Tbh I agree with the results in the Super Six in Season 4. I think Crocodile did better than Seahorse. While I wanted Jellyfish to win, I expected Mushroom would. And Sun vs Popcorn was really hard because they both had really strong performances but I think Sun deserved to win. The only episode that still to this day really rubs me the wrong way was the Battle of the Sixes in Season 3. I think Turtle and Astronaut were the two best of the night, so I don't understand how Astro got sent home. I would've picked Kitty or Rhino to go just based off those performances honestly.
Miss monster deffo picked the wrong song for her week but Gronk still should have gone. With seahorse and crocodile: A: REALLY bad song choice for the seahorse, did not like her singing bruno mars at all and B: she talked about she needs to do choreo and i'm 'didn't you not do at least SOME choreo during the rihanna and britney numbers, it's not like you just stood there"
The most robbed character in season 1-7 Season 1-Lion Season 2-Butterfly Season 3-Turtle Season 4-Seahorse Season 5-Russian Dolls/Yeti Season 6-Bull Season 7-Ringmaster
@Charlie Lie once they got top 6 it should have been everyone for themselves there was almost no point of the “one person from each group makes finale”
Personally I think kitty left at the right time since I thought rhino did incredible in the top 4. I think your opinion on butterfly that episode is spot on. I’ve always thought he stayed just so they didn’t piss Nicole off. The Russian dolls being eliminated was bullshit, I think chameleon or piglet should’ve left there, the episode banana left I thought was surprising. The super 6 of season 4 is still one of the most flawed episodes in masked singer history. The whole set up just didn’t make any sense. Why pin the last two from each group against each other instead of having all 6 fight against each other? We all wanted to see sun and seahorse go at it and we never did. Plus putting seahorse and crocodile together was BS since they both deserved a spot in the finals. Jellyfish losing to mushroom is seriously unbelievable. She was way better than him that night and I don’t get why she went home over him.
Personally I don't think thingamajig went through just to please nicole because to sing caught up in such a clean way that he did is NOT easy, trust me i've tried and i can only just pull it off.
My rankings of the performances on these episodes Group A Finals (Season 3) 4. White Tiger - really bad 3. Miss Monster - decent [OUT] 2. Kangaroo - really good 1. Turtle - really good Quarterfinals (Season 5) 5. Chameleon - pretty good 4. Piglet - pretty good 3. Black Swan - pretty good 2. Russian Dolls - really good [OUT] 1. Yeti - amazing Quarterfinals (Season 3) 5. Frog - pretty good 4. Rhino - pretty good 3. Night Angel - really good 2. Kitty - really good [OUT] 1. Turtle - amazing Faceoffs Part 2 (Season 2) 4. Thingamajig - pretty good 3. Butterfly - amazing [OUT] 2. Fox - amazing 1. Tree - amazing Faceoffs Part 2 (Season 3) 4. Frog - pretty good 3. Rhino - pretty good 2. Banana - really good [OUT] 1. Kitty - amazing Super Six (Season 4) 6. Jellyfish - pretty good 5. Popcorn - really good 4. Mushroom - really good 3. Crocodile - amazing 2. Seahorse - amazing 1. Sun - incredible
The Super Six just had a messed up format. Crocodile and Seahorse both deserved to be finalists along with Sun. Jellyfish, Popcorn and Mushroom deserved to go home.
I don’t agree with that but I respect personally I agree with jellyfish leaving because she didn’t really know what note to hit at different times and it came apart and her performances were messy. Then I think seahorse deserved that loss as that episode she gave her worst performance and crocodile gave one of his best and he was more of a fan favorite and one of the first powerful rock vocals Next I believe sun should’ve lost instead of popcorn I admit sun was way better but older singers aren’t appreciated but popcorn had a seasoned more raspy voice and it was perfect and sun just had a normal voice that you hear from country singers and you never hear anything like Taylor’s beautiful voice
My ranking: 6. Episode 8 (Season 3) Astronaut had left 5. Episode 4 (Season 5) Crab had left 4. Episode 15 (Season 3) Frog had left 3. Episode 9 (Season 2) Butterfly had to won the face-off against Fox and the smackdown against Thing 2. Episode 10 (Season 4) Seahorse and Popcorn had stayed 1. Episode 12 (Season 2) Flamingo had won, Rottweiler second and Fox third
The most messed up in each season: Season 1 Finale (Season 1 didn't really have any, but I picked this one simply because I thought Peacock should've won, but I'm ok with Monster winning) Season 2 Ep9 (I honestly think Tree should've gone home because I thought her performance was boring and she didn't have the best voice, and Butterfly should've won the smackdown, though Fox was still good) Season 3 Ep12 (I thought the exact opposite of this episode should've happened. Frog's first 4 performances were great, but this one was the weakest of the night. Kitty was the strongest, so I have no idea how Frog won. Banana also should've won because his was more powerful and Rhino's was boring. Honestly, Frog should've gone home.) Season 4 Semifinals (This one is weird because I actually agree with all the results, but the biggest problem was the format. It limited the options so much and it wasn't as much on who are the best 3, and more on which of the 2 are better.) Season 5 Semifinals (I was shocked when Yeti went home. I thought for sure he would make it to the finals, and Chameleon really should've gone home. He should've gone home in the top 8, but he made it all the way, and while he was far from bad, he just did the same thing every week, while everyone else kept doing something different.) Season 6 Premiere (I know I'll get attacked for saying this, but Pufferfish should've left first because I thought she was the weakest of the night. But I'm not that bothered by it, and I was fine with all the other episodes so I said this one.) Season 7 Finale (The only one I didn't think should've been in the finale won. It was all because of the song choice, but I think Prince did better than her, and Ringmaster should've taken home the trophy. And Thingamabob should've been there instead of Firefly.)
Here's mine 6. Miss Monster. How the hell did WT win? 5. Orca. I know people like Seashell, but I thought her performance was weak that round 4. Rhino. Frog was really weak that night but I'm not surprised that he made it through over my beloved Rhino 3. Butterfly. I still think she should've been in the smackdown cause Fox is in my opinion the best Masked Singer of all time so yeah. But she should've beat Thing in the Smackdown 2. Serpent. I can't say much about this cause both Seahorse and Croc are amazing. I just wish he was in a different group. Or it was a Super 7 instead 1. Snail. THEY DID KERMIT DIRTY SENDING HIM HOME BEFORE THAT THING
I 100% agree with all of these choices, especially the season 4 semifinals. Jellyfish did better then mushroom, sun did beat popcorn, and seahorse should've won over crocodile.
Here are my top 6 6. Season 1 finale This was a bit confusing overall in the finale I thought peacock should’ve won over monster. 5. Season 4 super 6 This was a shocker for all with seahorses battle she should’ve beat crocodile with mushrooms battle his performance was strong and deserved the win and popcorn should’ve been eliminated much sooner. 4. Season 2 finale this was a shocker for me due to Rottweiler having the best performance of the night I thought he would totally win over fox but I guess I was wrong. 3. Season 2 final 7 I totally believe butterfly was robbed and this episode was rigged thingamajig had the weaker performance. 2. Season 5 finale I can’t believe that chameleon made the finale he shouldn’t have I think it should’ve been robopine vs black swan vs piglet not chameleon. And I also believe black swan had the stronger performance overall while piglets was his best of the whole season. 1. Season 7 episode 1 This episode was filed with so many twists and turns firstly we had someone’s mask falls off and then somebody else being so scared they had to stop in the middle of the performance. I also believe that the elimination was unfair aswell. Thanks just my opinion
6. Season 5 Episode 9 Russian Doll, (I was really shocked and disappointed to see them go home. I thought for sure chameleon was going home but I wanted piglet to go home. I really think they should’ve stayed til the finale and shouldn’t have gone home) 5. Season 2 Episode 10 Flamingo (I was really disappointed when she went home at third. I personally think she should’ve won. Every performance she gave was flawless and amazing! And she really didn’t want to take the mask off. She delivered in that finale performance and should not have gone home at third) 4. Season 4 Episode 10 Jellyfish and Seahorse (I was extremely disappointed and shocked when Seahorse and Jellyfish went home. Jellyfish was amazing and her last performance was so beautiful. Mushroom was alright but nowhere near as good as jellyfish, and for seahorse, she should’ve have defeated Crocodile 100%. She was so good every week and the finale with her would’ve been amazing) 3. Season 3 Episode 10 Kangaroo, (I think this whole episode was just messed up. In the fight of Kangaroo and Night angel, Kangaroo should’ve won. She was amazing and her voice doesn’t get enough credit. I think the smack down should’ve been Night angel and Astronaut and I think Astronaut should’ve gone home that night. Kangaroo did not deserve her place and I’m really upset she went home when she should’ve been In the finale with turtle and Night angel) 2. Season 1 Episode 9 Lion (This episode was really messed up. I think that Lion was the best out of this season and that she did not need to go home. I think that the first person that should’ve gone home was peacock then rabbit. Lion did not deserve her place at all and should’ve won season 1) 1. Season 5 finale Black Swan (She should’ve won plain and simple. She delivered every single week with her great voice and stage presentation. Piglet was a great singer and all but when it comes to it Black Swan should’ve won. The finale performances were all great but she was the best. Every performance from her was flawless and I love her so much. She was a natural on the stage and when she came in second place I was so disappointed. She was robbed big time and I wish that she could have won that)
I was actually the opposite with banana and rhino, I found banana boring and I connected so much with Rhino. I just felt like the way banana sang 'Knockin on heaven's door' promised a lot of impact but then when it hit his voice kinda didn't really change and then the ending where he just runs on top of the piano and doesn't really do much else except shout to the audience felt like a let down to me. But 100% frog had his worst performance that week and should have been in the smackdown.
@@dancingseahorse Ya her song choise was good and the reason why Banana lost to Rhino I liked Banana better but Rhinoceros choose a way more popular then Bananas
To those who think the only reason thingamajig won because of nicole, like how. New people come in each masked singer episode and don't know about anything before. Their only hint of the relationship was his earlier performance. Still thingamajig's voice still sounded pretty good and he was entertaining which might have been the reason he won the smackdown. Altough I still prefer butterfly's performance though.
Personally, I don’t think anyone on this list chose the wrong song. Some of the song aren’t songs I was expecting, but I still think they were great song choices!
All I can say is that super six season 4 should have only one person leaving and it would be popcorn or jellyfish my opinion also jellyfish ruined the group performance so I kind of understand why she left also I think mushroom was better
Honestly. Back to black was the ONLY performance of Kitty's that I just did not like, i feel like back to black the original version is good but it doesn't really carry that much impact with it. There's a version done by Allie Sherlock that Strictly Come Dancing may have pinched and tweaked a bit for Angela Scanlon to use for her Argentine Tango but that part is irrelevant here. If she had done that specific arrangement which had extra drumbeats and strong powerful backing instruments, 100 percent she would have gone through. I actually thought 'You've lost that lovin' feeling' was one of Rhino's best so I was not gutted with that result at all.
1. 🇺🇸 Season 5 - 10 Russian dolls are the best and really robbed 2. 🇩🇪 Season 4 - final Leopard was the best and was really robbed! 3. 🇳🇿 Season 1 - Super 6 Jelly was the best and got so robbed!
Dancing seahorse I agree that miss monster deserve to be in super 9 and that kitty deserve to be in final 4 but I disagree see the format of season 4 in the super six was rigged like the triple elimination was stupid and if it wasn't a triple Crocodile seahorse and sun deserve to make it to the finale
I absolutely agree with all of your choices! I also feel like Season 5 Ep 7 (Super 8) could’ve been on the list as well; I had a feeling that Crab was going home that episode, even though his performance was really good, but Seashell going was what shocked me the most & it’s what the panelists said that also annoys me, why do they say in several episodes, that the contestant’s performance was their best yet they get eliminated?! If I had to choose who should’ve gone instead, if it was me during the season, I’d say Chameleon, but after summarising the whole season, I actually think Robopine should’ve gone instead, he wasn’t bad that episode, but that performance imo wasn’t his best & during the Spicy 6, I knew for sure he was going.
I don’t believe seahorse was robbed so here is my opinion on what the elimination order should have been for season 4 16. Lips 15. Dragon 14. Gremlin 13. Broccoli 12. Baby Alien 11. Squiggly Monster 10. Giraffe 9. Snow Owls 8. Serpent 7. Whatchamacallit 6. Jellyfish 5. Seahorse 4. Sun 3. Crocodile 2. Popcorn 1. Mushroom
Probably for me, with reasonings: 6. S3 F6 (should’ve been Rhino, Astronaut had one of his strongest performances) 5. S3 F5 (should’ve been Rhino, Kitty wasn’t as strong but solid) 4. S5 F5 (should’ve been Black Swan, she fucked herself over hard and finale format saved her ass, this round is weird since Black Swan was the worse and Piglet 2nd worse, Chameleon 3rd, Russian Dolls 2nd and Yeti was performance of the night) 3. S4 F10 (should’ve been Popcorn, Snow Owls were much better, but Sun was outdoing both competitors so it’d just be a placement swap if anything) 2. S3 F3 (Turtle should’ve won, the old way of winners being determined and this “female winner” agenda screwed him over) 1. S6 F2 (mainly since Bull was hyped up all season to be this powerhouse, which he was, and was the strongest at the finale with his best performance in Invisible though Straight Up is very close, then QoH won when she didn’t have her best performance, she should’ve saved Sia, as that was her best performance, in the end she pulled a Seahorse/Black Swan/Pepper and I think the background and the rumor that she could’ve won due to her album dropping is what saved her from 2nd. Ik some might claim peeps hate the female winners just because they outdid a talented male, which isn’t true, Piglet got a lot of shit, Crocodile especially got a lot of shit for the shitty format, while Sun didn’t get any hate. QoH wasn’t as strong which sucks cuz she’s the best female vocalist of the cast)
If you somebody else likes Season 2 , you may like Wayne Brady as a heartthrob with the best vocal and comparing the same voices like Jamie Foxx. You’re luckily that he didn’t mentioned miss the notes from the lyrics.
For season 3. My top 5 ones Ep 2 white tiger should’ve gone out Ep 6 rhino should have gone out Finale turtle should’ve won and night angel and frog didn’t deserve to make it into the finals Ep 15 rhino should’ve gone home besides turtles performance she was the best one Ep 14 I hated g this episode Astronaut was the best masked singer imo and rhino should’ve gone home in this episode and earlier in the competition like 10th place
The most bulls**t episode of each season Season 1 semi finals: Ok I thing rabbit should have kept going to the finals his performance was strong and I’ll say it the people going home should have been Lion and bee Season 2:Semi finals/Round two face offs:Both of these were bs for the semi finals Thingamajig and leopard should have gone the final with Rottweiler For the round two face off tree should have gone I don’t like her voice and butterfly should have kept going sadly I would have her leave in the semifinals Season 3 Super 6:Ok I personally think that frog should have gone in the smack down sadly but this round it should have been kitty I’m sorry that’s just my opinion he had a great performance. Season 4 Group C finals-(side note I thing the super 6 Should have been crocodile and serpent and sun and dragon) ok I think jellyfish should have gone here she was the weakest from the night and I think broccoli and mushroom should have kept going Season 5 semifinal-Yeti should have won the season plain and simple Season 6:Group b Semifinals-Ok I don’t like queen of hearts I think she should have gone first and I think mallard should have been in second place Season 7 Finale-Prince should have won I really like ringmaster and thingamabob should have been there but prince is just the best to me
I wanted popcorn to stay too but I like sun performance too so I think popcorn and sun to make to the finale and I liked crocodile performance too so I think the finale should be popcorn crocodile and sun
I agree with all of them except for your number 3 and number 1. I think Fox still should’ve won again Butterfly, but I do agree that Thing should have been eliminated. And then your number 1, I agree with it all except for Mushroom vs Jellyfish. I thought that Valerie was his strongest performance. Overall I though it was disappointing that they elongated 3 people.
For the super six, I blame the format for sending a legend like seahorse home. In the other seasons, there weren’t face offs which made the competition less difficult to send someone home. If there weren’t faceoffs I think crocodile and seahorse could fight sun in the finale
I think for season 3 episode 3 I didn’t like miss monster monster performance but I did want her to be in the super 8 and I didn’t like white tiger performance season 5 episode 11 i liked everybody’s performance in the feisty five season 3 episode 13 I liked rhino performance and banana and I liked kitty performance and I didn’t like the frog performance because frog forgot a word in the song season 4 episode 10 I like crocodile performance it was my favorite performance on season 4 I liked mushroom performance it was very fun and sun performance was awesome and emotional season 2 episode 9 face off round 2 I wanted butterfly to stay I like her performance I liked tree’s performance I was amazing and thingamajig performance I liked it too it was fun and wanted fox to leave season 3 episode 15 I didn’t like kitty performance It was the weakest performance on that night and I think rhino performance was better than the kitty’s
@@brandonbennett8368 yeah I definitely don’t think he was better than both Astronaut and Kitty and I definitely would say a little better than Night Angel
Thats because the correct people have made it to the finale each time. Gender should not effect the performance level of the competitiors because even though they are obvious what gender they are, technically it's an anonymous performance, so gender has little to no effect on here
Disagree on some here Miss monster was not good even though white tiger should go it wasn’t a complete Rob and seahorse deserved to go home over crocodile her song choice was shaky and his was one of the best on this entire series only issue is the match up jellyfish also shouldn’t be in the finals she was good but no where near the top three worthy
Season 3 finale should be on the list night angel had no business even in the finale should of left over astronaut in the top 6 turtle was far and away the best
night angel had all her business being in the finale her and turtle where the clear finalists after kitty and astro where gone they both had their best performances in the finale (as they should) and THAT finale came down to personally preference and it seems like the crowd that night liked night angel better
@@brandonbennett8368 well i agree with kitty being in the finale i’ll give you that but rlly dude night angel was good it’s just become a “common” thing to hate her because she won against turtle and i don’t rlly mean to stereotype but so many turtle, piglet, and croc fans are really toxic and you guys ruin the show :/ it’s celebrity’s singing in halloween costumes no need to be saying people suck edit: sorry this is a month later i didn’t get a notification
Mine Season 3:miss monster shouldve gone to the next round Season 4:seahorse she should've been 2nd Season 1:bee should've been 2nd instead of 3td Season 3:kitty should've been 3rd or 2nd instead of 5th and frog or rhino should've left Season 5:russian dolls should've been 3rd or 2nd instead of 5th chameleon should've left this episode
Here's mine and feel free to disagree if you don't like it Season 3 miss monster correct elimination decision Season 4 seahorse also correct elimination decision Season 1 bee right decision Season 3 kitty I agree with you Season 5 Russian dolls I actually agree with you on that one as well.
My poor Jellyfish was robbed during the supa 6. Mushroom does have talent, but Chloe Kim's performance was without a doubt the better one. And very emotional to boot
Mine Season 2 Episode 9 Faceoffs Round 2 In this round Both Thingamajig & butterfly both deserved to continue in the competition & tree should have gone home this episode Season 4 Episode 10 Super 6 In this episode Crocodile & sun both deserved to move on to the finale but Jellyfish should have moved on too & mushroom should Have Gone Home in this episode Season 3 Episode 17 the finale I new about this show in season 3 and I started watching the show in season 4 but I looked on UA-cam to look at his performances & with those performances he should have won Season 6 Episode 9 Group A Semi-Final Pepper should have moved on to the next round and in my opinion she in 2nd of my ranking of season 6 1st is bull so skunk should have lost that episode Season 5 Episode 11 Semi-Finals Yeti Is my favorite of season 5 he definitely deserved to move on and chameleon should have gone home in the semi-finals
Tbh I agree with the results in the Super Six in Season 4.
I think Crocodile did better than Seahorse.
While I wanted Jellyfish to win, I expected Mushroom would.
And Sun vs Popcorn was really hard because they both had really strong performances but I think Sun deserved to win.
The only episode that still to this day really rubs me the wrong way was the Battle of the Sixes in Season 3.
I think Turtle and Astronaut were the two best of the night, so I don't understand how Astro got sent home. I would've picked Kitty or Rhino to go just based off those performances honestly.
Miss monster deffo picked the wrong song for her week but Gronk still should have gone.
With seahorse and crocodile:
A: REALLY bad song choice for the seahorse, did not like her singing bruno mars at all and B: she talked about she needs to do choreo and i'm 'didn't you not do at least SOME choreo during the rihanna and britney numbers, it's not like you just stood there"
The most robbed character in season 1-7
Season 1-Lion
Season 2-Butterfly
Season 3-Turtle
Season 4-Seahorse
Season 5-Russian Dolls/Yeti
Season 6-Bull
Season 7-Ringmaster
I thought that most of my favorite contestants from seasons 1 through 5 were robbed and should've had stayed in the competition longer.
Kitty 🐈
Butterfly 🦋
Poodle 🐩
Unicorn 🦄
Ladybug 🐞
White tiger 🐅
Bear 🐨🐻
Popcorn 🍿
Baby 👽
Lips 👄
Squiggly monster 👹
Snow ❄️ owls🦉
Jellyfish
Seashell🐚
And Russian dolls 🪆
finale should have been
3-Crocodile
2-Seahorse/Sun
1-Sun/Seahorse
but they jacked up the format
@Charlie Lie once they got top 6 it should have been everyone for themselves there was almost no point of the “one person from each group makes finale”
Personally I think kitty left at the right time since I thought rhino did incredible in the top 4. I think your opinion on butterfly that episode is spot on. I’ve always thought he stayed just so they didn’t piss Nicole off. The Russian dolls being eliminated was bullshit, I think chameleon or piglet should’ve left there, the episode banana left I thought was surprising.
The super 6 of season 4 is still one of the most flawed episodes in masked singer history. The whole set up just didn’t make any sense. Why pin the last two from each group against each other instead of having all 6 fight against each other? We all wanted to see sun and seahorse go at it and we never did. Plus putting seahorse and crocodile together was BS since they both deserved a spot in the finals. Jellyfish losing to mushroom is seriously unbelievable. She was way better than him that night and I don’t get why she went home over him.
I agree with you she should have stayed in the competition and mushroom should have been eliminated instead
Personally I don't think thingamajig went through just to please nicole because to sing caught up in such a clean way that he did is NOT easy, trust me i've tried and i can only just pull it off.
My rankings of the performances on these episodes
Group A Finals (Season 3)
4. White Tiger - really bad
3. Miss Monster - decent [OUT]
2. Kangaroo - really good
1. Turtle - really good
Quarterfinals (Season 5)
5. Chameleon - pretty good
4. Piglet - pretty good
3. Black Swan - pretty good
2. Russian Dolls - really good [OUT]
1. Yeti - amazing
Quarterfinals (Season 3)
5. Frog - pretty good
4. Rhino - pretty good
3. Night Angel - really good
2. Kitty - really good [OUT]
1. Turtle - amazing
Faceoffs Part 2 (Season 2)
4. Thingamajig - pretty good
3. Butterfly - amazing [OUT]
2. Fox - amazing
1. Tree - amazing
Faceoffs Part 2 (Season 3)
4. Frog - pretty good
3. Rhino - pretty good
2. Banana - really good [OUT]
1. Kitty - amazing
Super Six (Season 4)
6. Jellyfish - pretty good
5. Popcorn - really good
4. Mushroom - really good
3. Crocodile - amazing
2. Seahorse - amazing
1. Sun - incredible
The Super Six just had a messed up format. Crocodile and Seahorse both deserved to be finalists along with Sun. Jellyfish, Popcorn and Mushroom deserved to go home.
Yeah probably agree broccoli or squiggly monster to group b crocodile to group c
Yeah they should have just eliminated them one by on on separate episodes like season 5
I don’t agree with that but I respect personally I agree with jellyfish leaving because she didn’t really know what note to hit at different times and it came apart and her performances were messy.
Then I think seahorse deserved that loss as that episode she gave her worst performance and crocodile gave one of his best and he was more of a fan favorite and one of the first powerful rock vocals
Next I believe sun should’ve lost instead of popcorn I admit sun was way better but older singers aren’t appreciated but popcorn had a seasoned more raspy voice and it was perfect and sun just had a normal voice that you hear from country singers and you never hear anything like Taylor’s beautiful voice
Yes!!
I agree
My ranking:
6. Episode 8 (Season 3) Astronaut had left
5. Episode 4 (Season 5) Crab had left
4. Episode 15 (Season 3) Frog had left
3. Episode 9 (Season 2) Butterfly had to won the face-off against Fox and the smackdown against Thing
2. Episode 10 (Season 4) Seahorse and Popcorn had stayed
1. Episode 12 (Season 2) Flamingo had won, Rottweiler second and Fox third
I totally agree with you she should have won Rottweiler runner-up and fox third
The most messed up in each season:
Season 1 Finale (Season 1 didn't really have any, but I picked this one simply because I thought Peacock should've won, but I'm ok with Monster winning)
Season 2 Ep9 (I honestly think Tree should've gone home because I thought her performance was boring and she didn't have the best voice, and Butterfly should've won the smackdown, though Fox was still good)
Season 3 Ep12 (I thought the exact opposite of this episode should've happened. Frog's first 4 performances were great, but this one was the weakest of the night. Kitty was the strongest, so I have no idea how Frog won. Banana also should've won because his was more powerful and Rhino's was boring. Honestly, Frog should've gone home.)
Season 4 Semifinals (This one is weird because I actually agree with all the results, but the biggest problem was the format. It limited the options so much and it wasn't as much on who are the best 3, and more on which of the 2 are better.)
Season 5 Semifinals (I was shocked when Yeti went home. I thought for sure he would make it to the finals, and Chameleon really should've gone home. He should've gone home in the top 8, but he made it all the way, and while he was far from bad, he just did the same thing every week, while everyone else kept doing something different.)
Season 6 Premiere (I know I'll get attacked for saying this, but Pufferfish should've left first because I thought she was the weakest of the night. But I'm not that bothered by it, and I was fine with all the other episodes so I said this one.)
Season 7 Finale (The only one I didn't think should've been in the finale won. It was all because of the song choice, but I think Prince did better than her, and Ringmaster should've taken home the trophy. And Thingamabob should've been there instead of Firefly.)
Seahorse should’ve been at least 2nd!!!
nah
Although Crocodile has an amazing performance, seahorse should’ve stayed considering all of her performances were excellent
2:29 I think the perfect finale would have been Snow Owls, Jellyfish, and Serpent
Here's mine
6. Miss Monster. How the hell did WT win?
5. Orca. I know people like Seashell, but I thought her performance was weak that round
4. Rhino. Frog was really weak that night but I'm not surprised that he made it through over my beloved Rhino
3. Butterfly. I still think she should've been in the smackdown cause Fox is in my opinion the best Masked Singer of all time so yeah. But she should've beat Thing in the Smackdown
2. Serpent. I can't say much about this cause both Seahorse and Croc are amazing. I just wish he was in a different group. Or it was a Super 7 instead
1. Snail. THEY DID KERMIT DIRTY SENDING HIM HOME BEFORE THAT THING
How did they send off busta first
No No No Mushroom didn’t rob Jellyfish Mushroom was better besides Jellyfish robbed him in the Group C Finals Mushroom got his payback on Jellyfish!
Season 3-Final 5
Season 5-Feisty 5
He took the season four super six out of my head. I do agree. Seahorse should’ve won and so should jellyfish
I 100% agree with all of these choices, especially the season 4 semifinals. Jellyfish did better then mushroom, sun did beat popcorn, and seahorse should've won over crocodile.
SEASON 4 GROUP B FINALS
WHY WWWWHHHHYYYY
SERPENT WAS BEST OF THE SEASON
Here are my top 6
6. Season 1 finale This was a bit confusing overall in the finale I thought peacock should’ve won over monster.
5. Season 4 super 6
This was a shocker for all with seahorses battle she should’ve beat crocodile with mushrooms battle his performance was strong and deserved the win and popcorn should’ve been eliminated much sooner.
4. Season 2 finale this was a shocker for me due to Rottweiler having the best performance of the night I thought he would totally win over fox but I guess I was wrong.
3. Season 2 final 7 I totally believe butterfly was robbed and this episode was rigged thingamajig had the weaker performance.
2. Season 5 finale I can’t believe that chameleon made the finale he shouldn’t have I think it should’ve been robopine vs black swan vs piglet not chameleon. And I also believe black swan had the stronger performance overall while piglets was his best of the whole season.
1. Season 7 episode 1
This episode was filed with so many twists and turns firstly we had someone’s mask falls off and then somebody else being so scared they had to stop in the middle of the performance. I also believe that the elimination was unfair aswell.
Thanks just my opinion
6. Season 5 Episode 9 Russian Doll, (I was really shocked and disappointed to see them go home. I thought for sure chameleon was going home but I wanted piglet to go home. I really think they should’ve stayed til the finale and shouldn’t have gone home)
5. Season 2 Episode 10 Flamingo (I was really disappointed when she went home at third. I personally think she should’ve won. Every performance she gave was flawless and amazing! And she really didn’t want to take the mask off. She delivered in that finale performance and should not have gone home at third)
4. Season 4 Episode 10 Jellyfish and Seahorse (I was extremely disappointed and shocked when Seahorse and Jellyfish went home. Jellyfish was amazing and her last performance was so beautiful. Mushroom was alright but nowhere near as good as jellyfish, and for seahorse, she should’ve have defeated Crocodile 100%. She was so good every week and the finale with her would’ve been amazing)
3. Season 3 Episode 10 Kangaroo, (I think this whole episode was just messed up. In the fight of Kangaroo and Night angel, Kangaroo should’ve won. She was amazing and her voice doesn’t get enough credit. I think the smack down should’ve been Night angel and Astronaut and I think Astronaut should’ve gone home that night. Kangaroo did not deserve her place and I’m really upset she went home when she should’ve been In the finale with turtle and Night angel)
2. Season 1 Episode 9 Lion (This episode was really messed up. I think that Lion was the best out of this season and that she did not need to go home. I think that the first person that should’ve gone home was peacock then rabbit. Lion did not deserve her place at all and should’ve won season 1)
1. Season 5 finale Black Swan (She should’ve won plain and simple. She delivered every single week with her great voice and stage presentation. Piglet was a great singer and all but when it comes to it Black Swan should’ve won. The finale performances were all great but she was the best. Every performance from her was flawless and I love her so much. She was a natural on the stage and when she came in second place I was so disappointed. She was robbed big time and I wish that she could have won that)
I was actually the opposite with banana and rhino, I found banana boring and I connected so much with Rhino. I just felt like the way banana sang 'Knockin on heaven's door' promised a lot of impact but then when it hit his voice kinda didn't really change and then the ending where he just runs on top of the piano and doesn't really do much else except shout to the audience felt like a let down to me. But 100% frog had his worst performance that week and should have been in the smackdown.
i dont think kitty chose the wrong song i thought it was her best performance i think FROG should have gone home (not kermit)
I also loved her song choice! I don’t think it was her best performance, but I still loved it and I have no idea how she lost!
@@dancingseahorse Ya her song choise was good and the reason why Banana lost to Rhino I liked Banana better but Rhinoceros choose a way more popular then Bananas
To those who think the only reason thingamajig won because of nicole, like how. New people come in each masked singer episode and don't know about anything before. Their only hint of the relationship was his earlier performance. Still thingamajig's voice still sounded pretty good and he was entertaining which might have been the reason he won the smackdown. Altough I still prefer butterfly's performance though.
Personally, I don’t think anyone on this list chose the wrong song. Some of the song aren’t songs I was expecting, but I still think they were great song choices!
WHO THOUGHT IT WAS A GOOD IDEA TO ELIMINATE HALF THE COMPITETION IN ONE EPISODE?!
I love White Tiger!
i hated the episode in season 3 when kangaroo went off, i loved her, she was so good
I feel the same. I cant watch that episode anymore because it was so hard to see her go down and the way they sent her off was awful.
Well it is your opinion. I really wanted her to go to the end. She was going to do more upbeat songs and choreography too.
@@houldinthehouse5304 banana should have gone off
@@houldinthehouse5304 yah, she should have been 3rd or 4th
All I can say is that super six season 4 should have only one person leaving and it would be popcorn or jellyfish my opinion also jellyfish ruined the group performance so I kind of understand why she left also I think mushroom was better
There was no way seahorse was beating crocodile in the smackdown that week
Honestly. Back to black was the ONLY performance of Kitty's that I just did not like, i feel like back to black the original version is good but it doesn't really carry that much impact with it. There's a version done by Allie Sherlock that Strictly Come Dancing may have pinched and tweaked a bit for Angela Scanlon to use for her Argentine Tango but that part is irrelevant here. If she had done that specific arrangement which had extra drumbeats and strong powerful backing instruments, 100 percent she would have gone through. I actually thought 'You've lost that lovin' feeling' was one of Rhino's best so I was not gutted with that result at all.
super 6 season 4 I was kind of upset seahorse lost but after a while I felt fine I think 4th is still good
Same
Same
Same
Am I the only one who thinks rhino and chameleon deserved making it far.
I think Rhino not Chameleon
1. 🇺🇸 Season 5 - 10
Russian dolls are the best and really robbed
2. 🇩🇪 Season 4 - final
Leopard was the best and was really robbed!
3. 🇳🇿 Season 1 - Super 6
Jelly was the best and got so robbed!
I agree!
I completely agree with the 3rd 1
I was screaming ELIMINATE THE F**KING TUATRA all the way through
I agree with Seahorse vs Crocodile
Dancing seahorse I agree that miss monster deserve to be in super 9 and that kitty deserve to be in final 4 but I disagree see the format of season 4 in the super six was rigged like the triple elimination was stupid and if it wasn't a triple Crocodile seahorse and sun deserve to make it to the finale
Mrs monster deserved elimination
I absolutely agree with all of your choices! I also feel like Season 5 Ep 7 (Super 8) could’ve been on the list as well; I had a feeling that Crab was going home that episode, even though his performance was really good, but Seashell going was what shocked me the most & it’s what the panelists said that also annoys me, why do they say in several episodes, that the contestant’s performance was their best yet they get eliminated?! If I had to choose who should’ve gone instead, if it was me during the season, I’d say Chameleon, but after summarising the whole season, I actually think Robopine should’ve gone instead, he wasn’t bad that episode, but that performance imo wasn’t his best & during the Spicy 6, I knew for sure he was going.
Nah I thought seashell was super underwhelming the entire competition. I never really cared for any of her performances
I don’t believe seahorse was robbed so here is my opinion on what the elimination order should have been for season 4
16. Lips
15. Dragon
14. Gremlin
13. Broccoli
12. Baby Alien
11. Squiggly Monster
10. Giraffe
9. Snow Owls
8. Serpent
7. Whatchamacallit
6. Jellyfish
5. Seahorse
4. Sun
3. Crocodile
2. Popcorn
1. Mushroom
I finally found someone who thinks Sun shouldn't have won! And I agree with the list except in my opinion Snow Owls would be a bit higher
Probably for me, with reasonings:
6. S3 F6 (should’ve been Rhino, Astronaut had one of his strongest performances)
5. S3 F5 (should’ve been Rhino, Kitty wasn’t as strong but solid)
4. S5 F5 (should’ve been Black Swan, she fucked herself over hard and finale format saved her ass, this round is weird since Black Swan was the worse and Piglet 2nd worse, Chameleon 3rd, Russian Dolls 2nd and Yeti was performance of the night)
3. S4 F10 (should’ve been Popcorn, Snow Owls were much better, but Sun was outdoing both competitors so it’d just be a placement swap if anything)
2. S3 F3 (Turtle should’ve won, the old way of winners being determined and this “female winner” agenda screwed him over)
1. S6 F2 (mainly since Bull was hyped up all season to be this powerhouse, which he was, and was the strongest at the finale with his best performance in Invisible though Straight Up is very close, then QoH won when she didn’t have her best performance, she should’ve saved Sia, as that was her best performance, in the end she pulled a Seahorse/Black Swan/Pepper and I think the background and the rumor that she could’ve won due to her album dropping is what saved her from 2nd. Ik some might claim peeps hate the female winners just because they outdid a talented male, which isn’t true, Piglet got a lot of shit, Crocodile especially got a lot of shit for the shitty format, while Sun didn’t get any hate. QoH wasn’t as strong which sucks cuz she’s the best female vocalist of the cast)
If you somebody else likes Season 2 , you may like Wayne Brady as a heartthrob with the best vocal and comparing the same voices like Jamie Foxx. You’re luckily that he didn’t mentioned miss the notes from the lyrics.
Also I truly believe the only reason Nick Lachey won is because he’s a judge on Alter Ego
For season 3. My top 5 ones
Ep 2 white tiger should’ve gone out
Ep 6 rhino should have gone out
Finale turtle should’ve won and night angel and frog didn’t deserve to make it into the finals
Ep 15 rhino should’ve gone home besides turtles performance she was the best one
Ep 14 I hated g this episode Astronaut was the best masked singer imo and rhino should’ve gone home in this episode and earlier in the competition like 10th place
I didn't want Frog to be in the smackdown. Frog was MUCH better than Kitty
the smack down where banana was sent home i think the format was jacked up and rhino and banana should have been in the smackdown
The most bulls**t episode of each season
Season 1 semi finals: Ok I thing rabbit should have kept going to the finals his performance was strong and I’ll say it the people going home should have been Lion and bee
Season 2:Semi finals/Round two face offs:Both of these were bs for the semi finals Thingamajig and leopard should have gone the final with Rottweiler For the round two face off tree should have gone I don’t like her voice and butterfly should have kept going sadly I would have her leave in the semifinals
Season 3 Super 6:Ok I personally think that frog should have gone in the smack down sadly but this round it should have been kitty I’m sorry that’s just my opinion he had a great performance.
Season 4 Group C finals-(side note I thing the super 6 Should have been crocodile and serpent and sun and dragon) ok I think jellyfish should have gone here she was the weakest from the night and I think broccoli and mushroom should have kept going
Season 5 semifinal-Yeti should have won the season plain and simple
Season 6:Group b Semifinals-Ok I don’t like queen of hearts I think she should have gone first and I think mallard should have been in second place
Season 7 Finale-Prince should have won I really like ringmaster and thingamabob should have been there but prince is just the best to me
2:31 I thought popcorn should've won
I wanted popcorn to stay too but I like sun performance too so I think popcorn and sun to make to the finale and I liked crocodile performance too so I think the finale should be popcorn crocodile and sun
Finally, a person who thinks Popcorn had to win this season
@@yolandamaqueda9289 Lol
I agree with you 💯 percent
Litarally she has all
S3 super 6 was the most disappointing for me, Astronaut had one of his best performances there and rhino stayed? Bruh
I agree with all of them except for your number 3 and number 1. I think Fox still should’ve won again Butterfly, but I do agree that Thing should have been eliminated. And then your number 1, I agree with it all except for Mushroom vs Jellyfish. I thought that Valerie was his strongest performance. Overall I though it was disappointing that they elongated 3 people.
Finally someone who agrees with me
Seahorse was not robbed, kitty was not very good, butterfly should have gone in a different face off episode
For the super six, I blame the format for sending a legend like seahorse home. In the other seasons, there weren’t face offs which made the competition less difficult to send someone home. If there weren’t faceoffs I think crocodile and seahorse could fight sun in the finale
I agree with all of these
instead of thingamajig i think tree should have gone.
You mean instead of tree thingamajig should’ve gone home?
@Kwame Winwah but tree was out instead of thingamajig
@Kwame Winwah oh ok thank you
@@jaydi3175 sorry if my sentence was off.
@@ratedkrt2010 it’s fine I was just confused
I think for season 3 episode 3 I didn’t like miss monster monster performance but I did want her to be in the super 8 and I didn’t like white tiger performance season 5 episode 11 i liked everybody’s performance in the feisty five season 3 episode 13 I liked rhino performance and banana and I liked kitty performance and I didn’t like the frog performance because frog forgot a word in the song season 4 episode 10 I like crocodile performance it was my favorite performance on season 4 I liked mushroom performance it was very fun and sun performance was awesome and emotional season 2 episode 9 face off round 2 I wanted butterfly to stay I like her performance I liked tree’s performance I was amazing and thingamajig performance I liked it too it was fun and wanted fox to leave season 3 episode 15 I didn’t like kitty performance It was the weakest performance on that night and I think rhino performance was better than the kitty’s
Am I the only one who liked both Rhino and Thingamajig I thought they deserved to make it where they did
Thingamajig was good but rhino eh 4th over hunter and Jackie? No he wasn’t that good maybe over kandi though
@@brandonbennett8368 yeah I definitely don’t think he was better than both Astronaut and Kitty and I definitely would say a little better than Night Angel
For some reason there’s always 1 girl in the finale so far 😐 (Bee, Flamingo, Night Angel, Sun & Black Swan)
That’s true! I think in Season 3 & 4, Kitty and Seahorse should’ve been in the finale.
Thats because the correct people have made it to the finale each time. Gender should not effect the performance level of the competitiors because even though they are obvious what gender they are, technically it's an anonymous performance, so gender has little to no effect on here
Imo The episode with the worst results was Season 3 Super 6
Quit complaining about seahorse losing
No one asked
Girs
I think Tree should’ve left when Butterfly left
Chu get
Disagree on some here Miss monster was not good even though white tiger should go it wasn’t a complete Rob and seahorse deserved to go home over crocodile her song choice was shaky and his was one of the best on this entire series only issue is the match up jellyfish also shouldn’t be in the finals she was good but no where near the top three worthy
Season 3 finale should be on the list night angel had no business even in the finale should of left over astronaut in the top 6 turtle was far and away the best
night angel had all her business being in the finale her and turtle where the clear finalists after kitty and astro where gone they both had their best performances in the finale (as they should) and THAT finale came down to personally preference and it seems like the crowd that night liked night angel better
@@elfranciscob nah night angel had a million bad performances respectively Final should of been 1st turtle 2nd kitty 3rd frog
@@brandonbennett8368 I completely agree! Man I feel like a woman and Black Velvet were aweful
@@brandonbennett8368 well i agree with kitty being in the finale i’ll give you that but rlly dude night angel was good it’s just become a “common” thing to hate her because she won against turtle and i don’t rlly mean to stereotype but so many turtle, piglet, and croc fans are really toxic and you guys ruin the show :/ it’s celebrity’s singing in halloween costumes no need to be saying people suck
edit: sorry this is a month later i didn’t get a notification
Mine
Season 3:miss monster shouldve gone to the next round
Season 4:seahorse she should've been 2nd
Season 1:bee should've been 2nd instead of 3td
Season 3:kitty should've been 3rd or 2nd instead of 5th and frog or rhino should've left
Season 5:russian dolls should've been 3rd or 2nd instead of 5th chameleon should've left this episode
Here's mine and feel free to disagree if you don't like it
Season 3 miss monster correct elimination decision
Season 4 seahorse also correct elimination decision
Season 1 bee right decision
Season 3 kitty I agree with you
Season 5 Russian dolls I actually agree with you on that one as well.
My poor Jellyfish was robbed during the supa 6. Mushroom does have talent, but Chloe Kim's performance was without a doubt the better one. And very emotional to boot
Ummmmmmm No Mushroom was better imo
Mine
Season 2 Episode 9 Faceoffs Round 2
In this round Both Thingamajig & butterfly both deserved to continue in the competition & tree should have gone home this episode
Season 4 Episode 10 Super 6
In this episode Crocodile & sun both deserved to move on to the finale but Jellyfish should have moved on too & mushroom should Have Gone
Home in this episode
Season 3 Episode 17 the finale
I new about this show in season 3 and I started watching the show in season 4 but I looked on UA-cam to look at his performances & with those performances he should have won
Season 6 Episode 9 Group A Semi-Final
Pepper should have moved on to the next round and in my opinion she in 2nd of my ranking of season 6 1st is bull so skunk should have lost that episode
Season 5 Episode 11 Semi-Finals
Yeti Is my favorite of season 5 he definitely deserved to move on and chameleon should have gone home in the semi-finals
🇬🇧season 1 semifinal fox should've replaced octopus in the final
🇬🇧season 2 final 7 sausage should've gone not blob