Ross Coulthart is an important voice in science circles. It's only during conversations like this that one learns just how deeply and widely he reads across many domains. He's not like so many interviewers who come with their 20 questions and scratch them off one by one. He digs deeply in his off-hours. And I appreciate that. I hope News Nation will continue to support him, and do their best to let a wide public know about him. This speaks well of News Nation as a relatively new News Network. We need as many credible sources as possible wherein all sides of an issue are explored.
He's full of shit, he is giving you breadcrumbs that lead exactly where black operative aspect of the global governments want you to go. Dig deeper. Look up "Forbes Malaysian flight"
An important voice in science? What are you talking about? He's not a scientist. How can he be an important voice in science? You mean a popular voice among UFO enthusiasts?
@@punkypinko2965 I have two STEM graduate degrees. Ross is exceptional because he digs deeply, has learned a great deal over decades interviewing all manner of experts, and is somehow able to convey these difficult topics to a much wider public. It's a rare skill. That's all I was trying to say.
David Grusch: the US Government has a crash retrieval program and have over 10 alien craft in their possession. Seti: we still searching for signals from space.
Exaclty. Seti is a huge coverup / psyop. The military knows for more than 50 years that advanced civilizations do not use radio, some use quantum entanglement tech, others are telekinetic. Seti's mission is to make people believing that, since there are no radio signals, there aren't any evidence of other civilizations.
@@duchon46 there is no way grush story can be true as if the usa government has a recovered alien craft in their possetion then dave grush would not have clearance to talk about it
I admire you, Ross Coulthard for doing what you do and handle all the criticism from basement dwellers 😅. You approach topics that are subject to criticism as well as some guests. Your reputation lends so much credibility to your work. You spent a lifetime in journalism to become so adept and wise with the interview process. Keep up the great work. The world needs people like you.
damn I actually never thought of that for some reason. they are pretending to look/or have already found something and are lying/covering it up pretending to find nothing.
@mike-vw1zn yeah a little of that "dupers delight" they call it. It's fun for certain types of people to lie like that. The smirk is when they perceive someone to be eating their story up. Sometimes we aren't though. Sometimes those types think they are better at lying than they are, like this guy. He's stuck in the 80's before wide spread info was more available. This isn't going to work anymore on anyone but old and slow people.
You naively believe in UFO's and UAP's but there has never been any, and never will be, any physical evidence that they exist. You are wasting our time with this BS.
@@dolphinliam888 Not idiots, huh? Wanna bet? Just read this string again and subject each comment to a binary choice. Idiot or Not Idiot. Tabulate the score... No, don't. You'll be greatly disappointed. Or try this: how many would I invite to a dinner party with my best friends and pair them up at table, one by one.
There once was a team from SETI, Whose hopes for aliens were heady. They listened all night, For signals just right, But heard only static and "Spaghetti?"
Brilliantly clear discussion with Bill providing concise information and giving us a very thorough description of SETI's activities and his views on how we may get to point where a signal is detected. A great guest Ross... and thanks for the well crafted questions. Just to stir the pot for a moment...Why would the Government not offer to fund the activities of SETI?.....Might it be because they may already know that life does exist throughout the Universe and have known this for a long time?
Sadly, its fundamental basis of existence and operations is inherently flawed. They will NEVER be allowed to transmit nor announce any such findings or evidence by dictatorial world gov'ts. Period.
This episode was excellent. It reminded me of the format that the New Horizons podcast uses which I enjoy very much. Please keep bringing on subject matter experts and allowing them to talk at length on whatever topic interests you two.
Ross, just want to let you know that you’re a seriously skilled interviewer and come up with some of the best questions possible to ask people of all professions, which goes to show the amount of research and thought you put into each interview. I see people in the comments suggesting that SETI is used by the government to cover up the existence of NHI, but if SETI is being manipulated by the government in any way, I wonder if it’s for the purpose of putting the burden of disclosure on a third party rather than themselves 🤔 one last thought, I’d also like to hear SETI’s thoughts on some of the strange signals they pick up at Skinwalker Ranch to see if they’ve ever detected anything similar or if they plan to look for signals in those areas.
Seti is a huge coverup / psyop. The military knows for more than 50 years that advanced civilizations do not use radio, some use quantum entanglement tech, others are telekinetic. Seti's mission is to make people believing that, since there are no radio signals, there aren't any evidence of other civilizations.
Thank you for this one Larry it rings true to my heart. I paid a lot of attention in my childhood to that war and in adult life I've been to the Holocaust Museum in Tampa Florida & talked with survivors...
Why is this joke told on every single video on this subject? Like every single one. Is it the same person making the comment on all the videos, or is it a bunch of people that aren’t even listening to the content of the videos? Like, why are they still joking about this?
That dude wins the award for COOLEST crash pad. It looks like some nook in the catacombs of London or Paris, it’s dope af and I’m always jealous scoping it out.
SETI - Dr. Puthoff (former chief scientist on AAWSAP) mentioned 2 years ago - „I’m glad to see some SETI people have begun to consider archaeological settings if there is any evidence of other genetic structures, molecules and materials (certainly encrypted) on earth, the moon or on mars, because I’ve always been pretty skeptical about that signals through speed of light, light waves etc and their effectiveness in space.“ - sorry, not a perfect transcript, but good enough to get the point ...
It would be funny if they find the archived video transcripts from then or officially released permission and they review it independently with what the networks have had on tapes since 1998.
Hooray for the scientists of discovery! This is the first description of a use for AI that is potentially totally benign that I have ever heard of. Normally I believe AI is a terrible thing that can only make the rich richer, the poor poorer, and the surveilled more so, but putting AI to work in scanning the skies for visitors actually sounds like a decent idea. Good luck to everybody involved in SETI! All the best, N.
54:30 first off, i am absolutely on the side that thinks the vast majority of civilizations are probably fairly benign (not harmless, but not actively out to get primitive civilizations like humanity). But what he is saying is yet again based on assumptions, naive assumptions. Just becuase you have a worldwide governenance that stands as the foundation of interstellar expansion, does NOT therefor automatically mean that freedom liberty and democracy "won" the competition of social evolution on that planet.. It is equally likely that their version of WW2 Germany or the USSR "won" the global conflict, and that their entire civilization is now thousands of years deep in an absolute authoritarian control, especially easy to manage when you factor in AI overseers or putting a neurallink in every childs brain to modify emotional states or "rebellious urges". So to sit there and assume a civilization cant go beyond nuclear without being democratic, is incredibly naive. They could have "gotten past" the nuclear threshold by NOT evading it, but by ACTUALLY having decended in a full global nuclear war. The difference being, the "bad guys won". You can have a global nucelar war without totally eliminating your whole civilization, if you only have a few nukes (below 800 or so). Yes, civilization on both sides, even the winning side, would be enormously ruined.. But give it a few hundred years, if the major emerging faction is the only one left with nukes, and is a bad actor, then the world enters a new era of dystopia. You can still have scientific progress, with an elite class that is allowed to live free and think free, as long as it doesnt oppose the state. It will be slower, but it will still progress. This notion that democracy is the only survivable option isnt correct. Its the only PLEASANT survivable option (for civilians), but not the only possible outcome. Likewise, the assumption that every interstellar civilization MUST be based on logic and objectivity, and wont make irrational decisions also doesnt hold water. What if their emerging power player is a highly religious theocracy that still has an elite class of actual scientists, but keeping discoveries hidden from the masses, and using them as divine displays of power? (Think Dune, or Warhammer 40k's imperium, where the masses believe spirits run the machines, becuase they have no free source of open scientific knowledge, but the elites do). You can absolutely have science and religion living together. Look at people in Saudi Arabia being very devout muslims while also expanding their energy and high tech manufacturing industry. Look at USA, where actual presidents are claiming a connection with God, and that their nation is "chosen by god to shepard the world" (no really, your leading actual politicians and senators fully genuinely believe, and have said, that). If you have an interstellar civilization run by a theocracy, you cannot predict their actions nor their morality. They could randomly and irrationally view homo sapiens as "demons". How you view another species has nothing to do with if you are capable of scientific innovation or not. Look at how far WW2 germany pushed rocketry, while being extremely authoritarian and while most top scientists held horrendous beliefs. So how can you assume a civilization must be peaceful because they have high technology?
Good interview. Can’t help notice Bill’s body language when answering some of Ross’s questions where Bill has a defensive cross armed posture. Most likely that Bill is limited to discuss certain topics openly as that could be confidential or govt related/nda for their govt contracts
Bill said data is not shared to prevent adversaries from knowing system capabilities. Ok. I agree. How about we just get shown a retrieved craft and bodies? No "data" equipment required.
Okay, here's my one comment for the room that I want to make. I was one of the original members of the seti program and yes I do recall having a signal pop up on my computer and I just didn't know what to do after it happened. But I'll give you the exact year. It was $19.99. I was dating. Gina and I was living in Orlando and it was on the third floor of the apartment I shared with my roommate
Ancient UFO's/UAP's were known as Vimana. These Vimanas are well documented in ancient Indian Sanskrit with incredible detail as to how these Vimana were constructed and propelled by their ‘gods’ using mercury and handheld Vajras. The peoples of ancient India, ancient Sumer/Shinar, ancient Chaldea and ancient Egypt shared these experiences and described the technology. There is nothing new under the sun. If past generations had this technology, certainly we are secretly using this same technology today. The question should be why the secrecy. A good place to start researching is “Ancient Flying Machines - The Ending” from the Investigating Babylon series by Kingdom in Context. Further examination in this series will uncover the technology to levitate and cloak identity through light waves.
Remember, the national networks informed everyone for like two weeks prior that pretty much all the unions would possibly strike or go on strike. At least 12 days before the object in the southeastern corner of the moon viewing was referred to on the news and debated for about two days and nights of the 5 days and nights it was there.
Ross, chuck had just won the world martial arts championship when Lee asked him to be in this film. Chuck said “I get it, you want to beat the champion in your film.” Lee replied, “no. I want to KILL the champion in my film.”
Exactly! It's ridiculous they think that a technologically superior species that can travel between stars would still be using something as primitive as radio to communicate
If they are here and they know we use radio waves to communicate, it wouldnt be hard for them to make antenas and reply. If they haven't done this and they are here, it's their choice not to speak to us
From all my favourite authors on the subject. This " alien presence comes from a less dense reality. A spiritual reality. Explains the poltergeist connection.
What if SETI has it wrong, what if some aliens are so advanced they use a powerful device to transmit thought using dark matter as a communications network, or some alien species are still using homing pigeons to send messages.
Well written. Our understanding of science is still incomplete and requires much more development to fully align with the reality around us. The question mark that is dark matter, along with dark energy and the origins of gravity, highlights how much we have yet to grasp. The incomplete connection between general relativity and quantum mechanics further underscores the complexity of these issues. If there are more advanced or differently aligned scientific beings out there, or even in other dimensions (which I don’t doubt), it stands to reason that we would likely be unable to detect or interpret their signals or whatever methods of communication they use.
If they discovered us, they should be capable of understanding what kind of signals we would detect... the fact that there is no public comunication with humanity is their decision. If we discover life on another planet, we would probably do the same... study them in secret and reveal our presence when we decide its appropiate
Technology itself seems like a parasitic invasive species that will consume the host during its own evolution. If consciousness is pervasive like a radio signal and we are simply tuning in to it, perhaps the signal is being manipulated. Just something I think about whenever I hear stats on how every generation of devices have eroded mental health and we still insist of using them more in the name of "progress". Progress for who, if it's not for our own biological and mental health?
New scientific study taken over ten months at Long Island Beach using mobile laboratory with multiple high-tech sensory instruments confirms UAPs are more prolific than previously thought: Open Journal of Applied Sciences > Vol.14 No.8, August 2024, Eye on the Sky: A UAP Research and Field Study off New York’s Long Island Coast
Well, I watched The Thing on our tiny black and white TV back in the late 50s. That seemed pretty great. And I was scared to death. Also, The Day the Earth Stood Still. I quite liked the Robot and the pretty girl. But I was 5. We lived in DC, so I kept an eye out.
@@dylanthomas12321 The Thing is definitely a great movie! It is funny to think you grew up watching it on tv when you were 5 and I grew up playing at the videogame when I was 10 (13 years ago) ❤
If any recall, a majority of the news anchors had to use their vacation days up or lose them with new contracts, so 90-98% of them were off on vacation as the strike talks loomed to the actual broadcasters strikes nationally in 1998.
Ross is a hoot! An alien came down from the skies, With twelve arms and twenty-three eyes. He said with a grin, "Mind if I come in? I just need to charge my Wi-Fi!"
Love Coulthart and his positivity but SETI...Schmeti are a joke imo. They search for alien life through only part of the spectrum of electromagnetic radiation, Ross is right they need to try different forms of technologies. It's just like they're a cover for spending, what have they achieved in the time they've existed.
@@pmcallah Ross kinda looks like a native animal from Australia. Te Koala 🐨 Bear. Tho it’s not a bear. However we recommend to watch out for DROP BEARS. THE JUMP OUT OF THE TREES ON THERE UNSUSPECTING HUMAN PREY AND DEVOUR ALL TRACES… YUP THE KOALA 🐨 BEAR…👍🤣🇦🇺
Looking for Extraterrestrial (ET) life out there in space is a waste of time and money. They are here on and flying around earth now. We have tens of thousands of firsthand reports of UAPs and ETs encounters. The pictures and films of UAPs are fuzzy because of their technology which allows them to manipulate space-time and gravity. What we are seeing is this forcefield around their craft. What we need is disclosure plus the cooperation between government and civilian agencies. The benefits we derive from this research must be shared with all of humanity, not a select few. Time to grow up as a species. Better late than never.
I’ve always felt that any galactic civilization using inter galaxy transportation probably gave up the CB radios and walkie talkies a couple of million years ago.
Definitely agree with him about the dark forest. For those reasons and because higher intelligences and higher consciousness leads towards harmony not chaos, it's unlikely they are "evil". What could be, however, is that while they're not malevolent, they're also detached on their higher circuit and will not be "melevolent" either but rather cold. I think that's equally likely.
This is so funny to me as Ross was saying what his favorite movie was is said Contact because its mine favorite too. I can still hear Jody Foster saying "I'm ready to go."
13:39 right but how can we actually KNOW that quantum entanglement will work like theorized? We've never tried it, we never put a particle across the galaxy and tri. Also how does time dilation factor into it? Would it really be instantaneous?
Avi Loeb never said ‘therefore, it must be ET.’ In fact he specifically said his hypothesis could never be proved or disproved because Oumuamua is long gone. The point he was making is you can’t just say you think the hypothesis subjectively sounds strange to you, so we should just throw it out. Let the evidence stand or fall on its own merit.
Another question would be: Wolf said he had a kill switch to release all informations he had if he died. It seems that did not happen… Or he did not really have much infos? So many possibilities…
Sorry Ross but quantum communication will not work. When 2 particles are entangled, that state only remains until they are observed and the entangled state collapses. And even then it only tells you what the spin of the second particle is once you have observed the first. So it's a once only deal. It's like the shell game but with only 2 shells. You have 2 coins (representing the 2 entangled particles), one under each shell on a table. You know at the beginning one shows heads and the other tails (spin up and spin down). You shuffle the shells around and then put them at opposite ends of the table. As soon as you look at one, you know what the other is - ie the quantum state collapses. Then the state of each coin (particle) is know and they are no longer "entangled"
He didn't explain it very well, but it's known as the inverse square law. Which means the intensity of the signal decreases with the square of the area from the sourse. So weak signals generated on other planets, or our own, will be literally undetectable in a pretty short distance, relatively speaking. And quantum entanglement holds great potential. As it stands at the moment, we have no control over it, and it breaks down with just the slightest interference. But humans have a way of persevering.
Ah Ross, you didn't ask him if they shouldn't be looking closer to home?! Very interesting to know what's going on & that us Aussies aren't going to be left out in the cold... Cheers, Mate!
Hi Ross, love your work, I'm an Aussie have seen you for years on telly. Can I ask why did the pope and Vladimir Putin and the king of Spain and sec of state John Kerry travel to Antarctica in 2016. Do you know what was found there? Was it your huge craft?
No, this was the Ark of Gabriel, which is not mentioned in the Christian Bible. It is a mysterious device, a secret weapon that many people are only beginning to learn about. I read it on the internet so it's absolutely true.
@@Souljourney22 Yea then he posted something disturbing on social media and later removed it! I think he also got sick and had to be evacuated out pretty quick.
Understanding that many are anxious on discovery, what is revealed could be precarious. Those who hope to gain, anxious yet negligent on outcomes yet also unmoved from such for specific gains and not mindful what costs and sacrifices it would entail.
Still doesn't mean seti has found anything. Even though we know they are already here. They may know how to create their own stealth craft or know how to hide their techno signature escaping their planet.
20 trillion galaxies and a trillion in each galaxy. We aren’t alone. You’d have to be an idiot to think we are alone. S4 has the evidence that no one talks about
Ross Coulthart is an important voice in science circles. It's only during conversations like this that one learns just how deeply and widely he reads across many domains. He's not like so many interviewers who come with their 20 questions and scratch them off one by one. He digs deeply in his off-hours. And I appreciate that. I hope News Nation will continue to support him, and do their best to let a wide public know about him. This speaks well of News Nation as a relatively new News Network. We need as many credible sources as possible wherein all sides of an issue are explored.
Ross is so good for UFO journalism, no one comes close
Absolutely 💯 💯 👍
He's full of shit, he is giving you breadcrumbs that lead exactly where black operative aspect of the global governments want you to go. Dig deeper. Look up "Forbes Malaysian flight"
An important voice in science? What are you talking about? He's not a scientist. How can he be an important voice in science? You mean a popular voice among UFO enthusiasts?
@@punkypinko2965 I have two STEM graduate degrees. Ross is exceptional because he digs deeply, has learned a great deal over decades interviewing all manner of experts, and is somehow able to convey these difficult topics to a much wider public. It's a rare skill. That's all I was trying to say.
David Grusch: the US Government has a crash retrieval program and have over 10 alien craft in their possession.
Seti: we still searching for signals from space.
EXACTLY
Exaclty. Seti is a huge coverup / psyop. The military knows for more than 50 years that advanced civilizations do not use radio, some use quantum entanglement tech, others are telekinetic. Seti's mission is to make people believing that, since there are no radio signals, there aren't any evidence of other civilizations.
Ross; I know the location of a giant buried ufo
Do you believe what Grusch said?That's sad
@@duchon46 there is no way grush story can be true as if the usa government has a recovered alien craft in their possetion then dave grush would not have clearance to talk about it
I love Reality Check!! And Ross is the Boss!!
There you go again.
Booksellers corner
I admire you, Ross Coulthard for doing what you do and handle all the criticism from basement dwellers 😅. You approach topics that are subject to criticism as well as some guests. Your reputation lends so much credibility to your work. You spent a lifetime in journalism to become so adept and wise with the interview process. Keep up the great work. The world needs people like you.
Excellent interview Ross..
Thanks News Nation.
Ross is definitely one of those blokes you can sit down with, grab a beer and talk about anything... no judgements no worries...
Not really. At first he seemed legit with Grusch but now I'm not sure. Seems like a talking head for who knows what organization (s).
Yup ❤
@@VHS_GIS 🤣🤮🐍
Seti is a cover to dispel ET life. We are not idiots!
damn I actually never thought of that for some reason. they are pretending to look/or have already found something and are lying/covering it up pretending to find nothing.
@@iamatlantis1your on to something, he does have a smirk on his face
@mike-vw1zn yeah a little of that "dupers delight" they call it. It's fun for certain types of people to lie like that. The smirk is when they perceive someone to be eating their story up. Sometimes we aren't though. Sometimes those types think they are better at lying than they are, like this guy. He's stuck in the 80's before wide spread info was more available. This isn't going to work anymore on anyone but old and slow people.
You naively believe in UFO's and UAP's but there has never been any, and never will be, any physical evidence that they exist. You are wasting our time with this BS.
@@dolphinliam888 Not idiots, huh? Wanna bet? Just read this string again and subject each comment to a binary choice. Idiot or Not Idiot. Tabulate the score... No, don't. You'll be greatly disappointed. Or try this: how many would I invite to a dinner party with my best friends and pair them up at table, one by one.
Ross is out here asking all the questions we want to be asked, thank you Ross!!!
Yes, SETI is a BIG bad joke!!! Keep up the good work Ross! 🙌💪
There once was a team from SETI,
Whose hopes for aliens were heady.
They listened all night,
For signals just right,
But heard only static and "Spaghetti?"
They've an operating budget that usually falls between 25 and 30 million what have they achieved?
Chuck for you and it was Jean-Claude Vandamme for me, keep up ur good UAP work Ross, very proud of what your doing buddy, keep it up! 💯
Thank you so much for this wonderful video.
Brilliantly clear discussion with Bill providing concise information and giving us a very thorough description of SETI's activities and his views on how we may get to point where a signal is detected. A great guest Ross... and thanks for the well crafted questions. Just to stir the pot for a moment...Why would the Government not offer to fund the activities of SETI?.....Might it be because they may already know that life does exist throughout the Universe and have known this for a long time?
SETI is a joke. We're supposed to believe SETI has never found anything when there are UAPs already on this planet?
Joke is an understatement. Full-blown circus.
Sadly, its fundamental basis of existence and operations is inherently flawed. They will NEVER be allowed to transmit nor announce any such findings or evidence by dictatorial world gov'ts. Period.
@@davidjones3226 I wonder how much money is being wasted on this "circus"?
You are correct. SETI is already on this planet.
The methods they use are primitive compared to what is actually possible, that's why I think S.E.T.I has not found anything of value.
This episode was excellent. It reminded me of the format that the New Horizons podcast uses which I enjoy very much. Please keep bringing on subject matter experts and allowing them to talk at length on whatever topic interests you two.
They found us thousands of years ago!
7:38 We know ETs are here under the water…. Ross tell his ass 🤘🏽🤘🏽😂😂💯💯!!!! lol Thank you for your service Ross❤
Ross thank you so much for doing such an amazing job, your interviews are great and the topics are very interesting. Great job!
Thanks for posting this!
Excellent interview Ross. And yes, Bill is a decent bloke! Well done. :)))
thanks again ross for another great reality check
Ross, just want to let you know that you’re a seriously skilled interviewer and come up with some of the best questions possible to ask people of all professions, which goes to show the amount of research and thought you put into each interview. I see people in the comments suggesting that SETI is used by the government to cover up the existence of NHI, but if SETI is being manipulated by the government in any way, I wonder if it’s for the purpose of putting the burden of disclosure on a third party rather than themselves 🤔 one last thought, I’d also like to hear SETI’s thoughts on some of the strange signals they pick up at Skinwalker Ranch to see if they’ve ever detected anything similar or if they plan to look for signals in those areas.
European S.E.T.I has, apparently found technological signatures across E.M frequencies last year ! ?????
Don't take Holland seriously FFS.
You lost me at climate change dawg
Wow
Seti is a huge coverup / psyop. The military knows for more than 50 years that advanced civilizations do not use radio, some use quantum entanglement tech, others are telekinetic. Seti's mission is to make people believing that, since there are no radio signals, there aren't any evidence of other civilizations.
Then it's absolutely true due in part to their successfully implemented policies around diversity, equality, and inclusion!
Thank you for this one Larry it rings true to my heart. I paid a lot of attention in my childhood to that war and in adult life I've been to the Holocaust Museum in Tampa Florida & talked with survivors...
We’re still searching for intelligent life on earth…so, it may be a while.
LMFICKENAO!!!
😂😂😂
Why is this joke told on every single video on this subject? Like every single one. Is it the same person making the comment on all the videos, or is it a bunch of people that aren’t even listening to the content of the videos? Like, why are they still joking about this?
@@davidb5215 Repetitive unoriginal parrots, proving their own point with the same worn out comment. Cheers!
@@davidb5215 classic
Wow! What a coincidence! I just rewatched Contact yesterday!! Great movie!
Same here haha
One of my two all-time favourite films, which would have been 7 hours long if they followed Carl Sagan's book more intensively.
Great movie
Every movie or tv series Ross mentions I go off to watch it 😂 I’m off to watch Contact now 😊
TY Rosco you beast. I love what you do...............keep on keeping on
Seti already found a technical Signal many years ago. Before they release the information they want to be 1000000000000000% sure
source: UA-cam channel Prof Simon Holland
That dude wins the award for COOLEST crash pad. It looks like some nook in the catacombs of London or Paris, it’s dope af and I’m always jealous scoping it out.
@@tonan8606lol
Lol
If you mean the proxima Centauri one that was already proven to be human in origin
Thank you Ross
SETI - Dr. Puthoff (former chief scientist on AAWSAP) mentioned 2 years ago - „I’m glad to see some SETI people have begun to consider archaeological settings if there is any evidence of other genetic structures, molecules and materials (certainly encrypted) on earth, the moon or on mars, because I’ve always been pretty skeptical about that signals through speed of light, light waves etc and their effectiveness in space.“ - sorry, not a perfect transcript, but good enough to get the point ...
I think that we need to Put Off this crank ,so called Dr ? Puthoff !
Love this interview
Spoiler alert..."they" already found us a long, long time ago. SETI is sadly just a glut of wasted money. 😣
What makes you so sure?
A few books will cover the costs .
This was Epic I learned a lot thanks!
Thank you Mr Coulthart for your efforts!
I would love to see David Paulidas on your Show and let him talk about missing411
Ross excellent as usual
It would be funny if they find the archived video transcripts from then or officially released permission and they review it independently with what the networks have had on tapes since 1998.
Thank you Mr Seti for knowing Edinburgh is in Scotland. 😊
SETI should take note of recent discoveries in crop patterns
Teasing us with that open shirt... You had my curiosity, Bill, but now you have my attention.
I did seti at home for a long time
Poor Ross, you looked exhausted. Thank you for doing what you do.
Rip Arecibo observatory
I don't think understand how professional and skillful Ross Coulthart is in this interview....significant and historically important...
Looking for modulated light is a good idea. We are starting to use it and it will probably replace most radio someday.
Hooray for the scientists of discovery!
This is the first description of a use for AI that is potentially totally benign that I have ever heard of. Normally I believe AI is a terrible thing that can only make the rich richer, the poor poorer, and the surveilled more so, but putting AI to work in scanning the skies for visitors actually sounds like a decent idea. Good luck to everybody involved in SETI!
All the best, N.
I have to say i have enjoyed the story, thank you ross
54:30 first off, i am absolutely on the side that thinks the vast majority of civilizations are probably fairly benign (not harmless, but not actively out to get primitive civilizations like humanity).
But what he is saying is yet again based on assumptions, naive assumptions.
Just becuase you have a worldwide governenance that stands as the foundation of interstellar expansion, does NOT therefor automatically mean that freedom liberty and democracy "won" the competition of social evolution on that planet..
It is equally likely that their version of WW2 Germany or the USSR "won" the global conflict, and that their entire civilization is now thousands of years deep in an absolute authoritarian control, especially easy to manage when you factor in AI overseers or putting a neurallink in every childs brain to modify emotional states or "rebellious urges".
So to sit there and assume a civilization cant go beyond nuclear without being democratic, is incredibly naive.
They could have "gotten past" the nuclear threshold by NOT evading it, but by ACTUALLY having decended in a full global nuclear war.
The difference being, the "bad guys won".
You can have a global nucelar war without totally eliminating your whole civilization, if you only have a few nukes (below 800 or so).
Yes, civilization on both sides, even the winning side, would be enormously ruined..
But give it a few hundred years, if the major emerging faction is the only one left with nukes, and is a bad actor, then the world enters a new era of dystopia.
You can still have scientific progress, with an elite class that is allowed to live free and think free, as long as it doesnt oppose the state.
It will be slower, but it will still progress.
This notion that democracy is the only survivable option isnt correct.
Its the only PLEASANT survivable option (for civilians), but not the only possible outcome.
Likewise, the assumption that every interstellar civilization MUST be based on logic and objectivity, and wont make irrational decisions also doesnt hold water.
What if their emerging power player is a highly religious theocracy that still has an elite class of actual scientists, but keeping discoveries hidden from the masses, and using them as divine displays of power? (Think Dune, or Warhammer 40k's imperium, where the masses believe spirits run the machines, becuase they have no free source of open scientific knowledge, but the elites do).
You can absolutely have science and religion living together.
Look at people in Saudi Arabia being very devout muslims while also expanding their energy and high tech manufacturing industry.
Look at USA, where actual presidents are claiming a connection with God, and that their nation is "chosen by god to shepard the world" (no really, your leading actual politicians and senators fully genuinely believe, and have said, that).
If you have an interstellar civilization run by a theocracy, you cannot predict their actions nor their morality.
They could randomly and irrationally view homo sapiens as "demons".
How you view another species has nothing to do with if you are capable of scientific innovation or not.
Look at how far WW2 germany pushed rocketry, while being extremely authoritarian and while most top scientists held horrendous beliefs.
So how can you assume a civilization must be peaceful because they have high technology?
Yes from what prof simmons says there had a few and received messages
Simon Holland and he isn't a professor. He is a filmmaker. An informed one, but still just a filmmaker whose main aim is to get views
Thanks Ross!
Ross knows what only found out yesterday !
SETI at Home was fun. Me & my roommate had that screensaver on all day in 2001. What about a new program? Called SETI on Your Phone.
Good interview. Can’t help notice Bill’s body language when answering some of Ross’s questions where Bill has a defensive cross armed posture. Most likely that Bill is limited to discuss certain topics openly as that could be confidential or govt related/nda for their govt contracts
More likely, he is uncomfortable pretending this channel is making a positive contribution and wishes he was talking to a mailbox.
Bill said data is not shared to prevent adversaries from knowing system capabilities. Ok. I agree. How about we just get shown a retrieved craft and bodies? No "data" equipment required.
Not a crazy one with revelations but interesting to hear the recap of SETI events over the decades 🔥
Okay, here's my one comment for the room that I want to make. I was one of the original members of the seti program and yes I do recall having a signal pop up on my computer and I just didn't know what to do after it happened. But I'll give you the exact year. It was $19.99. I was dating. Gina and I was living in Orlando and it was on the third floor of the apartment I shared with my roommate
Ancient UFO's/UAP's were known as Vimana. These Vimanas are well documented in ancient Indian Sanskrit with incredible detail as to how these Vimana were constructed and propelled by their ‘gods’ using mercury and handheld Vajras.
The peoples of ancient India, ancient Sumer/Shinar, ancient Chaldea and ancient Egypt shared these experiences and described the technology. There is nothing new under the sun. If past generations had this technology, certainly we are secretly using this same technology today. The question should be why the secrecy.
A good place to start researching is “Ancient Flying Machines - The Ending” from the Investigating Babylon series by Kingdom in Context. Further examination in this series will uncover the technology to levitate and cloak identity through light waves.
Remember, the national networks informed everyone for like two weeks prior that pretty much all the unions would possibly strike or go on strike. At least 12 days before the object in the southeastern corner of the moon viewing was referred to on the news and debated for about two days and nights of the 5 days and nights it was there.
No lmao. You ok dude.
Ross, chuck had just won the world martial arts championship when Lee asked him to be in this film. Chuck said “I get it, you want to beat the champion in your film.” Lee replied, “no. I want to KILL the champion in my film.”
Ross, please interview Dan Sheehan!
Thank you Ross and Bill for the insights re SETI and discussion. As always very interesting.
I think seti is a waste of money.....I do not think the ET's use radio transmission....I think their technology is beyong radio waves.?
Ya I think we're still in the stone age when it comes to this
Exactly! It's ridiculous they think that a technologically superior species that can travel between stars would still be using something as primitive as radio to communicate
If they are here and they know we use radio waves to communicate, it wouldnt be hard for them to make antenas and reply. If they haven't done this and they are here, it's their choice not to speak to us
@@Rafael-es3go would you want to speak to us most people cant even say hello to there neighbours
Trust me bro. I know more than the scientists in UA-cam educated
From all my favourite authors on the subject. This " alien presence comes from a less dense reality. A spiritual reality. Explains the poltergeist connection.
Yes, we are continuing to search the cosmos for intelligent life after realizing there is none on Earth
I assume your talking about the democrat party
@@mattbarr5486 every party
i have seen this comment 1000s of times, multiple times just on this one video
Seti@home v2 🎉 👍👍
Love your programmes, Ross 😊😊
Please buy his book or one of the countless books he pushes . Stay tuned for more books
Reality Chuck with Ross Coulthart
What if SETI has it wrong, what if some aliens are so advanced they use a powerful device to transmit thought using dark matter as a communications network, or some alien species are still using homing pigeons to send messages.
Well written. Our understanding of science is still incomplete and requires much more development to fully align with the reality around us. The question mark that is dark matter, along with dark energy and the origins of gravity, highlights how much we have yet to grasp. The incomplete connection between general relativity and quantum mechanics further underscores the complexity of these issues. If there are more advanced or differently aligned scientific beings out there, or even in other dimensions (which I don’t doubt), it stands to reason that we would likely be unable to detect or interpret their signals or whatever methods of communication they use.
If they discovered us, they should be capable of understanding what kind of signals we would detect... the fact that there is no public comunication with humanity is their decision. If we discover life on another planet, we would probably do the same... study them in secret and reveal our presence when we decide its appropiate
Technology itself seems like a parasitic invasive species that will consume the host during its own evolution. If consciousness is pervasive like a radio signal and we are simply tuning in to it, perhaps the signal is being manipulated. Just something I think about whenever I hear stats on how every generation of devices have eroded mental health and we still insist of using them more in the name of "progress". Progress for who, if it's not for our own biological and mental health?
You and I think alike. That's why I never leave home without my flashlight and my umbrella.
@@pmcallah you again?😂
New scientific study taken over ten months at Long Island Beach using mobile laboratory with multiple high-tech sensory instruments confirms UAPs are more prolific than previously thought:
Open Journal of Applied Sciences > Vol.14 No.8, August 2024, Eye on the Sky: A UAP Research and Field Study off New York’s Long Island Coast
"Contact" is the best Sci Fi movie ever! 😍
Yes ❤
Well, I watched The Thing on our tiny black and white TV back in the late 50s. That seemed pretty great. And I was scared to death. Also, The Day the Earth Stood Still. I quite liked the Robot and the pretty girl. But I was 5. We lived in DC, so I kept an eye out.
@@dylanthomas12321 The Thing is definitely a great movie! It is funny to think you grew up watching it on tv when you were 5 and I grew up playing at the videogame when I was 10 (13 years ago) ❤
If any recall, a majority of the news anchors had to use their vacation days up or lose them with new contracts, so 90-98% of them were off on vacation as the strike talks loomed to the actual broadcasters strikes nationally in 1998.
Ross is a hoot!
An alien came down from the skies,
With twelve arms and twenty-three eyes.
He said with a grin,
"Mind if I come in?
I just need to charge my Wi-Fi!"
@@pmcallah 🤣🤣 A poet I wonder if you know it. 👍
Love Coulthart and his positivity but
SETI...Schmeti are a joke imo.
They search for alien life through only part of the spectrum of electromagnetic radiation, Ross is right they need to try different forms of technologies.
It's just like they're a cover for spending, what have they achieved in the time they've existed.
They've an operating budget that usually falls between 25 and 30 million 🙄
@@victoriagonzalez5774 per annum ? It’s said SETI is part used for espionage from the US GOVERNMENT. I WOULDN’T BE SURPRISED..😳
@@pmcallah Ross kinda looks like a native animal from Australia. Te Koala 🐨 Bear. Tho it’s not a bear. However we recommend to watch out for DROP BEARS. THE JUMP OUT OF THE TREES ON THERE UNSUSPECTING HUMAN PREY AND DEVOUR ALL TRACES… YUP THE KOALA 🐨 BEAR…👍🤣🇦🇺
Bill Diamond seems like a cool dude - I like him!
Looking for Extraterrestrial (ET) life out there in space is a waste of time and money.
They are here on and flying around earth now. We have tens of thousands of firsthand reports of UAPs and ETs encounters.
The pictures and films of UAPs are fuzzy because of their technology which allows them to manipulate space-time and gravity. What we are seeing is this forcefield around their craft.
What we need is disclosure plus the cooperation between government and civilian agencies.
The benefits we derive from this research must be shared with all of humanity, not a select few.
Time to grow up as a species.
Better late than never.
Hello from New York City 🗽🛸
Great Aussie reporter/interviewer
I’ve always felt that any galactic civilization using inter galaxy transportation probably gave up the CB radios and walkie talkies a couple of million years ago.
Chuck Norris waa in USAF Security Forces like i was, he is a legend. Chuck Norris tells the Sun when to come up
Definitely agree with him about the dark forest. For those reasons and because higher intelligences and higher consciousness leads towards harmony not chaos, it's unlikely they are "evil". What could be, however, is that while they're not malevolent, they're also detached on their higher circuit and will not be "melevolent" either but rather cold. I think that's equally likely.
This is so funny to me as Ross was saying what his favorite movie was is said Contact because its mine favorite too. I can still hear Jody Foster saying "I'm ready to go."
👍🤔 Very Interesting. Thanks guys!
I think Ross needs to rewatch Contact to refresh his memory of the plot and characters.
Chuck Norris, the new Jack Lalane 😊
13:39 right but how can we actually KNOW that quantum entanglement will work like theorized? We've never tried it, we never put a particle across the galaxy and tri. Also how does time dilation factor into it? Would it really be instantaneous?
We as you do know we have been visited from the very earliest Prehistoric times. We have never ever been alone. They made us for the love of Ea/Enki.
Wow what lmao
15:30, head of SETI gets a cold shiver down his back, as he realizes funding will be pulled because of quantum entaglement communication research.
Well, Bill Diamond is a lovely guy indeed. No arrogance or hangups there.
Avi Loeb never said ‘therefore, it must be ET.’ In fact he specifically said his hypothesis could never be proved or disproved because Oumuamua is long gone.
The point he was making is you can’t just say you think the hypothesis subjectively sounds strange to you, so we should just throw it out. Let the evidence stand or fall on its own merit.
Another question would be: Wolf said he had a kill switch to release all informations he had if he died. It seems that did not happen… Or he did not really have much infos? So many possibilities…
Bruh if you're talking about karl wolfe. Them photos been out for years.
Sorry Ross but quantum communication will not work. When 2 particles are entangled, that state only remains until they are observed and the entangled state collapses. And even then it only tells you what the spin of the second particle is once you have observed the first. So it's a once only deal. It's like the shell game but with only 2 shells. You have 2 coins (representing the 2 entangled particles), one under each shell on a table. You know at the beginning one shows heads and the other tails (spin up and spin down). You shuffle the shells around and then put them at opposite ends of the table. As soon as you look at one, you know what the other is - ie the quantum state collapses. Then the state of each coin (particle) is know and they are no longer "entangled"
finaly someone who does use his brain....
Trippy! Can you hear us now? 😮😅
17:40 why must ppl lie to Ross and try to insult his intelligence??? Ross already KNOWS what’s up👍🏾🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯
He didn't explain it very well, but it's known as the inverse square law. Which means the intensity of the signal decreases with the square of the area from the sourse. So weak signals generated on other planets, or our own, will be literally undetectable in a pretty short distance, relatively speaking. And quantum entanglement holds great potential. As it stands at the moment, we have no control over it, and it breaks down with just the slightest interference. But humans have a way of persevering.
One problem with the entanglement theory...how long will it take the "twin" subatomic particle to cross the universe to test it?
Ah Ross, you didn't ask him if they shouldn't be looking closer to home?! Very interesting to know what's going on & that us Aussies aren't going to be left out in the cold... Cheers, Mate!
Hi Ross, love your work, I'm an Aussie have seen you for years on telly. Can I ask why did the pope and Vladimir Putin and the king of Spain and sec of state John Kerry travel to Antarctica in 2016. Do you know what was found there? Was it your huge craft?
That story disappeared fairly quick from the news reports! I remember
No, this was the Ark of Gabriel, which is not mentioned in the Christian Bible. It is a mysterious device, a secret weapon that many people are only beginning to learn about. I read it on the internet so it's absolutely true.
Didn't buzz Aldrin go down there as well.
@@Souljourney22 Yea then he posted something disturbing on social media and later removed it! I think he also got sick and had to be evacuated out pretty quick.
@@grant9301 had to be pretty disturbing considering he had already seen the ones on the moon.
Ross, tell they ass to,stop lyin❤❤g, you da man‼️‼️🤟🏽🤟🏽🎯
Understanding that many are anxious on discovery, what is revealed could be precarious. Those who hope to gain, anxious yet negligent on outcomes yet also unmoved from such for specific gains and not mindful what costs and sacrifices it would entail.
"Every star in the sky is in fact not a star, it's a solar system... There are tens of billions of inhabitable worlds."
That is pretty mind blowing.
Aren't some of them galaxies?
Still doesn't mean seti has found anything. Even though we know they are already here. They may know how to create their own stealth craft or know how to hide their techno signature escaping their planet.
False.
"Even though we know they are already here."
Complete and utter b.s.
20 trillion galaxies and a trillion in each galaxy. We aren’t alone. You’d have to be an idiot to think we are alone.
S4 has the evidence that no one talks about
Silly Effort To Investigate - SETI
Lol
RIP Stanton Friedman.
@@bugsyboy5323 There are bronze statues of people who are not as half as intelligent as Stan.
good one....my money is on Breakthrough Listen spilling the beans. ET tech signatures has been found.