JP3 Spinosaurus vs Accurate Spinosaurus | Jurassic Park vs Science

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 286

  • @Goji-C
    @Goji-C Рік тому +94

    The most unstoppable force in the Mesozoic era vs the immovable object of the JP franchise

  • @ryanhau1073
    @ryanhau1073 Рік тому +46

    An interesting note about Bite Force. Generally Spinosaurs have a Crocodilian-Like Head, in fact the speculation that Spinosaurs primarily ate Fish and may have been Aquatic came from their Croc-Like Features. Anyhow, a contender for the Strongest Bite Force of Modern Day Animals are Crocodiles, and due to the similar Skull, A Spinosaurus Bite Force may come no where near a Tyrannosaurus but it probably did greatly exceeds most Modern Animals

    • @swolecapybara
      @swolecapybara Рік тому +3

      I think you’re right. If I’m not wrong, the only modern bite force stronger than today’s crocodiles is that of the great white shark.

    • @NikkiBestGirl
      @NikkiBestGirl Рік тому +3

      Spinosaurus and co. had garhial like skulls the were meant for catching fish

    • @creativescreenname2750
      @creativescreenname2750 Рік тому +1

      We know they had comparatively weak bite force because their skull was too fragile to handle the stress forces

    • @kachanekusmitse8000
      @kachanekusmitse8000 7 місяців тому

      ​@@NikkiBestGirl *Tomistoma skull*

    • @Rodanguyy
      @Rodanguyy 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@creativescreenname2750 but don't they have dense bones so how are their skulls fragile

  • @Distix-uz8qr
    @Distix-uz8qr Рік тому +212

    Hydrogen bomb vs coughing baby

  • @Rimeaper
    @Rimeaper Рік тому +83

    I like how the other therapods like spino and giga are a lot stronger than their real counterparts and the rex isn't

    • @mechwarrior13
      @mechwarrior13 Рік тому +15

      Rex was og, before they realized larger dinos would actually attract more audience irl (kinda like in JW haha)

    • @pierre-samuelroux9364
      @pierre-samuelroux9364 Рік тому +7

      ​@@mechwarrior13when spino and giga actually smaller irl:

    • @Flufux
      @Flufux Рік тому +4

      The dilophosaurus would probably be in the same boat on that though

    • @the_blue_jay_raptor
      @the_blue_jay_raptor Рік тому

      Theropod*

    • @arnavtripathy2227
      @arnavtripathy2227 Рік тому +3

      The JP3 Rex can be argued to be more powerful seeing as how they constantly get thrown around and gets back up pretty easily and without much injury

  • @zakan4898
    @zakan4898 Рік тому +36

    I know that it was stated by the creatores but i find funny that the rex killed by spino was called juvenille just after the rage of the fans after JPIII but in movie they literaly used the adult trex animatronic from JPII XD

  • @seanledden4397
    @seanledden4397 Рік тому +20

    The JP III Rex-Spino fight was really bungled. They were so desperate to promote the Spino as the new Super Bad Guy that they put the fight early in the movie, and made it a quick knockout. A fight between two giant therapods was the one big novelty in that movie. They should have teased a confrontation early in the movie, but saved it for the last act. And then, it should have been longer and more dramatic.

    • @TheOverseerDebates
      @TheOverseerDebates  Рік тому +12

      That likely would've been better, but they had the spino lay out the rex immediately to set him up as a dangerous antagonist. Plus it didn't help that the rex animatronic got broken which I'm pretty sure cut the fight even shorter

  • @dracone4370
    @dracone4370 Рік тому +30

    Clint's Reptiles put out a video near the end of last month talking about all the members of the Spinosaur family, it might be a good idea to check that out as a companion to this video; also, there are some things said in this video that are a bit different than what was said in that video, but this is ironically in line with our knowledge of Spinosaurids. The fragmentary knowledge we have of their physiology and features means there will be a lot of conflicting data and ideas regarding the members of the family.

  • @Chronoic
    @Chronoic Рік тому +45

    in 10 years Spino will have Wings.

    • @GF-mf7ml
      @GF-mf7ml Рік тому +4

      It turn into birds

    • @daviddimitrov3696
      @daviddimitrov3696 6 місяців тому +2

      Accurate 💀💀💀

    • @Fort_cisken_guy
      @Fort_cisken_guy Місяць тому

      He's probably meaning in 10 years spino is dead probably doesn't have a halo for murder of the rex and others

    • @Skibidiohio-c2d7
      @Skibidiohio-c2d7 Місяць тому

      *s p i n o w i l l b r e a t h f i r e*
      -288

  • @selfiekroos1777
    @selfiekroos1777 Рік тому +24

    "A younger TRex"
    They used the Bull Rex animatronic from JP2, which was as big as Rexy

    • @classicgalactica5879
      @classicgalactica5879 Рік тому +7

      Malarkey. The JPIII T. Rex was 37 feet in length. Rexy was around 44 feet in length. The Buck and Doe were each approximately 42 feet in length. The T. Rex in JPIII was a dwarf compared to the other adult T. Rex's in the franchise.

    • @anandboddu4566
      @anandboddu4566 8 місяців тому

      Yeah,the rex in JP-3 was definitely smaller than any other rex in the franchise.

    • @Rodanguyy
      @Rodanguyy 6 місяців тому

      Bruh if they use the same animatronic it doesn't mean that in the movie it's not a younger rex that's like sayin that because old godzilla movies were people in godzilla suits in the actual movie godzilla is just a man in a suit also spino got slammed by big eatie keep crying

    • @VBandanna-yv7oc
      @VBandanna-yv7oc 13 днів тому

      ​Spino killed big eatie i just watched the episode the full fight is on UA-cam keep sprouting nonsense 😂​@@Rodanguyy

  • @kevgamer12
    @kevgamer12 Рік тому +10

    Fun fact : Jurassic park creator was actually an active T-rex hater hints why as soon as spino was created, the creator immediately attempted to replace the T-rex with the spino as the apex dinosaur which immediately backfired due to the 4th movie taking longer to release.
    As far as accuracy....realistically there is no carnivorous dinosaur that can beat a T-rex more times than not. The only way a spino would win against a rex is in the water.

    • @abdullahalbadaani4922
      @abdullahalbadaani4922 23 дні тому

      In the jp3 movie the spino was not like the spino we know now, and your argument to defend back the lost of the T-Rex is insane 😂 a T-Rex hater? 😂 There is no way this is your argument and can't just accept spino is stronger. And ofc the apex was replaced I don't want to see T-Rex as the apex lredator in every movie that's going to be boring and I think a lot of people share the same opinion as mine.

  • @maestro-zq8gu
    @maestro-zq8gu Рік тому +7

    I think the real spinosaurus was evolutionarily doomed because it only could survive as an ambush predator in a swamp.

  • @DYXAnims
    @DYXAnims Рік тому +7

    Definition of Coughing Baby vs Hydrogen Bomb

  • @paolopasaol9700
    @paolopasaol9700 Рік тому +3

    8:19 Never thought my reddit image post would make it on a YT vid 😂.

  • @UltimateYoutuber999
    @UltimateYoutuber999 Рік тому +19

    "snock's durability was too high for a real life creature to challenge" argentinosaurus: am i a joke to you?🦕💀💀

  • @Unbearable_Truth
    @Unbearable_Truth Рік тому +30

    Pretty accurate video though there are a few things I feel you forgot to mention that are important.
    *For the Jurassic Park Spinosaurus:*
    - During the start of JP3, the Spino was shot by Cooper's Einhorn 20mm Rifle, which destroyed a plane with one shot. We hear the Spino roaring during those shots yet we see it had no damage done to it. This durability easily exceeds anything we've seen in the Jurassic franchise.
    - Stamina. After the gun assault, Spino got clipped by the charging plane the proceeded to destroy it. Shortly after that it followed the group and fought an Adult Tyrannosaurus quickly dispatching it within minutes. All this takes places with 20 minutes.
    This is insane stamina. Easily the best in the franchise.
    - Intelligence. Spino was written on the script to be highly adaptable and aware. We saw some of this transpire in the movie. It quickly snapped the Bulls neck and ducked under the plane after Amanda screamed. That's high intelligence.
    - Spino withstood getting burned alive for a good minute before retreating during the boat sequence. This just shows how high its pain tolerance is.
    - During the events of Camp Cretaceous, Spinosaurus had been bitten by Big Eatie abruptly 5 times. No visible damage seen. Another showcase of insane durability and thick hide.
    P.S. The metal fence wasn't rusted and towards the far right during that scene, you'll see the rest of the fence reaction to that power burst.
    *Now for the "paleo accurate" Spinosaurus:*
    - There is evidence of a Carcharadontosaurus vertebra that had a Spinosaurus tooth embedded in. The fossil specimen was sold under a private collector but images of it still are accessible. This is evidence that such fights did break out.
    - The largest Spinosaurus specimen is a humerus called NMC 41852 that is over 50% greater than the neotype. Scaling it up from the model given by Ibrahim et al. 2020 and using the densities provided by Larramendi et al. 2020 with the disparity in size SpinoInWonderland (a paleoartist) got with it and the neotype it would have been around ~16.65 meters long and weighed around ~14,340kg.
    It possibly represents the largest known theropod and largest predatory animal capable of locomotion on land, only rivaled by Deinosuchus hatcheri.

    • @classicgalactica5879
      @classicgalactica5879 Рік тому

      For the Jurassic Park Spinosaurus, watch a video called Jack Horner on Spinosaurus. It should clear things up for you.

    • @GODEYE270115
      @GODEYE270115 Рік тому +5

      -we heard shots but never saw spino get shot, in fact there was no visible wounds to imply it either. How did spino get damaged by a plane clipping it but no wound from a 20mm rifle that could destroy planes? Make it make sense
      We heard shots but that’s it, Cooper either shot at another animal or missed(there’s even rumors that there was suppose to be a baby spino scene, where cooper shoots it and the adult gets mad. And with the crappy production JP3 had, I wouldn’t doubt that was the original idea for that scene)
      -I-Rex fought an ankosaur, a team of soldiers, killed dozens of sauropods, got shot at by helicopter and rockets, fought a Rex and a raptor pack(and was willing to keep going) and brought down a whole park. all within the same day. So no spino doesn’t have the best stamina. Not even close
      -the neck snap is the smartest thing it did. And we can argue Giga using its tail to sense the ledge and turning around mid fight to use it or going for rexy’s legs, in the final battle, to keep her off balance is equally smart. Nothing stands out, spino didn’t even duck the plane on purpose, it ducked to reach cooper. You’re reaching here
      -it didn’t get engulfed by the flames, it got a little bit on its leg and ran off scared
      Giga literally ate fire and didn’t give up til it got an eye blown out by the taser(and If you see the final fight. You can see Giga’s eye is damaged. It manhandled rexy while handicapped) That seems more resilient to me
      You spino fanboys always trying to hype it up to the sun lmfao
      It never did anything showing high intelligence, heck it never even did anything particularly cruel or sadistic. It just ate the humans when it got the chance, I-Rex literally dismembers people, plays with its victims and kills Dinos for sport. That’s cruelty
      And y’all actually believe it could beat Indominus for that matter, with a straight face😭

    • @Unbearable_Truth
      @Unbearable_Truth Рік тому +7

      @@GODEYE270115 Lmao, you seriously still trying to argue against canon material here? How sad are you?
      - Spino got shot and we hear it roaring in distress/anger. That's solidifies it. You saying otherwise is your opinion, which nobody cares for. Yeah... no visible damage on the Spino. That's why its durability is the strongest. Thanks for stating that 20 year + obvious fact lol.
      The plane hit the sail (which is all bone) there is little fleshing there compared to its entire scale like body. Even then, we see the sail quickly healed up within the fight scene.
      Lol rumors are your counter argument? Give a facts. In other words you got nothing. To quote the script "These two come highly recommended. That's right, I found the two best men I could possibly find"
      And yet none of those scale above the Spino. It caused the extinction of Sorna which was far dangerous dinosaurs looking at the list. Rockets? One missile which missed and blast radius effected it. Nothing compared to the 6 explosive shots we hear. This isn't including the other shots we heard before Udesky and Nash retreated. Kentosaurus swing to the face with no damage, several T.rex bites with no damage visible etc meanwhile Indominus struggled with a old Rexy and bleed. The list goes on.
      The neck snap alone is something Indominus couldn't do. The Giga was dumb given how 7 people were able to pass by it and hide behind the car. Let's not forget them climbing the ladder in front of it.
      The Spino ducked to reach Cooper? What? I'm talking about after the crash. Amanda screamed and the Spino ducked. Learn to read.
      The film clearly showed the burst of those flames reaching its face. The next panel shows it engulfed in the fire pushing away the construction bill. You're just yet again deliberately trying to downplay the Spinosaurus because you can't accept the facts.
      Breaking Nash's legs then watching him crawl. Proceeding to stomping on him then biting his head off. Explain that. It's like you're creating your own headcanon for the movie because of how much of a fanboy you are lol.
      Yap yap facts say otherwise given how the database supports it.

    • @diegoquezada3193
      @diegoquezada3193 Рік тому

      @@Unbearable_Truth Btw for the Spino getting hit by the plane feat, in the script it states that the plane actually hit it in the flank and that the propeller got snapped off

    • @Ryanbutcher123
      @Ryanbutcher123 11 місяців тому +1

      @@GODEYE270115 If the I rex was defeated by a very big, scary mosasaurus ( although the angle was less than ideal) with a bite force of about 40,000-50,00 psi then surely the spinosaurus can come close to its durability by being shot by a 20mm rifle with a mere 60,000-61,000 psi (also it is all that pressure in an area of

  • @digitalsoldierxp9027
    @digitalsoldierxp9027 Рік тому +3

    I never get tired of watching JP3 spino videos

  • @ryanhau1073
    @ryanhau1073 Рік тому +9

    I mean do we even have a Paleo Accurate Spinosaurus yet?

    • @anthonybusch4407
      @anthonybusch4407 Рік тому

      If anything, that would be the one from Planet Dinosaur (2011).

    • @Unbearable_Truth
      @Unbearable_Truth Рік тому +6

      The entire premise of Spinosaurus is open for debate. There really isn't a right answer

    • @MikeHawk-00
      @MikeHawk-00 Рік тому +2

      Yes, it’s called Spinofaarus

  • @CannibalisticWendigoGuy
    @CannibalisticWendigoGuy 9 місяців тому +1

    It's like that sibling fight you know like the younger sibling fighting the bigger sibling with martial arts☠️

  • @Spino_blaze
    @Spino_blaze Рік тому +4

    Pov 2040 spinosaurus: Oh spino's sail wasn't a sail.!! It was spino's wing bones.. and yeah it could fly 🕊️

  • @Legendary_Truth
    @Legendary_Truth Рік тому +2

    Real life T rex versus JP rexy? Amazing video btw

  • @arnavtripathy2227
    @arnavtripathy2227 Рік тому +4

    It wasn’t even close to being close

  • @greyideasthetheliopurodon4640

    The thing about Irritator is bit more complicated, the paper which describes Irritators brain also notes how spinosaurus probably had a better sense of sight and also made better use of pressure receptors

  • @Julian.noa21
    @Julian.noa21 Рік тому +4

    Can you do can you do can megaprimatus Kong(king kong 2005) survive in Cretaceous Africa along with spinosaurus, carcharodontosaurus etc or can megaprimatus Kong survive in the hell creek formation or can you do can the indominus rex the one we saw in the movie or a juvenile indominus rex survive in the hell creek formation or the kem Kem beds/formation

  • @Thekingoftherobloxpirates
    @Thekingoftherobloxpirates Рік тому +1

    Nice video

  • @thatpaleodude3769
    @thatpaleodude3769 Рік тому +2

    You should do a video on Barosaurus, I mean its one of the largest animals discovered in the morrosin formation, and just over-all is a very interesting animal

  • @tofuteh2348
    @tofuteh2348 Рік тому +6

    Imo the accurate spinosaurus is a more interesting animal than the JP3 version. It's just so unique and was basically a therapod aquatic leviathan and would've been so cool to see irl

  • @cemilhan725
    @cemilhan725 Рік тому +1

    I do not think that comparing these 2 animals would be fair. One is a real animal that have evolved to fill a niche, and one is a movie character that has made to look cool and fun to watch.

  • @amirram8308
    @amirram8308 Рік тому +1

    Actually the trex was an adult in the Jurassic park 3, which confirmed that the bull was adult not young.

  • @BoneReaperLagiallosaurus
    @BoneReaperLagiallosaurus 11 місяців тому

    You should do Allosaurus next it would be interesting :)
    *Also I wanna see my Allo BOIS in action!*

  • @Magnaraptor1836
    @Magnaraptor1836 Рік тому +1

    I like this video because it directly confronts some of the reasons I loath JPIII. I always have to address the "It's based off what was known at the time" during debates; It wasn't. Practically everything about the JP Spino had no basis in fact. They took advantage of the fact that we didn't know much about Spinosaurus to insert ficticious capabilities that would allow it to not just fight a rex, but beat it. This doesn't surprise me seeing as the paleontologist advising the production team has, for some reason, a strong personal vendetta against T.rex with a history of pissing off the greater paleo community.

    • @Doomguyhunter1
      @Doomguyhunter1 Рік тому +5

      Uhh, you're wrong here. At the time of JP3, spinosaurus was basically thought to be a 60 foot long, 12-23 ton super-baryonyx with a sail on its back. The only thing that was changed about it was a thicker snout, some allosaur-like crests and the typical pronated wrists. Everything else was good for the time. There was basis on the facts of the time, which were what I listed above. Also spinosaurus beating T. rex is a really stupid reason to dislike a movie. That was one scene. There's a lot of bigger problems in JP3 than that.

    • @Magnaraptor1836
      @Magnaraptor1836 Рік тому +1

      @@Doomguyhunter1 I did say SOME of the reasons I don't like JPIII, and "basically thought" is too much credit. Even for what was then known about spinosaurus it doesn't hold up. You also just admitted they went so far as to change even what we DID know about spino at the time to fit what they WANTED spino to be, not what spino actually was. If I had a say in the matter spino wouldn't even have been a character. Too much was unknown to justify putting it into a franchise who's whole things was "This is what dinosaurs were actually like and how they'd interact with us."

    • @Doomguyhunter1
      @Doomguyhunter1 Рік тому +3

      @@Magnaraptor1836 They literally changed three features about it, and even if they didn't change those, it would've had no effect on the movie, except the spino looking slightly different. Three features is a lot less than a lot of other JP designs, like even the pretty accurate T. rex, which's arms were too big, their teeth were too knife-like, their tail was too short, their wrists were pronated, etc.
      And how is basically thought giving too much credit, when they got all the basics right, with some details being wrong?
      And spino being a bit of an enigma at the time is no justification for it not being in JP. One of the great things about the first two movies was that they brought badly known genera into the limelight. Some of those genera are Pachycephalosaurus and Velociraptor for example.

    • @Magnaraptor1836
      @Magnaraptor1836 Рік тому

      @@Doomguyhunter1 "They based it off what was known at the time but actually they changed things we did know at the time." Got the basics right? We didn't even know what the basics were until the the 2010s. It's not a Spinosaurus, it's a movie monster that shares the name and had greatly exaggerated characteristics not at all in-line with what was known.

    • @Doomguyhunter1
      @Doomguyhunter1 Рік тому +1

      @@Magnaraptor1836 And those exaggarated features are a thicker snout, small crests and wrists that are rotated a bit, that's not some gigantic difference. You're acting like they made it a 100 foot long monstrosity that has claws and teeth the size of rhinos or some other ridicolous shit like that, when it three slightly exaggarated or wrong features, THREE.
      And we did "know" the basics at the time, and they were that Spinosaurus was a 60 foot long, 12-23 ton super baryonyx with a sail on its back. That was a very reasonable conclusion for the time, because every at the time discovered spinosaurus looked a lot like a baryonyx. It just turned out those basics were wrong, but we can't blame them for not knowing that over ten years before they were proven wrong.

  • @godzilla44556
    @godzilla44556 2 місяці тому

    This is really giving me the Virgin versus the chat vibes

  • @maozilla9149
    @maozilla9149 Рік тому

    nice keep it up

  • @robb5828
    @robb5828 9 днів тому

    ,, accurate,, is an overstatement when it comes to dinosaurus in general,more so in this particular case where we don't and can't really know much about Spinosaurus.These are only suppositions based on guessing. I know we like the creations of imagination,but reality might have very well been different.

  • @Vader6640
    @Vader6640 Рік тому +5

    Overseer: *Uses European measurements*
    Me: *Confused American Noises*

  • @indzilla1699
    @indzilla1699 7 місяців тому +1

    4 second old infant baby vs Mike Tyson

  • @Fins-Up-74
    @Fins-Up-74 Рік тому +4

    This is... very unfair

  • @MooronaX
    @MooronaX Рік тому

    Great video, but we need a case study about me! (deinosuchus)

  • @Tyrannosaurus_rex.
    @Tyrannosaurus_rex. Рік тому +16

    8.3 tonnes is size of Spinosaurus cf. "aegypticus", the largest size for Spinosaurus. I think 7.7 tonnes would still be a large individual unless you have other information?

    • @NolanDraconis
      @NolanDraconis Рік тому +1

      Yeah, it would be a large adult, if we use the 6.9 ton size as your regular adult.

    • @Unbearable_Truth
      @Unbearable_Truth Рік тому +1

      The largest theoretical size for Spinosaurus would be over 10 tonnes based on who you ask. Serenos model is flawed.

    • @Killerg238
      @Killerg238 Рік тому +2

      @@Unbearable_Truth nope. Biggest spinosaurus was 7.8 tonnes. Sereno model is outdated

    • @Unbearable_Truth
      @Unbearable_Truth Рік тому +1

      @@Killerg238 Those lower end estimates are based off a lower density scaling.

  • @Whaleydavey
    @Whaleydavey 7 місяців тому

    Spinosaurus skeleton looks almost more dragonlike than a lot of Hollywood dragons. If it had wings - it would make a perfect dragon.

  • @Collendune
    @Collendune Рік тому

    Here is an idea for a dinosaur battle. 1920 tyrannosaurus vs 2020 tyrannosaurus. Old vs new.

  • @TBBPretzel
    @TBBPretzel 3 дні тому

    Another thing with the accurate spino the bone density is another reason it was most likely water capable because the density would help with diving
    Another thing is the accurate spinos arms were incredibly strong and would help to defend the spino but i do still think the jp spino would win

  • @PhilipMurphy8Extra
    @PhilipMurphy8Extra Рік тому

    Good video

  • @Lego___91st___Clone
    @Lego___91st___Clone Рік тому +1

    Next episode do a navy seal with an m4 vs a toddler paralysed from the neck down.

  • @Rioluscave
    @Rioluscave Рік тому +1

    Either way, spinosaurus was an awesome dino in Jurassic Park.

  • @jpenir
    @jpenir Рік тому +2

    Spino is cool all being said. Real and JP version.

  • @FieryRed_BE
    @FieryRed_BE Рік тому

    ik this about the spinosaurus but i noticed how the tyrannosaurus‘ neck has that bulk to it. the animatronic from jp3. so we know it’s a young buck

  • @solar-jaymi
    @solar-jaymi 4 місяці тому

    Indom tore through a steel gate, it appears it created two holes in the gate containing toro, and this gate was in better condition than the one spino broke through, despite it being reinforced, it was weakened by rust, which weakenes the steel. It also appears to have slowed the spino down given the fact it couldn't break through the door. And the indom also tore through a steel radio tower. I say those two the indom has shown are more impressive than the spino gate feat.

  • @MistyMountainPath
    @MistyMountainPath Рік тому

    Now I wanna pronounce 'epitome' the way you do just to see ppl's reactions xD

  • @SWag-w1r
    @SWag-w1r Місяць тому

    2045 spinosaurus was species of hummingbird

  • @LuciusVulpes
    @LuciusVulpes 8 місяців тому

    The real spinosaurus was significantly more mundane lol.

  • @joaovictorburgosfernandes6274

    Snappy the neck snapper vs a poor real animal? This is gonna be an interesting video!

  • @daviddimitrov3696
    @daviddimitrov3696 6 місяців тому

    Even though i prefer the more unique accurate spino...this isnt a fight, its an exacution 💀

  • @xenodragon77
    @xenodragon77 Рік тому +10

    Jp spino takes major, major steroids. It'd smack all theropods, both irl and from the other films.
    Might be a controversial statement, but I stand by it.

    • @Unbearable_Truth
      @Unbearable_Truth Рік тому +3

      I support most of what you said here

    • @GODEYE270115
      @GODEYE270115 Рік тому +3

      Prologue giganotosaurs one shotted a prime Rex in record time. Spino would get wrecked

    • @xenodragon77
      @xenodragon77 Рік тому +5

      @@GODEYE270115 the giga did that by twisting the neck of the rex. It's not easy to see due to the lighting and angle, but that's how the rex died. It wasn't the raw power of the bite.
      Giga's actual bite power is weaker than the rex's, as we see the biosyn giga (perfect clone of the prehistoric giga) failing to significantly damage Rexy with its jaws. It had to use its body strength to knockout Rexy with blunt force because it's jaws were so ineffective. Prologue's twisting tactic is functionally the same as what the jp3 spino did, and it is weaker than the cc spino.
      If that's not enough, Colin himself said spino > giga > trex in an interview

    • @GODEYE270115
      @GODEYE270115 Рік тому +1

      @@xenodragon77 Colin also said giga was the “joker” of the series, which in fact it wasn’t. He also said between the big 3, it could go either way. Let’s not mislead anyone here
      The prologue giga snapped the Rex one way or the other, why biosyn giga didn’t do the same is plot armor. Spino got tossed around by a 37ft long Rex and also lost to big eatie(who is substantially smaller than him)
      Prologue and Biosyn giga manhandled their opponents with ease. The species as a whole are top shelf fighters, spino would get wrecked
      Biggest terrestrial predator the world has ever seen > 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @xenodragon77
      @xenodragon77 Рік тому +3

      @@GODEYE270115 that joker statement was a one off thing for marketing. Colin intended the giga to feel that way, and gave it a scar even for that, but botched it. Tho, it's more subjective than anything by nature of the concept
      The "spino=giga=rex" statement doesn't even mean that. He said they are "all apex predators of their era and of their area", meaning they are apexes of their environment, a statement which holds true in the vast majority of contexts. He never said "any of them could beat the other". That statement doesn't disprove spino > giga > rex, especially since it is in the exact same interview.
      The method is important because it requires the giga to have a bigger strength advantage and twist the neck to far to work, as opposed to just chomping through. Biosyn giga not using that is because it doesn't know that strategy.
      The spino is taller, stronger, heavier, more durable, and more flexible than a rex, and has functional arms. That tactic would be far harder to use if not blatantly fail
      Spino wasn't really tossed around in jp3. Bull pushed spino down from the side, but couldn't hold it down or make it lose its footing, so he pulls the spino around, however he struggles to do so and the spino breaks free. Bull rammed the spino and it just stumbled back a foot. When spino grabs Bull, the fight ends immediately.
      If you take the jp3 size charts as fact, the spino was also small back then, so "small rex" doesn't work cause the spino was small as well and it'd just upscale the big cc spino. If you don't, then Bull would be the size of Buck and spino would be a bit bigger.
      As for CC, the spino was mind controlled and being forced to fight a lot after being locked in a desert for awhile. Not much food, not much water, and skill/experience are gone because of mind control. Which, even then, spino still won when they actually fought. 1 bite was able to down Big Eatie. The only reason she didn't go down sooner was human skill issue stopping the spino from landing a decent hit. The combined efforts of Big Eatie, Little Eatie, Pierce, and the raptor's couldn't even get through the spino's skin. It just kept tanking.
      Where the giga needed to twist the rex's neck, the spino actually had the jaw power to take a rex down with biteforce alone. Combine this with useful arms and the spino being much more durable, and giga is not winning.

  • @ukan1527
    @ukan1527 Рік тому +5

    Personally, I don't really buy into the whole "the JP3 rex is a juvenile" thing everyone seems to be taking for granted. No, it wasn't a young animal and it was never meant to be one, they used the exact same practical and 3D models that were used for TLW's Buck, which is around the same size as Roberta/Rexy. The spinosaurus absolutely killed a full grown bull T. rex, Universal later retconned it after they received backlash from people who couldn't handle seeing one random movie monster kill another random movie monster. Retcons can be executed well on occasion - this was not one of them, therefore I don't think it should be as easily accepted as it seems to be. Personal ranting aside, great video, really enjoyed watching!

  • @foreverjune8
    @foreverjune8 Рік тому +2

    Aint no such thing as an "accurate" Spinosaurus.

    • @diooverheaven6561
      @diooverheaven6561 Рік тому

      With new spino discoveries i wouldn't be suprised if at some point we would learn they were ultimate life forms

  • @craigbrown6437
    @craigbrown6437 11 місяців тому

    I have yet another question for the maker of this video. Here is my question: who do you think would win a head to head one on one fight to the death between a Saltwater Crocodile and a African male Hippopotamus. Could you please state your opinion as to which animal would win this fight and why? Could you please give reasons to support your answer. I await your reply.

  • @ShnarkNarc69
    @ShnarkNarc69 Рік тому +1

    Wait, i thought the jp3 spinos name was Tricicloplotus or "Plotus

  • @DinoSpino1
    @DinoSpino1 Рік тому

    a lot of people call him snock- GIRL WHO, WHAT, WHEN, WHERE BRO I DIDNT SEE THAT-?!

    • @DinoSpino1
      @DinoSpino1 Рік тому

      in all honestly jp3 spino is my fav in the entire jurassic franchise

  • @jILONIAN
    @jILONIAN День тому

    5:52 how did you, the overseer, mess this up so horribly?
    1: animals dont just develop the need for revenge, only INCREDIBLY smart animals like corvids do that
    2: used its claws to try and pry open a cage
    3: followed the humans around the island, was smart enough to know how to ambush (was only discovered by the phone ringtone)
    4: when in jp3 (it was a subadult) it quickly figured out how to effectively DESTROY trex of similar size. Only smart animals can learn this quickly
    id say its smarter than the giga, ~rexy and a bit less intelligent than the raptors

  • @thelegenddeuce
    @thelegenddeuce Рік тому

    The T Rex in JP3 was confirmed to be an adult, not a sub or younger

  • @austinbunyard3284
    @austinbunyard3284 Рік тому +5

    A real rex would destroy a real spino

    • @scylla9962
      @scylla9962 3 місяці тому

      still upset over a fictional dinosaur fight over 22 years old is crazy 💀

    • @ThatOneDudeWhoLikePancak-cq2vx
      @ThatOneDudeWhoLikePancak-cq2vx 2 місяці тому

      This shit has nothing to do with your fucking "t rex" god shut the hell up and stop meatriding T. rex that Dumass debate was from feb 2023

    • @TheRedSpinosaur
      @TheRedSpinosaur 21 день тому

      @@scylla9962 How does stating a fact = being upset?

  • @angelomatheusletstalkabout4671
    @angelomatheusletstalkabout4671 24 дні тому

    He is acctualy 5.7 meters tall in the head, in camp cretáceos

  • @TytanYem
    @TytanYem Місяць тому

    Wait the real one can go on four legs and bites the underside of snock

  • @sega20x80
    @sega20x80 8 місяців тому

    What if accurate Spinosaurus replace the fictional Spinosaurus in jurassic park 3? Goji Center replace Rexy with an accurate Tyrannosaurus.

  • @Tghddfds
    @Tghddfds Рік тому +7

    The t.rex is weak in Jurassic park and it's neck is also quite weak but i agree

    • @Mr.Wetherilli
      @Mr.Wetherilli Рік тому +6

      the same animal that can destroy buses with just a head slam, can encounter the same theropod that can smash through large metal fences, and can go toe-to-toe with the same animal that can smash through buildings and smash through geodesic glass (material greater than)
      On top of that can survive being smashed through buildings is somehow weak, ok.

    • @Tghddfds
      @Tghddfds Рік тому +3

      @@Mr.Wetherilli all of them are different animals and a real t.rex is stronger and would win

    • @Tghddfds
      @Tghddfds Рік тому

      @@Mr.Wetherilli I subscribed to your channel good stop motion

    • @Mr.Wetherilli
      @Mr.Wetherilli Рік тому +5

      @@Tghddfds the real rex is only stronger, no real animal with has the capability of easily destroying the sides of buses and surviving being smashed against literal concrete, may I remind you that the indominus has the literal capability of smashing through concrete with her own arms and can destroy literal steel, yet the rex was about to do perfectly fine against against her for a while
      The real rex is strong but there is no way it would survive any of the punishment the jp rex took, it's just not happening.

    • @Tghddfds
      @Tghddfds Рік тому +1

      @@Mr.Wetherilli a Rex can survive that and rexy got demolished in less than 30 second's

  • @jessehutchings
    @jessehutchings Рік тому +1

    JP Spino obviously wins but i love the real Spino even though it's obviously nowhere near the super predator that T-Rex is

  • @owenconteh3077
    @owenconteh3077 Рік тому

    I love both JP3 Spinosaurus and accurate Spinosaurus. Also Snock? I call him Spiny

  • @Dan-zz8mz
    @Dan-zz8mz 5 місяців тому

    0:12 wtf is that name?!?
    Helll nah. Most of people just call him *spino*
    And for the clarity. The Jp3 Spinosaurus is 17 feet in height and 44 feet in lenght (13,4 meters) with weight of 8 tons.
    The CC one is around 16-18 (52-59 feet)
    meters in lenght and as tall as 21 feet to his head- grown since the Jp3 spino was litteraly 2 years old.
    5:51: Couple *IQ Feats*
    Easily being able to sneak up to humans as a 8 ton dinosaur without anyone noticing which is litteraly insane feat of IQ even intentionaly waiting for humans to notice how stupid they were.
    In the scene after.. he again was able to trick alan grant and co.
    After they think they are safe from him, so he waits a second for them to not look then he smashes giant fucking fence.. which was not rusty at all (bald claim realy)

  • @dozierworld4350
    @dozierworld4350 Рік тому

    Do triceratops next

  • @leaguenpaleontology23
    @leaguenpaleontology23 Рік тому

    Jp3 spino gets irl spino in dinner 🍽️

  • @sethnaffziger1402
    @sethnaffziger1402 11 місяців тому

    Snock 100% of the time, he's got an invulnerability hack! Survives the strongest bite of any land animal to the neck without even a scratch... either that or he has a healing factor Wolverine would be jealous of

  • @Nicaveli
    @Nicaveli Рік тому +5

    ''accurate'' lmao, il be back in a few years

  • @annamaranon4858
    @annamaranon4858 Рік тому +2

    Ill take the accurate spinosuarus

  • @advanceotion
    @advanceotion 11 місяців тому +1

    You’re wrong an accurate spinosauras wins

  • @IfYouAreMemeRelatable
    @IfYouAreMemeRelatable 5 місяців тому

    Jp3 spino clearly neg diffs paleo accurate spino, there's nothing the paleo one can do except accept death

  • @amirram8308
    @amirram8308 Рік тому +3

    Actually the Spinosaurus is now 8.4 tons at average instead of 7.8, this is bc of major updates on the Spinosaurus legs.

  • @denisn8336
    @denisn8336 Рік тому +6

    This is another case of Reality being disappointing.

    • @rexyjp1237
      @rexyjp1237 Рік тому +5

      It isnt.
      A lion does not win a fight against an elephant.
      Does that mean that a lion is dissapointing to you?

    • @nickgennady
      @nickgennady Рік тому

      @@rexyjp1237yes

    • @MallikRVR
      @MallikRVR Рік тому +4

      You know there is more to real life than just strength and fighting

    • @denisn8336
      @denisn8336 Рік тому +1

      @@MallikRVR but strength and fighting is so cool

    • @denisn8336
      @denisn8336 Рік тому

      @@rexyjp1237 good point

  • @Megalodon_Productions
    @Megalodon_Productions Рік тому +1

    JP3 Spino wins no diff.

  • @dynamosaurusimperious2718
    @dynamosaurusimperious2718 Рік тому

    3.2 is for the holotype spinosaurus
    8.3t is for the largest "spinosaurus" as it's still unkwon whether it belongs to spinosaurus itself or not
    15kmh is the estimated swim speed for spinosaurus
    Overall I like this video is pretty cool, but it's for sure is overkill cause "Snock" is legit jusy a better spino jere

    • @amirram8308
      @amirram8308 Рік тому +1

      Actually the Spinosaurus Aegyptiacus is now 8.4 tons at average, means it is buffed from 7.8 to 8.4 tons

    • @dynamosaurusimperious2718
      @dynamosaurusimperious2718 Рік тому

      @@amirram8308 if you have RandomDinos Spinosaurus skeletal it is literally labelled as "largest" so no 8.4t isn't an "average" for spino since it doesn't exist but whatever you want to dream I guess

    • @amirram8308
      @amirram8308 Рік тому +1

      @@dynamosaurusimperious2718 blud says dreams lol
      Are you High? If we use Sereno's model, the updated density of the axial body is 1.05 which means the axial body is 7.72 tonnes. The tail is 8.5% of the axial volume which means it is 625 L (in this case 748 kg). Total mass is 8.47 tonnes. Despite the tail being a lot wider, the tail mass would remain constant even with Dan Folkes' longer tail because the tail needs to be ~735 kg to maintain the optimal COM suggested by Sereno. Ibrahim 2020's 3D model gives 8.87 tonnes, the recent model of the new skeletal gives 8.3_8.4 tonnes
      And cuz of major updates on the Spinosaurus legs, it seems to have a little bit bigger legs than its 2020s version of itself, spinosaurus buffed to 8.4 tons at Average, so go cry about it buddy And when you don't know something, you don't need to discuss it

    • @dynamosaurusimperious2718
      @dynamosaurusimperious2718 Рік тому

      @@amirram8308 sereno's model view from the top has too much tail thickness so it's unreliable

    • @amirram8308
      @amirram8308 Рік тому +1

      @@dynamosaurusimperious2718 don't say bullshit man
      Lol buddy you literally ignored the officially paleontologist pual by saying bullshits of your own

  • @soniczillasaurus5491
    @soniczillasaurus5491 6 місяців тому

    Spinosaurus spin is not a weak point that is just a myth jp3 spinosaurus wins but I think your underestimating the real spinosaurus

  • @GODEYE270115
    @GODEYE270115 Рік тому +8

    How did you get 10 tonnes for the jp spino? That puts it near Giga’s weight and it’s constantly stated as the biggest in the series by multiple characters in JWD.
    If I remember correctly the JP3 DVD pamphlet stated it was 8 tonnes

    • @Dtorvo
      @Dtorvo Рік тому +6

      Jwd Giga is 11 tons

    • @GODEYE270115
      @GODEYE270115 Рік тому +2

      ⁠@@Dtorvoyes I remember that Trevorrow statement from the Empire interview. But I wanna know where these 10 tonne spino numbers are coming from. JP3 was the only one that gave spino sizes, camp Cretaceous didn’t. And if we going by on screen sizes, they are never consistent. Rexy looks absolutely huge in some shots then normal in others. these movies aren’t consistent enough to take on screen measurements

    • @Killerg238
      @Killerg238 Рік тому

      ​@@GODEYE270115There's also Sauroniops pachytholus a huge 7.7-7.9 tons carcharodontosaurid that lived alongside Spinosaurus & Carcharodontosaurus & hunted spino from time to time

    • @GODEYE270115
      @GODEYE270115 Рік тому +1

      @@Killerg238 I wasn’t aware a second large Charcharodontosaur lived alongside Spino. What in the world was going on in that environment to support so many mega theropods

    • @Dtorvo
      @Dtorvo Рік тому +1

      ​@@GODEYE27011510 tonnes spino is a made up bs

  • @lemniscate.526
    @lemniscate.526 Рік тому +1

    The accurate spinosaurus is going to get changed so much from now. We don't have very many bones of the spinosaurus is why I say that. That is the only thing that makes me think the spinosaurus mightve had weaker bones that would disappear after death more likely.

    • @kaytlinjustis5643
      @kaytlinjustis5643 Рік тому

      Blame the WW2 bombings from Nazis. There had been only ONE complete fossil of the Spinosaurus, as well as all the written research from the individual who found it. All had been destroyed, so now we are literally piecing together what Spinosaurus COULD have been like!

  • @zakan4898
    @zakan4898 Рік тому +6

    Accurate for now...

  • @Gnarwolf
    @Gnarwolf 11 місяців тому

    Lets be real tho, the JP3 spino is just way fucking cooler , if youre gona make a game or show or any kind of media that is fiction and has a spino in it, just use the JP3 design lol

  • @somekidcalledmark3754
    @somekidcalledmark3754 Рік тому

    Aren't classic spinosaur bigger the real life one taller only classic spinosaur had body like 14m t-rex with crocodile body unlike body today longer neck and tail

  • @Krona-fb4dn
    @Krona-fb4dn Рік тому

    This is already common knowledge???
    JP3 came out more than 20 years ago.

  • @dozierworld4350
    @dozierworld4350 8 місяців тому

    maybey you can pit spino/snock against a real t.rex

  • @timaking5438
    @timaking5438 Рік тому +4

    Bull rex is adult in movie

    • @Dtorvo
      @Dtorvo Рік тому +1

      No it's sub adult.

    • @Dtorvo
      @Dtorvo Рік тому +1

      Stk fanboy

    • @timaking5438
      @timaking5438 Рік тому

      ​​@@Dtorvo no it is adult and ther is in proof in novel it is say full grow rex

    • @timaking5438
      @timaking5438 Рік тому

      ​@@Dtorvoı am not that dumb to say spino is 18m lol

  • @Cup-violation
    @Cup-violation Рік тому

    It’s a hybrid

  • @TytanYem
    @TytanYem Місяць тому

    Dude real spino goes on four legs 🫣

  • @TytanYem
    @TytanYem Місяць тому

    😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳😳

  • @Sirdilophosaurusthethird2.0
    @Sirdilophosaurusthethird2.0 5 місяців тому

    Poor acurrte spino

  • @randomguyodst46
    @randomguyodst46 Рік тому +1

    primordial soup cringe.

  • @LuisRivera-jk1vo
    @LuisRivera-jk1vo Рік тому +1

    Fictional Monster In JP3
    vs.
    Ancient Animal In Prehistoric Past.

  • @niallmoseley6760
    @niallmoseley6760 Рік тому +2

    5:17 is BS. Look up spino tripodal posture vs t rex and u can see irl spino was very able to use its claws offensivley.
    Edit : The reality is, most of the "science " spino has been debunked. Its back to being land based, bipedal and the legs were also most likely normal. But most people prefer the mess that Nizar Ibrahim cooked up in 2014 cuz it looks better for t rex. The spino is a culprit of down powering to protect the image of t rex. Giga and tricerotops have also had the same treatment and its getting silly

    • @Unbearable_Truth
      @Unbearable_Truth 11 місяців тому

      Be cautious regarding Prehistoricking. They're been banned from multiple Discord servers due to their flame bait, spam and harrassment etc.

  • @Procrastinater
    @Procrastinater Рік тому

    "accurate spino"

  • @antstudios167
    @antstudios167 Рік тому

    Wow thanks for ruining my favourite dinosaur guess its time to move to team trex

  • @Killerg238
    @Killerg238 Рік тому

    There's also Sauroniops pachytholus a huge 7.7-7.9 tons carcharodontosaurid that lived alongside Spinosaurus & Carcharodontosaurus & hunted spino from time to time

    • @Killerg238
      @Killerg238 Рік тому

      ua-cam.com/users/shortscZ_2jcIb6JQ?si=ZD211mP-JoMmltA1

  • @Julian.noa21
    @Julian.noa21 Рік тому +1

    First

  • @godzillakingofthemonsters5812
    @godzillakingofthemonsters5812 Рік тому +1

    Animal abuse.