Why Little Wing seems IMPOSSIBLE to play

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,9 тис.

  • @heavyrelic8506
    @heavyrelic8506 8 місяців тому +1596

    Can we please mention how crazy good this video has been edited ?!
    Awesome job Dude

    • @victorwilburn8588
      @victorwilburn8588 8 місяців тому +13

      One of Paul's consistent strengths.

    • @SethPerler
      @SethPerler 8 місяців тому +5

      i love to watch paul improve as a creator over time, he's solid, a truly passionate creator

    • @catedoge3206
      @catedoge3206 8 місяців тому

      yuh

    • @bobbyboyderecords
      @bobbyboyderecords 8 місяців тому +2

      it's AI

    • @carlosfernandez3565
      @carlosfernandez3565 8 місяців тому +1

      There's a lot of thought behind this one. Feels like Paul is exploring the code for a new era of his videos.

  • @christianfernandez8749
    @christianfernandez8749 8 місяців тому +933

    "I'm sure he wasn't thinking like this; no one thinks about music like this when they're playing, but analyzing brilliant minds let us grow as musicians".
    - Paul Davids.

    • @robertcialone6609
      @robertcialone6609 8 місяців тому +12

      Your answer is genius. I’m not a good drummer but sometimes I can’t stand these super analyzers analyze when what you are saying is totally correct thanks

    • @SillyMoustache
      @SillyMoustache 8 місяців тому +10

      @@robertcialone6609 Please note that I have the highest regard for Paul D, and love his videos. I do think that Jimi's styles is sometime over analysed. Strangely, immediately after watching this video, I saw another by a well respected US guitarist analysing what he now thinks he has done wrong when playing Little Wing and Wind Cries Mary. I don't see the point of duplicating another's style - cover the songs, fine, but play it your own way.

    • @shadracastrat
      @shadracastrat 8 місяців тому +3

      ​@SillyMoustache I couldn't agree more. I don't think Hendrix forensically dissected every note by his hero's. He learnt how to capture the flavour and make it his own. Plus he played live in front of people doing all sorts of music and gigs. You'll never get as good as hendrix sitting in a bedroom, as theres no pressure. Great editing and well made though.

    • @zepp2498
      @zepp2498 8 місяців тому

      I agree complitly with you : he did not think about 'how' to play...but just the way he feels ( and it was each time different). Now we try to analyse things ( in my opnion). The result is often that we try to play the same way as he did....but if he would be here he would tell us that each one should play music ( and do things) the way they feel. And this is also why Hendrix did such a masterpeace when he played his way Dylan's ' all along the watchtower".

    • @Snuffsaid2007
      @Snuffsaid2007 8 місяців тому +3

      Well obviously not. He was more likely thinking about "butterflies, zerbras and moonbeams" and where his next acid tab was coming from, but he subconsciously digested all these musical ideas at some point even if he didn't know all their names or dissect the theory.

  • @VictorTemchenko
    @VictorTemchenko 8 місяців тому +339

    My dad, who was a seasoned musician and player, told me when i started playing guitar that I will only be “good” once I can play Little Wing properly. Took me many years to figure out why, and now you told them all the secret. You have to feel the groove.

    • @gnatiu
      @gnatiu 8 місяців тому +28

      Your dad was wrong. There are people who cannot play Little Wing "properly" but are bloody good musicians.

    • @nofrojeff2000
      @nofrojeff2000 8 місяців тому +18

      I'm not the best player by any metric at all, and I'm a huge fan of this channel, but this entire video had me thinking "no sh*t just feel the groove and express it through your fingers" ..... Metronomes are great for practicing technique but not every lick needs to be broken down so analytically....maybe dude was just feeling the music..... idk that's how I play, in time but the fingers do the thinking more than the brain sometimes, I don't think about it and defer creative control to my hands

    • @davidcodesidolopez1040
      @davidcodesidolopez1040 8 місяців тому +18

      @@nofrojeff2000 This. Specially when they say that every time Hendrix played it was different... No point in analyzing this. He was just feeling it every time and every time his feels were different. I don't picture Hendrix thinking ok, let's move this not 2 ms upfront so I create urgency and now 2 ms back so I can screw with people in the future trying to play this...

    • @monkeyrevolution1964
      @monkeyrevolution1964 8 місяців тому +3

      You need to bem Brazilian musician tô have the Groove

    • @markv.5962
      @markv.5962 8 місяців тому +2

      @@davidcodesidolopez1040 that’s right. Same asm jimmy page

  • @devanshissoni
    @devanshissoni 8 місяців тому +24

    Thank you so much for making videos for us and doing so much for music, I really can't thank you enough, you really really have helped me in my Guitar journey.
    Love you! ❤

  • @jeffrowlette
    @jeffrowlette 8 місяців тому +590

    Hendrix did every bit of this NATURALLY.
    The same way we talk...we all talk with a rhythm....Jimi's guitar was such a natural part of him, he literally spoke through his guitar.

    • @Quikshiver
      @Quikshiver 8 місяців тому +51

      I think you're on to it. This is like making a geometric analysis of a Monet painting.

    • @SimonGilliard
      @SimonGilliard 8 місяців тому +10

      it's crazy how non musicians think music is magic

    • @arthurt.chasperton3569
      @arthurt.chasperton3569 8 місяців тому +6

      You don’t actually play anything do you

    • @jeffrowlette
      @jeffrowlette 8 місяців тому +9

      @@arthurt.chasperton3569
      I most certainly do....

    • @CornelisGerard
      @CornelisGerard 8 місяців тому +3

      But we all do that when we play an instrument. It's harder to play like a robot with exact timing to the beat and every note played at the same volume.

  • @johnnymcauley6216
    @johnnymcauley6216 8 місяців тому +43

    Third Stone From The Sun also has a really unusual feel. Jimi's rhythm playing was lush.

  • @puebloblau
    @puebloblau 8 місяців тому +419

    When I watched the interview with Rick beato and sting, sting said one of the most important things of a song is the element of surprise. The intro riff to little wing does exactly that. It's not just the changes in rhythm, but also all the different melodic elements Hendrix used. It almost feels like a rollercoaster of different emotion throughout that maybe 20 sec long intro. This element of surprise is why I never seem to get sick of that intro. Every time I hear it it feels like I still discover something new even though I have heard it 100+ times and deconstructed it when I tried to learn to play it. It just does something amazing to my brain, really an outstanding work of music!

    • @mrlaserboy
      @mrlaserboy 8 місяців тому +4

      Beautiful song and it taught me so much as well about feel and that music and how you play it is sooo much more than just learning and hitting the correct notes

    • @floob3rdoob3r
      @floob3rdoob3r 8 місяців тому +4

      I have no interest in Sting's music but he is 100% right. The journey of a song must remain interesting, and there's many ways you can intrigue the listener.

    • @whatilearnttoday5295
      @whatilearnttoday5295 8 місяців тому +5

      Rick Beato is a hack selling clickbait with keywords and whiteboards full of nonsense.

    • @marcsullivan7987
      @marcsullivan7987 8 місяців тому +14

      @@whatilearnttoday5295well, even if that’s what you think, you can’t deny the incredible string of long form interviews with titans of their genres

    • @victorwilburn8588
      @victorwilburn8588 8 місяців тому +6

      @@whatilearnttoday5295: His interviews with musicians are top-notch and consistently insightful, with few exceptions. The Sting interview was one of his better ones. Brian May and Daniel Lanois were also highlights.
      I tend to avoid his livestreams, since they tend to ramble (and even on his non-live stuff, his editing is not his strong point), and his "old man complaining about today's music" rants, which tend to be kind of lazy. He also doesn't have the teaching skills of Paul or of, say, David Bennett. I see his value as being more of an enthusiast who can get you excited about aspects of music that you might not otherwise have thought about deeply.
      In any case, again, his interviews are not to be missed. And it's pretty clear from the reactions of his subjects that he is NOT talking nonsense, but able to draw great insights from them. E.g. in the Sting interview, you could tell Sting was a bit wary at first (I imagine musicians often have to deal with clueless interviews), but by the end, he was explicit in saying how much he enjoyed the conversation. It was clear he was pleasantly surprised.

  • @SillyMoustache
    @SillyMoustache 8 місяців тому +51

    Interesting video. Its about the options of "on, behind or ahead of the beat - something well known to drummers.
    I was "on the scene" in London and the same time as Jimi, Mitch and Noel. I never saw him live as our gigs always seemed to clash. I was a drummer then, and mentored Mitch a little as Charlie Watts mentored me. As a drummer, you don't "measure" everything you "feel" it which is what Mitch and I and of course Jimi did. Now as a guitarists. I frequently to do push, and/or pull notes in my soloing, which "humanises" and makes the melody more "emotional".
    Back in the day, I worked with a bass player that I went to school with. We just could not get on socially, but on stage our bass and drums fitted together perfectly doing those push and pulls together perfectly. Nick passed some years ago, as have most of my band in the '60s but oh they were cool days!

  • @jonbona876
    @jonbona876 8 місяців тому +161

    I learned to play this song by ear about 20 years ago (when I was in my mid 20s). I never thought about it, I simply played by feel. But this is the best breakdown of Jimi's genius I have ever seen.

    • @tristandennis3194
      @tristandennis3194 8 місяців тому +6

      wow maybe u r a genius too congrats

    • @Alexander-Lionheart_1881
      @Alexander-Lionheart_1881 8 місяців тому +1

      Not really that impressive actually

    • @doobledoo
      @doobledoo 8 місяців тому +1

      And I bet you play it badly

    • @MegaGruik
      @MegaGruik 8 місяців тому

      "this is the best breakdown of Jimi's genius I have ever seen." @jonbona876: it's obvious, you're absolutely right. Paul's work with his DAW allows you to understand the placement of each note.
      Paul is an excellent guitarist in many different genres and techniques. He is also a brilliant teacher, for me the best guitar teacher on the Internet. You certainly know his analysis of George Harrisson's performance in "Here comes the sun"...

    • @HumbleAstronaut
      @HumbleAstronaut 2 місяці тому

      ​@@Alexander-Lionheart_1881actually learning all by feel and ear is a talent. There is also "perfect pitch"

  • @attilatoth1051
    @attilatoth1051 8 місяців тому +11

    "hangover wobble" is the name of Hendrix's most common effect. A beautiful manifestation of this can be heard in "Little Wing". Slight movement coordination disturbances, but tempo remains in place. Deeply beautiful and human. Beautiful song, beautiful playing.

  • @cowboygypsey
    @cowboygypsey 8 місяців тому +26

    Tim with Paul great to see everyone collaborating.

  • @tomfinn8076
    @tomfinn8076 8 місяців тому +43

    The interplay of rhythms between Hendrix ad Mitchell really is the stuff of magic. Its amazing how they both change the syncopation up so much, yet always find themselves back together with the last note.

  • @thechamp9696
    @thechamp9696 8 місяців тому +85

    I love all the visuals and the effort you put into this analysis. Great video! Really interesting stuff

  • @lukaskontrimavicius4417
    @lukaskontrimavicius4417 8 місяців тому +908

    Hendrix just casually vibing with his guitar and not paying attention to the rythm, and people nowadays analyze every little thing he did like he did it on purpose. I like it.

    • @johnnyjohnsonmusic
      @johnnyjohnsonmusic 8 місяців тому +30

      100%

    • @shnootch
      @shnootch 8 місяців тому +15

      yeah wish I could casually vibe like that

    • @1gerardt1
      @1gerardt1 8 місяців тому +34

      Probably too stoned to keep the rhythm

    • @christianfernandez8749
      @christianfernandez8749 8 місяців тому +79

      ​@@alexanderyaroslavich2703 at the end of the video he says: "I'm sure he wasn't thinking like this; no one thinks about music like this when they're playing, but analyzing brilliant minds let us grow as musicians". I don't think the point of the video is to get views but to realize how certain subtleties affect the way we hear or feel what we play as musicians.

    • @RayHikes
      @RayHikes 8 місяців тому +42

      I don't think it's doing it "like he did it on purpose", this was on purpose. He didn't think about it like this, but he knew his groove. This is just the breakdown the rest of us have to do if we want to capture the feel that came naturally to him.

  • @TonyVirili
    @TonyVirili 8 місяців тому +10

    Thank you, Paul, for not only preserving the magic of well composed and expertly performed music, but also the value of masterfully produced video content (some of the best online).

  • @johnharpdalton4092
    @johnharpdalton4092 8 місяців тому +4

    A great and incontrovertible analysis of the shifting rhythms that make those few seconds so fascinating RHYTHMICALLY... and then there's the beautiful, tasteful and sparing way he voices those chords... it's wonderfully rich music that doesnt need a video to boost and sell it.

  • @UrbanGarden-rf5op
    @UrbanGarden-rf5op 8 місяців тому +56

    @ 12:30
    My theory is that the super straight lick
    was a count in for mr Mitchell.
    A call and response moment.
    I just love videos like this one 🎶

    • @mannoplanet
      @mannoplanet 8 місяців тому +2

      great point... count in would be needed too!

    • @themixmusicandmore6280
      @themixmusicandmore6280 8 місяців тому +5

      That's super smart of you to pick up on that I never would've thought of it that way

    • @fadenyaba8650
      @fadenyaba8650 8 місяців тому

      I like your theory, makes perfect sense!

    • @BenjiSchaub
      @BenjiSchaub 8 місяців тому

      Hihi 🤭, and then the drums come in with all triplets...

  • @alexcrouse
    @alexcrouse 7 місяців тому +159

    Jimi didn't waste his time being "on time". He just played what he felt.

    • @DigitalViscosity
      @DigitalViscosity 3 місяці тому +6

      He was still on time, he had great timing and rhythm. But best of all he had amazing never to be matched expression.

    • @Nor-p5v
      @Nor-p5v 2 місяці тому

      @@DigitalViscosity to hear new gen people said shit like Guthrie is better than Jimi is a joke really.
      But what the hell do they know, am i right?
      🤣

    • @degande-d1w
      @degande-d1w 2 місяці тому +1

      @@Nor-p5v No not really. Jimi is amazing, but he died at age 27. There are people alive today that have been playing for longer than he was alive. There are people creating songs that he would never be capable of playing, because he wasn't alive long enough to reach the same heights. Even among his contemporaries, he wasn't head and shoulders above all of them. Just off the top of my head, people like Gilmour, Page, Blackmore, Clapton, Zappa, Moore, Jeff Beck, Eddie Hazel, and I'm sure there's plenty I'm forgetting.
      That doesn't mean you can't personally have Hendrix as your favorite guitarist. But to put him on some insane pedestal where you refuse to entertain anyone else being near him shows more ignorance on your part. I'm not sure how anyone who truly loves the guitar could pick out one person in that way, because there are so many guitarists doing completely different and incomparable things.

    • @outlander234
      @outlander234 2 місяці тому

      @@degande-d1w In skill yeah but in creativity they are nowhere near. How many guitarists can play Voodoo Chile? Plenty. But he CREATED it. Also even in pure skill there are some things Hendrix did that is very hard to replicate. People praise Stevie Ray Vaughan and many put him above Hendrix. But his rendition of Voodoo Chile is just not better. Its not even on par. Its just not.

    • @bulldogfight
      @bulldogfight 2 місяці тому

      He is playing with time

  • @dr.buzzvonjellar8862
    @dr.buzzvonjellar8862 8 місяців тому +148

    Jimi’s nervous system was incredible. He had a foot in another world. Some of his work is just magical.

    • @djhygs
      @djhygs 8 місяців тому +11

      No he was a blues guitarist who had one or two new ideas. He was not a god, and did not come up with much that hadn't been done before him.

    • @gameboyjacks
      @gameboyjacks 8 місяців тому +25

      @@djhygs nah he was a god for sure

    • @Monyornothin
      @Monyornothin 8 місяців тому +8

      Every note he played got special consideration and treatment. No one can replicate Jimi. He had the grooviest soul ever ✌️😎

    • @CareySullivan-cu3fw
      @CareySullivan-cu3fw 8 місяців тому +7

      @@djhygs Sure if you say so😂

    • @Peter7966
      @Peter7966 8 місяців тому +11

      @@djhygs I wonder why so many great guitarists thought that Jimi Hendrix was something uniquely special, not just a blues guy doing the typical blues guitar cliches? Jimi was a transformative player who changed the landscape of electric guitar playing for most every electric guitar players afterward.

  • @playtheblues
    @playtheblues 8 місяців тому +6

    That image at 13:03 would make a great wall hanging for a music room... 🙂

  • @Art_Vandelay_Industries
    @Art_Vandelay_Industries 8 місяців тому +11

    One of my all time favorites brilliantly analysed.
    Top notch production quality too

  • @EricWhite-s1p
    @EricWhite-s1p 8 місяців тому +9

    Hi, I just watched your video on Little Wing. As a teenager I had already found out it was impossible to get perfect. However, I caught a radio interview with the producer who recorded it. Jimi played it 3 times, each time a little different. The final song was a layering of all 3. This explains why it's different in a live performance. 😁

    • @PaulDavids
      @PaulDavids  8 місяців тому +2

      Really? Awesome, do you remember where you heard this?

  • @AngelHadzi
    @AngelHadzi 7 місяців тому +22

    57 years after this song was recorded the world is trying to figure out how Jimi made his magic.. a true genius.

  • @Texasbluesalley
    @Texasbluesalley 2 місяці тому

    I recently tabbed out over 60 Hendrix chord embellishments from 4 different recordings of Little Wing, and I ran smack into what you're describing here. He mixed straight feel with varying levels of swing, sometimes within the same measure. All instinct and feel. Great video, really superb teaching and editing!

  • @Scoots1994
    @Scoots1994 8 місяців тому +36

    Two of my top songs of all time are covers. Jimi's version of All Along the Watchtower, and SRVs Little Wing.

    • @NosretapH
      @NosretapH 8 місяців тому +4

      SRV's Little Wing is fantastic but one of the things I love most about the Hendrix original is how short it is. It ends gently but quickly. When I first heard it I couldn't believe it had ended so soon, I felt it was just getting started! But the ephemeral nature of it adds to the beauty of the track, it almost feels fragile. Very fitting for a song (presumably) about his mother's spirit. For all its brilliance the SRV version loses that.

    • @pandadoublexl
      @pandadoublexl 8 місяців тому

      @@NosretapH it also misses the beautiful vocals and lyrics

    • @morriypoulsen1238
      @morriypoulsen1238 6 місяців тому

      SRV version is no where as good as Jimi's, and he don't sing in it,so he's not converting all what the song is about.

    • @Scoots1994
      @Scoots1994 6 місяців тому

      @@morriypoulsen1238 And music appreciation is opinion. I love Jimi's version. I love SRVs more. It's a different song. To be fair, SRV didn't like his version enough to release it, his brother released it after his death.

  • @VisualSOLUTIONSMedia
    @VisualSOLUTIONSMedia 8 місяців тому +8

    The irony of Hendrix's playing and groove being analyzed using a computer would probably just make him laugh and shake his head.
    That said, it's a spot on analysis Paul, thank you!

  • @alecursini
    @alecursini 8 місяців тому +5

    This video is amazingly nerdy and so good. Appreciate the breakdown and the editing is great. 👍🏼

  • @aaronnebauer6046
    @aaronnebauer6046 8 місяців тому

    Bravo! I've been teaching guitar for almost 30 years and I steer my students toward your videos because your analysis is always so solid. The editing on this video is next level too, well done and thank you Paul

  • @PaulMcCaffreyfmac
    @PaulMcCaffreyfmac 8 місяців тому +5

    It's amazing and pleasing for me to find that the default Jimi picture in use for the last year or so is from the second Royal Albert Hall show in February 1969. I was at both shows and that second one is the best evening I have ever had at any kind of concert.
    Interesting video.

    • @robertworrall2346
      @robertworrall2346 8 місяців тому

      Blessings to you🙏 You have lived well, in the presence of Divinity.

  • @igorino1767
    @igorino1767 2 місяці тому +3

    Add to that all the notes he hits that you can barely even hear and you have a song that you can't play by learning it. You have to feel it. It's all the little things that you can figure out only by listening to the recording that make this song so special.
    I'm pretty sure that even Hendrix wouldn't be able to play it perfectly again. All the little intricacies are dictated by his emotions, unique to the moment. Truly one of a kind player.

  • @Nik.No.K
    @Nik.No.K 8 місяців тому +61

    This is the problem with music nowadays. Everyone is so focused on perfection that they forgot how actual music made by humans is supposed to sound. It’s not supposed to be perfect

    • @thedp6736
      @thedp6736 6 місяців тому +9

      You're right, if this was recorded today they would quantise the guitar, bass and drums and autotune the vocal because everything Paul and Tim were discussing would be considered mistakes by modern producers.

    • @thilobraun3440
      @thilobraun3440 6 місяців тому +3

      I think you are right. Rock music in those days was not really about precision.

    • @crawfordscott3d
      @crawfordscott3d 2 місяці тому +1

      I notice this with the Internet UA-cam guitar. People are so incredible technically but I begin to realize they aren't doing the part where they live life and express through the craft as art.. They are just kind of technical masters. It can be very impressive but I think obfuscates something crucial

    • @lemenelli5100
      @lemenelli5100 Місяць тому

      Micro analysing a song is not a bad thing, can learn many things,
      Personally I think just feel the song and do your own thing 🙂

  • @guitarfriendtim
    @guitarfriendtim 8 місяців тому +10

    Awesome, Paul. Swing, straight, shuffle and free - Jimi played with all the colors, all the time

  • @mazyqotmazyqot4952
    @mazyqotmazyqot4952 3 дні тому

    This is my first time on a video of you, Paul Davids. Your're a GENIUS!!! The way you communicate, the way you present your research, with such a didactic DNA, are a mix of passion of music, empathy and, on the other hand, very technical and professional based. What a pleasure to watch this. And I'm not a pro player (I don't even know how to read music).

  • @Pooker_CS
    @Pooker_CS 8 місяців тому +149

    It would be cool if you did this kind of analysis on Stevie Ray Vaughan's version and then compare them to each other, just to see the difference. (Not trying to start a war in the comments between which is best, would just be fun to really understand the differences between the versions.) Great video by the way!

    • @Dr.Pepperdave
      @Dr.Pepperdave 8 місяців тому +8

      Great idea.

    • @lawrencetaylor4101
      @lawrencetaylor4101 8 місяців тому +11

      Agreed. There is no best. I'm sure Stevie would say that there is the original, and everything else is just a copy. And we are all winners listening to the efforts.

    • @martijn_yt
      @martijn_yt 8 місяців тому +10

      There is a similar problem if you try to copy many EVH riffs. Many guitar players can now copy all his notes in the right order at a comparable speed (or even faster). But there is (almost ?) no one that can play them with his unique 'shuffle' feel :)

    • @localbod
      @localbod 8 місяців тому

      ​@@martijn_ytI agree. Van Halen definitely made it swing.

    • @GeorgeChristian-q2x
      @GeorgeChristian-q2x 8 місяців тому

      P​@@lawrencetaylor4101

  • @purleybaker
    @purleybaker 8 місяців тому

    It's one of my favorite songs and having it broken down like this is amazing. Thank you.

  • @JayTeeProds
    @JayTeeProds 8 місяців тому +22

    Why is this video the perfect video right when Little Wing has been on my mind the past month!?
    Thanks again Paul!!

    • @family-accountemail9111
      @family-accountemail9111 8 місяців тому +2

      I ve been thinking about it for 45 yrs

    • @rogerYT69
      @rogerYT69 8 місяців тому

      same😊

    • @professorkaos62
      @professorkaos62 8 місяців тому

      Same. I've actually been working on learning SRV's cover of it the past few days lol

  • @milktop1
    @milktop1 6 місяців тому

    This actually mind blowing! The urgency due to the slightly pulled forward note explains so much! Thank you

  • @PlayLikeTheGreatscom
    @PlayLikeTheGreatscom 8 місяців тому +6

    11:59 That *C* chord [x3201x] is actually a *C6* chord [x3221x]!
    (I suppose he used his middle finger for both notes on fret 2 with a “shared fingertip fretting”.)

    • @pietervermeulen67
      @pietervermeulen67 8 місяців тому +3

      It's called 'shared finggertip fretting' or sff! I was thaught that technique by Wim Overgaauw.! Jimi Hendrix used it also with an open E chord by using his 2nd finger on the A and D strings. You put your finger between the two strings. It's not a partial bar. And with this C chord he did the same and made it a C6 by placing his 2nd finger between the D and G strings. That's why those necks are more narrow in that area I guess!

    • @PlayLikeTheGreatscom
      @PlayLikeTheGreatscom 8 місяців тому +3

      @@pietervermeulen67 Thank you - I never heard this term until now! I edited my comment accordingly :D

  • @nathanspindler6385
    @nathanspindler6385 8 місяців тому

    I play that song for my 3 yo son nearly every time we go somewhere in the truck. I had no idea all the nuances in it and why. Very well-edited video and breakdown!

  • @MaxPower2719
    @MaxPower2719 8 місяців тому +6

    1:46 “It's the notes in between that are f***ing with me.”

  • @og_paulsack
    @og_paulsack 8 місяців тому

    I love the way you visualize music theory for your viewers. Those of us who don’t have a background in music can understand and appreciate this so much more. Good stuff!

  • @faboolean7039
    @faboolean7039 8 місяців тому +61

    I think these are the kind of details that are missing from modern instagram type guitar

    • @denysholovatyi3149
      @denysholovatyi3149 8 місяців тому +2

      most of it is uninventive crap but the best insta guitarists will be ( some already are) the virtuosos and trail blaizers of the future

    • @Kaktysh_metal
      @Kaktysh_metal 8 місяців тому +3

      It's a problem of modern music in common. Everything is quantized, even if it doesn't need to

    • @SomerandomShmuck
      @SomerandomShmuck 4 місяці тому

      @@denysholovatyi3149I know a guy in my school that plays the guitar like he was James Hetfield himself on there.
      Short, quiet, dorky Hispanic dude

  • @zykify
    @zykify 8 місяців тому +2

    An interesting video would be: Should we really use click tracks and quantizing as much as we do? Would Jimi have played Little Wing as he did if he had grown up with ProTools? We learn to adjust whatever natural feel we have so it fits the machines...
    Another topic could be TAB's vs classical musical notation. I am of the opinion that TAB's is a shortcut that does not lead to actual reading music. It is more like reading a book in a foreign language written in phonetics.

  • @Hyper5nic
    @Hyper5nic 8 місяців тому +7

    Amazing! From an early album of Sting, 'Little wing' is my favourite song, but the depth of the knowledge shared here, is what makes me want to pick up my guitar and start playing right away!
    Thank you for sharing this, and I'm definitely interested in your course now!
    All the best, cheers!

    • @MrMmcdaid9
      @MrMmcdaid9 3 місяці тому

      Sting really got me playing/singing Little Wing with a fresh view of it as an acoustic ballad, essentially - It's a great song per se [I've got a bit of a Bert Jansch vibe going on it, sans swing]. A different approach.

  • @JulienMARY
    @JulienMARY 6 місяців тому

    Terrific job. Thanks Paul. Everything is brilliant in this video, and not the least, the editing work as it really helps to understand everything.

  • @russellzauner
    @russellzauner 8 місяців тому +19

    Next Video: I got an email from Jimi Hendrix

  • @ElMarko2000
    @ElMarko2000 20 днів тому

    Fantastic analysis! I never knew how rhythmically complex this was. The combination of swing and straight feel even in the same bar is unbelievable. Unmatched in electronica.

  • @harolddeschenes4640
    @harolddeschenes4640 8 місяців тому +7

    You have no idea what a relief this video is to me. I have been struggling with Little Wing for more than 25 years... I've been playing guitar for 40 years and I still can't play it right. So thank you for making feel better. If Mr. Pierce still can't play it the way Jimi did, all hopes are lost for me. LOL

    • @jpdemer5
      @jpdemer5 7 місяців тому

      On the bright side, you now know what it is that you need to work on!

  • @marcscharbrough865
    @marcscharbrough865 7 місяців тому +1

    Thank You. You actually taught Me something that numerous people have tried and failed!

  • @MrPnew1
    @MrPnew1 8 місяців тому +11

    Great to see Paul and Tim analyse Hendrix's musical techniques and timing in Little Wing

  • @michael52250
    @michael52250 8 місяців тому +1

    So amazing... and great to see two of my favorites working together.

  • @squierjoshyt
    @squierjoshyt 3 місяці тому +5

    AS spot on and interesting as this analysis is, I have a hard time believing Jimi put this much thought into it. He had a sound in his head and it just came out of his fingers.

  • @TheBeanGreen
    @TheBeanGreen 7 місяців тому

    Your videos always get my creativity going when I have writers block. And thanks for putting us on to some of these oldies. Great to draw inspiration from.

  • @hunterkarr5618
    @hunterkarr5618 8 місяців тому +3

    Cool use of technology to illuminate the craft of a brilliant artist!!!

  • @ravimukerji6609
    @ravimukerji6609 3 місяці тому

    i love the straight part at the end. it really gives an emphasis to that part and makes it feel so powerful imo

  • @johncrafton8319
    @johncrafton8319 8 місяців тому +8

    It's a pretty simple concept: Hendrix's sense of timing was always "in the moment". He played how he felt. It was a conversation between Jimi and his rhythm section, with Jimi seeming to be in his own world while the rest of the band kept him anchored so he wouldn't just float away.

  • @SoulSonder26
    @SoulSonder26 6 місяців тому +2

    Muddy Waters isn't delta blues, he's one of the progenitors of chicago blues! Love your stuff! Great video as always!

  • @daddyg1973
    @daddyg1973 8 місяців тому +57

    I love it when people say that Hendrix was a "sloppy" player. It immediately lets me know that person has never really listened to Hendrix. I mean, really listened.

    • @scottemmonsmusic6001
      @scottemmonsmusic6001 8 місяців тому +7

      There is no bigger Hendrix fan than me, at 10 years old when are you experienced came out it took me a month just to get one roof in the intro of little wing because it was heavily swung and he started off with a minor second and ended with a major Triad, but when he played live sometimes he was really sloppy he had a lot of off nights and also some nights that were so good it defies analyzing. He became the instrument that was being played by music. Band of gypsies January 1st 1970 first show I don't know and machine gun in particular also La Forum 1970 was amazingly great although the recordings are not that great

    • @sigiligus
      @sigiligus 8 місяців тому +12

      Cope. The reason all these mid-20th century players have all these "inimitable sounds" is precisely because it was sloppy. There's an adage that an unskilled person can be dangerous in a fight because he will move erratically and unpredictably, whereas a trained person will reliably move in predictable, systematic ways. Same thing with the old guitar players. It was drugged out "let's just see what happens" playing. It gave unique sounds, and it is definitely difficult to replicate with intention, but it was not profound genius because some music nerds can technically describe that a bunch of different bits of theory happened to be manifested. That's just post hoc intellectualising. A professional painter could just as easily look at a child throwing a bucket of paint on a canvas and describe the result in terms of all sorts of highbrow painting techniques. Doesn't mean the child tapped into the power of the cosmos to intuitively manifest a work of genius.
      None of these guitarists you idolise from the boomer-era can even replicate their own playing. Hendrix himself was never able to play the same thing twice. Neither can any of them. And no, that is not a good thing. Literally every other group of musicians on the planet besides electric guitar players know this.

    • @predeterminedmeat5024
      @predeterminedmeat5024 8 місяців тому +7

      ​​​​Did you forget the entire genre of free jazz? I don't think they were replicating the songs they made. I highly doubt you're a musician of any worth if you don't know the importance of improv. If hendrix wanted to he could learn all his solos and riffs perfectly (within human limit) he was certainly technically able, some of his riffs he played very well live were very complex. But that would suck. Everytime i find a new bootleg of Jimi i'm excited by the fact i know he's going to switch it up and do some cool shit. He was an improv player and that's why people love him. Jimi Hendrix is and for the forseable future the greatest guitarist to ever walk the earth. Your assumption that he was unable to play the same thing twice is dumb, plain and simple. The fact he didn't doesn't make him a worse guitarist it makes him a better one.

    • @BeefNEggs057
      @BeefNEggs057 8 місяців тому +7

      @@sigiligus Derp

    • @singleplayer75
      @singleplayer75 8 місяців тому +7

      @@sigiligus I get your point to a degree. But in every art form, especially music, being too accurate and always repeating one thing a thousand times over, defeats the very purpose of it. To be FUN and emotional. It's the difference between ART and a CRAFT. He couldn't play it the same way? He had proved x times during his career that he never ever wanted it that way. People are not robots. All Along The Watchtower is another great example - you take the swing out of it and it becomes bland. It's even in the way he sings it. The terms ''groove'', ''swing'' and ''shuffle'' were coined based on it all, for a reason.

  • @skitarist
    @skitarist 3 місяці тому

    Cool analysis. I like when non-percussionists take swing/shuffle/groove into account and are able to explain why it changes the entire atmosphere of the sound. Subscribed! Currently trying to learn/optimize "Spanish Castle Music" from the same album, and it's a very humbling learning curve...

  • @herrunsinn774
    @herrunsinn774 8 місяців тому +13

    Note to self: Burn guitar before going to bed tonight. 😅🤣😂

  • @Grabulosa
    @Grabulosa 8 місяців тому +1

    Next Level Playing id a beautiful course to do, I enjoy every bit. I honestly recommend it. Many thanks for that Paul, your video editing is getting better and better. Your musical talent is obvious. Amazing stuff.

  • @abrahamdavidsmith
    @abrahamdavidsmith 8 місяців тому +5

    Is there a recording of the full discussion with Tim Pierce?

    • @Pierrico
      @Pierrico 8 місяців тому

      That's all we want to know now!

  • @TrevorBrennan-j4b
    @TrevorBrennan-j4b 6 місяців тому

    I have been waiting for someone to make a video like this for little wing for a long time. youre the perfect one to do it

  • @mikebauer6917
    @mikebauer6917 8 місяців тому +6

    Didn’t understand much of this, but your enthusiasm made it very engaging.

  • @johnstoddard4692
    @johnstoddard4692 5 місяців тому

    You are such a consumate professional with your expression of music. Combined with your warm reception and human approach to the appraisal and recreation of classic songs and obscure and forgotten songs alike , your offering here on UA-cam is genuine and original and I am happy I found this. Thank you

  • @michelstomp
    @michelstomp 6 місяців тому

    This is a great lesson on timings in general and Hendrix's magic in particular. I first learned about this - en het kwartje viel ;) - when I was in a studio in Amsterdam with Cordell 'Boogie' Mosson of Parliament / Funkadelic. He taught us youngsters (I think I was 19 or 20 at the time) about timing and 'breathing' by example, by first playing Little Wing "as everyone plays it", followed by the way Hendrix played it. We were blown away; it was magic! It was the biggest lesson in music I've ever had. And I've referred to it many times ever since. Thanks for the elaborate analysis and beautiful lecture Paul!

  • @eyesofpangea9659
    @eyesofpangea9659 8 місяців тому +80

    That's because hendrix made mistakes. he never played the same thing twice. He said it himself. People try to copy him so much they copy his mistakes.

    • @Trwillis9
      @Trwillis9 8 місяців тому +6

      Wrong lol.. he played things different for variation sakes lol.. and he was insane at improvising..

    • @johnnyandersson5622
      @johnnyandersson5622 8 місяців тому +7

      No mistakes, you are metronom injured if you think that. Same goes for all blues and many rock genres. It's almost always hilarious when someone schooled playes blues.

    • @mastpg
      @mastpg 8 місяців тому +2

      Meh, that's like saying Jordan made a "mistake" switching hands while going down the lane at Sam Perkins during game 2 of the '91 finals. Jimi was a performer. He wasn't replicating anything. He wasn't playing as a session guitarist. He was f'ing Jimi Hendrix. The idea of a "perfect" performance isn't really useful in this sense.

    • @JPVanderbuilt
      @JPVanderbuilt 8 місяців тому +6

      Hendrix was *brilliantly* bending the concepts of music. If you think those were mistakes, you’ve just missed the beauty & power of Hendrix.

    • @mastpg
      @mastpg 8 місяців тому +3

      @@JPVanderbuilt Ok, yes...but there are also might have been pauses and hiccups in some of his old, live, bootleg stuff...or even studio stuff...that your nostalgia goggles might have deemed brilliant but that might have just been his pushing back his sleeve or moving his cigarette...but then he just fell into the vibe that created, again because he's a genius, and changed the whole song on the fly. Jazz groups do this all the time when jamming for long sets because they're dropping this instrument or that percussion guy to the bathroom or a drink or flirting with the waitress.
      I wouldn't be surprised, if we had a full documenting of every session, that we might not find that Jimi was thinking on his feet more often than we might believe.

  • @joseph-ow1hf
    @joseph-ow1hf 8 місяців тому

    This is one of the most interesting things I've seen in my journey to try to really understand music. Brilliant job Paul!

  • @raiga2916
    @raiga2916 8 місяців тому +5

    This guy is him

  • @AhmadAboulFarag
    @AhmadAboulFarag 8 місяців тому

    I love this video so much cause that's what I always heard in Hendrix music... Not to mention the way he strikes each string differently so that it would twang or just a normal strike and the dynamics of selecting which notes to emphasize. That's how I feel when I play too. It's wonderful.

  • @newardinesh1938
    @newardinesh1938 8 місяців тому +5

    Jimi Hendrix is league on his own class❤
    He changes the way of playing the guitar. One the True G.O.A.T of guitar

  • @MrSandford
    @MrSandford 8 місяців тому

    Absolutly fantastic. Thank you for doing the hard yards in breaking down the song. Will change my perspective forever

  • @Paul71H
    @Paul71H 8 місяців тому +12

    I came here to watch this video before it gets blocked for including Jimi Hendrix music.

  • @davidcann8788
    @davidcann8788 8 місяців тому

    Thanks for breaking down the timing on this. I've always wondered about Little Wing and why I found its oddness beautiful.

  • @Little_Lemon200
    @Little_Lemon200 8 місяців тому +3

    I learned this song 15 years ago and still play it.

  • @jimshunamon2512
    @jimshunamon2512 8 місяців тому

    Awesome! You just opened a whole new understanding for me of one of my most favorite tunes ever. Thank you Paul!

  • @traynelly9082
    @traynelly9082 2 місяці тому +11

    I think yall are overthinking it pretty sure he was just a very talented dude that just liked jamming. He didn’t necessarily care about time signatures and notes he just played the guitar homie

    • @ethan6840
      @ethan6840 2 місяці тому

      Yes, but the question is “what did he play that we aren’t” and ‘he played Jimi Hendrix isn’t a good answer if you actually want to know. So I’ll ask you. What exactly did Jimi Hendrix play that we aren’t, besides “he’s just Jimi Hendrix”

    • @traynelly9082
      @traynelly9082 2 місяці тому

      @@ethan6840 Jimi Hendrix he played what he felt yeah there was technical ability involved but that’s not the point.

    • @ethan6840
      @ethan6840 2 місяці тому +1

      @@traynelly9082 yeah the point of the video was what actually made his playing different, along with what shaped music along the years

  • @mercster
    @mercster 8 місяців тому +1

    Yeah when at 8:07 Tim says "This is the only time he played it like that," I was just about to type, the sad thing for the rest of us is, Jimi just played it like that in the moment, from his soul. It comes from the beat of the heart, not from plotting anything on a piece of paper.

  • @thatderek
    @thatderek 8 місяців тому +7

    Might get flamed for this and absolutely no disrespect to Jimi at all but Stevie Ray takes this song to the next level. Of course the original is legendary but this is one of the rare times the cover is better IMO.
    RIP Jimi and SRV.

    • @nicko6710
      @nicko6710 8 місяців тому +1

      The beauty of Little Wing is that it is 2:26 long (and is a song) not a wank fest of licks for 10 mins. You have totally missed the point. Even SRV didn't release it. Posthumous album.

    • @thatderek
      @thatderek 8 місяців тому

      @@nicko6710 Seems I've somehow offended your knowledge of music history and taste. I apologize for stoking any inner negativity.
      When it comes to art I have always felt the point is to find something that connects emotionally and 'stirs the soul'. I honestly try my best not to let history or someones opinion (especially the artist) influence me.
      Hendrix connects so deeply with so many other songs and I like his covers of Hey Joe and All Along the Watchtower much more than Dylan's. However, for me personally, something about the feel, tone, and improv of those runs in SRV's cover simply speaks to me.
      Jimi is a legend but I think SRV took a great song, injected something more, and made it universally emotional no matter the language of the listener.
      I respect your opinion, arguing with someone about art is pretty silly. Peace ✌

  • @MrSoundsandVision
    @MrSoundsandVision 8 місяців тому

    Nice explanations! Adding a lot to the magic of the song is streching the rhythmic feel over two beats by entering a 2/4 bar in a 4/4 song.

  • @michimütze
    @michimütze 8 місяців тому +3

    You need brown sugar for that😊

  • @danmejia4361
    @danmejia4361 8 місяців тому +1

    Paul you did a good job with Little Wing ,and I learned a lot about the swing of this song.

  • @Mark-l9k9q
    @Mark-l9k9q 2 місяці тому +5

    Ridiculous over analysis of someone's guitar playing style. No one plays it like Hendrix because no one created it but Hendrix.

    • @ethan6840
      @ethan6840 2 місяці тому

      Yes, we know that. But why? That’s the question of the video. If you know the answer, tell me why, besides the fact that he’s just Jimi Hendrix.

    • @Mark-l9k9q
      @Mark-l9k9q 2 місяці тому

      @@ethan6840
      There is no other answer. Why did Picasso paint the way he did? Because he was Picasso. Why didn't Dali paint like Picasso? Because he wasn't Picasso. Do you really need such a simple and obvious truth explained to you?

    • @ethan6840
      @ethan6840 2 місяці тому

      @@Mark-l9k9q you could have just said you don’t know

    • @Mark-l9k9q
      @Mark-l9k9q 2 місяці тому

      @@ethan6840
      But I do know. It's you who has trouble digesting simple truths.

    • @ethan6840
      @ethan6840 2 місяці тому

      @@Mark-l9k9q no it’s okay I get it, I’m not judging you or anything

  • @geoffatutahi8520
    @geoffatutahi8520 21 день тому +1

    Something that still blows my mind.. Jimi wrote, played and recorded this stuff in the 1960s, died in 1970 at age 27.. it is now 2024 and we are STILL mesmorized, captured and amazed by his musical prowess. Forever idolised Mr Hendrix legend absolute 🙏

  • @hdconley
    @hdconley 7 місяців тому

    Hi Paul you may have already come across him, Sean Mann’s take on “little wing” is something to behold. He definitely isn’t just a regular UA-cam guitarist. Pure class. He even takes on SRV’s version as well. Just wow.

  • @dtwo31
    @dtwo31 8 місяців тому

    Off topic question i've wanted to ask you for a while:
    - Why'd you choose the Mobius over it's competitors?
    I'm trying to decide on a multi-modulation but there are three main prospects. Mobius, MD-500, and the GFI Synesthesia

  • @isaacaskew3899
    @isaacaskew3899 5 місяців тому

    Damn. Thank you for making this video and showing so clearly the differences between swing and a 'rhythm-corrected' style. Huge difference and I never thought about it this way.

  • @gimmeagig
    @gimmeagig 6 місяців тому

    What a great video. I'm mainly a bass player but I dabble on guitar. I have been loving this song ever since it came out. I was never consciously aware of these subtleties.

  • @dontlistentoanythingisay
    @dontlistentoanythingisay 2 місяці тому

    A buddy of mine can play this and I got him to do it so many times. It was always my favorite thing to listen to him play

  • @willster7272
    @willster7272 7 місяців тому

    Once again a great edited video and explanation, you are the undisputed king of you tube guitar lessons my friend

  • @BeForFree
    @BeForFree 8 місяців тому +1

    Yes Jimi so so good, crazy good piece of music too, a music gem...but never forget that fantastic drummer that stand behind him...

  • @yadielmercedes3635
    @yadielmercedes3635 5 місяців тому

    Paul Davis your videos are so well put together and edited

  • @michaelmattingly3773
    @michaelmattingly3773 6 місяців тому

    Fun video! Great stuff. One note I would add: that last C chord is C6; 1st finger on 2nd string C, 2nd finger playing both A and E on 3rd and 4th string respectively and 3rd finger on C 5th string. This allows for the 4th finger to do the hammer on/pull off on 2nd string. Thoughts?

  • @wolfman-vt2zr
    @wolfman-vt2zr 8 місяців тому

    at the first section of the yellow part between 12:31 and 12:32 theres a note so rushed and swinged thats almost not perceivable consciously, but its the difference between hendrix's feel and sounding stiff. Its not completely "super straight", at least not at the beginning of the yellow part

  • @sRockstarHQ
    @sRockstarHQ 8 місяців тому +1

    man everything about this song is mind blowing ,its was absolutely magical the first time I heard it

  • @operatorenabla8398
    @operatorenabla8398 8 місяців тому

    I will be dead honest: been seeing this video in my feed for some days. The clickbait title kept me away from it (I'm not trying to criticize, or say "change", I understand how the "market" works on UA-cam and if I worked on this site I would do the same) for a while, but then today I understood from the thumbnail what the argument was about: very interesting topic. While I'm not new to it, it is still interesting both to be refreshed about it and to see that it gets talked about online: I feel like, expecially with this ease of accesibility to instruments like metronomes, the habit to stick to the grid when recording, this kind of feeling can get dangerously overlooked, and by some (a couple I've met personally) be thought to be outright wrong!
    Great video man! Gonna check out the Bold as Love one right now

  • @ianpierson3887
    @ianpierson3887 8 місяців тому

    This is a great example of how musicians communicate through their instruments… the emotions that are evoked by this kind of playing are IMHO completely lacking from modern commercialized music. This is true expression and every single time I hear Little Wing I get an emotional reaction.
    Thanks for breaking this down!!!

  • @odesseus
    @odesseus 8 місяців тому +1

    Thanks, Paul, this was incredibly eye opening!

  • @navik786
    @navik786 8 місяців тому

    Beautiful editing throughout! Was that a nod to the Bold As Love cover at 2:52 !? 👌

  • @arottie4097
    @arottie4097 8 місяців тому +1

    W0W! You sir are a fabulous music educator! Thank you for sharing!!