irene forgetting a bit of lyrics in her part then apologizing is so cute😂 been 3 years since the last i'm hearing red velvet with their heavenly vocals singing live while sitting down like this so i'm happy that these live clips gets to be uploaded❤
They performed In My Dreams live while sitting down, but perhaps this reminds you of the Psycho album where they sat in front of fans in an intimate setting. They always slay the live vocals.
you push it in twice some girls has vocals.. plus SM search people with voice in GOT they all had powerful voice though in the end BP had no vocals they sell a lot because of the look :(
@@lomltaegi8190 and coz tbh they’re beautiful girls with Lisa being best dancer, Rose having ‘Koreans golden voice’ even tho Wendy’s vocal is unmatched I’m not a bp Stan I rather RV be the successful group than BP
@@le_hiyushi5459 rv did not making it big cause there are no wealthy member that brags about her first ever school bag was chanel.. honestly in music wise rv has lot more to offer, their discography is amazing and soo diverse, they can do any genre from bubblegum pop to slow r&b like this. its just shame most people around the world are just more concern about looks and aesthetics
@@pandumiharja6769 yeah which is a shame I agree, this is exactly why I like RV so much coz of their harmonies which are impeccable. No other group can compare tbh. And they can nail any concept they put and hasn’t disappointment once. RV is only of the rare groups where they have it all are literally the full package
@@Max-my6rk cause they can’t sing lol😭😭 All Red velvet members can actually sing and do it with ease, not ive tho they CANT leave the auto tune alone either
@@Max-my6rk bro this is a red velvet video why y'all always gotta bring ive down??? it's not fair comparing one of the best vocal groups in kpop to one of the worst vocal groups of 4th gen. other groups have done that too and yet Ive gets all the hate lol Ive sings live 80% of the time anyway
What I like about Red Velvet is that they were never afraid to SING! They just don’t sit or stand there to be pretty, they’re truly passionate about music.
Irene's voice is perfect for the song opening..each one of them can sing each other part perfectly..and people might say this is lipsync if not becos of irene's cute mistake..indeed red velvet's vocals are undeniably great..i love these girls soo much..
When all of them sing the chorus of this song at that last part I always get goosebumps. It’s almost as if their voices were made for each other. In my opinion, Red Velvet will forever be the vocal queens of kpop. ❤️
Irene making a mistake and laughing it out with Joy taking the lead after wards reminds of the last time when they did this the time of Revé festival final album, when they were singing live just like this... I think Irene even had the similar outfit or color of outfit as before too 😂😂 I hope Red velvets 2023 will be the best
With Red Velvet, you don't have to worry if it's lip sync or not. From the main vocal to the rappers, all of them can sing and harmonize well together. My underrated queens. 👸
@@dgls127 In a sense I agree, I felt other groups are gaining so much popularity, the new generation, that everybody seems to forget about some groups from previous generation, one of them being Red Velvet, but their music and talent are what keep them relevant to some of us.
Red Velvet is really the best when they’re five. They’re powerful individually, but they’re untouchable when they’re five. They create a new voice that only their harmonies can make.
I love how Red Velvet is genuinely into music. They really love their craft and work very hard for it. Some idols nowadays are only in it for the benefit that comes with it.
Terakhir dapet konten kayak gini pas era psycho sumpah senang banget dikasih konten Red Velvet nyanyi live gini karna semua orang harus tau kalo RV vocalnya top tier
@@rajapranathadoloksaribu4808, inget kata Bung Korea di kontennya, SM cenderung "nahan" beberapa kelebihan artis2nya, alias gak dikeluarin all out dalam satu waktu aja. strategi marketing sih kayaknya
I am obsessed with Red Velvets Bsides tracks. Like SNSD they have the best Bsides for a girl group. All of the songs are nice to the ears and so relaxing and the vocals is so soothing.
Joy’s sweet, soft and clear vocal makes you feel things. Like her vocals makes you feel longing and nostalgic at the same time. Her voice gives a lot of emotions. That’s why hers is my favorite vocals in Kpop.
이 노래 이 앨범 수록곡중 가장 좋아하고 내가 힘들때 들었던 노래라 너무 소중함
Irene reminding everyone they’re really singing live HAHAHAH
T R U E
😂❤
that joy correction though hahaha
unlike bts flops
@@goop3263LMAO SLAY
RV = Real Vocals
Irene's laugh so cute
I thought it was Wendy's lol
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF KPOP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 we all know that’s a lie sweetie ☺️
and RV is also = real visuals
마지막 후렴구 합창부분 목소리합 미쳤다....
Irene’s mistake was so cute and I love how Joy laughed casually and quickly said “katchi”
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF KPOP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
What does "Katchi" means?
@@veronicamercadejas7686 together
@@veronicamercadejas7686'together'
Irene's laugh and Joy saving her, I love them so much
irene forgetting a bit of lyrics in her part then apologizing is so cute😂 been 3 years since the last i'm hearing red velvet with their heavenly vocals singing live while sitting down like this so i'm happy that these live clips gets to be uploaded❤
Stray kids the king of kpop
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 wtf
sameee we need these every cb
They performed In My Dreams live while sitting down, but perhaps this reminds you of the Psycho album where they sat in front of fans in an intimate setting. They always slay the live vocals.
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 nah man this is really pathetic you've made like dozens of these comments on so many channels
ㄹㅇ 탑급 목소리들임 다섯명 다가치 부르면 천상의 목소리라고 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
They don't make idols like this anymore. The vocal qualities of RV are insane. So much talent here
you push it in twice some girls has vocals.. plus SM search people with voice in GOT they all had powerful voice though
in the end BP had no vocals they sell a lot because of the look :(
@@Jsarmy87124 bp sell mainly cz of the ‘aesthetic’
@@lomltaegi8190 and coz tbh they’re beautiful girls with Lisa being best dancer, Rose having ‘Koreans golden voice’ even tho Wendy’s vocal is unmatched I’m not a bp Stan I rather RV be the successful group than BP
@@le_hiyushi5459 rv did not making it big cause there are no wealthy member that brags about her first ever school bag was chanel.. honestly in music wise rv has lot more to offer, their discography is amazing and soo diverse, they can do any genre from bubblegum pop to slow r&b like this. its just shame most people around the world are just more concern about looks and aesthetics
@@pandumiharja6769 yeah which is a shame I agree, this is exactly why I like RV so much coz of their harmonies which are impeccable. No other group can compare tbh. And they can nail any concept they put and hasn’t disappointment once. RV is only of the rare groups where they have it all are literally the full package
앨범 막곡이 이 노래라 다시 벌스데이로 돌아가서 무한 루프하게 되는 곡..... 넘 좋아ㅠㅠ
irene’s vocals just hit different fr
Stray kids the king of k-pop
The part I like most is when Irene forgets the lyrics and Joy completes the part.
This is how a singer sings live on stage. Red Velvet is one of the best K-pop girl groups about vocals.
IVE were sitting there lip-syncing.
@@Max-my6rk cause they can’t sing lol😭😭 All Red velvet members can actually sing and do it with ease, not ive tho they CANT leave the auto tune alone either
@@Max-my6rk bro this is a red velvet video why y'all always gotta bring ive down???
it's not fair comparing one of the best vocal groups in kpop to one of the worst vocal groups of 4th gen.
other groups have done that too and yet Ive gets all the hate lol Ive sings live 80% of the time anyway
@@Max-my6rk let's only talk about RV here to respect them. Bcs i think we don't really need an information about any other groups hahahahaha 🙈
@@winning976 jealous of what ? bad vocals ?
이게 바로 케이팝이지.. 우리 갓벨벳 노래 다 잘하고, 하모니도 장난 아니고, 비주얼도 너무 이쁘고.. 하.. 스엠.. 레벨 컨서트 언제와?! 아니.. 이렇게 완벽한 다섯명 목소리 왜 킬링 보이스 안 나와ㅜ
진짜 미쳣다……… 내기준 보컬풀 원탑 걸그룹이다…
갓더비트 수록곡 듣고 다시왔습니닷..
귀 떨어지는줄,,,, 역시 난 레벨 취향
Irene forgetting her line is the cutest thing I saw all day 😆😆
이번 수록곡은 거를 타선이 1도 없네 곡도 잘나오고 실력도 상향 평준화되고
Irene forgetting the lyrics just proves that they are indeed singing it LIVE. Love you Irene no matter what 💗💗💗
2:07 레벨 목소리 합 황홀 그 잡채,, 못 들은 사람 없게 해주세요
Irene and Yeri absolutely proved that it wasn't lip-sync .
What I like about Red Velvet is that they were never afraid to SING! They just don’t sit or stand there to be pretty, they’re truly passionate about music.
HSHSHSHSHSHSHS sit there and be prettyyy very wy energy sksksksksks
No backtracks, just pure vocals. Love it
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF K-POP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 😀
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 wrong place kids
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 who STRAY ADULT?.
JOY vocal is just something else. I can't even imagine how much' her vocal is so sweet like that..
all RV are talented rappers, visuals, entertainers, & vocalists with hearts of gold who love and inspire their fans endlessly
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF K-POP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 why are you posting this everywhere?
@@jinni9500 i did it only once and u start complaining. I really pity u
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 Get out of here kid
앨범 노래중에 이노래가 제일좋음
Red Velvet and live singing 😍. Talented Queens indeed. Really hope i could hear them live someday on their concert
Stray kids the king of kpop
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
아 역시 보컬 맛집 미쳤다
Not Joohyun being like “OOP sorry yall” then Joy being like 🤗🤗🤗
5명의 하모니는 언제 들어도 정말 좋다… 감동적이야
다음 레벨 콘서트때 이곡 막곡으로 나오는 상상.. 눈물나벌써ㅠㅠ 라이브로 꼭 들어보고싶었는데 넘 좋음
너무 좋다..한개 더 있는것도 풀어주세요 제발..
RV LITERALLY STANDS FOR REAL VISUAL AND REAL VOCAL🥰🥰🥰
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF KPOP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 We are talking about Red Velvet From SM Entertainment not Stray Kids from JYP Entertainment
라이브 들을 때 마다 러비로써 자부심이 뿜뿜
싸이코때 이런 라이브 영상올라온거 엄청 좋아했는데 또 이렇게 보니까 너무너무 좋다 우리 언니들 너무 잘해 ... 개멋있어
The simple mini concert like this is one of the privilege of being a reveluv. Not so many group outside of SM that can give you this kind of content.
Yes please SM 😭 I'm Really happy, although only two songs but this is make reveluv happy
@@silvermistt874yessss we get to hear their raw vocals
Irene's voice is perfect for the song opening..each one of them can sing each other part perfectly..and people might say this is lipsync if not becos of irene's cute mistake..indeed red velvet's vocals are undeniably great..i love these girls soo much..
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF K-POP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 us knowing that’s a lie💀
Joy's honey toned voice is so heavenly... Close your eyes and listen then you will feel how melodic her voice is.... Love you Joy.
진짜 완벽해... 나 다섯명 목소리 너무 사랑해 이런 곡 제발 많이 킬링보이스 제발
킬링보이스 안나오는게 이해안될뿐인 그룹 중 하나
3집 컴백과 함께 나왔다고한다...
seungwannie's vocals 🫠
벨순이들 음색 세상좋다
I just want to appreciate Irene's voice here 😭 it's seldom that this happens (Irene getting more lines)
2:07 배젼 실수하니깐 박셩 팬들한때 냉큼 "다같이" 유도하는것보소~~ ㅋㅋ 센스 좋다.
When all of them sing the chorus of this song at that last part I always get goosebumps. It’s almost as if their voices were made for each other. In my opinion, Red Velvet will forever be the vocal queens of kpop. ❤️
웬디 라이브에서 확실히 파워가 엄청나게 느껴져 너무 사랑해
Wendy's grown woman vocals just standing out! 💙💙💙
에스엠 장점..확신의 메보가 항상 있다는것..실력으로는 최고인 회사지..
Irene making a mistake and laughing it out with Joy taking the lead after wards reminds of the last time when they did this the time of Revé festival final album, when they were singing live just like this... I think Irene even had the similar outfit or color of outfit as before too 😂😂 I hope Red velvets 2023 will be the best
레드벨벳 노래에서 제일 좋아하는 노래 중 하나
진짜 연말과 잘 어울린다
역시 레벨 라이브 너무 잘한다,, 제발 킬링보이스 나와줘,,🙏🔥
2:07 다같이! 하고 웃는거 넘 사랑스러워….너무귀여워🥲
With Red Velvet, you don't have to worry if it's lip sync or not. From the main vocal to the rappers, all of them can sing and harmonize well together.
My underrated queens. 👸
Underrated????
@@dgls127 In a sense I agree, I felt other groups are gaining so much popularity, the new generation, that everybody seems to forget about some groups from previous generation, one of them being Red Velvet, but their music and talent are what keep them relevant to some of us.
for me Red Velvet more to underappreciated than underrated
@@jendeugi1345 this !
레드벨벳 멤버들 다 설렘에 가득한 목소리여서 넘 예쁨 음색 조합 끝장남😮
I really like this song. And Joy's voice is so sweet, really suits this song😭💚
Tone fairy things
Red Velvet is really the best when they’re five. They’re powerful individually, but they’re untouchable when they’re five. They create a new voice that only their harmonies can make.
I love Irene's vocal so much
joy’s voice always angelic
하 이러니 레드벨벳을 사랑하지…평생 좋아할게
진짜 보컬 장난아니다..
정규 낼 때라도 킬링보이스 출연 제발 부탁드립니다
Joy’s vocals is as beautiful as her visual. Wow.
irene's cute giggle after she made a mistake🥹💗 2:05
이게 말이 되는 아이돌 라이브냐? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 개미쳤네
irene laughing😂 red velvet who aren't afraid and always consistently try to sing live..... we love you girls🥹🫶🏻
Celebrate 진짜 라이브로 듣고 싶었는데ㅠㅠ 너무 좋아ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Irene’s laugh. 😂 Oh we know it’s definitely live. :D
Irene voice is really smooth
Yeri and Irene casually proving it is 💯% live
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF K-POP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
haha yes - go go Yerene
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 Get out of here kid
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 we really don't care
I love how Yeri doesn't forget to smile everytime she sings ❤️
레벨 보컬 짱짱이다 증말
I love how Red Velvet is genuinely into music. They really love their craft and work very hard for it. Some idols nowadays are only in it for the benefit that comes with it.
I love how all 5 of them sang the last chorus.
레드벨벳은 귀엽고 예쁘고 노래도 잘함~심지어 예능도 잘함~^
Irene is so beautiful and her voice is soft, warm, sweet and beautiful as well ❤️🩹
Yerene opening celebrate gets me levitating every time I hear it
떼창할때 목소리합 진짜 예쁘다
Thank you Joy, you bring me to this group back in 2016. Stan Red Velvet!!
왜케 잘해 잘하는거 입아프고 목소리 다들 너무 좋아
if every k-pop idol could sing like this, no one would have hated ballad songs
진짜 레드벨벳 다들 왜케 노래 잘하냐
STRAY KIDS THE KING OF KPOP
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 okey
@@Jungkookiethetrueleader97 외퀴야 너네 계정가라
Thank you Irene unnie for that cute mistake, you proved that its really your real voice guyz. I so love this song.its on my repeat.
0:36 THE QUALITY OF HER VOCALS 🔥 SHE'S THE ONLY MAIN VOCAL FOR A REASON
Irene this song perfect for your voice love it
Terakhir dapet konten kayak gini pas era psycho sumpah senang banget dikasih konten Red Velvet nyanyi live gini karna semua orang harus tau kalo RV vocalnya top tier
Iya bener, banyak-banyakin konten kayak gini
SETUJU
iya anjir, kayak pelit gitu SM ngasi konten live singing ke mereka. Padahal mereka kan penyanyi, ya harusnya kerjanya banyak nyanyi.
Sumpah iya banget!! Ini aja On A ride sama In out Belom Huhu
@@rajapranathadoloksaribu4808, inget kata Bung Korea di kontennya, SM cenderung "nahan" beberapa kelebihan artis2nya, alias gak dikeluarin all out dalam satu waktu aja. strategi marketing sih kayaknya
I am obsessed with Red Velvets Bsides tracks. Like SNSD they have the best Bsides for a girl group. All of the songs are nice to the ears and so relaxing and the vocals is so soothing.
레드벨벳 보컬 진짜 최고최고최고다!!! 💗💛💙💚💜
웬디는 날이 갈수록 예뻐지는듯
I think we are both agree that Irene's small mistake is really cute and the most interesting part in this video hahahah
하…너무 좋다 킬링보이스 나와줘여💗💛💙💚💜
Irene so cuteee
Thank you, Red Velvet for existing!!!!
레드벨벳이 오래 살아남는 이유가 바로 이거임
Joy’s sweet, soft and clear vocal makes you feel things. Like her vocals makes you feel longing and nostalgic at the same time. Her voice gives a lot of emotions. That’s why hers is my favorite vocals in Kpop.
Perfect Vocals!!! Perfect Harmonies!!! Red Velvet OT5 Forvever
Crazy.. Wendy always makes singing seems so easy..
Yeri low tones always the best
그냥 음원 그 자체...🥺🥹 승완언니 진짜 미쳤다,,
their vocal no joke!!
2:08 레드벨벳의 올파트 라이브는 언제나 진리다
그와중에 각자 개인파트 전부다 딱 세번씩이네
It's amazing
wendy can slay in every concept and i love it..