Scout's Eye with Matt Williamson: Things that make your stomach turn

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 78

  • @briansnyder5412
    @briansnyder5412 20 днів тому +18

    Youre who i rely on for the 100 percent real steelers news. And i can feel you depression and realization that this team just isnt good enough and i sadly just agree with you. If everything goes right we lose in the 2nd round. Over and out

    • @blackphilip8936
      @blackphilip8936 20 днів тому +1

      2nd round is the absolute ceiling.
      And if the Texans weren’t playing as bad as they are right now, no one would think they could beat them either.
      The Steelers are the poster team for mediocrity and Tomlin is their King. They will NEVER compete for a SB as long as Mediocre Mike is on the sidelines.

  • @mjb_33
    @mjb_33 20 днів тому +1

    I love the bass line in your intros, helps me lock into the content. Love the show

  • @graysonbrown9778
    @graysonbrown9778 20 днів тому +13

    I'm tired of hearing about Mahomes, Allen, Lamar... Burrow... not having a QB is a resentful experience.
    As a follower of the team...I'm getting disappointed with the false hope of having a good team that can contend.
    Its a pipe dream, making me question everything about the team. This is year 5 of 3 in a row December losses...
    Its painful to watch the team get to 10 wins and fall apart when it matters.

    • @billymartin5657
      @billymartin5657 20 днів тому +1

      The false hope in your head is your fault. This is a mike Tomlin team. This is expected. If you thought otherwise it's on you

    • @davidmurphy9255
      @davidmurphy9255 19 днів тому

      If you are disappointed, I get it. Me too but this team is better - top 10 team but not top 6 -KC, Philly, Balt, Buf, Det, Min. We have below Ave QB, average OL, lack of quality receivers and our two best and highest paid defenders not making splash plays.

    • @stoneylonesome5826
      @stoneylonesome5826 18 днів тому

      So true. We will not be contenders until we have a franchise QB, it’s just that simple. Those teams you listed weren’t sniffing a Super Bowl until those guys arrived.

  • @3-4ZoneBlitz
    @3-4ZoneBlitz 20 днів тому +4

    I agree with Trice...Trice and JPJ are 2 BIG fast corners that play man

    • @mjb_33
      @mjb_33 20 днів тому +1

      Now let's somehow draft Amos out of Ole Miss or Porter out of Iowa St. In round two of the 2025 draft, keep Pierre as CB4/gunner, cut Sutton, draft Bowman as a slot safety (Kazee replacement) in round 4 and the secondary is hopefully a strength going forward.

    • @M98-j9k
      @M98-j9k 19 днів тому

      Porter isn't that good. Penalty machine.

    • @davidmurphy9255
      @davidmurphy9255 19 днів тому

      Good analysis - need to draft WRs also

  • @RelaxedStylesCom
    @RelaxedStylesCom 20 днів тому +1

    Thanks for your work.

  • @jerryyeager1307
    @jerryyeager1307 20 днів тому

    Thank you Matt. Great numbers and is appreciated. Great show

  • @bibmitchell6542
    @bibmitchell6542 20 днів тому +6

    O-line has stunk for years. They draft people and move them to positions they've never played. Tomlin hires yes men. Those 2 things alone are a recipe for success. Not. Tomlin is long past his expiration date

  • @AAKFILMPRODUCTIONS
    @AAKFILMPRODUCTIONS 20 днів тому +4

    Will not be surprised if we draft a rb this draft

  • @batman5194
    @batman5194 20 днів тому +6

    This guy says Wilson is doing bad but fail to mention he is doing bad because the offensive line is getting him hit sooner then he wants.

    • @90FirstGenPGT
      @90FirstGenPGT 19 днів тому +2

      If that's the case, the ball needs to come out faster. Either russ needs to stop holding onto it or the scheme needs to draw up quick pass plays.

    • @davidmurphy9255
      @davidmurphy9255 19 днів тому +1

      Agree - Russ holds on too long and is made worse that we don't have WRs getting separation.

  • @bvee4952
    @bvee4952 20 днів тому

    Great last point, Matt. I head the same thing for Thanksgiving games and it makes sense. Even the Lions struggled with the Bears this year.

  • @Justin_Watson23
    @Justin_Watson23 20 днів тому +3

    Does anyone think this team is better after they allocate most of their upcoming cap room to a QB whose arm is failing, throws to boundary, & doesn't see your 10 mil/year TE?
    Corey Trice impressed the hell out of me. One of few bright spots of defense.

    • @plaubelmakina8916
      @plaubelmakina8916 20 днів тому +1

      Agree and it surprised me when several podcasters couple of weeks ago were complaining about Trice.

    • @alwaysteeler
      @alwaysteeler 20 днів тому

      Yeah, with him and JPJ as our permanent starters to finish off this season and going to next year into the future, we look damn good

    • @90FirstGenPGT
      @90FirstGenPGT 19 днів тому

      A couple of weeks ago, trice was aweful. But he's settled in since.​@plaubelmakina8916

  • @roberthalyama
    @roberthalyama 20 днів тому +1

    Matt, what do you think the plan of attack should be for the offseason? It’s clear we need cornerback help, should we pursue someone like DJ Reed? Omar signing PQ seems to have opened the door for larger free agency splash. Love the show!

  • @y2kelly66
    @y2kelly66 20 днів тому +4

    Every given Sunday, anything is possible in the playoffs, but the Steelers seem done after watching them get dismantled for the past three games by top tier teams. I'm already thinking of draft. I hope they move Pickens. Also, we need to not be the highest paid defense. We can bring the salaries down some and probably do just as good or bad, however you look at it. We need help on the o line bad. Idk about Russell Wilson now. He holds ball way too long and we giving up more sacks than i can remember. Maybe we dont need to be signing him for crazy money. His play definitely giving us reasons to rethink that signing.

    • @blackphilip8936
      @blackphilip8936 20 днів тому

      Yeah, move Pickens, the only real talent they have.
      Don’t EVER hope they fire Tomlin, the reason so many players want OUT of this football hell hole.

  • @adammurphy5699
    @adammurphy5699 20 днів тому +1

    Everytime the Steelers get stomped, the time to throw is really low. They just allow quick slants, drags and outs all day long and give up 5+ yards each time

  • @jaredkrol3739
    @jaredkrol3739 20 днів тому +3

    The more I see of Russ the more I wish we got off Fields. Also no matter how good people think Trice might be I hope to god they don’t act like he is the answer as starter next year. This secondary is on life support and needs better scheme AND an infusion of top end talent badly. Especially at corner

    • @blackphilip8936
      @blackphilip8936 20 днів тому +1

      The more I see Russ and Fields, the more I wish they kept Pickett and flushed the coaching staff.
      Mike Tomlin doesn’t have a clue on how to use or develop a QB. He was gifted a HOF franchise Ben. Ben’s the only reason he has any playoff wins and the one ring. 18 years of being the HC, name ONE QB outside of Ben that Tomlin drafted/developed.

    • @mycalbrooks8161
      @mycalbrooks8161 20 днів тому +2

      @@blackphilip8936did you see Pickett last week? He’s just as bad as Wilson.. we got some weird days ahead

  • @Cardel34
    @Cardel34 20 днів тому +2

    I think everyone was excited for Russ when he started after injury. I've always said I preferred Justin. I think he was improving from his time in Chicago and he was taking care of the ball. If we would have stuck with him and let him grow into the offense I think we could possibly be in the same situation (as far as record) as were in now and had a better outlook on the position for next year. There's no way I would resign Russ.

    • @blackphilip8936
      @blackphilip8936 20 днів тому

      Justin sucks too.
      There isn’t a QB on the roster that should come back next year. You want to pay for Fields, but you were ready to hang Pickett? Pathetic.

    • @raymondrak961
      @raymondrak961 20 днів тому +1

      Wilson has obvious shortcomings but the Steelers will stay with him because that is what they are.

    • @jordellfreshbreeze7133
      @jordellfreshbreeze7133 20 днів тому +1

      Fields is way better than Pickett

    • @mike2687
      @mike2687 20 днів тому

      @@jordellfreshbreeze7133 - I agree, Fields is better than KP… also, the offense under Fields was only marginally better than with KP having most of his games resulting in under 300 yards of offense.
      In the end, neither are of the level the Steelers need to compete - more potential with JF but I hate talking about potential after the first 3 years in the league as it’s most likely wishful thinking at that point.

  • @jackcollin2476
    @jackcollin2476 19 днів тому

    A team's coach being their buddy can only go so far before the coaches deficiencies come to the surface through play on the field

  • @mycalbrooks8161
    @mycalbrooks8161 20 днів тому

    11:44 not that you care but just gained my respect.. almost thought he was paying you

  • @11co5955
    @11co5955 20 днів тому +6

    It's time. I'm tired of the same old garbage, same old looking unprepared and getting embarrassed. Tomlin needs to go, and so does 80% of the coaching staff.

  • @jerichosmite2140
    @jerichosmite2140 18 днів тому

    One of the problems with Fields were some statistics showing turnover worthy plays. His was becoming higher as the games went on. This was especially troubling when you consider that he wasnt really throwing it downfield. We know that the more you throw it downfield the chances of turnovers are higher just from the sheer number of oppourtunities. With turnover worthy plays, they have trends to show that this play or that play had a high likelihood of being a turnover. The fact that it didnt could be variables, like just luck, but the play itself is looked at as simply a bad play. Overall, this showed people that his low turnover rate was an anomoly and a regression to the mean is inevitable.
    None of this means that it was for sure going to happen, but it showed some people that his stats didnt match his play. Russell on the other hand had a really low turnover worthy play rate, which meant that regardless of the outcome of the play, it was the "correct play". The fact that hes having turnovers now, could be seen in many different ways. It could be argued that hes getting incredibly unlucky as not all turnover worthy plays result in turnovers. It seems to some that Russell's "luck" has no margin for error vs Fields luck having an incredibly high margin for error. Both are expected to regress to the mean.

  • @toddwilliams4493
    @toddwilliams4493 20 днів тому

    Makes all the sense in the world now... Sutton and Jackson!! that's who the players are calling out

  • @MichaelBrown-z1j
    @MichaelBrown-z1j 19 днів тому +1

    I'd like to see Bishop out there instead of Sutton. And Patrick Queen ? The effort level is disappointing.

  • @plaubelmakina8916
    @plaubelmakina8916 20 днів тому +1

    Did any Steeler CB’s jam their receivers at the line?

  • @cmc5207
    @cmc5207 20 днів тому

    You talked about Russ, the height, the decision making, etc.
    I dont think Rudolph was great, but I do think he was someone who stood tall, got the ball out and showed enough last year to get a shot this year. I dont think its absurd to assume he couldve gotten this team to 10-6. I certainly believe he couldve had better chemistry with the receivers and he could actually SEE receivers running free (the point about height).
    I still wonder who the future franchise QB will be, or how the Steelers can find him.

    • @franmcginley7776
      @franmcginley7776 20 днів тому +2

      Don’t finish in the middle. Draft no later than pick 10 or 11 depending on how many QB’s in a given class.
      Unfortunately even that’s no guarantee. They hit the jackpot with Ben, but there are tons of QB’s drafted in top 10 who are busts or simply serviceable starters.

  • @3-4ZoneBlitz
    @3-4ZoneBlitz 20 днів тому +1

    Scares me that TJ has faced lots of backups this year and does very little.

    • @stoneylonesome5826
      @stoneylonesome5826 18 днів тому

      I think he’s more injured than the Steelers are letting on.

  • @AAKFILMPRODUCTIONS
    @AAKFILMPRODUCTIONS 20 днів тому +3

    Who is Roman Wilson says Mike Tomlin

    • @Justin_Watson23
      @Justin_Watson23 20 днів тому +1

      Someone not good enough to get a helmet

    • @blackphilip8936
      @blackphilip8936 20 днів тому +2

      Not good enough to get a helmet... that sums up Tomlin’s football playing career.

    • @mike2687
      @mike2687 20 днів тому

      @@blackphilip8936 - might be right, though I’m not big on this HC to evaluate talent…

  • @jerichosmite2140
    @jerichosmite2140 18 днів тому

    That's an interesting piece about home teams and Christmas. It got me thinking, well how has that bore out over the years? I looked it up.
    Since 1971 including two playoff games that were held on Christmas until present day:
    32 games played
    Home team wins 14 44% Winrate
    Away team wins 18 56% Winrate
    Home team 686 Points scored 21ppg
    Away team 746 Points scored 23 ppg
    Could be something to it.

  • @michaelgiannetti3846
    @michaelgiannetti3846 18 днів тому

    This team is just incredibly frustrating.

  • @Abracadoofus
    @Abracadoofus 15 днів тому

    Out of 72 games with quickest release time he's 57-5 where'd the other 10games go. 😂

  • @raymondrak961
    @raymondrak961 20 днів тому +1

    This game against the Chiefs showed the short comings of the Steelers in certain areas. There will be upgrades but not enough through the draft alone. The Steelers need to replace Wilson because he Is not the answer at QB.

    • @stoneylonesome5826
      @stoneylonesome5826 18 днів тому

      If they don’t resign Wilson or Fields, who is the Steelers 2025 QB? Kirk Cousins? 🤣

  • @tonyh.anderson2658
    @tonyh.anderson2658 20 днів тому +3

    How did we get here? Oh I know “ we’re good with the receivers we have in our room!” How did we get here? “Let’s run Najee! When we have Warren!” SMH I can’t root go on and on!

    • @jordellfreshbreeze7133
      @jordellfreshbreeze7133 20 днів тому

      Why use Patterson when you have Najee?

    • @mike2687
      @mike2687 20 днів тому

      @@jordellfreshbreeze7133 - idk, maybe because he averages more yards and has more game breaking potential than Najee 🤷‍♂️
      Regardless, Patterson gets just a handful of snaps… I’d view it more as Patterson is getting snaps that should go to Warren rather than Najee.

  • @M98-j9k
    @M98-j9k 19 днів тому

    You failed to mention Tomlins stats and results since 2010. Maybe thats a big problem!!

  • @chrisdavis1301
    @chrisdavis1301 20 днів тому

    3 games in 11 days just isn’t right. Other teams do it too etc, a bunch of Malarkey. You can’t tell me a schedule like that doesn’t take away from preparation and practice time. I’m glad that stretch is over. Back to the Xs and Os. If we can’t improve on defense then the offensive mentality needs to change.

  • @ChrisCash720
    @ChrisCash720 20 днів тому +4

    Mike tomlin will ride with najiee and lose. Mike tomlin will start cam sutton and get blown out. The mans ego is to big

  • @jim6807
    @jim6807 20 днів тому

    How is cam Sutton so bad lol. He was pretty good with us before. Our defense is stacked on paper. I don’t understand. Other teams do more with less… like the chiefs

  • @rizzomatt
    @rizzomatt 20 днів тому

    Sounds like the Stillers pretty much stink.

  • @williammcpherson9953
    @williammcpherson9953 19 днів тому +1

    No one cares about the numbers your reading. Just the final number is the issue. ( score)

  • @anthonydandrea6653
    @anthonydandrea6653 20 днів тому

    Figures that we would get the dad Pat Mahomes and not the superstar kid.

  • @alexlupsor5484
    @alexlupsor5484 17 днів тому

    Wilson is and should be the only backer that should control our destiny bar injury. The problem isn't Wilson but the five line front. Straighten this porous non-protection front five to change the out come. They couldn't stop a good 4 man pass rush of a major highs hool program the last three losses. Let the quarterback win WITH PROTECTION without injuries and not the end of our chances.
    Fields should remain out of the game. He's as cold as a witches t. He's THE WRECKING CREW nothing more. If he's used pull the covers over our heads. An non-porous offensive line is what the team will feed off not some rooky whose known to throw interception(s) per game that would kill any defence. He hasn't the needed experence to wi this critical game.
    The steers were out coached especially in the second half. There was no adjustment for what the cheifs were doing and thus they ran over completely until they broke their backs in the 4th.

  • @battistimo
    @battistimo 20 днів тому +1

    The Tomlin experience

  • @brentkromer_
    @brentkromer_ 20 днів тому

    Would it be crazy to have Trice and JPJ on the outside and DJ in slot? Rotate beanie in. Kick cam s off team lol

  • @edwardkrott2394
    @edwardkrott2394 20 днів тому

    You invest in O-line for the last several years and still we continue have issues of being overmatched.No dominance on push or pass protection these last few yrs.To me that sounds like coaching.maybe Meyer needs to be looked at

  • @victoryasher1729
    @victoryasher1729 20 днів тому +1

    I don't know who's worse...the 49ers De'Vondre Campbell or George Pickens with his passive-aggressive, borderline personality disorder? GP14 had no business near the "CHIEFS" post-game Netflix interview. Not going full go on plays, taking off his helmet during the game, and the list continues to go on from week to week. He's an uncontrollable problem on the football field. No way he should have the entire Steelers organization stuck-up with his weapon of volatile antics. No way should the Steelers be forced to depend on the unstable and immature mindset of this guy (and good Lord, who decided to make this guy WR1). May as well make a deal with the 49ers and add De'Vondre Campbell and keep GP14 on weekly suspension. Outstanding WR skills, substandard thought process.

    • @mike2687
      @mike2687 20 днів тому

      I see two sides to this coin:
      This was his MO prior to drafting him and then they did so knowing they were pairing him with KP and Canada in an offense that MT wants to be very conservative and then followed up with AS that’s really run heavy.
      Then they out him in a WR led by Diontae who had the single biggest “pouty quit play” I’ve ever seen and there was no public punishment, meanwhile, Chuks makes an offhand comment about quitting on a play and is benched for the rest of the season and released afterwards.
      In a lot of ways, I see this as the bed they made.
      I don’t disagree with your points, rather, I see getting rid of him as putting a band-Aid on the symptom instead of treating the cause.

  • @christianglover2447
    @christianglover2447 16 днів тому

    This feels at times that this is Matt's Platform to smear the Steelers. I get it your being objective and going over the data, BUUUUUT you like to sprinkle a little extra " umph" when explaining it. I feel it's a little too much 😕 at times

  • @yourneighbor6957
    @yourneighbor6957 20 днів тому

    Seems like a history of steelers having one guy cripple the team .

  • @3-4ZoneBlitz
    @3-4ZoneBlitz 20 днів тому

    We dropped a couple INTs...funny how stats can be manipulated.