because of the Cats trailer. Respect. XD
clint being a siren made my day... so ty!
It killed me
I know!!!! XD
Can you please talk about Shark Boy and Lava Girl/Spy Kids, those were some of my favourite childhood films and part of what got me interested in VFX and they aged...interestingly
Mr. Electric, send him to the principal's office and have him expelled!!!!
The human faces and cat movements are horrifying
You must scare easily.
Spooktober came early
Even furries fear it
props to you guys for having subtitles in every language
My favourite thing about this series is when someone is explaining something with their hands and everyone else just rocks around the couch listening awkwardly
Clint pulling up with the sirens has me in stitches that whole intro was amazing
#VFXEmergency
Why couldn't they just do the makeup? That's what Cats has always been, that's what it should be.
Ikr
Exactly!
That makeup is creepier than the cgi, idk why everyone thinks it's better 😂
Because Hollywood is allergic to practical effects ect.
@Rizzo Grant exactly, it should either be the same costumes from the show and NO CGI or just literal CGI cats. Honestly, I prefer neither and for this movie not to exist at all, but both are preferable to mutant pygmy cat-people.
My problem with the Cats movie is that they tried to literally adapt a broadway stage show to a movie screen. This lead to a lot of inconsistency because what we have to use to portray animals and creatures on stage does not translate to film. The same goes for books, video games and other media. I think it would have been so much if they made actual CG cats that could dance and stuff like the "live asction" lion king animals... or even Puss In Boots from shrek? I mean Lion King The Musical is great, but there is a reason disneu didn't do what Cats did for the live action version agh. It just did such injustice to the actual story that Cats tells of llife and rebirth and spirituality and the natural world.....
One day they’re going to reveal that everyone in these videos is CGI
I don't think Clint ia real. 😄
What a massive waste of time rendering all those frames. Could have played minecraft instead
@@Patchaddictedpolymath it would be more productive than minecraft
Ghorda9 no
with todays computers that would take a week to a whole month to render, none of them is cgi unless they are time travelers from the future with powerful computers
These aren’t the cat girls we wanted
Spilled Milk but it’s the ones we deserved... 😔
@@sarahsunn7829 then i'll call the Ordo hereticus cuz this is heresy of the highest order
@@hoshi314 This videomotion artifact of cats must be PURGED to prevent further HERESY!!!
It's because they don't have breasts, nipples and belly buttons.
Speak for yourself...
The problem with this cats movie/trailer is that they don't have to do it with cgi, just actors with make-up would look way better and "normal".
yea like cgi enhance costumes instead of pure cg.
So your gonna go see this?
Or just create CGI cats that sings and do cute things. That would make everyone happy.
I find makeup and costumes more creepy than this. This cg is a bit weird, but, not creepy, IMO.
Or just dont make a movie at all
“wHaT iS uP wItH yOu aNd gLaSs bLoWiNg?!”
~Wren 2019
Why did they even do this in CG at all? The usual broadway style cat suits would’ve been good. And they had already built practical sets!
Exactly. This version is just disturbing and honestly just ruins the musical
Because they already had a script and dialogue completed from the broadway show. It was an easy cash grab.
I agree
One broadway show that doesn't work for the screen. Should have made th book of mormon a movie instead
0:33 I hurt myself laughing at that moment! What a great intro.
I was not expecting him to fly up from there, almost sprayed my drink everywhere
Now part of me wants to see a police car in a high speed chase with Clint ratchet strapped to the roof holding the light and doing the siren
@@Jarsia perfect
Jarsia we have the technology. We can do this.
Came here to say this
That intro tho 😂😂 CLINT APPEARING OUT OF NOWHERE MAKING SIREN SOUNDS 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
fpp ikr how did he even
“Syren”
Favorite part of the intro!
00:32
SIREN
The first 45 seconds is PURE Corridor energy. Love it.
Thank you for opening my eyes to how much of a technological marvel 2012 was.
Best episode of this show so far. Good on you for listening to feedback and making the VFX breakdowns in this one way more substantive. Very informative! Real fun intro sketch too. Great work guys 👍
woah hold one, Jogwheel?!
you guys are the ones who made that old hit series Is It A good Idea To Microwave This
I had no idea you were still active on youtube, that's really cool!
huge fan of your work!
I never left! 😊
React to found footage films! (Chronicle, Cloverfield, etc)
I need this.
Holly shit yESS!
And V/H/S 1 or 2
The Poughkeepsie Tapes
@@matixpolska_Ah I see many men with culture here
Blair Witch Project (can't do it without what started it all)
"We have a vfx emergency!"
Clint: RRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
"Taylor Swift said there was no motion capture" 30 seconds later, oh look motion capture...
J Slater AU probs cuz when they did her parts there weren’t any
I read that she refused to do motion capture.
J Slater AU I hold the 69th like
Never trust the highest paid celebrity
The fact that Mike Myers looked so much better in Cat in the Hat is hilarious
Unlike the play, they made the cat's faces way too smooth which accentuates the massive.... human forehead... Making them just look so odd.
yep they look too human was it that hard to put some makeup on the nose? seriously
And it doesnt help when they have cartoony proportions with an art style that is photorealistic thusly making it jarring, like with that battle angel movie
I KNOW!!! none of them have any scruff which makes them look soooooooooooo weird!!!
Everyone: Cats looks cursed.
Me: How TF did Clint pull off that siren sound perfectly?
it looks so much like the whole movie is a deepfake
@@Aree_TD_ i couldn't agree more
you nailed it!
With catsuits, it would look like superfake..
Man, Cat in the Hat has changed so much. Can't wait to see how thing one and thing two look!
Please react to Alita Battle Angle for the next epispde of Good vs Bad CGI.
I can be your Angle or I can be your DEVAL
Commented the same then saw this 😂
I dunno how interesting it’d be because besides the eyes, it’s really good
I was gonna say the same!! 👍🏻
@@DannoHung and the eyes arent really bad either
Clint talkin mad shit for someone whose dream was to play Simba.
*Can you guys react to the VFX for Alita: Battle Angel?*
Oh that would be interesting. Particularly comparing the intentional uncanny valley in that to accidental valley in other movies.
Oh yes please! Honestly the movie had some strange scenes, but overall great animation and vfx!
Came here to say this. Amazing VFX.
Just watched that yesterday, would definitely be a cool one to look at
Good Idea!
I think you should react to Ted.
This movie has surprisingly amazing CGI in regards to the character of Ted himself.
"No cat nipples"
0% Rotten tomatoes
Nick oml
Cat nip
. More tits lol
This video intro has got to be the best thing I have come across so far!
Man of Steel. The opening Krypton sequence has everything from digital characters, water sims, destruction sims, digital suits, Kelor's metal bead display thingy! Phenomenal artistry.
The whole movie is phenomenal. BvS, too (the Ultimate Edition, at least).
"It's just furry Grease."
-My Dad 2019
It wishes it was Grease. At least Grease has some semblance of a plot.
Chris Carpenter “Furry Grease” sounds so wrong 😂
As a Furry, you might be right...
HOWEVER, furries don't mostly have human characteristics. Furries are anthropomorphic animals, meaning animals with human characteristics, like Zootopia characters. They walk on two legs, still look like an animal but talks like a human and thinks like a human. They still have their animalistic face and or limbs. THIS MOVIE HOWEVER, is just about humans that barely look like cats! The arms and face and legs are the same as normal humans. All they did was just stick some fur on their skin and add a tail. Not to mention the addition to whiskers.
Long story short, IF you wanna make a movie about animals with human characteristics, do it like Zootopia. Wanna make it realistic? Make it less cartoony, and do it right. But if you wanna make a musical featuring HUMANS with ANIMAL characteristics, seek help because nobody would like to see that. I bet even if you make fun of the furry fandom and say that everyone in it would want to see the movie, you're wrong. Trust me.
fuck off furry
@@elementartsofficial68 I think it'd look a lot better if they did it with actual theatre costumes, like the video said. But apparently that's not allowed in movies? Have to use CGI just for the sake of being different. A lot of people out there don't seem to get how audience immersion works.
Do an Andy serkis based episode. Covering Star Wars, the hobbit, lord of the rings, planet of the apes... etc
Thats not Serkis. Thats Weta Digital.
@@anirudhmenon4234 Fuck andy Serkis, credit thief
@@kingBenTheBadger Man fuck you. Andy Serkis is a genius.
@@kingBenTheBadger how is he a credit thief? His performance is all we really care about. Gollum/PoTA is the only films where the Visual Effects outshine his talent
Y’all are amazing at your jobs lol your opening skits are all so uniquely well done
Why are we debating the flat eart dude
they have HUMAN ANIMAL hybrids
r/furry has *H U M A N A N I M A L h y b r i d s*
Meanwhile, in Ireland, the flat eart debate rages on.
@@westminsterabbey.6916 stupidity toke over some dudes
Suddenly have an idea: Flat Earth, the musical.
@@normang3668 yes . to show how ridiculous they are
React to the deleted scene from *Fantastic Four* when Reed Richards morphs his face into Wolverine
Is that an actual thing?
@@brown-eyedcheese5440 ua-cam.com/video/Y4Rd8x4z-e0/v-deo.html
Voz woah he looks like the human version of Shrek
James Corden seems so dumb when he says ”these are people but these are cats, actually blowing my mind” as if he never saw a photo from the broadway show
He's hinting that he's a pussy
James Corden is a talentless unfunny fat slob
Tbh alot of stars tend to be bags of hair...
@@willb1405 Exactly, James Corden is an unfunny mess
@@willb1405 cut real deep
When Clint popped up making the siren sound I lost it! Lmaooo
Their reactions are only reactions that I legitimately look forward to.
Maan, you are everywhere!!!, hahahaha
So in summary: Awful Taste But Great Execution
r/atbge
Yeah I was like why is everyone mad about the cgi when its the actual designs that are terrifying.
Because people confuse the two when it comes to movies.
Definitely done on purpose. They want it to be creepy.
RAZZA well the cgi is shit too. At one point it looked like a ps2 game from behind when she was running up to the gate
@@jrive9506 and in 2d animation aswell.
@@kayden2119 this video literally just said that its not the cgi which looks good but is still unfinished. its the movement choices and uncanny valley designs.
0:32, I don’t know why but I’m dying!! 😂
That analysis of the 2012 scene is exactly what keeps me coming back to this channel. Such an insightful examination that I would have never even thought of.
Can you do a video where you react to movies who have won an academy award for
Best visual effects
great idea
Marco Dupa thanks dude
Yh very smart idea. Like the old knes and the recent
Would love to see you react to Alita: Battle Angel. Just watched it and the CGI is amazing in my opinion!
Technically it's OK I guess, pretty good in some scenes. The thing is you can always tell you're looking at a full CGI caracter and it just removes you from the story, wich isn't great in the first place.
Alita has some of the best vfx I've ever seen. It's insane. Also good vfx=/=realistic.
@@musguelha14 I actually kept forgetting she was CG, I was only reminded that she's not real when she were in shots next to real characters. I honestly didn't expect the CG to be that good, but it was. The benefit of having James Cameron as producer, I suppose.
@@musguelha14 I agree with what Arcian said. But I didn't even think about it in the scenes where Alita stands next to real characters. Of course there are scenes that are obviously CG, but those were made in such a stylistic way, that they still fit pretty well and weren't distracting at all. But you can see, since we already have different opinions here, that it would be awesome to see the guys talk about it in a future episode :D
Oh, yeah, technically the movie is fine. Story wise, I don't like it.
It's almost the end of the dreaded year 2020, and Clint's Siren still gives me life.
Starship troopers. Specifically the scene where one of the soldiers climbs on top of the bug and shoots in it's back
YES!
My fav part was what's his face screeching like an alarm at the beginning. 🤣
Clint, his name was literally on screen
@@jmir1 I couldn't read his name over the sound of his screeching!
@@jmir1 Thanks, whatever your name is.
I think Dredd, Tron: Legacy, and Episode III: Revenge of The Sith each deserve their own episodes!
I must say, General Grievous is a masterpiece.
Yesss!
CT 0872 not really
TRON Legacy for sure!
To this day I am mesmerized by the VFX in Tron: Legacy
On John wick, we made real firearms for the film. I was on the small crew making the rifles, pistols, and shotguns. They were real weapons (that's as far as I know if they used blanks, or just cg flashes)
But we hand built and modified the guns