Yes. It wasn't great but he wanted her to KNOW he loves her still, no matter the decisions he was making. Brenda didn't understand but he knew she would understand in Time. He couldn't make love to her [even tho he wanted to] then leave her to go to Lily. I just LOVE their love story. It was SO compelling. SnB were the IT Couple in the 90s ❤
This whole Sonny marrying Lily I hated. Lily knew Sonny & Brenda loved each other & she used this to get her hooks into Sonny. I think Lily was selfish. She followed Sonny around like a puppy. Disgusting ... Really!
True but i think Vanessa and Maurice leaving at the time was a big problem. They couldn't have Sonny and Brenda get married and have a bunch of kids, given the timing of their departures. Shame, Sonny and Brenda are the hottest couple to never get married ever on daytime...
I am with you..I love Brenda and detest Carly. It would be nice to see a new GH writer. One that is NOT all about the Carly character but one that will adhere to GH history and can write fascinating storylines like Claire Labine did. I miss S@B!
@mohr1020 - He felt Brenda talked too much but even when he found out that Brenda kept the secret about Ned being Eddie Maine.. she kept that secret for the longest time. You'd think after learning that she kept that secret, he would know that she was able to keep her mouth shut when needed.
I think it was more so, he didn't want her to know about him, the bad things he did. He wanted to keep her away from that. He looked at himself as dark, and looked at her like light. So he didn't want to condemn her. He lied not because he didn't trust her, but because he knew she could "cut him a ribbon" he said it when he proposed to her.
So, we just gonna ignore the fact that Sonny walked crossed the hall to Brenda's room. The day Sonny RIPPED OUT my S&B loving heart. Sonny: I have always loved you and I will always love you. No matter what happens you have to know that. Me: NEGRO just be straight with her, DAM! He was so SELFISH to go to Brenda confess his love and leave her. I see why she was confused. His A** can't be HONEST to save his life. SMH!
Y'all talk about how Sonny left Brenda at the altar, which I wouldn't say he did on purpose. This right here is the worst PURPOPSLEY came to her, told her he loved her, confused TF out of her, and left. He ain't ISH for this! Talk about ripping her heart out. She was in the stages of a breakdown during this time.
Yes some of that is coming back to me. Vanessa just had a son born, not long before she came back and wanted more time off then GH was willing to allow and a raise so she left. Pretty ridiculous when they have Tony Geary, around for a few months and then gone for months all the time. I did hear that Guza was all about the Carly character and not a Brenda fan. I Hate Carly, always have..
I was thinking the exact same thing. I loved him more than anyone on the show now I can barely tolerate him. I want Brenda back but I don't want her to come back to the GH they have now.
Poor Brenda . I get that Lily was the perfect woman because she knew how to handle the mob and Sonny as an individual but all Brenda really wanted was someone to really love her and be patient with her , also honestly , she could have been that woman if Sonny had let her .
@dbreiden83080 yeah tamara braun seemed tamer than the first and third Carly...Sarah Brown's face is weird to me and Laura Wright does not seem to go with Sonny at all! i also thought it was weird that he and alexis were together..brenda is the best for sonny!
Honestly, no disrespect to Sarah Brown, I just never found her attractive and thought she was too masculine for Maurice and Sonny's character. Carly always seemed like a woman Sonny would sleep with and just leave behind but for whatever reason they made it into a love story. I never could understand it....
That's the thing.... not everyone loathes Guza. This is just my personal observation but many of the newer viewers enjoy Guza's writing because they have no idea what GH was like years ago, before he was head writer. They do not know the history of many of the great characters that left the show or Guza killed off. I do know that many long time fans, like myself, are dissatisfied with the turn the show has taken and wish that GH would find a fresh new and gifted writer with more creativity.
I mean from about 2007 to 2009. My problem is I need to.....LET GO OF THE PAST!(LOL). After VM left I stopped watching the show religiously, like I once did. Years ago, I would plant myself in front of the television to watch GH every chance I got. Now, I have the opportunity to catch every epi but I don't care if I miss a few or weeks of the show. In 2005, I enjoyed the show because of Robin's return. I just miss the passion and romance, among other things.
just excuses. He never trusted her or loved her. He put her threw the mill&Hell&Back!!! Brenda deserved more then that. Lily had it planed all Along. she was a coniver and manipulator. She exploited how her felt about his mother&protective.
@mohr1020 -I was just thinking Brenda was able to keep the secret that Ned had a double life. She was able to keep that secret for a LONG time. so even though she may have talked a lot, she was very capable of keeping certain secrets. Sonny was an idiot. He should have just told her that he made a deal with rivera and his daughter and not kept Brenda in the dark. Yea he probably thought Brenda would have went to Lily and confronted her, but that's all she would do.. nothing more nothing less.
Yes, S&B were kissing outside of Luke's, then they were gonna get together after a brief appearance at a party. Sonny was gonna forget Lily and be with Brenda but Sonny got arrested and Lily called her dad gur a favor so he promised to marry Lily.
@mohr1020 - I guess he felt she talked too much...maybe that's why he thought he coudn't tell her anything?... but i was saying the same thing you said... there's nothing she did that should have made him doubt her trust in him.
@lol21432 She was fine when Tamara Braun played her, although the Sonny stuff was still too much too take. Laura Wright i don't care for at all. Makes an annoying character that much worse..
I have not been watching the show so much lately because I am not impressed with the storylines. I have grown bored with Steve and Maurice's characters. Just my personal opinion, but for me, if the actors are good but the material is crappy...it is disappointing. Brenda was my favorite character on GH but if she returned and had a poor storyline I would loathe that and probably not continue to watch everyday.
@celgrl28 i hate that Franco dude, I just dont get it nor have I tried to im just waiting for someone to kill him off...franco storyline is boring and ridiculous!!!
After watching this again, Sonny just couldn’t tell Brenda that he was leaving her. He had tears in his eyes....😢💔
What he did was really cruel. "I love you but we can't and won't be together, and I won't tell you why" That is kind of sick when you think about it.
Yes. It wasn't great but he wanted her to KNOW he loves her still, no matter the decisions he was making. Brenda didn't understand but he knew she would understand in Time. He couldn't make love to her [even tho he wanted to] then leave her to go to Lily. I just LOVE their love story. It was SO compelling. SnB were the IT Couple in the 90s ❤
Sonny took Brenda through so much!I can see why she snapped!
OmGOD I hated Sonny during this time BROKE MY GIRL DOWN
This whole Sonny marrying Lily I hated. Lily knew Sonny & Brenda loved each other & she used this to get her hooks into Sonny. I think Lily was selfish. She followed Sonny around like a puppy. Disgusting ... Really!
Exactly true. You could tell her motives as soon as she came into the picture even while she was supposed to be with Miguel. Worst add on.
Hated it too !!!!
WORD!!! BISH was like a BONEHOUND!
True but i think Vanessa and Maurice leaving at the time was a big problem. They couldn't have Sonny and Brenda get married and have a bunch of kids, given the timing of their departures. Shame, Sonny and Brenda are the hottest couple to never get married ever on daytime...
I am with you..I love Brenda and detest Carly. It would be nice to see a new GH writer. One that is NOT all about the Carly character but one that will adhere to GH history and can write fascinating storylines like Claire Labine did. I miss S@B!
@mohr1020 - He felt Brenda talked too much but even when he found out that Brenda kept the secret about Ned being Eddie Maine.. she kept that secret for the longest time. You'd think after learning that she kept that secret, he would know that she was able to keep her mouth shut when needed.
I think it was more so, he didn't want her to know about him, the bad things he did. He wanted to keep her away from that. He looked at himself as dark, and looked at her like light. So he didn't want to condemn her.
He lied not because he didn't trust her, but because he knew she could "cut him a ribbon" he said it when he proposed to her.
Sonny wrong AF for coming to her and leaving her confused. He allowed her to hug and kiss all over him knowing what he was about to do.
So, we just gonna ignore the fact that Sonny walked crossed the hall to Brenda's room. The day Sonny RIPPED OUT my S&B loving heart.
Sonny: I have always loved you and I will always love you. No matter what happens you have to know that.
Me: NEGRO just be straight with her, DAM!
He was so SELFISH to go to Brenda confess his love and leave her. I see why she was confused. His A** can't be HONEST to save his life. SMH!
Sonny and brenda....greatest love ever🤩😍🥰
You mean, REAL couples, REAL triagles, REAL love. I don't even recognize GH anymore
Y'all talk about how Sonny left Brenda at the altar, which I wouldn't say he did on purpose. This right here is the worst PURPOPSLEY came to her, told her he loved her, confused TF out of her, and left. He ain't ISH for this! Talk about ripping her heart out. She was in the stages of a breakdown during this time.
She went crazy behind Sonny. He put her through hell especially this part when he married Lily.
I think it was mainly him saying he loves her forEVER and then leaving without any explanation.
Yes some of that is coming back to me. Vanessa just had a son born, not long before she came back and wanted more time off then GH was willing to allow and a raise so she left. Pretty ridiculous when they have Tony Geary, around for a few months and then gone for months all the time. I did hear that Guza was all about the Carly character and not a Brenda fan. I Hate Carly, always have..
Mutual feelings f-- that ……..
I was thinking the exact same thing. I loved him more than anyone on the show now I can barely tolerate him. I want Brenda back but I don't want her to come back to the GH they have now.
From one prison to another 😂
Poor Brenda . I get that Lily was the perfect woman because she knew how to handle the mob and Sonny as an individual but all Brenda really wanted was someone to really love her and be patient with her , also honestly , she could have been that woman if Sonny had let her .
This was the most original storyline ever... w him having to marry lilly...as much as i hated it... it was everything...
When exactly was this? ANYONE?
He went from one prison to another. 😢
@dbreiden83080 yeah tamara braun seemed tamer than the first and third Carly...Sarah Brown's face is weird to me and Laura Wright does not seem to go with Sonny at all! i also thought it was weird that he and alexis were together..brenda is the best for sonny!
Honestly, no disrespect to Sarah Brown, I just never found her attractive and thought she was too masculine for Maurice and Sonny's character. Carly always seemed like a woman Sonny would sleep with and just leave behind but for whatever reason they made it into a love story. I never could understand it....
That's the thing.... not everyone loathes Guza. This is just my personal observation but many of the newer viewers enjoy Guza's writing because they have no idea what GH was like years ago, before he was head writer. They do not know the history of many of the great characters that left the show or Guza killed off. I do know that many long time fans, like myself, are dissatisfied with the turn the show has taken and wish that GH would find a fresh new and gifted writer with more creativity.
They have bad taste is all lol
I mean from about 2007 to 2009. My problem is I need to.....LET GO OF THE PAST!(LOL). After VM left I stopped watching the show religiously, like I once did. Years ago, I would plant myself in front of the television to watch GH every chance I got. Now, I have the opportunity to catch every epi but I don't care if I miss a few or weeks of the show. In 2005, I enjoyed the show because of Robin's return. I just miss the passion and romance, among other things.
just excuses. He never trusted her or loved her. He put her threw the mill&Hell&Back!!! Brenda deserved more then that.
Lily had it planed all Along. she was a coniver and manipulator. She exploited how her felt about his mother&protective.
those walls must be really THICK if Lily can't hear the two of them! Aren't their rooms right next to each other??
LOL!!!!
She prob knew and pretended not to hear.
@mohr1020 -I was just thinking Brenda was able to keep the secret that Ned had a double life. She was able to keep that secret for a LONG time. so even though she may have talked a lot, she was very capable of keeping certain secrets. Sonny was an idiot. He should have just told her that he made a deal with rivera and his daughter and not kept Brenda in the dark. Yea he probably thought Brenda would have went to Lily and confronted her, but that's all she would do.. nothing more nothing less.
What is Brenda talking about "what happened the other night"? Is there video of the other night?
Yes, S&B were kissing outside of Luke's, then they were gonna get together after a brief appearance at a party. Sonny was gonna forget Lily and be with Brenda but Sonny got arrested and Lily called her dad gur a favor so he promised to marry Lily.
hard to believe.
Clothes Tree -- LMAO :)
hmmm...I don't know why she left but I think she stopped writing for GH in 1996.
@mohr1020 - I guess he felt she talked too much...maybe that's why he thought he coudn't tell her anything?... but i was saying the same thing you said... there's nothing she did that should have made him doubt her trust in him.
LMAO too!
@lol21432
She was fine when Tamara Braun played her, although the Sonny stuff was still too much too take. Laura Wright i don't care for at all. Makes an annoying character that much worse..
I have not been watching the show so much lately because I am not impressed with the storylines. I have grown bored with Steve and Maurice's characters. Just my personal opinion, but for me, if the actors are good but the material is crappy...it is disappointing. Brenda was my favorite character on GH but if she returned and had a poor storyline I would loathe that and probably not continue to watch everyday.
@celgrl28 i hate that Franco dude, I just dont get it nor have I tried to im just waiting for someone to kill him off...franco storyline is boring and ridiculous!!!